Plot Summary
Shadows at the Doorstep
Beverly's world is upended when her father, a local police officer, brings home Blake, a traumatized foster child with a haunted past. The quiet, loving rhythms of her family are interrupted by this boy who barely speaks, eats with his hands, and flinches at kindness. Beverly's initial jealousy and confusion give way to empathy as she learns about Blake's suffering. The two children, both outsiders in their own ways, begin a tentative, silent connection—one built on late-night knocks on the wall and the unspoken promise that neither is truly alone. The shadow of Blake's trauma lingers, but so does the hope of belonging.
A Home for the Broken
Blake's nightmares and silence persist, but the Price family's patience never wavers. Beverly's mother homeschools him, nurturing his hunger for knowledge, while her father becomes the first adult Blake trusts. Beverly and Blake develop a ritual of knocking on the wall to comfort each other through the night. Slowly, Blake learns to read, to laugh, and to celebrate small joys—like his first real birthday. The family's love is not perfect, but it is steadfast, and Blake's presence becomes less an intrusion and more a thread in the fabric of their lives. Beverly realizes that Blake is not her brother, not really, but something else—her friend, her shadow, her secret.
Rituals of Belonging
As the years pass, Blake and Beverly's bond deepens through shared routines and unspoken care. Blake's protectiveness emerges in subtle ways—walking on the outside of the sidewalk, saving her the last slice of pizza, sitting by her bed when she's sick. Beverly, in turn, becomes his anchor, filling the silence with chatter and laughter. Their friendship is marked by quiet companionship, cake fights, and the comfort of simply being together. The world outside is unpredictable, but inside the Price home, they create their own rituals of safety and belonging.
Summer's Quiet Transformations
Adolescence brings new tensions. Blake's growing confidence and Beverly's changing body create a subtle, electric undercurrent. Summer trips to the lake become a stage for new boundaries—teaching Blake to swim, feeling the heat of his touch, and the thrill of being needed. Beverly's jealousy flares when Blake's attention shifts, and she struggles with the realization that her feelings for him are no longer simple. The world is expanding, and so are the risks of heartbreak.
The Distance Between
Middle school and high school bring new friends, new interests, and new distances. Blake's brilliance sets him apart, and he skips a grade, finding kinship with Jamal, a classmate who challenges and teases him. Beverly, meanwhile, throws herself into dance and friendships with girls like Tiffany. The two drift, their connection strained by misunderstandings, jealousy, and the fear of wanting too much. The silent knocks on the wall become less frequent, replaced by the ache of absence.
Growing Pains and Silences
Blake's withdrawal leaves Beverly feeling abandoned. She tries to fill the void with hobbies and new friends, but nothing replaces the comfort of his presence. Their attempts to reconnect are clumsy and fraught with unspoken longing. When Beverly gets her first period at school, it is Blake—not her girlfriends—who comes to her rescue, breaking the ice with awkward tenderness. The moment is both mortifying and healing, a reminder that their bond, though battered, is not broken.
The First Fractures
As they enter their mid-teens, both Blake and Beverly test the limits of their relationship. Beverly's flirtations with other boys and Blake's new friendships spark jealousy and confusion. Their first real fight leaves them both raw and exposed, each blaming the other for the growing distance. Yet, in moments of crisis—illness, heartbreak, or fear—they still turn to each other, unable to sever the thread that binds them.
Unspoken Promises
Blake begins leaving Beverly books with secret messages underlined in pencil, confessions hidden in plain sight. Each book is a puzzle, a love letter, a plea for her to see him. Beverly reads them all, piecing together the truth he cannot say aloud: that he wishes he were braver, that he loves her in ways he cannot name. Their connection becomes a secret language, a series of almost-confessions and near-misses, as they circle the truth of their feelings.
The Party and the Aftermath
A high school party becomes the crucible for everything unsaid. Beverly, dressed to impress, dances with a boy who pushes past her boundaries. Blake, unable to watch, intervenes violently, exposing the depth of his possessiveness and care. The aftermath is messy—fights, accusations, and the realization that their relationship has crossed a line. Both are left reeling, unsure if what they feel is love or something more dangerous.
Lines Crossed, Lines Drawn
The fallout from the party is swift and brutal. Beverly is left shaken, her trust in others shattered. Blake, wracked with guilt and rage, seeks solace in violence, unable to process his own helplessness. Their parents, caught in the crossfire, struggle to understand the intensity of their bond. The two are forced to confront the reality that their love is no longer innocent, that it carries consequences for everyone around them.
The Cost of Protection
Blake's need to protect Beverly becomes both his salvation and his undoing. He takes the blame for fights, endures punishment, and isolates himself to keep her safe. Beverly, meanwhile, is left to navigate the aftermath of trauma alone, her pain compounded by the silence of those who love her most. Their relationship becomes a series of sacrifices—each giving up pieces of themselves for the other, even as it drives them further apart.
The Weight of Secrets
The Price family is tested by illness, grief, and the slow unraveling of trust. Beverly's mother falls ill, and the weight of caring for her threatens to crush them all. Blake and Beverly's love, once a source of comfort, becomes a secret too heavy to bear. When their father discovers the truth, his reaction is not anger but heartbreak—a plea for them to wait, to grow, to choose themselves before choosing each other. The advice is both wise and devastating, and it sets the stage for the greatest loss of all.
Breaking and Mending
A moment of violence in a parking lot leaves Beverly's father dead and Blake drowning in guilt. The family fractures under the weight of grief, each member retreating into their own pain. Blake, convinced he is to blame, withdraws completely, shutting Beverly out. She, in turn, lashes out—destroying his room, her own body, and any hope of reconciliation. Their love, once a lifeline, becomes a wound that refuses to heal.
The World Moves Forward
Unable to bear the weight of loss, Beverly flees to San Francisco, seeking refuge with her aunt and a new life in a city that doesn't know her name. Blake, left behind, spirals into depression, therapy, and the slow work of rebuilding himself. Both try to move on—Beverly with new friends and a job at a women-run tech startup, Blake with college and the creation of a social network that becomes his way of reaching for connection. The world moves forward, but neither can escape the shadow of what they left behind.
The Pink Thread
Small tokens—a pink scrunchie, a stack of unsent letters, a dance studio bought on a whim—become the threads that tie Blake and Beverly to each other, even in absence. Both are haunted by memories, by the things they never said, by the hope that someday, somehow, they will find their way back. Their friends, Jamal and Tiffany, become the keepers of their secrets, the witnesses to their heartbreak, and the architects of their eventual reunion.
The Night Everything Changed
Fate intervenes when Beverly, now working at ChimeIn, discovers that Blake is the company's founder. Their reunion is electric—charged with years of longing, regret, and the undeniable pull of unfinished business. Old wounds are reopened, but so are old promises. They circle each other warily, each afraid to hope, each desperate to believe that love can survive even this.
The Ruin of Us
The truth of their separation comes to light—letters never delivered, apologies never heard, love never truly lost. Beverly reads the stack of letters Blake wrote her during their years apart, each one a testament to his devotion and his pain. The two finally confront the reality of their choices, the ways they hurt each other, and the possibility of forgiveness. Their friends rally around them, offering laughter, comfort, and the reminder that healing is possible.
Grief's Long Shadow
Returning to Los Angeles, Blake and Beverly face the ghosts of their past—her destroyed room, his father's grave, the memories that linger in every corner of their childhood home. Together, they begin the slow work of rebuilding—not just their relationship, but themselves. They find solace in old rituals, new routines, and the knowledge that love, though battered, can endure.
Letters Never Sent
Blake's letters become the foundation for a new beginning. Beverly, finally able to read the words he wrote in her absence, understands the depth of his love and the cost of their separation. The two make new promises—to stay, to fight, to choose each other every day. Their love is no longer a secret, no longer a shadow, but something real and hard-won.
The Return and the Reckoning
Blake and Beverly, older and wiser, build a life together in Los Angeles. She opens a dance studio; he runs ChimeIn. Their friends, Jamal and Tiffany, remain by their side, proof that found family can be just as powerful as blood. The past is not forgotten, but it is no longer a prison. Together, they learn that love is not about perfection, but about choosing each other—again and again, in every version of time.
Characters
Blake McHayes
Blake is a boy forged in trauma—a survivor of horrific violence, shuffled through the foster system, and rescued by the Price family. His intelligence is both a shield and a burden, setting him apart from his peers and making him hyper-aware of every risk, every possibility of loss. Blake's love for Beverly is obsessive, protective, and deeply vulnerable; she is his anchor, his home, and his greatest fear. He struggles with guilt, self-loathing, and the belief that he is unworthy of happiness. Over the years, Blake's journey is one of learning to accept love, to forgive himself, and to choose vulnerability over isolation. His relationship with Beverly is both his salvation and his greatest test—a love that demands everything and gives everything in return.
Beverly Price
Beverly is the heart of the Price family—a girl raised in love, but never quite sure of her place once Blake arrives. Her empathy is both her strength and her weakness, making her fiercely loyal but also prone to jealousy and self-doubt. Dance is her escape, her way of making sense of a world that often feels too heavy. Beverly's love for Blake is complicated—part friendship, part obsession, part desperate hope that love can fix what is broken. She is brave, stubborn, and unafraid to fight for what she wants, even when it means risking everything. Her journey is one of learning to choose herself, to forgive, and to believe that she is worthy of the love she so freely gives.
Arthur Price
Arthur is the moral center of the Price family—a police officer who believes in justice, loyalty, and the power of second chances. His decision to bring Blake into the family is both an act of compassion and a source of tension, as he struggles to balance the needs of his daughter with the wounds of a broken boy. Arthur's love is quiet but fierce, and his death is the catalyst for the family's unraveling. His legacy is one of sacrifice, wisdom, and the reminder that love sometimes means letting go.
Jenna Price
Jenna is the glue that holds the Price family together, even as she is slowly undone by illness and loss. Her love for both Beverly and Blake is unconditional, but her own grief often leaves her unable to comfort them in the ways they need. Jenna's journey is one of survival—learning to live with absence, to forgive her children for their choices, and to find her own way back to hope.
Tiffany Maclay
Tiffany is Beverly's best friend and the story's much-needed source of levity. Outspoken, fashionable, and unafraid to throw a punch (or a hairbrush), she is the friend who shows up with snacks, advice, and a willingness to fight anyone who hurts the people she loves. Tiffany's loyalty is unwavering, and her own journey is one of learning to let others in, to accept help, and to believe in her own worth.
Jamal Majeed
Jamal is Blake's closest friend—a boy who meets Blake's intensity with humor, honesty, and a refusal to let him drown in his own darkness. Jamal's family offers Blake a glimpse of a different kind of love—one rooted in faith, tradition, and the quiet strength of community. Jamal is the bridge between worlds, the friend who pulls Blake back from the edge, and the one who reminds him that he is not alone.
Sydney Covington
Sydney is Blake's girlfriend during his years apart from Beverly—a smart, confident woman who wants more than he can give. Her presence is a mirror for Blake's inability to move on, and her heartbreak is a reminder that love cannot be forced. Sydney's story is one of learning to let go, to demand more, and to believe that she deserves a love that chooses her first.
Nathan
Nathan is Beverly's attempt at moving on—a charming, surface-level boyfriend who ultimately reveals himself to be selfish and dangerous. His actions at the party are a turning point, forcing Beverly to confront the reality that not all love is safe, and that sometimes, the people who claim to care for us are the ones who do the most harm.
Maxine
Maxine is Beverly's boss at ChimeIn—a woman who embodies the possibility of a different kind of future. She is supportive, no-nonsense, and quietly radical in her belief that women deserve respect, opportunity, and a seat at the table. Maxine's presence is a reminder that healing is possible, that new beginnings can be found in unexpected places, and that sometimes, the best thing we can do is offer space.
Aiden
Aiden is Beverly's coworker and friend in San Francisco—a flirtatious, supportive presence who offers her the chance to be seen without expectation or judgment. He is the proof that not all relationships are meant to be romantic, and that sometimes, the best kind of love is the one that simply lets us be ourselves.
Plot Devices
Dual Narration and Time Jumps
The novel alternates between Blake and Beverly's perspectives, often jumping forward and backward in time. This structure mirrors the fractured nature of trauma and memory, allowing the reader to experience the story as a series of moments—some sharp, some blurred, all interconnected. The use of letters, unsent messages, and hidden confessions deepens the sense of longing and missed connections, while the time jumps create a sense of inevitability and fate.
Symbolism and Motifs
Throughout the novel, small objects—a pink scrunchie, a stack of letters, a dance studio, a tattoo—serve as symbols of love, loss, and hope. These motifs ground the characters in their shared history, offering both comfort and pain. The recurring image of shadows, both literal and metaphorical, underscores the themes of absence, longing, and the ways we haunt each other.
The Wall and the Knock
The nightly ritual of knocking on the wall between their rooms becomes a lifeline for Blake and Beverly—a silent promise that neither is alone, even in the darkest moments. This device is used to show both the depth of their bond and the pain of its absence, as the knocks become less frequent and eventually stop altogether.
Letters and Unsent Messages
Blake's habit of leaving books with underlined messages, and later, his stack of unsent letters, serve as both a plot device and a metaphor for the things we cannot say. These letters become the bridge between past and present, the proof that love endures even in silence.
Parallelism and Mirroring
The novel is structured to mirror itself—scenes from childhood are echoed in adulthood, rituals are repeated with new meaning, and the characters' journeys are marked by cycles of loss and reunion. This mirroring reinforces the idea that healing is not linear, that love is a choice made over and over, and that the past is never truly gone.
The Dance Studio and ChimeIn
The dance studio and the tech startup are more than settings—they are symbols of new beginnings, spaces where the characters can rebuild themselves and their relationships. These places offer the possibility of community, purpose, and the chance to create something lasting out of pain.
Analysis
Beverly is a story about the ways we break and the ways we mend. At its core, it is a romance—but not the kind that promises easy answers or perfect endings. Instead, it offers a raw, unflinching look at what it means to love someone who is both your salvation and your undoing. The novel explores the long shadow of trauma, the weight of guilt, and the slow, painful work of forgiveness—both of others and of oneself. Through its dual narration and fragmented structure, Beverly captures the reality that healing is not a straight line, that love is not always enough, and that sometimes, the bravest thing we can do is choose each other, again and again, in the face of uncertainty. The story is a testament to the power of found family, the necessity of vulnerability, and the hope that, even after the worst has happened, we can still find our way home. In a world that often demands perfection, Beverly reminds us that it is our brokenness—and our willingness to keep loving in spite of it—that makes us whole.
Last updated:
Review Summary
Beverly received highly polarized reviews, with many readers praising its emotional depth, angst-filled forbidden romance between foster siblings, and beautiful 90s setting. Fans loved the dual POV, poetic writing, and intense pining between Blake and Beverly. However, numerous reviewers accused the book of being plagiarized from RJ Lewis's "Obsessed," citing copied chapters and passages. Some readers found it boring, repetitive, or overly long. The plagiarism allegations significantly impacted ratings, with many reducing scores or removing the book from their reading lists entirely.
