Key Takeaways
1. Markets are Naturally Organized, Not Chaotic
I still remember the page of the textbook where it said that through the bell curve, out of apparent chaos comes a beautiful cosmic order.
Cosmic order. Contrary to popular belief, markets are not chaotic but possess a natural, underlying organization, much like the statistical bell curve. This realization, stemming from early academic exposure to statistics, became the foundational insight for understanding market behavior. The bell curve illustrates that most activity clusters around a mean, with diminishing frequency towards extremes.
Negotiation process. This inherent order is driven by the negotiation process among market participants, which establishes three key reference points: the consummated trade price, a price perceived as too high, and a price perceived as too low. The auction process, involving multiple buyers or sellers, further structures this, rationing activity as prices move. As prices rise, buyers drop out; as prices fall, sellers drop out, creating a predictable pattern of participation.
Human behavior. The market's organization is a reflection of human behavior, which is never perfectly balanced. This imbalance creates opportunities. The market's purpose is to efficiently distribute a product, and this "trade facilitation" is measured by volume. Understanding this natural organization allows traders to move beyond mere prediction and interpret current market conditions.
2. Market Profile Visualizes Price, Time, and Value
Market Profile is the product of a professional floor trader’s ability to communicate the pit trading experience symbolically in chart form.
Beyond bar charts. Market Profile is a unique charting technique that transcends traditional bar charts by dynamically displaying price activity across both vertical (price) and horizontal (time/price opportunity or TPO) dimensions. Unlike conventional charts where the horizontal axis is fixed by chronological time, Market Profile expands horizontally only when prices repeat within a given time segment, revealing the market's "feel" and efficiency.
Price x Time = Value. The core principle of Market Profile is that Price multiplied by Time equals Value. It visually represents how much time the market spends at various price levels, forming a distribution that often resembles a bell curve. The widest part of the profile, where most TPOs accumulate, indicates the "value area" or fair price, while thinner sections represent prices less accepted by the market.
Objective information. This tool provides objective, present-tense information about market conditions, allowing traders to identify when the market is in balance (responsive activity) or out of balance (initiative activity). By observing the shape and evolution of the profile, traders can discern whether prices are being accepted or rejected, offering a significant advantage over relying solely on historical data for predictions.
3. Understand Market Activity: Responsive vs. Initiative
To determine whether activity is initiating or responsive we need to use the previous day’s value area as our reference.
Two market types. Market activity can be broadly categorized into two fundamental types: responsive and initiative. Responsive activity occurs when participants react to prices perceived as "cheap" or "expensive" relative to a reference point, typically the previous day's value area. They buy below value or sell above value, expecting prices to revert to the mean.
Shifting value. Initiative activity, conversely, involves participants buying above the previous day's value area or selling below it, driven by a belief that value itself has shifted. These traders "go with the flow," pushing prices directionally in anticipation of a new fair price. Recognizing whether the market is responsive or initiative is crucial for aligning trading strategies.
Contextual cues. Distinguishing between these activities requires using the previous day's value area as a primary reference. If current prices are being accepted and extended beyond this value area, it signals initiative action. If prices are quickly rejected and pulled back into the value area, it indicates responsive behavior. This understanding dictates whether a trader should fade the move or go with the momentum.
4. Master the Four Steps of Market Activity
It is one of the most important, if not the most important, skill a trader must learn and apply to be successful.
Market's natural cycle. Markets inherently move through a four-step process to factor out inefficiencies and establish new value. Visualizing this cycle is paramount for successful trading, applicable across any time resolution (5-minute, daily, etc.). These steps are:
- Step 1: Distribution. A series of prices moving in one direction, often sharply.
- Step 2: Stopping. The market reaches a price where the directional momentum wanes.
- Step 3: Development. Activity clusters around the stopping price, forming a new value area.
- Step 4: Retracement. The market attempts to move the developed value area back towards the middle of the structure's vertical range, seeking efficiency.
Steidlmayer Distribution. The first three steps—distribution, stopping, and development—form what is known as the Steidlmayer distribution (visually resembling an uppercase "P" or lowercase "b"). This skewed distribution represents the present-tense development of an ongoing market move, unlike the symmetrical "normal distribution" which is often a retrospective view of a completed cycle.
Timing insights. The "internal time clock of the market," measured by the number of TPOs at the widest point of a structure, helps objectively identify where the market is within these four steps. For instance, 0-18 TPOs suggest trend continuation, while 30-42 TPOs indicate normal development and potential for retracement (Step 4). This objective timing mechanism helps traders anticipate shifts from directional movement to consolidation or reversal.
5. The "You" Factor is Half the Trading Equation
Their market understanding may be great but they do not have a handle on the you.
Self-awareness is critical. The equation for trading success is "Market Understanding + You = Results." Many traders possess excellent market understanding but fail due to a lack of self-awareness and discipline. Objectivity is the trader's primary job, requiring constant observation of the market's story without personal opinions or emotions clouding judgment.
Emotional pitfalls. During the stress of trading, emotions like anger, fear, jealousy, or overconfidence can easily derail objective decision-making. Stubbornly holding onto a losing position, rationalizing adverse moves, or failing to adapt to changing market conditions are common pitfalls stemming from a lack of emotional control.
Market discipline. Developing "market discipline" involves rigorous self-analysis: studying every trade against market backdrop, understanding why decisions were made, and identifying emotional patterns. This continuous process of self-discovery helps traders recognize their limitations, learn from mistakes, and build confidence, ultimately improving their ability to manage both winning and losing positions effectively.
6. Leverage Volume for Deeper Market Insight
Volume is the “footprint” the market leaves in its wake; picking up on heavy volume, light volume, and volume excesses communicates a great deal of information to the trader.
Beyond price alone. While Market Profile organizes price and time, integrating volume analysis provides a crucial third dimension for deeper market insight. Three key volume tools are:
- Liquidity Data Bank (LDB): Post-market report showing volume by participant type (local, commercial, public/funds).
- On Floor Information (OFI): Post-market report indicating the skew of large buy vs. sell orders from off-floor participants.
- Volume @ Time: Real-time data showing volume occurring in defined time segments, allowing for "net money flow" analysis.
Commercial vs. fund activity. LDB helps identify abnormal commercial (CTI-2) or fund (CTI-4) activity. Commercials typically "fade" extremes (buy low, sell high), while funds "go with" momentum (buy high, sell low). Unusually heavy commercial selling at highs, for instance, can signal "commercial capping," indicating a strong barrier to further upside.
OFI and Volume @ Time. OFI reveals the "big barn boss's" bias, suggesting directional plays for the next 1-1.5 hours of trading. Volume @ Time, a more revolutionary tool, measures "volume dollars" (money flow) in real-time. It identifies "blow off extremes" (price spikes on heavy volume indicating exhaustion) and "volume excesses" (directional integrity reversing, signaling a turning point), offering objective trade triggers independent of price.
7. Day Structures and Auction Points Reveal Opportunities
If one can make the correct classification as the day develops, one can project how far the market is likely to move and create trading opportunities.
Five day types. Market Profile categorizes daily activity into five typical day structures, each reflecting different levels of long-term trader influence and offering distinct trading opportunities:
- Nontrend Day: Little long-term influence, small range, no extension beyond the first hour.
- Normal Day: Slight long-term push, range extension ~50% of the first hour.
- Normal Variation Day: Moderate long-term activity, range extension ~100% of the first hour.
- Trend Day: Strong long-term influence, market moves dramatically, closes near extreme.
- Neutral Day: Conflicting long-term influences, symmetrical extensions, closes near the middle.
Auction points. An "auction point" is a specific price level where longer-term participants expand the range beyond the initial balance (first hour's trade). If the market closes beyond this point, it's a "confirmed range extension," signaling validation of the long-term bias. If it closes back within the initial balance, it's a "failed range extension," indicating rejection and potential reversal.
Support and resistance. Confirmed auction points act as future support or resistance. Failed range extensions are particularly powerful, often occurring near market tops or bottoms, as they represent a failed attempt by long-term players to push prices further. These objective price levels provide clear entry, exit, and stop references for traders.
8. Single Prints Signal Minus Development and Opportunity
Unopposed buying or selling (single prints) is what we call minus development.
Lack of development. Single prints within a Market Profile are price levels traded only during one half-hour period, indicating "minus development" or a lack of acceptance and two-sided trade. These areas represent unopposed buying or selling, where the market moved quickly through a price range without building significant horizontal depth.
Market gaps. Conceptually, single prints are akin to price gaps in traditional charting; they represent areas of inefficiency that the market often revisits or "tests." The speed and magnitude of a retest into a single print area provide crucial insights into the underlying strength or weakness of the market.
Trading strategy. A shallow retracement into single prints, followed by a quick rejection, signals strong underlying conviction and a high probability of a larger vertical move away from that area. Conversely, a deep retracement or "filling" of the single prints suggests a weaker conviction and a market moving back into equilibrium. Trading against the far side of single prints, with a stop just beyond them, offers a high reward-to-risk opportunity.
9. Adaptation and Risk Control Ensure Long-Term Success
One of the keys to being a successful trader over a period of time is to adapt to change.
Dynamic markets. Markets are dynamic, constantly evolving organisms. Trading strategies that work today may become obsolete tomorrow if market conditions change. Successful traders must continuously adapt their methods, recognizing when an old program is no longer effective and having the discipline to implement a new one.
Control risk. The paramount rule in trading is to control risk, ensuring capital preservation to "fight another battle." This means limiting losses and avoiding situations where a few setbacks can end a trading career. Arbitrary "monetary stops" are often ineffective; instead, exit prices should be dictated by market activity and structural changes that negate the original trade idea.
Learning from mistakes. Every trade, whether winning or losing, is an opportunity for learning and growth. Dwelling on negatives or rationalizing bad decisions hinders progress. By objectively analyzing outcomes and taking responsibility for actions, traders can refine their skills and build a robust, adaptable trading business that can sustain itself through market fluctuations.
10. Technology Enhances Trading Content and Access
The apex of our pyramid (the traders) is moving our energies to management of trades and away from being an observer.
Evolution of trading. Trading has evolved from manual pit activity to sophisticated electronic platforms, driven by technological advancements. This "information revolution" has transformed raw price data into valuable, processed insights, moving traders from "tape readers" to "information processors." The Market Profile methodology itself has evolved from chronological displays to dynamic "market time" databases and automated analysis tools.
Content and access. Making money in trading relies on two pillars: "content" (generating trading ideas) and "access" (efficient order routing and execution). Technology enhances both. Tools like Capital Flow software provide advanced Market Profile displays, auto-splitters for market time segmentation, proprietary studies (DMR, compression, lonesome dove), and "product creation" (combining unrelated instruments for cash flow).
Automated execution. The latest advancements, exemplified by Trading Technologies' (TT) MD_Trader™ and Autospreader, offer unparalleled speed and reliability in order entry and automated spread management. Future tools like Autotrader will allow system traders to execute signals directly from their "black box" models. This shift empowers traders to delegate observation and signal generation to computers, freeing them to focus on higher-level trade management and strategy.
Last updated:
Similar Books
