Plot Summary
A Song at the Dealership
In the first days after high school, Remy Starr is handling the details of her mother Barbara's latest wedding while counting down to Stanford and the independence it promises. Her father, Thomas Custer, is dead, but the sentimental song he wrote when she was born follows her through shops, weddings, and radio stations.
At the Toyota dealership, where Barbara met her new fiancé, Don Davis, Remy finishes negotiating the car purchase and wedding bills for her. A curly-haired young drummer named Dexter Jones drops into the chair beside her, declares an instant connection, and writes his name and number on her hand. Remy dismisses him as pushy and ridiculous. Yet his sudden certainty unsettles the controlled summer she has planned.
Two Breakups, One Closet
Remy prepares to end her relationship with Jonathan before leaving for college, but finds another woman's red underwear in his room and learns he has been cheating for weeks. She leaves without her car, furious that the betrayal has made her a victim in other people's eyes. At the same time, her sentimental friend Lissa is dumped by Adam, the boyfriend she expected to take into college.
Remy comforts Lissa, then throws a drink at Adam's head as Jess drives them past him. Back home, she tucks herself into her closet, where she secretly listens to her father's song until she can sleep. The night reinforces her habits: leave first, keep control, and hide the hurt where nobody can see it.
The Wedding Band Returns
At Barbara and Don's rehearsal dinner, Remy discovers that the wedding band is Dexter's group, Truth Squad, working under the name the G Flats. Their performance gets the guests dancing, but Remy keeps her distance, still wary of Dexter's insistence. After the reception, her brother Chris and his girlfriend Jennifer Anne leave without her, and the band's van departs before Dexter returns.
Waiting for a cab, Remy sits with him over leftover cake and learns that his mother has married repeatedly too. He describes how children in unsettled families learn to adapt as adults come and go. Remy recognizes the territory, though she refuses to accept his easygoing view of it. She leaves by cab, watching him walk home alone.
A Hand Reaches Through
After Remy needles Chris about their childhood wager on how long Barbara's marriages will last, Chris calls her bitter and says she makes it hard to love her. Upset, Remy drinks too much at Bendo and slips back toward the reckless version of herself she has tried to outgrow. A man named Sherman grabs her and tries to pull her outside; Remy strikes him while wrenching free, and the bouncer threatens to involve the police.
Dexter arrives, claims responsibility for her temper, and gets Sherman to leave. Outside, Remy breaks down. Her distress reaches back to a drunken first sexual encounter with an older boy who ignored her efforts to slow things down. Dexter neither touches nor presses her. Remy steps toward him and kisses him.
A Summer Without Rules
The morning after their first kiss, Remy wakes at Dexter's house, escapes through a window, and is startled when he later climbs through hers. This time she chooses to kiss him again, and their summer relationship begins.
Dexter's world is the opposite of hers: the band's yellow house is disorderly, its members survive on odd jobs, and its elderly dog, Monkey, is neglected. Remy cleans, helps with household mishaps, and grows fond of both dog and people, even as she insists the relationship has an expiration date.
During a family cookout, Don belittles Dexter for abandoning college and a scholarship to play music; Remy pulls Dexter away and defends him. Later, when Dexter plays her father's song, Remy explains its painful meaning. He listens, then holds her without pushing for sex.
The Song Turns Against Her
Truth Squad learns that Arianna Moss, a record-label scout, may give them a path to a larger stage. The band argues over whether to perform original songs or crowd-pleasing covers, exposing Ted's rigidity and Dexter's wish to keep the group moving.
At Bendo, their set falters until Dexter launches into a rearranged version of This Lullaby, the song Remy has told him she hates. The crowd and Arianna respond warmly, but Remy hears her father's legacy turned into a performance without her consent.
She leaves before Dexter can finish talking with the scout. Later, when Dexter follows her home, he challenges her claim that their relationship was only a summer arrangement. Remy admits she fears commitment because she has watched love end repeatedly, then insists they should break up.
Friends After the Breakup
Dexter asks Remy to attempt friendship rather than turn every shared workplace into an awkward battlefield. She accepts the arrangement, with rules against unnecessary touching and unspoken discomfort, though her friends doubt it will hold.
At a dealership fair, she sees that she and Dexter can still talk, but Don's temper shifts her attention homeward. After Remy returns from dinner, Don berates her for failing to answer calls while he and Barbara are locked out. When he points at her and demands respect, Remy tells him not to speak to her mother that way.
Barbara takes the keys and follows Don inside without backing Remy up. Remy feels displaced from the family she has long managed. Jess and Lissa suggest Barbara may be afraid of being alone, a possibility Remy has never considered.
A Date With Certainty
At the salon, Remy's boss Lola arranges a dinner with Paul, a considerate college student who seems to meet all the standards Remy has developed for a safe, temporary boyfriend. Before the date, Barbara explains that her marriages contained real happiness as well as painful endings, and that avoiding love to prevent hurt would have cost her more.
Remy listens, unsettled by her mother's willingness to risk another disappointment. She goes to dinner with Paul and enjoys his company; he shares her interest in college and offers a future that looks orderly and manageable.
They begin seeing each other. Remy tells herself that this is proof she can move forward without Dexter, while Barbara's argument keeps troubling the tidy distinction Remy has always drawn between affection and danger.
The Safe Exit Fails
On a drive-in outing with Paul and Lissa, Remy hides inside Trey's oversized SUV when Dexter and John Miller arrive at the Quik Zip, tipsy and playing with disposable cameras. From the shadows, she hears the two bandmates lament failed romances and Dexter describe her as someone who refused to risk more than a summer.
When Paul calls to her, Dexter realizes she has been listening. He confronts her about treating their connection as interchangeable with any other boyfriend. Remy says they are finished and leaves with Paul.
Barbara returns from a writing conference determined to make her marriage work, while Truth Squad heads to Washington for a record meeting. After the band leaves town, Remy restores order to her room and car, then ends things with Paul, whose reliable kindness never made her feel fully present.
Patty's Picture Exposes Don
On her last day at the salon, Remy visits Dexter at Flash Camera to make peace before leaving for college. He shows her the band's latest wall of embarrassing customer photographs. One picture stops her: Don's secretary, Patty, poses in lingerie in Barbara's bedroom, with the distinctive biblical tapestry visible behind her.
Remy assumes Dexter chose the image to punish her and throws it at him, refusing to hear his explanation. At home, she finds Ensure cans scattered through the house and a copy of the photograph in Barbara's typewriter.
Don has left after Patty revealed their affair. Remy immediately starts planning lawyers, bank accounts, and the logistics of another separation. Barbara, heartbroken but composed, asks Remy to let her handle it herself, giving her daughter permission to stop managing every crisis.
The Mistake Comes Clear
At the Quik Zip, Remy tells her friends that Dexter used Patty's photograph to hurt her. Chloe and Lissa point out that the picture proves the affair, not that Dexter knew whose bedroom it showed or understood its connection to Don.
Remy recognizes that she leapt from shock to accusation without asking what he knew. Earlier that evening, Chris and Jennifer Anne arrive engaged, and Barbara manages to celebrate their news despite her own marriage collapsing. Remy sees her mother's strength in the choice to let the next generation build its own future.
When Don pulls into the Quik Zip, Remy and her friends pelt his new car with fountain drinks. Then she drives off to look for Dexter, finally acting on uncertainty instead of waiting for certainty to protect her.
The Wedding Curb
Remy searches the town's reception halls and finds Truth Squad playing another wedding, back in their G Flats suits. The band's covers earn only scattered applause, and Dexter is outside alone when she reaches the service entrance.
The memory of their first meeting returns: Dexter had claimed they were meant to meet before he knew anything about her. This time Remy does not wait for him to pursue her or make the choice easy. She sits beside him, asks whether he truly believed in their connection, and accepts his answer through action rather than argument.
Remy kisses him, touching the pulse at his neck as he kisses her back. Her leap does not erase the distance between their plans or guarantee a future. It means she is willing to enter the uncertainty with him.
Epilogue
By November, Remy is settled at Stanford and receives a package from Dexter. Inside are imperfect photographs from the band's warped disposable cameras, including one of the two of them at the airport when she left for school. A CD from Rubber Records contains Truth Squad's music, including Dexter's altered version of This Lullaby.
On the back of the airport picture, Dexter has listed tour stops and added that he will reach her. Remy also reads Barbara's new novel, whose heroine chooses to leave both possible lovers and begin again alone. Remy understands the choice, but she is not making it herself. Dexter is far away, and nothing is guaranteed; she listens to the song and lets the next part remain unwritten.
The ending refuses to turn romance into a solved problem. Remy and Dexter are separated by geography, and the tour note promises effort rather than permanence. The damaged photographs embody that distinction: their flaws are visible, yet they preserve a real encounter. Barbara's novel offers a contrasting form of freedom, with its heroine refusing both suitors and choosing solitude. Remy does not need to imitate her mother or her mother's fictional character. She can leave for college without treating departure as proof that love was a mistake. The song also changes ownership: her father's recording remains part of her history, while Dexter's version becomes a shared present. Remy's growth is not certainty. It is her willingness to keep listening.
Analysis
This Lullaby treats cynicism as a learned survival skill rather than an innate personality. Remy has watched Barbara's marriages begin with theatrical hope and end in practical fallout, so she develops systems to keep emotion from becoming dependence: a schedule for relationships, a speech that limits expectations, and a childhood wager that turns marital collapse into arithmetic. Those habits give her control, but only by narrowing what she is willing to experience. Dexter unsettles her not because he is flawless, but because he is visibly imperfect and still approaches attachment without demanding guarantees.
The novel's central contrast is not between a wise romantic and a foolish skeptic. Barbara and Dexter both believe that an uncertain relationship can be worth having, but their optimism is not identical. Barbara has lived through many endings and continues to see love as a substantial part of a life, not proof that every marriage succeeds. Dexter's band life makes improvisation ordinary. Remy, by contrast, has confused avoiding pain with choosing freely. Her turning point comes when she stops requiring proof before taking a risk, first by seeking Dexter and then by accepting that distance will remain a real problem.
The song gives this emotional argument its most precise form. Thomas's version taught Remy to hear abandonment as a legacy, a father's preemptive admission that he would disappoint her. Dexter's arrangement briefly turns that inheritance into a public performance, which feels like a violation because he has mistaken access for understanding. Yet his later recording does not replace her father's song or erase the hurt. It allows Remy to add a new association without pretending the old one never existed.
The family subplots keep romance from becoming an isolated cure. Remy must stop managing Barbara's crises, while Chris's commitment to Jennifer Anne shows a different route into adulthood. Barbara's request that Remy step back is a gift of trust, not a rejection. The ending offers no certainty about forever. It offers a more adult measure of courage: Remy can leave home, love someone, and accept that neither choice guarantees the other.
Review Summary
This Lullaby receives mostly positive reviews, with readers praising Dessen's character development and relatable themes. Many enjoy the unconventional romance between cynical Remy and carefree Dexter. Some find the plot predictable but appreciate Dessen's writing style. Readers connect with Remy's journey to overcome her fear of love and relationships. While not everyone's favorite Dessen novel, many consider it a enjoyable, thought-provoking summer read. Some criticize the pacing and Remy's stubbornness, but overall, the book is well-received for its exploration of love, family, and personal growth.
People Also Read
Characters
Remy Starr
The guarded daughterRemy is a sharp, highly organized recent graduate who has spent years acting as her mother's fixer and planning her own escape to Stanford. She treats relationships like temporary arrangements with known expiration dates, believing that rules and careful exits can keep other people from hurting her. Her cynicism comes from repeated exposure to marriages that begin with hope and end in upheaval, as well as from a painful early sexual experience she has never fully faced. Remy is capable, funny, and fiercely protective, but she often mistakes emotional distance for strength. Her relationship with Dexter tests her belief that every attachment can be measured in advance, while her bond with Barbara forces her to reconsider who is responsible for carrying the family.
Dexter Jones
The fearless drummerDexter is the lanky, impulsive lead singer and drummer of Truth Squad, a band that travels from town to town and survives on day jobs and stubborn ambition. He meets Remy with startling confidence, then keeps returning despite her sharp refusals. His humor, challenges, and willingness to improvise can look like carelessness, but they also reflect a resilience developed in a family where relationships and stepfathers repeatedly changed. Dexter believes that risk is part of being alive, a view that clashes with Remy's need to forecast every ending. He is devoted to his elderly dog, Monkey, and to his bandmates, even when their ambitions conflict. His emotional openness is not the same as perfect judgment, but it gives Remy a different model of intimacy.
Barbara Starr
The hopeful novelistBarbara is Remy's romance-writing mother, a dramatic, energetic woman who commits herself to each new project and relationship with genuine hope. Her many marriages have made Remy cynical, but Barbara does not view the experience as wasted simply because some relationships end. She is imaginative and loving, yet her aversion to practical details leaves Remy carrying far too much responsibility. Writing lets Barbara inhabit grand emotional lives, while her everyday life is full of unfinished projects, new enthusiasms, and sudden crises. Her relationship with Remy combines deep affection with a long-standing imbalance: mother and daughter often slip into roles where Remy manages and Barbara depends. Barbara's beliefs about love are tested by experience, but she refuses to let disappointment define the whole of her life.
Chris Starr
The reforming brotherChris is Remy's older brother, a former troublemaker who has served jail time and is trying to build a steadier life. His relationship with Jennifer Anne has changed his habits: he dresses more carefully, holds a job, and takes pride in doing things for someone else. He and Remy share a childhood shaped by Barbara's unpredictability, and their old marriage-duration wager reflects a private sibling language built from skepticism. As Chris becomes more hopeful about commitment, he and Remy find themselves on opposite sides of the belief she once shared with him.
Jennifer Anne Baker
The determined reformerJennifer Anne is Chris's girlfriend, a receptionist with ambitious self-presentation and a strong belief in manners, discipline, and conventional commitment. She encourages Chris to improve his work habits and appearance, and her meticulous planning contrasts with the Starr household's improvisation. Remy initially sees her as rigid and self-important, especially when Jennifer Anne disapproves of the family's cynicism. Beneath the polished image, she is persistent and capable, and she shows care through practical effort, prepared meals, and attention to Chris's future.
Don Davis
The new stepfatherDon is a successful Toyota salesman who falls quickly for Barbara and brings money, possessions, and the promise of a stable home into the Starr family. As a lifelong bachelor, he is unused to sharing space or adjusting his routines to other people. He is generous with resources and eager to belong, but he can also be self-centered and quick to expect deference. His presence changes Remy's home from a place she manages into a household where another adult claims authority.
Lissa
The tender friendLissa is Remy's sensitive, affectionate friend, inclined to imagine a lasting future even when other people are wary. Adam's breakup leaves her grieving the future she had planned, and she struggles to separate losing a boyfriend from losing her whole path. Her tendency to feel everything openly makes the group protective of her, but it also gives her insight into Remy's hidden emotions. Lissa is more observant than Remy expects, and her gentle insistence can challenge the assumptions that Remy treats as facts.
Jess
The steady protectorJess is Remy's oldest and most dependable friend, a large, blunt young woman who rarely dresses up her opinions. Her mother died when Jess was young, leaving her to help raise her two younger brothers while her father worked. That responsibility made her practical and protective, especially when the friend group needs a sober driver or a clear-eyed voice. Jess does not romanticize relationships, but unlike Remy she is not obsessed with turning every feeling into a rule.
Chloe
The stylish skepticChloe is a fashionable, socially confident friend whose mother's work as a flight attendant supplies her with a steady stream of small liquor bottles and travel goods. She dates freely and shares Remy's suspicion of lasting relationships, making her a natural ally in the group's teasing and dating rituals. Beneath her easy confidence, Chloe is attentive to changes in Remy and worries when her friend begins to break the rules they built together. Her loyalty often appears as sharp humor rather than tenderness.
Paul
The polished alternativePaul is a well-mannered college student introduced to Remy through a salon client's matchmaking efforts. He is attractive, considerate, and comfortable with the temporary terms Remy prefers. He talks easily, respects her plans for Stanford, and appears to offer the uncomplicated relationship she believes she wants. Paul is not cruel or careless; the contrast is that their compatibility on paper does not necessarily create emotional depth.
Ted
The band's stubborn guitaristTed is a guitarist and one of Truth Squad's founders. He is fiercely protective of the band's original music and sees commercial covers as a threat to its artistic identity. His confidence can harden into inflexibility, creating conflict when the band has a chance to impress a record label. Ted's arguments reveal that a shared dream does not mean the bandmates agree on what success should cost.
Lucas
The practical keyboardistLucas plays keyboards in Truth Squad and often argues for a pragmatic mix of original songs and covers. He has more experience in bands than Dexter and Ted, and he is willing to adapt if it gives them a better chance with audiences or industry scouts. His dry intelligence makes him an effective counterweight to Ted's purity and Dexter's optimism, though he can be impatient with both.
John Miller
The hopeful drummerJohn Miller is Truth Squad's redheaded drummer, a good-natured and easily indignant young man who works at a coffee shop. His infatuation with manager Scarlett gives him a romantic subplot that echoes the band's broader uncertainty about growing up. He wants a future with music partly because it offers an alternative to the corporate path his family expects. His comic challenges and loyalty make him an affectionate presence in the band's makeshift household.
Lola
The salon matchmakerLola owns Joie Salon, where Remy works as a receptionist. Loud, generous, and quick to act, she trusts her instincts about people and tries to arrange dates for Remy even when Remy objects. Lola values loyalty and practical kindness, and she recognizes Remy's competence because Remy knows how to handle demanding customers. Her salon becomes one of the few places where Remy is appreciated for the work she quietly does.
Monkey
Dexter's old companionMonkey is Dexter's elderly, scruffy dog, with cloudy eyes, a trembling back leg, and a devotion that becomes visible whenever Dexter returns to him. He is a source of comic disorder at the band's house, but Remy's decision to wash and groom him reveals her tenderness before she is ready to admit it. Monkey makes care concrete: someone must notice the dirt, bring water, and stay beside him.
Scarlett Thomas
The coffee shop managerScarlett manages Jump Java and is the object of John Miller's earnest crush. She is a young single mother who has continued her education while working, and she is polite without encouraging his assumptions. Her presence gives John Miller a chance to confront the difference between admiring someone and understanding the demands of her life.
Arianna Moss
The record-label scoutArianna Moss works in artist relations for a record label and comes to hear Truth Squad perform. Her attention offers the band a possible path beyond local clubs, forcing the musicians to confront the tension between artistic ideals and the compromises that might help them be heard.
Patty
Don's dealership secretaryPatty works as Don's secretary and moves within the same local social orbit as Barbara and the dealership crowd. She is a small but consequential presence in the overlapping worlds of work and family, where private choices can become public knowledge.
P.J.
Lissa's new possibilityP.J. works with Lissa promoting KaBoom, a fizzy energy drink. His easy companionship gives Lissa a new focus after her breakup with Adam, though she must decide whether to wait for him or make the first move herself.
Thomas Custer
The absent songwriterThomas Custer is Remy's late father, a musician remembered publicly for one enduring song and privately through the recording Remy keeps hidden. He is more absence than memory in her life, which gives the song its double meaning: a gift from a father she never knew and a reminder of what he could not provide.
Angela
Remy's college roommateAngela is Remy's roommate at Stanford, an aerobics instructor who is casual about keeping their room tidy. She offers a brief glimpse of Remy's new college life and helps deliver the package that reconnects Remy with her summer.
Plot Devices
This Lullaby
A song reshaped by loveThomas Custer's hit song is both Remy's inheritance and the wound she associates with an absent father. Its promise of disappointment has helped her justify emotional distance. Dexter first learns its significance from Remy, then performs a new arrangement with the band, changing the song from a private family relic into a source of conflict. Later, his recording gives it another meaning: Remy can keep the history without treating it as a forecast of every relationship. The device links the opening image of a song that follows her everywhere to the final choice to listen differently.
The Marriage Wager
A private forecast of endingsAs children, Remy and Chris bet on how long Barbara's marriages will last, writing their guesses down and judging them by the day she announces a split. The wager turns family instability into a game with rules, dates, and a winner. Remy carries the same impulse into dating, using a schedule and a breakup speech to make romance feel predictable. The device shows how a coping strategy can become an identity: she is not merely protecting herself from hurt, she is trying to make uncertainty measurable.
Dexter's Challenges
Play becomes a test of trustDexter turns ordinary moments into bets, from naming states before a customer leaves the cleaners to daring a bandmate to eat a stack of bananas. The challenges are comic, but they also show how he approaches life: he prefers to try something and discover the result rather than calculate every risk in advance. Remy joins in because she likes competition, yet the habit gradually places her in situations she cannot control through preparation alone. The challenges create a shared language for flirting, arguing, and negotiating the possibility of a future.
The Warped Cameras
Flawed images distort certaintyDexter and Lucas keep defective disposable cameras from work and photograph strangers, bandmates, and ordinary objects. The pictures are visibly flawed, but they still preserve recognizable details. One image of Patty in lingerie becomes the evidence of Don's affair, while Remy wrongly assumes Dexter understood its connection to her family. Later, the camera's imperfect photographs reach Remy at Stanford, including a picture of her with Dexter at the airport. The device makes seeing and knowing distinct: an image can reveal a truth while leaving its context uncertain.
Diet Zip Cups
Anger finds its aimRemy and her friends turn fountain drinks into a recurring test of aim, arc, and wrist. The ritual is comic and social, but it also gives Remy a way to act when she cannot put her feelings into words. She has already used a cup to retaliate against Adam, and later the group uses drinks to shame Don after learning how he hurt Barbara. Their throws do not repair the damage, but they convert helpless anger into a shared physical gesture, one of the few ways the friends can make a consequence land immediately.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.