Plot Summary
Not On The Masthead
Clodagh "Clo" Harmon arrives in New York City, determined to make her mark at a prestigious magazine. She is not yet on the masthead, the official list of staff, and so she exists in a liminal space—unseen, undervalued, and desperate to prove herself. Her days begin earlier and end later than her colleagues, and she navigates the unspoken rules of the office with anxious precision. Clo's self-worth is tied to her ability to blend in and be useful, but she is haunted by the knowledge that her value is measured by her associations, not her own merit. The city is both exhilarating and alienating, and Clo's longing for recognition is matched only by her fear of being exposed as an outsider.
Show Horses, Workhorses
Clo learns the magazine is divided into "Show Horses"—the privileged, polished, and connected—and "Workhorses"—the diligent, overlooked, and striving. She is drawn to Davis Lawrence, a Show Horse with effortless charm and social capital, and becomes obsessed with understanding and emulating her. The office is a microcosm of class and ambition, where every detail—from shoes to lunch choices—signals status. Clo's internalized judgments and insecurities drive her to mimic the habits of the elite, even as she recognizes the futility of ever truly belonging. The unspoken rules are relentless, and the threat of failure is ever-present.
The Invisible Girl
Clo's days are filled with menial tasks and silent observations. She is both fascinated and intimidated by her boss, Marie Clarice, and her glamorous colleagues. When Marie abruptly leaves the magazine, Clo is thrust into uncertainty, fearing for her job and her place in the pecking order. She clings to Davis for guidance and validation, but their relationship is fraught with power imbalances and unspoken competition. Clo's longing for acceptance is palpable, and her self-deprecating humor masks a deep vulnerability. The magazine's culture rewards compliance and punishes deviation, leaving Clo in a constant state of anxious performance.
Borrowed Dresses, Borrowed Lives
Invited to a black-tie benefit, Clo is outfitted by the fashion department in a borrowed designer gown. The experience is both humiliating and intoxicating, as she is forced to confront her body's inadequacies and her outsider status. Yet, when she sees herself in the mirror, she is momentarily transformed—beautiful, powerful, and worthy. The gala itself is a revelation, exposing Clo to a world of privilege and possibility she never imagined. But the illusion is fleeting, and the return to her modest reality is jarring. The borrowed dress becomes a symbol of the life she covets but cannot claim.
Library Gala, Dive Bar
After the gala, Clo meets her best friend Allie at a dive bar, still in her ballgown. Their conversation is a bittersweet reminder of home, friendship, and the distance that ambition creates. Clo recounts the awe and awkwardness of the benefit, her hunger for recognition, and her fear of being left behind. The city's promise of reinvention is seductive, but the cost is a persistent sense of displacement. Clo's relationship with Allie grounds her, but also highlights the sacrifices required to chase success in New York. The night ends with laughter and longing, as Clo clings to fleeting moments of connection.
Climbing The Ladder
Clo's proximity to Davis and her growing competence earn her small opportunities, but also expose her to the magazine's darker realities. She learns to manipulate expense reports, navigate office politics, and leverage relationships for advancement. The boundaries between personal and professional blur, as Clo becomes entangled in Davis's social world and the machinations of powerful editors. The pursuit of success demands constant vigilance and self-censorship. Clo's ambition is both her engine and her undoing, as she is forced to choose between authenticity and assimilation.
Homesick Holidays
Returning home for Christmas, Clo is confronted by the comforts and constraints of her upbringing. Her family's chaos and her brother's struggles remind her of what she has left behind, while her friendship with Allie offers solace and perspective. The holidays are tinged with disappointment, as Clo realizes that the life she is building in New York is both exhilarating and isolating. The train ride back to the city is a meditation on fear, hope, and the relentless drive to prove herself. Clo's longing for home is matched by her determination to never settle.
Name On The Masthead
Clo's name finally appears on the masthead, granting her a sense of legitimacy and belonging. She savors the moment, recalling her childhood love of magazines and the dreams that brought her to New York. Yet, the achievement is bittersweet, as the realities of the job—competition, insecurity, and the constant threat of obsolescence—persist. The magazine's culture of exclusivity and performance leaves little room for vulnerability or error. Clo's victory is real, but fragile, and she is acutely aware that her place is always provisional.
Winter's Brutal Lessons
The city's harsh winter mirrors Clo's internal struggles. She endures daily indignities—awkward commutes, office slights, and encounters with powerful men who test her boundaries. The magazine's hierarchy is unforgiving, and Clo learns to swallow her pride, adapt to shifting expectations, and accept the transactional nature of relationships. Moments of kindness and camaraderie are rare, and often tinged with competition or ulterior motives. Clo's resilience is tested, and she is forced to confront the limits of her ambition and the compromises required to survive.
Alone In The City
Clo's weekends are marked by solitude and self-doubt. She practices being alone, hoping that one day it will feel like strength rather than failure. The city's promise of reinvention is seductive, but the reality is often one of isolation and disappointment. Clo's friendships are strained by distance, ambition, and the relentless demands of work. She clings to routines and small pleasures, but the ache of loneliness persists. The dream of belonging remains elusive, and Clo is haunted by the fear that she will never find her place.
Dancing With Davis
A night out with Davis offers Clo a taste of acceptance and excitement, but also exposes the precariousness of their bond. The evening is a blur of dancing, laughter, and late-night confessions, culminating in a shared meal and a sense of possibility. Yet, beneath the surface, tensions simmer—jealousy, insecurity, and the knowledge that their friendship is shaped by power dynamics and unspoken competition. Clo's desire to be chosen by Davis is both a source of joy and pain, as she grapples with the reality that true intimacy may always be out of reach.
Hangovers And Confessions
The morning after, Clo is wracked with guilt and self-recrimination. She seeks solace in familiar routines—church, coffee, small talk with her landlord—and reflects on the ways she has learned to manage her shame. The rituals of Catholicism offer comfort, but also reinforce the sense of never being good enough. Clo's interactions with the women in her neighborhood and her landlord are tinged with longing for approval and fear of judgment. The cycle of striving, failing, and seeking redemption is relentless, and Clo wonders if she will ever break free.
Show Horses, Workhorses, Again
Clo's observations of her colleagues deepen her understanding of the magazine's social order. The distinction between Workhorses and Show Horses is both subtle and profound, shaping every interaction and opportunity. Clo recognizes herself as a Workhorse—privileged, but not privileged enough—and becomes increasingly adept at reading the codes of belonging. The desire to be chosen, to be seen as exceptional, drives her to mimic the habits and tastes of the elite. Yet, the realization that the game is rigged leaves her both resentful and complicit.
Red Coat, Gold Card
A shopping trip with Davis and the acquisition of a red designer coat mark a turning point for Clo. The coat is both a symbol of arrival and a reminder of the compromises she has made—using Davis's mother's credit card, lying to herself and others, and accepting gifts that come with strings attached. The thrill of transformation is tempered by guilt and the knowledge that her new identity is built on borrowed resources. Clo's complicity in the magazine's culture of appearances becomes increasingly difficult to ignore.
Barbara's World
Clo is drawn deeper into the orbit of Davis and her mother, Barbara, a former actress whose charisma and volatility shape every interaction. The apartment is a stage, and Clo is both audience and understudy, learning the scripts and cues that govern Barbara's world. The relationship between Barbara and Davis is fraught with competition, resentment, and unspoken wounds. Clo's desire to be chosen by Barbara is matched by her fear of being discarded. The boundaries between loyalty, ambition, and self-preservation blur, and Clo is forced to confront the limits of her own agency.
New Boss, New Rules
The arrival of a new editor, Isobel Fincher, brings changes to the magazine's culture and to Clo's role. Isobel is competent, demanding, and enigmatic, offering Clo both mentorship and a new set of challenges. The shifting power dynamics create opportunities for advancement, but also expose Clo to new forms of competition and scrutiny. The lines between friendship, rivalry, and exploitation become increasingly difficult to navigate. Clo's ambition is both rewarded and punished, and she is forced to reckon with the moral costs of her choices.
Lunches, Lies, and Loyalties
Clo's relationships with Davis, Harry, and Barbara become increasingly tangled as secrets, lies, and betrayals accumulate. The pursuit of success demands constant negotiation of loyalties and the willingness to sacrifice others for personal gain. Clo's complicity in the magazine's culture of deception is mirrored in her personal life, as she rationalizes questionable choices and distances herself from the consequences. The cost of ambition is isolation, and Clo is haunted by the knowledge that her victories are built on the losses of others.
The Price of Belonging
As the magazine and Clo's personal life unravel, she is forced to confront the emptiness at the heart of her ambition. The relationships she has built—fragile, transactional, and often toxic—begin to collapse under the weight of accumulated secrets and betrayals. The pursuit of belonging has left her alienated from herself and others, and the realization that she may never truly arrive is both devastating and liberating. Clo's journey ends with a reckoning—with her own complicity, with the limits of reinvention, and with the knowledge that the price of belonging may be more than she is willing to pay.
Characters
Clodagh "Clo" Harmon
Clo is the novel's protagonist, a young woman from a modest background who arrives in New York City determined to make her mark at a prestigious magazine. Her intelligence and work ethic are matched by deep insecurities and a relentless desire for approval. Clo is both a keen observer and a chameleon, adept at reading social cues and adapting to the expectations of those around her. Her relationships—with Davis, Barbara, Harry, and her colleagues—are shaped by a longing for acceptance and a fear of exposure. Clo's journey is one of transformation, compromise, and ultimately, reckoning with the costs of ambition and assimilation. Her psychological arc is defined by the tension between authenticity and performance, and her development is marked by moments of self-awareness, shame, and fleeting triumph.
Davis Lawrence
Davis is the golden girl of the magazine, a Show Horse whose beauty, pedigree, and social capital make her both admired and resented. She is the daughter of Barbara Lawrence, a former actress, and her life is defined by privilege, expectation, and the burden of being exceptional. Davis is both generous and withholding, drawing Clo into her orbit while maintaining a careful distance. Her relationship with her mother is fraught with competition and unspoken wounds, and her friendship with Clo is marked by power imbalances and mutual need. Davis's psychological complexity is revealed through moments of vulnerability, self-doubt, and rebellion against the roles imposed on her. Her development is shaped by trauma, loss, and the struggle to assert her own identity.
Barbara Lawrence
Barbara is Davis's mother, a former Broadway actress whose charm, volatility, and need for control dominate the lives of those around her. She is both nurturing and destructive, offering Clo opportunities and affection while demanding loyalty and compliance. Barbara's relationship with Davis is a study in maternal ambivalence—pride, envy, and the projection of her own unfulfilled ambitions. Her interactions with Clo are transactional, and her generosity is often laced with expectation and manipulation. Barbara's psychological profile is marked by narcissism, insecurity, and a desperate need to remain relevant. Her development is a cautionary tale about the costs of living through others and the dangers of unchecked power.
Harry Wood
Harry is a journalist and social connector, known for his wit, ambition, and ability to navigate multiple social worlds. He is both a confidant and a competitor to Clo and Davis, leveraging his relationships for personal and professional gain. Harry's background is marked by instability and a longing for belonging, which drives his relentless networking and self-promotion. His friendship with Davis is complex—protective, exploitative, and tinged with unresolved feelings. With Clo, he oscillates between ally and adversary, offering mentorship and manipulation in equal measure. Harry's psychological arc is defined by the tension between loyalty and self-interest, and his development is shaped by moments of vulnerability, betrayal, and self-preservation.
Marie Clarice (MC)
MC is Clo's first boss at the magazine, a French editor whose sophistication and unpredictability set the tone for Clo's early experiences. Her abrupt departure is a reminder of the magazine's ruthless culture and the precariousness of success. MC's relationship with Clo is transactional, and her expectations are both exacting and opaque. She serves as a cautionary figure, embodying the fate that awaits those who fail to adapt or fall out of favor. MC's psychological profile is marked by exhaustion, disappointment, and the erosion of identity in a world that values novelty over loyalty.
L.K. Smith
L.K. is the magazine's second-in-command, a formidable presence who oversees staffing, enforces the rules, and protects the institution's reputation. She is both feared and respected, and her approval is a coveted prize. L.K.'s relationship with Clo is one of tough love—she recognizes Clo's potential but demands compliance and discretion. Her psychological complexity lies in her ability to balance empathy with ruthlessness, and her development is shaped by the need to maintain order in a world of constant flux. L.K. serves as both a mentor and a reminder of the costs of survival.
Isobel Fincher
Isobel is the new senior editor who replaces MC, bringing a different energy and set of expectations to the magazine. She is intelligent, principled, and somewhat aloof, offering Clo both mentorship and a new set of challenges. Isobel's relationship with Clo is marked by mutual respect, but also by the limitations of institutional change. Her psychological profile is defined by a commitment to craft, a resistance to compromise, and a quiet resilience. Isobel's development is a counterpoint to the magazine's culture of performance, offering a glimpse of what integrity might look like in a compromised world.
Allie Blum
Allie is Clo's best friend from childhood, a source of comfort, perspective, and occasional judgment. Her life in New York is both a model and a warning for Clo, and their friendship is tested by distance, ambition, and the divergent paths they take. Allie's psychological role is to ground Clo, offering reminders of home, shared history, and the possibility of a different kind of success. Her development is shaped by her own ambitions, relationships, and the challenges of adulthood. Allie serves as a mirror for Clo's choices and a touchstone for her values.
Lydia Saintclair-Abbott (Liddy)
Liddy is another assistant at the magazine, initially perceived as a Show Horse but later revealed to be a fraud. Her carefully constructed identity and eventual downfall serve as a cautionary tale for Clo, highlighting the dangers of self-invention and the fragility of social capital. Liddy's relationship with Clo is competitive, and her presence amplifies Clo's insecurities about class, belonging, and authenticity. Her psychological arc is one of exposure and collapse, and her development is a reminder of the costs of living a lie.
Mark Angelbeck
Mark is the magazine's publisher, a charming and influential figure whose attention is both flattering and dangerous. His relationship with Clo is marked by flirtation, manipulation, and the implicit exchange of favors for advancement. Mark embodies the magazine's culture of transactional relationships, and his psychological profile is defined by nostalgia, entitlement, and a willingness to exploit others for personal gain. His development is a warning about the perils of seeking validation from those in power.
Plot Devices
Social Hierarchies and Codes
The novel's central plot device is the navigation of social hierarchies—both within the magazine and in the broader world of New York's elite. The distinction between Show Horses and Workhorses shapes every interaction, opportunity, and betrayal. The unspoken codes of dress, speech, and behavior are both a means of survival and a source of anxiety. Clo's journey is marked by her ability to read and adapt to these codes, even as she recognizes their arbitrariness and cruelty. The plot is driven by moments of inclusion and exclusion, and the constant threat of exposure or obsolescence.
Borrowed Identity and Reinvention
Clo's ascent is facilitated by her willingness to borrow—clothes, credit cards, personas, and even relationships. The act of borrowing is both literal and metaphorical, symbolizing the fluidity of identity and the costs of assimilation. The plot is punctuated by moments of transformation—putting on a borrowed dress, acquiring a red coat, using someone else's resources—that offer temporary empowerment but also deepen Clo's sense of fraudulence. The tension between authenticity and performance is a recurring motif, and the threat of being unmasked drives much of the narrative's suspense.
Power, Complicity, and Moral Ambiguity
The novel employs a structure of escalating moral compromise, as Clo and other characters make choices that blur the lines between right and wrong. The pursuit of success demands complicity in systems of exploitation, deception, and betrayal. Foreshadowing is used to hint at the consequences of these choices—lost friendships, professional setbacks, and personal disintegration. The narrative is structured around moments of reckoning, where characters are forced to confront the costs of their ambition and the limits of their agency.
Cyclical Structure and Recurring Motifs
The novel's structure is cyclical, with recurring motifs—changing shoes, borrowed clothes, longing for the masthead, the tension between home and ambition—reinforcing the sense that Clo's journey is both unique and universal. The repetition of certain events (parties, benefits, betrayals) underscores the futility of seeking arrival in a world that is always moving the goalposts. The use of mirrors, doubles, and rivalries amplifies the psychological complexity of the characters and the instability of identity.
Narrative Voice and Self-Reflection
The story is told through Clo's first-person perspective, blending sharp observation, self-deprecating humor, and moments of raw vulnerability. The narrative voice is both confessional and unreliable, inviting readers to question the accuracy of Clo's perceptions and the motivations behind her choices. The use of direct address, rhetorical questions, and meta-commentary creates intimacy and complicity with the reader, while also highlighting the constructed nature of the story. The plot is propelled by Clo's internal monologue, her shifting alliances, and her evolving understanding of herself and her world.
Analysis
Caroline Palmer's Workhorse is a razor-sharp exploration of ambition, class, and the relentless pursuit of belonging in a world defined by invisible hierarchies and shifting codes. Through Clo's journey from invisible assistant to compromised insider, the novel dissects the costs of assimilation and the moral ambiguities of survival in elite spaces. The distinction between Show Horses and Workhorses serves as both a social taxonomy and a psychological framework, exposing the ways in which privilege is performed, policed, and perpetually out of reach for outsiders. Palmer's narrative is both a satire and a lament, capturing the intoxicating allure of transformation and the emptiness that often lies beneath borrowed glamour. The novel's cyclical structure and recurring motifs reinforce the futility of seeking arrival in a world that is always moving the goalposts. Ultimately, Workhorse is a meditation on the price of ambition—the friendships sacrificed, the self betrayed, and the realization that the pursuit of belonging may leave one more alienated than ever. The lesson is both timely and timeless: in a culture obsessed with reinvention, the hardest work is learning to live with oneself.
Last updated:
