Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Banana Splitsville

Banana Splitsville

Two teen girls dodge romance as returning exes and new crushes unsettle their plans.
by Catherine Clark 2000 288 pages
3.36
500+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Ten Weeks Without Parents

Colleen’s friends move into the island home

Colleen Templeton is spending the summer on a Maine island while her parents take a ten-week trip through Europe. Her boyfriend, Ben, works on the ferry, and her friends Haley and Samantha are moving into the family house so Colleen will not be alone. Erica arrives with Colleen from Portland, then reveals that her protective parents have forbidden her to live there.

Before leaving, Colleen’s mother makes the girls sign a list of rules against drinking, parties, and overnight guests. The emotional send-off leaves Colleen crying at the airport, but her friends are waiting at home. Their summer arrangement promises independence, though the empty bedroom and strict rules leave room for complications.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The summer begins as both a gift and a test. Colleen’s parents trust her enough to leave, but their bright-pink contract makes clear that independence is conditional, monitored, and easy to lose. Erica’s exclusion also complicates the fantasy of a perfectly balanced household: friendship cannot override family authority. Colleen is excited by the prospect of privacy with Ben, yet the airport farewell shows that growing up does not erase attachment to home. Her imagined summer is already pulled between two forms of intimacy, romantic closeness and the enduring shelter of family.

Evan Returns to Bobb’s

The ex Colleen never expected to see is hired

On her first shift at Bobb’s Lobster, Colleen sees Evan, the Philadelphia boy who spent the previous summer with her and then stopped answering her messages. He has returned without warning and will work beside her, while Ben is employed on the ferry. Evan treats their reunion lightly, recounting the mishaps that delayed his arrival; Colleen is left furious that he can joke after disappearing from her life.

At the staff meeting, Trudy also introduces Blair, a newcomer who needs housing. Colleen offers Blair the empty bedroom after checking with her parents. Haley objects that the household should have decided together, but Blair accepts the house rules and moves in, setting a second source of tension inside the home.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Evan’s return turns Colleen’s carefully ordered summer into a test of her own account of the past. She has described him as an old mistake and Ben as a safer, more dependable love, but her physical response to Evan makes that distinction harder to maintain. Blair’s arrival parallels the disruption: Colleen offers trust before she has enough evidence to judge a person, while Haley resents being excluded from the decision. Both relationships expose a weakness in Colleen’s confidence. She wants to believe that good intentions can make a situation manageable, even when history and boundaries say otherwise.

Secrets on the Ferry

Colleen delays telling Ben about her ex

Colleen postpones telling Ben that Evan is back, hoping to spare him an awkward conversation and herself the discomfort of naming the old relationship. When she finally explains during a ferry trip, Ben is hurt less by the fact that she dated Evan than by her week of silence. The awkward crossing leaves them distant, but he later accepts her explanation over lunch and admits he has not shared every detail of his own past.

Meanwhile, Colleen and Evan fall into their old teasing rhythm at work. During a rainy shift, she shoves him on the dock; he slips into the harbor, then pulls her in after him. Their soaked clothes and sudden laughter revive memories she thought she had buried, even as she insists she is committed to Ben.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Colleen’s concealment is small in practical terms but large in relational meaning. By managing Ben’s knowledge for him, she tries to control his reaction and protect the image of herself as a trustworthy partner. His anger reveals that honesty is not simply a record of past behavior; it is a sign of whether someone is treated as an equal in the present. The harbor tumble exposes what her explanations cannot settle. Her rivalry with Evan is charged with play, memory, and desire, while her attachment to Ben rests on security. The novel lets those motives coexist before Colleen can name the difference.

Blair Rewrites the Rules

A house party leaves Colleen facing inspections

Blair paints Colleen’s parents’ bedroom purple without permission, then throws a loud party while Colleen and Samantha are still at work. Guests drink in the house despite the posted rules, and the next morning Colleen’s aunt and uncle arrive to find a trashed kitchen and a young man rushing out of Haley’s room. Haley claims he had been fixing a drain, but the explanation does little to reassure the relatives.

Colleen invites them to dinner to prove the house is under control. Blair also borrows Colleen’s Volvo without asking and neglects shared chores, while Haley and Samantha grow tired of carrying her share. Colleen keeps trying to smooth things over, even as Blair repeatedly makes her responsible for the consequences.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The household conflict makes the parents’ rules more than comic decoration. Each violation transfers risk from Blair, who acts freely, to Colleen, whose name is attached to the house and whose relatives can report back to her parents. Colleen’s instinct is to absorb the trouble rather than confront the person causing it. That habit resembles her romantic evasions: she manages appearances so that nobody has to face an unpleasant truth. Haley’s anger is therefore not merely about towels, paint, or a borrowed car. She sees Colleen weakening the shared authority that made their arrangement feel fair.

The Hamilton Jewelry Scandal

A theft accusation sends Ben away in anger

After Bobb’s caters a party at the wealthy Hamilton home, jewelry goes missing. Trudy tells Colleen that she was the last worker inside and suspends her while the theft is investigated. Colleen is devastated by the suspicion and turns to Evan for comfort on the dock. Ben sees them embracing and leaves before she can explain.

Colleen abandons her shift and runs to Ben’s house, but he tells her he cannot remain her boyfriend while she decides whether she wants Evan. He ends their relationship. When Colleen returns home, Haley says she has treated Ben like a backup and refuses to excuse her behavior. Colleen is left without her job, her boyfriend, or the easy support of her closest friend.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The theft accusation supplies the immediate crisis, but it does not create Colleen’s underlying dilemma. It exposes it. In the moment she feels most wronged, she reaches for Evan rather than the friends who would also have comforted her, and Ben reads that choice against weeks of secrecy and tension. His breakup forces Colleen to confront the difference between loving someone and choosing him clearly. Haley’s rebuke matters because it comes from a friend who has seen the entire pattern, not just the dockside embrace. Colleen can no longer treat indecision as harmless when other people are paying for it.

Blair’s Bag Tells the Truth

Samantha finds the jewelry and clears Colleen

Samantha suspects Blair after noticing gaps in her story about the Hamilton party. She searches Blair’s backpack and finds the missing jewelry along with belongings taken from the house. Blair admits the theft, apologizes to Trudy, and is fired; Colleen’s suspension is lifted.

The discovery clears Colleen professionally but does not repair her relationships. She learns that Evan’s visiting friend, Dahlia, has come to the island, and realizes he has not offered her the steady commitment she once wanted.

Colleen also misses Haley, who has returned to her family’s home after their fight. To bring the group together, Colleen organizes a barbecue and invites Sam’s summer admirer, Troy, giving her friends a reason to gather without forcing an apology from anyone.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The solved theft restores Colleen’s reputation, but the emotional damage does not vanish with the evidence. That separation is important: being proved innocent does not make her innocent of the choices Ben and Haley challenged. Blair’s betrayal clarifies how much Colleen’s generosity depends on trust, while her own romantic situation asks whether attraction can be trusted without consistency. Organizing a party for Samantha and Troy is a small move toward repair. Colleen cannot command Haley’s forgiveness or Ben’s return, but she can create a space in which friendship might resume without turning every gathering into a courtroom.

The Closet Door Closes

Colleen and Evan choose desire over distance

At Colleen’s barbecue, Ben attends and speaks with her civilly, but their old ease has not returned. Evan arrives without an invitation, and Colleen tries to keep away from him. They end up upstairs, where he admits that thinking about her helped change his plans and bring him back to the island. Colleen accepts his kiss and spends the night with him, despite the house rule and the uncertainty between them.

A violent storm soon knocks out the island’s power and telephone service. Evan, Samantha, and Haley shelter together with Colleen as the house shakes around them. By morning the island is damaged but safe. Colleen sees Ben helping Haley from a boat, and recognizes a closeness between them she no longer wants to deny.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The night with Evan is not a clean romantic solution. It is a deliberate movement toward what Colleen wants, but it does not erase his history of leaving or guarantee a future. The storm gives that choice a physical setting: the household loses its ordinary signals and must rely on whoever is actually present. Evan’s place among the friends matters because he joins their crisis rather than appearing only as a private temptation. At the same time, Colleen’s acceptance of Ben and Haley’s closeness marks a change in her moral attention. She begins to see other people’s bonds as real, not as obstacles to her own story.

A Cat Boards Moby

Colleen prepares for home and an uncertain future

Colleen’s parents cut their trip short and will arrive within days, so the household scrambles to restore their bedroom and clean the house. Colleen and Samantha repaint the purple walls, while Erica, Betty, and Colleen’s aunt and uncle help with chores and food.

Samantha’s plan to sell Colleen’s collage art at Bobb’s gives Colleen a concrete way to pursue her artistic ambitions. Haley gradually returns to the household, and Colleen tells her she would be happy if she and Ben became closer.

When Colleen finally boards the ferry to collect her parents, Evan comes to see her off. A calico cat slips aboard after her, carrying a dark patch around one eye like a tiny pirate mask. Colleen watches the island recede, ready to return to her family and face what comes next.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ending does not secure Colleen’s romantic future; it enlarges her sense of what a future can contain. She can want Evan without demanding that he become Ben, and she can release Ben without treating his possible connection with Haley as a betrayal. Restoring the house is practical restitution for the freedoms she abused, while the art-show plan gives her a direction beyond romance. The ferry cat echoes her father’s stories about how island cats arrived, but its deeper function is to carry uncertainty forward. Colleen leaves with affection, work, friendship, and artistic possibility, not a finished map.

Courtney’s Year Without Dates

Dave ends their relationship before senior year

In Colorado, Courtney Smith begins a journal after Dave breaks up with her at a backyard cookout, just before leaving for college in Boulder. He frames the split as inevitable, while Courtney feels blindsided and humiliated. She tries to avoid returning to school as the girl whose boyfriend left, then vows not to date anyone during senior year.

Her friends Beth and Jane push her toward student council, where Courtney runs for vice president against a field of boys and partners with the charming, notorious Tom Delaney. She wins after classmates mock her embarrassing middle name and Tom publicly helps her regain control of the room. The election gives Courtney a role and a mission at the exact moment her private life feels directionless.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Courtney uses the journal to turn pain into a case she can review, but her first conclusion is rigid: if relationships can end without warning, avoiding them must be safer. The no-dating vow gives her a sense of control, while student council offers a public arena where she can act rather than wait for Dave to call. Yet her election beside Tom immediately complicates the vow. The book’s comedy comes from Courtney’s attempt to legislate desire, but its psychology is sharper than the joke. Rules help her survive uncertainty, then become another way to avoid responding to the changing people around her.

Hail Between Courtney and Dave

A hopeful letter sends her toward Boulder

Dave eventually sends Courtney a letter saying he misses her and remembers their trip together. Courtney reads it as a request to reconcile and drives toward Boulder, but a violent hailstorm batters her Taurus with dents and forces her to turn back.

At a gas station, she finds Dave’s friends on their way to visit him, and their plans make her feel excluded before she has even arrived. Later Dave visits her workplace, Truth or Dairy, and Courtney’s hope rises again.

They talk privately, but he proposes waiting several months before considering a reunion. Courtney refuses to organize her life around his timetable. The exchange leaves them neither together nor fully finished, and her attempts to move on remain tangled with every message he sends.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The hailstorm works as a literal interruption to Courtney’s attempt to recover the past, but it does not provide a supernatural verdict. She wants the weather to mean something because chance is harder to tolerate than a clear sign. Dave’s letter feeds the same interpretive habit: Courtney converts ambivalence into a promise, then discovers that his idea of reconciliation is delayed and conditional. Her refusal to wait is an early act of self-respect, though it is not yet emotional freedom. She still measures her choices by what Dave may think, which keeps him central even when she says she is done.

The Roof, the Dog, the Lie

Grant helps Courtney through a difficult autumn

Courtney’s student council book challenge succeeds, forcing the officers to sleep on the middle school roof in November weather. She ends up beside Tom, but the cold and shared sleeping bag produce awkward comedy rather than romance. Outside school, her dog Oscar, who has epilepsy after being hit by a car, runs away.

Grant Superior, a former target of Courtney’s suspicions and now a worker at the pet shop, searches for him and helps find him near a pasta factory. His practical kindness makes Courtney reconsider him. She also gets closer to him over lunch, though she denies that their meeting feels like a date. Courtney’s promise to avoid romance remains intact on paper, while her attention is increasingly drawn to Grant.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The roof challenge and Oscar’s disappearance test Courtney in different registers. The roof exposes how little control she has over weather, bodies, or the consequences of her own student-council ideas. Oscar’s illness makes care concrete: affection means remembering medication, searching streets, and accepting help. Grant earns Courtney’s trust through those actions rather than through a dramatic declaration. Her attraction unsettles the vow she treats as moral proof of maturity. The contrast suggests that integrity is not the ability to keep every rule unchanged; it is the willingness to revise a rule when lived experience reveals what it excludes.

A Nebraska Blizzard Rescue

Tom pulls Courtney’s family from a snowbank

On the drive to Thanksgiving with her family, Courtney skids the Taurus into a snowbank during a blizzard. Tom, traveling to visit his father, stops and takes Courtney, her mother, her brother Bryan, and Oscar to the family gathering. The delay strands them with her grandparents, whose renewed intimacy shocks Courtney and complicates her idea of what older people want.

She and Tom share a room and an accidental night beside each other, but nothing happens between them. Back at school, Dave tells Courtney he is seeing someone else. She blames Grant for not warning her sooner and lashes out, even though he had been trying to be a friend. Her gratitude to Tom and her anger at Grant leave her more confused than before.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The blizzard strips Courtney of her usual ability to narrate events from a safe distance. She needs rescue, accepts help from Tom, and witnesses her grandparents choosing a form of intimacy she had not imagined for them. Their age does not cancel desire, just as Courtney’s own rules cannot make desire disappear. The difficult call about Dave’s new girlfriend then redirects her fear into anger at Grant, the person closest enough to disappoint her. This displacement matters: she treats Grant as responsible for information and feelings he cannot control, repeating the same demand for certainty that Dave has trained into her.

Love Moves Through the Family

Courtney discovers Beth and Bryan are dating

Courtney overhears Beth and her younger brother Bryan speaking affectionately by phone and learns that they have been secretly dating. She resents being excluded and worries Beth will hurt Bryan, while Beth argues that she has changed and wants a real relationship.

At Christmas, Courtney’s older sister Alison arrives with Jessie, the woman she loves, and reveals that she is gay. Courtney realizes Alison kept this private because she was not ready to tell the family.

These discoveries arrive alongside the news that Dave has a girlfriend and that Courtney’s grandparents have rekindled their marriage. Instead of one betrayal, Courtney faces several relationships developing outside her supervision, forcing her to consider whether her protectiveness is really care or fear of being left behind.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The family plot broadens the book’s definition of change. Beth’s relationship with Bryan unsettles Courtney’s assumptions about age, loyalty, and her own authority as Bryan’s sister. Alison’s disclosure adds a more intimate form of trust: she has not hidden herself to wound Courtney, but because coming out belongs to her own timing. The grandparents’ renewed intimacy further defeats Courtney’s belief that relationships follow a predictable schedule. Her first reaction to each revelation is to evaluate whether it threatens her, yet their separate stories reveal a pattern. People can love one another without organizing their choices around Courtney’s comfort.

The Student Council Money Vanishes

A school inquiry collides with Courtney’s new job

The school discovers that student council funds and supplies are missing, and suspicion falls on Courtney and Tom, the two people with access to the accounts. Grant leads the student honor review, putting Courtney’s growing attraction to him alongside her fear that he may judge her guilty.

At the same time, smoothie-shop owner Gerry pressures her to help open a second Truth or Dairy in Boulder, where Dave now lives. Courtney resists the transfer, quits, then reluctantly returns when she realizes how much she misses Beth and their original workplace.

When Grant brings Dave into the new shop, Courtney feels exposed and treats both boys coldly. The job change, investigation, and strained friendships converge, leaving her unable to hide behind a simple promise to avoid dating.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The financial investigation externalizes a question Courtney has been avoiding: what does being trustworthy look like when other people have reason to doubt her? Grant’s role makes her private feelings inseparable from public accountability, while Gerry’s transfer to Boulder places her near Dave without giving her control over the encounter. Her quitting is less a clear act of independence than an attempt to escape discomfort. Returning to Truth or Dairy shows that work, friendship, and identity are tied together for her. The episode challenges her habit of treating departure as the only way to regain power.

A Kiss and a Confession

Courtney’s choices push Grant out of reach

At a Christmas party, spiked punch leaves Courtney drunk enough to kiss Tom after spotting Dave with his new girlfriend. Grant sees the kiss and is hurt, especially because Courtney had refused his invitation to ski while insisting she would not date anyone.

The next day, Tom visits Courtney’s family and admits he spent the student council money on himself. He asks her to help negotiate a way to repay it and avoid expulsion. Courtney agrees to help, but Grant refuses to trust her after her evasions about Tom, Thanksgiving, and her plans.

She finally understands that her supposedly harmless lies have made her words difficult to believe. Rather than wait for Grant to forgive her, Courtney begins organizing a fundraiser to repair the school’s losses.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The kiss is less a romantic choice than a panic response: Courtney sees Dave with someone else and uses Tom to demonstrate that she can move on. But the gesture lands in the life of someone who genuinely cares about her, making it impossible to dismiss as meaningless. Grant’s anger reflects the accumulated cost of her evasions, not simply jealousy. Tom’s confession then forces Courtney into a role she has wanted to claim, that of advocate and future lawyer, while denying her the comfort of pretending the case is innocent. Accountability begins when she stops arguing about what she meant and starts repairing what she helped damage.

A New Year, a Found Dog

Courtney raises the money and says yes to Grant

Courtney persuades Gerry and the pet shop to support a school fundraiser, where students groom animals and sell smoothies to raise money. The proceeds fall short, but her grandparents donate enough to save the New Year’s party.

Tom faces community service, repayment, and a public apology for taking the funds. At the celebration, Courtney becomes interim student council president after the faculty recognizes her work. Grant, who had stopped speaking to her, asks her to go skiing; this time she accepts.

They visit the zoo together and find Oscar beside a giant illuminated giraffe. Grant helps calm the dog, and Courtney kisses him. She ends the year with Oscar safe, a repaired sense of purpose, and a relationship she chose without pretending she could predict its outcome.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Courtney’s final progress is measured through actions rather than a sudden cure for insecurity. She builds a fundraiser, persuades adults to contribute, and accepts consequences for Tom instead of trying to conceal the scandal. The grandparents’ donation repairs the practical damage while also showing that family support can be offered without controlling her choices. Finding Oscar at the zoo joins the novel’s two forms of care: Grant’s patient knowledge of animals and Courtney’s willingness to let him help. Her yes to skiing is significant because it is not a promise of permanence. It is a decision made in the present, after she has finally stopped treating uncertainty as a reason to refuse life.

Analysis

These two novels place teenage romance inside communities where private choices rarely remain private. On the Maine island, Colleen’s home, restaurant, ferry, and friendships form one small social system. Her unresolved attachment to Evan is not an isolated love triangle; it affects Ben, Haley, her housemates, and her confidence in herself. The story treats reliability as a real form of intimacy, but it does not make reliability the same thing as desire. Colleen has to recognize that she can care for Ben and still be unable to choose him honestly. Her growth is less about selecting the correct boy than learning to stop managing others through silence and reassurance.

Courtney’s Colorado story approaches the same adolescent uncertainty through comic overplanning. She makes vows, reads meaning into weather, and interprets every message from Dave as evidence in a case she hopes to win. Her journal preserves the mismatch between her self-image and her behavior: she claims to reject romance while watching for signs that she is wanted. The plot gradually redirects her attention toward commitments she can enact, including caring for Oscar, helping her school, and being truthful with Grant. In both stories, adults and young people alike are shown revising their relationships, from Colleen’s grandparents to Courtney’s sister Alison. Maturity emerges not as certainty or permanent commitment, but as the ability to respect other people’s choices while taking responsibility for one’s own.

Summary in 60 Seconds
Colleen spends the summer on a Maine island while her parents travel, sharing their home with friends. Her former boyfriend Evan returns, stirring old feelings just as she is dating Ben. When jewelry disappears from a catering job, Colleen is blamed, and Ben ends their relationship after seeing her with Evan. Her friend Samantha finds the stolen items in Blair’s bag, clearing Colleen. Colleen chooses Evan, while recognizing that Haley and Ben are growing close. In Colorado, Courtney vows to avoid dating after Dave leaves her, but she struggles with his mixed signals and grows close to Grant. When student council money goes missing, Courtney discovers Tom took it. She helps organize repayment, earns the trust of her community, and begins a relationship with Grant. Oscar, her dog, is found safe.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.36 out of 5
Average of 500+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Banana Splitsville follows Courtney's senior year after being dumped by her college-bound boyfriend Dave. Told through diary entries, she vows to stay boyfriendless while working at Truth or Dairy and running for student council, though Dave's friend Grant complicates matters. Reviews average 3.36/5 stars. Readers praise the humorous, diary-style writing and relatable protagonist, comparing it to The Princess Diaries. Critics note Courtney can be vain and hard to root for, the plot is predictable and light, and some found the journal format jarring. Most agree it's a quick, fluffy read best suited for teenage girls who enjoy chick-lit.

Your rating:
4.04
46 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Colleen Templeton

Island artist in transition

Colleen is an artistic, observant teenager who lives year-round on a Maine island and works at Bobb’s Lobster. She wants love to feel dependable, which makes Ben’s steadiness appealing and Evan’s unpredictability difficult to resist. Her quick humor often protects her from admitting that she is hurt or confused. Colleen is generous with friends and neighbors, but she sometimes confuses keeping the peace with behaving honestly. Her collage art gives her an independent identity beyond romance, while the island’s close community makes every choice visible. She is driven by affection, curiosity, and a wish to be trusted, even as she learns that trust requires more than good intentions.

Evan

Unsettling summer ex

Evan is Colleen’s former summer boyfriend, a lively runner from Philadelphia who returns to the island and works at Bobb’s. He is playful, physically confident, and skilled at turning discomfort into a joke. His appetite for spontaneity makes him exciting company, but his unreliable communication has left Colleen feeling discarded. He is interested in her art and remembers the intimate details of their past, which makes their renewed connection harder for her to dismiss. Evan tends to live in the immediate moment rather than offer dependable plans, and that difference shapes the tension between what Colleen desires and what she can safely expect.

Ben

Steady ferry boyfriend

Ben is Colleen’s current boyfriend, a newcomer to the island who once met her on the school ferry while struggling with seasickness. He is gentle, reliable, and affectionate, with a practical sense of responsibility shaped by his ferry job and close family. Ben offers Colleen a calm relationship after her turbulent summer with Evan, but he also expects honesty and emotional clarity. His kindness is not passivity: when he feels treated as a fallback, he names the problem and protects himself. Ben values trust more than a polished romantic image, and his presence helps Colleen see the consequences of avoiding difficult conversations.

Haley

Blunt island best friend

Haley Boudreau is Colleen’s oldest friend, a sharp, independent islander from a long-established lobstering family. She is brilliant, stubborn, and determined to attend Dartmouth and build a life beyond the place she knows. Her independence is partly a defense against a family that can use guilt and obligation to keep her close. Haley says what she thinks, sometimes more harshly than Colleen can bear, but her candor comes from loyalty rather than cruelty. She resents being excluded from household decisions and expects friendship to include mutual respect. Her humor and practical competence make her a central presence in Colleen’s island life.

Samantha

Candid summer friend

Samantha is Colleen and Haley’s direct, generous friend, visiting the island from Virginia. She is an attentive worker at Bobb’s and often sees the simplest explanation when Colleen has tangled herself in anxious overthinking. Samantha organizes outings, supports the household, and is willing to challenge Colleen without shaming her. Her generosity is practical as well as emotional: she notices when others are overwhelmed and steps in. She values honesty, friendship, and experiences beyond the island, and her summer connection with Troy gives her a romantic subplot that remains distinct from Colleen’s.

Erica

Gentle household caretaker

Erica is Colleen’s warm, dependable friend from Portland. Her protective parents require her to stay with her grandparents, but she remains closely involved with the island household and often visits or sleeps over. Erica is naturally accommodating, a capable cook, and a conscientious worker at Bobb’s. Her instinct to care for others sometimes makes her vulnerable to overwork, yet her kindness is not weakness: she speaks up when someone is in trouble and helps Colleen through difficult moments. Erica values belonging and family connection, and her gentle presence often softens the sharper exchanges among Colleen, Haley, and Samantha.

Blair

Careless summer housemate

Blair is a new Bobb’s employee who arrives on the island without housing and accepts Colleen’s offer of a bedroom. She is sociable, energetic, and eager to make the most of a place she finds beautiful. At home, however, she prioritizes her own comfort over shared rules, chores, and boundaries. Her casual attitude toward property and responsibility creates friction with Haley and Samantha, who believe a household must be reciprocal. Blair’s charm initially makes her seem easy to trust, illustrating the difference between being likable and being dependable.

Colleen’s parents

Trusting but watchful parents

Colleen’s parents are playful elementary-school teachers who leave the island for an extended European trip. They trust their daughter enough to let her manage the house with friends, but they write detailed rules to protect her and the home. Their affectionate, slightly eccentric style is visible in their farewell tears, goofy jokes, and carefully planned itinerary. They want Colleen to become independent without being exposed to avoidable risks. Their absence gives the summer its freedom, while their early return reminds Colleen that growing up involves both separation and continued family attachment.

Richard

Charming older brother

Richard is Colleen’s older brother, a stockbroker who visits the island on holiday weekends. He is handsome, sociable, and quick to move from one romance to another, though he remains affectionate toward Colleen. His habits provide a cautionary contrast to her desire for lasting commitment.

Betty McGonagle

Independent painter neighbor

Betty is an older island artist known for small seascapes sold in the local gift shop, though her private work is more varied and abstract. She is independent, blunt, and unwilling to be treated as helpless. When an injury temporarily limits her painting, she welcomes Colleen’s visits and encourages her artistic ambitions. Betty’s relationship with Colleen challenges the younger girl’s habit of judging art by its commercial appearance.

Trudy

Bobb’s demanding owner

Trudy owns Bobb’s Lobster and manages the summer staff with a mixture of restaurant experience, business-book enthusiasm, and lobster-themed advice. She values teamwork and routine, but her decisions can be impulsive or unfair under pressure. She has known Colleen for years and expects her to be dependable, making their workplace relationship a meaningful test of trust.

Aunt Sue and Uncle Frank

Blueberry-loving relatives

Colleen’s aunt and uncle live nearby and act as her parents’ local safety net. Aunt Sue experiments constantly with blueberry recipes, while Uncle Frank pushes Colleen toward painting traditional seascapes. Their unannounced inspections make the house rules feel real, even as their fondness for Colleen gives her practical support.

Courtney Smith

Colorado journal keeper

Courtney Smith is a funny, self-questioning high-school senior who records her emotional life in a journal. After Dave breaks up with her, she tries to control uncertainty through vows, plans, and elaborate interpretations of ordinary events. She is a committed vegetarian, devoted to animals, and interested in law, but she can be self-absorbed when hurt. Courtney’s confidence rises and falls with attention from boys, even as she earns responsibility in student council and at work. Her development depends on learning to distinguish a genuine boundary from a rule designed to keep her from feeling vulnerable.

Dave

Unsteady college ex

Dave is Courtney’s former boyfriend, now studying at the University of Colorado in Boulder. He is affectionate when they share a moment but hesitant to make a clear commitment, leaving Courtney to interpret his letters, visits, and silences. His wish to keep the possibility of a future reunion open conflicts with Courtney’s need for certainty. Dave is not simply cruel; he is young and unsure, but his indecision repeatedly gives Courtney hope without offering a firm relationship. His role exposes how easily nostalgia can be mistaken for a promise.

Grant Superior

Animal-loving classmate

Grant is a former school outsider who has grown into a strong, quietly attractive senior. He works at a pet shop, cares about animals, and tends to show concern through practical help rather than performance. Courtney repeatedly misreads his presence and intentions, partly because her attention remains fixed on Dave. Grant is patient, but not endlessly forgiving; he expects people to mean what they say. His modesty and kindness challenge Courtney’s assumptions about both popularity and romantic confidence.

Beth

Frank but changeable friend

Beth is Courtney’s close friend and coworker at Truth or Dairy. She is outspoken, socially confident, and prone to giving advice drawn from her own attempts to change, including quitting smoking and abandoning casual relationships. Her history makes her wary of being vulnerable, even as she begins to want a deeper connection. Beth cares fiercely for Courtney, but her bluntness can sting, especially when Courtney refuses to acknowledge her own contradictions.

Jane

Stylish practical friend

Jane is Courtney’s friend, known for her fashion sense, sharp observations, and changing tastes. She helps push Courtney toward student council and later challenges her to reconsider the no-dating vow. Jane is supportive but independent, and her advice often reflects a willingness to revise her own opinions rather than cling to an old identity.

Tom Delaney

Flirtatious student president

Tom is the popular student council president, famous for his good looks, gifts, and short-lived romances. He likes attention and often treats flirtation as a game, but he also shows unexpected moments of loyalty and vulnerability. His position gives him control over school funds and activities, making his charm inseparable from the responsibilities he holds.

Alison

Musical older sister

Alison is Courtney’s older sister, a gifted cellist who studies music away from home. Her thoughtful, private nature makes it difficult for Courtney to know what is happening in her life until Alison chooses to share it. She cares about Courtney and wants her to make decisions freely, rather than out of resentment or fear.

Bryan

Younger brother finding love

Bryan is Courtney’s younger brother, once dismissed by her as an annoying child. As he grows older, he becomes more capable and independent, especially in his affection for Beth. His changing role in the family forces Courtney to recognize that she cannot keep treating him as the little boy she remembers.

Courtney’s mother

Planner turned advocate

Courtney’s mother is a practical single parent who plans family events carefully and worries about telephone companies, budgets, and her children’s futures. Her fierce protest against poor phone service reveals a public, activist side that surprises Courtney. She loves her children but can mistake planning for control.

Courtney’s father

Affectionate distant parent

Courtney’s father lives in Arizona with his new family. He remains affectionate toward Courtney and her siblings, though his distance and habit of forgetting to share important news sometimes leave them feeling peripheral.

Oscar

Wandering epileptic dog

Oscar is the Smith family’s beloved dog, whose epilepsy followed a head injury from a car accident. His disorientation and tendency to run off create worry for Courtney, who is deeply protective of him. Oscar’s needs repeatedly bring her into contact with people who show care through action.

Gerry

Expanding smoothie-shop owner

Gerry owns Truth or Dairy, where Courtney and Beth make smoothies and ice-cream treats. A former guidance counselor, he still gives unsolicited advice and dreams of expanding his business. His enthusiasm can create opportunities, but he sometimes overlooks the personal cost to his employees.

Witchy Wheatgrass Woman

Uninvited truth teller

A regular Truth or Dairy customer, she drinks wheatgrass juice and offers unsolicited advice about Courtney’s love life and sexual health. Her blunt interventions are comic, but they also puncture Courtney’s attempts to keep private decisions entirely unexamined.

Plot Devices

The House Rules

Trust made visible

Colleen’s parents leave a pink poster listing rules for the summer household, including restrictions on alcohol, parties, property changes, and overnight guests. The list turns abstract parental trust into a visible contract that the girls can obey, revise, or violate. It gives the household conflicts concrete stakes: Colleen is responsible for the home even when other residents disregard the rules. The poster also tracks her shifting sense of authority as she adds practical instructions and tries to restore the house before her parents return.

The Island Ferry

A small world’s threshold

The ferry connects the Maine island to school, work, mainland shopping, and family visits, while also keeping the island socially enclosed. Colleen and Ben first meet aboard it, and later trips bring news, visitors, jealousy, and farewells into view. Because residents watch who arrives and leaves, private relationships rarely stay private for long. The ferry’s repeated crossings give the summer a natural rhythm and make leaving feel both ordinary and emotionally charged.

Courtney’s Journal

A mind on the page

Courtney’s journal records her daily reactions to Dave, Grant, school, family, work, and her own promises. Its informal entries let readers see the difference between the conclusions she announces and the feelings she has not yet admitted. The diary also captures interruptions and competing voices when Beth and Jane write in it, turning the notebook into a record of friendship as well as private thought. Courtney uses writing to organize experience, but the entries reveal that analysis can become another way to postpone a decision.

Oscar’s Disappearances

Care tested through action

Oscar’s epilepsy and disorientation make his occasional escapes frightening for Courtney and her family. Each disappearance requires practical searching, medication, and help from others rather than a simple emotional reassurance. The episodes reveal how Courtney responds to vulnerability and create opportunities for Grant to demonstrate his attentiveness to animals. Oscar’s repeated returns tie the novel’s comedy to a serious question: who notices when a dependent creature is missing, and who is willing to look?

The Student Council Fund

Integrity under scrutiny

The missing student council money turns Courtney’s public role into a test of trustworthiness. Because she and Tom have access to the accounts, the school’s inquiry exposes the difference between being suspected and being responsible. The fund also connects the comic school challenge to a tangible obligation: the students must replace money before they can hold their New Year’s celebration. Courtney’s fundraiser allows her to respond to the scandal through work and accountability rather than simply defend her reputation.

About the Author

Catherine Clark is an author who writes across multiple age categories. According to her author bio, she loves both reading and writing books for children, young adults, new adults, and adult audiences. Her approach suggests versatility in crafting stories that appeal to different age groups. Clark has written multiple books featuring protagonist Courtney Von Dragen Smith, including Banana Splitsville, Picture Perfect, Maine Squeeze, and Rocky Road Trip. Her writing style frequently employs diary or journal formats, and she's known for creating humorous, light-hearted contemporary fiction with romantic elements that particularly resonate with teenage female readers.

Download PDF

To save this Banana Splitsville summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.41 MB     Pages: 29

Download EPUB

To read this Banana Splitsville summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.47 MB     Pages: 37
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen1 mins
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...