Plot Summary
Arrival at the Edge
Fayette Wynne, a weary screenwriter, arrives in Carmel-by-the-Sea, carrying the magical sourdough starter "Mother" and the weight of her family's recent deaths. She rents a modest cottage, hoping for a fresh start and a place to write. The cottage's landlady, Mrs. Fitz, and her silent helper, Heidi, introduce Fayette to the peculiar rules and quiet sadness of the household. As a storm brews, Fayette's grief and loneliness are palpable, but she clings to her work and the hope that this new place will offer healing. The presence of Mother, both a blessing and a burden, lingers in the background, hinting at deeper magic and responsibility.
The House That Waits
The narrative shifts to the perspective of a magical house perched on a cliff, once home to a powerful witch. The house is sentient, able to feel, remember, and long for companionship. It mourns its witch, whose bones still rest within, and yearns to be a home again. The house senses Fayette's arrival in the area, recognizing her as someone touched by magic. It hopes she will enter and fulfill its purpose once more, even as it remains bound to its roost, unable to move or act without a witch's command.
Storm, Stranger, Salvation
During a violent storm, Fayette ventures out and encounters Rex Hallstrom, a famous actor on the verge of suicide at the cliff's edge. Driven by her own grief and memories of loss, Fayette intervenes, physically pulling Rex away from danger. They seek shelter in the mysterious house, which opens its door to them. Inside, they find warmth and a strange sense of safety, as if the house itself is watching over them. Their shared vulnerability forges a tentative bond, and the house, sensing their need, offers silent comfort.
The House Remembers
The house, awakened by the presence of Fayette and Rex, revels in the warmth and voices within its walls. It recalls its history of testing and sometimes devouring those who entered, but now it yearns to be a true refuge. The house is aware of its own limitations and the fragility of the cliff beneath it. It hopes that Fayette and Rex will return, bringing life and purpose back to its lonely existence.
Bread, Grief, and Ghosts
Fayette struggles with her grief and the burden of Mother, the magical sourdough starter. She resents the responsibility but cannot abandon it. Seeking distraction, she explores the town, meets the local marshal, and observes the peculiarities of Carmel. She checks on Rex, who is recovering from his ordeal, and together they investigate the mysterious house in daylight. The house reveals itself only to those touched by magic or need, deepening the sense of mystery and connection between the characters.
Earthquake Warnings
The house feels the instability of the cliff, aware that an earthquake or further strain could send it tumbling into the sea. It tries to lighten itself and remain vigilant, especially as Fayette and Rex return to explore. The house's awareness of its own vulnerability adds urgency to its desire for a new witch and a renewed purpose.
The Hidden Cottage
Fayette and Rex examine the house's architecture, noting its Russian design and the uncanny way it blends into the landscape. They discover a fence made of bones and other unsettling details, but the house welcomes them, opening doors and windows to provide light and warmth. Inside, they find a massive oven and evidence of a life once lived. The house's magic is palpable, and both Fayette and Rex are drawn deeper into its mysteries, sensing that it is more than just a building.
Seeking Answers
Fayette visits the local library and learns more about the house's history and the Fitz family's connection to the land. She discovers that the house appeared suddenly in 1918 and that only certain people can perceive or approach it. The librarian's gossip reveals tensions in the community and hints at Heidi's mysterious past. Fayette's investigation deepens her sense of responsibility and curiosity about the house and its magic.
Secrets of the Landlady
Fayette confronts Mrs. Fitz about the house, learning that it is considered cursed and possibly demonic. Mrs. Fitz recounts strange events and her own inability to enter the house. She invites Fayette to a séance, hoping to contact her catatonic husband's spirit. The séance becomes a focal point for the community's grief and longing for connection, and Fayette agrees to attend, sensing that the house and its magic are at the heart of the town's mysteries.
Mother's Burden
Overwhelmed by grief and the demands of Mother, Fayette tries to discard part of the starter but cannot escape its pull. She reflects on her family's history with Mother and the dangers of misusing its magic. Encounters with Margaret, Rex's would-be bride, reveal the pressures and secrets of Hollywood life. Fayette's growing friendship with Rex offers solace, but the weight of her obligations and the house's mysteries loom large.
Bread and Rescue
Fayette and Rex return to the house to bake bread using Mother in the magical oven. The house responds eagerly, amplifying the bread's power. As the bread rises, a magical door appears, and a starving girl from Eastern Europe stumbles through, fleeing danger. Fayette and Rex feed her, and the bread's magic brings healing and hope. The house reveals its ability to open doors across time and space, offering refuge to those in need. The act of sharing bread becomes a symbol of healing and connection.
The House's Lament
The house reflects on its joy at helping Fayette, Rex, and the lost girl. It longs to be a true home and to continue opening doors for those in need. The house's sense of purpose is renewed, but it remains aware of its vulnerability and the threat of other witches who might seek to claim or destroy it.
Skeletons and Secrets
Fayette and Rex discover a secret door in the house, revealing the skeleton of the former witch. The house shows them this as a warning and a plea for understanding. The experience is terrifying but deepens their bond with the house and their resolve to protect it. They realize that the house is both powerful and endangered, and that its fate is tied to their own choices.
Writing and Watching
Fayette finds renewed inspiration in her writing, fueled by the magic of the house and her growing friendship with Rex. She confronts Heidi, seeking answers about her connection to the house, but Heidi remains silent and fearful. The town's secrets and the house's magic intertwine, drawing Fayette deeper into a web of mystery, grief, and hope.
Baking in the Izba
Fayette and Rex research the house's Russian origins, identifying it as an izba, a traditional peasant hut. They bake bread together, and the house responds with warmth and magic. The bread's power brings healing and comfort, and the act of sharing food becomes a ritual of connection and renewal. The house's ability to open doors for those in need is affirmed, and Fayette begins to see her role as a caretaker and mediator.
Lost Souls, Open Doors
The house continues to open doors for lost souls—starving women, refugees, and others in desperate circumstances. Fayette and Rex provide food and comfort, using Mother's bread to heal and sustain. The house's magic grows stronger with each act of kindness, but the strain on Fayette and Mother increases. The house's longing for a new witch and a renewed purpose becomes more urgent.
The Hungry Arrive
The house brings more hungry and desperate people through its doors, and Fayette and Rex share what they have. The act of feeding others becomes a form of redemption and healing for Fayette, helping her to process her own grief and guilt. The house's magic is both a blessing and a burden, and the need for a new witch becomes increasingly clear.
The House's Hope
The house reflects on its longing for companionship and purpose. It hopes that Fayette, Rex, or Heidi will become its new witch and restore its power. The house's memories of past quests and its desire to help others drive it to open more doors and seek connection, even as danger looms from other witches who might seek to claim or destroy it.
Séance and Revelation
At Mrs. Fitz's séance, the medium Silas Pennington exposes the magical nature of Mother and the secrets of those present. His genuine psychic abilities are overwhelmed by the house's power, leading to a dramatic collapse. The séance becomes a turning point, revealing the depth of the house's magic and the dangers of meddling with forces beyond understanding.
Mediums and Motives
Silas's attempts to harness the house's power backfire, causing pain and chaos. His blend of fraud and genuine ability makes him both dangerous and pitiable. Silas's arc is one of hubris and unintended consequence, serving as a warning about the dangers of meddling with forces beyond understanding.
The Witch's Shadow
The house senses the approach of another witch, drawn by its display of power. This rival seeks to claim or destroy the house, and the threat becomes imminent. The house's fear and desperation grow, and it calls out to Fayette and Rex for help. The need for a new witch to claim and protect the house becomes urgent.
Letters and Losses
Fayette receives news that she is to be fired from her studio job, compounding her sense of loss and uncertainty. The house's vulnerability increases as Silas and others seek to exploit its magic. Fayette's bond with Rex deepens, and together they resolve to protect the house and those it shelters, even as danger draws closer.
The Cliff's Collapse
The rival witch arrives, bringing her own magical house to challenge the cliff house. A battle ensues, threatening to destroy both houses and the cliff itself. The house, guided by its new witch, uses cunning and the instability of the cliff to outwit its rival. The battle is fierce and destructive, but the house survives, battered but triumphant.
The Interpreter's Blood
With the house weakened and in need of help, Fayette and Rex enlist the aid of a guest who offers her blood to write a message in Cyrillic. The house communicates its need for a new witch and warns of the rival's approach. The act of translation and understanding becomes a lifeline, allowing the house to convey its desperation and hope.
The Witch Returns
Heidi, revealed as the lost Grand Duchess Anastasia, returns to the house and claims her role as the new witch. Her acceptance and healing restore the house's power, and together they prepare to face the rival witch. The house's longing for belonging and purpose is fulfilled, and its future is secured.
The Battle of Houses
The rival witch's house arrives, and a dramatic battle unfolds in the sky above Carmel. The cliff house, guided by Heidi and empowered by Mother, uses cunning and the terrain to outmaneuver its larger foe. The rival is defeated and driven away, and the house's survival is celebrated by all who witnessed the spectacle.
The New Witch
With the rival gone and the house restored, Heidi embraces her role as the new witch. She vows to use the house's power to help those in need, continuing the tradition of opening doors for lost souls. Fayette, Rex, and their found family gather to celebrate, sharing bread and hope for the future.
Farewells and New Beginnings
Fayette entrusts Mother to Heidi, recognizing that the magic must be shared and used for good. The house, now a true home once more, prepares to travel and help others. Fayette and Rex, their burdens lightened and their hearts healed, look to the future with hope, knowing that they are loved and that their actions have made a difference.
Characters
Fayette Wynne
Fayette is a screenwriter fleeing the recent deaths of her mother and siblings, burdened by grief and the magical sourdough starter, Mother. Her role as caretaker is both blessing and curse, symbolizing the weight of family legacy and the struggle to find meaning after loss. Fayette's journey is one of healing, as she learns to open herself to new connections, accept help, and share her gifts. Her relationship with Rex is deeply platonic, rooted in mutual respect and understanding. Fayette's psychological arc moves from isolation and resentment to acceptance, generosity, and hope, culminating in her willingness to let go of Mother and trust others with her legacy.
Rex Hallstrom
Rex is a famous actor hiding deep wounds—his sexuality, the pressures of Hollywood, and a recent suicide attempt. His encounter with Fayette on the cliff is a turning point, as her intervention saves his life and forges a bond of trust. Rex's struggle is one of identity and survival in a world that demands conformity. His friendship with Fayette and love for Art offer him a sense of home and acceptance. Rex's psychological journey is marked by vulnerability, resilience, and the courage to seek help. He becomes a steadfast ally, using his resources and influence to protect the house and those he loves.
Heidi / Grand Duchess Anastasia
Heidi, known to the world as a silent helper, is revealed to be the lost Grand Duchess Anastasia, survivor of the Russian Revolution and inheritor of Baba Yaga's legacy. Her trauma and fear keep her silent and hidden, but the needs of others and the house's call draw her back to her true role. Heidi's arc is one of reclaiming agency, embracing her power, and choosing to use it for good. Her relationship with Mrs. Fitz is one of found family, and her acceptance of Mother and the house marks the beginning of a new era of healing and hope.
The House (Baba Yaga's Hut)
The house is a living entity, shaped by centuries of magic, memory, and longing. It is both nurturing and dangerous, capable of opening doors across worlds and testing those who enter. The house's psychological depth is rooted in its desire to be a true home, its fear of abandonment, and its hope for a new witch. Its relationship with Fayette, Rex, and Heidi is transformative, as it learns to trust, help, and be helped. The house's arc is one of redemption, moving from a history of devouring to one of sheltering and healing.
Mrs. Fitz
Mrs. Fitz is the landlady of the cottage and caretaker of her catatonic husband. Her relentless pursuit of healing—through séances, mediums, and magic—reflects her inability to let go and her deep love. She is both stern and compassionate, offering support to Fayette and Heidi. Mrs. Fitz's arc is one of acceptance, as she learns to find peace in her husband's condition and to let go of false hope.
Silas Pennington
Silas is a young medium whose blend of trickery and genuine psychic ability makes him both dangerous and pitiable. His attempts to harness the house's magic backfire, causing pain and chaos. Silas's arc is one of hubris and unintended consequence, serving as a warning about the dangers of meddling with forces beyond understanding.
Mother (the Sourdough Starter)
Mother is a magical sourdough starter passed down through Fayette's family, capable of healing and sustaining those in need. Though voiceless, Mother's presence is deeply felt, representing the burdens and blessings of inheritance. Mother's arc is one of generosity and letting go, as she is finally entrusted to Heidi to continue her work.
Art (Artem Jaroff)
Art is Rex's partner, a Russian émigré and tailor with deep knowledge of folklore and magic. His arrival brings clarity about the house's origins and the dangers it faces. Art's relationship with Rex is one of mutual support and love, offering a vision of hope and acceptance in a hostile world.
Margaret Proudlock
Margaret is Rex's would-be bride, pressured by the studio into a sham marriage. Her struggles with addiction and the demands of fame mirror Rex's own battles. Margaret's arc is one of agency and self-acceptance, as she chooses her own path and supports Rex and Fayette in their journey.
Mr. Fitz
Mr. Fitz is Mrs. Fitz's husband, rendered catatonic by war injuries. His presence is a constant reminder of loss and the limits of healing. Through Fayette's magical intervention, it is revealed that his soul is intact and at peace, offering a bittersweet resolution to his wife's quest for restoration.
Plot Devices
Dual Perspectives and Shifting Narrators
The novel employs a dual narrative structure, alternating between Fayette's third-person perspective and the first-person voice of the sentient house. This device deepens the reader's understanding of both human and magical motivations, creating empathy for the house and highlighting the theme of found family. The house's chapters provide foreshadowing, emotional resonance, and a unique lens on events, blurring the line between setting and character.
Magical Realism and Portal Fantasy
The house's ability to open doors across time and space functions as both a literal and metaphorical plot device. It allows the narrative to explore themes of refuge, healing, and the universality of suffering. The magical realism grounds the story in emotional truth, while the portal fantasy elements expand its scope and stakes.
Bread as Symbol and Catalyst
The act of baking and sharing bread is central to the plot, serving as a symbol of legacy, healing, and community. Mother's magic is both a blessing and a burden, driving Fayette's arc and enabling the house to fulfill its purpose. Bread becomes a catalyst for transformation, redemption, and the forging of new bonds.
Foreshadowing and Chekhov's Gun
The novel employs careful foreshadowing—such as the instability of the cliff, the house's longing for a witch, and the dangers of meddling with magic—that culminate in the climactic battle and the revelation of Heidi's true identity. Objects and details introduced early (the bones, the oven, the feathers) become crucial in later chapters, creating a sense of inevitability and cohesion.
Found Family and Chosen Bonds
The plot is driven by the formation of a found family—Fayette, Rex, Heidi, and the house—each seeking belonging and healing. The narrative structure emphasizes the importance of chosen bonds over blood ties, and the resolution hinges on the willingness to trust, share, and let go.
Analysis
A House Between Sea and Sky is a luminous meditation on grief, legacy, and the redemptive power of found family. Beth Cato weaves together historical fiction, magical realism, and folklore to create a narrative that is both intimate and epic. The sentient house, longing for purpose after centuries of testing and devouring, becomes a vessel for healing as it opens doors to those in need. Fayette's journey from resentment and isolation to generosity and hope mirrors the house's own arc of redemption. The novel interrogates the burdens of inheritance—whether magical, familial, or societal—and the courage required to let go, trust others, and share one's gifts. The bread, both literal and symbolic, becomes a means of connection, sustenance, and transformation. The story's queer subtext and exploration of chosen family resonate powerfully in a modern context, offering a vision of survival and joy amid trauma. Ultimately, the novel suggests that home is not a place but a constellation of relationships, and that healing is found in the willingness to open doors, both magical and mundane, to those who hunger for belonging.
Last updated:
