Plot Summary
Three Weeks to Retirement
Three weeks before leaving the sheriff’s office, Les,1 a reserved lawman and watercolor painter,1 is asked by resort spokesman4 C.J. Gant4 to stop Gerald Blackwelder3 from fishing on resort land. Les1 warns Gerald3 instead of charging him. He also learns that Gerald’s nephew,5 Darby,5 has kept Gerald’s3 lawn mower, and promises to retrieve it.
At the nearby state park, superintendent2 Becky Shytle2 shares Les’s1 attention to wildlife and the lingering marks of painful histories. They have been tentatively close for two years, but neither has settled what their companionship means. Les’s1 retirement plans, including a new cabin, look simple beside the old loyalties and unresolved grief that this complaint begins to stir.
The first dispute is about trespassing, but the deeper conflict is over who gets to define a place and its obligations. Les treats the law as something that can bend toward compassion; C.J. sees a business under pressure, while Gerald experiences new boundaries as an erasure of the life he knows. Les’s approaching retirement makes each decision feel like a final judgment on the kind of man he has been.
Concrete at the Lodge
After Les1 warns him away from the resort, Gerald3 drives there to confront owner10 Harold Tucker.10 A guard shoves him onto the concrete and points a handgun at his head. Becky2 rushes in, pulls the guard off, and gives Gerald3 his heart medication; Les1 takes the weapon and refuses Tucker’s10 demand to arrest the injured man.3
Later, Les1 finds Darby5 at home with a woman12 and discovers Gerald’s3 mower has been pawned. Darby5 resents Becky’s2 concern for his uncle3 and believes the farm should eventually be his. His drug use and grievance make him dangerous in a quieter way than Gerald’s3 temper. Les1 leaves without knowing that the family dispute is already moving toward a more serious crime.
The assault converts an argument about property into a test of whose power counts. Tucker’s guards can make an old man physically helpless, while Les’s restraint prevents the law from simply endorsing that force. Darby’s theft adds another kind of violence: he treats Gerald’s possessions and future as resources already owed to him.
The Baby in the Microwave
On Tuesday, Les1 joins Jarvis Crowe6 and deputy7 Barry7 in a raid on a suspected meth house. They arrest Rodney Greer and find Robin Lindsey11 unconscious, but Robin’s11 baby is missing. Les1 discovers the child alive in a microwave, wrapped in a blanket, and Jarvis6 carries her to safety. Barry,7 overwhelmed by the danger and squalor, removes his badge and walks away from the job.
The discovery pulls Les1 back to an earlier raid and the moment he told his depressed wife,8 Sarah,8 to go ahead and kill herself. She survived, but their marriage ended. Becky’s2 own history includes a school shooting and a former partner,9 Richard,9 whose environmental activism turned violent. Both carry pasts that make present crises hard to meet calmly.
The baby’s survival is a narrow reprieve, not a clean victory: Barry cannot continue, and Les must face the damage his old cruelty did to Sarah. Becky and Les are drawn together by histories that resist simple recovery. Their work among living things offers attention and care, but it cannot undo what people have done to one another.
Red Water, Dead Trout
The next morning, dead trout and a red kerosene sheen appear in Locust Creek. Becky2 takes water samples, while Tucker10 shows Les1 security footage of Gerald3 near the waterfall. Becky2 insists the man3 who treasured the rare native trout would not poison them, but Les1 cannot dismiss the evidence.
He goes to Gerald’s3 farmhouse to bring him in. Gerald3 is confused by the accusation, then collapses under the stress; Becky2 rides with Les1 to the hospital and keeps him alive with nitroglycerin.
Jarvis6 finds an empty kerosene can near the boundary of Gerald’s3 land, strengthening the case against him. Yet Les1 notices that Gerald’s3 behavior and the footage do not fit neatly together, and he begins checking the supposed meeting that brought Gerald3 to the creek.
The apparent evidence is powerful because it fits what people already fear about Gerald: his temper and history of violence. Becky’s trust in him is equally shaped by what she has seen him cherish. The case asks whether either kind of knowledge can withstand a camera image, a discarded can, and the pressure to blame someone quickly.
The Call From Tennessee
Les1 learns there was no call from the resort to Gerald,3 but phone records show a brief call from a Tennessee number. The number belongs to a phone owned by imprisoned dealer Levon Carlson. Les1 tracks down Shiloh,12 a woman12 using Carlson’s phone and staying with Darby.5 She admits she called Gerald3 at Darby’s5 direction and told him to meet someone at the waterfall.
She has since sold the phone to pawnshop owner13 Trey Yarbrough,13 who still has it. Les1 also rechecks the resort video: Gerald’s3 shoulders stay level as he walks up and back, unlike a man carrying a heavy kerosene can. The clues no longer support the easy accusation, but they point toward a deliberate setup.
The investigation changes when Les stops treating the footage as a complete account. Small discrepancies, a missing call, a level gait, and a phone passed between people, open space for an alternative explanation. His attention to evidence becomes an ethical choice: he risks angering Tucker rather than forcing the facts to fit the first suspect.
Darby’s Inheritance Scheme
The phone records and Shiloh’s12 account lead Les1 to question Darby.5 Darby5 admits that C.J.4 recruited him to frame Gerald,3 hoping an arrest or confinement would hasten the old man’s3 death and free the farm for sale. Darby5 poured kerosene into the creek; C.J.4 supplied the plan, including the false invitation and knowledge of the resort cameras.
C.J.’s4 motive is tangled with his fear of losing the security he struggled to build for his sons, but that does not excuse the scheme. Les1 persuades Darby5 to sign a confession taking sole responsibility, promising to pay the fine and restitution himself. He shields C.J.4 from prosecution and shields Shiloh12 from further harm, choosing an imperfect remedy over a public trial.
C.J.’s betrayal grows from old humiliation and real responsibility for his family, but he turns those injuries into permission to endanger Gerald. Les’s bargain is morally compromised: it protects people and repairs damage, yet hides the truth. The novel refuses to make justice feel clean when every available choice carries a cost.
A Quiet Kind of Repair
Les1 gives C.J.4 money for his sons’ education, partly repaying the debt he has carried since C.J.4 saved him in a hay-baler accident as a teenager. C.J.4 accepts without apology and plans to seek work elsewhere. Les1 takes a night-watchman job and prepares to leave the sheriff’s office. Gerald,3 still grieving his wife and son, asks Becky2 to spread his ashes on their graves and keep some near the pool where the native trout live; she promises.
The false accusation is cleared, and Les1 goes to remove Gerald’s3 ankle monitor, but first finds Becky2 at the park. He holds her as she confirms her faith in Gerald,3 then takes her hand and asks to speak privately. Their closeness, once tentative, now has room to become something chosen.
The ending does not restore what was lost: C.J.’s job, Gerald’s dead family, and Les’s marriage remain beyond repair. Instead, Les makes specific acts of restitution and accepts that kindness can coexist with accountability. Becky’s promise to remember Gerald among the trout joins human grief to a living place, while her and Les’s renewed intimacy suggests a future built through attention rather than certainty.
Analysis
Above the Waterfall sets two kinds of evidence against each other. Les1 investigates recordings, phone logs, chemicals, and physical traces, while Becky2 reads people through the care they give to a place and its living creatures. Neither method is sufficient alone. Becky’s2 faith in Gerald3 risks overlooking his capacity for violence; Les’s1 skepticism risks treating an image as a verdict. Their conflict asks how judgment can remain open without becoming naïve.
The book links environmental damage to personal harm without equating them. Kerosene in the creek kills fish, while addiction, depression, and inherited violence damage families through slower forms of exposure. The novel’s recurring attention to water, insects, birds, and children offers no guarantee that nature makes people good. It does offer a practice: notice what is vulnerable before deciding it is expendable.
Les’s1 final choices are imperfect acts of repair rather than cleansing absolution. He protects C.J.4 from prosecution, pays for the harm Darby5 caused, and accepts help and intimacy he has long avoided. The ending’s hope rests not on forgetting wrongdoing, but on choosing what to care for next.
Review Summary
Reviews of Above the Waterfall are largely positive, averaging 3.52/5. Readers praise Rash's lyrical, poetic prose and vivid Appalachian landscapes. The alternating narrative voices of Sheriff Les and park ranger Becky are frequently highlighted, with Becky's poetic chapters drawing particular admiration. Many appreciate the novel's themes of trauma, redemption, and nature's restorative power. Some critics found the plot thin or predictable, and Becky's character underdeveloped. References to Gerard Manley Hopkins and the portrayal of meth addiction are frequently noted. Most consider it a beautiful, meditative work, if perhaps not Rash's strongest.
Characters
Les
The retiring sheriffA solitary county sheriff who paints watercolors and notices the small lives gathered along creeks and trails. Les is capable and compassionate, but his guilt over his former wife’s8 depression has taught him to mistake withdrawal for restraint. His bond with Becky2 unsettles his careful isolation.
Becky Shytle
The park’s close observerA state park superintendent who studies plants, animals, and children with patient intensity. Becky’s past includes a school shooting and a destructive relationship with an environmental radical. She trusts what she has witnessed in people, even when that trust leaves her exposed.
Gerald Blackwelder
The rooted farmerAn aging farmer with a damaged heart, a fierce temper, and a deep attachment to his land. Gerald’s grief over his wife and only son lives close to the surface, though his care for Becky2 and his attention to the creek reveal a tenderness he rarely puts into words.
C.J. Gant
The resort spokesmanA polished public-relations professional who rose from poverty through discipline and ambition. C.J. values loyalty, achievement, and the security he wants for his family. His pride in escaping childhood humiliation can make him impatient with those whose needs threaten the life he has built.
Darby Ramsey
The resentful nephewGerald’s nephew3 is a repeat offender whose drug use has narrowed his sense of the future. He resents the distance between the inheritance he expects and the life he actually leads, and treats family loyalty as an obstacle when it does not benefit him.
Jarvis Crowe
Les’s successorA capable, red-haired deputy preparing to take over the sheriff’s office. Jarvis is firm without enjoying cruelty and has his own standards for the job. His questions make clear that he will not simply inherit Les’s1 compromises.
Barry
The shaken deputyA young deputy, devoted husband, and father whose caution reflects how deeply meth raids affect him. Barry is attentive to the danger children face in drug houses, but the emotional cost of the work presses against his ability to continue.
Sarah
Les’s former wifeLes’s1 former wife struggled with severe depression during their marriage. Her experience exposes the limits of Les’s1 sympathy and his tendency to defend his own behavior before he understands the pain he has caused.
Richard Pelfrey
Becky’s radical former partnerA passionate environmental activist who believes ordinary protest cannot stop corporate harm. Richard’s conviction and capacity for violence become inseparable in Becky’s2 memory, leaving her wary of how love can blur judgment.
Harold Tucker
The resort ownerA forceful businessman who protects his resort and expects loyalty from those who work for him. Tucker’s concern for his employees and investment is genuine, but his confidence in authority can make other people’s rights seem secondary.
Robin Lindsey
A mother caught in addictionA young woman whose meth addiction has damaged her health and strained her relationship with her parents15. Her presence at the center of a dangerous household shows how addiction can make neglect look like a series of isolated failures.
Shiloh
The phone’s current ownerA woman who survives on unstable arrangements and uses an assumed name. Her dependence on drugs and on the people around her narrows her choices, though she retains a practical instinct for protecting herself.
Trey Yarbrough
The pawnshop ownerA musician and pawnbroker who knows the county’s unsavory trade firsthand. Trey’s wary humor and willingness to help Les1 make him a useful source of information, while his rattlesnake is an unconventional form of security.
Ruby
The steady dispatcherThe sheriff’s office dispatcher, experienced enough to worry over every dangerous call and warm enough to think of deputies as family. Ruby offers Les1 practical help and, at a rare personal moment, lets him know how much she cares.
Ben Lindsey
Robin’s devoted fatherA quiet, worn-down father who continues to hope for his daughter11 despite repeated disappointments. Ben’s loyalty to Robin11 places him in conflict with his wife’s16 exhaustion and makes him vulnerable to the financial cost of her addiction.
Martha Lindsey
Robin’s exhausted motherRobin’s mother11 has reached the edge of what she can endure. Martha’s anger protects her from further disappointment, but it also reveals the grief of a parent who feels forced to stop hoping.
Plot Devices
The blue cell phone
A trail to the setupA phone borrowed from a jailed dealer is used to contact Gerald3 and then passed through Shiloh12 to a pawnshop. Its call history lets Les1 test Gerald’s3 account and trace the people who arranged the false meeting.
Resort security footage
An image mistaken for proofCameras near the waterfall appear to place Gerald3 at the scene of the fish kill. Their limited angle makes the footage persuasive but incomplete, and Les’s1 closer review reveals why a recorded image cannot tell the whole story.
The creek and its wildlife
A measure of careBecky’s2 work with the park’s plants and animals, especially the rare native trout, shapes how she understands responsibility. The creek is both habitat and shared inheritance, a place where human choices leave visible consequences.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.