Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Alasdair Macintyre

Alasdair Macintyre

Critic of Modernity
Modern institutions call choices neutral; what moral framework vanished beneath that claim?
by Peter McMylor 1991 236 pages
2.90
10 ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Key Takeaways

Treat moral disputes as symptoms of a fractured shared world

A shared language breaks apart. MacIntyre argues that modern people inherit moral words such as justice, duty, and rights after losing much of the common framework that once made those words persuasive. The result is not simply disagreement about answers. It is disagreement about what counts as a reason. In this setting, moral argument can resemble a contest of personal preferences, a pattern MacIntyre calls emotivism. He does not claim that everyone consciously accepts this philosophy. His point is that it is enacted in institutions and everyday debate.

Debate becomes performance. The book uses disputes over nuclear weapons to show the divide: opponents may appeal to duties toward human life, while state officials defend deterrence as an effective means to an accepted end. Without shared standards for judging ends, argument can slide from reasoning toward persuasion, pressure, or competing displays of will.

Analysis

What's striking is how this account distinguishes disagreement from the loss of shared terms for resolving disagreement. That distinction helps explain why public debates can feel repetitive: participants may use the same moral vocabulary while relying on different, unspoken standards. Contemporary political psychology similarly distinguishes factual disagreement from disputes over identity and values, though it does not establish that public morality has become uniformly emotivist. The framework is most useful as a diagnostic, not a verdict on every argument. Some moral disputes do involve evidence and reasoned persuasion, even when consensus remains elusive.

Keep Marx's moral indictment, but distrust claims to scientific destiny

Marxism carried moral force. McMylor traces MacIntyre's early view that Marxism gave material and historical form to concerns also central to Christianity: suffering, poverty, justice, and the possibility of reconciliation. In his first book, written in his early twenties, MacIntyre treated Marx's criticism of capitalism as a powerful challenge to a church too comfortable with existing social arrangements. The traditions were not identical, but each tied belief to action in the world.

Certainty became a danger. MacIntyre worried that Marxism could combine a sweeping account of human purpose with the certainty claimed by natural science. When a political movement treats its program as history's inevitable outcome, it risks ignoring suffering and dissent in the name of progress. MacIntyre lost confidence in Marxism as a complete solution, then turned toward an Aristotelian account of virtue and, eventually, Thomist Christianity, while retaining a critique of liberal society.

Analysis

This intellectual journey is more than a conversion story. It shows how a thinker can retain a tradition's moral questions while rejecting its claims to guaranteed political outcomes. The distinction resembles a broader problem in movements that present history as a reliable forecast: urgency can motivate reform, but certainty can also excuse coercion. At the same time, the theological parallel does not by itself establish that Marxism depends on Christianity. The stronger claim is structural: both traditions make judgments about human suffering and the good life that cannot be reduced to technical predictions.

Reconnect moral rules to the human goods they help us achieve

Purpose gives morality direction. A teleological view understands human life in relation to ends, or goods toward which people can develop. In the Aristotelian account McMylor presents, ethics helps people move from their present condition toward a fuller human life. Virtues are dispositions that support this development, not merely rules imposed from outside.

Modern ethics lost the bridge. MacIntyre argues that Reformation-era changes and the rejection of Aristotelian purpose weakened the connection between human nature and moral instruction. Thinkers such as Hume and Kant tried to ground morality in passion or reason without restoring a shared account of humanity's end. Moral rules then seemed detached from the facts of human life. MacIntyre's alternative is practical reasoning: ask what forms of conduct allow people to flourish in the activities and relationships that matter to them.

Analysis

The appeal of this model is that it makes morality answer a practical question: what kind of person and community can these choices produce? Contemporary virtue ethics and professional education use a related insight, treating judgment as a cultivated capacity rather than a checklist. Yet a shared account of human flourishing is difficult to establish in plural societies. People can agree that health, friendship, or meaningful work matter while disagreeing about their priorities and proper forms. The framework gains strength when it supports careful public argument about goods, rather than assuming one inherited account settles every dispute.

Judge institutions by whether they protect a practice's internal goods

Practices have goods of their own. MacIntyre uses practice to mean a complex, cooperative activity with standards of excellence and benefits that participants can gain only by learning and doing it well. In chess, for instance, a player may first be tempted by an outside prize, but serious participation can reveal goods specific to the game, such as strategic understanding. These are internal goods because they belong to the activity itself.

Institutions bring competing incentives. Practices need organizations, money, buildings, and authority to endure. But institutions also pursue external goods, such as status, wealth, and power. Those goods are necessary, yet can displace the activity's own standards. A school can serve education, while its pursuit of rankings or revenue can distort what teaching is for. Virtues help practitioners resist that drift and sustain standards worth sharing.

Analysis

This distinction offers a useful way to examine incentives without treating every reward as corrupt. Research on motivation often finds that external incentives can crowd out intrinsic motivation in some settings, but their effects depend on how rewards are designed and understood. MacIntyre's account adds a social dimension: a practice is not merely an individual's passion, but a shared activity with standards that participants inherit and revise. The harder question is who gets to define excellence. Institutions can protect a craft, but they can also use its language to preserve hierarchy or exclude newcomers.

Treat markets as engines that remake social identity, not neutral tools

Economic life can be embedded. Drawing on Karl Polanyi, McMylor contrasts economies governed within kinship, religion, and political obligation with market societies in which economic activity gains greater independence. Markets existed in many earlier societies, but Polanyi's point is that they did not usually organize the whole social order. Modern market society makes labor and land into commodities and gives economic calculation unusual authority.

Exchange reshapes relationships. Georg Simmel helps explain the personal cost and attraction of this change. Money can loosen dependence on a particular lord, employer, or neighbor, expanding individual freedom. But it also makes relationships more impersonal and people more interchangeable. Albert Hirschman's history of the word interest shows a related shift: economic self-interest came to seem a stabilizing, respectable motive, rather than simply another passion. The market changes both what people do and how they understand themselves.

Analysis

The account's strength is refusing the idea that markets merely coordinate pre-existing preferences. Rules of exchange can help create the preferences and social roles they appear only to serve. This resonates with contemporary work on how institutions shape behavior, including research on markets in areas such as education and health care. Still, Polanyi's contrast can be overstated if embeddedness is taken to mean moral harmony. Older communities also contained coercion and exclusion. The important question is not whether an economy has norms, but which norms govern it, whose interests they protect, and whether they can be challenged.

Question managerial certainty when human purposes are part of the facts

Expertise cannot erase uncertainty. MacIntyre argues that managers claim authority by presenting goals as given and their methods as neutral. But social science cannot reliably predict human action with the precision needed to justify every managerial decision. People can change their minds, situations evolve, and new ideas or unexpected events alter outcomes. A forecast can inform judgment without making the future controllable.

Technique can conceal choices. The book describes a managerial culture in which efficiency becomes its own justification, while arguments about ends are treated as private values. During the miners' strike, officials presented pit closures through technical and financial claims, even though those claims were open to dispute and the closures had profound social effects. The criticism is not that expertise is useless. It is that expertise cannot turn contested political choices into morally neutral necessities.

Analysis

The argument is a valuable warning against confusing quantification with neutrality. A model can be technically sound and still reflect choices about what to measure, which costs to include, and whose losses matter. Modern decision science reinforces the need to state uncertainty and assumptions plainly. But an opposite danger deserves attention: pointing to unpredictability can become an excuse to dismiss evidence or avoid difficult decisions. The appropriate standard is accountable expertise, where forecasts inform deliberation, assumptions are visible, and affected communities can question how a problem has been framed.

Read a life through its story, roles, and inherited commitments

Actions need a setting. MacIntyre's narrative account says that an action becomes intelligible when placed within a person's history and the history of the relationships around them. Someone working in a garden might be exercising, preparing for winter, or caring for a household. The physical behavior alone does not reveal its meaning; intentions and social context matter.

Identity is not a blank slate. People begin life inside families, languages, places, and traditions that shape what they can understand and choose. A tradition, in MacIntyre's specialized sense, is not simply an unquestioned inheritance. It is a continuing argument about what a community's shared history means. People can challenge what they inherit, but they cannot make that inheritance disappear by declaring themselves wholly independent of it. A coherent life involves interpreting commitments across time, rather than treating each choice as isolated.

Analysis

Narrative offers a strong alternative to the picture of the self as a sequence of detached preferences. Work in medical sociology on chronic illness, for example, finds that illness can disrupt a person's account of who they are and require a new interpretation of life events. That connection supports the claim that stories help organize experience. Yet narratives can also impose coherence where life remains unresolved, and inherited identities may constrain people unevenly. A useful account of narrative identity should therefore allow revision, conflict, and experiences that do not fit a satisfying plot.

Use history to expose modernity without pretending the past was harmonious

Historical contrast is the method. MacIntyre's critique depends on showing that modern liberal society is not the only possible arrangement of moral and social life. McMylor connects this philosophical history to Polanyi's account of economic change: markets and individualism did not simply exist in the same form across all eras. The aim is to identify what became distinctive about modernity, not to claim that earlier societies were perfect.

The past was divided too. MacIntyre describes ancient and medieval worlds as containing competing communities and conflicting moral traditions. McMylor also discusses Alan MacFarlane's claim that English individualism and market behavior reach far back into medieval history. Critics argue that evidence of land sales or local markets does not prove a society was organized around individual self-interest; custom, shared land use, and obligations matter too. Historical details change the argument, not just its scenery.

Analysis

This is a productive way to use history: comparison can reveal that familiar institutions are contingent rather than inevitable. The debate over medieval English individualism also shows why legal records alone may not disclose how people experienced property or obligation. The caution is that broad contrasts between premodern and modern life can compress regional variation and long transitions. McMylor resists a simple nostalgia reading, but the historical case still depends on which societies and periods are selected. Comparison is most persuasive when it explains variation as carefully as it explains difference.

Build local institutions where common goods can outrank market rewards

Community can support resistance. McMylor closes by considering MacIntyre's proposal to sustain local forms of life where shared practices and moral debate can survive market pressure. The 1984-85 miners' strike serves as a concrete case. Mining communities organized around the threat of pit closures, defending work, local ties, and institutions built around the industry. The conflict was not only about wages; it exposed a clash between communal commitments and a state-driven language of efficiency.

Shared life needs structure. The answer is not simply to praise community or revive an idealized past. Institutions must make cooperation possible and remain open to debate about who benefits and who bears costs. A common good is more than adding up private advantages. It asks participants to recognize some purposes they share, even when pursuing them does not maximize each person's immediate gain.

Analysis

The miners' example gives the book's abstract account of community real political stakes: decisions framed as economic adjustments can dismantle networks of identity, skill, and mutual support. Contemporary local governance and cooperative institutions face a similar challenge when market pressures meet place-based obligations. The idea of a common good is not self-validating, however. Communities can silence minorities, enforce conformity, or defend arrangements that distribute burdens unfairly. Local institutions need both shared purpose and procedures for dissent. Otherwise, resistance to distant managerial power can reproduce domination on a smaller scale.

Analysis

McMylor's study is best understood as a sociological interpretation of MacIntyre's intellectual journey, rather than a simple guide to virtue ethics. Its central thread runs from the young MacIntyre's attempt to hold Christian moral urgency and Marxist social analysis together, through his critique of liberal moral fragmentation, to an Aristotelian account of practices, narrative, and tradition. This trajectory matters because it shows that MacIntyre's target is not simply individual selfishness. It is a social order in which moral language loses shared authority while markets and bureaucracies present their own priorities as neutral facts.

The book's most persuasive move is to connect philosophical claims to institutions and economic history. Polanyi's distinction between economies embedded in social obligations and a market society, Simmel's account of impersonal dependence, and the miners' strike make the argument legible beyond moral philosophy. The manager is not just a caricature of an overconfident professional: managerial authority depends on a culture that treats ends as settled and technical means as decisive. That connection gives social scientists a reason to examine their own categories and clients, not merely their methods.

The argument also has a vulnerable edge. Its historical contrasts can make the transition to modernity look more unified than it was, and the aspiration to shared goods raises difficult questions about pluralism, power, and exclusion. McMylor acknowledges conflict within earlier societies, but showing that modern individualism is historically specific does not by itself establish that inherited communities are just. The most durable reading is therefore neither a return to the past nor a rejection of modern institutions. It is a demand to make their purposes contestable, and to ask whether they sustain human activities whose value cannot be measured by money, efficiency, or status alone.

Summary in 30 Seconds
Moral disputes become hard to resolve when people no longer share standards for judging reasons and ends. Virtues connect ethical rules to human flourishing, while cooperative practices offer goods that cannot be gained through money or status alone. Institutions need external rewards to survive, but those rewards can distort the activities they support. Markets and managerial systems shape social relationships while presenting contested priorities as technical necessities. Shared traditions and local institutions can help communities debate common purposes without idealizing the past.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue
Want to read the full book?

Glossary

Emotivism

Moral judgment as preference

The view that moral judgments express personal attitudes or feelings rather than claims that can be rationally shown to be true or false. In McMylor's account of MacIntyre, emotivism is not merely a philosophical doctrine. It also describes a social pattern in which moral disputes lack shared standards and become contests of persuasion or influence.

Bureaucratic Individualism

Managerial systems, private selves

A modern social culture combining organizations focused on effectiveness with individuals treated as autonomous choosers. The manager takes goals as given and selects efficient means, while the individual is expected to define personal aims privately. McMylor presents this pairing as a setting where moral disagreement becomes difficult to resolve through shared standards.

practice

Cooperative activity with standards

A socially established, complex activity in which participants cooperate and pursue standards of excellence. Learning a practice can reveal goods available through participation itself, such as strategic understanding in chess or achievement in artistic work. Practices require institutions for resources and continuity, but can be distorted when institutional rewards such as money, status, or power take priority.

internal goods

Goods specific to an activity

Benefits that can be understood and achieved only through participation in a particular practice and the development of its standards. In chess, these might include strategic skill and a deeper understanding of play. Internal goods can enrich a community of practitioners, unlike external goods, which can be possessed or distributed independently of the activity.

external goods

Portable rewards and advantages

Benefits such as money, status, and power that can be gained through many different activities and pursued independently of their purposes. They are often scarce and competitive: one person's greater share can leave less for others. Institutions need external goods to function, but an excessive focus on them can undermine the practices institutions exist to support.

teleological framework

Life understood through human ends

An account of human life that evaluates actions in relation to purposes or goods toward which people can develop. In the Aristotelian view presented by McMylor, ethics helps people move from their present condition toward a fuller realization of human capacities. This framework links moral guidance to claims about human flourishing.

narrative unity

A life understood as a whole

The idea that an individual life gains coherence through an unfolding story of intentions, relationships, roles, and commitments. An action cannot always be understood in isolation; its meaning may depend on a person's history and the social setting in which it occurs. This account connects personal identity to communities and traditions.

embeddedness

Economic activity within social obligations

Polanyi's term for the way economic activity in many societies is governed within social institutions such as kinship, religion, and political authority. McMylor contrasts this with modern market society, where economic exchange becomes more independent and influential. Embeddedness does not mean markets are absent, or that earlier societies are harmonious.

managerialism

Authority through claimed expertise

A culture in which managers claim the authority to select effective means for achieving goals treated as already settled. MacIntyre's criticism, as presented by McMylor, is that social science cannot offer the precise predictive laws this authority often implies, and that decisions about goals remain moral and political choices rather than neutral technical facts.

Download PDF

To save this Alasdair Macintyre summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.29 MB     Pages: 15

Download EPUB

To read this Alasdair Macintyre summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.35 MB     Pages: 19
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...