Plot Summary
Mouse in the Office
Nell Sullivan is a timid, overlooked secretary in 1970s New York, desperate to fit in with her glamorous coworkers at Rambert & Bertram. She meticulously arranges her desk, dreams of being "one of the girls," and contemplates taking up smoking just to belong. Her self-consciousness is amplified by the cruel jabs of Mary Ann Thomas and her clique, who mock Nell's appearance and social awkwardness. Nell's only solace is her older brother Barrett, a mute, enigmatic figure whose love is both a comfort and a cage. The office's daily rhythms and Nell's yearning for acceptance set the stage for a story of psychological horror, where the desire to belong becomes a dangerous vulnerability.
Barrett's Silent Dominion
Barrett, Nell's older brother, is a silent, brooding presence who hasn't spoken since childhood. He communicates through notes, exerting a quiet but absolute control over Nell's life. He discourages her from making friends, warning her of the world's dangers, and his possessiveness is both protective and suffocating. Nell's dependence on Barrett is deep—she works to support them both, idolizes his intellect, and fears his eventual abandonment. Their relationship is fraught with unspoken tension, rooted in a traumatic childhood and a shared sense of being outsiders. Barrett's silence is a constant reminder of past wounds, and his influence shapes every choice Nell makes.
Yearning for Belonging
Haunted by loneliness, Nell makes a clumsy attempt to befriend her coworker Linnie Carter after a humiliating incident with Mary Ann's clique. Linnie offers a small kindness, helping Nell clean a coffee stain, and Nell latches onto this gesture, fantasizing about a real friendship. She plans an elaborate tea party to thank Linnie, hoping to finally break free from her isolation. But her efforts are met with polite rejection—Linnie, uncomfortable with Nell's intensity, makes it clear they are not friends. This rejection deepens Nell's sense of alienation and sets off a chain of emotional unraveling, as her longing for connection turns to bitterness and rage.
Linnie Carter's Kindness
Linnie's brief act of kindness is a lifeline for Nell, who interprets it as the start of a genuine friendship. Nell's gratitude becomes obsessive, and she invests emotionally in the idea of being accepted. The tea party she plans is both a gesture of thanks and a desperate plea for belonging. When Linnie declines the invitation, Nell's hope shatters, and the humiliation festers into resentment. The episode exposes Nell's fragile psyche and the dangers of unmet emotional needs, as her disappointment morphs into dark fantasies and a growing sense of persecution.
The Tea Party Rejection
Linnie's refusal to attend Nell's tea party is a devastating blow. Nell's humiliation is compounded by the indifference and cruelty of her coworkers, and her internal monologue grows increasingly hostile. She imagines violent retribution against those who have wronged her, and her thoughts become tinged with paranoia and self-loathing. The rejection is a catalyst, pushing Nell further into isolation and fueling her dependence on Barrett. The boundaries between fantasy and reality begin to blur, and Nell's grip on her own identity weakens as she seeks solace in imagined acts of vengeance.
Violence and Vengeance
After being harassed by a local gang, Nell finally snaps, pelting them with rocks in a rare act of defiance. The adrenaline rush is intoxicating, but it also marks a turning point—Nell's anger is no longer contained. At home, her rage erupts in the destruction of the tea party cake, a symbolic rejection of her own hope. Barrett, witnessing her breakdown, responds with a rare display of solidarity, but his silence and inscrutable gaze hint at darker intentions. The violence, both real and imagined, signals the beginning of a more dangerous cycle, as Nell's pain seeks an outlet.
The Office Turns Cold
News of Linnie Carter's brutal murder shocks the office. Nell, suspecting Barrett's involvement, is both horrified and secretly gratified by the attention her "friendship" with Linnie brings. She performs grief for her coworkers, relishing the sympathy and sense of belonging it affords her. But beneath the surface, guilt and fear gnaw at her—she knows Barrett is capable of violence, and her own complicity is ambiguous. The office atmosphere grows tense and suspicious, and Nell's lies begin to unravel as Mary Ann and others question her narrative. The murder cements Nell's outsider status, even as it briefly elevates her to the center of attention.
Lies and Loneliness
As suspicion mounts, Nell's lies about her relationship with Linnie become harder to sustain. Her coworkers' initial sympathy turns to skepticism, and she is once again ostracized. Harriet Lamont, her supervisor, confronts her about the inconsistencies, and Nell's desperation leads her to double down on her fabrications. The isolation is now total—Nell is trapped between the cold indifference of her peers and the suffocating control of Barrett. Her sense of self fractures, and she becomes increasingly untethered from reality, haunted by the knowledge of her own deceit and the violence it has unleashed.
Barrett's Deadly Protection
Barrett's role as Nell's protector takes a deadly turn. He murders Linnie to avenge Nell's humiliation, and his actions are both a twisted expression of love and a manifestation of his own trauma. Nell, torn between horror and gratitude, rationalizes his violence as a necessary defense against a hostile world. Their relationship becomes a closed circuit of mutual dependence and destruction, each enabling the other's worst impulses. Barrett's silence is now a weapon, and Nell's complicity deepens as she realizes she cannot escape him—or herself.
Nell's Fractured Identity
Nell's identity unravels as the boundaries between victim and perpetrator blur. She is haunted by memories of childhood abuse, her mother's cruelty, and Barrett's possessiveness. The violence that surrounds her is both external and internal—a reflection of her own suppressed rage and longing. As more murders occur, Nell's sense of agency dissolves, and she becomes increasingly dissociated from her actions. The narrative fractures, revealing the extent to which Nell's reality is shaped by trauma, loneliness, and the desperate need for connection.
The Cycle of Hurt
The story's core is the cycle of trauma—how abuse, neglect, and unmet needs are passed down and repeated. Nell and Barrett are both victims and perpetrators, shaped by a mother who was herself broken. Their attempts to protect each other only perpetuate the violence, and every act of love is tinged with pain. The past is never truly past; it haunts the present, manifesting in both psychological and physical harm. The cycle is self-perpetuating, and escape seems impossible.
Haunted by the Past
The narrative's horror is both supernatural and psychological. The presence of a malevolent force—whether embodied in Barrett, the house, or the past itself—blurs the line between reality and delusion. Objects like the Ouija board and the doll become conduits for trauma, and the house is a character in its own right, holding the memories and violence of generations. The supernatural is a metaphor for the inescapability of pain, and the true terror lies in the recognition of oneself in the monster.
The Board's Invitation
The Ouija board, introduced in the second novella, becomes a symbol of curiosity, guilt, and the desire to control fate. Maggie, like Nell, is drawn to the board out of loneliness and a longing for connection—with the dead, with her own past, with the truth. The board's promise of answers is seductive, but it opens the door to forces beyond her understanding. The supernatural events that follow are both literal hauntings and manifestations of psychological wounds, and the board's invitation is a warning about the costs of seeking what should remain hidden.
Brynn's Final Plea
Brynn, Maggie's goth sister, is a tragic figure—isolated, misunderstood, and ultimately destroyed by the same forces that haunt Nell. Her repeated pleas for Maggie to come home are ignored, and her suicide is both a cry for help and a sacrifice. Brynn's death is the culmination of years of pain, and it serves as a catalyst for Maggie's confrontation with the past. The sisters' relationship is marked by love, rivalry, and the inability to save each other, and Brynn's final act is both an accusation and a gift.
The Shadow in the House
The house, now haunted by the accumulated trauma of generations, becomes the stage for a final reckoning. Maggie, like Nell before her, is forced to confront the darkness she has tried to escape. The shadowy presence is both a literal ghost and a metaphor for the legacy of pain—an evil that attaches itself to the vulnerable and refuses to let go. The haunting is cyclical, passing from one family member to the next, and the house's destruction is both a cleansing and a surrender.
Hope's Inheritance
Hope, Maggie's niece, emerges as the story's final inheritor of the family's curse. Her eerie knowledge, strange behavior, and connection to the supernatural suggest that the cycle is not broken, only transferred. The doll, the board, and the shadow all find new life in Hope, and Maggie's attempts to save her are fraught with ambiguity. The story ends with the sense that trauma, once unleashed, cannot be contained—it finds new vessels, new victims, and continues its work.
The Fire Cleansing
In a final act of defiance, Maggie sets fire to the family home, hoping to destroy the evil that has taken root there. The flames consume the physical space of trauma, but the act is both cathartic and futile. The family is forced to flee, stripped of their possessions and history, but the true horror—the legacy of pain—remains. The fire is a cleansing, but not a cure, and the survivors are left to reckon with what cannot be burned away.
The Doll's Return
Even after the fire, the doll—symbol of the haunting—returns, finding its way back to Maggie. Its presence is a reminder that the past cannot be discarded, that the forces unleashed by trauma are persistent and adaptable. The doll's cracked face and missing hand are emblems of damage, but also of survival. The story's final moments are haunted by the knowledge that what is broken is never truly gone.
Never Letting Go
The story closes with Maggie realizing that the evil she tried to destroy has not been vanquished—it has simply changed form. The pain in her neck, the shadowy hand on her shoulder, and Hope's cryptic words all point to a future where the cycle continues. The horror is not in the supernatural, but in the persistence of suffering, the way it attaches itself to the living and refuses to let go. The final image is one of endurance, not escape—a warning that some hauntings are forever.
Characters
Nell Sullivan
Nell is the emotional core of the first novella—a painfully shy, self-effacing woman whose longing for acceptance is matched only by her fear of rejection. Her relationship with her brother Barrett is both her anchor and her undoing; she is trapped in a cycle of dependence, guilt, and unspoken desire. Nell's psychological fragility is exacerbated by a lifetime of bullying, family trauma, and unmet needs. As the story progresses, her sense of self fractures, and she becomes both victim and perpetrator, complicit in violence she cannot fully comprehend. Nell's journey is a study in the corrosive effects of loneliness and the dangers of seeking validation from those who cannot give it.
Barrett Sullivan
Barrett is Nell's older brother, rendered mute by childhood trauma and defined by his intense, possessive love for his sister. He is both protector and jailer, his silence a weapon and a wound. Barrett's intelligence and creativity are stifled by his inability to communicate, and his frustration manifests in controlling behavior and, ultimately, violence. He is haunted by memories of abuse and abandonment, and his actions are driven by a desperate need to keep Nell close. Barrett is a tragic figure—his love is genuine, but it is also toxic, and his inability to break the cycle of hurt dooms them both.
Linnie Carter
Linnie is a brief but pivotal presence in Nell's life—a coworker whose small act of kindness becomes the focus of Nell's obsessive longing. Linnie's friendliness is genuine but limited; she is uncomfortable with Nell's intensity and ultimately rejects her overtures. Her murder, likely at Barrett's hands, is both a punishment for her rejection and a perverse gift to Nell. Linnie's fate underscores the dangers of unmet emotional needs and the way kindness can be weaponized in a world of desperate people.
Mary Ann Thomas
Mary Ann is the queen bee of the office—a beautiful, confident woman whose power is maintained through exclusion and mockery. She is both an object of Nell's envy and a symbol of everything Nell cannot have. Mary Ann's cruelty is a defense mechanism, masking her own insecurities and fears. Her eventual murder is a grim commentary on the costs of social hierarchies and the violence that festers beneath the surface of everyday life.
Harriet Lamont
Harriet is Nell's supervisor, a woman who has clawed her way to a position of power in a male-dominated world. She offers Nell advice and second chances, but her support is conditional and ultimately self-serving. Harriet's attempts to help are undermined by her own need for control, and she becomes both a surrogate mother and a target for Nell's resentment. Her fate is a reminder that good intentions are not enough to break cycles of harm.
Maggie Olsen
Maggie is the protagonist of the second novella—a woman whose childhood curiosity and loneliness open the door to supernatural horror. She is defined by guilt, convinced that her actions have caused the deaths of her loved ones. Maggie's journey is one of reckoning with the past, confronting the legacy of trauma, and seeking redemption. Her relationships—with her sisters, her niece Hope, and her former best friend Cheryl—are fraught with longing and regret. Maggie's struggle is both literal and metaphorical, as she battles forces both within and beyond herself.
Brynn Olsen
Brynn is Maggie's middle sister, a goth outsider whose strangeness is both a shield and a curse. She is the family's scapegoat, blamed for everything that goes wrong, and her own pain is masked by sarcasm and rebellion. Brynn's relationship with Maggie is complex—she is both mentor and rival, protector and provocateur. Her suicide is the story's emotional climax, a final plea for help that goes unanswered. Brynn's legacy is one of both warning and love.
Arlen Olsen-Dormer
Arlen is the eldest Olsen sister, a mother of three who tries to maintain order in the face of chaos. She is pragmatic, often dismissive of Maggie and Brynn's strangeness, and focused on survival. Arlen's attempts to help are often undermined by her own limitations, and her relationship with her sisters is marked by both love and resentment. She represents the struggle to break free from the past while being constantly pulled back by family obligations.
Hope
Hope is Maggie's niece, a child whose precociousness and strange knowledge mark her as the next vessel for the family's haunting. She is both a symbol of innocence and a harbinger of the cycle's continuation. Hope's connection to the supernatural is ambiguous—she is both victim and participant, and her fate is left unresolved. She embodies the story's central question: can trauma ever truly be escaped, or is it always passed on?
The Shadow / The Doll
The shadowy presence that haunts both novellas is both a literal ghost and a metaphor for the legacy of pain. It attaches itself to the vulnerable, feeding on loneliness, guilt, and unmet needs. The doll, the Ouija board, and the house itself are all vessels for this force, which is as much psychological as supernatural. Its persistence is a reminder that some wounds never heal, and that evil, once unleashed, is difficult to contain.
Plot Devices
Cyclical Trauma and Inherited Evil
Both novellas use cyclical narrative structures to illustrate how trauma, abuse, and unmet emotional needs are passed down through generations. The stories are haunted by repetition—of violence, of longing, of failed attempts at connection. Objects like the Ouija board and the doll serve as physical manifestations of this cycle, carrying the past into the present and ensuring that the wounds of one generation become the burdens of the next. The supernatural elements are both literal and symbolic, blurring the line between external evil and internal pain. Foreshadowing is used to build dread, with early hints of violence and rejection blossoming into full-blown horror. The narrative's structure—shifting between past and present, between different points of view—mirrors the fractured psyches of its characters and the impossibility of escaping one's own history.
Analysis
Ania Ahlborn's Apart in the Dark is a masterclass in psychological horror, using the trappings of the supernatural to explore the far more terrifying realities of loneliness, trauma, and the desperate need for connection. The novellas dissect the ways in which family, society, and personal history conspire to trap individuals in cycles of pain—cycles that are as much inherited as they are self-perpetuated. The horror is not just in the ghosts or the violence, but in the recognition of oneself in the broken, yearning characters. Ahlborn's work is a meditation on the dangers of unmet needs, the corrosive effects of shame and secrecy, and the impossibility of truly escaping the past. The stories warn that evil is not always an external force; often, it is born of neglect, misunderstanding, and the small cruelties we inflict on ourselves and others. In a modern context, the book is a powerful reminder of the importance of empathy, the need to break cycles of harm, and the courage required to face the darkness within.
Last updated:
