Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Before Dorothy

Before Dorothy

An aunt raises her niece on a failing Kansas farm as the Dust Bowl closes in.
by Hazel Gaynor 2025 352 pages
4.11
9k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

In the opening of Emily Gale’s later account of prairie life, she remembers Kansas as a place of startling color and beauty, where she believed she could plant a new future in the soil.

She also admits that she mistook the land’s generosity for a promise. The same earth that once seemed enchanted would test the people who tried to farm it, and force them to discover what kind of courage could survive when their dreams failed.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The prologue establishes memory as both witness and correction. Emily’s first vision of Kansas is sincere, not foolish: its beauty gives her a reason to risk a new life. But the retrospective voice already knows that love of the land does not confer mastery over it. This tension frames the novel’s environmental history as intimate experience. The prairie is not simply a setting that reflects Emily’s feelings; it acts upon the lives she builds, while her later storytelling tries to preserve the beauty without concealing the damage.

Annie’s Empty House

Emily inherits a grieving child and a ruined estate

In 1932, Emily Gale returns from her Kansas farm to her sister Annie’s Chicago home after Annie and her husband, John, drown in a boating accident. Their seven-year-old daughter, Dorothy, has gone quiet and wakes from frightening dreams, so Emily tries to comfort her with family memories and an apple.

A lawyer makes Emily and her husband, Henry, Dorothy’s legal guardians, but reveals that John’s debts have consumed the family’s fortune. Annie has left a sealed letter for Dorothy’s sixteenth birthday, and Emily packs it without knowing what it contains. She must take the child west to a life she barely knows how to share, carrying grief for her sister and anxiety about what the move will demand of her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The novel begins with care arriving as an obligation before it can become a choice. Emily is grieving Annie, but Dorothy’s presence makes grief practical: a child needs a guardian, a home, and adults capable of tolerating her pain. The family’s wealth disappears alongside its former household, forcing Emily to accept that inheritance is not always material. The sealed birthday letter gives the past a future claim on Dorothy, while the apple offers Emily a modest method of connection. Her instinct is to teach the child how memory can survive loss, even as she doubts her ability to provide the security Dorothy needs.

A Prairie Dream Takes Root

Emily meets Henry and chooses a life beyond Chicago

Ten years earlier, Emily and Annie share a cramped Chicago boardinghouse and work at Marshall Field’s, where Emily longs for a life more meaningful than selling silk. At a dinner hosted by Annie’s wealthy suitor, John Gale, she meets his cousin Henry, a modest bank clerk saving to farm the Great Plains. Henry’s enthusiasm for the prairie awakens Emily’s own memories of her mother’s dream of Kansas.

As Emily and Henry grow close, Annie marries John and leaves the store, widening the distance between the sisters. Henry proposes, and Emily accepts both marriage and the journey west. Their sudden city-hall wedding begins the adventure she has imagined, but her choice soon collides with Annie’s need for her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Emily’s move toward Kansas is not merely an escape from monotonous work. It joins her appetite for adventure to a family inheritance: her mother’s unfulfilled longing for the prairie. Henry attracts her because his ambitions are physical and legible, a counterweight to the financial abstractions surrounding John. Yet Emily’s independence is entangled with attachment. She wants to choose her own future, but the decision strains the sisterhood that has been her safest home. Her quick marriage is both a declaration of agency and a leap made before she can know what the land, or separation from Annie, will cost.

A Birth and a Secret

Annie’s fear keeps Emily in Chicago longer

When Annie reveals she is pregnant, Emily delays joining Henry in Kansas to stay through the birth. A fall on icy steps injures Emily’s ankle, and she later miscarries a pregnancy she had not yet recognized, a loss she hides from Henry. During a storm, Emily helps deliver Annie’s daughter, Dorothy, whose arrival brings joy and fresh grief.

While tending the newborn, Emily overhears Annie speaking of another man as the child’s father. She recognizes the secret as dangerous, but leaves for Kansas without confronting Annie or telling Henry what she knows. Before she goes, she gives Dorothy a toy lion and ties a red ribbon to the crib, then carries Annie’s secret west with her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The birth turns private pain into a lasting asymmetry between the sisters. Emily has lost a pregnancy without knowing she was carrying one, while Annie becomes a mother in the same house where Emily must act as midwife and then leave. Her silence protects Annie from immediate exposure, but it also isolates Emily from Henry and converts compassion into a burden. The lion and ribbon show her trying to leave Dorothy a trace of safety and affection. At the same time, the concealed truth about the child’s father gives the family’s future an unstable foundation, one built from love and deliberate omission.

Building Gale Farm

Emily learns the land alongside Henry

Emily arrives in Kansas to find that Henry has built them a small timber home beside fields of winter wheat. She embraces farm work, studies agricultural manuals, learns to drive the machinery, and joins Laurie Miller’s circle of prairie women, who offer friendship and practical knowledge.

Henry’s modern tractor and plow increase their yields, though old farmer Ike West warns that stripping the native grass could leave the soil exposed. Emily notices the warning but shares Henry’s confidence in progress.

The couple plant an orchard and garden, preserve food, and build a life around the seasons. Their early harvests bring money and optimism, while Emily’s growing attachment to the prairie makes her determined to prove that she belongs there.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The farm’s first success rests on an uneasy bargain between skill and scale. Emily learns the work through attention to living systems, from soil and weather to animals and food preservation. Henry sees machinery as a way to make farming efficient and prosperous. Ike’s warning exposes the cost hidden inside that efficiency: increased production depends on disturbing an ecosystem whose limits the newcomers do not understand. Emily wants to belong, so she initially treats the warning as resistance to change rather than knowledge. Her competence and pride are real, but they grow within a boom that rewards the very practices that will later imperil the community.

Sisters at Crossroads

Annie’s visit ends with the truth unspoken

After years apart, Annie visits Gale Farm without Dorothy, who is supposedly ill. Emily and Annie rediscover moments of affection, but their differences remain sharp: Annie finds the farm austere, while Emily resents her sister’s doubts. During the visit, Emily learns from the town women about marriages shaped by concealed paternity and confronts Annie with what she overheard at Dorothy’s birth.

Annie refuses to explain and warns Emily to keep the matter private. They part coldly, and Annie leaves a photograph of Dorothy for Emily. The sisters exchange occasional letters afterward, but their closeness does not recover. Emily’s questions about Dorothy’s father stay buried beside her guilt over the pregnancy she never told Henry about.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The visit makes secrecy a form of intimacy and estrangement at once. Emily raises the question because she still wants to be trusted as Annie’s sister, but Annie’s refusal turns that desire into an enforced boundary. Emily, meanwhile, has concealed her own loss from Henry, so she is not simply a truth-teller confronting a deceiver. Both women protect themselves by withholding, though the costs fall on different relationships. The photograph gives Emily a continuing connection to Dorothy while intensifying her distance from Annie. Their rupture is not caused by a single quarrel; it is the accumulated result of incompatible choices and the truths each woman cannot safely share.

The Tornado Takes Home

A storm destroys the life Emily built

In 1929, a tornado lifts Gale Farm’s house from its foundations and scatters its contents across the prairie. Emily and Henry survive in the cyclone cellar, then find their home, crops, and animals devastated. Neighbors bring food, clothing, and lumber, and Henry builds a temporary shelter from the wreckage. Amid the destruction, Emily discovers she is pregnant and finally tells Henry.

For a brief time, the coming child gives them a reason to imagine rebuilding, even as the farm’s losses deepen. Emily struggles with the shame of accepting help and doubts whether the prairie ever truly welcomed her. The storm does not end their life there, but it breaks the version of that life they had believed they could preserve.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The tornado exposes the vulnerability concealed by the farm’s earlier prosperity. Emily and Henry have treated home as something they can make secure through labor, good timber, and careful preparation. The storm demonstrates that survival is not the same as control. Community generosity keeps them from facing the aftermath alone, yet receiving help also wounds Emily’s self-image as a capable newcomer who has earned her place. Her pregnancy arrives amid this collapse, joining renewal to material precarity rather than replacing it. The novel makes hope difficult but not sentimental: a future can begin in wreckage, though it cannot restore what the wreckage has taken.

The Crash After the Storm

Bad investments and another loss undo their recovery

While Emily and Henry try to rebuild after the tornado, the stock market collapses. Henry admits that he ignored John’s advice to sell his shares and invested their remaining savings in machinery and loans. Their money is gone, leaving them unable to repair the farm as planned. Soon afterward, Emily miscarries again.

She walks to the creek alone to wash, then buries pressed wildflowers for the two children she has lost. Henry mourns privately too, and the pair gradually return to the routines that keep them alive. Years of drought and falling crop prices follow. By 1932, the once-thriving farm has shrunk to a humble shelter, and the couple must face the added responsibility of raising Dorothy.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The crash makes financial risk as intimate as weather. Henry’s decision is not simply a failed calculation; it is a breach in the shared confidence that had once allowed the couple to imagine themselves as a team. Emily’s second miscarriage deepens their grief, but the story gives her no clean ritual of closure. She finds a private ceremony at the creek because ordinary domestic space cannot contain what she has lost. Their return to routine is resilience, but also a defense against feelings they do not know how to discuss. By the time Dorothy arrives, the Gales have endured repeated losses that make care both urgently meaningful and frightening.

Dorothy Comes to Kansas

Aunt and uncle make room for a wounded child

After Annie’s death, Emily brings Dorothy from Chicago to the diminished Kansas farm. The child mourns her parents, clings to her toy lion and grandfather’s tin man, and finds the landscape bleak and lonely. Henry welcomes her with a magic coin trick and makes her a straw Brigid doll; Emily struggles to match his ease, especially when Dorothy insists that Emily is not her mother.

Nightmares and sleepwalking make the adults fear for her safety. Emily begins telling Irish stories and showing Dorothy how an apple slice reveals a blossom, while the girl starts to understand that her aunt will preserve her mother’s memory. The household grows around grief, not by erasing it, but by making space for one more person.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The transfer from Chicago to Kansas repeats Emily’s own migration in miniature, but Dorothy experiences it without the agency that Emily once claimed for herself. Her objections to the farm are not ingratitude; they are a child’s accurate recognition that safety has also meant losing everything familiar. Emily initially tries to perform the role of aunt through good intentions and useful explanations. Dorothy’s blunt resistance prevents that role from becoming sentimental. Shared objects and stories do more than symbolize family continuity: they give the two a concrete activity through which trust can form. Henry’s warmth helps, but Emily must learn that kinship cannot be demanded as a title.

A Pilot in the Barn

Adelaide restores wonder as dust closes in

A female barnstormer, Adelaide Watson, lands her damaged Jenny on the Gales’ farm and captivates Dorothy with stories of flight. Emily, whose caution has hardened through years of loss, accepts Adelaide’s invitation to fly and rediscovers the thrill of looking beyond the fields. Adelaide later leaves to find a traveling rainmaker, while Dorothy’s sleepwalking prompts Henry to bring home an orphaned puppy.

Dorothy names him Toto, and the dog helps settle her into the household. Yet drought worsens, dust storms darken the sky, and Emily begins to consider sending Dorothy to her older sister Nell in safer California. Her growing love for the child is real, but it does not quiet her fear that Kansas may endanger her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Adelaide’s brief presence works because she does not solve the Gales’ problems. She offers Emily an experience of risk that is chosen, unlike the storms and losses imposed on the farm. Flight lets Emily feel possibility without pretending that the damaged land below has changed. Toto, by contrast, brings care back to ground level: Dorothy gains a companion, and the adults gain a practical safeguard against her wandering. Emily’s wish to send Dorothy away is therefore not a failure of affection but its consequence. She is beginning to love the child enough to consider a painful separation, even as that possibility reveals how deeply the household has changed.

The Rainmaker Returns

Emily recognizes Annie’s lost love in the barn

Adelaide returns with Leonardo Stregone, a former circus aerialist now selling rainmaking experiments to desperate farmers. Dorothy recognizes him as her mother’s special friend, and Emily understands that he is the man she has long suspected was Dorothy’s father. Leonardo confirms that Annie loved him and that he knew the child was his, but he refused to leave the circus life and take responsibility for them.

He had visited Dorothy occasionally before Annie’s death. In Kansas, he performs for the town, yet the promised rain does not arrive. Emily later catches him searching Henry’s papers and stealing Annie’s emerald ring. He admits he hoped to find money, and leaves after Emily rejects his claim to a place in Dorothy’s life.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Leonardo’s arrival collapses the distance between Emily’s private memory and the crisis facing her present family. His charisma once helped make Annie’s romance feel like an enduring promise; now it masks a history of refusing responsibility. The rainmaking show reproduces that dynamic on a public scale, offering spectacle where desperate people need material relief. Emily’s judgment sharpens when she sees him take the ring: charm is no substitute for dependable care. Yet her certainty does not come from denying his past with Annie. It comes from measuring what Dorothy needs now against what he actually does, rather than what his performance invites others to believe.

The Black Blizzard

A colossal duster leaves Dorothy fighting for breath

After Leonardo’s experiments fail, a monstrous dust storm swallows the prairie. Dorothy is away checking the rain gauge when the Gales shelter in their cellar; when the wind passes, Henry digs through the drifts and finds her alive in an abandoned dugout, with Toto beside her. Dust has filled Dorothy’s lungs, and she develops severe dust pneumonia.

At her hospital bedside, Emily reads from her journal, tells stories of Ireland, and finally understands that Dorothy is not a burden she can send away to safety. She chooses the child as family, wherever they must live. Dorothy eventually wakes and says her dream taught her that home is not a particular place, but being together with the people she loves.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The storm turns environmental damage into an immediate test of attachment. Emily and Henry cannot protect Dorothy through good intentions alone; the child is endangered by the same dust that has already stripped their livelihood and health. Henry’s search makes his bond with Dorothy unmistakable, while Emily’s vigil transforms caregiving from a duty imposed by Annie’s will into a chosen relationship. The hospital also gives Emily a new definition of home. The farm has been her proof of belonging, but Dorothy’s illness reveals that place is secondary to the people for whom she is willing to stay, leave, or keep watch.

The Road West

Emily leaves Kansas with her new family

With Dorothy recovering, Emily and Henry accept that they cannot remain on the devastated farm. Adelaide, who has revealed the guilt she carries over her brother Cooper’s death in a plane crash, leaves to return to the circus and pursue another flight. Emily and Henry say goodbye to the prairie community and bury the piece of Irish marble Dorothy no longer needs to carry, hoping it might help the land grow green again.

Dorothy asks Emily to call her Dot, the name Annie used, and Emily accepts it as a sign of trust. They take Annie’s birthday letters west, including the sealed letter meant for Dorothy at sixteen. Emily leaves with Henry, Dorothy, and Toto, carrying a grain of wheat and the memories of the home they could not save.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Leaving Kansas does not cancel Emily’s earlier choice to come there. She can affirm the life she built with Henry while also recognizing that persistence has ceased to be the same as wisdom. The decision becomes possible only after Emily stops treating departure as proof of failure. Dorothy’s invitation to use her mother’s intimate name marks a new bond that neither replaces Annie nor depends on pretending to do so. The objects they carry and leave behind distribute memory across different futures: letters remain unread, marble returns to the soil, and a grain of wheat travels onward. Home becomes something carried in relationships rather than secured by land.

Epilogue

Years later, Dorothy reflects on the people who made a home with her and the lessons Emily taught her about memory, courage, and wonder. At sixteen, she reads the letters her mother and Emily saved for each birthday and learns that Leonardo was her father.

Emily later tells Henry the truth about Dorothy’s parentage and her own long silence; he understands why she concealed it, though he wishes they had faced the secret together. Leonardo remains a distant presence in Dorothy’s life, while Emily’s prairie journal becomes the record of the family’s years in Kansas. Dorothy’s sense of home rests with Emily, Henry, and Toto, wherever they live.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The epilogue gives Dorothy access to the truth without making revelation a cure for the past. Learning that Leonardo is her father changes the meaning of her childhood memories, but it does not undo his absence or displace the people who raised her. Emily’s delayed confession to Henry also shows the cost of protective secrecy: her motive was love, yet her silence denied her partner the chance to share the burden. Dorothy’s account joins these truths to Emily’s written record, allowing a child to inherit more than a hidden history. The final measure of family is neither blood nor geography alone, but sustained care and the willingness to tell the story honestly.

Analysis

Before Dorothy makes its central relationship a work of revision. Emily begins with a fixed idea of home: a place her family can build through labor, a dream inherited from her mother, and a proof that she chose correctly when she left Chicago. The prairie rewards that faith for a time, then exposes its limits. The farm’s prosperity depends partly on machinery and cultivation practices that damage the grasslands, so the novel does not treat hardship as an arbitrary punishment. Human ambition and environmental vulnerability become entangled, though the Dust Bowl’s scale eventually overwhelms any one family’s power to change course.

Emily’s private grief mirrors this public history without collapsing into it. Her miscarriages, her silence about them, and her long estrangement from Annie teach her that love cannot be measured by the dreams people share or the secrets they keep. She wants to protect Henry by withholding painful truths, just as she wants to protect Dorothy by controlling where the child lives. These acts arise from care, but care becomes isolating when it denies others the chance to participate. Her growth is not a sudden transformation into a perfect mother. It is the gradual recognition that responsibility means remaining present, listening, and sometimes changing the plan.

Dorothy’s arrival alters the meaning of the title. Emily’s life before the child is already full of migration, romance, work, and loss, but Dorothy turns those experiences into a new family story. The apple, fiddle, letters, shoes, and journal are not decorative symbols. They are tools for transmitting memory when direct explanation is difficult. The Wizard of Oz motifs emerge from everyday objects and emotional needs rather than from a literal journey to a magical land. By the end, home is no longer a claim to be secured against disaster. It is the durable practice of loving people through uncertainty, including the courage to leave a place that can no longer keep them safe.

Summary in 60 Seconds
In 1932, Emily Gale takes custody of her seven-year-old niece Dorothy after Dorothy’s parents drown and their fortune disappears. Emily and her husband Henry bring the grieving child to their struggling Kansas farm. Years earlier, Emily had left Chicago for prairie life, carrying a secret: she knew Dorothy’s father was another man, and hid her own miscarriages from Henry. After a tornado, the stock market crash, drought, and failed crops deepen the family’s losses, Dorothy arrives. A barnstormer and a traveling rainmaker bring wonder and a connection to Dorothy’s past, but the rainmaker, Leonardo, admits he is her father and leaves after trying to steal from the Gales. A devastating dust storm leaves Dorothy gravely ill, but she survives. Emily and Henry abandon the farm and head west with Dorothy and her dog. At sixteen, Dorothy learns Leonardo’s identity from her mother’s letters, and Emily finally tells Henry what she had concealed.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.11 out of 5
Average of 9k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Before Dorothy reimagines Auntie Em's life before the events of The Wizard of Oz. Set against the backdrop of 1920s Chicago and Dust Bowl-era Kansas, it explores Emily Gale's journey from city life to prairie farming, her relationship with her sister, and the challenges of raising orphaned Dorothy. Readers praise Gaynor's vivid historical details, emotional depth, and clever Oz references. The novel effectively captures the hardships of the Great Depression and Dust Bowl while exploring themes of family, resilience, and home. Most reviewers found it a heartwarming and enchanting read, though a few felt the pacing was slow.

Your rating:
4.68
8 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Emily Gale

Reluctant prairie mother

An Irish American woman shaped by migration, family loss, and a fierce appetite for adventure, Emily first chooses Kansas because it promises a life built with her own hands. She is practical without being unfeeling, but often hides sorrow behind chores and keeps painful truths to herself to protect the people she loves. Her relationship with Annie is marked by closeness, competition, and unresolved hurt; with Henry, she finds a partner in work and imagination. As an aunt, Emily must learn that care is not the same as replacing a child’s mother. Her identity is rooted in memory, but she is capable of revising what home and family mean.

Henry Gale

Steady prairie builder

Emily’s husband, Henry is a former bank clerk who dreams of farming and prefers tangible labor to speculation. Patient, affectionate, and often gently humorous, he builds their home and trusts machinery to make the farm thrive. His confidence can become stubbornness, especially when money or the land’s limits are at stake, and he sometimes carries worry alone rather than inviting Emily into it. He offers Dorothy warmth without demanding that she accept him quickly. His partnership with Emily rests on shared work and loyalty, even when grief and financial pressure test how openly they can depend on each other.

Dorothy Gale

Restless orphan storyteller

Annie and John’s young daughter, Dorothy arrives in Kansas after losing both parents and being uprooted from the only home she knows. She is observant, imaginative, and unafraid to say when adults fail to understand her. Her dreams, conversations with toys, and stories give shape to grief she cannot yet explain. She treasures her mother’s memory and resists anyone who seems to claim that role too easily. Dorothy’s bond with Emily develops through shared stories, household work, keepsakes, and the ordinary reassurance of being looked after. Her curiosity makes her vulnerable to danger, but also helps her find wonder in a difficult world.

Annie Gale

Romantic city sister

Emily’s sister and Dorothy’s mother, Annie is charming, imaginative, and drawn to romance, beauty, and the excitement of city life. As a young woman, she shares a deep bond with Emily and dreams of adventures beyond their modest circumstances. Marriage to wealthy businessman John brings comfort and social security, but it also pulls Annie away from her former independence and closeness with Emily. She is not simply a romantic ideal: she can avoid difficult conversations and use charm to deflect conflict. Her love for Dorothy is profound, and her choices leave a legacy of stories, keepsakes, and questions for the family she leaves behind.

Adelaide Watson

Fearless flying drifter

A woman barnstormer who travels in a battered Jenny, Adelaide embodies the independence and daring Emily once imagined for herself. Confident, quick-witted, and candid, she connects easily with Dorothy and challenges Emily to take risks that are not dictated by fear. Her charm can make her seem invulnerable, but her wandering life also protects her from the responsibilities and attachments she finds difficult. Adelaide’s friendship with Emily is brief yet consequential: she offers a different model of courage, one that includes movement, regret, and the possibility of choosing partnership again.

Leonardo Stregone

Charismatic traveling showman

A former circus aerialist, Leonardo moves through life as a performer, relying on charm, tricks, and a gift for turning an audience’s longing into belief. His past is closely connected to Annie, and his appearance in Kansas places him amid the family’s grief and the community’s desperation for rain. He is resourceful and theatrical, but his ease with spectacle contrasts with his difficulty accepting responsibility. Leonardo’s presence tests Emily’s judgment: she must distinguish the hope he can inspire from the dependable care Dorothy needs.

Nell Hugson

Practical eldest sister

Emily and Annie’s older sister, Nell lives in California with her rancher husband and children. Sensible, kind, and experienced in raising a family, she offers perspective and help from a distance. Her life gives Emily a model of family rooted in steady daily care rather than romantic spectacle. Although separation and circumstance keep Nell from the center of the Kansas story, her support remains an alternative source of safety when Emily must consider what is best for Dorothy.

John Gale

Ambitious Chicago husband

Annie’s husband and Henry’s cousin, John is a wealthy businessman whose confidence in investment and commerce shapes the family’s early social world. He is generous in appearance and accustomed to making decisions with money, but his financial affairs are more precarious than those around him realize. His marriage offers Annie security and status, while his absence from domestic life leaves her to manage much of motherhood herself. John’s business choices also connect the Chicago family to the economic risks that reach the prairie.

Cora McNulty

Irish household anchor

The housekeeper in Annie’s Chicago home, Cora is an Irish immigrant who cares for Dorothy and offers Emily practical kindness during the first days of bereavement. Her warmth helps Emily approach a child she barely knows, and her stories about Dorothy’s habits give Emily clues to the girl’s inner life. Cora’s familiarity with Irish customs also provides a point of connection to Emily’s childhood and inherited traditions.

Laurie Miller

Prairie community matriarch

A schoolmistress and the general store owner’s wife, Laurie welcomes Emily into the local women’s circle and helps her learn the practical demands of prairie life. She is perceptive, generous, and grounded, offering food, clothing, advice, and companionship when the Gales face hardship. Laurie sees community not as sentiment but as mutual labor, a principle that becomes essential after disaster. Her steady friendship gives Emily a place to belong beyond her marriage.

Ingrid Anderssen

Grieving immigrant mother

A Dutch immigrant and mother of two boys, Ingrid came to the prairie seeking healthier air for her son Pieter. She is thoughtful and private, carrying both the homesickness of an immigrant and the burdens of family life. Her friendship with Emily deepens through shared work and loss, and she offers frank insight into the fear and ambivalence that can accompany motherhood. Ingrid’s experience helps Emily recognize that uncertainty does not cancel love.

Wilhelmina West

Suspicious town watchdog

Known as Mina, Wilhelmina is an opinionated, suspicious woman who polices the behavior of others and resists the changes brought by newcomers and modern farming. Her severity has roots in a difficult family history and a deep protectiveness toward her sister. She often appears as an antagonist to Emily and Dorothy, but her strictness also reflects fear and grief hardened into control. Her character complicates the prairie community’s easy divisions between welcoming and unwelcoming neighbors.

Hank Miller

Practical storekeeper farmer

Laurie’s husband and the owner of Liberal’s general store, Hank helps Henry establish himself and shares the community’s practical response to farm hardship. He is a resourceful neighbor who lends equipment, offers advice, and joins the local effort to support families in need. His work connects the Gales to town life, making the store both a marketplace and a vital source of news and assistance.

May Lucas

Blunt club storyteller

A member of the prairie women’s supper club, May is outspoken, funny, and unusually frank about marriage, money, and the compromises people make. Her stories sometimes offer Emily warnings disguised as gossip. May’s humor helps the women endure difficult conditions without pretending those conditions are easy, and her experiences illuminate the private bargains beneath respectable family life.

Pieter Anderssen

Dorothy’s prairie companion

Ingrid’s energetic young son, Pieter becomes one of Dorothy’s first friends in Kansas. He shares her excitement about the circus and Adelaide’s airplane, giving her companionship beyond the adults in the Gale household. His health and childhood experiences also help Emily understand the vulnerability of children on the prairie.

Toto

Small loyal guardian

A small orphaned puppy adopted by the Gales, Toto becomes Dorothy’s constant companion. His presence helps soothe her after the move and alerts the adults when she wanders. He is a practical protector as well as a source of affection, binding the household together through the ordinary routines of feeding, sheltering, and caring for him.

Ike West

Old prairie farmer

Wilhelmina’s uncle and an experienced farmer, Ike distrusts Henry’s powerful new machinery. He warns that plowing up the native grass could leave the soil vulnerable. His caution is easy for the prosperous newcomers to dismiss, but it represents hard-earned knowledge of the land’s limits.

Eric Anderssen

Ingrid’s devoted husband

Ingrid’s husband and the father of her boys, Eric is part of the immigrant farming community that seeks a healthier and more hopeful life on the prairie. His illness and family’s vulnerability deepen Emily’s understanding of how quickly hardship can turn a working household into a community responsibility.

Plot Devices

Emily’s prairie journal

Memory across hard years

Emily’s journal records farm work, weather, private grief, and the changing prairie across the years. It gives the story a second register beyond immediate action: the older Emily’s observations preserve the landscape as it once was, while the younger Emily writes from inside uncertainty. The journal also becomes a source of comfort when Dorothy is ill, as Emily reads aloud from the life Dorothy never saw. Its survival through the tornado turns it into a material record of what the family built and lost. In the epilogue, the journal becomes the basis for Emily’s account of the Dust Bowl years.

Annie’s birthday letters

A truth deferred

Annie leaves sealed letters for Dorothy’s birthdays, including one intended for her sixteenth birthday. Emily becomes custodian of the letters after Annie’s death but does not open them, even when she fears they may contain answers about Dorothy’s father. Their presence makes the past an active responsibility rather than a closed chapter. They also give Annie a way to continue addressing her daughter across an absence she cannot repair. The final letter reveals the truth about Dorothy’s parentage, allowing the epilogue to resolve a secret that Emily has kept for years.

The prairie’s weather

Nature tests every plan

Tornadoes, drought, hail, and dust storms shape the Gales’ choices as directly as any human antagonist. The weather first appears as part of the prairie’s beauty and agricultural promise, then exposes the cost of treating the land as endlessly productive. Emily and Henry build a cyclone cellar, learn to read the sky, and still cannot control the storms. Dust both damages the farm and threatens Dorothy’s health, turning ecological crisis into a family emergency. The changing landscape also challenges Emily’s belief that hard work alone can secure a home.

Circus and rainmaking

Hope staged as spectacle

The circus connects Annie’s romance, Emily’s memories, Dorothy’s imagination, and Leonardo’s talent for performance. Later, Leonardo uses the same showmanship to sell rainmaking experiments to farmers desperate for relief. His chemicals and aerial explosions create spectacle and communal hope, but they do not bring the promised rain. The device asks how people distinguish genuine possibility from a performance designed to exploit need. Adelaide’s barnstorming offers a contrasting kind of wonder: flight does not solve the drought, but it gives Emily a real experience of courage and renewed perspective.

Inherited keepsakes

Objects carry belonging

The toy lion, tin man, silver shoes, emerald ring, Irish marble, fiddle, and pressed flowers link different generations of the family. Each object carries a story, but its meaning changes as Emily and Dorothy grow closer. The apple blossom inside a slice of fruit becomes a practical lesson in remembering what cannot be seen at first glance. The silver shoes become a game that helps Dorothy express a wish, while the marble offers comfort during migration. The family’s keepsakes make memory tactile, helping Emily preserve Annie’s presence without asking Dorothy to stop grieving.

About the Author

Hazel Gaynor is an award-winning New York Times and internationally bestselling author of historical novels. Her works explore significant 20th-century events and have been translated into 20 languages across 27 territories. Gaynor has received numerous accolades, including the 2015 RNA Historical Novel award and the 2024 Audie award for Best Fiction Narrator. She regularly speaks at literary festivals and co-founded The Inspiration Project. Gaynor also programmed and hosted Historia Live events in Dublin. Her latest novel, Before Dorothy, imagines the life of Dorothy's Aunt Em from The Wizard of Oz and is set for publication in June 2025. Gaynor resides in Ireland with her family.

Download PDF

To save this Before Dorothy summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.29 MB     Pages: 24

Download EPUB

To read this Before Dorothy summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.27 MB     Pages: 32
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...