Key Takeaways
Investigate repeated changes before they become a crisis between loved ones.
Small signs add up. B. Smith was a celebrated model, restaurateur, and television host, known for flawless live performances. Years before her diagnosis, she began repeating questions, missing appointments, buying too much food, and leaving things behind. Her husband, Dan, first read these changes as carelessness or marital trouble. Even a frightening moment on live television did not immediately make Alzheimer’s seem possible. That delay matters: families may mistake early symptoms for ordinary forgetfulness, stress, or a change in personality.
Look for a pattern. One lapse proves little. Repeated changes that interfere with familiar tasks deserve medical attention. Early signs in B.’s story included trouble remembering recent conversations and following a train of thought, even while her long-term memories and social warmth remained.
What's striking is how the disease first altered the couple's interpretation of each other, not simply B.'s memory. That is a useful lesson in relationship psychology: when behavior changes abruptly, explanations based on character can become self-reinforcing. A partner's frustration elicits withdrawal or anger, which then seems to confirm that the relationship is failing. A medical assessment cannot explain every conflict, but it can widen the frame before blame hardens. The caution is to avoid turning every ordinary lapse into a diagnosis. The signal is a persistent change in function, not a single forgotten name.
A diagnosis can end the wrong story, even when it cannot cure.
Knowing changed the frame. At Mount Sinai, B. struggled to recall three words after a short delay and could not draw a clock showing a specified time. A PET scan then revealed amyloid plaques in her brain, supporting the diagnosis. Before that, the couple had considered depression and a possible minor stroke. The diagnosis did not restore B.’s memory, but it helped Dan understand that the unexplained anger and repeated arguments were symptoms of illness, not proof that their marriage had failed.
Treatment had limits. In the book’s 2016 account, available medications could ease some symptoms for some patients, but they did not stop the underlying disease. Doctors also recommended diet, exercise, and clinical trials. These were ways to support B. and pursue future options, not cures.
A diagnosis can be valuable even when it does not offer a cure. It changes what a family can reasonably expect, which behaviors to interpret as symptoms, and what safety decisions to make. This is a form of explanatory relief: the facts remain painful, but the story becomes less needlessly accusatory. The PET scan also illustrates a distinction important in medicine: detecting a biological marker is not the same as predicting an individual's exact future. The book's treatment descriptions reflect its publication period, so medication and testing decisions belong with current clinicians, not with a memoir written in 2016.
Preserve dignity by making ordinary tasks smaller, shared, and safe.
Agency needs scaffolding. B. wanted to remain independent, but tasks that once felt automatic began to overwhelm her. At the grocery store, a wall of choices could leave her unable to choose rice or pasta. Dan learned that offering one manageable option worked better than demanding that she decide among many. They also cooked together, walked their dog, and gave her small household tasks she could still complete, such as loading the dishwasher or ironing.
Help without taking over. The goal was not to keep B. performing every task exactly as before. It was to preserve meaningful participation while reducing confusion and risk. Simplifying her wardrobe, setting out clothes, and breaking activities into steps could make daily life easier. The tension remained real: B. valued privacy, particularly around her closet, and Dan's attempts to help could feel intrusive.
This approach resembles accessible design: instead of insisting that a person adapt to a difficult task, the surroundings and choices are adjusted to the person's current abilities. A smaller decision can preserve agency better than either a complex demand or a complete takeover. The distinction matters because assistance can quietly become control, especially when the caregiver is anxious. B.'s resistance to closet changes shows that practical efficiency is not the only value at stake. Familiar possessions can carry identity and security, so simplifying should involve the person whenever possible, not merely clear space for the caregiver.
Respond to the feeling beneath a memory error, not the error alone.
Reason may not reassure. B.'s sense of time became unreliable: plans could disappear within minutes, while a moment could feel endless. Dan began repeating plans regularly and found that clocks and a visible calendar could help. When she asked the same question again, correcting or scolding her only increased distress. A gentle answer, a change of subject, or a walk in a different setting often worked better.
Join the moment. The couple used the phrase “joining the journey” for meeting B. in her present experience instead of repeatedly pulling her back to what she could no longer retain. Cooking, walking Bishop on the beach, sharing familiar meals, and sitting together quietly created connection without requiring her to remember yesterday. B.'s long-term memories of childhood and family often remained vivid, so stories from Everson could still bring closeness.
The practical insight is emotional as much as cognitive: a distressed person may need reassurance more than correction. This resembles person-centered care, which treats the individual's felt experience as real even when the facts are confused. It can lower conflict and protect trust. Yet joining someone's perspective does not mean ignoring danger or abandoning honest communication in every situation. The caregiver still has to judge when a gentle redirection is kind and when direct explanation is necessary. The book's strongest example is relational: shared attention and familiar rituals can sustain connection when shared memory becomes unreliable.
Turn a frightening disappearance into a concrete safety plan.
Independence can become risk. Dan initially allowed B. to ride a bus alone between Manhattan and Sag Harbor, believing the driver would keep watch. B. got off in Manhattan after forgetting why she was on the bus. She walked through the city for much of the night, rode the Staten Island Ferry, and was eventually found at a familiar diner. She had felt adventurous rather than lost, and had no phone or reliable identification with her.
Plan for changing abilities. The episode forced the family to stop treating supervision as optional. The book recommends considering an identification bracelet or necklace, a GPS locator, and clear limits on driving and unsupervised travel. Driving decisions should be based on warning signs such as getting lost, poor judgment, or confusion, with clinicians and local rules considered. Safety measures should be prepared before a crisis, not improvised during one.
The disappearance exposes a difficult gap between perceived independence and actual capacity. B. could navigate socially and appear composed, yet could not reliably remember the purpose of a trip or find her way home. That mismatch makes safety planning especially hard for families: outward confidence is not a dependable test of judgment. The episode also shows why responsibility cannot rest on one informal promise from a stranger. A system involving family, transportation, identification, and professional advice is more robust. Protection still involves tradeoffs, since restrictions can diminish autonomy, but avoiding that discomfort can create much greater danger.
Accept help before caregiver devotion turns into exhaustion.
Love is not a staffing plan. Dan tried to manage B.’s medicines, meals, appointments, household needs, and business responsibilities alone. Their daughter Dana moved in, took over medication routines, helped with cooking, and supported both parents. Still, Dan resisted hiring a home-care worker because he feared losing privacy and believed no one could care for B. as well as he could. After B. wandered, the family finally hired Isabel, a caregiver whom both B. and Dan liked.
Care has a price. The book describes home care costing roughly $1,000 a week at the time, with more intensive care potentially costing far more. Medicare did not cover long-term care, leaving families to shoulder substantial expenses. Respite, help from relatives, and caregiver support are not indulgences. They help sustain care and reduce the risk that exhaustion will make an already difficult situation less safe.
The caregiver's reluctance is not simply stubbornness. Accepting help can feel like surrendering intimacy, control, or a role that has become central to one's identity. But unpaid family care is still labor, with costs to health, income, and family relationships. Treating support as infrastructure rather than a personal favor makes the problem easier to discuss honestly. The book also makes clear that advice to hire help can sound hollow without affordable options. Individual families need respite and reliable workers, while policy must address who can pay for care that may last years.
Treat food, movement, and company as supports, not cures.
Build helpful routines. Dan and B. adopted a Mediterranean-style diet emphasizing vegetables, fruit, fish, and olive oil, and B. continued walking and exercising. The book cites studies associating this eating pattern with sharper memory or lower risk of cognitive decline, while noting that the results were uncertain and that one study found no benefit for participants with diabetes. The authors treated the diet as a reasonable health choice, not a guaranteed way to prevent or reverse Alzheimer’s.
Keep life engaging. Doctors encouraged regular physical activity and social contact. B. enjoyed walking Bishop, cooking with Dan, and revisiting music and childhood stories. These routines offered pleasure and structure, even when their effect on the disease itself could not be promised. The memoir's practical standard is modest: support health and preserve satisfying moments without presenting lifestyle changes as a substitute for medical care.
This is a useful model for living with uncertain evidence. A behavior can be worthwhile because it supports cardiovascular health, mood, mobility, and daily enjoyment, even when its effect on Alzheimer’s is unclear. That is different from claiming it prevents or treats the disease. The distinction protects readers from false hope and from blame if a loved one's condition progresses despite conscientious choices. The social dimension also matters: a healthy routine that isolates someone or becomes a source of conflict may not be helpful in practice. Sustainable habits need to fit the person's abilities and preferences.
Close research gaps by building trust, not blaming communities.
Disparity has many roots. The book reports that African Americans were about twice as likely as white Americans to develop Alzheimer’s, while stressing that the reasons were not established. Diabetes, hypertension, cardiovascular disease, access to care, and possible genetic factors all deserved investigation. A Duke research effort had only 43 African American samples among 7,000, making conclusions about the group difficult. The history of the Tuskegee Syphilis Study helped explain why some Black families distrusted medical research.
Research must be reciprocal. Dr. Goldie Byrd listened to caregivers before asking them to join a study, addressing concerns about being treated as experimental subjects and then abandoned. Her work helped build research participation and community support through COAACH, a center connecting patients and caregivers with services. A later study discussed in the book found that one gene, ABCA7, explained only a small part of the disparity.
The section resists a tempting but damaging explanation: that unequal outcomes arise because a community is careless or unwilling to participate. Trust depends on history, representation, informed consent, and whether research institutions remain accountable to participants. Better inclusion improves both scientific validity and the fairness of future treatments. At the same time, representation alone cannot explain a health disparity; income, education, chronic disease, environment, and access to diagnosis may interact in ways the book's period-specific evidence could not resolve. The productive response is not to choose genes or social conditions as the sole cause, but to study their interactions with communities as partners.
Demand research funding and care support as one Alzheimer’s agenda.
Discovery needs participation. The book describes a research landscape marked by costly trials and frequent failures. PET imaging helped researchers identify amyloid plaques in living patients, and the authors report that about 30 percent of people entering some trials did not have Alzheimer’s. In Boston, researchers created “Alzheimer’s in a Dish,” a model of human brain cells that developed plaques and tangles, potentially allowing candidate drugs to be tested faster. The authors present it as a research tool, not a cure.
Care needs policy, too. They also point to long medical appointments, limited guidance for caregivers, and high out-of-pocket costs. The Brain Registry was presented as a way for volunteers to connect with studies. Their wider argument is that scientific progress depends on funding and participants, while families need practical support now. A promising experiment cannot replace home care, and good care cannot replace research.
The book connects two time scales that public debate often separates. Drug development is slow, uncertain, and collective; caregiving is immediate, intimate, and expensive. Treating research and care as competing priorities obscures the fact that families need both. The laboratory model offers a way to screen possibilities more efficiently, but results in a dish cannot establish safety or benefit in people. Biomarkers also raise a policy question: a test has limited practical value if patients cannot afford it or if it does not change care. The strongest agenda therefore pairs scientific rigor with access, participation, and support for caregivers.
Analysis
This memoir works on three levels at once: a marriage under pressure, a practical account of Alzheimer’s caregiving, and an argument for public investment. Its emotional force comes from the gap between B.’s visible warmth and the invisible losses beneath it. She can charm strangers, remember childhood vividly, and still be unable to keep a plan in mind. That contrast helps explain why families may misread illness as indifference, stubbornness, or a failing relationship.
Dan’s narration is valuable partly because it does not make him a flawless caregiver. He admits to anger, avoidance, jealousy, denial, and the relief of escaping to a bar. These admissions make the advice more credible: patience is not a permanent personality trait but a practice that can fail under strain. Dana’s interventions and the eventual home-care worker also show that caregiving is a family system, not a private test of one spouse’s devotion.
The book’s wider argument is that Alzheimer’s requires both biomedical discovery and a more humane care infrastructure. Its account of research emphasizes uncertainty, trial failures, and the promise of earlier detection, while its account of home life shows that safety, respite, and clinical guidance cannot wait for a breakthrough. The racial disparity section broadens the question further: research that excludes affected communities cannot reliably explain unequal outcomes or ensure treatments work for everyone.
Readers should treat the medical forecasts and statistics as a snapshot from the book’s 2016 publication, not as current clinical guidance. Some of the lifestyle claims are appropriately cautious, but the hope attached to diet, supplements, and new drugs can outpace evidence. The memoir is most useful when it distinguishes comfort from cure, and practical support from promises. Its central insight is not that love defeats Alzheimer’s. It is that love must change its methods: less expectation of remembered pasts, more attention to safety, dignity, and the life still available in the present.
Review Summary
Before I Forget is a poignant memoir about B. Smith's journey with early-onset Alzheimer's, co-written with her husband Dan Gasby. Readers praise the book's honesty, informative content, and helpful tips for caregivers. Many found it eye-opening, especially regarding the disease's impact on African Americans. The book combines personal experiences with medical facts and advocacy for more research. While most reviewers appreciated the candid account, some felt uncomfortable with Gasby's perspective. Overall, it's considered a valuable resource for those affected by Alzheimer's.
People Also Read
Glossary
joining the journey
meeting the person’s present realityA caregiving approach described in the book: instead of repeatedly insisting that a person with Alzheimer’s remember plans, events, or facts, the caregiver engages with the person’s present experience. For B. and Dan, this meant sharing activities and moments of connection without expecting her to retain what had happened before.
habilitation
reducing stress through adaptationAn approach to dementia care associated in the book with Joanne Koenig Coste. It asks caregivers to understand situations from the perspective of the person with Alzheimer’s and adapt routines and surroundings to reduce confusion. Examples include laying out clothes, simplifying the table, and using reassuring conversation rather than insisting on a fact the person cannot accept.
The A’s of Alzheimer’s
a symptom vocabularyA group of terms used in the book to describe common effects of Alzheimer’s: agitation, agnosia, amnesia, anomia, anxiety, apathy, aphasia, and apraxia. They refer to changes such as restlessness, difficulty recognizing things, memory loss, trouble retrieving names or speech, reduced motivation, and difficulty carrying out learned actions.
perseveration
repeating the same thoughtA behavior observed during B.’s medical assessment, in which she repeated the same description of her facial tingling several times. In the book, the term refers to repetition that can occur when Alzheimer’s affects memory and thinking. It differs from ordinary repetition because the person may not recognize that the information has already been shared.
Alzheimer’s in a Dish
a laboratory brain-cell modelA model developed by researchers Rudolph Tanzi and Doo Yeon Kim using human stem-cell-derived brain cells. In the book’s account, the cells developed amyloid plaques and tau tangles, allowing researchers to study aspects of Alzheimer’s and screen possible drugs more quickly than in animal models. The model was a research tool, not proof that a treatment would work in people.
A4 study
an early-prevention drug trialA clinical trial described in the book, led by researcher Reisa Sperling, to test an antibody drug in older adults with amyloid buildup but no cognitive symptoms. The study aimed to test whether treatment before noticeable impairment could affect the disease course. The book emphasizes the need for a substantial and diverse participant group.
Brain Registry
a volunteer research registryA registry described in the book as a way for adults to sign up as potential participants in brain research, including Alzheimer’s studies. It aimed to make recruitment faster than having each research team find volunteers separately. The book presents participation by both healthy volunteers and people with memory disorders as important to meaningful comparisons.
COAACH
a community Alzheimer’s centerThe Center for Outreach in Alzheimer’s, Aging, and Community Health, established at North Carolina A&T State University under Dr. Goldie Byrd. As described in the book, it connected people affected by Alzheimer’s and their caregivers with education, support, and community services, while helping address needs that were often not met during brief medical appointments.
FAQ
1. What is Before I Forget: Love, Hope, Help, and Acceptance in Our Fight Against Alzheimer's by B. Smith and Dan Gasby about?
- Personal journey with Alzheimer’s: The book is a memoir chronicling B. Smith’s experience with early-onset Alzheimer’s disease, told through her and her husband Dan Gasby’s perspectives.
- Caregiving and relationships: It explores the emotional, physical, and practical challenges faced by both patient and caregiver, offering an intimate look at how the disease affects marriage and family.
- Advocacy and education: The narrative raises awareness about Alzheimer’s, especially in the African American community, and combines personal stories with accessible explanations of the disease and its management.
- Resource for families: It serves as both a memoir and a practical guide, providing advice, hope, and support for others facing Alzheimer’s.
2. Why should I read Before I Forget by B. Smith and Dan Gasby?
- Unique firsthand perspective: The book offers a rare, candid account from a high-profile African American woman and her husband, breaking stigma and raising awareness.
- Comprehensive caregiving insights: Dan Gasby’s honest recounting of the caregiving journey provides practical advice and emotional support for families.
- Educational and inspirational: Readers gain a better understanding of Alzheimer’s stages, symptoms, and treatments, as well as inspiration from the couple’s resilience and love.
- Advocacy and call to action: The book encourages participation in research, early diagnosis, and community support, especially among African Americans.
3. What are the key takeaways from Before I Forget by B. Smith and Dan Gasby?
- Alzheimer’s is multifaceted: The disease impacts memory, behavior, relationships, and daily life, requiring both medical and emotional strategies for management.
- Caregiving is challenging but vital: The transition from spouse to caregiver is emotionally taxing, but support, patience, and self-care are essential.
- Awareness and research matter: The book highlights the need for increased research funding, clinical trial participation, and early intervention, especially in underserved communities.
- Hope and dignity endure: Despite the hardships, the importance of love, dignity, and living in the moment is emphasized throughout the journey.
4. What are the early signs and symptoms of Alzheimer’s described in Before I Forget by B. Smith?
- Memory lapses and confusion: B. Smith experienced short-term memory loss, misplacing items, and repeating questions, which gradually became more frequent.
- Emotional and behavioral changes: Mood swings, irritability, and withdrawal were early signs, straining relationships and daily routines.
- Cognitive and physical difficulties: Challenges with planning, organizing, and following through on tasks, as well as occasional disorientation and physical sensations, were noted.
- Subtle progression: The symptoms started subtly and increased over time, making early detection challenging.
5. How is Alzheimer’s diagnosed according to Before I Forget by B. Smith and Dan Gasby?
- Cognitive and memory testing: B. underwent tests like word recall and drawing a clock face, revealing short-term memory and spatial impairments.
- Advanced brain imaging: PET scans detected amyloid plaques, providing a definitive diagnosis and representing a breakthrough in living patient assessment.
- Medical evaluation: Other causes such as stroke were ruled out through MRI and specialist consultations.
- Emotional impact of diagnosis: The diagnosis was described as both devastating and a starting point for planning care and management.
6. What are the main stages and symptoms of Alzheimer’s as explained in Before I Forget by B. Smith?
- Three-stage and seven-stage models: The book details both models, from mild memory loss to severe dementia requiring full-time care.
- The “A’s” of Alzheimer’s: Eight key symptoms are highlighted: Amnesia, Agnosia, Aphasia, Apraxia, Anomia, Anxiety, Apathy, and Agitation.
- Progressive decline: Symptoms worsen over time, affecting memory, reasoning, coordination, communication, and independence.
- Care implications: Understanding the stages helps families anticipate care needs and emotional challenges.
7. What caregiving challenges and emotional experiences does Dan Gasby share in Before I Forget?
- Role transition: Dan describes shifting from husband to full-time caregiver, managing daily tasks, medications, and emotional support.
- Emotional rollercoaster: He candidly discusses frustration, anger, guilt, exhaustion, and the struggle to balance caregiving with personal needs.
- Communication struggles: Alzheimer’s impaired B.’s ability to converse, leading to silence or repetition, which was emotionally taxing for both.
- Need for support: The importance of seeking help, avoiding isolation, and accepting outside caregivers is emphasized.
8. What lifestyle and treatment approaches are recommended in Before I Forget by B. Smith and Dan Gasby?
- Mediterranean diet: A diet rich in omega-3s, fruits, vegetables, and lean proteins is advocated to support brain health and slow decline.
- Medications: Drugs like Aricept and Namenda are used to manage symptoms, along with antidepressants for mood stabilization, though they do not cure the disease.
- Exercise and social engagement: Physical activity and maintaining social connections are highlighted as crucial for cognitive and emotional well-being.
- Caution with alternative therapies: Supplements like ginkgo biloba are discussed, but the authors caution against unproven treatments.
9. How does Before I Forget by B. Smith address the impact of Alzheimer’s on African American communities?
- Higher prevalence: African Americans are up to twice as likely to develop Alzheimer’s, with significant rates in older age groups.
- Contributing factors: Genetics, higher rates of diabetes, hypertension, and cardiovascular disease increase risk in the black community.
- Stigma and delayed diagnosis: Cultural stigma and mistrust lead to delayed medical help and missed early intervention opportunities.
- Advocacy for research participation: The book urges more African Americans to join clinical trials to ensure effective treatments and advance understanding.
10. What are the best caregiving strategies and advice from Before I Forget by B. Smith and Dan Gasby?
- Patience and compassion: Caregivers are encouraged to respond with gentleness, recognizing that behaviors are disease-driven, not intentional.
- Medication management: Using pill dispensers and involving family members can help prevent medication errors.
- Avoiding burnout: Self-care, support groups, and accepting help are vital for sustaining caregiving ability.
- Communication and safety: Use simple questions, maintain dignity, and plan for safety measures like stopping driving and securing the home.
11. How does Before I Forget by B. Smith explain the science and research behind Alzheimer’s?
- Amyloid plaques and tau tangles: The book discusses these brain changes as central to Alzheimer’s pathology and diagnosis.
- Drug development challenges: It explains the high failure rate of drug trials and the complexity of finding effective treatments.
- Emerging research: PET imaging, gene studies (like APOE), and innovative trials such as the A4 study are highlighted as hopeful developments.
- Advocacy for participation: The authors encourage involvement in research and clinical trials to accelerate progress.
12. What is the significance of the “handbag” and “closet” metaphors in Before I Forget by B. Smith?
- Symbol of identity: B.’s gold-sequined handbag represents her sense of self and dignity, even as memory fades.
- Daily frustration: Misplacing the handbag and the growing mess in her closet illustrate the practical challenges of memory loss and organizational decline.
- Caregiver’s emotional toll: Dan describes the difficulty of searching for lost items and respecting B.’s privacy while managing the disorder.
- Metaphor for disease progression: The increasing weight of the handbag and the closet’s chaos symbolize the accumulating burden of Alzheimer’s on both B. and her loved ones.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.