Key Takeaways
Treat a child's feeling as the message beneath the behavior
Listen for the hidden worry. Ten-year-old Andy kept asking his father how many children were abandoned. The question sounded like curiosity about social statistics, but his real fear was that his own parents might leave him. Reassurance addressed the worry better than a lecture about abandonment. A kindergartner's blunt criticism of classmates' paintings carried a similar question: would she be safe if her own work was imperfect? The teacher answered that children could make imperfect pictures without getting into trouble.
Acknowledge before advising. Ginott's central move is to name the likely feeling: disappointment, embarrassment, anger, or fear. When a child is upset, advice and explanations often arrive before the child is ready to hear them. Recognizing the feeling does not mean agreeing with every belief or allowing every action. It tells the child that the experience has been heard.
What's powerful here is the shift from treating speech as a report to treating it as a bid for connection. Developmental research on co-regulation similarly emphasizes that a calm, attentive adult can help a child regain enough composure to think. The approach also resists a common parental reflex: correcting the facts before understanding why they matter. There is a limit, though. A parent can guess wrong about an unspoken fear. Tentative language and a genuine invitation to correct the guess keep empathy from becoming mind-reading.
Describe the effort and result, not the child's permanent worth
Make praise believable. Ginott argues that labels such as brilliant, perfect, or good can burden children with an identity they may not believe. A boy who secretly feels angry at his baby brother may find praise for being good especially jarring. In the car, six-year-old Ivan was praised for staying quiet, then promptly made a mess. He later explained that the praise clashed with his troubling thoughts about his brother.
Give evidence, not a verdict. When Julie cleaned a neglected yard, her mother described the work she had done and how much better the yard looked. Julie could take pride in the accomplishment herself. This is appreciative praise: specific recognition of effort or contribution, rather than a judgment of character. Ginott also warns that praising children as naturally gifted can make them avoid difficult tasks that might threaten that reputation.
This distinction anticipates a useful idea from motivation research: feedback can direct attention toward learning and effort, or toward protecting a flattering self-image. Specific, credible observations give a child information without demanding agreement with an adult's judgment. Still, the book's broad suspicion of praise needs qualification. Children can benefit from warm approval, especially when it is authentic and tied to meaningful behavior. The practical test is not whether a sentence contains a compliment, but whether it helps the child notice what they did and build their own realistic sense of capability.
Address the problem without turning a mistake into a character judgment
Trade accusation for useful information. When seven-year-old Nathaniel broke a cup, his father called him stupid and the argument escalated into insults, punishment, broken glass, and a frightened child running away. Ginott's alternative is to deal with the cup: remove it before it breaks, or calmly help clean up and explain that cups are not toys. The accident needs a response, not a verdict on the child.
Don't set traps. If a parent already knows a library book is overdue, asking whether the child returned it invites a defensive lie. State what is known and what needs to happen. The same approach applies to stealing: require the item to be returned or the money repaid, without branding the child a thief. Brief, factual guidance leaves more room for repair than interrogation, sarcasm, threats, or a sermon.
The book treats language as part of the consequence, not decoration around it. That insight connects with procedural justice: people are more likely to accept correction when they are treated with dignity and understand what action is required. Separating a harmful act from a child's identity also preserves the possibility of restitution. But a calm tone is not a substitute for follow-through. A parent still needs to set a clear expectation, protect anyone affected, and ensure the repair occurs. Kindness without accountability becomes vagueness; accountability without respect becomes humiliation.
Welcome every feeling, while firmly stopping harmful behavior
Separate emotion from action. Ginott's discipline approach accepts a child's wishes, fantasies, and feelings, including anger or jealousy, while placing limits on dangerous or destructive acts. When four-year-old Margaret wanted to cut a cat's tail to see inside, her father recognized her curiosity but stopped the act and offered a picture that could answer her question. The boundary was firm, but the child was not shamed for wondering.
Offer an acceptable outlet. A limit works best when it names both what is not allowed and what the child can do instead. A child may not throw dishes, but can throw a pillow. The book distinguishes behavior that is encouraged, behavior temporarily tolerated during hard times or learning, and behavior that must be stopped. Punishment often adds rage and revenge; a clear limit and a safe alternative teach control without treating the child as bad.
This is a useful bridge between emotional acceptance and behavioral accountability. In contemporary terms, it resembles the combination of validation and structure found in effective caregiving: the feeling is real, and the boundary is real too. The distinction can reduce shame without making safety negotiable. It also places a demanding task on the adult, who must stay steady when a child's emotion is intense. The method should not be mistaken for passivity. Immediate physical intervention may be necessary when someone is at risk, with explanation and emotional support following once the danger has passed.
Name your anger without using it to attack the child
Make anger informative. Ginott rejects the impossible goal of never feeling angry. Instead, parents can identify the feeling, state it plainly, and explain what behavior or situation caused it. A mother whose daughter could not find a baseball shirt said she was angry that several shirts had been lost and that clothes needed to be kept in the dresser. She did not call her daughter careless or revive a list of past failures. The girl went to look for the missing shirts.
Keep the message congruent. Pretending to feel loving while shouting angrily confuses a child. The parent can be honest about being upset without threatening abandonment or attacking character. Ginott's sequence moves from naming annoyance, to stating stronger anger if necessary, to explaining the specific cause and desired change. The point is not to unleash fury, but to express it clearly enough that it does not build into an explosion.
This distinction resembles emotional regulation models that treat emotion as information rather than an order to act. Naming anger can create a pause, while a specific request makes the conflict more solvable. The approach also models that anger can coexist with care and does not have to become aggression. Its risk is that even an accurately worded declaration can sound threatening when delivered with contempt, volume, or a history of intimidation. Tone, timing, and repair matter as much as the sentence. Adults remain responsible for preventing their anger from becoming frightening or unsafe.
Let children practice responsibility through decisions they can own
Give autonomy in manageable doses. Ginott distinguishes between a child's voice and a child's choice. Parents retain decisions that concern a child's welfare, but can listen seriously to the child's view. Where the decision belongs to the child, parents can offer a bounded choice, such as selecting between suitable breakfasts or deciding which acceptable coat to wear. The adult sets the options; the child gets meaningful control.
Let consequences teach. Sixteen-year-old Phil forgot a permission slip and missed the class bus for a ski trip. Rather than drive him all the way there, his mother acknowledged his disappointment and let him consider alternatives. He found a bus route himself. The book applies the same principle to homework, allowances, and chores: children need experience making decisions, not only practice following orders. Responsibility is meant to grow from judgment and values, not from compliance alone.
The distinction between voice and choice is especially useful because autonomy is not all-or-nothing. Developmental science supports offering children increasing control as their skills mature, while maintaining adult responsibility for safety and essential care. The bus story shows how sympathy can coexist with not rescuing a child from every consequence. Yet the boundaries must fit the child's actual capacity and circumstances. A choice is not empowering if every option is unacceptable, and leaving a child alone with a problem they cannot manage is not autonomy. Good scaffolding gradually transfers real responsibility.
Give each sibling individual attention instead of measuring equal shares
Expect rivalry rather than demanding gratitude. Ginott treats a new baby as a genuine disruption to a child's secure place in the family. Promising that an older child will love the baby or gain a built-in playmate can deny the child's likely worry. One mother instead prepared her five-year-old for the baby bringing both enjoyable moments and extra work, and invited her to talk about jealousy or feeling left out.
Protect the baby and hear the older child. When Jordan said he wanted the baby gone, his mother acknowledged his anger and fear, reassured him of their lasting relationship, and offered extra affection. When he later handled the baby roughly, she stopped him and redirected his anger toward a doll or drawing. Ginott argues that siblings need to feel loved in a particular relationship, not receive identical gifts, privileges, or amounts of attention.
The book's strongest contribution here is its refusal to confuse fairness with sameness. Family members have different needs, ages, and relationships, and children can often recognize that distinction when it is explained without defensiveness. One-on-one attention may also reduce the sense that affection is a scarce resource. At the same time, parental claims of loving each child uniquely should not excuse entrenched favoritism. The practical question is whether each child experiences reliable care, respect, and access to a parent's attention, even when the form of that care differs.
Prepare children honestly for separation, grief, and other frightening changes
Make an approaching separation imaginable. When a mother needed surgery, three-year-old Yvette's family used dolls to act out the hospital stay, the mother's absence, and her return. They also introduced the new caregiver and left familiar recordings and photographs. The play gave the child a way to rehearse the change instead of facing a sudden disappearance with no explanation. Ginott similarly warns against threats that a parent will leave a child behind.
Tell the truth about loss. Children should be allowed to grieve a death rather than be distracted with a quick replacement or confusing euphemisms. Parents can name the loss, acknowledge the child's feelings, and answer questions simply and honestly. The book's broader point is not that preparation removes fear or sorrow. It gives a child a trusted adult with whom those feelings can be understood.
The use of play as preparation is a compelling example of translating an adult explanation into a child's medium. Rehearsal can make an uncertain event more predictable, while honest language supports trust when reality is painful. This matters especially because children may fill silence with self-blame or frightening explanations. The advice should remain responsive to age, culture, and the family's beliefs about death. Truthfulness does not require bluntness or exhaustive detail. The goal is enough accurate information to orient the child, with space for repeated questions and changing understanding.
Make questions about sex safe to ask before adolescents stop asking
Trust is the precondition for useful guidance. The book describes parents who shut down questions about sex with suspicion or moralizing, teaching children that some truths are unwelcome. It cites a 2000 report in which half the mothers of sexually active teenagers believed their children were virgins. Ginott argues that accurate information and family values both matter, but that values are best conveyed through a relationship where young people can speak honestly.
Answer the question actually asked. With younger children, use correct names for body parts and give brief, factual explanations that fit the child's curiosity. With teenagers, discuss responsibility, honesty, respect for one's own wishes, and the difference between sex and mature love. A father hearing his son describe a new girlfriend did not launch into a lecture; he stayed engaged and asked him to consider the other person's feelings.
The book's emphasis on openness remains important: silence does not prevent adolescent sexuality, but can make trusted guidance harder to access. Communication also depends on whether parents can tolerate hearing information that unsettles them. Modern readers may notice that the chapter gives less explicit attention to consent, contraception, sexual health, and diverse identities than a current guide should. That gap does not undermine its central insight. A caring relationship is the channel through which concrete, contemporary safety information can be discussed rather than avoided.
Redesign daily routines so cooperation does not depend on nagging
Remove avoidable points of friction. An eight-year-old who fought every morning about getting up was given an alarm clock and control over waking herself. Ginott also recommends giving children realistic time cues instead of repeatedly ordering them to hurry, and welcoming them home with empathy rather than a quiz they are too tired to answer. Small changes can prevent ordinary routines from becoming daily contests over authority.
Choose where adult attention goes. Bedtime can include a quiet conversation, while a defined bedtime range gives an older child some choice. Parents can also establish limits on television rather than relying on the screen as the default activity. The larger principle is to arrange the day with predictable expectations, room for children's preferences, and protected moments of connection, instead of turning every transition into a lecture.
Routines are a form of environmental design: a clock, a clear deadline, or a predictable bedtime can do work that repeated verbal reminders cannot. This connects the book's relationship-centered advice to behavioral approaches that reduce friction before conflict begins. Its treatment of television reflects concerns of its era, so its specific media assumptions should not be applied mechanically to present-day devices. The durable question is how family time is being used, and whether the routine supports sleep, conversation, play, and focused activity rather than default consumption.
Analysis
Between Parent and Child is a practical psychology book built from brief family scenes rather than a single linear argument. Its governing claim is that parenting skill lives in the small exchange: the response to a spilled drink, a complaint about school, a broken rule, or a child's uncomfortable question. Ginott repeatedly asks adults to notice the difference between the child's observable act and the emotional experience underneath it. He then pairs that recognition with concrete language, clear limits, and increasing opportunities for children to make decisions.
The book's most useful tension is its insistence on both acceptance and authority. Feelings are not misconduct; actions can still require firm limits. Parents are encouraged to acknowledge anger without endorsing aggression, to listen without surrendering every decision, and to guide without making a child's character the target. This is more demanding than permissiveness because it asks the adult to regulate their own response while remaining responsible for safety and standards.
Its strongest practical insight is that respect is communicated procedurally. Children learn not only from what parents intend to teach, but from how correction feels: whether the adult listens, humiliates, explains, or gives a route to repair. The clinical anecdotes make this distinction memorable, although they illustrate principles rather than prove them experimentally. Some of the book's confident explanations of behavior, including links between jealousy and physical symptoms, should therefore be read as therapeutic interpretations, not universal diagnoses.
The book also reflects its period. Its advice about sex, media, and family roles needs updating, and its preference for concise empathy can sound formulaic if applied without genuine attention. A script cannot substitute for curiosity. The larger method remains valuable when treated as a discipline of noticing: identify the feeling, state the limit or problem plainly, and preserve the child's dignity while guiding what happens next. That combination offers parents a usable alternative to both punitive control and anxious over-permissiveness.
Review Summary
Between Parent and Child receives high praise from readers for its practical advice on communicating with children. Many find it life-changing, offering valuable insights into understanding children's emotions and responding effectively. The book's emphasis on empathy, respect, and avoiding criticism resonates with parents. While some note dated elements, most appreciate its timeless wisdom. Readers highlight its applicability beyond parenting, improving communication in all relationships. Some disagree with certain values presented, but overall, it's widely recommended as an essential parenting resource.
People Also Read
Glossary
Emotional first aid
Comfort after emotional injuryA parent's immediate response to a child's hurt, embarrassment, fear, or anger. Rather than dismissing the experience, defending another person, or rushing into advice, the parent names and acknowledges the child's likely feelings. The aim is to help the child feel understood and regain the steadiness needed to cope.
Emotional mirror
Reflection of a child's feelingsA way of helping children recognize their emotions by describing them without judgment or distortion. The adult reflects what the child may be feeling, much as a mirror shows an image. The reflection is not a diagnosis or a command to feel differently, but an invitation to understand and express the feeling.
Appreciative praise
Specific recognition of effortRecognition focused on a child's actions, effort, contribution, or accomplishment, rather than a broad evaluation of personality. By describing what the child did and its effect, the parent gives concrete information from which the child can draw a realistic conclusion about their own abilities. It differs from labels such as good, brilliant, or perfect.
Voice and choice
Participation with age-appropriate controlA distinction between letting children express views on decisions that affect them and allowing them to decide matters that fall within their responsibility. Parents may retain the final decision on health or safety while taking the child's perspective seriously. Where a decision properly belongs to the child, bounded choices let the child practice judgment.
grant in fantasy
Acknowledge an unfulfilled wishA way to say no while showing that the child's desire has been understood. The parent imagines with the child what it would be like to have the requested object or permission, while remaining clear that it cannot be provided in reality. The technique softens rejection without changing the boundary.
Congruent communication
Words match genuine feelingsCommunication in which a parent's words honestly reflect their emotional state without using emotion to insult or shame the child. A parent can say they are angry and identify the behavior that caused it, rather than pretending to feel calm or loving. The child hears a clear message without being labeled as a bad person.
Three zones of discipline
A map of permitted behaviorA way of sorting behavior into three categories: actions adults actively encourage, actions they tolerate temporarily because of learning or difficult circumstances, and actions that must be stopped. The categories help parents make expectations clearer and distinguish ordinary mistakes from conduct that threatens safety, welfare, or important rules.
FAQ
What's "Between Parent and Child" about?
- Parent-Child Communication: The book focuses on improving communication between parents and children, emphasizing understanding and empathy.
- Emotional Intelligence: It teaches parents how to help their children develop emotional intelligence by acknowledging and validating their feelings.
- Practical Guidance: The book provides practical advice and techniques for handling everyday parenting challenges without resorting to punishment.
- Revolutionary Approach: Written by Haim G. Ginott, it revolutionized the way parents and teachers relate to children, promoting a compassionate and respectful approach.
Why should I read "Between Parent and Child"?
- Improved Relationships: Reading this book can help you build stronger, more respectful relationships with your children.
- Effective Communication: It offers tools to communicate effectively, reducing conflicts and misunderstandings.
- Emotional Growth: The book supports the emotional growth of both parents and children by fostering empathy and understanding.
- Timeless Advice: Despite being written decades ago, its principles remain relevant and applicable to modern parenting challenges.
What are the key takeaways of "Between Parent and Child"?
- Empathy is Key: Understanding and acknowledging children's feelings is crucial for effective communication.
- Avoid Punishment: The book advocates for finding alternatives to punishment, focusing on guidance and understanding.
- Respectful Language: Using language that respects children's feelings and experiences fosters trust and cooperation.
- Parental Self-Awareness: Parents should be aware of their own emotions and reactions to better guide their children.
How does "Between Parent and Child" suggest handling misbehavior?
- Identify Feelings: Recognize and address the feelings behind the misbehavior rather than the behavior itself.
- Set Clear Limits: Establish clear, consistent limits while allowing children to express their emotions.
- Offer Choices: Provide children with choices to empower them and reduce resistance.
- Use Guidance, Not Criticism: Focus on guiding children towards better behavior rather than criticizing them.
What are the best quotes from "Between Parent and Child" and what do they mean?
- "Words are like knives": This quote emphasizes the power of words to either harm or heal, urging parents to use language carefully.
- "Don't be a parent, be a human being who is a parent": It suggests that parents should relate to their children as fellow human beings, not just authority figures.
- "The beginning of wisdom is listening": Highlights the importance of truly listening to children to understand their needs and feelings.
- "Love is not enough. Insight is insufficient. Good parents need skill": Stresses that effective parenting requires more than love and understanding; it requires practical skills.
How does "Between Parent and Child" address sibling rivalry?
- Acknowledge Jealousy: Recognize and validate feelings of jealousy between siblings without judgment.
- Avoid Comparisons: Refrain from comparing siblings, which can exacerbate rivalry and resentment.
- Unique Love: Emphasize that each child is loved uniquely, not equally, to foster individual self-worth.
- Encourage Expression: Allow children to express their feelings about siblings openly and safely.
What is the "language of caring" in "Between Parent and Child"?
- Empathetic Responses: Use language that acknowledges and validates children's feelings and experiences.
- Non-Judgmental Communication: Avoid evaluative or judgmental language that can harm a child's self-esteem.
- Descriptive Praise: Focus on describing specific actions and efforts rather than labeling the child's character.
- Respectful Dialogue: Engage in conversations that respect the child's perspective and encourage open communication.
How does "Between Parent and Child" suggest dealing with children's anxiety?
- Preparation for Separation: Prepare children for separations to reduce anxiety about abandonment.
- Acknowledge Fears: Validate children's fears and provide reassurance without dismissing their feelings.
- Create Safe Spaces: Encourage children to express their anxieties in a safe and supportive environment.
- Model Calmness: Demonstrate calmness and confidence to help children feel secure and less anxious.
What role does empathy play in "Between Parent and Child"?
- Foundation of Communication: Empathy is the foundation for effective communication and understanding between parents and children.
- Emotional Connection: It helps parents connect with their children's emotions, fostering trust and openness.
- Conflict Resolution: Empathy allows parents to address the root causes of conflicts and misbehavior.
- Modeling Behavior: By showing empathy, parents model compassionate behavior for their children to emulate.
How does "Between Parent and Child" address discipline?
- Permissive of Feelings: Allow children to express all feelings, even negative ones, without judgment.
- Strict with Behavior: Set clear boundaries for behavior while understanding the emotions behind actions.
- Non-Punitive Approach: Focus on guidance and natural consequences rather than punishment.
- Empowerment Through Choice: Give children choices to encourage responsibility and reduce defiance.
What are some practical techniques from "Between Parent and Child"?
- Mirroring Emotions: Reflect children's feelings back to them to show understanding and empathy.
- Granting in Fantasy: Acknowledge children's desires in fantasy when you can't fulfill them in reality.
- Brief Statements: Use concise, clear statements to set limits and expectations without lengthy explanations.
- Written Communication: Use notes or letters to communicate appreciation and understanding, especially when verbal communication is challenging.
How does "Between Parent and Child" suggest handling children's questions about sex?
- Age-Appropriate Answers: Provide simple, factual answers that match the child's developmental level.
- Encourage Curiosity: Allow children to ask questions and explore their curiosity without shame.
- Avoid Over-Explanation: Answer only what is asked, avoiding overwhelming the child with too much information.
- Model Comfort: Demonstrate comfort and openness when discussing sexual topics to encourage healthy attitudes.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.