Plot Summary
The Bobblehead Bargain
Aubrey Bloom is leaving Chicago for a new law job in Temecula, carrying nearly her whole life in a packed BMW and trying to escape a relationship that has soured. At a Nebraska rest stop, she breaks a souvenir bobblehead and meets Chance Bateman, an Australian-accented former soccer player whose Harley has stopped running.
Their teasing turns practical when Chance spots her flat tire. He replaces it, but only after Aubrey agrees to drive him toward California while his motorcycle is repaired. Chance quietly buys her an intact bobblehead, then sticks it to her dashboard. By the time he tells her his name, Aubrey has already accepted a ride with a stranger she finds both infuriating and hard to ignore.
The bargain makes attraction inseparable from dependence. Aubrey has chosen a move that is supposed to restore her control, yet the flat tire forces her to rely on someone she cannot categorize or manage. Chance’s teasing tests her defenses, while his replacement bobblehead complicates her first judgment of him: he is not simply the cocky man he performs. The object becomes a small record of attention, a gift she did not ask for and cannot easily dismiss. Their journey begins not with a declaration of trust but with a practical exchange that makes trust possible.
A Goat in the Road
Chance soon answers Aubrey’s persistent calls from Harrison, her former partner at a Chicago law firm. His blunt handling of the caller angers her, but their argument draws out the truth: Harrison cheated, and Aubrey left both him and the career path her father had chosen for her. At breakfast she admits she feels lost and has always loved animals.
Chance shares little about his own past, then embarrasses her by finding the vibrator packed among her belongings. As she reaches for it, the BMW swerves toward a small goat in the road. They have not struck it, but it faints repeatedly and wanders into obstacles. Aubrey refuses to leave it behind, so their westward drive turns toward an animal hospital.
Aubrey’s confession connects the move to more than romantic escape. She is trying to distinguish her own wants from the ambitions inherited from her father and reinforced by Harrison. Chance recognizes her appetite for a different life before she can name it herself, though his teasing often makes insight feel like an ambush. The goat’s appearance converts that private longing into a decision with consequences: Aubrey insists on stopping, and Chance must either share responsibility or leave her behind. Her care is not an abstract virtue. It changes the route, the pace, and the shape of their companionship.
The Goat Takes Their Tent
A veterinarian identifies the goat as blind and prone to fainting when frightened, not injured by Aubrey’s car. With no reliable refuge available, Aubrey and Chance take him along. They buy camping supplies, squeeze the animal into the already crowded BMW, and share a tent with a divider between their sleeping areas.
Chance explains that he once played professional soccer in Australia, but tore his ACL in his first game and could not return to the sport. He now makes art from discarded materials and lives on royalties. The goat repeatedly startles and faints, turning the campsite into comic chaos, while Aubrey and Chance grow more at ease with each other. Their road trip now includes a creature neither can abandon.
The goat gives the pair a shared obligation before they have agreed on what they mean to each other. Caring for an animal that cannot see danger coming literalizes the vulnerability both adults conceal: Aubrey fears choosing badly, and Chance has lost the future that once organized his life. His soccer story replaces the public image of a handsome former athlete with the private experience of a career ended almost at its beginning. The tent’s divider preserves a boundary, but their close quarters expose how little either can control the intimacy building between them.
The Canyon's Confessions
At the Grand Canyon, Aubrey talks about her late father, her distant relationship with her mother, and uncertainty about what would make her life fulfilling. Chance explains that he returned to California because his younger sister Adele was in serious trouble after becoming involved with a drug dealer.
He also describes losing his father and admits that his former fiancée, model Piper Ramsey, left him for a teammate after his soccer injury derailed his career. The disclosures bring them closer, but their intimacy is uneven: after the goat soils the car and Chance disappears for hours to find dinner, Aubrey fears he has abandoned her. He returns to comfort her, then later sends her back to her own room when she seeks him out.
The canyon invites each character to imagine a future while making their pasts newly visible. Aubrey’s uncertainty is not simply indecision; she has spent years fulfilling other people’s plans. Chance’s family loyalty, meanwhile, competes with the desire he is beginning to feel for her. His account of Piper explains why attention and attraction are not enough to make him feel safe. The evening’s missed call and rejected advance expose their central mismatch: Aubrey reads distance as the start of abandonment, while Chance uses distance to contain a situation he believes he cannot offer her.
Elvis Marries Them
Aubrey and Chance detour to Las Vegas, where their teasing resumes in a strip club, at a couples massage, and beside the hotel pool. Jealousy breaks through their jokes when Chance watches a male masseur work on Aubrey, while Aubrey discovers how much she enjoys pushing his composure. After dinner and too much wine, Chance persuades her to join him in a quick chapel wedding.
The ceremony is fake, complete with borrowed clothes, souvenir rings, and an Elvis impersonator, but Chance gives personal vows that move Aubrey to tears. When the officiant reaches the kiss, Aubrey hesitates. Chance kisses her anyway, and the intensity leaves both of them shaken. Their joke has given them a public image of commitment neither can dismiss afterward.
The fake wedding lets the couple approach commitment under cover of comedy. Because the ceremony is legally meaningless, Aubrey can accept its intimacy without having to choose a future; Chance can say what he feels while pretending the occasion is a performance. Yet his vows are more revealing than the ritual requires, and the kiss collapses the distance between play and desire. The scene shows how humor functions as both permission and protection. They can risk emotional exposure only when they have an exit available, even as the ceremony makes that exit feel less convincing.
The Morning After
Back at the hotel, Aubrey pushes past Chance’s repeated warnings and the two finally sleep together. Their night feels like the beginning of something lasting, but Chance leaves before she wakes. Aubrey waits six hours in the lobby, then drives on with the goat and reaches Temecula alone.
She spends the next months grieving, trades in the BMW because its memories of Chance make driving painful, and struggles to let a kind client, Jeremy Longthorpe, get close. When a Popeyes meal brings back the road trip, she tells Jeremy what happened and agrees to go out with him as a friend. The new life she had hoped to build has begun, but Chance’s disappearance remains its most painful unfinished fact.
The departure turns the same intimacy that felt liberating into evidence Aubrey cannot interpret. Chance’s silence deprives her of the information needed to distinguish rejection from sacrifice, so she fills the gap by blaming herself and rehearsing alternate choices. Her grief attaches to ordinary objects and routines: the car, a familiar meal, the dashboard keepsake. Jeremy offers patience rather than a cure, and Aubrey’s willingness to see him marks a modest return to agency. She does not stop caring about Chance; she chooses not to let that attachment be the only possible future.
Two Years Behind Bars
Two weeks after leaving Aubrey, Chance goes after Darius Marshall, the drug dealer dating Adele, who had been raped and threatened by another dealer. Chance beats Darius until he gives up the attacker’s location; the information helps police arrest the man, but Chance accepts a felony battery conviction and a two-year sentence rather than deny what he did.
In prison he takes classes and organizes soccer for juvenile inmates, trying to make the time count. His mother dies while he is incarcerated, and he cannot say goodbye. On release, Chance debates whether to look for Aubrey. He had left her without explanation because he believed she deserved not to spend two years waiting for a man who might emerge from prison changed.
Chance’s choice is protective and self-punishing at once. He acts from loyalty to Adele, but his account of the assault makes clear that rage, not a measured plan, takes control. Accepting the sentence allows him to protect his sister without pretending the violence was lawful. The prison years then exact a cost he could not anticipate: he loses his mother and must rebuild a life outside the structure of confinement. His decision not to contact Aubrey repeats the logic of the earlier abandonment. He calls it a sacrifice, but also uses it to avoid asking whether she might choose him despite the risk.
The Coffee Shop Collision
After release, Chance searches online for Aubrey and drives to Temecula. He sees her with Richard Kline, a fellow lawyer and her boyfriend, then spends days watching her routines instead of approaching her. When Aubrey unexpectedly returns to Starbucks and learns Chance has been buying her coffee, she turns and finds him nearby.
She knocks over a display in shock and refuses to hear him out. Chance follows her into the office elevator and stops it, insisting she let him explain. Aubrey tells him that the disappearance took years to recover from and demands that he leave. He releases the elevator and gives her his motel details, promising he will go if she still wants him gone after hearing the truth.
Chance’s return begins with a troubling contradiction: he wants to repair the harm, yet his surveillance and the stopped elevator repeat the very loss of control that hurt Aubrey. His persistence is not automatically proof of devotion; it makes her feel cornered before she has any reason to trust him. Aubrey’s anger, in turn, is grounded in labor she has already done to rebuild her life. The scene refuses to treat reunion as a reward for longing. Chance must move from wanting access to accepting that Aubrey controls whether he gets it.
The Truth in Her Office
Aubrey agrees to a brief meeting at her law office, where Chance explains Adele’s assault, his attack on Darius, and the prison sentence that kept him away. He apologizes for leaving without a word. Aubrey accepts that he had a reason, but says she is with Richard and needs time. Chance then follows Richard, expecting to find a drug deal, and instead discovers him volunteering at a soup kitchen.
Rather than use the discovery against him, Chance joins Aubrey’s animal shelter as a dog walker. His repeated coffee deliveries and gardening help eventually earn him a key to her house. Aubrey meets him for walks and meals, though she still avoids telling Richard about their renewed contact.
The explanation repairs a factual misunderstanding without erasing the injury. Aubrey learns why Chance left, but the knowledge cannot return the two years she spent believing he chose to discard her. Richard’s unexpected generosity prevents Chance from simplifying the love triangle into a contest against a villain. By volunteering at the shelter, Chance begins to participate in a life Aubrey has built rather than merely demand that she return to his. The key she gives him is practical, but its meaning is relational: access is being granted in increments, not seized through persistence.
A Ride Without Answers
Chance and Aubrey fall into cautious routines: breakfast, animal-shelter dog walks, and a dinner at her bungalow that ends when Richard arrives and Aubrey asks Chance to leave through the back. Soon afterward, Chance takes Aubrey on his Harley to Julian for apple pie. She enjoys the ride and accepts a bracelet he buys her, but Chance admits he wants more than friendship and refuses to pretend otherwise.
Aubrey says she cannot keep him waiting indefinitely, yet she does not choose him. Chance decides to give her space. When he later finds her at home, he declares that he loves her. Aubrey reveals Richard has been offered a Boston job and wants her to move with him, putting a deadline on her decision.
The motorcycle ride gives Aubrey a way to experience closeness without deciding what it means. She trusts Chance with her physical safety and responds to his gift, but trust in the moment is not the same as trust in a future. His declaration of love and her news about Boston make the conflict concrete: she must choose between a stable relationship and a man whose earlier disappearance still governs her expectations. Chance’s decision to give space shows a shift from pursuit toward restraint, though the deadline makes restraint difficult to sustain.
Hermosa's Empty Morning
Chance pretends to be his own twin, Harry, when Richard visits Aubrey’s house, buying time before she agrees to spend a weekend in Hermosa Beach. She meets Chance’s sister Adele, sees his recycled-material sculptures, and shares a day at the beach.
Chance promises not to touch her sexually; Aubrey later breaks the distance by touching herself while he watches, then leaves before morning with the goat and a note saying she cannot keep crossing the line while still with Richard. Chance returns to Temecula after giving her space, but finds her house empty and hears from a neighbor that she is moving to Boston. Believing she chose Richard, he goes home to Hermosa and refuses Carla’s offer of comfort.
The weekend grants the couple a glimpse of ordinary life, but it also shows that desire can outrun Aubrey’s ethical commitments without resolving them. Her departure is not a rejection of Chance so much as an attempt to stop living between two relationships. Chance misreads the empty house because he has learned to expect abandonment and because he still receives crucial information secondhand. His refusal of Carla confirms that his attachment is not merely sexual, but it also leaves him isolated with a conclusion he has not checked.
The Goat Finds Him
Aubrey appears on the beach near Chance’s home with the goat and her packed car. She explains that she did not go to Boston: she quit her job, ended her relationship with Richard, and came to Hermosa because she wants a life with Chance. Her fear has not vanished, but she no longer wants it to make the decision for her.
Chance welcomes her, and their reunion turns the road trip’s old longing into a mutual choice. They begin again together, with the goat in tow. Aubrey plans to find work connected to her love of animals, while Chance offers to support her as she changes direction. The couple’s future is no longer a fantasy spoken in a fake chapel; it is a life they are choosing to build.
The reunion depends on Aubrey acting, not on Chance persuading her. She resolves the relationship with Richard before arriving, so the new beginning is not founded on secrecy or a borrowed promise. Her move also completes the search that began when she left Chicago: she is no longer choosing a career simply because it is available or approved by someone else. Chance’s welcome matters, but the decisive change is hers. The goat, present from their first shared detour, makes their reunion feel like the return of a small, unruly household rather than a reset to the moment they met.
Epilogue
A year later, Aubrey and Chance return to the Las Vegas chapel where their first wedding was a joke. This time they bring a marriage license, Adele and her partner as witnesses, and the goat as their unofficial best man. Aubrey gives vows of her own, describing how Chance changed her sense of what a life could hold.
They exchange real rings and leave for a honeymoon with the old bobblehead on the dashboard. Aubrey explains that she once let the keepsake go while trying to erase reminders of Chance, then bought it back when it resurfaced. Now pregnant with their son, she and Chance treat the recovered bobblehead as a reminder that their second beginning was built from the first.
The return to the chapel converts the couple’s earlier performance into a chosen commitment. Their first ceremony allowed them to express desire while denying its consequences; the second asks them to stand inside those consequences openly. Aubrey’s recovered bobblehead carries the same double meaning. It is an object she once surrendered to survive heartbreak, then reclaimed without knowing whether Chance would return. The pregnancy points forward, but the scene does not make fate do all the work: the couple reaches this future through separation, explanation, and renewed choice. The old symbol matters because they have changed what it can mean.
Analysis
The novel makes miscommunication consequential rather than decorative. Chance’s first disappearance is not caused by a lack of feeling, but his decision to conceal the reason still produces the same experience Aubrey would have had if he had simply abandoned her. His protective logic substitutes his judgment for hers, while her effort to recover from that injury makes a later explanation necessary but not sufficient. The romance therefore treats trust as a practice, not a revelation: Chance must disclose what happened, respect Aubrey’s existing relationship, and show up in the ordinary work of her life.
The road-trip comedy keeps that work embodied. A flat tire, a broken souvenir, a goat with a startling condition, and the indignities of camping repeatedly force the characters to respond to immediate needs. Aubrey’s care for the goat is also an early version of the life she wants, one oriented toward animals rather than inherited professional expectations. Chance’s lost soccer career similarly complicates his public image. His humor is not proof that he has healed; it is a tool that lets him approach pain without naming it until someone earns the truth.
The story’s romantic triangle avoids making Richard a simple antagonist. His kindness and service work mean Aubrey’s choice cannot be solved by discovering that her current partner is secretly unworthy. She must decide which future is genuinely hers, while Chance must accept that wanting her does not give him a claim on her. Their eventual reunion becomes credible because Aubrey ends one relationship before beginning another and because Chance’s persistence gradually makes room for her judgment.
Objects hold emotional memory across the time jump. The bobblehead, fake ring, house key, motorcycle, and goat each record a different degree of access between the couple. None can substitute for speech or repair, but each gains meaning when the characters act differently than before. The ending’s real wedding does not erase the years of separation. It makes the earlier promise truthful by showing that both people have chosen it with knowledge of its costs.
Review Summary
Cocky Bastard received mostly positive reviews, with readers praising its humor, chemistry between characters, and unexpected plot twists. Many enjoyed the road trip storyline and found the main characters, Chance and Aubrey, endearing. The book's dual-perspective narration was appreciated, though some readers found the second half less engaging. While the majority loved Chance's character development and persistence, a few critics felt uncomfortable with certain plot elements. Overall, the book was praised for its entertaining blend of romance, comedy, and emotion.
People Also Read
Characters
Aubrey Bloom
The guarded animal loverAubrey is a Chicago-trained patent lawyer whose carefully ordered life has begun to feel borrowed from her father’s expectations and her former partner’s ambitions. She is intelligent, observant, and slow to voice anger; when hurt, she tends to retreat into analysis and self-blame rather than ask directly for what she needs. Her love of animals gives her a more instinctive language for care, as her insistence on helping the frightened goat shows. Beneath her restraint is a playful, curious woman who responds to humor, food, travel, and physical affection. Her central tension is between wanting security and wanting a life chosen for herself, a conflict that shapes both her career questions and her romantic decisions.
Chance Bateman
The irreverent protectorChance is an Australian-raised former professional soccer player whose career ended after a severe knee injury in his first game. He masks disappointment and emotional fear with sexual jokes, teasing, and a confidence that can look like arrogance. Under that performance, he is loyal to his family, especially his younger sister, and capable of patient practical care, whether repairing Aubrey’s tire or making room for an abandoned animal. Chance often believes he is protecting people by deciding what they can bear, a habit that causes real harm even when his motives are loving. His attraction to Aubrey unsettles his usual ease because it asks him to be honest, vulnerable, and accountable rather than merely charming.
Pixy
The fainting goatPixy is a blind goat with a condition that makes his muscles briefly stiffen when he is frightened. His sudden collapses first turn a roadside mishap into a shared responsibility, then make him a familiar presence in Aubrey and Chance’s changing relationship. He is affectionate, stubborn, and far more capable of choosing his companions than either human initially expects. Pixy’s care also reflects Aubrey’s instinct to protect those who cannot easily protect themselves, while Chance’s growing attachment reveals a gentler side beneath his swagger.
Adele Bateman
Chance's resilient sisterAdele is Chance’s younger sister and one of the people he most fiercely wants to protect. Her difficult past has left the family carrying fear and guilt, but she works toward an independent life rather than remaining defined by what happened to her. Chance’s loyalty sometimes becomes overprotective, and Adele’s recovery forces him to recognize that love cannot erase another person’s agency. She is perceptive about his feelings and willing to challenge the choices he makes in the name of protecting Aubrey.
Richard Kline
The principled boyfriendRichard is a partner at Aubrey’s law firm and her boyfriend when Chance returns to Temecula. Careful, dependable, and invested in community work, he offers a form of steadiness that matters to Aubrey after a painful period. He encourages her involvement with the animal shelter and appears in her professional life as a colleague as well as a romantic partner. Richard is not simply an obstacle to Chance: his good qualities make Aubrey’s choices more complicated and prevent the story from reducing her decision to choosing between a good person and a bad one.
Jeremy Longthorpe
The patient new friendJeremy is a technology-company executive and one of Aubrey’s clients in Temecula. He is thoughtful, attentive, and direct about liking her, but does not pressure her to move faster than she is ready to. When Aubrey tells him about Chance, Jeremy listens without judgment and offers friendship rather than demanding immediate intimacy. His steadiness gives Aubrey a chance to experience care that is not built around pursuit or emotional games.
Harrison
The Chicago ex-partnerHarrison is a senior lawyer at the Chicago firm where Aubrey worked and her former romantic partner. Their relationship entangles professional advancement with personal loyalty, making her decision to leave both feel especially consequential. His repeated attempts to contact her keep the past present during the road trip, even when Aubrey would rather move on.
Piper Ramsey
Chance's former fiancéePiper is a model associated with Chance’s brief years in professional soccer and the public attention that followed his injury. Her history with him helps explain why he distrusts relationships built around image and excitement. She belongs to the life Chance left behind in Australia and remains a sore point he discusses reluctantly.
Carla
The candid bartenderCarla is the bartender at the Temecula bar where Chance goes to drink and talk through his return to Aubrey’s life. With a sharp tongue and a generous streak, she recognizes when he is disguising fear as patience. She offers blunt advice, challenges his assumptions, and treats him as a friend even when she wants something more from him.
Harry Beecham
Adele's accountant boyfriendHarry is Adele’s boyfriend, an accountant Chance first meets unexpectedly at home. His ordinary, slightly awkward presence surprises Chance, who is used to seeing his sister with less dependable companions. Harry’s relationship with Adele signals her effort to build a different kind of life.
Eddie
Chance's blunt confidantEddie is Chance’s cellmate and a perceptive, teasing companion during a major transition in Chance’s life. He notices how often Chance dreams about Aubrey and refuses to let him disguise longing as indifference. His practical humor helps Chance face a decision he would rather avoid.
Philomena
Aubrey's eccentric neighborPhilomena is Aubrey’s lively neighbor, a frequent source of unsolicited offers, odd purchases, and comic interruption. She keeps an eye on the neighborhood and helps care for Pixy when Aubrey works late. Her observations also influence what Chance believes is happening in Aubrey’s life.
Darius Marshall
Adele's dangerous associateDarius is a drug dealer connected to Adele during a frightening period for the Bateman family. His knowledge becomes important to Chance’s attempt to protect his sister. He is a reminder that Chance’s fierce loyalty can tip into violence when he believes the authorities are failing someone he loves.
Melanie
The watchful baristaMelanie works at the Starbucks Aubrey visits each morning. She recognizes Chance’s repeated coffee purchases as more than a routine and quietly supports his attempt to reconnect. Her role is small but memorable because she helps turn a public, awkward encounter into the moment Aubrey learns he has returned.
Zelda
The chapel's wedding helperZelda helps arrange ceremonies and photographs at the Las Vegas chapel where Aubrey and Chance first stage a wedding. Her cheerful professionalism makes the ceremony feel both absurd and unexpectedly intimate. She is present again when the couple returns for a more meaningful occasion.
The Elvis impersonator
The chapel officiantThe Elvis impersonator conducts the chapel ceremony that lets Aubrey and Chance play at being married. His routine turns their private joke into a public ritual and gives Chance a setting for an unusually sincere expression of feeling.
Plot Devices
The cross-country road trip
Forced proximityAubrey’s move to California gives the story a practical reason to place her and Chance together for days rather than minutes. Her flat tire strands them at the same rest stop where his Harley has broken down, and their bargain turns a chance meeting into a shared route. Stops for food, repairs, camping, and the goat continually alter their plans, letting private histories emerge through action rather than formal confession. The trip also creates a sharp contrast with the later years apart: a relationship that first grows through unplanned closeness must eventually survive deliberate distance.
The bobblehead
A keepsake of returnThe broken souvenir bobblehead begins as the comic accident that brings Aubrey and Chance into conversation. Chance replaces it without asking for credit and fixes it to Aubrey’s dashboard, giving the object a place in their shared road-trip memories. After Chance leaves, Aubrey tries to discard reminders of him, but the bobblehead returns to her through an unlikely chain of owners. Its presence in the final journey links the first meeting to the couple’s later reunion. The object does not prove that fate has arranged their lives; it gives Aubrey a tangible way to recognize how much of the past she has chosen to keep.
Pixy the goat
Shared responsibilityThe goat enters the story when Aubrey swerves to avoid him, then proves to be blind and prone to fainting rather than injured. Aubrey insists they help him, and Chance reluctantly makes room in the car, buys camping supplies, and takes part in caring for him. The goat’s needs repeatedly interrupt the couple’s plans, giving their flirtation a practical, comic counterweight. Later, his presence in Aubrey’s home shows that she has preserved something from their brief trip, even while trying to move on. His attachment to both of them makes him a living reminder of the care they learned to share.
The Vegas wedding ring
A promise in disguiseThe chapel ceremony is presented as a drunken joke, complete with borrowed clothes and inexpensive rings, but it gives Chance and Aubrey a safe way to voice feelings they have not formally admitted. Their kiss and private fantasies make the performance emotionally real even though the marriage is not legal. Chance keeps wearing his ring during the years apart, treating a souvenir as a personal commitment. When the couple eventually returns to the chapel, the first ceremony’s playful ritual becomes the frame for an actual marriage. The ring tracks how a symbol can outlast the certainty of the people who first put it on.
Chance's sentence
The hidden reasonChance’s unexplained departure initially looks like a simple rejection because he disappears before Aubrey wakes and gives her no account of what happened. The later revelation that he was sentenced to prison for attacking a man connected to Adele’s assault reframes his absence without undoing its harm. The sentence also explains why Chance believed Aubrey would lose two years if she waited for him. His silence is therefore both protective and damaging: he tries to spare her a burden by making the decision for her, repeating the control he later must learn to relinquish.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.