Key Takeaways
Turn violent conflict into peaceful change, rather than trying to abolish disagreement
Conflict is unavoidable. The authors define conflict broadly as groups pursuing incompatible goals. It can expose injustice and drive social change, so preventing all conflict is neither possible nor desirable. The goal is to prevent disagreements from becoming deadly and to create ways for change to proceed without violence. They call the deeper work conflict resolution: addressing the underlying causes, hostile attitudes, and destructive behavior, not merely stopping the fighting. Conflict transformation describes deep changes in relationships and the conditions that produced conflict.
Peace is ongoing work. A ceasefire can stop direct violence while leaving grievances and unequal relationships untouched. A lasting response therefore needs both immediate restraint and sustained efforts to change the conditions that keep violence likely.
The distinction between conflict and violence prevents a common mistake: treating calm as proof of justice. A quiet society may simply have silenced people with less power. The book’s approach instead asks whether disagreement can remain politically productive without becoming physically destructive. That is a demanding standard, because some conflicts concern genuine competing claims, not misunderstandings that a mediator can dissolve. Still, it offers a useful test for any proposed solution: does it make peaceful change more possible, or merely make visible dissent harder?
Search beneath opposing demands for needs both sides can actually satisfy
Positions hide the problem. A position is the demand a party states openly. Its interests explain what that demand is meant to achieve, while needs refer to basic requirements such as security, identity, and recognition. The authors argue that apparent deadlocks may loosen when parties discuss these deeper concerns instead of bargaining only over fixed demands. A shared need does not guarantee agreement, but it can reveal options that a winner-takes-all framing obscures.
Incentives can change. The Prisoner’s Dilemma illustrates how two parties acting defensively can both end up worse off than if they cooperated. In repeated encounters, Axelrod’s computer tournaments found that a strategy beginning cooperatively, responding to defection, and being willing to cooperate again performed well. Future interaction can make trust and restraint rational, not merely generous.
This framework usefully separates what people demand from what they are trying to protect. It also links negotiation to institutional design: reliable communication, repeated contact, and credible commitments can alter the incentives that make cooperation risky. Needs language should not be treated as a magic solvent, however. Parties may disagree about what recognition or security requires, and material resources can be genuinely scarce. The practical value lies in widening the question, not assuming that every conflict contains a hidden solution that satisfies everyone.
Map power, attitudes, and incompatible interests before choosing an intervention
Three dimensions interact. Johan Galtung’s conflict triangle distinguishes contradiction, attitude, and behavior. Contradiction means the underlying clash of goals or relationships. Attitude includes perceptions, beliefs, and emotions toward the other side. Behavior ranges from cooperation to coercion and violence. These dimensions feed one another, so reducing violence alone may leave hostile attitudes and the original contradiction intact.
Power changes the diagnosis. In asymmetric conflict, the unequal relationship itself may be a central cause, as in a dominant group’s control over a marginalized one. The authors describe how change may require raising awareness, organizing those with less power, and negotiating a more equitable relationship. In South Africa, opposition to apartheid involved challenging the structure of power, not just finding a compromise over individual disputes.
The triangle is valuable because it discourages single-cause explanations. A ceasefire addresses behavior; dialogue may affect attitudes; reform may address the underlying structure. Those interventions are related, but they are not interchangeable. The model also highlights a political risk: treating both parties as equally positioned can conceal an unequal relationship and make an unjust status quo look neutral. At the same time, recognizing asymmetry does not automatically settle which reforms are legitimate. Careful analysis still needs to include the parties’ varied interests and the voices within each camp.
Treat civil wars as international-social crises, not sealed domestic disputes
Conflict crosses levels. Edward Azar’s account of protracted social conflict emphasizes identity groups whose basic needs are frustrated, especially where governments exclude communities or fail to provide legitimate ways to participate. The authors connect this to fragile governance, economic deprivation, and international ties that can sustain or intensify conflict. Their term international-social conflict captures struggles that are domestic in their immediate setting but shaped by outside actors and regional or global pressures.
Look beyond the battlefield. A useful analysis considers global and regional conditions, the state’s social, economic, and political structures, group organization, and the decisions of leaders. This helps explain why internal wars may involve cross-border support, displaced populations, arms flows, and economic interests. The authors’ conflict-mapping guide asks analysts to examine parties, issues, relationships, context, and possible routes to change.
The multi-level view resists two tempting shortcuts: blaming timeless cultural hatred, or explaining every conflict as the product of one global force. It instead treats political violence as emerging from interactions among institutions, communities, and outside pressures. That perspective makes responsibility harder to evade, especially when external policies contribute to local instability. It also makes solutions harder to simplify. A change in national leadership may matter greatly, yet fail if regional incentives, unequal access, or local relationships continue to reproduce the conflict.
Prevent violence early, but build institutions that can absorb future disputes
Two kinds of prevention. Light prevention aims to keep a dangerous situation from escalating, through diplomacy, mediation, or monitoring. Deep prevention addresses the conditions that make violence likely, such as exclusion, weak governance, or unresolved community tensions. The authors argue that both matter: crisis diplomacy can buy time, while deeper changes help societies handle later disputes peacefully.
Warnings are not proof. In Estonia in 1993, Russian-speaking residents of Narva voted for secession, and officials threatened force. OSCE High Commissioner Max van der Stoel helped the sides treat the vote as an expression of aspiration rather than an immediate breakaway, while encouraging restraint. Violence was avoided, but it is difficult to prove that one intervention alone caused that outcome. Early-warning data can identify risk; it cannot reliably predict every trigger or guarantee that decision-makers will act.
The distinction between light and deep prevention separates urgent containment from durable capacity. The Estonia case shows how an intervention can create room for political movement without resolving every underlying dispute. That is a meaningful achievement, but it should not be confused with a final settlement. Prevention is especially difficult to evaluate because success often appears as an event that never happened. A sound assessment therefore needs to track more than the absence of fighting: it should also ask whether institutions and relationships have become better able to manage disagreement.
In war zones, relief and peacekeeping always alter the conflict’s balance
Aid is not outside politics. In some war zones, armed groups profit from controlling resources, coercing civilians, or capturing humanitarian assistance. Aid agencies and peacekeepers can therefore affect who holds power, even when their purpose is relief. The authors argue for connecting security, humanitarian, and political efforts rather than treating them as separate missions.
Rwanda shows the cost of inaction. After a peace agreement stalled, organized genocide began in 1994. Between 500,000 and 800,000 people were killed in roughly three months. The UN reduced its peacekeeping force after the deaths of ten Belgian peacekeepers, despite commander Romeo Dallaire’s appeal for a much larger force. The case exposed the gap between warnings and action, and the need to coordinate protection, relief, and political engagement while supporting local peace efforts.
This analysis treats aid as a form of participation in a political environment, not as a neutral package delivered from outside it. That insight pushes agencies to ask who controls supplies, who gains legitimacy, and whether assistance increases civilian safety or dependence. It also cautions against an easy prescription: greater intervention can carry serious risks, while withdrawal can leave civilians exposed. The relevant choice is not between pure neutrality and total control, but how to help while understanding the consequences and coordinating with others.
A peace process needs changing incentives, not merely a ripe negotiating moment
War endings are varied. Of 68 armed conflicts that ended between 1989 and 1996, only 19 concluded through peace agreements, according to the study discussed in the book. Others ended through military victory or different outcomes. Ending the fighting, therefore, is not the same as resolving the conflict.
Ripeness is a process. A hurting stalemate exists when parties see that continued fighting is costly and unlikely to achieve their aims. It can make negotiations more attractive, but it does not ensure a deal. Conflict resolution may also require changes in leadership, public support, power relations, and the issues under discussion. In South Africa, negotiations advanced through repeated impasses and shifts in position; spoilers on both extremes tried to derail the process. Mediators can help, but they cannot substitute for political change within the parties.
The idea of a hurting stalemate is a useful prompt to examine incentives, not a clock that tells negotiators when peace is due. A costly stalemate can persist when leaders fear losing power, when war economies reward continuation, or when a proposed settlement seems unsafe. The South African example emphasizes the importance of internal shifts as well as negotiation. This broader view avoids making diplomacy look like a technique that works independently of politics, while still recognizing that intermediaries can create channels when direct contact is dangerous.
Treat signed settlements as openings, then prevent relapse and rebuild trust
Agreement leaves work unfinished. The authors separate post-settlement peace-building into two connected tasks: preventing a return to war, and building conditions for a self-sustaining peace. The first may involve disarmament, security arrangements, elections, and guarantees. The second includes stronger institutions, economic and social recovery, reconciliation, and attention to the harms of war. A settlement can stop combat without repairing the divisions that produced it.
The trade-offs are real. In El Salvador, UN involvement helped keep the peace process from coming apart during implementation. But rapid elections, market reforms, and demands for justice can also create new tensions if pursued without regard to the fragile situation. The authors argue for long-term support and coordination, rather than assuming that an election or a signed agreement completes the work.
Peace agreements are better understood as political infrastructure than as the destination. They set procedures for a society to manage disputes, but those procedures need public legitimacy, material support, and room to adapt. The distinction between preventing relapse and building durable peace clarifies why short-term success can coexist with long-term fragility. It also exposes a difficult choice: compromises that stop violence may protect powerful actors or postpone justice. Treating the settlement as an opening keeps that tension visible rather than declaring it solved.
Let local peacebuilders shape settlements, while keeping justice and accountability in view
Legitimacy grows locally. The authors argue that outside mediators and international institutions should support, not replace, domestic capacity. Community groups, religious organizations, political actors, and local peacebuilders may understand which methods people will trust and sustain. Multi-track efforts connect official diplomacy with civil society and community-level work. The book also warns that Western approaches cannot simply be assumed to fit every political or cultural setting.
Inclusion matters. Women were often active in local peace efforts but excluded from formal negotiations, limiting which experiences and interests shaped political arrangements. Postwar societies also face difficult choices among peace, justice, and reconciliation. Truth-telling and acknowledgment can support repair, but the right balance of accountability and pardon is contested. A process seen as imposed, culturally tone-deaf, or exclusionary may produce a settlement that is fragile even when its formal terms look sound.
Local ownership is not a decorative gesture added to an international plan. It is part of the mechanism by which people recognize rules as legitimate and continue using them after outside attention fades. But local traditions should not be romanticized: they can also preserve exclusion or unequal power. The same scrutiny applies to international models. A strong peace process therefore needs two tests at once: whether it draws on knowledge and agency within the affected society, and whether it gives marginalized groups a meaningful voice.
Analysis
The book’s most durable contribution is its refusal to separate the analysis of conflict from the work of changing it. A conflict is not just a dispute between two leaders: it is a shifting system of power, unmet needs, public beliefs, institutions, and outside interests. That perspective explains why a ceasefire, a negotiated formula, or a new election can be important without being sufficient.
Its framework also exposes a central dilemma of international action. Outside actors may supply leverage, resources, and protection that local groups cannot provide alone. Yet the same intervention can reinforce dependency, distort incentives, or impose institutions that people do not regard as legitimate. The authors’ answer is not to withdraw, but to connect external support with locally grounded political capacity. This is persuasive as a principle, though difficult to operationalize when local actors are divided, unrepresentative, or themselves invested in violence.
The book is especially strong on sequencing and uncertainty. Prevention is hard to prove because its success is an avoided event; peace processes rarely move in a straight line; and settlements inherit the conflict’s political struggles. Its historical cases show that peace is less a single agreement than a continuing contest over security, participation, resources, and accountability.
The limitation is partly one of scope and time. The discussion is anchored in post-Cold War cases and the institutional debates visible by 2005, while its own warnings about changing forms of conflict make any fixed typology provisional. The value of its categories is therefore diagnostic, not predictive. They help identify what needs attention, but cannot replace detailed local knowledge or guarantee that a particular intervention will work. The book’s deepest practical lesson is modest but demanding: pursue change without violence, and judge progress by whether people gain lasting capacity to manage the next disagreement peacefully.
People Also Read
Glossary
Conflict resolution
Addresses conflict’s underlying causesIn this book, conflict resolution means more than ending violence or reaching an agreement. It aims to address the sources of conflict, reduce hostile attitudes and destructive behavior, and change relationships or structures that sustain the conflict. The term also names a specialist field that studies and practices these approaches.
Conflict transformation
Changes conflict relationships deeplyConflict transformation is a deep change in the parties, their relationships, and the situation that gave rise to conflict. It is especially relevant when unequal social relationships must change, not simply when parties need to settle a particular dispute. The authors treat it as the deepest level of change within conflict resolution.
Conflict triangle
Maps three interacting conflict dimensionsJohan Galtung’s model represents conflict through contradiction, attitude, and behavior. Contradiction concerns incompatible goals or unequal relationships; attitude covers perceptions, beliefs, and emotions; behavior includes cooperation, coercion, or violence. The dimensions influence one another, so addressing only violent behavior may leave the underlying conflict intact.
Protracted social conflict
Explains persistent group-based conflictEdward Azar’s term for prolonged conflicts in which communal groups struggle over basic needs, including security, identity, political access, and economic participation. The analysis connects group grievances to governance, international linkages, and the ways parties respond to one another. It challenges explanations that treat internal and international causes as separate.
International-social conflict
Connects domestic and external conflictThe authors’ label for conflicts that are neither purely interstate nor purely domestic. Such conflicts may arise within a state while being shaped by regional relationships, outside support, global pressures, or international intervention. The term emphasizes that political violence can cross the boundary between a society’s internal affairs and the international system.
Light prevention
Stops a crisis escalatingInterventions intended to prevent a dangerous or politically tense situation from becoming armed conflict. Examples include diplomatic engagement, mediation, monitoring, and preventive peacekeeping. Light prevention may limit an immediate crisis without addressing the underlying grievances or institutional weaknesses that could produce future violence.
Deep prevention
Reduces underlying conflict risksEfforts to address conditions that make societies prone to violent conflict. Depending on the situation, this can involve strengthening governance, improving political inclusion, supporting economic and cultural development, or building community capacity to manage disputes. Unlike crisis containment, deep prevention seeks more durable ways to handle conflict.
Hurting stalemate
Makes negotiation seem preferableA condition in which conflict parties see continued fighting as costly and unlikely to achieve their aims, making a negotiated settlement more appealing. The concept can help identify why parties might consider talks, but it does not guarantee agreement. Leadership changes, internal politics, and confidence in a settlement also affect whether negotiations can succeed.
Multi-track diplomacy
Coordinates peace work across levelsAn approach that combines official diplomacy with unofficial mediation and locally rooted peacebuilding. Different actors work with political leaders, civil society, and communities, sometimes at the same time. The aim is to connect negotiations with wider social and institutional change, rather than relying on a single mediator or one short diplomatic intervention.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.