Plot Summary
Wendy Meets Wanda
Sophie Chi, a meticulous first-year at Wellesley, has spent months anonymously answering classmates’ relationship questions as Dear Wendy. Her roommate, Priya, brings her a new account, Sincerely, Wanda, whose jokey advice and Comic Sans make it look like a deliberate imitation.
The account belongs to Jo Ephron, who created it after helping roommate Katy leave Jason, a boyfriend who dismissed Katy’s bisexuality, pressured her for sex, and ignored her distress. Jo meant to tease her friends, but Katy’s followers turned the joke into a second advice page. When Sophie contacts Wanda, Jo insists the account is not meant to take Wendy’s place. Neither student knows the other’s identity, and both are already watching the other’s posts.
The rivalry begins as a collision between two styles of care. Sophie makes advice orderly and defensible, while Jo uses humor to make difficult situations feel less intimidating. Yet both are responding to the same campus need: students want a peer who will take their private confusion seriously. Anonymity gives each writer room to speak, but it also creates a blank surface onto which the other can project threat. Sophie’s concern about imitation is not simply vanity; the account has become a place where her judgment is trusted, a kind of belonging she rarely receives at home.
Partners in Gender Studies
Jo and Sophie meet during a Women’s and Gender Studies class, where a shared complaint about their professor’s dense explanations breaks the ice. The class pairs them for a presentation on trans-exclusionary feminism, and they quickly discover that they can work together without competing.
Sophie arrives prepared and driven; Jo brings humor and a willingness to challenge the reading. Meanwhile, their online accounts keep needling each other. Jo notices Sophie’s account through a public comment, while Sophie hears classmates praising Wanda’s advice and feels her authority slipping.
Neither brings the rivalry into their new friendship. Instead, they exchange numbers, plan their presentation, and start comparing their experiences of college, family expectations, and the effort of fitting into a community that feels safer than home.
Their first connection is built through shared work rather than attraction or instant intimacy. The classroom lets both characters test each other’s judgment in public, where their differences become useful: Sophie organizes, Jo punctures pretension. That cooperation quietly complicates the online feud, since each has begun to distrust the other without knowing the person behind the account. Their college setting also functions as a contrast to home. Wellesley gives them language and peers, but it does not erase the pressures carried from immigrant families, high school, or gendered expectations.
Aroace, At Last
After their presentation, Sophie and Jo share dinner and trade stories about roommates, classes, and the awkwardness of college friendships. When Jo says they do not get crushes, Sophie risks naming herself as aromantic and asexual.
Jo identifies the same way, and both realize they have finally met someone whose experience is not merely adjacent to their own. They take the conversation to Boston, where a nauseating shuttle ride gives way to hours of talk about media, attraction, gender, and families.
Jo’s lesbian mothers accept their identity; Sophie’s parents still treat hers as a phase. Back on campus, Sophie tells Priya and Izzy that Wellesley’s former a-spec group has gone dormant. They encourage her to revive it, and Jo eagerly agrees to help.
The revelation offers recognition, not sameness. Sophie has spent years explaining herself to people who care about her but do not understand her; Jo’s matching identity makes some explanations unnecessary. Their conversation also reveals different forms of security. Jo has supportive parents but worries about how gender labels fit; Sophie has a more settled sense of herself but must negotiate parental disbelief. The proposed club grows from this asymmetry. It is not just an extracurricular project: it is an attempt to build the kind of room neither girl could reliably find while growing up.
The Dianas Begin
Sophie and Jo plan an a-spec discussion group, eventually naming it the Dianas after the Roman goddess associated with archery. Jo’s first evening with Sophie is less organized: they watch Inside Out, cry over the film, and talk about the fear that friendship may never feel as secure as romance seems to promise. Jo describes how a childhood best friend drifted away after falling in love, leaving Jo wary of being displaced.
Sophie shares her own experience of losing Oliver, then invites Jo to stay over. The club’s first meeting draws only Evelyn and Charlie, but the conversation flows as they compare queer high school experiences. Hannah joins the next gathering, where members discuss the loneliness of being a-spec inside queer spaces.
The club gives a social form to what the movie night first makes personal: intimacy does not have to follow romantic scripts to be durable. Jo’s fear is not that friends will date, in the abstract, but that a partner will become the unquestioned center of another person’s life. Sophie’s willingness to listen without treating that fear as irrational begins to challenge Jo’s expectation of abandonment. The small meeting turnout matters too. Rather than measuring the group by popularity, the book presents its first value as the quality of attention its few members offer one another.
A Crush Enters the Room
Jo suspects that their roommate Lianne, a Black lesbian, has a crush on Katy, another roommate still recovering from her relationship with Jason. Lianne tries Bumble and matches with Alicia, a confident hallmate of Sophie’s, but her feelings for Katy make every new connection complicated.
Sophie and Jo discuss the uncertainty over meals and during a rainy afternoon when Alicia and Lianne finally meet in person. Jo watches Lianne tense up, then sees her brighten when Alicia speaks with her.
The scene leaves Jo caught between wanting to protect Lianne from rejection and wanting to keep the familiar trio unchanged. At the same time, Sophie consults Professor Fineman about a paper on gender and relationships, while Jo’s uncertainty about appearance and identity deepens.
Jo’s interference grows from a protective impulse that is only partly about Lianne. They are afraid that a romance will rearrange the household and leave them outside it, so they treat other people’s uncertainty as a threat to manage. Lianne’s attraction to both Katy and Alicia exposes the limits of Jo’s confidence: Jo can identify the social pattern but cannot control what anyone feels. Sophie’s academic work offers a counterpoint. She studies relationships with curiosity, yet her growing closeness to Jo is not something she can reduce to a tidy theory.
Advice Turns into Combat
As Wanda’s following grows, Jo mixes jokes with increasingly useful answers, while Sophie worries that students may mistake satire for reliable guidance. Their comments become sharper, especially after Wanda publicly boasts that one answer helped more than Wendy’s.
Sophie responds with a story post criticizing Wanda; Jo fires back, and the disagreement becomes campus entertainment. Midterms worsen Sophie’s fixation, though Priya persuades her to pause the feud while keeping Dear Wendy active.
When she returns to Wanda’s posts, she finds much of the advice sound, but one flippant answer about avoiding confrontation alarms her. Sophie calls Wanda out, and Jo agrees to back off only if Sophie does the same. Both insist there is nothing to win, yet neither stops watching.
The accounts turn advice into a contest over who deserves to be trusted. Sophie sees rigor as an ethical obligation because real students may act on what she posts; Jo sees the performance as playful until Sophie’s attention makes it feel consequential. Their online hostility is intensified by the very thing they share: each wants to help, and each fears being dismissed. The medium rewards speed and spectacle, however, so careful differences in tone become public provocations. Their private friendship continues alongside the feud, creating dramatic irony: they are learning to trust each other in person while rehearsing distrust online.
The Anonymous Names
Lianne sends Dear Wendy a question about choosing between a close friend she likes and a new woman who interests her. Sophie recognizes the situation and asks Wanda for an outside opinion, not realizing Jo is the person answering.
Jo advises Lianne to pursue neither until she understands her feelings, but gives Sophie too little explanation to satisfy the person seeking help. When Lianne messages Wendy for clarification and mentions that Wanda is her roommate, Sophie connects the accounts.
She calls Jo, who admits the truth and explains that fear of losing Lianne and Katy shaped the advice. Their argument exposes the deeper betrayal: each believes friendship should have made disclosure easier. Lianne overhears Jo admit that she feared being left behind, calls the fear selfish, and walks out.
The reveal converts a comic rivalry into an ethical failure. Jo’s advice was not neutral because Jo had a personal stake in the outcome, and Sophie’s account depends on precisely the impartiality she thought she had preserved. Yet neither deception is simply malicious. They hid their identities to protect privacy and avoid judgment, then mistook secrecy for safety. Lianne’s departure marks the cost of Jo’s fear made visible: trying to prevent a friendship from changing can damage it more directly than the change itself.
A Voice Draws Fire
After the fight, Jo promotes queer and a-spec campus groups through Wanda and identifies themself as a-spec. Students discuss the revelation on anonymous apps, and some question whether an aromantic, asexual person should offer relationship advice. Sophie, still hurt, answers with a Dear Wendy post defending a-spec students and pointing readers toward the Dianas.
The defense draws support as well as criticism, leaving Sophie to wonder whether her own identity undermines her credibility. She turns to her mother, who tells her that anger and sadness can coexist with moving on. Jo, meanwhile, retreats from posting and visits home, carrying the public scrutiny together with the silence from Sophie and Lianne.
The online controversy shifts the story from private identity to public legitimacy. The critics assume that experience is valid only when it resembles the majority’s, as though studying relationships requires being romantically involved in one. Sophie’s defense matters because it is not abstract advocacy: she places her own identity beside the club and risks being questioned too. The incident also shows how anonymity protects and exposes at once. Jo’s name stays hidden, but the identity disclosed through the account becomes material for strangers to debate.
The Apology Tour
At home, Jo tells their mother how frightened they are that friends will leave once romance becomes available to them. Their mother reminds them that love is not limited to couples, and Jo’s twelve-year-old brother Theo confides that he worries his straightness will make him seem out of place in their queer family.
Jo sees how easily imagined rejection can turn into isolation. Back on campus, Jo apologizes to Lianne for interfering and admits that they gave bad advice to protect their own place in the household.
Lianne accepts the apology and says she wants to reconnect with Alicia. Jo then sends Sophie a long, honest note describing their friendship and taking responsibility for the harm they caused. Sophie calls, apologizes for her own part, and agrees to meet.
Jo’s growth begins when they stop treating the fear of abandonment as evidence that abandonment is inevitable. Their mother’s reassurance does not erase the fear, but it gives Jo a broader vocabulary for attachment. Theo’s confession adds humor and perspective: even a family that seems secure can make someone worry about being the odd one out. Jo’s apology to Lianne is the first concrete consequence of that insight. Instead of demanding reassurance, Jo acknowledges the selfishness of trying to control other people’s relationships.
A Friendship Finds Its Way
Sophie reaches Jo in the library during a downpour and embraces them before they can finish apologizing. She admits that she also mishandled Lianne’s question and the confrontation that followed. At the dorm, they give Lianne the fuller answer she needed: she should decide what she wants rather than use Alicia to escape her feelings for Katy.
Lianne speaks honestly to Katy, who cares for her but does not want to date her, and then reopens contact with Alicia. As the Dianas resume meeting, members discuss the hostility a-spec people face within queer spaces and defend the legitimacy of their identities. Sophie and Jo also examine why they built their advice accounts: they wanted to help, but also wanted to be heard.
Repair comes through specific accountability rather than a quick return to affection. Sophie and Jo each name what they did wrong, while Lianne receives advice that does not pretend to choose for her. Katy’s response clarifies that rejection need not destroy a friendship, and Lianne can move toward Alicia without treating Katy as a fallback. The Dianas’ discussion mirrors the private reconciliation: people need room to define their own relationships, identities, and forms of belonging. The accounts become less a competition for authority than an inquiry into why anyone seeks authority at all.
Bracelets and Roommates
Sophie makes Jo a friendship bracelet in the colors of their a-spec flags, then explains that it is a small way to show how much she values them. When Jo admits they still question whether their identity is real, Sophie explains that uncertainty can recur without invalidating what they know about themselves.
Watching Sophie and Priya care for each other through ordinary gestures helps Jo imagine companionship outside romance. The two friends watch The Half of It, laugh and cry together, and Jo asks Sophie to room with them the following year. Sophie accepts. They also create a joint Instagram account for material that does not fit neatly on either advice page, changing their public rivalry into a collaboration.
The bracelet is a deliberate answer to Jo’s fear that love must arrive in a romantic form to count. It is material, modest, and made by hand, which makes care visible without making it possessive. Sophie’s account of uncertainty also resists a common demand placed on a-spec people: that they prove their identity once and for all. The roommate proposal turns emotional recognition into a practical plan. Rather than promising that neither will ever change, they choose to build a shared daily life while allowing both friendship and self-understanding to remain open.
A New Student Listens
At the Dianas’ final meeting of the semester, Sophie and Jo meet Nora, a prospective student touring Wellesley with her family. Nora lights up when they explain that the club is for a-spec students, so Sophie adds her to the mailing list. The moment makes the founders realize that their small group may give someone else a reason to feel welcome before arriving.
Soon after, Jo learns that a WZLY radio slot has opened and invites Sophie into the studio. They introduce their club and play music they connect with as aroace friends, trading jokes while members and friends listen remotely. The story closes not with a romantic coupling, but with two collaborators making their community audible.
Nora’s reaction provides a quiet measure of the Dianas’ achievement. The club has not become large or institutionally powerful, but it has made an otherwise hard-to-find possibility visible to someone deciding where she might belong. The radio broadcast extends that work beyond a room and a mailing list. Sophie and Jo share a public platform without disguising their differences or returning to the old contest. Their ending treats friendship as an active form of world-building: they create the kind of recognition they once searched for.
Analysis
Dear Wendy treats friendship not as a consolation prize for romance, but as a relationship that requires the same honesty, negotiation, and deliberate care. Jo’s central fear is not simply being single. It is that friends will rank romantic partners above them and eventually disappear. That fear becomes damaging when Jo tries to manage Lianne’s choices, proving that a need for security can turn into control even when it begins in love. Sophie’s parallel mistake is to confuse expertise with objectivity. Her account presents advice as researched and impartial, yet her growing attachment to Jo makes her own judgment emotionally invested too.
The anonymous accounts turn these private vulnerabilities into a public performance. Wendy and Wanda are not merely opposing personalities: they are competing models of authority. Sophie believes useful advice should be careful and qualified; Jo believes humor can make people feel less alone. The novel does not declare either method sufficient. Their most consequential error comes when Jo gives advice that protects Jo rather than Lianne, and when Sophie treats the resulting failure as proof that Jo has betrayed their friendship. Repair requires them to admit how their own interests shaped their decisions.
A-spec identity is woven into this structure rather than isolated as a lesson. Sophie and Jo share a vocabulary, but their experiences differ: one has comparatively accepting parents and uncertainty about labels, while the other has more certainty about identity and less acceptance at home. The Dianas make room for those differences and for people whose experiences do not match a single template. The novel’s ending follows the same logic. Jo and Sophie choose a shared room and a shared project, not because friendship eliminates loneliness, but because they can imagine a future in which care is not measured by romance. Their community is built through concrete acts: answering a message, showing up, apologizing, making a bracelet, and inviting someone new to join.
Review Summary
Dear Wendy receives mixed reviews, with many praising its representation of aromantic and asexual characters and focus on platonic relationships. Readers appreciate the exploration of identity and college life. However, some criticize the writing style as juvenile and the dialogue as unrealistic. The book's heavy reliance on internet culture and Wellesley College references is divisive. While some find the story heartwarming and relatable, others feel it lacks depth and character development. Overall, it's seen as an important contribution to aroace representation in literature.
People Also Read
Characters
Sophie Chi
The meticulous advice-giverSophie is a Chinese American first-year who relies on preparation, achievement, and practical care to make herself useful to others. She is aromantic and asexual, and she has a clear sense of her identity even as her parents question whether it will last. Her instinct is to research before advising, which gives her confidence but can also make her defensive when her judgment is challenged. She values her friends deeply, especially the small acts that make a relationship feel reciprocal. Beneath her composure is a fear of being dismissed as too serious or too difficult, a fear shaped by family expectations and a painful friendship from home.
Jo Ephron
The wary campus comedianJo is a she/they first-year from nearby Natick, raised by two lesbian mothers and accustomed to a lively, affectionate household. Aromantic and asexual, Jo is still working out how gender and appearance fit together, and dislikes being expected to have a definitive label for every part of themself. Humor helps Jo connect with people and deflect discomfort, but it can also conceal how intensely they fear being left behind. Jo is perceptive about friends’ romantic troubles, partly because they have spent years watching relationships rearrange social groups. Their wit is genuine, but so is their need for reassurance that friendship can endure change.
Priya Chakrabarti
Sophie’s blunt roommatePriya is Sophie’s roommate, a lesbian, and Izzy’s devoted long-distance girlfriend. She is direct enough to challenge Sophie when online conflict consumes her attention, but patient enough to offer comfort without turning every problem into a lecture. Her relationship with her Bengali immigrant father is loving and strained by his refusal to acknowledge Izzy as her partner. Priya’s everyday loyalty helps Sophie feel supported, while her willingness to tease both friends keeps difficult conversations from becoming solemn performances.
Izzy Sun
Priya’s attentive girlfriendIzzy is a Chinese American student at Brown and Priya’s girlfriend. She is demisexual and thoughtful about how identity shapes relationships, and she has known Sophie since high school. Izzy offers practical perspective without pretending that every queer person shares the same experience. Her closeness with Priya is expressed through small acts of care, and her easy friendship with Sophie gives Sophie a model of intimacy that remains generous rather than exclusive.
Katy Murphy
The recovering romanticKaty is one of Jo’s roommates, an artist and bisexual woman who wants closeness but has learned that effort alone cannot make a partner treat her well. She seeks help when a boyfriend undermines her identity and boundaries, and she takes therapy seriously. Katy is often the caring, observant presence in her dorm, though her own feelings can be harder for her to interpret. Her recent heartbreak makes her cautious about dating, not cynical about love.
Lianne
The guarded roommateLianne is Jo and Katy’s Black lesbian roommate, confident in public but less sure of herself when romance is involved. She has little prior experience dating women and is learning to navigate attraction in a college community where queer possibilities are more visible. Her loyalty to her roommates can become tangled with unspoken feelings, while her humor and candor help her recover from awkwardness. Lianne wants to be treated as a person with choices, not as the center of someone else’s protective plan.
Alicia Flores
The easygoing new matchAlicia is Sophie’s hallmate, a confident, funny student interested in journalism and broadcast news. She is a queer woman of Puerto Rican heritage who thinks carefully about the work involved in dating across cultural differences. Alicia approaches people directly, but she is not immune to being overlooked when someone else is caught in their own uncertainty. Her friendship with Sophie and potential connection with Lianne show how campus relationships can overlap without belonging to the same social circle.
Professor Lisa Fineman
The queer studies mentorProfessor Fineman teaches Women’s and Gender Studies and researches queer representation, especially sapphic experience. Her lectures can sound inaccessible to Jo, but in office hours she is warm, curious, and generous with resources. She takes Sophie’s intellectual excitement seriously and makes room for personal conversations without acting as a substitute parent or therapist. Her attentiveness offers a model of adult mentorship grounded in respect rather than control.
Ying and Bowen Chi
Sophie’s ambitious parentsSophie’s parents are Chinese immigrants whose hopes for their daughters are shaped by instability in their own upbringing and faith in education as a route to security. Her mother is an accountant and her father a nurse practitioner. They love Sophie and remain involved in her life, but they expect conventional achievement and do not fully accept her aromantic and asexual identity. Their care and their limitations coexist, making family love a source of both comfort and friction.
Melissa and Becky Ephron
Jo’s openly queer mothersJo’s mothers are warm, teasing parents who raised Jo and their younger son in an openly queer household. Their relationship began at a political protest and gives Jo a vivid example of enduring partnership, which can make Jo’s own future feel harder to imagine. They accept Jo’s identity and offer a home where difficult feelings can be spoken aloud. Their support does not remove Jo’s anxiety, but it gives Jo a place to return when that anxiety becomes overwhelming.
Abby Chi
Sophie’s irreverent sisterAbby is Sophie’s younger sister, a high school student who calls to report school mishaps and friend drama. She teases Sophie without hesitation and is more open to queer identities than their parents. Their sibling banter gives Sophie a connection to home that is affectionate, ordinary, and occasionally exhausting.
Theo Ephron
Jo’s earnest younger brotherTheo is Jo’s twelve-year-old brother, a straight boy growing up among queer family members. He is funny, self-conscious, and more perceptive than his age might suggest. His worries show that even a loving family can make a person feel conspicuous when they differ from the people around them.
Darcy
The club-starting bigDarcy is Sophie’s assigned Wellesley big, an older student who has sustained a long-term relationship and started the campus geese-watching club. Sophie turns to Darcy for practical guidance on organizing a student group. Their example makes the Dianas’ revival feel possible without requiring the founders to know every bureaucratic step.
Evelyn Dawson
The first Dianas regularEvelyn is a sophomore who joins the Dianas early and speaks openly about being an aromantic lesbian. She helps establish the group’s candid, welcoming tone and brings a grounded perspective on family expectations and friendship.
Charlie Santos
The candid first-yearCharlie is a nonbinary first-year and former theater techie who joins the Dianas. They speak thoughtfully about queer and neurodivergent community, and about how online culture can both validate identity and make it feel like a passing phase.
Hannah Rizzo
The questioning club memberHannah is a first-year asexual student who joins the Dianas after its earliest meetings. Her perspective complicates assumptions about who belongs in queer spaces and helps the group discuss exclusion without flattening different experiences.
Nora Deng
The hopeful prospective studentNora is a prospective Wellesley student touring campus with her family. She is enthusiastic about the possibility of joining an a-spec group, and her curiosity shows how important visible community can be before a student even arrives.
Plot Devices
Dear Wendy and Sincerely, Wanda
Anonymous advice and rivalryThe two Instagram advice accounts let Sophie and Jo speak to their campus without attaching their public reputations to every opinion. Wendy offers researched, careful guidance; Wanda begins as comic imitation and develops into a more serious alternative. Their comment threads create the story’s public conflict, while their hidden authorship allows the two friends to misunderstand one another. The eventual revelation makes their advice ethically complicated because Jo’s answer about Lianne was shaped by personal fear. The accounts later become a collaboration rather than a contest.
The Wellesley Dianas
A-spec community made visibleSophie and Jo revive a dormant discussion group for aromantic and asexual students and allies. The Dianas give the protagonists a concrete project that requires planning, outreach, and shared responsibility. Their small early meetings dramatize the difference between having a mailing list and having a community, while later conversations give a-spec students room to discuss exclusion inside queer spaces. The group’s value is measured less by size than by the recognition it offers members and prospective students.
Campus social media
Private conflict made publicInstagram, campus forums, and student posts create a fast-moving social world where jokes can become advice, conflict can become entertainment, and identity can become a topic for strangers. The platforms magnify the Wendy and Wanda feud and help students find groups like the Dianas, but they also encourage speculation and aphobic commentary. Their anonymity is double-edged: it protects the people behind the accounts while making their words seem detached from the feelings of the people who write them.
Wellesley radio
Friendship shared on airJo’s weekly WZLY show first appears as a private pleasure and a way to share music with a handful of listeners. It later gives Sophie a place beside Jo on a public microphone. Their joint broadcast connects personal taste, a-spec identity, and the Dianas, making their friendship audible to the community they have been trying to build. The radio show offers a quieter counterweight to social media: it is live, shared, and grounded in the two friends’ ease with one another.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.