Plot Summary
The Captain's Empty C
After star captain Foster Grant leaves Colchester for the NHL, senior forward Christopher Jacobs expects to inherit the team’s leadership. He has spent years earning his scholarship and building his game, while wealthy defenseman TJ Beckett, known as Beck, seems to succeed through charm and natural talent. Coach Hogan surprises them by asking the players to choose between the two.
Jacobs sees the vote as a threat to the future he has worked toward, especially because Beck is popular with the team. Beck, meanwhile, had planned a summer abroad, but chooses to stay in Vermont and help at hockey camp. The chance to compete for captain, and to needle Jacobs along the way, suddenly gives him a reason to stay.
The captaincy contest gives the romance a concrete arena: Jacobs and Beck are not merely opposites in temperament, but rivals for a role that represents security to one and possibility to the other. Jacobs has attached leadership to years of disciplined effort and to his bond with Grant. Beck treats the contest as a last chance to make college feel vivid before a future he did not choose closes in. Their competing stakes are unequal, which is central to the tension. The novel begins by showing how privilege can make another person’s hard-won ambitions look like a game, even when Beck has his own reasons for playing.
Summer Camp, New Rivalry
At camp, Beck and Jacobs mentor high-school players while competing in drills and for their teammates’ respect. Beck discovers that teaching the younger players gives him a satisfaction he has not found in partying or easy success.
The summer team, led by Cohen, turns the captain contest into a series of dares. Beck wins a drinking race, but Jacobs beats him at collecting phone numbers by recruiting hockey fans as coaching clients. Their next test sends them running naked across campus.
Beck wins after Jacobs pulls them both into a hedge to avoid being seen, then Beck invents a security guard to repay Jacobs for his earlier trick. The score leaves the men even, while their teasing grows more personal and their rivalry becomes the summer’s daily entertainment.
The dares turn leadership into spectacle, exposing the gap between being liked and being responsible. Beck knows how to charm a room, but camp gives him something more durable than applause: younger players listen because he has useful knowledge to share. Jacobs, by contrast, treats every contest as a test of competence, yet his quick thinking protects them both during the streak. Their exchanges are comic, but they also establish a pattern of mutual attention. Each man watches closely enough to find the other’s vulnerabilities, then uses that knowledge as play. The games create intimacy before either is ready to name it.
A Kiss Breaks Formation
The team’s next challenge is a kissing contest, and Jacobs initially refuses. Beck needles him until Jacobs accepts, determined not to hand Beck an easy victory. Their kiss is meant to be a joke for the locker room, but Beck responds with unexpected hunger and pulls away only when he realizes how aroused he is. Jacobs leaves shaken too.
He replays the kiss alone in the gym, recognizes that his body wanted it, and begins reconsidering the attraction he once misread as hero worship for Grant. When Beck returns to camp, both men pretend the moment meant nothing, though Jacobs watches Beck’s mouth and Beck avoids the subject. Their rivalry continues, but the kiss has made their old insults impossible to experience as harmless.
The kiss functions as a disruption because it removes the protection of performance. Until this point, hostility has allowed both men to stay close while claiming indifference; the challenge briefly makes physical contact permissible, then reveals that the desire is not a joke. Jacobs responds by trying to interpret his body through an existing story about Grant, a familiar strategy for containing uncertainty. Beck’s retreat is less an answer than evidence that his usual confidence cannot manage this new attraction. The scene makes self-knowledge bodily before it becomes verbal. Neither man chooses a label yet, but both lose the comfort of believing their reactions are only competitive.
The Catamount Gets Vandalized
For the final dare, the team orders Beck and Jacobs to deface the University of Vermont’s catamount statue. Jacobs refuses to risk his scholarship over vandalism, but Beck goes alone, using toilet paper and spray paint to turn the rival school’s mascot into a crude joke. From Cohen’s car, Jacobs sees campus security approach and warns Beck by phone.
He then drives to the statue and gets Beck away before the guard can catch him. The two return to Colchester together, and Beck recognizes that Jacobs could have left him to face the consequences. Later, Jacobs sends the team the photograph he took of Beck at work, although he could have withheld it and protected his own captain bid. The gesture helps Beck claim the summer team’s endorsement.
The statue stunt makes the difference between the men’s risks visible. Beck can treat arrest as survivable because his family’s money offers a safety net; Jacobs has to calculate what one mistake could cost. Yet Jacobs does not simply lecture him from a distance. He warns Beck and drives into danger to get him out, acting on loyalty before he can explain it. Sending the photograph afterward is a second, quieter risk: Jacobs gives up leverage in a contest he once believed he needed to win. The story shifts their bond from antagonism toward trust through decisions with consequences, not through a sudden change of personality.
A Captain's Unexpected Gift
The team celebrates Beck as its new summer captain after Jacobs shares the statue photograph, and Beck cannot understand why his rival helped him win. He finds Jacobs alone and presses him for an explanation.
The confrontation turns into their first private sexual encounter, which neither wants the team to know about. Jacobs insists the experience cannot mean anything, while Beck agrees to keep it secret rather than force a definition. Their arrangement soon becomes a repeated nighttime escape from camp, with daytime sniping preserved as cover.
Jacobs begins to see Beck’s charm as something more than carelessness, while Beck finds that sex with Jacobs gives him a charge his usual hookups never did. Their captain contest is no longer the only reason they keep seeking each other out.
The gift of the photograph matters because it is not a declaration of affection. Jacobs acts generously while still resisting the vulnerability of saying why, allowing the relationship to advance through behavior ahead of conscious commitment. Their secrecy similarly serves two functions: it protects them from the team’s teasing, and it lets Jacobs postpone deciding what his desire means. Beck’s willingness to accept those limits shows that his usual pursuit of immediate excitement has acquired an attachment he cannot treat as disposable. The secret arrangement is therefore both shelter and constraint. It gives them room to explore, but each concealed night increases the emotional cost of pretending that nothing is changing.
Jealousy Finds Its Name
Beck’s younger sister, Baby, arrives unexpectedly, upset after clashing with their father about her ambitions. Jacobs sees Beck comfort her and mistakes their closeness for a romance, then drinks too much and confronts Beck at his dorm. When Beck identifies Baby as his sister, Jacobs learns that Beck’s full name is Teddy Junior and that his family’s pet names explain their closeness.
Embarrassed, Jacobs admits he feared Beck might be seeing someone else. Beck answers that he wants no other partners, and Jacobs agrees, turning their secret encounters into an exclusive arrangement. The exchange gives Jacobs a glimpse of Beck’s family pressure, while Beck sees that Jacobs’s jealousy is not simply another way to compete with him.
Jealousy forces Jacobs to acknowledge a claim he has not been willing to make. His anger is misdirected at Baby, but the mistake exposes the emotional logic beneath his insistence that their arrangement is casual: he wants Beck’s attention to belong somewhere specific. The reveal of Beck’s legal name also reverses their usual teasing. Jacobs gains access to a private, slightly absurd family detail, not through Beck’s polished public persona but through a moment of vulnerability. Exclusivity does not resolve their identities or define a full relationship, yet it changes the ethical terms between them. They now owe each other more honesty than secrecy can comfortably contain.
A Date, Then Trust
After several nights together, Beck takes Jacobs to a modest Italian restaurant that feels more welcoming to him than his family’s polished world. Jacobs notices the difference and listens as Beck admits how little he feels at home in his expected future.
Their dinner becomes a real date, and they begin asking about the lives each has kept private. On their next outing, they play mini golf for the chance to choose who tops. Beck is the stronger player but deliberately misses the final shot, giving Jacobs the win and letting him set the pace.
Later, Beck trusts Jacobs to guide their first penetrative encounter, while Jacobs checks his comfort and follows his cues. The contest becomes less about victory than learning how to trust each other with control.
The restaurant and mini golf course let the couple rehearse intimacy outside the familiar structures of hockey and sex. Beck’s choice of an unpretentious place challenges Jacobs’s assumption that money determines what Beck values; the restaurant’s warmth matters more than its status. The wager at mini golf keeps their competitive language, but Beck’s intentional loss transforms that language into consent and generosity. He gives Jacobs the choice without pretending to be powerless, while Jacobs’s care counters the fear that surrender means losing control. Their physical trust grows through attention and adjustment. The romance’s central negotiation is not simply who leads, but whether each can be both playful and accountable.
Two Families, One Boyfriend
Beck brings Jacobs to New York, where his parents return early and find the two men together in the rooftop hot tub. His father treats Beck’s attraction to a man as another reckless stunt and warns that it could damage his future at Beckett Enterprises.
Beck finally says he is miserable being groomed to run a company he does not want. He and Jacobs leave for the Jacobs family farm, where Lenny, Jenny, and the brothers welcome Beck as Jacobs’s boyfriend.
During the visit, the men discuss labels and call Grant and his boyfriend Zach for perspective; Jacobs tentatively identifies as gay, while Beck remains unsure which label fits. The contrast between the households gives them room to choose their relationship without pretending their circumstances are identical.
The family visits stage two competing forms of belonging. Beck’s father treats sexuality, career, and public reputation as matters to be managed, while Beck’s mother is more open but cannot erase the power imbalance in the household. At the farm, the Jacobs family makes space for Beck through ordinary welcome and shared work, not interrogation. That contrast does not make one family simple and the other irredeemable; it clarifies how belonging depends on whether a person is allowed to speak about their own future. The conversation with Grant and Zach offers language without imposing a label. The couple’s commitment becomes more secure precisely because they are permitted to remain uncertain.
The C Changes Hands
When the team returns to campus, Jacobs and Beck decide they no longer want to hide their relationship. At the official meeting, Coach Hogan announces that Jacobs will be captain and Beck will serve as alternate, replacing the summer team’s expectation that Beck had won the role.
Jacobs is surprised, but Beck supports the decision and helps him put on the captain’s jersey. The team’s embraces and jokes make their relationship public without turning it into a crisis.
Before classes begin, Beck’s father offers him an alternative to joining the family company: by graduation, Beck must present a credible plan for a sustainable life of his own. Beck accepts the challenge, but his effort to add classes and build a plan soon leaves him distracted and exhausted, worrying Jacobs.
The captaincy reversal separates public recognition from the private competition that began the story. Beck can accept the alternate role because the relationship has changed what winning means; Jacobs’s achievement no longer threatens Beck’s sense of worth. The team’s response matters too: their affection makes disclosure less catastrophic than both men feared, though it does not erase the family conflict waiting elsewhere. Beck’s father’s offer is conditional freedom, not an apology. It gives Beck an opening while preserving the power to judge whether his future is acceptable. The section therefore moves the conflict beyond romance: the couple must now make room for ambition, time pressure, and the material consequences of Beck’s independence.
A Future Beyond Beckett
As the season begins, Beck overloads his schedule while trying to satisfy his father’s deadline and keep up with hockey. Jacobs notices the distance but chooses to ask directly rather than follow him or assume betrayal. During a quiet evening, Jacobs tells Beck he loves him, then gives him room to explain.
Beck reveals that he wants to create a hockey camp for high-school players who cannot afford elite coaching, but fears the idea will not support him. Jacobs supports the goal and helps him think beyond short-term approval.
With advice from Zach’s friend Ray, they consider structuring the camp as a nonprofit that Beckett Enterprises could fund and use for tax benefits. Jacobs sees his own experience as a scholarship player reflected in the camp’s purpose, and agrees to help build the plan.
The couple’s first major conflict is not a betrayal but an omission driven by fear. Beck hides the plan because the stakes are personal: failure could mean losing financial security and returning to a life chosen by his father. Jacobs’s decision to ask, rather than surveil or accuse, models a different kind of intimacy from their earlier contests. His declaration of love does not solve the practical problem; it creates enough safety for Beck to name what he wants. The nonprofit proposal then joins private desire to public use. Beck’s camp is not merely an escape from family power. It converts his privilege into access for players who lacked the resources he took for granted.
The Plan Gets Backing
Over Thanksgiving, Beck presents his hockey-camp proposal to his father, explaining its nonprofit structure and the value it could bring to underserved players. His father recognizes the strength of the plan and promises to take it to the company board, while agreeing to give Baby a serious chance to contribute.
The approval does not make Beck’s future effortless, but it gives him a path outside the executive role he never wanted. On New Year’s Eve, he and Jacobs travel to Montreal to watch Grant play for the NHL.
After Grant’s team wins, Beck discusses the camp with him, and Grant offers to help when his schedule allows. Jacobs is preparing for physiotherapy work near his family, and the men imagine ways to combine their skills. They enter the new year committed to building a future together, with hockey still at its center.
The resolution is not a clean break from Beck’s family but a renegotiation of what family resources are for. Beck’s father grants support because Beck has made a persuasive, practical case, and because his son has finally demonstrated that resistance can produce a plan rather than mere defiance. The promise to consider Baby’s abilities addresses the gendered logic that shaped both siblings’ futures. At Montreal, Grant’s presence links the old team to Beck and Jacobs’s next phase, but the couple’s project no longer depends on hockey fame alone. Their future is collaborative: Beck brings resources and initiative, Jacobs brings clinical training and lived knowledge of financial barriers.
Analysis
The novel uses a sports rivalry to ask what counts as earned success when two people begin from unequal positions. Jacobs’s scholarship makes discipline a condition of survival: a poor grade or reckless choice could cost him both education and hockey. Beck’s wealth buffers him from consequences, but it also gives his father control over his future. Their antagonism begins in a real asymmetry, not a simple misunderstanding. Jacobs sees Beck’s freedom as carelessness; Beck mistakes Jacobs’s guardedness for joyless judgment. Their attraction does not erase those judgments. It forces each man to discover what the other’s behavior protects.
Hockey provides the pair with a shared language for conflict, trust, and ambition. On the ice, they already know how to anticipate each other; off it, they must learn to distinguish playful provocation from genuine care. The captaincy plot tests this distinction. Jacobs can surrender an advantage without becoming passive, and Beck can accept a lesser title without treating it as defeat. Leadership becomes less a prize than a practice of making room for someone else.
The book also refuses to turn identity into a puzzle with one mandatory answer. Jacobs and Beck explore attraction at different speeds, and Grant’s example offers information rather than a verdict. Their relationship becomes legible through choices: exclusivity, disclosure, asking instead of assuming, and taking one another’s plans seriously. The emotional climax is therefore not simply their public acceptance as a couple. It is the moment Beck admits what future he wants and Jacobs helps him plan for it.
That future joins romance to material responsibility. Beck’s proposed nonprofit camp redirects family money toward young players who lack access, while Jacobs brings experience of the barriers those players face. Their partnership does not dissolve economic difference; it gives them a way to use it honestly. By the end, love is neither an escape from work nor a reward for perfect self-knowledge. It is a working alliance in which both men can choose a life, revise their assumptions, and build something beyond the roles handed to them.
Review Summary
Face Offs & Cheap Shots receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, averaging 4.17 stars. Readers praise the enemies-to-lovers romance between hockey players Jacobs and Beck, highlighting their exceptional banter, chemistry, and natural relationship progression. The "gay chicken" challenge serves as a catalyst for their attraction. Reviewers appreciate the double bi-awakening, low angst, excellent communication, and lack of unnecessary drama. Many consider it superior to the first book in the CU Hockey series, with several calling it their favorite couple. The steamy scenes feel purposeful rather than gratuitous, and the humor consistently delights readers throughout.
People Also Read
Characters
Christopher Jacobs
The driven scholarship captainA senior forward at Colchester, Jacobs has built his place on the team through discipline, high grades, and years of effort. His hockey scholarship is tied to academic performance, so he experiences mistakes as threats with real consequences, not harmless adventures. He is loyal to his family’s farm and plans a practical career that will let him help at home. His bluntness and guardedness can read as judgment, especially around Beck’s wealth and easy charm. Under that stern surface is a man who pays close attention, protects teammates instinctively, and struggles to trust feelings he cannot immediately explain. The captaincy matters to him because it stands for earned recognition and a future he can control.
TJ Beckett
The restless golden boyBeck is a gifted defenseman whose money, confidence, and quick humor make him seem untouchable. He enjoys attention and risk, partly because both keep him from dwelling on a future his father has planned for him. The ease with which he can charm people sometimes hides how little emotional security he feels at home. On the ice, he is more than a bruiser: he reads plays well and can teach younger players with patience. Beck is drawn to novelty, but he also wants work that feels consequential. His relationship with Jacobs challenges his assumption that life is best handled as a series of temporary thrills, while his family’s expectations force him to consider what freedom would actually require.
Foster Grant
The departed captainGrant is Colchester’s former captain, an exceptional player whose skill and natural authority shaped the team. He has been Jacobs’s close friend and a model of leadership for the younger players. Open about his sexuality, Grant has also helped make the locker room a place where teammates are expected to respect one another. His NHL opportunity gives the team a new captaincy to fill, and his experience later offers Jacobs and Beck a useful perspective on attraction and identity. Grant is confident without being detached from the people who helped him reach the professional game.
Zach
Grant's observant partnerZach is Grant’s boyfriend, a thoughtful and academically inclined outsider to the hockey team’s usual culture. His quiet perceptiveness lets him notice emotional currents that the players mistake for ordinary bickering. He does not always know how to navigate the team’s rough humor, but he is willing to say what he sees and to support Grant without trying to compete with hockey for his attention. Zach’s relationship offers Jacobs and Beck an example of affection that is steady rather than performative.
Baby Beckett
The overlooked younger sisterBeck’s younger sister studies at Harvard and is both sharp and ambitious. She wants her father to take her business ideas seriously, yet family expectations favor her brother as the future company leader. Her anger at being dismissed sends her to Colchester, where she can lean on Beck without pretending everything at home is fine. She knows him well enough to notice when his behavior changes and is comfortable teasing him about it. Baby’s situation reveals that the Beckett family’s restrictions burden both siblings, though they take different forms.
Theodore Beckett
The controlling patriarchBeck’s father runs Beckett Enterprises and expects his son to inherit the company. He values stability, reputation, and a conventional path to adulthood, and he often mistakes resistance for immaturity. His assumptions about gender and leadership also shape how he treats Baby’s ambitions. Theodore is not an easy person to confront because he controls much of the family’s financial security, but his certainty is not the whole of him. He can listen when presented with an argument he respects, even if doing so requires him to reconsider his ideas about what is best for his children.
Jessica Beckett
The glamorous motherBeck’s mother is warm, exuberant, and less bound by the conventions her husband enforces. Her past as a Playboy model is a source of family embarrassment and humor, but she is not merely an ornament in the Beckett household. She tries to welcome people Beck loves and is more comfortable than Theodore with difference. Her support has limits within the family’s power structure, yet her presence gives Beck a glimpse of acceptance even when a difficult conversation with his father is underway.
Coach Hogan
The measured team coachHogan coaches the Colchester hockey team and oversees its summer training camp. He sees both Jacobs and Beck as credible leaders, which is why he initially lets the players’ opinions influence the captaincy decision. His focus is not simply on individual statistics; he watches how players work with the team and with younger prospects. Hogan’s authority gives the competition its stakes, but he also recognizes that leadership can take more than one form.
Cohen
The instigator teammateCohen is one of the teammates who spends the summer at camp, and he supplies much of its unruly energy. He turns the captain contest into a sequence of dares, eager to entertain the group even when his ideas test the players’ judgment. Beneath the mischief, he is a loyal friend who cares about the team and wants its members to take part rather than stand apart. His challenges push Jacobs and Beck into situations they would not choose for themselves.
Rossi
The practical teammateRossi is a teammate who often helps keep the group’s antics within bounds. He participates in the summer challenges but also notices when a joke could become unsafe or have consequences. His steady presence makes him a useful foil to Cohen’s enthusiasm and Beck’s appetite for risk. Rossi is among the players who help create the social space in which Jacobs and Beck can move from rivalry toward trust.
Lenny Jacobs
The welcoming farm fatherLenny runs the family farm with his wife and children. He is physically imposing but welcoming, and his easy humor helps put Beck at ease when he visits. He understands that Jacobs needs a future beyond hockey, while remaining proud of his son’s place on the team. Lenny’s approach to family is practical and affectionate, expressed through shared work and an open door.
Jenny Jacobs
The openly supportive motherJenny helps run the Jacobs farm and brings a lively, accepting spirit to the household. She treats Beck warmly and makes clear that her family has room for people who do not fit conventional expectations. Her humor can embarrass her sons, but her acceptance is not conditional on them explaining themselves perfectly. Jenny represents a home where care is shown through welcome, work, and ordinary inclusion.
Tony Jacobs
The farm-minded brotherTony is Jacobs’s younger brother and is already deeply involved in the family farm. His practical commitment gives Jacobs one less reason to abandon hockey and school out of guilt.
Rafter Jacobs
The teasing younger brotherRafter is one of Jacobs’s younger brothers. He joins the family’s teasing and shows how noisy, affectionate, and crowded the farm household can be.
Cole Jacobs
The youngest brotherCole is Jacobs’s youngest brother. His adolescent teasing adds to the lively family atmosphere that Beck encounters at the farm.
Seth Grant
Grant's twin brotherSeth is Foster Grant’s twin, though the brothers do not look alike. He drives the group to Montreal and lends a quieter counterpoint to the hockey players’ relentless joking.
Ray
The nonprofit-minded friendRay is a friend of Zach’s whose practical observation helps Beck and Jacobs consider a nonprofit structure for the proposed hockey camp.
Plot Devices
The captaincy contest
A rivalry with real stakesGrant’s departure opens the Colchester captaincy, setting Jacobs and Beck against each other for a role both value for different reasons. Coach Hogan’s initial decision to let the team choose makes popularity part of the contest, while the summer dares dramatize the difference between being entertaining and being responsible. The competition also gives the men a socially acceptable reason to focus intensely on each other. Its eventual outcome matters less than the way each man changes his understanding of winning and leadership. This device’s resolution is a spoiler.
The summer hockey camp
A laboratory for leadershipThe camp brings the team together for several weeks of coaching, skating, and mentoring high-school players. It keeps Jacobs and Beck in close contact after the academic year ends and lets their rivalry unfold through practical work rather than only locker-room banter. For Beck, teaching becomes an unexpected source of purpose; for Jacobs, camp reinforces the value of discipline and team responsibility. The younger players also make the men visible as role models, foreshadowing the kind of hockey work Beck may want beyond college.
The team dares
Competition becomes intimacyCohen’s challenges begin as comic tests of the two captain candidates, ranging from drinking and collecting phone numbers to streaking, kissing, and the final vandalism stunt. Each dare creates a new contest, but the sequence steadily narrows the distance between Jacobs and Beck. The kissing challenge makes their attraction difficult to dismiss, while the statue challenge creates a concrete moment of trust when Jacobs chooses to help Beck escape. The dares therefore move the plot from public rivalry to private recognition. The device’s outcomes are spoilers.
The hockey camp proposal
A future built from privilegeBeck’s ambition to create a camp for high-school players who cannot afford elite coaching gathers the novel’s personal and economic conflicts into one plan. His wealth gives him access to resources, but Jacobs’s scholarship experience helps him understand who is excluded from expensive training. A nonprofit structure could make the camp useful to young players while giving Beckett Enterprises a reason to support it. The plan asks Beck to use inherited privilege differently, and it gives Jacobs a way to combine hockey with his practical training. Its approval is a spoiler.
CU Hockey Series
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.