Plot Summary
The Best Man Returns
Jess Canning has spent months planning the wedding of her youngest brother, Jamie, and his fiancé, professional hockey player Ryan Wesley. At their rehearsal dinner, she is still adjusting silverware and flowers when Blake Riley, Wes's loud, handsome best man, arrives with fresh jokes about glitter and banners.
Jess wants nothing to do with him, especially after their encounter in Toronto the previous spring, when they slept together while caring for Jamie during a serious illness.
She has kept that mistake from her family and intends not to repeat it. Her work has already made her feel scrutinized: relatives praise the event as if her competence is a surprise, while she privately prepares to tell them that party planning is not her future.
The wedding gives Jess a public task and a private test. Her precision is not simply aesthetic fussiness; it is an attempt to earn a stable place in a family that has come to expect her to change direction. Blake disrupts that carefully managed performance because he knows her outside the role of capable sister and event planner. Their sexual history makes his arrival emotionally consequential before either admits attraction. The absent Wesley family also shadows the celebration, setting up the contrast between the family support Jess can organize and the support Wes has been denied.
The Wedding Gets Rescued
The wedding morning starts with Blake drunk on Jess's couch after giving his hotel room to his married date. He wakes in Jess's bed, and she escapes his embrace before they can turn their teasing into another hookup.
He then helps with errands, but replaces her white balloons with oversized blue hockey fingers and gets her grandmother tipsy at the airport. Jess is furious until the ceremony begins and Blake finally arrives with Angela Wesley, Wes's mother, whom he has quietly persuaded to attend after months of unanswered family calls.
Wes welcomes her, and Jess signals the musicians to begin. Blake escorts Jess down the aisle, while her parents accompany Jamie and Wes. The ceremony proceeds through family readings, a toddler carrying the rings, and vows that leave Wes in tears.
Blake's help arrives in two forms, one spectacularly inconvenient and one deeply considerate. His balloon prank exposes how poorly he reads Jess's need for control, but his effort to bring Angela gives the wedding the family presence Jess could not manufacture herself. The contrast complicates her judgment of him: he is disruptive, yet attentive to the emotional needs of others. For Wes, his mother's arrival cannot erase years of estrangement, but it lets him enter marriage with a family member present. Jess's meticulously planned ceremony becomes meaningful because of an act she did not plan.
Jess Changes Her Future
After the ceremony, guests celebrate Jamie and Wes while Jess slips away to the garden and cries over her mother's praise. She fears that telling her family she no longer wants to plan events will make their approval disappear. Blake finds her and listens as she explains that she wants to become a nurse, a direction inspired by the care Jamie received in hospital.
His reassurance steadies her, and they kiss; he then gives her pleasure in the garden, renewing the attraction she had tried to contain. Later, her mother asks her to take the newlyweds to the airport. Jess agrees, then admits that event planning is not right for her. Her mother worries about the cost of nursing school, but Jess insists she will find a way herself.
Jess's career decision is inseparable from her need to be recognized as an adult rather than managed as the family's unreliable child. Her mother's praise does not solve that insecurity; it makes the risk of disappointing her more immediate. Blake offers affirmation without pretending that her choice is easy, which helps Jess separate ability from vocation. The garden encounter also shows how quickly physical intimacy can provide comfort without resolving their mismatch in expectations. Jess leaves the wedding with a goal, but not yet with confidence that she can sustain it.
The Cancer Ward Lesson
Months later, Jess moves to Toronto after receiving a place at a competitive nursing program and a probationary scholarship. Her roommate, Violet Smith, imposes strict study rules, leaving Jess anxious about fitting in and keeping her funding.
During a pediatric oncology assignment, Jess freezes as other students choose patients, then sits with Leila, a teenager with stage-four cancer who is struggling to knit a hat for her younger brother. Jess repairs the dropped stitches and helps her learn the ribbing.
When Leila admits she may not live until Christmas, Jess is overwhelmed and leaves before the clinical debrief. Blake later asks what she noticed. As she describes Leila's bruises, fatigue, pallor, and steady hands, he helps her see that she had observed more than she realized.
Jess's connection with Leila begins where her formal training falters. She cannot yet separate compassionate attention from the fear of witnessing suffering, so she leaves before she can report what she has seen. Yet the practical knowledge she brings to knitting gives Leila a small, concrete success and a way to make something for her brother. Blake's questions help Jess recognize that care includes noticing details, not just completing a checklist. This episode establishes a tension that follows her through school: her empathy is a clinical strength, but she must learn to remain present long enough to use it.
A Favor in the Hummer
Blake proposes taking Violet out with his teammates so she and Jess can find common ground beyond nursing school. At the bar, Violet's reserve gives way when she recognizes Blake and meets the players, while Jess discovers she has a way into her roommate's attention. Will O'Connor flirts with Jess, and Blake intervenes with unmistakable jealousy.
Jess challenges him, but leaves with him and they have sex in the back of his Hummer. Afterward, Blake asks her to pose as his girlfriend at his sister's baby shower, hoping to discourage an ex who will be there. Jess agrees as a favor, not a commitment. The arrangement forces her to meet the Riley family and puts Blake's unresolved past directly in front of her.
The bar scene works because Blake helps Jess socially without making himself the center of her nursing-school problem. Violet's excitement about the hockey players gives the roommates an unexpected point of connection, though Jess's renewed intimacy with Blake quickly complicates the evening. Blake's jealousy reveals an attachment he has not earned the right to claim, and Jess resists being treated as someone already spoken for. Their sex is mutual, but their expectations remain mismatched. The fake-date request then turns a private arrangement into a social performance, placing Jess inside Blake's family life before she knows what his history there means.
The Riley Family Test
At the shower, Blake introduces Jess as his girlfriend, surprising his sisters and unsettling Molly, his former fiancée and Brenna's close friend. Jess notices the strain but keeps playing her part. On the drive home, she asks about the grief she overheard Molly and Brenna discussing.
Blake explains that Molly once told him she was pregnant while they were engaged, then tried to make the claim real by seeking fertility medication. He discovered the lie at her doctor's office and ended the engagement.
To protect Molly's place in the family, he let everyone believe she had miscarried. Jess is appalled that he has carried the blame and the secret for five years. Her sympathy makes Blake feel understood, even as she sees how his habit of protecting others has cost him.
The fake pregnancy is not merely a deception between former lovers; it has become a family story that assigns guilt and innocence across years. Blake chose silence to protect Molly and preserve his sister's friendship, but that choice requires him to accept a false account of his own past. Jess sees the cost clearly because she is already sensitive to how family judgments shape identity. Her anger is protective, though it cannot undo the secret. The scene also clarifies Blake's moral pattern: he would rather absorb injury himself than risk making people he loves suffer.
A Kiss Before the Encore
At a Toronto game, Jess sits beside Blake's exuberant mother, Annette, and endures her probing questions about their supposed relationship. Blake scores, and his mother celebrates Jess as if she already belongs with the family.
Later, Jess asks Blake to take her to a benefit where Hozier is performing. He spends the evening jealous of her attention to the singer, while she learns that he has raised substantial money for a dog rescue and volunteered at its shelters.
A rescue-dog slideshow moves Jess to tears, and she squeezes his hand. They slip into a coatroom and have sex, but O'Connor catches them leaving. Jess dismisses the encounter as a foolish lapse, and Blake hears her judgment as proof that he matters less to her than she matters to him.
Blake's charity work makes visible a tenderness that his comic, sexually confident persona often hides. Jess responds to the rescue story because it aligns with her own instinct to care for vulnerable people, creating a bond deeper than attraction. Yet the coatroom encounter remains hurried and undefined. When O'Connor witnesses it, Jess protects her privacy by minimizing what happened, but Blake hears the minimization as rejection. Their central conflict is now less about whether they desire one another than whether Jess can trust a relationship and Blake can risk asking for one plainly.
The Elevator Confession
After the benefit, Blake's concentration slips at practice, while Jess studies for a difficult final and worries that she has failed. She reaches out, and the two spend an evening together at his apartment. Their intimacy deepens, and Blake insists that sleeping in his bed means they are dating; Jess resists the label even as she stays close to him.
The next morning, she finally tells Wes that she and Blake are together when he catches them kissing in the elevator. Blake is elated. At school, Jess learns she earned an A-minus in anatomy and a B-minus in pharmacology, both enough to keep her on track. Her instructors also praise her patient care, confirming that her strengths extend beyond exam scores.
The elevator turns a private relationship into a choice Jess is willing to own in front of people whose opinions matter. Her acceptance does not arrive through a grand romantic argument; it follows a week in which she sees Blake hurt and decides not to leave him alone in that uncertainty. The academic results provide a parallel correction to her self-image. Jess is not the failure she fears she is: she performs well in class and earns trust through patient care. The book links commitment and vocation through the same act of courage, which is continuing despite imperfect confidence.
Home Is a Team Sport
When Jess admits she cannot afford to visit California for Thanksgiving, Blake offers to buy her ticket. She initially refuses another handout, but accepts the gift and returns from home feeling restored.
Their closeness grows, and Blake's apartment becomes a second home, especially as Jess and Violet settle into a less hostile roommate routine. At a WAGS gathering, Jess watches a Toronto game with Jamie and hears the players' partners identify her as Blake's girlfriend after he blows a kiss toward the camera.
She is embarrassed, but also warmed by the team's welcome. The domestic ease and public recognition make their relationship harder to dismiss as a temporary convenience, while Jess still works to preserve her independence and manage school without leaning entirely on Blake.
The flight forces Jess to distinguish dependence from mutual care. She fears that accepting money will confirm her family's view of her as unable to manage her own life, while Blake understands the ticket as a gift that lets her return to people she misses. Their differing interpretations do not disappear, but his offer respects what she values rather than purchasing access to her. The WAGS gathering adds a public dimension: the hockey community recognizes Jess as part of Blake's life before she fully knows how to inhabit that role. Belonging here is practical, affectionate, and negotiated.
The Lie Breaks at Lunch
At Sunday lunch with the Rileys, Molly again speaks as though she experienced a pregnancy and miscarriage with Blake. When his sister Brenna defends Molly's grief, Blake finally tells the whole family there was never a baby. He leaves the house, shaken by the years he spent protecting a lie that has kept Molly close to his family.
Jess stays behind as the room absorbs the truth. Brenna then becomes dizzy and vomits; Jess recognizes her severe swelling and headache as possible preeclampsia and urges the family to take her to the emergency room. Blake is still reeling, but the crisis gives Jess an immediate task and redirects the family's attention from accusation to Brenna's health.
The revelation breaks the social arrangement Blake built around his hurt. His silence had protected Molly from consequences, but it also allowed his family to misunderstand him and kept him emotionally tied to the deception. Speaking plainly is painful because it threatens his relationship with Brenna, who trusted the story. The sudden medical emergency tests Jess in a different register: she must act before certainty is available. Her attention to Brenna's symptoms demonstrates the clinical judgment Blake helped her recognize earlier, converting her anxiety into responsible action.
The Baby Arrives Early
At the hospital, doctors confirm that Brenna has preeclampsia and move her for an emergency C-section. Blake blames himself for the family argument, but Jess and the doctor make clear that Brenna's symptoms had been building all week and were not caused by his outburst. The Rileys wait together until Brenna's husband emerges with news that their daughter is safe.
Jess, exhausted and frightened by how close the situation might have come to disaster, finally lets Blake comfort her. The family gathers at the nursery window to meet the newborn, Annalise Jessica Daly. Her middle name honors Jess, who recognized the danger and pushed for care. The birth gives the family a reason to unite after the lunch's painful revelation.
The emergency does not erase the family rupture, but it changes what the family must attend to. Jess's warning is consequential because it turns an uncertain impression into a medical evaluation before Brenna's condition worsens. Blake's guilt shows how readily he assumes responsibility for pain around him, even when the cause is unrelated to him. Jess counters that reflex with evidence and steadiness. The baby's name offers recognition of Jess's contribution without implying that she has become responsible for saving everyone. Care here means noticing risk, escalating appropriately, and allowing others to share the fear.
Jess Bars the Door
Back at Blake's condo, Jess finds Molly waiting outside and refuses to let her enter while Blake is showering. Molly threatens to damage Jess's standing with the hockey partners unless she helps secure Blake's forgiveness.
Jess rejects the threat and reminds Molly that Blake protected her secret for years at the cost of his own reputation. Blake overhears Jess defending him, a form of loyalty he has rarely received. He asks her to move in, making clear that she can contribute to expenses rather than accept a handout.
Before she answers, Jess reveals a chocolate Labrador puppy she arranged through the dog rescue Blake supports. Blake accepts the puppy and Jess accepts his proposal, choosing a shared home without surrendering her independence.
Jess's refusal at the door marks a shift from being Blake's temporary date to actively protecting the relationship they have built. She does not forgive Molly on Blake's behalf or dictate how he must respond; she simply prevents another intrusion and names the imbalance in their history. Blake's invitation to share his home is more careful than his earlier assumption that they were dating, because he addresses Jess's fear of financial dependence. The puppy is not a cure for his past loss, but it gives him a new responsibility grounded in care rather than secrecy.
The KissCam Names Them
Jess packs her books out of the dorm and leaves Violet with a promise to meet again in class. At the arena, she joins the WAGS box, where the partners welcome her with a jersey, team gear, and a playful welcome packet. Blake scores, and Jess takes the customary celebratory tequila shot before heading down to greet his parents.
Annette insists that Jess cheer like a Riley, and Jess joins her in shouting through the final moments of the game. Blake spots Jess near the players' tunnel and kisses her in front of the crowd. The kiss appears on the arena's KissCam, making their relationship public to thousands. Jess accepts the attention with a grin, no longer treating love as something she must keep at a safe distance.
The final arena scene gathers the book's recurring forms of belonging into one noisy public ritual. Jess has a place in Blake's home, in his family's circle, and now among the partners who share the pressures of a hockey season. Her cheerleading with Annette is not a surrender of her own identity; it is a chosen participation in a family style that once overwhelmed her. The KissCam makes private affection visible, but the emotional resolution has already happened through the smaller acts that precede it: Jess's work, her boundaries, and the couple's decision to share a life.
Analysis
Good Boy makes its romantic argument through practical acts of care. Blake's humor can make him seem unserious, but his choices repeatedly involve attention: he keeps calling Wes's mother, supports a dog rescue, comforts Jess when she doubts her clinical ability, and responds to the Riley family's needs. Jess, meanwhile, is not asked to abandon independence for love. Her nursing education matters in its own right, and Blake's support becomes meaningful when it helps her pursue that goal rather than replace it.
The novel's two central conflicts turn on mistaken ideas about responsibility. Jess believes changing careers confirms her family's judgment that she gives up too easily. Blake believes keeping Molly's secret is the kindest way to protect his family, even when the silence harms him. Both learn that care without honest boundaries can become self-erasure. Jess's development is visible in action: she reports what she observed, trusts her assessment of Brenna, refuses Molly access, and accepts help on terms she can live with. Blake's growth is quieter but equally concrete: he tells the truth, asks for commitment, and offers Jess a home without demanding that she surrender financial agency.
The book also treats comic excess as a form of intimacy. Blake's pranks, sexual confidence, and noisy family rituals create a comic surface, but they are not evidence of emotional shallowness. Jess's attraction grows not because he becomes a different man, but because she begins to read the care already present beneath the performance. Their eventual public kiss is earned by small, repeated choices: showing up, listening, naming what is wrong, and letting another person help. The ending's loud arena celebration suits a romance that finds security not in perfect composure, but in being welcomed as oneself.
Review Summary
People Also Read
Characters
Jess Canning
The determined nursing studentJess is Jamie's sister, a California-raised woman who has tried several careers while feeling measured against her accomplished siblings. She wants creative work, but discovers that helping patients gives her a stronger sense of purpose. Her insecurity often makes her overprepare, second-guess her abilities, and resist help even when it is offered with affection. Jess is observant and compassionate, especially with frightened patients, though she initially mistakes emotional overwhelm for professional inadequacy. Her attraction to Blake challenges her assumptions about what kind of partner she should want. She values independence and must learn that accepting care does not erase it.
Blake Riley
The generous hockey starBlake is a Toronto hockey forward, Wes's teammate, and Jamie's friend. Huge, funny, sexually confident, and nearly incapable of filtering a thought, he uses humor to keep difficult feelings at arm's length. His loyalty is practical: he calls Wes's estranged mother, helps Jess with wedding errands, supports a dog rescue, and makes time for people who need him. A past betrayal has made him distrust commitment, although he remains protective of the people around him. Blake is more emotionally perceptive than his careless manner suggests, but his eagerness can make him assume that others share his intentions.
Jamie Canning
Jess's devoted younger brotherJamie is Jess's youngest sibling and Wes's fiancé, later husband. Gentle and emotionally steady, he gives Jess a model of love that is secure rather than dramatic. He appreciates her work on the wedding and supports her nursing-school plans, even when she doubts herself. Jamie also knows Blake well enough to recognize that his joking exterior hides serious loyalty. His warm relationship with Wes anchors the wedding and gives Jess a close family connection in Toronto.
Ryan Wesley
Jamie's hockey-star husbandWes is a successful Toronto hockey player, Jamie's partner, and Blake's closest teammate. He is more private and tightly wound than Blake, especially around public attention and his estranged parents. Jamie's steadiness gives him room to show vulnerability, while his friendship with Blake is built on trust earned through their team life. Wes also supports Jess as she settles into Toronto, treating her as family rather than as a guest.
Violet Smith
Jess's exacting roommateViolet is Jess's nursing-school roommate, a gifted and highly competitive student who begins their shared life with strict rules. Her confidence in academic settings makes Jess feel even less prepared, and her habit of displaying what she knows can read as contempt. Violet is also carrying pressure from a family whose identity is closely tied to medicine. Her relationship with Jess softens as they find common ground, revealing that achievement does not protect her from insecurity.
Molly
Blake's complicated former fiancéeMolly is Blake's former fiancée and Brenna's longtime friend. Her place in the Riley family is strong enough that her history with Blake affects gatherings years after their relationship ends. She is socially composed and accustomed to being treated as part of the family, which makes her presence difficult for Blake to avoid. Her connection to Brenna and to the Riley household places personal loyalty in tension with the truth.
Brenna Riley
Blake's expectant sisterBrenna is one of Blake's sisters, pregnant with her first child and closely connected to Molly. She is protective of her friend and expects Blake to account for the grief she believes they share. Her loyalty makes the family secret especially painful when it is challenged. Brenna's pregnancy also brings the Riley family together around practical care and the arrival of a new child.
Annette Riley
The roaring Riley matriarchAnnette is Blake's loud, affectionate mother, a generous host and an unapologetic hockey fan. She measures love through food, physical affection, and enthusiastic involvement in her children's lives. Her bluntness can overwhelm newcomers, but her instincts are sharp: she notices family tensions and wants her children protected. She welcomes Jess through the rituals that define the Riley household.
Leila
The young patient knitterLeila is a teenager receiving treatment for advanced cancer. Frustrated by her knitting, she is making a hat for her younger brother and appreciates being treated as a person with interests, not only as a patient. Her frankness about uncertainty unsettles Jess, but their shared work gives Jess an early lesson in attentive care.
Dyson Hart
Jess's candid nurse friendDyson is Jess's stylish, talkative friend and a nurse. He offers practical encouragement about nursing school and later shares a useful technique for helping elderly patients relax. His blunt humor makes him an easy confidant, while his clinical experience gives Jess an accessible picture of the work she is considering.
Plot Devices
The wedding
A forced reunionJamie and Wes's wedding puts Jess and Blake together as maid of honor and best man after their earlier hookup. Its schedule creates reasons for them to argue, work together, and confront the attraction Jess wants to deny. The event also gives Blake a chance to help Wes reconnect with his mother, while Jess's success hosting the celebration prompts her to reconsider whether event planning is truly her vocation.
Nursing school
A test of self-trustJess's competitive nursing program gives her a second storyline beyond romance. The scholarship makes grades consequential, while clinical assignments test skills that cannot be measured by exams alone. Her encounters with Leila and later Brenna reveal her ability to notice, comfort, and act. School therefore challenges Jess's self-image through specific tasks rather than through abstract encouragement.
The fake pregnancy
A family-shaping secretYears before the main story, Molly told Blake she was pregnant while they were engaged. After discovering the claim was false, Blake concealed the truth and allowed his family to believe she had miscarried. That choice preserves Molly's standing with Brenna but leaves Blake carrying the cost of a story that recurs at family gatherings. The secret turns a private betrayal into a conflict about loyalty, reputation, and who gets to define the past.
Hockey and the WAGS
A ready-made communityThe Toronto team links Blake to Jamie and Wes, supplies recurring social occasions, and makes Jess's relationship visible to a wider circle. Games and charity events provide settings where athletic status matters less than the choices players make off the ice. The WAGS group gives Jess a place among the partners, while its rituals, from cheering to celebratory drinks, turn the hockey season into shared social life.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.