Plot Summary
Prologue
Preston Carmichael lies on the dining-room table while his surgeon father cuts and stitches his abdomen as punishment. He has learned to keep his face still, study the ceiling, and help clean up afterward. His father is also forcing him to abandon the Boston hockey future he chose for a place at Darby University in Colorado, closer to home.
Preston accepts the move because his younger sister, Lily, is still vulnerable to their father’s control. With his body already mapped by scars and his plans repeatedly overruled, he leaves for college determined to endure until Lily can escape.
The opening makes abuse a practiced routine rather than a single eruption. Preston’s attention to the ceiling, controlled breathing, and automatic cleanup show how a child survives by turning terror into procedure. His transfer is not merely a change of school: his father can still dictate his life from a distance, while Preston believes protecting Lily requires obedience. The careful public image of a celebrated surgeon stands against the private ritual of cutting his son. This establishes the central conflict between what others see as privilege and the bodily cost hidden beneath it.
The Roommate From Boston
Jeremy Albrooke arrives at Darby University eager to play hockey beside his friends from the junior leagues. Coach announces that elite defenseman Preston Carmichael is transferring in, and Jeremy learns Preston will share his dorm room. Their first meeting is spectacularly awkward: Preston walks in while Jeremy’s longtime friend Brendon is giving him a blowjob.
Brendon flees, leaving the roommates to size each other up. Preston offers little beyond cold judgment, while Jeremy tries to be civil and refuses to feel ashamed of being gay. Preston has no interest in joining the team socially, and Jeremy cannot tell whether the hostility is personal or simply the hard edge of a player accustomed to getting his way.
The interrupted hookup puts sexuality and power in the room before either man can control the impression he makes. Jeremy meets embarrassment by asserting that his desire is nothing to apologize for; Preston meets intimacy with withdrawal and contempt. Their cramped dorm makes avoidance impossible, while hockey gives both a socially acceptable language for aggression. The scene also complicates Preston’s reputation: Jeremy knows his brutal performance on ice, but the rigid young man in the doorway seems less triumphant than guarded. Their rivalry begins as a clash of manners, but its charge comes from the attention each pays to the other.
A Spectator in the Showers
Preston pushes the team through punishing practices, publicly criticizing Jeremy’s footwork, speed, and eating habits. The captain urges the players to treat the criticism as a chance to improve, but Jeremy takes it as a personal attack.
Preston’s relentless training has another purpose: exercise silences the fear and shame his father has planted in him. After one practice, Preston catches Jeremy and Brendon having sex in the showers. Rather than expose them, he watches from the locker area and masturbates, locking eyes with Jeremy.
The encounter leaves Jeremy confused about Preston’s interest and makes their hostility harder to dismiss as simple dislike. Preston retreats into his routines, while Jeremy begins imagining what the hard-edged defenseman might be like in private.
Hockey becomes both a shared discipline and a cover for unequal forms of control. Preston can name every flaw in another player because he has internalized a system that measures worth through performance. Yet his watching of Jeremy exposes desire without requiring him to risk direct contact. The gaze turns a humiliating scene into a private exchange, but it leaves Jeremy uncertain whether he has been seen as a person or as a spectacle. Preston’s self-punishing workouts and public perfection suggest that discipline is less a route to ambition than a way to quiet an intolerable inner life.
Control Breaks Through
After another interrupted attempt to hook up with Brendon, Jeremy confronts Preston for driving his friend away. Preston responds by pinning Jeremy against a dresser and masturbating him, then orders him back to hockey as though the encounter meant nothing.
Jeremy is startled by how much he wanted the force and certainty Preston brought to the moment. Preston, meanwhile, runs himself to collapse at the gym, trying to bury his desire beneath exhaustion and self-reproach.
Their next practices sharpen the tension: Preston deliberately checks Jeremy and needles him until Jeremy shoves him. When Jeremy later kisses him in an empty hallway, Preston kisses back, then punches him as approaching voices trigger panic. He bolts barefoot across campus, leaving Jeremy bruised and worried.
The sudden intimacy gives each man something he has wanted, but neither yet knows how to hold it safely. Jeremy discovers that his attraction is tied to being handled with confidence, while Preston experiences desire as a dangerous loss of control. The kiss is therefore followed not by rejection alone but by an old survival response: he strikes, flees, and tries to outrun the consequences. Jeremy’s concern after being hurt marks an important shift. He does not reduce Preston to the harm he caused, though his compassion now carries the risk of becoming an excuse for it.
Dinner Under Watch
Before the team dinner at Preston’s father’s home, Preston insists Jeremy change into a proper suit and warns him to avoid conversation with Doctor Andrew Carmichael. The elaborate meal seems welcoming, but Preston stands stiffly beside his father, barely present.
When Preston disappears, Jeremy searches for him and finds Andrew berating him in private, threatening his sister and calling his son a failure. Jeremy interrupts, forcing Andrew to turn on his public charm.
He answers the surgeon’s questions and says he plays hockey to fund his education, not to reach the NHL. Back with the team, Jeremy stays close rather than leaving Preston alone. Later, Preston seeks him out for rough sex, using control to quiet the fear stirred by his father’s home.
The dinner reveals how effectively Andrew separates public benevolence from private cruelty. The catered meal and team sponsorship make the father appear generous, while Preston’s stillness registers the cost of being displayed as a successful son. Jeremy’s interruption is meaningful because it challenges Andrew’s control without pretending to rescue Preston outright. Yet the intimacy that follows is not uncomplicated comfort: physical dominance is the form of contact Preston can tolerate and direct. The contrast asks whether care can enter a relationship through an existing language of power, and what trust will require beyond it.
The Cost of Leaving
As Darby’s season begins, Preston keeps criticizing Jeremy while his attention on him grows increasingly possessive. Their first encounters become a secret sexual arrangement, but Preston still cannot bear ordinary touch, and Jeremy does not yet know why. During a game, Preston is sent off after fighting an opponent; afterward, his father takes him away.
Jeremy sees the fear beneath Preston’s composure and waits for him to return. Preston comes back exhausted, and that night Jeremy comforts him through a nightmare. In the morning Preston shoves him away, unable to accept the same closeness in daylight. The pattern repeats: Preston seeks Jeremy when terror overwhelms him, then denies the need once he regains control.
The separation exposes the cost of Preston’s dependence before he can name it. His father’s authority reaches beyond the home and into hockey, where a penalty becomes an opening for renewed punishment. Jeremy’s nighttime comfort offers a different kind of physical contact, but Preston can accept it only while half-conscious and frightened. The morning rejection protects him from vulnerability while wounding the person who stayed. This cycle is not simple mixed messaging: it shows a nervous system trained to associate touch with danger, struggling against a genuine wish for connection.
Scars in the Light
Weeks of secret closeness do not stop Preston’s father from summoning him again. During a later game, Preston fights violently after an opponent targets Jeremy, earning another ejection. Jeremy is injured in the same brawl and sent to the hospital, where Andrew visits the dorm and handles Jeremy’s wound without permission. Preston returns from his father’s penthouse cold, sleepless, and marked by fresh cuts.
When Jeremy sees the stitched injuries, Preston collapses against him and sobs. He has never shown anyone the evidence of his father’s punishments. Jeremy holds him through a nightmare rather than demanding explanations, and Preston wakes disoriented. For once, he lets Jeremy see the scars before retreating behind his usual mask.
The two injuries make visible the unequal meanings of bodily contact. Jeremy’s hockey wound is treated as an accident to be cleaned and stitched; Preston’s injuries are deliberate, hidden, and administered by a respected physician. Andrew’s unauthorized handling of Jeremy’s face hints that he sees other bodies as objects within his reach. Preston’s collapse is not a sudden cure, but a break in the secrecy that has protected his father. Jeremy’s response matters because he neither looks away nor turns disclosure into a demand for immediate explanation.
The Truth Between Them
Preston tells Jeremy that his father has cut and stitched him since childhood, punishing perceived failures while insisting the injuries are Preston’s fault. He also explains that he has protected Lily by absorbing their father’s anger, and that his mother died when he was young.
Jeremy refuses to accept the blame Preston has learned to carry. Their relationship changes through small acts: Preston lets Jeremy hold him, accepts a gentle kiss, and admits he does not know how to touch someone without turning sex into control.
Brendon and Paul learn that Jeremy and Preston are involved, while Paul begins questioning his own sexuality. When Lily visits for Thanksgiving, Jeremy helps reunite the siblings, and Preston names his possessive bond with Jeremy as a real relationship.
Disclosure changes the meaning of earlier scenes without erasing their harm. Preston’s cruelty and rigid habits now appear as adaptations to a household where affection was conditional and pain was explained as discipline. Jeremy’s insistence that the abuse was not deserved challenges the story Preston has been forced to tell himself. The relationship’s progress is measured less by sexual intensity than by tolerable forms of care: a held hand, a kiss, a request for comfort. Lily’s visit also reveals the limits of Preston’s protective strategy. Keeping his sister ignorant has kept her safer, but it has left him alone with the truth.
A Place at Christmas
When Jeremy leaves Colorado for Christmas, Preston spirals without the nightly comfort he has come to rely on. He drinks, runs until he gets lost, and calls his father for help, only to be told to run back to campus. Teammates Paul and Brendon find him and urge him to seek Jeremy rather than hide. Preston buys a ticket to Michigan and arrives at the arena where Jeremy once played.
Jeremy brings him home, where his mother, siblings, niece Ella, and grandparents make room for him. Preston struggles with the noise and casual affection, then receives a handmade hockey quilt from Jeremy’s grandmother. Its welcome moves him to tears. He gives Jeremy a leather bracelet, and the two return to school committed to building a life together.
The Christmas visit makes belonging tangible through ordinary domestic acts: a ride, a meal, a place at the table, a blanket made by hand. Preston’s crisis shows how thoroughly Jeremy has become a source of regulation, but his decision to travel is also an act of agency. He does not wait for rescue; he seeks it. The Albrookes’ warmth unsettles his belief that closeness must be earned through usefulness or perfection. The quilt is a particularly potent counter-object to his scars: a covering made to comfort, offered without a price.
The Video Goes Public
After the holiday, Preston dislocates his shoulder during a game and is sedated at the hospital. While medicated, he speaks about his father’s cuts, making a nurse concerned about the scars on his body.
Lily’s friends inadvertently record doctors discussing the abuse and allegations against Andrew, including complaints from former patients. The clip spreads online despite attempts to delete it. Reporters gather around Preston’s team, and the university’s legal staff tells him not to make a public statement without advice.
His teammates form a protective line through the airport and shield him from questions. The attention overwhelms Preston, but Jeremy helps him stay present. For the first time, the people around Preston know enough to stand beside him openly.
The hospital converts a hidden history into public evidence, but exposure does not automatically restore Preston’s control. His disclosure is involuntary, and the viral clip risks making his body and trauma another spectacle. Yet the response differs sharply from his childhood experience of adults suppressing complaints: a nurse offers help, the university provides counsel, and teammates protect his space. The scene distinguishes visibility from consent. Public attention may create pressure for accountability, but Preston still needs the right to decide how his story is told.
Andrew’s Final Call
As reports about Andrew’s treatment of patients spread, Preston’s father calls to blame him for ruining the family and endangering Lily. Preston finally tells him he will no longer submit to his control. He condemns Andrew for harming patients and for making him believe every scar was deserved.
During the call, Andrew says he never wanted children and identifies Preston’s mother as the one person he regrets losing. The line fills with wind, then a fall and a distant scream. Police confirm that Andrew jumped from his building’s roof.
Preston calls Lily and tells her the truth about the abuse, including when it began. She grieves, but the siblings agree to live near each other after she graduates. Preston also admits he no longer wants a professional hockey career.
Preston’s confrontation is a decisive break from the logic that has organized his life: he no longer treats obedience as the price of protecting Lily. Andrew’s death ends the immediate threat but does not deliver uncomplicated freedom. Preston must absorb both the loss of a father and the recognition that the man’s authority was built on cruelty. Telling Lily the truth risks hurting her, yet it replaces protective silence with shared knowledge. His rejection of professional hockey is similarly important: for the first time, he distinguishes his own desire from the future imposed on him.
Choosing a Future Together
With Andrew dead, Preston and Lily begin untangling the practical and emotional aftermath. Preston considers suing the hospital that ignored complaints about his father, while reporters continue to pursue him. Jeremy encourages him to seek therapy, and Preston attends only with Jeremy beside him.
He describes the abuse, his distrust of doctors, and the family bonds he is beginning to accept. Jeremy makes clear that Preston’s trauma is not a burden that disqualifies him from love.
The couple decide to build a hockey camp for young players, with Jeremy coaching and Preston using his resources to create the program. When Jeremy’s family visits Colorado, Preston proposes marriage and asks to take the Albrooke name. Jeremy accepts, and Preston chooses a future no longer defined by his father.
Therapy is framed not as a device that erases trauma but as a practice of reclaiming choice. Preston enters reluctantly, with Jeremy’s presence serving as support rather than substitute for his own voice. The camp transforms hockey from an imposed measure of worth into a resource the couple can offer children. Their proposal answers the book’s opening image of scars with a different account of imperfection: damage need not be hidden, and a shared future need not depend on being fixed first. Taking Jeremy’s surname also makes belonging a deliberate choice.
Epilogue
Five years later, Preston and Jeremy open Albrooke Hockey Camp in Michigan, built with money Preston recovered from the hospital that buried complaints about his father. Jeremy coaches, Preston runs the business, and their friends and family help welcome the young players.
Preston still keeps routines and needs the reassurance of familiar touch, but his life now includes a husband, a home, a dog, and a chosen family. As the first campers arrive, he looks at the rink they created and recognizes it as a place where hockey can be offered freely, not imposed as punishment.
The epilogue resolves the book’s central question about what hockey means when it is no longer controlled by Preston’s father. The rink remains, but its function has changed: it is a shared project and a place for children to learn, not a stage on which a parent manufactures a perfect son. Preston’s work with young players turns inherited expertise into care. His continued routines suggest healing is not a clean disappearance of old responses. The difference is that he can now live with those responses inside relationships and institutions he helped choose.
Analysis
Hidden Scars builds its romance around a difficult distinction: the difference between being touched and being safe. Preston has been taught that authority can injure him while calling the injury improvement, so his early preference for controlled roughness is not simply a sexual quirk. It is a way of keeping agency inside an experience where his body has repeatedly been treated as someone else’s property. Jeremy’s care matters because it gradually broadens intimacy beyond sex, but the novel also shows the limits of love as treatment. Jeremy can hold Preston through a nightmare; he cannot undo the conditioning that makes daylight tenderness frightening. The story’s repeated cycles of closeness and withdrawal give that conflict behavioral form. Hockey mirrors it. Preston’s excellence is real, yet the discipline surrounding it has been shaped by a father who converts performance into obedience. Jeremy’s wish to coach offers a countermodel in which sport can teach without becoming punishment. Family provides another contrast: the Albrookes make belonging visible through meals, teasing, quilts, and space at the table, while Preston’s childhood home makes affection contingent on compliance. Public exposure complicates the idea of justice. The viral recording and patient allegations challenge the protection Andrew’s reputation has purchased, but they also threaten to turn Preston’s trauma into public property. His eventual move toward therapy, chosen family, and a hockey camp does not erase his scars or make his pain useful by itself. Instead, he begins choosing what his skills, body, and future are for. The novel’s hopeful claim is not that love repairs every wound. It is that dependable care can help a survivor reclaim authorship, one choice at a time.
Review Summary
Hidden Scars receives mostly positive reviews, with readers praising its emotional depth, complex characters, and intense romantic relationship. Many appreciate the author's handling of trauma and healing. The book is described as a gripping enemies-to-lovers hockey romance with steamy scenes and strong character development. Some readers found certain plot elements unrealistic or rushed, and a few felt the relationship dynamics were unhealthy. Overall, the book is considered an emotionally charged, addictive read that resonates with many fans of the genre.
Characters
Preston Carmichael
The guarded defensemanPreston is an exceptionally gifted hockey defenseman whose severe routines and cutting remarks hide years of abuse by his surgeon father. He works compulsively because exhaustion quiets his thoughts and because he believes his performance can protect his younger sister, Lily. Touch is difficult for him, while controlled roughness offers a form of intimacy he can manage. His polished appearance is both social armor and a demand imposed on him at home. Beneath the intimidation is a young man who has learned to confuse love with obedience and punishment with failure. His central struggle is to discover what he wants when hockey and his father no longer dictate the answer.
Jeremy Albrooke
The stubborn caretakerJeremy is a college hockey player who hopes to coach rather than pursue the NHL. Openly gay and close to his large Michigan family, he is funny, competitive, and more perceptive than his teasing manner suggests. He first meets Preston as a hostile roommate and rival, then notices the fear beneath Preston’s aggression. Jeremy offers care without pretending he can solve everything, though he sometimes pushes into situations before fully understanding the risks. His bond with Preston tests his tendency to fix what hurts and teaches him to respect boundaries while remaining present. He brings warmth, humor, and a grounded sense of family to Preston’s isolated world.
Andrew Carmichael
The celebrated surgeonAndrew is a famous plastic surgeon whose public charm and professional standing conceal a demand for absolute control at home. He treats Preston’s hockey career as an extension of his own ambitions and uses shame, threats, and physical harm to enforce obedience. His carefully managed image makes it difficult for others to recognize the violence behind it. Andrew’s authority depends on making his son believe that success is proof of love and pain is proof of failure.
Lily Carmichael
Preston’s protected sisterLily is Preston’s younger sister, a bright and outspoken teenager who has spent much of her life at boarding school. She loves her brother but resents his distance and does not understand the danger he has been trying to absorb for her. Her humor and independence stand in contrast to Preston’s vigilance. She is not simply someone he protects; she has her own judgments, friendships, and capacity to confront family truths.
Brendon Oiler
Jeremy’s loyal teammateBrendon is Jeremy’s longtime friend, teammate, and former casual sexual partner. He is bisexual, sociable, and fond of provoking Preston, often using humor to test the limits of a tense room. His friendship with Jeremy is important even as their physical arrangement changes. Brendon can be careless with boundaries, but he is also loyal and willing to help when Preston’s isolation becomes dangerous.
Paul Johnson
The steady best friendPaul is a former junior-league teammate of Jeremy and Brendon, and a dependable presence within their circle. He tends to notice what others avoid saying and offers practical help without demanding explanations. As he questions his own sexuality, his friends give him room to find language for it. Paul’s loyalty is quiet but active: he helps monitor Preston’s wellbeing and supports Jeremy when caring becomes frightening.
Coach
The demanding team leaderDarby’s hockey coach is a demanding former professional who expects discipline and teamwork. He pushes the players hard, names a captain, and tries to turn Preston’s expertise into an asset for the whole team. Though initially focused on performance, he becomes alert to signs that Preston may be unwell and treats the players’ safety as part of his responsibility.
Stacy Albrooke
Jeremy’s protective sisterStacy is Jeremy’s older sister and the mother of Ella. She balances family responsibilities with a sharp sense of humor and is willing to call her brother out when he is distracted or evasive. Her daughter’s closeness to Jeremy shows the everyday care he brings to his family. Stacy’s directness helps make the Albrookes a warm, lively contrast to Preston’s controlled household.
Ella
The beloved nieceElla is Stacy’s young daughter and Jeremy’s adored niece. She is too young to follow the adults’ tensions, but her spontaneous affection offers Preston a gentle, unplanned encounter with family life. Her trust is expressed through simple actions, such as climbing into his lap or sharing food, and she helps reveal the tenderness beneath his guarded manner.
Trish Albrooke
Jeremy’s welcoming motherTrish is Jeremy’s affectionate mother, a practical host who keeps her family fed and involved in one another’s lives. She is openly curious about Jeremy’s relationships and makes room for Preston without demanding instant intimacy. Her instinct is to comfort through food and touch, though she learns to respect Preston’s discomfort with hugs.
Mr. Albrooke
The hockey-loving fatherJeremy’s father is a steady, understated presence in the Albrooke household. He is comfortable with family routines and shares his family’s interest in sports and the outdoors. His uncomplicated warmth helps show Preston a model of fatherhood that does not depend on fear or achievement.
Grandma Brown
The quilt-making matriarchJeremy’s maternal grandmother makes quilts for the family and welcomes Preston through the same practical generosity she extends to her relatives. Her gifts carry no test or condition. She is observant enough to see the importance of Jeremy and Preston’s bond, but offers acceptance without pressing Preston to explain his past.
Grandpa Brown
The gruff family elderJeremy’s maternal grandfather is a gruff, outdoors-loving family elder who values ordinary conversation about sports, fishing, and hunting. His straightforward welcome gives Preston another experience of an older man who does not seek to dominate or impress him.
Keith and Jordan
The mischievous twinsKeith and Jordan are Jeremy’s younger twin brothers, both football players and habitual conspirators. They tease one another, stir up trouble, and help make the Albrooke home noisy and close-knit. Their easy confidence around their parents contrasts with Preston’s vigilance, while their acceptance makes room for him without ceremony.
Doctor Butler
The team physicianDoctor Butler is a team doctor who checks players’ injuries and speaks plainly about what they need. He notices Preston’s condition and quietly offers a route to help, showing concern without forcing disclosure.
Jessica
The observant nurseJessica is an emergency-room nurse who treats Preston after his shoulder injury. Direct and reassuring, she notices that his scars do not fit an ordinary injury pattern and offers him a path toward support without demanding that he accept it immediately.
Celeste Montgomery
The patient therapistCeleste Montgomery is a therapist who meets Preston after his father’s death. She does not promise to erase what happened and does not push him to reveal everything at once. Her patience and willingness to discuss his distrust give Preston a chance to approach treatment on terms he can tolerate.
Carpenter
Darby’s team captainCarpenter is the senior player chosen to captain Darby’s hockey team. He urges teammates to learn from Preston’s demanding standards rather than letting bruised egos divide them.
Plot Devices
Preston’s scars
The body keeps evidenceThe scars left by Andrew’s cuts make the private cost of Preston’s polished life physically present. At first he hides them beneath clothes and routines, fearing questions and the consequences of exposure. Their eventual visibility changes the story from a conflict that can be dismissed as roommate hostility into a history of sustained abuse. The scars also distinguish harm from healing: they cannot simply vanish, but their meaning can change as Preston stops treating them as proof of personal failure and lets trusted people witness them.
Hockey and routine
Control disguised as disciplinePractice schedules, strict food habits, early workouts, and polished game-day preparation give Preston a sense of control. They also carry his father’s demands into the life Preston is trying to build for himself. Hockey first serves as both a talent and a trap: success draws attention, while mistakes risk punishment. Jeremy’s different relationship to the sport, rooted in enjoyment and a desire to coach, helps expose that distinction. Later, the rink can become a shared project rather than an instrument of coercion.
Touch and the quilt
Safety made physicalPreston’s changing response to touch gives the relationship a clear emotional measure. He can initially tolerate contact only when he controls its intensity, then gradually accepts Jeremy’s hand, embrace, and presence during nightmares. Familiar scents and shared sleep help anchor him when fear overwhelms him. The handmade hockey quilt extends that comfort beyond the couple: it is a physical welcome from Jeremy’s family, offered without a demand for disclosure or repayment. Touch is not a cure, but it becomes something Preston can increasingly choose.
The viral recording
Private harm becomes publicA recording made during Lily’s visit captures doctors discussing Andrew and Preston’s abuse. Though the original video is deleted, another copy circulates, drawing reporters, university lawyers, and the team into the crisis. The recording brings scrutiny to a powerful man whose reputation has helped conceal harm, but it also exposes Preston to attention he did not choose. Its function is therefore double-edged: it disrupts the silence protecting Andrew while forcing Preston to negotiate who controls the story of his own body and history.
Darby U Hockey Boys Series
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.