Key Takeaways
Translate canine signals before correcting behavior
A warning can be a plea. Coren opens with Finnigan, an Irish setter whose family mistook his tooth-baring for aggression. The dog was actually showing a submissive, appeasing grin. Each harsh correction made him more anxious, widening the expression and exposing more teeth. His family was punishing a message they had misunderstood.
Fear can look deliberate. Weedels urinated when her owner approached, which the family called spiteful behavior. Coren interpreted it as submissive urination from a frightened dog, made worse by earlier punishment. In both cases, changing the human interpretation changed what the behavior meant and what response made sense.
What's striking is that the same visible action can carry opposite meanings depending on its context. That is a familiar problem in human communication, where a pause can signal thoughtfulness, uncertainty, or refusal. The practical lesson is not that every tooth display is friendly, but that behavior should be interpreted alongside posture, history, and what happened just before it. Misreading a frightened dog can create the very escalation people think they are preventing. When safety is uncertain, distance and qualified help matter more than confident amateur translation.
Notice what your dog understands, not only what it can say
Listening comes first. Receptive language is the ability to understand messages; productive language is the ability to create messages others understand. Coren argues that dogs can comprehend far more human speech than their limited vocal anatomy lets them express. He cites estimates that an average dog can distinguish close to 200 words, while some trainers report teaching substantially more. These are estimates, not a guaranteed vocabulary for every dog.
Words gain meaning in life. Dogs can learn commands, object names, and familiar phrases through repeated experience. A dog may respond to a casual mention of a walk or dinner because it has connected those sounds with predictable events. Understanding does not require humanlike speech, just reliable responses to meaningful cues.
Separating comprehension from speech production corrects a common human bias: the assumption that an animal that cannot answer aloud cannot understand. Communication technology makes the same distinction, separating a system's ability to receive information from its ability to generate it. Still, an appropriate response does not prove that a dog understands a sentence as a human does. Tone, routine, and gestures can all contribute. The strongest evidence comes when a dog responds accurately in new contexts, not merely when it repeats a familiar routine.
Hear pitch, duration, and repetition as canine punctuation
Sound has structure. Coren calls the shared acoustic patterns he proposes for animal signals “Evolutionary Esperanto.” The label refers to recurring relationships between a sound's pitch, length, and repetition, not to a literal universal language. In his account, low sounds tend to signal threat or distance, while high sounds tend to invite approach or communicate vulnerability. Shorter, sharper sounds can indicate intense pain or alarm; repeated sounds suggest greater urgency.
The pattern changes the message. A few spaced barks may alert a dog to something uncertain, while rapid barking suggests heightened arousal. A growl can warn another animal away; a growl combined with a bark can add an appeal for others to attend. The sound should be read with posture and situation, not as a dictionary entry on its own.
This model makes animal vocalization easier to notice without pretending that every bark has a precise English translation. It resembles prosody in human speech: identical words can sound like a question, a threat, or a joke depending on pitch and timing. The analogy is useful because it directs attention to patterns listeners often ignore. Its limit is equally important. A sound's meaning can vary with the individual, setting, and learned history, so the proposed rules are best treated as interpretive clues rather than a dependable codebook.
Read the whole dog, not one dramatic signal
Signals work in combination. A wagging tail is not automatically an invitation. In Coren's account, Bagel bit a child who reached toward a chew toy. The owner had seen a wag and assumed friendliness, but the tail was high and stiff, paired with a direct stare. Together, those signs suggested a warning over a valued object. The tail's position and movement mattered more than the simple fact that it was moving.
Context completes the picture. A dog showing teeth may be appeasing or threatening; ears, eyes, mouth, posture, and the events around the dog help distinguish them. Breed also matters because tails and ears differ in shape and normal position. Cropping ears or docking tails can make some signals harder to see.
The book's strongest practical insight is its insistence on reading a system rather than a single gesture. In behavioral science, this is a form of contextual inference: evidence becomes more reliable when several independent cues point in the same direction. But signals are not transparent windows into an animal's mind. A wag, stare, or lowered posture can have several causes, including pain or excitement. The safest interpretation is provisional. When cues conflict, slow down, create space, and avoid testing the dog's tolerance.
Use calm Doggish gestures when greeting unfamiliar dogs
Your body is already talking. Coren uses “Doggish” as a convenient name for canine communication, including the signals people send without meaning to. Direct staring, approaching head-on, reaching over a dog's head, or rushing forward can resemble threats or challenges. A calmer greeting, as described in the book, involves turning partly sideways, moving slowly, and avoiding a fixed stare. A hand offered low and with fingers together is less confrontational than a hand reaching down from above.
Watch the response. A nervous dog may need room rather than contact. The book recommends allowing the dog to approach and delaying petting until it appears comfortable. These gestures are not a guarantee of safety, and an unfamiliar or threatening dog should not be approached simply to try a communication technique.
This is a useful reminder that good intentions do not determine how an approach is received. Human nonverbal behavior is similarly interpreted through posture, distance, and gaze before words are considered. The advice also shifts the goal from winning a dog's affection to reducing pressure and letting the animal choose whether to engage. That distinction matters. Signals that calm one dog may not calm another, and a frightened animal can bite. Respecting distance is more reliable than assuming a gesture will work.
Teach words with consistent cues and the dog's name
Make the message clear. Coren argues that a dog's name helps signal that the next words are addressed to it. He recommends using the name before a command, rather than adding it after the instruction has already passed. He also advises choosing one phrase for one purpose. If “out” sometimes means leave the room and sometimes means release an object, the dog has to guess which meaning applies.
Attach words to actions. His technique called autotraining links a word to a behavior the dog is already beginning to do. When a puppy starts to sit, the person says the chosen cue and then praises it. Repeating this association helps the word predict the action, after which the cue can be used deliberately.
The method draws on a basic principle of learning: cues become meaningful when they consistently precede or accompany a useful outcome. It also explains why household agreement matters. If several people use different words or tones for the same behavior, the dog receives a noisier learning signal. The approach is simple, but consistency should not be confused with rigid repetition. Dogs also rely on gesture and setting, so training in varied situations helps distinguish knowledge of a cue from memorization of one familiar scene.
Point with your body, not just your finger
Direction can be a message. Coren describes pointing as both something dogs interpret and something they produce. In his training example, a dog reliably chose a jump when the handler turned the head and body toward it, but became uncertain when only the handler's eyes shifted. The larger movement was easier to read from a distance.
Gestures can coordinate action. Coren compares this with a wolf pack's silent hunt. A wolf indicated the prey's direction, and the pack leader's head and body movements helped position the others around the target. The comparison suggests that pointing is more than a human hand gesture: body orientation can identify a place, direct another animal, or coordinate a group without sound.
Pointing reveals how much communication depends on shared attention: one individual directs another toward something in the world. Developmental psychology studies this closely in infants, where pointing helps establish joint attention before children can explain what they want. The dog example broadens that idea beyond human hands. Still, the wolf hunt is an observation, not proof that wolves use humanlike sentences. The more defensible conclusion is that coordinated gestures can carry specific information and support complex behavior without speech.
Treat scent marks as canine messages, not waste
Smell carries social information. Coren contrasts the roughly 5 million scent receptors he attributes to people with about 220 million in an average dog. He describes dogs as gathering information from odors that humans barely notice. Pheromones are chemical signals associated with matters such as identity, sex, and emotional state; urine can carry some of these signals.
A marked spot is an update. Dogs sniffing a tree or hydrant may be investigating which animals have passed and what information their scent left behind. Dogs also mark territory, and the height of a mark can make it more visible to other dogs. Coren recounts reports of dogs detecting mines and a dog drawing attention to a person's cancerous mole, though such anecdotes do not establish that dogs can reliably diagnose disease.
The scent chapter asks readers to imagine a world whose information is largely invisible to them. That is a productive shift in perspective: what looks like an aimless pause on a walk may be active investigation. It also makes clear that sensory experience is species-specific, not simply a weaker or stronger version of ours. The dramatic medical anecdotes deserve caution, however. A dog's sensitivity can inspire research, but a story about detection is not the same as a validated screening test.
Interpret mounting as status behavior, not proof of sexuality
Mounting has several contexts. Coren argues that mounting between dogs often serves as a social display rather than a mating attempt. Puppies may mount littermates before puberty, and adult dogs of either sex may mount dogs of the same or opposite sex. In his account, the behavior can express an attempt to establish status or control, which is why he rejects the assumption that a male mounting another male is evidence of sexual orientation.
Read the whole episode. Actual mating is preceded by courtship and acceptance from a female in heat, according to the book. Coren recommends using training and calmly interrupting mounting of people rather than treating it as affection. The interpretation should still account for the situation: excitement, play, or stress can also accompany mounting, so one action alone cannot reveal motive.
The useful correction is to stop mapping a human label directly onto an animal behavior. A visible action can have social, sexual, or arousal-related functions, and context separates them better than appearance does. The book's status explanation is one possibility, not a universal rule. Modern behavioral interpretation generally treats mounting as a behavior with multiple potential causes rather than a simple rank declaration. The practical response is to manage the behavior calmly and investigate its triggers, not to shame the dog or infer a fixed identity.
Expect dogs and cats to misread each other's signals
Shared gestures can mean opposite things. Coren points out that a broad tail wag often signals friendliness in dogs, while a cat's tail-swinging can signal tension or a wish for distance. A cat holding its tail high may be offering a friendly greeting, while a dog may interpret a high tail as a claim of dominance. A cat rolling onto its back may be ready to defend itself with all four sets of claws, even though a dog may read the posture as surrender.
Living together can teach translation. Animals raised together may learn each other's cues through repeated experience. Coren recommends supervising introductions and interrupting a dangerous confrontation from a safe distance, rather than reaching between the animals. Peaceful coexistence depends less on assuming shared meaning than on learning each other's signals.
This is a vivid example of a general problem in communication: a signal has no fixed meaning outside the system that gives it meaning. The same gesture can be a welcome in one species and a warning in another. That insight also applies across human cultures, where familiar gestures can be misread. Early exposure may help animals adapt, but it does not eliminate risk. Careful introductions and escape routes are safer than assuming that familiarity will automatically produce mutual understanding.
Judge canine language by meaning, not human speech
Language need not sound human. Dogs lack the vocal anatomy and fine control needed for human speech, but Coren argues that speech is only one route for communication. He evaluates canine signals by whether they carry meaning, refer to absent things, and combine in patterned ways. For example, dogs can search for an object that is not visible, and some sounds or gestures change meaning when their order changes.
The claim has limits. Coren's conclusion is that Doggish is a simpler language than human language, not a vehicle for abstract conversation. Its productivity, or ability to create unlimited new messages, is much more restricted. His broader point is that a social animal can communicate meaningfully through sound, posture, gaze, tail, and scent, even when its language does not resemble ours.
The book's central move is to replace a human-only standard with a comparative one. That makes animal communication worth studying on its own terms rather than dismissing it for lacking speech or philosophical vocabulary. The argument is strongest when it identifies observable signals and the responses they reliably produce. It is less settled when it calls patterned communication language: researchers disagree about how much grammar, displacement, and flexible novelty are required. The debate does not diminish the practical lesson. Dogs communicate enough to be misunderstood, helped, and harmed by human interpretation.
Analysis
Coren's book is part field guide, part argument about where language begins. Its practical premise is compelling: dogs and humans live together while relying on different channels of communication, so ordinary behavior can be misread as threat, defiance, affection, or spite. Stories such as Finnigan's apparent grin and Bagel's warning over a chew toy make that mismatch concrete. The reader is asked to replace a single-cue interpretation with attention to posture, sound, context, and history.
The book's range is also its difficulty. It moves from the anatomy of speech to vocal signals, gestures, scent, mating, dog-cat encounters, and domestication. Its organizing idea is that communication is not synonymous with spoken words. Dogs may comprehend human vocabulary while conveying their own messages through bodies and odors. Coren uses animal studies and anecdotes to make this case accessible, then argues that canine communication meets several modest criteria for language.
The strongest contribution is observational discipline: notice what happens before and after a signal, and ask what response it seems designed to produce. The weakest point is the confidence with which some gestures receive a single translation, especially when explained through dominance. A wag or a mount can have several causes, and status is not a universal key to behavior. The book is best read as an invitation to observe more carefully, not as a literal phrasebook that makes every dog transparent.
That distinction matters because the practical stakes are real. Misinterpretation can lead to punishment, fear, or injury, while a more attentive human can give a dog room, clearer cues, and safer interactions. Coren's argument that dogs possess a simple, meaningful communication system remains valuable even if the boundary between communication and language is contested. Readers do not need to settle that scientific debate to benefit from the central habit: attend to the animal's signals before deciding what its behavior means.
People Also Read
Glossary
Doggish
Canine communication systemCoren's informal name for the signals dogs use to communicate with other dogs and with people. It includes vocalizations, facial expressions, ear and tail positions, body movements, pointing, and scent. The term helps describe canine communication as a system, but it does not imply that every signal has one fixed translation.
Evolutionary Esperanto
Shared acoustic patternsCoren's label for recurring relationships between animal sounds and their likely social meanings. He emphasizes three sound features: pitch, duration, and repetition rate. In his account, low sounds often convey threat, high sounds tend to invite approach or signal vulnerability, and longer or more repeated sounds alter intensity. The label is a proposed interpretive model, not a literal universal language.
Receptive language
Understanding languageThe ability to understand a message without necessarily being able to produce it. Coren uses the term to distinguish what dogs can learn from human speech, such as names, commands, and familiar phrases, from their limited ability to form humanlike spoken words. A dog may respond appropriately to a cue even though it cannot say anything in return.
Productive language
Producing meaningful signalsThe ability to create messages that another individual can interpret. In humans, this includes speaking or signing. In dogs, Coren discusses productive communication through barks, growls, posture, tail movements, and other signals. Dogs have a much more limited capacity than humans to produce spoken sounds, but that limitation does not prevent them from sending meaningful messages.
Doggerel
Human speech to dogsCoren's term for the simplified, expressive style people often use when talking to dogs. It commonly involves short phrases, repetition, questions, commands, and a higher or more animated tone. The term describes a human speaking style, not a canine language. Consistent, relevant words may help a dog learn cues, though casual affectionate talk is often mainly social for the human.
Autotraining
Label actions as they happenA teaching technique described by Coren in which a person names a behavior while the dog is already beginning to perform it. For instance, the person says a chosen cue as the dog starts to sit, then praises the action. Repeatedly pairing the word with the behavior helps the dog learn what the cue refers to before it is used as a deliberate command.
Neoteny
Retained juvenile traitsThe persistence of juvenile physical features or behaviors into adulthood. Coren applies the term to domesticated dogs, which may retain traits such as a shorter muzzle, floppy ears, and a strong desire to play. He argues that breeding for tameness also selected for these puppy-like characteristics, and that breeds differ in how much of the adult wolf's social signaling repertoire they display.
Pheromones
Chemical social signalsChemicals released by an animal that can carry information to other animals of the same species. Coren describes pheromones as conveying details such as identity, sex, emotional state, or reproductive condition. In dogs, some scent information is present in urine and other bodily odors. Humans can detect far less of this chemical information than dogs, whose sense of smell is much more acute.
Olfactory adaptation
Reduced response to an odorA decline in sensitivity when a particular smell remains present for a period of time. Coren explains that tracking dogs can become less able to detect a strong scent after sustained exposure, then recover sensitivity after breathing fresher air. In a hunting pack, different dogs may take turns following the trail while others rest their scent receptors.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.