Key Takeaways
Build value around human needs, not tasks machines have not mastered yet
The machine keeps moving. At a retail conference, Geoff Colvin faced IBM’s Watson in a game of Jeopardy!. Watson solved a tricky movie-wordplay category almost instantly, a small demonstration of a larger trend: computers were advancing into legal analysis, driving, writing, physical tasks, and even reading facial expressions. The author’s warning is not to search for a permanent list of things machines cannot do. Past predictions about translation, chess, and driving repeatedly proved wrong as computing improved.
A different question matters. People may continue to demand human accountability, collaboration, judgment, and personal connection even when machines can perform related tasks. The durable advantage is not an uncrossable technical boundary. It is understanding which experiences people want from other people, and learning to provide them well.
The argument usefully shifts attention from a machine’s current limits to human preferences, which are often more durable than technical boundaries. A computer may supply a diagnosis, but a patient may still want a person to explain it, answer questions, and share responsibility. That distinction is especially valuable because technological forecasting tends to confuse “not yet” with “never.” Still, human preference is not a guarantee of employment: institutions can choose cheaper automation, and customers may accept a less personal service. The book’s proposal is therefore a strategic opportunity, not an automatic shield. Human-centered work needs both genuine demand and organizations willing to pay for it.
Make technical knowledge your baseline, not your whole competitive edge
Work has shifted before. Industrial machinery first displaced artisans, then electricity and large factories increased demand for educated operators and managers. From the 1980s, information technology squeezed many middle-skill jobs while helping some high-skill and service roles grow. The book describes a fourth shift: computers increasingly threaten work at both ends, from analytical professions to physical jobs once thought too messy to automate.
The labor evidence points toward interaction. From 2001 to 2009, U.S. production jobs fell by 2.7 million and transaction jobs by 700,000, while jobs involving human interaction grew by 4.8 million. The author calls the emerging worker a “relationship worker”: someone whose value comes not just from possessing knowledge, but from using it with clients, colleagues, and teams. Cognitive expertise still matters, but it is less reliably scarce.
The historical sequence makes the change easier to see: new technology does not simply erase work, it changes which capabilities command a premium. The useful distinction is between a skill’s importance and its scarcity. Mathematics, law, and engineering remain essential, but when software can perform pieces of them cheaply, expertise alone may not differentiate a worker. The risk is treating “relationship skills” as a universal substitute for technical competence. In complex industries, social fluency without domain knowledge can produce confidence without accuracy. The strongest position is often a combination: technical literacy sufficient to judge the work, plus the ability to coordinate people around a problem.
Protect face-to-face practice before screens weaken the cues relationships run on
Social skills need practice. In a study described in the book, 51 sixth graders spent five days at camp without phones, screens, or other digital devices. Afterward, they performed better at reading emotion from faces and silent video. The result suggests that interpreting expressions, posture, and tone improves through live interaction, not merely through knowing that such cues exist.
Channels are not interchangeable. Research comparing friends’ conversations found stronger reported bonding in person than by video, by phone, or by text. Face-to-face conversation also synchronizes activity in speakers’ brains, while simple social encounters can exercise executive functions such as attention, planning, and impulse control. Digital communication remains useful, but it omits many rapid signals that help people respond naturally to one another.
The camp study offers a concrete reminder that social competence is partly learned through use, rather than stored as a fixed personality trait. The point is not that screens make connection impossible. A message can maintain contact across distance, and digital tools can help people who face barriers to meeting. The more careful conclusion is that convenience can quietly displace richer practice. If a team relies on text for every disagreement, it loses chances to notice hesitation, repair misunderstandings, and adjust in real time. The practical question is not “online or offline?” but which interactions deserve the bandwidth of physical presence.
Practice empathy as accurate understanding plus an honest, fitting response
Empathy is more than kindness. The book defines it as discerning another person’s thoughts and feelings, then responding appropriately. One doctor comforted an anxious patient by promising he would be fine, despite knowing nothing about his condition. Another specialist sometimes had to tell patients that a diagnosis they wanted was wrong. Reassurance alone can soothe, but it is not necessarily empathy if it avoids the truth or the patient’s real needs.
The skill has measurable consequences. American Express removed rigid call-center scripts and gave service representatives more freedom to connect with customers. Customer recommendations rose, and employee departures fell by half. Studies cited in the book also linked doctors’ empathy with better diabetes outcomes, fewer errors, and fewer malpractice suits. Empathy can be practiced through listening, noticing emotional cues, and responding in language that matters to the other person.
This account avoids a common mistake: equating empathy with agreement, sympathy, or comfort at any cost. Good empathy requires a model of the other person’s perspective, but it also requires judgment about what response is useful and ethical. That makes it relevant well beyond customer service. A manager who understands an employee’s frustration may still need to set a boundary; the understanding simply makes the boundary more precise and humane. The evidence from medicine is persuasive because trust can affect whether patients share information and follow treatment. Yet empathy is not a replacement for technical competence. A caring but incorrect answer remains incorrect.
Train against realistic difficulty, then review mistakes without rank or excuses
Practice must resemble the real task. During the Vietnam War, U.S. Navy pilots trained in realistic dogfights against skilled opponents flying aircraft like those used by North Vietnam. Each exercise was recorded, reviewed candidly, and repeated. After the training program began, the Navy’s aircraft exchange ratio rose from about 2.4 to 12.5, while the Air Force’s, which kept its old approach, slipped from about 2.3 to 2.0.
The review made learning visible. The military’s after-action review, or AAR, is a structured discussion held soon after an exercise or event. Participants compare what was intended with what happened, identify specific strengths and mistakes, and use the findings to guide another round of practice. The central move is to analyze performance rather than protect status. At the National Training Center, this approach helped prepare soldiers for realistic combat and difficult interactions with civilians.
The training story makes a strong case for replacing vague experience with deliberate rehearsal, observable feedback, and another attempt. It also explains why honest review can be more valuable than a polished performance score: a score says how the group did, while a review can reveal what to change. The model transfers naturally to high-stakes work where errors are costly but practice can be made safe. Its hardest requirement is psychological, not technical. Candor collapses if people fear humiliation or retaliation. A useful review therefore needs clear standards, evidence, and leaders who can accept criticism without turning every mistake into a verdict on character.
Make teams smarter by sharing airtime and reading one another closely
A team has its own capacity. Researchers studying groups found a factor called collective intelligence, or c, that predicted how well a team handled different tasks. The average IQ of members, and even the IQ of the smartest member, did little to explain the group’s results. Social sensitivity and more balanced conversational turn-taking mattered much more. Groups dominated by a few voices were less effective at using everyone’s ideas.
Small changes can matter. At a large Bank of America call center, employees worked mostly alone and rarely met at the same time. Coordinating team coffee breaks increased interaction and participation. The company estimated that the change could save $15 million annually. In golf, Paul Azinger organized the 2008 U.S. Ryder Cup team into small groups based on personality and comfort with one another, not merely playing strengths. The team won by its widest margin in decades.
The findings challenge the familiar belief that a team is simply the sum of its strongest résumés. A group’s process determines whether individual knowledge becomes shared knowledge. Balanced airtime is not a courtesy ritual; it is a way to increase the range of information available before a decision. Still, equal speaking time by itself is not a measure of quality. A team can distribute airtime fairly and still be wrong, or spend hours discussing weak ideas. The deeper principle is that members must be able to contribute, respond, and revise one another’s thinking. Leaders can make that possible by designing meetings around participation rather than performance theater.
Tell stories in person when you need people to change
A story moved a bureaucracy. At the World Bank, Stephen Denning tried charts and written material to persuade colleagues to share the institution’s expertise. Neither worked. He then described a health worker in Zambia who searched online for malaria guidance but could not access the World Bank’s extensive knowledge. The story made the gap between the bank’s mission and its actual service vivid. Denning found that telling the story face-to-face had more effect than distributing it in print or video.
Narrative gives facts a human shape. The book explains that people instinctively connect events into stories about agents, motives, and consequences. A classic narrative introduces a disruption, develops conflict, and reaches a resolution. Research described in the text found that one emotionally involving film about a father and a seriously ill child increased viewers’ oxytocin and charitable giving, unlike a less structured account of the same pair.
Stories make abstract problems legible by giving listeners a person, a conflict, and a consequence to hold in mind. In Denning’s case, the story was effective because it connected organizational failure to the World Bank’s stated purpose, rather than merely dressing a proposal in colorful language. The emphasis on live telling adds another layer: listeners can judge sincerity and the speaker can respond to their reactions. This power also creates risk. A compelling narrative can make a weak claim feel true, and emotional intensity is not evidence. Strong communicators use stories to illuminate facts, not to replace them, and keep the limits of the story visible.
Pair creative exploration with trusted collaboration to solve moving problems
Computers can generate novelty. IBM’s Watson combined ingredients in recipes that human chefs might not have considered, and people enjoyed the results. The book accepts that computers can be creative. But high-value innovation often concerns real problems whose definition changes as people investigate them. A company may begin by seeking a cheaper manufacturing process, then realize a different material or a new goal matters more. People must keep reframing the problem and deciding which solution is useful.
Innovation needs two kinds of contact. Exploration brings ideas from beyond a team; engagement lets team members examine and develop those ideas together. Studies cited in the book associate creative work with trust, face-to-face interaction, and physical proximity. One research team predicted which days were most creative from the balance of exploration and engagement with 87.5% accuracy. The author’s point is not that offices guarantee invention, but that interaction helps ideas travel and improve.
This distinction separates producing an unusual idea from turning it into a successful innovation. A novel solution has little value if it addresses the wrong problem, ignores users, or cannot gain support. Exploration protects a team from recycling its own assumptions; engagement helps members test and reshape what they find. Proximity can make those exchanges easier, but it should not become a simplistic argument that every task belongs in an office. Deep individual work may benefit from quiet and distance. The design challenge is to create deliberate moments for cross-pollination and collective judgment, while preserving the conditions that let people think independently.
Treat women’s average social-sensitivity edge as evidence, not destiny
Group research showed a pattern. In studies of collective intelligence, women scored higher on average on measures of social sensitivity, and groups with more women tended to perform better. The book connects this advantage to skills such as noticing who wants to speak, reading reactions, and sharing conversational space. But group composition alone did not guarantee success: when members competed for status, the performance advantage associated with women disappeared.
The claim is about averages, not individuals. The author describes both biological and social influences on gender differences, while also noting variation within each sex and the effect of experience. The practical implication is not to assign people roles based on gender. It is to value the behaviors linked to effective collaboration, and to avoid incentives that reward dominance over contribution.
The most useful part of this section is its movement from demographic patterns to workplace conditions. If status competition suppresses contribution, then an organization can lose valuable perspectives even when it hires socially skilled people. The demographic finding should be treated cautiously: group studies do not establish that every woman is more sensitive than every man, or that gender itself causes a team’s success. Social sensitivity is the more actionable variable. Teams can observe whether members notice others’ contributions, invite quieter voices, and respond constructively. That focus preserves the book’s insight without turning an average difference into a hiring rule or a claim about any individual’s potential.
Use technology to learn facts faster, then spend freed time practicing human skills
Social abilities can be trained. Business schools described in the book moved some technical instruction online and used classroom time for team simulations, realistic assignments, and feedback. In military experiments, soldiers who explored a digital model of a room for ten minutes worked together faster on their first live attempt than other teams did after several runs. Software can therefore prepare people for human encounters, not only teach facts.
Make practice deliberate. The book’s examples include role-playing difficult patient conversations, reviewing team behavior after simulations, and reading literary fiction to consider characters’ inner lives. At Southwest Airlines, a technically capable new employee who rejected the company’s everyday social interaction was dismissed because his behavior undermined the culture. The lesson is concrete: technical competence opens doors, but many workplaces also expect employees to listen, cooperate, and connect.
The closing prescription is more practical than simply telling people to become more personable. Knowledge can often be taught efficiently through digital tools, leaving scarce shared time for activities that require negotiation, feedback, and perspective-taking. Simulations are especially useful because they let people make errors before the consequences are real. But training should not be confused with personality correction. Not everyone wants the same amount of interaction, and cultures differ in how warmth, directness, or eye contact are expressed. Effective development teaches adaptable behaviors and attentive listening, rather than one narrow style of sociability. The aim is better coordination and understanding, not compulsory extroversion.
Analysis
The book’s most useful claim is not that human beings possess a secret talent machines can never copy. It argues almost the opposite: computers may keep absorbing tasks once treated as uniquely human. The more defensible source of human value is social demand. People want accountable decision-makers, trusted advisers, responsive colleagues, and collaborators who can revise the problem as circumstances change. This reframes career planning from finding a supposedly automation-proof occupation to combining technical competence with skills that make knowledge usable among people.
The evidence is strongest when the book describes specific mechanisms. In teams, balanced participation makes more information available. In training, realistic rehearsal and candid review turn mistakes into learning. In storytelling, a person’s presence helps listeners assess authenticity. These are more precise claims than the sweeping prediction that interaction work will simply replace knowledge work. The book’s examples also suggest that social skills are not soft in the sense of vague: they can affect medical outcomes, military performance, customer loyalty, and productivity.
Some conclusions deserve boundaries. The book occasionally treats face-to-face contact as superior in general, though its own examples point to a more useful distinction: medium should match the task. Digital tools can teach content and support established relationships; they are weaker where rapid social cues, trust-building, or ambiguous negotiation are central. Similarly, gender averages in social sensitivity should not become assumptions about individuals. The relevant workplace behaviors can be observed and trained without using sex as a proxy.
The argument’s largest practical implication is institutional. Workers cannot be expected to cultivate empathy and collaboration while employers reward only individual output, keep teams constantly changing, or make honest feedback dangerous. Organizations must structure time, incentives, and training around the behaviors they claim to value. Technology may compress the price of information, but it does not automatically create trust, sound judgment, or shared purpose. Those remain human achievements, and they require deliberate design rather than inspirational slogans.
Review Summary
Humans Are Underrated explores the value of human skills in an increasingly automated world. Colvin argues that empathy, creativity, and social intelligence will become more crucial as technology advances. While some reviewers found the book insightful and thought-provoking, others felt it lacked depth or relied too heavily on anecdotes. The book emphasizes the importance of teamwork, storytelling, and human-to-human relationships in future careers. Many readers appreciated Colvin's perspective on the evolving job market, though some questioned the practicality of his predictions.
People Also Read
Glossary
Relationship workers
value through human connectionThe author’s term for workers whose greatest value comes not simply from holding knowledge, but from applying it through relationships. They collaborate, build trust, understand customers and colleagues, and help groups solve problems. Technical expertise remains relevant, but it becomes more valuable when paired with the ability to communicate and work effectively with people.
Collective intelligence
group-level task effectivenessA group-level factor, labeled c in the research discussed in the book, that predicts how effectively a team performs across different tasks. The studies found that individual members’ average IQ, or the IQ of the smartest member, did not explain group performance well. Social sensitivity and balanced participation in conversation were stronger predictors.
after-action review (AAR)
candid performance reviewA structured review held soon after a training exercise or event. Participants examine what was supposed to happen, what actually happened, and which specific actions helped or hindered the goal. In the military approach described in the book, the discussion is evidence-based and candid, includes people at different ranks, and informs further practice rather than assigning a general grade.
emotional contagion
automatic spread of emotionThe tendency to take on another person’s emotional state, sometimes without conscious awareness. The book describes evidence that even newborns respond differently to the cries of similar infants, and that people can unconsciously mirror emotional expressions or vocal tones. Researchers treat this automatic responsiveness as one foundation for the more developed ability to empathize.
Reading the Mind in the Eyes
inferring feelings from eyesA test that asks participants to infer a person’s thoughts or feelings from photographs showing only the eye region. In the studies discussed in the book, participants selected from possible descriptions such as sadness, frustration, or fear. Scores were used as a measure of social sensitivity and helped predict how effectively groups performed together.
Facial Action Coding System
catalog of facial movementsA system developed by psychologist Paul Ekman for describing facial expressions through the movements of facial muscles. The book explains that the system identifies combinations of muscle actions associated with different expressions and emotions. Researchers used it as a basis for training people, and later computer systems, to analyze facial movement and infer emotional states.
human domain
social dimension of operationsA military concept for the human and social conditions that shape success in an operation. It includes how people interpret gestures, build or withhold trust, respond to authority, and make decisions within a culture. The book uses the term to describe why superior weapons and information may not be enough when outcomes depend on interactions with civilians, allies, or opponents.
exploration and engagement
two modes of creative interactionThe paired social activities associated in the book with creative group performance. Exploration means interacting beyond the immediate team to encounter new information and perspectives. Engagement means working closely with team members to test, develop, and refine ideas. Exploration broadens the idea pool, while engagement helps a group assess and improve what it finds.
FAQ
What's Humans Are Underrated about?
- Focus on Human Skills: The book explores the shift from technical abilities to deeply human traits like empathy and social interaction as technology advances.
- Impact of Technology: It discusses how computers outperform humans in many tasks, emphasizing the need for humans to focus on interaction and understanding.
- Future of Work: Geoff Colvin argues that the future economy will reward those who excel in human-centric skills, making adaptation essential.
Why should I read Humans Are Underrated?
- Understanding Economic Shifts: The book provides insights into the changing landscape of work and the skills that will be most valuable in the future.
- Empathy as a Key Skill: It emphasizes the importance of empathy, stating that it is increasingly sought after in various professions.
- Practical Applications: Offers real-world examples from fields like the military and healthcare, showing how empathy leads to better outcomes.
What are the key takeaways of Humans Are Underrated?
- Value of Human Interaction: As technology takes over more tasks, connecting and empathizing with others becomes crucial for success.
- Empathy Training: Programs like Roots of Empathy teach children to recognize and respond to emotions, suggesting empathy can be developed.
- Team Dynamics: Effective teams rely on social skills and emotional intelligence, with the quality of social interactions determining success.
What are the best quotes from Humans Are Underrated and what do they mean?
- "Being a great performer...": Personal attributes, especially emotional intelligence, are becoming more important than technical knowledge.
- "Empathy will be the difference...": Employers increasingly recognize empathetic skills as essential for high performance.
- "Machines don’t fight wars...": Highlights the importance of human decision-making and interaction, even in technology-driven environments.
How does Humans Are Underrated define empathy?
- Understanding Others' Feelings: Empathy is the ability to discern what another person is thinking and feeling, and respond appropriately.
- Two-Part Process: True empathy involves recognizing emotions and knowing how to respond, crucial in interactions.
- Innate Human Trait: Empathy is hardwired in humans, but it can diminish without practice.
What role does technology play in the future of work according to Humans Are Underrated?
- Advancement of Computers: Technology is improving rapidly, making computers better at tasks traditionally performed by humans.
- Shift in Job Market: As technology takes over more jobs, the demand for uniquely human skills, particularly social interaction, will increase.
- Need for Adaptation: Individuals must develop interpersonal skills to remain competitive in the job market.
How does Humans Are Underrated suggest we can improve our empathy?
- Engagement in Real Interactions: Advocates for more face-to-face interactions to develop emotional intelligence and empathy.
- Training Programs: Highlights successful programs like Roots of Empathy, suggesting similar training can benefit adults.
- Practice and Reflection: Emphasizes practicing empathy in everyday situations and reflecting on interactions to improve.
What insights does Humans Are Underrated provide about teamwork?
- Social Skills Over Technical Skills: Effective teams rely more on social skills and emotional intelligence than on technical expertise.
- Collective Intelligence: Teams perform better than the sum of their parts through effective communication and empathy.
- Importance of Diversity: Teams with diverse members, particularly those with women, tend to perform better due to higher social sensitivity.
How does the military exemplify the principles in Humans Are Underrated?
- Training for Human Interaction: The U.S. military focuses on human interaction and empathy in modern warfare training.
- After-Action Reviews: Encourages candid discussions about performance, fostering a culture of learning and improvement.
- Realistic Simulations: Training scenarios help soldiers develop social skills necessary for effective communication and teamwork.
What does Humans Are Underrated say about the decline of empathy in society?
- Cultural Shifts: Modern technology and social media have contributed to a decline in face-to-face interactions, reducing empathetic skills.
- Generational Changes: Research shows empathy levels among college students have declined, indicating a broader societal trend.
- Need for Rebuilding Skills: Emphasizes actively working to rebuild empathetic skills for personal fulfillment and professional success.
How can organizations benefit from the insights in Humans Are Underrated?
- Fostering Empathy in the Workplace: Implement training programs to develop empathy and social skills among employees.
- Creating a Culture of Openness: Encourage open communication and after-action reviews to foster a learning environment.
- Valuing Human Interaction: Prioritize human interaction and emotional intelligence in hiring and training to remain competitive.
What specific methods does Humans Are Underrated suggest for improving interpersonal skills?
- Engagement in Real Situations: Engage in real-life interactions to build social skills, rather than relying on digital communication.
- Training Programs: Highlights military training programs that develop interpersonal skills through simulations and real-world scenarios.
- Reading Fiction: Suggests reading literary fiction to enhance empathy and social understanding, making it valuable for personal development.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.