Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
In the Unlikely Event

In the Unlikely Event

An Irish musician and his first love reunite for a songwriting assignment: can old promises survive?
by L.J. Shen 2019 368 pages
3.86
34k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Snow in the Ballroom

A record deal brings Rory face to face with Mal

At twenty-six, Rory Jenkins has built a careful New York life: photography work, a small apartment, and a steady boyfriend, Callum Brooks. At a music-industry gala, she spots an Irish songwriter whose appearance seems to summon the boy she loved eight years earlier. She tries to dismiss the resemblance, until her boss, Jeff Ryner, introduces the man as Malachy Doherty.

Mal is now famous, wealthy, and cold where she remembers him as carefree. When Ryner sends Rory to meet him alone on a snowy balcony, Mal covers her shoulders with his coat. Their reunion offers no easy welcome. Rory is still bound to the promise they made as teenagers, but neither knows what the other has become.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The reunion makes success feel less like arrival than containment: Rory has assembled the life she thought would protect her, yet Mal's entrance unsettles it before he says anything. Her stability is not false, but it is partly organized around avoiding an unresolved attachment. Mal's changed public identity similarly complicates memory. The famous songwriter seems to contradict the penniless busker she loved, forcing Rory to confront how little she can claim to know about him now. Snow externalizes the disturbance without turning it into destiny; the important rupture is that both must meet the consequences of choices made when they were young.

The Grave and the Busker

A priest points a grieving daughter toward her father's past

Eight years earlier, eighteen-year-old Rory travels from New Jersey to Dublin to visit the grave of her estranged father, Glen O'Connell. She has come hoping to feel connected to him, but knows little beyond her mother's bitter account of a talented, unreliable man. At the cemetery, Father Doherty, a priest who knew Glen, tells Rory that she has Irish half-siblings and that her father spoke proudly of her.

He gives her an address for his grandson, Malachy, who learned guitar from Glen. Rory follows the directions to Drury Street, where a crowd has gathered around a young busker. Before she knows anything about Mal beyond his music and magnetic presence, she finds herself watching him as if he might answer questions her father left behind.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Rory's trip begins as an attempt to visit a place, but Father Doherty converts geography into a family history she was never allowed to enter. Her grief has no shared memories to attach itself to, so she searches for evidence: a grave, a sibling, a story. The priest's squirrel tale quietly complicates the idea of belonging, presenting newcomers and locals as parties competing over a home. Rory's uncertain position in Ireland is already shaped by other people's loyalties. Meeting Mal does not solve that uncertainty; it gives her a vivid person through whom the past can become intimate, dangerous, and emotionally immediate.

A Song on Drury Street

Rory's accidental tip buys her an evening with Mal

Rory recognizes Mal's force before she knows him: his performance silences the street, and his original song holds the crowd still. In a fluster, she drops the fifty euros Father Doherty gave her into Mal's guitar case. Mal catches her before she can escape and persuades her to drive him out of Dublin.

He jokes through the journey, asks about her birthmark, and takes her to the village pub, where Rory finally explains that she came to learn about Glen. Mal describes how Glen taught him music and writing, then offers to take Rory to Kathleen, her half-sister. His easy warmth disarms Rory even as his flirtation alarms her. The father she came to mourn is already leading her toward a family she never expected to meet.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The accidental money turns Rory's vulnerability into an opening: instead of asking for help directly, she makes a mistake that gives Mal a reason to engage. Their courtship is built on a mismatch of defenses. Rory tries to control the encounter through skepticism and rules, while Mal treats those rules as playful invitations. Yet his connection to Glen is not merely romantic scenery; he has inherited some of the father's artistic influence and can offer Rory a living account of him. The encounter also introduces a central tension: Mal's gift for making Rory feel seen coexists with his habit of acting before considering what his attention might cost others.

Sisters at the Door

Kathleen welcomes Rory, then warns her away from Mal

Mal brings Rory to Kathleen's home, where her half-sister embraces her warmly in front of him. Rory soon sees Kathleen's longing for Mal, and, once he leaves the room, Kathleen privately accuses Rory of coming for Glen's inheritance and claims Mal is hers. The hostility confirms that their reunion is not a simple restoration of family.

Rory keeps Kathleen's cruelty from Mal, then kisses him outside the house partly to make Kathleen watch. The kiss becomes genuine almost at once. At Mal's cottage, the two spend the night together, and Rory experiences an intimacy that makes her feel newly alive. By morning, desire has become a choice with consequences: Rory must leave Ireland for college, while Kathleen remains in Mal's life.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Kathleen's welcome and private attack expose how family affection can become performance when love and inheritance are treated as scarce resources. Rory responds to humiliation with retaliation, but the kiss stops being a weapon once Mal answers it with genuine desire. That shift matters because Rory's actions are no longer only about resisting her sister or escaping grief; she is making an attachment she knows has an expiration date. Mal's tenderness gives her pleasure and recognition, while his casual control over Kathleen's hope raises a warning about his emotional immaturity. The scene establishes that desire can be sincere and still entangle people in harm.

The Napkin Pact

They leave separation to chance, then part at the airport

Rory and Mal cannot agree to a long-distance relationship: she is committed to college in America, and he refuses to watch her build a life with someone else from across an ocean. Instead, they write a rule on a pub napkin: if they meet again by chance, they will choose each other, but neither may search for the other.

Mal keeps the original; Rory takes a photograph. At the airport, they part after one last kiss, each pretending the pact is only a joke. Back in Tolka, Mal soon regrets refusing a relationship and tries to contact Rory. Their separation is therefore not silence freely chosen by both. Other people will soon decide what each of them believes the other has said.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The napkin gives a concrete shape to a promise neither young person can responsibly enact. Its condition, a chance reunion, allows them to preserve the intensity of the night without facing the ordinary labor of staying together. The bargain is romantic, but also an avoidance strategy: they outsource choice to coincidence. Keeping the napkin becomes especially consequential because the two have no reliable way to verify what happens after they part. Their future will be governed not by fate alone, but by who controls the messages, photographs, and stories that stand between them.

A Life Built on Letters

Rory's mother cuts off contact while Mal marries Kathleen

After Rory leaves, Mal writes repeatedly and searches for a way to reach her. Rory's mother, Debbie, intercepts his letters and sends him Rory's photographs with harsh captions Rory had written as an exercise in getting over him.

She also sends a letter falsely claiming Rory became pregnant, had an abortion, and wants Mal to leave her alone. Believing the rejection, Mal spirals into drinking and turns to Kathleen for comfort; they have sex, and she becomes pregnant. Pressured by their families, they marry.

On their wedding day, Kathleen discovers the napkin and flees in Mal's car. Mal runs after her, but she collides with a truck driven by their friend Sean. Kathleen dies after giving birth to their daughter, Tamsin, whose survival requires extensive medical care.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

This chain of events shows how intimate relationships can be redirected by people who claim to protect or love those involved. Debbie's fear of Mal and Ireland leads her to manufacture rejection, while Mal's despair and Kathleen's longstanding attachment produce a marriage that neither can inhabit honestly. The accident is not presented as a clean moral punishment; it follows a collision of secrecy, grief, pressure, and reckless choices. Tamsin's survival binds Mal to the family he has built through tragedy, while the napkin becomes both a promise and a source of pain. The story's central rupture is therefore not simply that Rory and Mal separated, but that they were denied a truthful account of why.

Back Under One Roof

A two-month assignment traps Rory with Mal and Callum

In New York, Ryner hires Rory to document Mal writing music with pop star Ashton Richards in Ireland. Mal has demanded her for the project after recognizing her name on a record cover, though he presents their reunion as an unwanted business arrangement. Rory accepts for the career opportunity and brings Callum to Tolka for one night.

Mal's cottage is filthy, the livestock has been sold, and a locked room is off limits. Mal needles Rory and interrupts her and Callum in bed, then summons her to work in the middle of the night. Richards arrives surrounded by drugs and staff, making the assignment less a songwriting retreat than an unpredictable crisis. Callum leaves for England, and Rory is left to work inside Mal's hostile, familiar world.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The assignment converts the old pact's imagined reunion into an institutional arrangement: Rory is not in Tolka by chance, but because Mal has used his leverage to bring her there. That distinction sharpens the conflict between romantic fate and deliberate control. Rory's professional ambition is real, yet her decision is made inside a charged domestic situation that threatens her relationship with Callum. Mal's contemptuous behavior is partly a defense against his own unresolved hurt, but it also functions as retaliation. The disorder of the cottage reflects his refusal to make a welcoming space, even as the project forces them to share one.

The Missing Star

A runaway singer exposes the past Mal conceals

Richards disappears after a drug-fueled night, leaving Rory and Mal to search the fields around Tolka while Ryner floods their phones with angry calls. Rory's nervous stories about college and redirected mail make Mal realize her letters may never have reached her. Before they find Richards trying to mount a cow, the singer blurts out that Mal is a widower.

Rory learns that Kathleen died, but Mal refuses to explain how. Back at the cottage, Glen's Christmas song plays on the radio. Rory recognizes her father's voice and bolts into the rain, overwhelmed by grief and the secrets around it. Mal follows, gives her his coat, and admits he wants them to stop resisting their bond. Later, she discovers he has kept the napkin.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Richards's disappearance is comic on the surface, but it loosens information that Mal has carefully withheld. The more important disclosure comes indirectly, through Rory's casual account of how her mail was routed and Richards's blunt naming of Mal's loss. Rory is forced to assemble truths from fragments because Mal remains protective to the point of deception. Glen's song then makes the past audible rather than abstract, collapsing Rory's search for her father into the immediate pain of losing the family she imagined. The napkin's survival offers proof of Mal's attachment, but it cannot substitute for the explanations he still owes her.

A Bottle Picks Sides

Callum's party game turns jealousy into a breakup

Ashton moves the project to Greece, where Callum arrives to be with Rory. At a New Year's party, a game of spin the bottle becomes a test of their relationship. Callum kisses another guest, and Rory feels little; when the bottle brings her together with Mal and Ashton, Mal's kiss becomes unmistakably intimate.

Callum watches Rory respond to Mal with a desire she cannot disguise, then ends their relationship and reveals he had planned to propose. Rory is ashamed of hurting him, but no longer pretends that their partnership can contain what she feels. The engagement ring Callum leaves behind makes the choice concrete. She has not yet resolved her guilt, but the life she built to escape Mal is over.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The party game makes private emotional truth public and performative. Callum uses the rules to test Rory, while she initially accepts them as harmless; the difference between her response to his kiss and to Mal's exposes the relationship's imbalance. Callum's proposal plans complicate the breakup without invalidating it. His desire for commitment is sincere, but his vision of Rory has often involved her becoming available to his social world and future plans. Rory's guilt is not proof that she should stay. It marks the ethical cost of having delayed honesty until desire had already become betrayal.

Vows in Cyprus

Rory and Mal marry before facing their unfinished truths

After Callum leaves, Rory and Mal stop treating their attraction as an accident and marry in Cyprus, fulfilling the promise they made on the napkin. Their ceremony is impulsive, but neither mistakes it for a complete solution. They spend their honeymoon talking, having sex, and signing playful agreements on fresh napkins, while avoiding the questions that could threaten their new happiness: Tamsin, Rory's childhood, Mal's absences, and the secrets held in Tolka.

Rory also sees how far Richards's drug use has escalated. Mal wants to return home, but he keeps postponing explanations about his family. The marriage gives the couple a chosen bond at last, yet their intimacy is built atop facts Rory still does not know.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The wedding fulfills the literal contract while exposing its limits. Rory and Mal can make a public commitment, but marriage cannot retroactively repair the years of false information that shaped their choices. Their new napkins are playful revisions of the original pact, a sign that they are trying to author a shared future rather than rely on a single youthful bargain. Yet the subjects they avoid remain structurally central. Their intimacy is genuine, but it is not yet informed consent to the life Mal is asking Rory to enter. The scene's tenderness is therefore shadowed by an asymmetry of knowledge.

Richards Falls Silent

The rock star's secret illness ends the album project

Rory and Mal find Richards unconscious in his hotel room, and Mal realizes he is dead. Earlier, Richards had been using drugs to conceal and outrun terminal cancer, choosing spectacle over treatment because he did not want the public to see him wasting away. The project collapses, and Ryner, devastated and furious, orders the couple back to Ireland and tells them not to speak to the press.

On the flight, Rory grieves for Richards despite their chaotic encounter, while Mal explains that death makes ordinary ambitions look small. He speaks from experience, having lost Kathleen, and urges Rory to value the living people beside her. His words bring them closer, but they do not erase the secrets waiting at home.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Richards's death shifts the story from romantic urgency to the irreversibility of time. His celebrity persona had turned risk into entertainment, making his illness easy for others to misread as another episode of excess. Rory's grief registers a human bond beneath his obnoxious conduct, while Mal's response is shaped by a loss he has not yet fully narrated. His insistence on living is not a vague lesson: it is an argument formed by the cost of postponing care and truth. The death also removes the work assignment that brought Rory to Ireland, forcing her to decide whether she remains for Mal rather than for her career.

The Girl Behind the Door

Rory meets Tamsin and discovers Mal's hidden family

Back in Tolka, Rory visits Father Doherty to investigate rumors about her birthmark and the unanswered questions surrounding her father. Instead, she meets Tamsin, a young girl who calls Mal her father, and learns that Kathleen was her mother. Mal has kept his daughter from Rory and from the assignment, sending Tamsin to live with relatives while he worked.

The discovery makes sense of his absences, the locked room, and his urgent trips home, but it also exposes a deliberate lie inside their marriage. Rory leaves before Mal can explain and tears up the napkin contract. At the pub, she corners Father Doherty, who admits that Rory's mother once lived in Tolka and that the family has hidden far more than Rory imagined.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Tamsin transforms the stakes of the romance: Rory is no longer deciding only whether she can trust Mal with her own heart, but whether he can trust her with the person most dependent on him. His concealment may have begun as protection, yet after marriage it becomes an exclusion that denies Rory the chance to choose her place in the family. The torn napkin rejects the idea that a promise can excuse ongoing dishonesty. Rory's turn toward Father Doherty is an effort to reclaim authorship of her own history, especially when her husband and mother have each treated information as something to ration for her supposed good.

The Scar's Real Story

A priest reveals how the family rewrote Rory's childhood

Father Doherty tells Rory that Debbie came to Ireland with infant Rory to try to make a family with Glen. Glen's drinking became abusive; during a violent argument, he threw a bottle that cut Rory's temple. Debbie fled with her bleeding child, and the priest drove them to hospital.

Later, Debbie fabricated Glen's letters and gifts to spare Rory the feeling of being rejected, while also intercepting Mal's messages and sending him false claims about Rory.

Mal catches Rory's taxi and admits he sought her out after she left, believed the lies, married Kathleen under pressure after a drunken night, and became a father to Tamsin. Kathleen died in a crash on their wedding night. He also explains his retaliatory affair with Maeve, whose husband Sean had blamed him for Kathleen's death.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The revelations dismantle the family myth in layers. Glen was neither the distant, loving father Rory imagined nor simply the villain Debbie described; he was a dangerous man whose conduct forced her to flee. Debbie's protective inventions gave Rory an emotionally survivable story, but they also removed her ability to grieve what actually happened. Mal's own secrecy repeats that pattern, turning protection into control. His account of Kathleen's death and his affair with Maeve shows grief becoming retaliation, with innocent partners made to carry pain they did not cause. Truth does not make these actions harmless, but it gives Rory the agency to judge them rather than inherit other people's versions.

A Family Chosen Honestly

Rory forgives her mother and builds a home with Mal

Rory learns that Debbie, not Rory, wrote the letter claiming an abortion; Debbie had kept Rory and feared Mal would repeat Glen's destructiveness. Rory accepts the explanation without excusing the damage, and Mal brings Debbie to Ireland so mother and daughter can begin repairing their relationship.

Rory also leaves Blue Hill rather than let Ryner exploit Richards's death, choosing photography on her own terms. She and Mal raise Tamsin together, and Rory eventually reconciles with Summer after learning that Summer had slept with Callum and hidden it.

Callum's affair with Whitney further confirms that their relationship was already compromised. A year later, Mal publicly proposes again while busking, and Rory accepts a life defined by their choices rather than the old napkin's chance condition.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Resolution here depends on accountability more than absolution. Rory can understand Debbie's fear and still name the harm caused by her lies; she can love Mal while insisting that he stop deciding what she is allowed to know. Her career choice mirrors this movement toward self-authorship: she rejects an industry that treats grief as marketable material and keeps the work that gives her meaning. Forgiving Summer is similarly distinct from pretending the betrayal did not happen. The final proposal transforms the original pact from an escape hatch into a renewed, public commitment. Rory's happiness rests not on fate making the right people meet, but on people finally telling the truth.

Epilogue

Fifteen years later, Mal drives Rory and their twins to Tamsin's wedding, still struggling to accept that his daughter is grown. He buys a nearby house for Debbie and her partner so Rory can stay close to her mother. In the bridal room, Tamsin thanks Rory for helping make a family out of her and Mal.

The scene completes the household Rory entered as an outsider: she is a wife, a mother by choice, and part of a larger family whose losses are remembered without defining every day. Mal watches his daughter prepare to marry and recognizes how thoroughly Rory has changed the life he once thought he had lost.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The epilogue measures resolution across generations. Mal's anxiety about Tamsin's marriage repeats the protective impulse that once made him withhold truth, but his family now has the language and closeness to face change together. Rory's bond with Tamsin is not presented as a replacement for Kathleen; it is a relationship built through daily care, allowing inheritance to become something more generous than blood or grievance. Buying a house for Debbie also turns forgiveness into practical inclusion. The ending does not erase the past. It shows a family able to carry it without making secrecy the price of belonging.

Analysis

The novel treats romance as a problem of knowledge as much as attraction. Rory and Mal's chemistry is immediate, but the relationship is repeatedly governed by stories other people tell on their behalf: Debbie's invented correspondence, Kathleen's account of Rory, the village's judgments, and Mal's decision to conceal Tamsin. These interventions do not make the couple's choices disappear. They show how people can act on partial information and then mistake the consequences for proof of betrayal.

The recurring objects give that problem physical form. The napkin preserves a promise, but cannot guarantee trust. Rory's camera lets her shape what others see, even as the birthmark reveals a past she cannot frame away. Glen's song similarly carries both artistic inheritance and the history of harm. The novel's comic object narrators complicate its emotional seriousness by showing that even trivial witnesses can expose what the lovers refuse to say.

The book also distinguishes protection from care. Debbie lies to keep Rory from feeling rejected; Mal hides family history because he fears losing Rory. Both acts arise from love, but both take away her agency. Their motives do not cancel their impact. Rory's growth lies in refusing the false choice between understanding someone and holding them responsible. She can forgive her mother without pretending the deception was harmless, and love Mal without accepting his right to ration the truth.

Death sharpens the stakes without supplying a simple moral. Kathleen, Glen, and Ashton leave different kinds of unfinished business, while Tamsin makes the future tangible. The final movement toward family is not a return to innocence or a reward for fate. It is the result of choosing honest attachment after secrecy has already done its damage. The novel's most durable claim is that a second chance matters only when people use it to become more truthful, not merely more passionate.

Summary in 60 Seconds
At eighteen, American Rory visits Ireland to learn about her estranged father and falls in love with his grandson, musician Malachy. Unable to agree on a long-distance relationship, they part, promising to reunite only by chance. Rory's mother intercepts their letters and sends Mal false claims, leading him to marry Rory's half-sister Kathleen, who dies in a crash after giving birth to their daughter, Tamsin. Eight years later, Rory and Mal reunite on a music project. They rekindle their relationship and marry, but Mal conceals Tamsin, and Rory leaves when she discovers the truth. A priest reveals Rory's father was abusive and her mother fabricated the correspondence. Rory and Mal reconcile, raise Tamsin, and build a family with Rory's mother. Fifteen years later, they attend Tamsin's wedding.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.86 out of 5
Average of 34k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

In the Unlikely Event receives polarizing reviews, averaging 3.86/5. Enthusiastic readers praise its unique storytelling, witty banter, multiple POVs (including inanimate objects), and the chemistry between Mal and Rory. Critics highlight significant issues: a rape scene handled poorly, excessive miscommunication, cheating, a hidden child, and problematic character decisions. Many note it differs greatly from Shen's previous work. Even critical reviewers acknowledge the book's addictive quality, with several admitting they couldn't put it down despite their reservations.

Your rating:
4.8
1 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Aurora Belle Jenkins

The watchful photographer

Rory, short for Aurora, is an American photographer with a punk-rock style, a camera always close, and a crescent birthmark she has spent years disliking. She is funny, defensive, and more perceptive of other people's needs than of the compromises she makes for herself. Her longing to understand her absent father grows from a childhood shaped by her mother's guarded version of events. Photography gives Rory a way to frame experience without pretending it is simple, but her own emotional life is harder to control. She is drawn to unruly people and intense feeling, while also wanting the safety of a life she can manage. Her central struggle is learning to choose desire and family without surrendering her right to know the truth.

Malachy Doherty

The reluctant songwriter

Mal is an Irish musician whose talent draws crowds even when he is busking in worn clothes and refusing offers for his songs. He is witty, impulsive, sexually confident, deeply tied to his family, and suspicious of wealth and fame. Beneath his apparent lightness lies a capacity for intense attachment, but he often confuses protecting people with controlling what they know. He can be generous in practical ways and cruel when hurt, sometimes using charm to avoid responsibility for the effects he has on others. His art is private at first, a way to keep meaning separate from money. Mal's struggle is to reconcile loyalty to home and family with his desire for a love that asks him to be honest.

Kathleen O'Connell

Rory's Irish half-sister

Kathleen is Rory's half-sister and a lifelong presence in Mal's village. She is polished, ambitious, and outwardly dutiful, with a deep need to feel chosen by the people she loves. Her childhood relationship with Glen and her long attachment to Mal shape how she views Rory's arrival: as a possible rival for affection, family history, and security. Kathleen can be warm when she feels safe and cutting when she feels threatened. Her desire for a settled life sits uneasily beside her willingness to manipulate emotional situations. She is not simply a rival in a romance; she is a person trying to secure a place in a family whose affections have often felt conditional.

Callum Brooks

The polished boyfriend

Callum is Rory's well-connected English boyfriend, a stockbroker whose polished manners and reliable routines offer a sharp contrast to Mal. He presents himself as attentive and stable, remembering Rory's preferences and making room for her artistic identity in public. Yet he also imagines a future in which her work and independence will yield to the demands of his social world. His charm can make control look like care, and his confidence in the relationship sometimes prevents him from noticing Rory's doubts. Callum is not merely the safe alternative to a passionate first love; he represents a respectable life that may be comfortable without being fully mutual. His relationship with Rory tests the difference between being treated well and being truly understood.

Debbie Jenkins

Rory's guarded mother

Debbie raised Rory largely alone and built a flamboyant, self-protective persona around a difficult young adulthood. She is practical, sharp-tongued, and intensely concerned with keeping her daughter safe, though her concern can become controlling. Debbie's bitterness toward Glen conceals a history she has never been ready to share, while her efforts to give Rory a loving picture of her father reveal how much she fears her daughter feeling unwanted. She has made sacrifices that Rory does not initially recognize, and she also makes damaging decisions in the name of protection. Their relationship carries affection, resentment, and unfinished conversations. Debbie's complexity lies in the gap between the care she intends and the truth she withholds.

Summer

Rory's candid best friend

Summer is Rory's longtime best friend, roommate, and an actress who speaks with theatrical confidence about love and bad decisions. She supports Rory's ambitions and recognizes how deeply Mal has shaped her, even when Rory denies it. Her advice is often blunt, funny, and well meant, but Summer's own loneliness and insecurity complicate her loyalty. She wants Rory to choose happiness, yet she does not always behave in ways that protect their friendship. Summer's role shows how intimate betrayal can arise inside a bond that is genuinely loving, not only from malice.

Glen O'Connell

The absent songwriter

Glen is Rory's Irish father, a gifted songwriter whose reputation rests largely on one enduring hit. To Rory, he begins as a distant figure assembled from presents, letters, and conflicting accounts. In Tolka, his history connects Rory to Kathleen, Mal, and Father Doherty. Glen's musical gift and his failures as a parent coexist, making him a source of both artistic inheritance and painful family myth. His influence reaches the living through songs and stories, but those stories are shaped by the people who survived him.

Father Doherty

The village priest

Father Doherty is Mal's grandfather by affection and a priest who knew Glen and both branches of Rory's family. Gentle, observant, and burdened by old decisions, he acts as a bridge between Rory's American life and the history Tolka has kept from her. He tries to shield people from pain, but his silence contributes to the very confusion he hopes to prevent. His kindness is real, as is his responsibility for having offered advice with lasting consequences.

Ashton Richards

The reckless pop star

Ashton is a famous young performer whose celebrity, appetite for spectacle, and chaotic drug use make him an unstable focus for Ryner's music project. He is vulgar, impulsive, and often difficult to work with, but his humor and moments of vulnerability reveal a person behind the public caricature. Rory approaches him as a subject to document, while Mal has to manage the practical consequences of his behavior. Ashton brings industry excess into the intimate space of the cottage.

Tamsin

The bright Tolka child

Tamsin is a lively young girl in Tolka, perceptive about the adults around her and full of opinions about clothes, school, and family. Her warmth cuts through the secrecy and old grief that surround her. She is imaginative, affectionate, and capable of drawing Rory into ordinary routines that matter more than grand declarations. Tamsin represents the possibility of building family through daily presence, while remaining her own person rather than a symbol of anyone else's reconciliation.

Jeff Ryner

The opportunistic label boss

Ryner runs Blue Hill Records and treats artists, staff, and publicity as parts of a commercial machine. He is flamboyant, self-indulgent, and often more interested in a marketable story than in the people creating it. His assignment brings Rory and Mal together again, while the demands he makes expose the compromises built into the music industry. Ryner's opportunism can look grotesque, but he is also candid about how little concern the business has for private grief.

Maeve

The village confidante

Maeve is part of the close Tolka circle around Mal, Kathleen, and the O'Leary twins. Her relationships become entangled with Mal's anger and his attempt to retaliate against someone who has blamed him for a loss. Maeve longs for affection and recognition, but she is also a mother whose choices affect her children. Her presence makes clear that Mal's pain does not stay contained between him and Rory.

Sean

Mal's former friend

Sean is one of the O'Leary twins and once belonged to Mal's closest circle of friends. He is protective of Kathleen and carries strong convictions about what Mal owes the people around him. His anger, especially in moments of crisis, helps shape the lasting divisions in Tolka. Sean's loyalty is sincere, though grief can make his judgments unforgiving.

Elaine

Kathleen's protective mother

Elaine is Kathleen's mother and part of the village family network that surrounds Mal. Her loyalty to her daughter and her history with Glen shape her view of Rory's presence in Tolka. She is protective, wary, and inclined to see Rory through the old injuries that preceded her arrival.

Lara

Mal's devoted mother

Lara is Mal's mother, a hardworking woman whose closeness to her large family anchors his sense of home. Her presence helps explain why Mal resists leaving Ireland and why his choices are never only about romance.

Heather

A Tolka friend

Heather belongs to the village circle around Kathleen and the O'Leary family. She helps reveal how quickly local stories travel and how Rory's arrival is interpreted by people who knew the family before she did.

Daniel

The sensible twin

Daniel is Sean's twin and one of Mal's friends. More measured than his brother, he urges Mal to take his feelings for Rory seriously rather than hide behind the pact's conditions.

Brandy

The rock star's assistant

Brandy works with Ashton and is attracted to Mal. Her flirtation becomes part of the increasingly public, unstable dynamic surrounding Rory, Mal, and Callum during the project.

Whitney

Ryner's sharp assistant

Whitney is Ryner's assistant and Brandy's sister. She is socially perceptive and involved in the music industry's private dealings, though her own choices become more consequential than her professional role first suggests.

Divya Patel

The newsagent keeper

Divya runs a Tolka newsagent and knows pieces of the village history surrounding Rory's family. She is compassionate toward Rory, but her willingness to speak is checked by the older loyalties and promises that govern the town.

Plot Devices

The Boar's Head napkin

A promise carried forward

Rory and Mal write their reunion pact on a pub napkin before she returns to America. Its rule against seeking one another turns chance into a romantic test, while Mal's decision to keep it gives the object a life beyond the night it was written. Years later, the napkin becomes evidence of memory, a source of conflict in Mal's marriage, and a symbol Rory can reject when she learns that promises cannot replace informed choices. Their later playful agreements show the couple trying to make commitment more active and mutual.

The intercepted letters

False rejection drives separation

Rory's mother controls the correspondence between Rory and Mal after their first parting. She sends Mal photographs with misleading captions and a fabricated letter that makes him believe Rory wants him gone. At the same time, Rory never receives Mal's letters. Their separate interpretations harden into resentment, helping push Mal toward Kathleen and shaping his hostility when they reunite. The device turns ordinary communication into a power struggle: whoever controls the message can make affection look like contempt. The eventual correction forces both lovers to reconsider choices they had blamed on each other.

Rory's birthmark

A scar hiding a family history

Rory believes the crescent mark on her temple is simply a birthmark and feels self-conscious about it. In Tolka, people recognize it as evidence of a violent episode from her infancy, one her mother concealed to protect her from the truth about Glen. The mark links Rory's appearance to a childhood she cannot remember and to the village's shared guilt. Its revelation changes her understanding of both parents, especially the mother she had judged as cold. It also demonstrates how the body can preserve a history that families have tried to edit away.

Glen's Christmas song

The past returns by sound

Glen's familiar song reaches Rory through a radio in Mal's cottage. Hearing her father's voice without warning overwhelms her and sends her into the rain, where Mal follows and comforts her. Music is both Glen's legacy and the means by which Rory encounters him most directly, despite never having known him well. The song also connects Mal to Glen's influence as a writer and teacher. Its effect shifts as Rory learns the truth: what once carried grief and shame can eventually be heard without demanding that she excuse her father or remain trapped by his actions.

The shifting narrators

Side voices widen the story

Interludes from objects and secondary characters, including the napkin, a cow, the chocolate bar, and people around the couple, provide comic commentary and withheld context. These brief perspectives interrupt Rory and Mal's first-person accounts, reminding readers that their interpretations are incomplete and self-serving. The device can expose information the central couple does not yet possess, particularly around betrayal and Richards's illness. Its tonal playfulness prevents grief from becoming the only register, while the shifting viewpoints make the novel's central question sharper: whose version of a relationship gets treated as truth?

About the Author

L.J. Shen is a bestselling author whose work appears regularly on the New York Times, USA Today, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, and Amazon Kindle Store bestseller lists. Specializing in contemporary romance, she has built a devoted readership through her signature style: deeply angsty storylines featuring morally complex, wealthy anti-heroes paired with fierce, spirited heroines. Her writing is known for its emotional intensity, sharp wit, and unpredictability. She maintains an active presence across multiple platforms, including Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook, and connects with readers through her newsletter and personal website.

Download PDF

To save this In the Unlikely Event summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.27 MB     Pages: 25

Download EPUB

To read this In the Unlikely Event summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.27 MB     Pages: 34
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...