Key Takeaways
Treat markets as a linked system, not four isolated charts
Read the whole picture. Intermarket analysis compares currencies, commodities, bonds, and stocks because movement in one market can alter the prospects for another. A falling dollar can lift commodity prices; pricier commodities can raise inflation concerns and pressure bonds; weaker bonds can eventually weigh on stocks. These relationships are tendencies, not mechanical rules, and some markets can lead others by months or years.
The 1980s made the case. The commodity surge of the 1970s coincided with rising interest rates and stagnant stocks. When commodities peaked in 1980, the dollar strengthened, bonds turned higher in 1981, and stocks began a major advance in 1982. Looking at stocks alone would have missed the chain of clues.
What's useful here is the shift from single-market storytelling to a system view. In complex systems, a local change can propagate through feedback loops, and finance is no exception: expectations about inflation affect bond yields, financing costs, and equity valuations. The caveat is that a visible relationship does not establish a single cause. A strong dollar and falling commodities may coincide for several reasons, so the links are best used as context and confirmation, not as a substitute for testing a trade.
Watch neighboring markets for danger before a stock chart breaks
Warnings appeared early. Before the 1987 stock-market crash, commodities rose and bond prices fell months before stocks peaked. Rising commodity costs suggested renewed inflation pressure, while falling bonds meant higher borrowing costs. The stock rally persisted, but its foundations were weakening. In 1990, bonds and commodities also turned against stocks before Iraq invaded Kuwait and oil prices surged toward $40 a barrel.
Not every warning is immediate. Commodity prices can turn before bonds, and bonds often turn before stocks, but the lead time varies. The 1994 downturn offered another example: industrial metals rose as bonds weakened, and the stock market followed. Monitoring related markets would not have predicted the exact day of a decline, but it could have helped investors recognize that the risk picture had changed.
The practical value of this method is earlier risk recognition, not perfect prediction. That distinction resembles medical screening: a warning signal can justify closer monitoring without proving that a crisis is imminent. The 1987 and 1990 examples make a persuasive case for widening the lens, while also showing why timing claims need restraint. A lead of months can be informative for allocation but unusable for a short-term trade. Signals become more credible when several independent markets point in the same direction.
In deflation, rising bonds can accompany falling stocks
The old rule broke. In the postwar pattern Murphy describes, bond and stock prices usually moved together, apart from transitions at major turning points. The Asian currency crisis that began in 1997 spread financial stress and fears of falling prices. Investors sold stocks and sought the relative safety of U.S. Treasury bonds. During the third quarter of 1998, the Dow fell about 20 percent while Treasury prices surged.
The divergence persisted. Stocks rallied in 1999 as bonds fell, then the technology bubble burst in 2000. Over the next three years, stocks continued downward while bonds generally rose. The Federal Reserve cut short-term rates repeatedly, but lower rates did not restore the stock market's advance. The book argues that deflation changes the usual bond-stock relationship: bonds may benefit from falling prices even as weak demand and profits hurt stocks.
This is the book's most important warning against treating correlations as permanent. Financial relationships depend on the economic regime: inflation fears can hurt both bonds and stocks, while deflation can support government bonds and damage corporate earnings. The comparison is powerful because it explains why familiar stimulus logic seemed ineffective in the period described. Still, deflation is not the only possible explanation for every divergence. Policy, risk appetite, and market structure also matter, so the regime diagnosis should remain open to revision.
Use a falling dollar and weak stocks to reassess gold
Gold can hedge more than inflation. Gold weakened for much of the 1980s and 1990s while stocks rose. That relationship began to change around the 2000 stock-market peak. Gold shares turned upward, followed by bullion, as stocks weakened and the dollar lost strength. By late 2002, gold had broken above a level that had contained prices for years, while the dollar had fallen through a long-term support line.
Look beyond one year's performance. Murphy argues that gold can attract investors during financial upheaval and has also performed well in historical deflationary periods. He points to the 1930s, when Homestake Mining shares rose even as the broader stock market collapsed. A falling dollar can add support because gold is priced in dollars. The shift toward hard assets is a possibility to monitor, not a guarantee of a lasting commodity boom.
Gold's role as an alternative asset is more nuanced than the common inflation-hedge label suggests. It can gain appeal when confidence in financial assets or a currency weakens, which connects the argument to portfolio insurance and safe-haven demand. The distinction between gold bullion and gold-mining shares matters: shares add company, cost, and operational risks, so they are not simply leveraged bullion. Long-term breakouts can signal a changed market regime, but they do not tell investors how much exposure is appropriate.
Use ratios to find which asset is actually winning
Compare performance directly. Relative strength analysis divides one market by another. A rising ratio means the first asset is outperforming the second; it does not necessarily mean the first asset is rising in price. For example, a bond-to-S&P 500 ratio rose after 2000, showing that bonds were becoming stronger than stocks. That shift could have supported reducing stock exposure and increasing bond exposure during the period described.
Ratios expose turning points. The CRB Index divided by the Dow began to break a long decline in 2002, a sign that commodities were gaining ground relative to stocks. The Dow-to-gold ratio also fell after 1999, showing gold's improved performance. Trendlines on these ratios can help identify changes in leadership, but they should be checked against the underlying price charts. A rising ratio can result from a falling denominator, a rising numerator, or both.
Ratios offer a compact way to answer a decision-focused question: where is capital being rewarded relative to its alternatives? This connects intermarket analysis with benchmark-relative investing, where performance is judged against an opportunity cost rather than in isolation. The method is especially helpful when two assets move in the same direction but at different speeds. Its limit is that a ratio is backward-looking and can be volatile near turning points. It supports comparison, but cannot by itself determine risk, valuation, or the right holding period.
Use bonds, stocks, and commodities to locate the business cycle
The markets turn in sequence. The book presents a typical pattern: bonds often peak first as expansion matures, stocks turn down next, and commodities can remain strong longest. During a contraction, bonds tend to bottom first, stocks next, and commodities last. The pattern helps explain why falling bonds can warn of pressure on stocks, while improving bond prices may signal that financial conditions are easing.
Historical leads offer context, not a calendar. Research cited from economist Geoffrey Moore's study of eight postwar business cycles found bonds led economic peaks by an average of 27 months, stocks by about nine months, and industrial commodity prices by about eight months. These averages helped Murphy frame the 2001 recession using earlier market turns. The actual recession began in March 2001. The sequence was informative, but such averages cannot precisely time the next cycle.
This framework is strongest as a map of changing expectations. Markets respond to forecasts of future activity, while official economic data often confirm changes after they have begun. That helps explain why market signals can precede recession announcements. The cited averages are useful historical summaries, but a sample of eight cycles is not a universal law. Business cycles differ in cause, policy response, and global setting. Investors should treat the sequence as a hypothesis to test against current evidence rather than a countdown.
Read sector leadership to judge whether expansion is fading
Leadership changes with the cycle. Murphy uses a sector-rotation model to connect stock groups with economic phases. Energy stocks often lead late in an expansion, when fuel prices and inflation pressures are rising. Consumer staples tend to hold up as growth weakens because demand for everyday goods is steadier. Utilities and financials can gain favor during contraction, while technology, transportation, and consumer-cyclical companies may lead as recovery takes hold.
The 2000 shift was visible. Energy led in 1999, then defensive sectors such as consumer staples, utilities, and financials gained ground as the market weakened. By 2003, technology, transportation, and consumer-discretionary shares were showing stronger relative performance, which the book reads as evidence of improving expectations. Sector leadership can help identify the market's view of the economy, though a single group may also move for industry-specific reasons.
Sector rotation turns a broad economic story into observable changes in market leadership. It resembles a dashboard: no single indicator tells the whole story, but a pattern across several groups can reveal what investors are pricing. The 1999-to-2000 transition is particularly vivid because energy strength gave way to defensive leadership. The model is not a substitute for economic measurement, however. Interest-rate changes, regulation, or a commodity shock can move one sector independently of the cycle, so confirmation across groups matters.
Do not assume foreign markets will cushion a global selloff
Crises cross borders. The 1987 crash and the bear market after 2000 showed major stock markets falling together. The 1997 Asian currency crisis began with pressure on Thailand's currency, then affected regional stocks, commodities, and markets far beyond Asia. The book also tracks correlations between U.S. interest rates and Japanese markets, arguing that Japan's prolonged deflation mattered to global financial conditions.
Diversification has limits. Holding foreign stocks can spread risk when markets behave differently. During a global downturn, however, correlations can rise and many markets can fall together, weakening that protection. Currency moves add another layer: a weaker dollar can increase dollar-denominated returns on foreign investments, while a rising local currency can challenge exporters. Global exposure should therefore be evaluated alongside currency risk and the possibility of synchronized declines.
The central insight is that diversification is conditional, not a permanent property of a list of holdings. Portfolio theory relies on assets not moving in lockstep, but crises can change correlations precisely when protection is most needed. This makes stress scenarios more useful than average correlations alone. The book's global examples support broader monitoring, although they do not imply that international investing is futile. Different countries, industries, and currencies can still provide diversification across ordinary market conditions and longer horizons.
Consider commodities and currencies beyond a stock-bond portfolio
More assets can mean more choices. Futures markets offer access to commodities, currencies, bonds, and stock indexes, and allow traders to take short as well as long positions. Murphy discusses managed futures accounts, professionally run portfolios that trade these markets. Research cited from John Lintner and later work suggested that managed futures could improve a traditional portfolio because their returns were not closely correlated with stocks and bonds.
Commodity exposure needs discipline. The book also discusses commodity indexes such as the CRB and Goldman Sachs Commodity Index as ways to gain broad exposure. It cites research suggesting that adding an unleveraged commodity allocation could improve a portfolio's risk-return profile. Futures leverage can magnify losses as well as gains, however. The argument is for considering additional sources of return and diversification, not for treating commodities or managed futures as low-risk investments.
The portfolio logic is coherent: assets that respond differently to economic shocks can reduce dependence on a single return source. This is the same basic principle behind diversification across equities, bonds, and real assets. The important qualifier is implementation. Managed futures vary widely in strategy, and headline correlations do not remove leverage, fees, liquidity constraints, or periods of poor performance. The book's research makes a case for evaluating the category, but individual investors still need to assess costs and understand how the strategy behaves under stress.
Treat housing as a rate-sensitive refuge, not a permanent hedge
Low rates changed the cycle. During the stock bear market after 2000, falling long-term interest rates helped homebuilders and real estate investment trusts, or REITs. REITs also offered a source of income and often moved differently from technology stocks. Homebuilding shares, such as Centex in the book's examples, became unusually resilient while broader equities weakened.
The support had a condition. The housing strength described in the book depended heavily on historically low mortgage rates. Rising rates could weaken demand and challenge the sector, even if the stock market were improving. Murphy also discusses an approximately 18-year real-estate cycle identified by Clarence Long, while stressing that other forces, including interest rates, can affect timing. Housing can diversify a portfolio, but its behavior changes with financing conditions and should not be mistaken for guaranteed protection.
Housing illustrates why asset labels can mislead. Real estate is often described as an inflation hedge, yet the period examined here was marked by weak inflation and strong housing, with unusually low interest rates offering a more convincing explanation. This is a useful reminder to identify the mechanism behind an asset's performance rather than rely on its reputation. Real estate also carries leverage, local supply, and liquidity risks. Its diversification value depends on the investor's exposure and the economic conditions driving prices.
Analysis
Murphy's central contribution is a practical change in the unit of analysis. Instead of asking whether a stock chart looks bullish, the analyst asks what bonds, commodities, currencies, and related stock sectors imply about the same economic environment. This expands technical analysis from pattern recognition within one market into a framework for comparing signals across markets. Its clearest explanatory success is the transition from disinflation to deflation: familiar relationships, especially the tendency of bonds and stocks to rise together, became unreliable when falling prices and weak earnings altered investor priorities.
The historical narrative gives the method credibility through episodes rather than abstract rules. The 1987 crash, the 1990 oil shock, the Asian crisis, and the 2000 technology collapse show how signals can appear outside the market that eventually suffers. The book also connects macro trends to practical decisions: sector selection, relative performance, foreign exposure, and the possible inclusion of commodities or managed futures.
The framework's main weakness is its temptation to turn repeated correlations into causal laws. A falling dollar may support commodities, but supply disruptions, policy decisions, or demand shifts can dominate. Markets also anticipate one another unevenly, and a relationship that works in one regime may fail in another. The evidence includes historical examples and averages, not a fully specified trading system with transaction costs, position sizing, and out-of-sample tests. Relative-strength charts identify leadership but do not establish whether that leadership will persist. The most durable lesson is therefore methodological: use intermarket relationships to ask better questions and to recognize regime changes, not to claim certainty. Compare several markets, check whether the proposed mechanism makes economic sense, and revise the interpretation when the relationships stop confirming one another. The book is most valuable as a disciplined way to widen market awareness and least reliable when its tendencies are treated as forecasts with fixed timing.
Review Summary
Intermarket Analysis receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 4.17/5. Readers appreciate Murphy's clear writing and insights into market relationships, particularly during deflationary periods. The book is praised for its comprehensible explanations of complex economic concepts and its value for understanding market interactions. However, some criticize its reliance on historical data and limited coverage of currencies. While considered dated by some, many still find it useful for grasping the big picture of market dynamics and sector rotations.
People Also Read
Glossary
Intermarket analysis
Compares connected marketsAn approach that studies currencies, commodities, bonds, stocks, and sometimes global markets together. Its premise is that price movements in one market can provide context or signals for another. The relationships are conditional and may change with economic conditions, so the analyst looks for confirmation rather than assuming that a historical correlation will always hold.
Decoupling
Markets move apartA divergence from a customary relationship between markets. In the book's central example, bonds and stocks, which often moved in the same direction, began moving oppositely during the period of growing deflation fears after 1997. Decoupling can signal a changed economic regime, though it does not by itself explain the cause or establish that the divergence will continue.
CRB Index
Basket of commodity pricesA widely followed index designed to represent the direction of commodity prices. The book describes it as a basket covering major commodity groups, including energy, metals, grains, livestock, and other agricultural markets. Because weather-sensitive commodities can influence its movement, Murphy recommends comparing it with industrial commodity measures when judging economic and inflation trends.
Journal of Commerce (JOC)-Economic Cycle Research Institute (ECRI) Industrial Price Index
Tracks industrial commodity pricesAn index of selected industrial commodity prices developed from the work of Geoffrey Moore and his research team. Unlike a broad commodity index, it excludes food, grains, and precious metals, and focuses on materials such as metals, textiles, and petroleum products. The book uses it as a measure more closely connected to cyclical economic activity and inflation pressure.
Relative strength analysis
Measures comparative performanceA charting technique that compares one market or sector with another, commonly by dividing one price series by a benchmark. A rising ratio means the first series is outperforming the second; it does not necessarily mean that its price is rising. Murphy uses the technique to identify sector leadership and shifts in preference among bonds, stocks, and commodities.
Kondratieff Wave
Long economic cycleA proposed long-term economic cycle, roughly 55 to 60 years in length, associated in the book with broad shifts in inflation, commodity prices, interest rates, and stock-market leadership. Murphy presents it as a historical interpretation rather than a short-term timing tool. Its stages are used to compare long periods of asset outperformance and economic expansion or contraction.
Sector rotation
Leadership shifts among sectorsThe movement of investor funds and market leadership from one stock sector to another as economic expectations change. The book describes energy stocks as tending to lead late in an expansion, defensive consumer staples as holding up when growth weakens, and technology or consumer-cyclical stocks as gaining leadership during recovery. These are tendencies, not fixed rules.
FAQ
What's Intermarket Analysis: Profiting from Global Market Relationships about?
- Market Relationships: The book delves into the interconnectedness of financial markets, including stocks, bonds, commodities, and currencies, and how they influence each other.
- Intermarket Analysis Tool: John J. Murphy presents intermarket analysis as a branch of technical analysis, useful for predicting market trends and making informed trading decisions.
- Historical Context: It reviews significant market events from the 1980s to the early 2000s, illustrating the evolution of intermarket relationships during economic changes.
Why should I read Intermarket Analysis by John J. Murphy?
- Comprehensive Understanding: The book enhances your understanding of global market interactions, crucial for informed investment decisions.
- Practical Applications: It offers practical advice on applying intermarket analysis in real-world trading, valuable for both novice and experienced traders.
- Historical Insights: Murphy's analysis of past market events provides context and lessons to anticipate future market movements.
What are the key takeaways of Intermarket Analysis?
- Market Interconnections: All markets are linked, both domestically and globally, meaning changes in one can significantly impact others.
- Deflation vs. Inflation: The book discusses how deflationary trends can alter traditional market relationships, such as rising bond prices being bad for stocks.
- Sector Rotation: Understanding sector rotation is crucial, as different sectors perform better at various stages of the economic cycle.
What are the best quotes from Intermarket Analysis and what do they mean?
- "All markets are linked": Emphasizes the importance of considering multiple markets for accurate financial trend analysis.
- "Rising bond prices are actually bad for stocks": Highlights a critical shift in market dynamics during deflationary periods.
- "Charts don’t lie": Underscores the importance of technical analysis and charting in understanding market trends.
What is intermarket analysis as defined in Intermarket Analysis?
- Definition: Intermarket analysis studies relationships between different financial markets to forecast price movements.
- Key Components: Focuses on stocks, bonds, commodities, and currencies, providing insights into economic conditions and investment opportunities.
- Dynamic Nature: Relationships are not static and can change due to economic shifts, requiring traders to stay informed.
How does Intermarket Analysis explain the relationship between commodities and bonds?
- Inverse Relationship: Bond prices and commodities trend in opposite directions; when commodity prices rise, bond prices typically fall.
- Impact of Inflation: Rising commodity prices often signal inflation, leading to higher interest rates and lower bond prices.
- Historical Context: Provides historical examples to illustrate these relationships during significant economic events.
What role does the dollar play in intermarket analysis according to John J. Murphy?
- Dollar's Influence: A falling dollar is bullish for commodities, affecting their prices and U.S. export demand.
- Global Impact: Changes in the dollar's value influence global markets, affecting commodity prices and stock valuations.
- Investment Strategies: Understanding dollar movements aids in better asset allocation, especially in commodities and multinational stocks.
How does Intermarket Analysis address the concept of deflation?
- Deflationary Trends: Deflation alters traditional market relationships, being good for bonds but bad for commodities and potentially stocks.
- Historical Examples: Provides context on how deflationary pressures impacted markets in the past.
- Investment Implications: Guides investment strategies, particularly in choosing between asset classes during economic downturns.
What is the significance of sector rotation in Intermarket Analysis?
- Sector Performance: Different sectors perform better at various economic cycle stages, guiding investment strategies.
- Investment Strategy: Recognizing outperforming sectors helps in resource allocation during economic transitions.
- Historical Context: Provides examples of sector rotation during past economic cycles, emphasizing its importance.
How can I apply the concepts from Intermarket Analysis to my trading strategy?
- Comprehensive Market Analysis: Evaluate multiple markets simultaneously to enhance trading decisions.
- Monitor Economic Indicators: Key indicators like interest rates and commodity prices provide insights into market trends.
- Adapt to Market Conditions: Be flexible, adjusting focus based on current market conditions and sector performance.
How do commodities influence the stock market according to Intermarket Analysis?
- Inflation Hedge: Commodities serve as an inflation hedge, with rising prices indicating strengthening economic conditions.
- Sector Performance: Rising commodity prices boost sectors like energy and materials, lifting the overall stock market.
- Market Sentiment: Changes in commodity prices affect market sentiment and investor behavior, influencing stock prices.
What is the significance of the yield curve in Intermarket Analysis?
- Economic Indicator: The yield curve reflects economic health, with a normal curve indicating growth and an inverted curve signaling recession.
- Investment Decisions: Understanding the yield curve aids in bond investment decisions and anticipating stock market changes.
- Market Reactions: Shifts in the yield curve impact various asset classes, highlighting market interconnectedness.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.