Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Lessons In Faking

Lessons In Faking

A soccer star and his rival's twin fake-date to provoke him, but who will catch feelings?
by Selina Mae 2024 480 pages
3.74
10k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Statistics Sets Them Together

Athalia’s failing grade puts her under Henry’s rival

Athalia Pressley, a wealthy college student whose twin brother Henry keeps her at arm’s length, is failing Statistics II after she can no longer cheat her way through exams. Professor Shaw makes weekly tutoring with his teaching assistant the condition of passing. The tutor is Dylan McCarthy Williams, the soccer player Henry despises for taking his jersey number, captaincy prospects, and, supposedly, his girlfriend.

Athalia arrives ready to dislike him, and Dylan answers her insults with his own. Their first session exposes how little she understands, while his persistence makes clear she cannot simply replace him. She resents the assignment, but statistics is now tied to her chance of staying on course at university, so she returns.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The tutoring arrangement gives the romance a practical engine while placing Athalia inside the very comparison she fears. Statistics is not merely a difficult class: it is her late mother’s field, and every failure risks becoming evidence, in Athalia’s mind, that she falls short of her family’s legacy. Dylan’s teasing initially confirms her belief that others see her as privileged and unserious. Yet he also represents a challenge she cannot dismiss, because passing now depends on working with the person she has been taught to treat as an enemy.

A Brother Oversteps

Henry’s intervention turns tutoring into a family fight

After Henry mistakenly believes Athalia and Dylan are sleeping together, she explains that Dylan is her tutor. Henry responds by emailing Shaw to try to change the arrangement, despite Athalia’s explicit refusal of his help. When she discovers what he has done, she confronts him at soccer practice.

Henry insists he is protecting her from Dylan; Athalia hears the familiar assumption that she cannot manage her own life. Their argument becomes personal as she accuses him of appearing only when he can solve a problem, while he admits he cannot bear the thought of her spending time with his rival. Athalia leaves furious, but also recognizes that Henry’s jealousy has finally made him pay attention to her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The fight exposes the difference between protection and intimacy. Henry’s intervention is controlling, but Athalia’s anger is not only about his email: she wants evidence that she matters to him beyond being a problem to fix. Because grief has left her with one close blood relative, conflict can feel like connection, even when it wounds. Her proposed retaliation grows from this emotional bargain. She chooses to provoke Henry rather than risk asking directly for the affection she misses.

The Fake Dating Contract

Athalia recruits Dylan to provoke her twin

Athalia approaches Dylan with a plan to fake a relationship because nothing would upset Henry more than seeing his sister with his enemy. Dylan agrees almost immediately, asking only that she owe him a favor. They write down rules: weekly dates, public affection, exclusivity, and an end date around New Year’s. They also forbid themselves from falling in love, a clause Dylan adds with conspicuous emphasis.

Athalia sets the performance in motion, beginning with public attention around campus and scheduled time together. Their bargain gives her a way to demand Henry’s attention without admitting how much she wants it, while Dylan gets a chance to irritate his rival. Neither treats the arrangement as emotionally dangerous yet.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The contract makes emotional risk legible by pretending it can be managed like a business arrangement. Athalia and Dylan specify dates, appearances, and limits, but their most important motive remains unstated: she wants to be noticed, and he wants access to a situation that will unsettle Henry. The no-falling-in-love clause is comic on the surface, yet it also shows that both understand intimacy as a possible consequence before either will acknowledge desire. Their rules give them permission to get close while supplying a ready-made excuse to deny what the closeness means.

The Performance Gets Personal

Coffee dates and soccer games sell the lie convincingly

At Daisy’s Coffee, Athalia and Dylan quiz each other on the personal facts they have prepared, turning a fake relationship into an unexpectedly attentive study of one another. They stage affection where Henry can see it, and Dylan begins bringing Athalia red roses, even though she has told him she dislikes them.

At a team celebration, he seats her on his lap, and later draws her close at the bar when Blake’s attention risks confusing the performance. Athalia also attends Dylan’s matches, where she finds herself cheering despite her usual dislike of soccer. Their act makes Henry visibly tense, but the repeated touches and private jokes begin affecting Athalia even when her brother is nowhere nearby.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The performance succeeds because its details require real attention. Memorizing preferences, noticing a disliked flower, and showing up at games all imitate the labor of a relationship, and imitation starts changing the people doing it. Athalia initially measures success by Henry’s reaction, but she increasingly registers Dylan himself: his laugh, his confidence, and the ease of their private rhythm. The roses work especially well as a motif because they are both a deliberate provocation and an ongoing sign that Dylan remembers what she told him.

The Kiss Changes Everything

Henry challenges the act, and Dylan makes it real

At a crowded frat party, Henry confronts Athalia and Dylan, accusing them of performing a relationship only when he is present. Athalia refuses to admit the truth, and when Henry challenges her claim that they kiss, she and Dylan close the gap and do so. The kiss is meant to convince her brother, but it leaves both of them shaken after he storms away.

Dylan walks Athalia home and gives her his shoes when her heels hurt, a small kindness that makes their silence feel more intimate than their staged dates. Days later, they kiss again in Dylan’s office, then agree to turn studying into a game: correct statistics answers earn Athalia kisses. Their contract’s boundaries begin to collapse.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The first kiss converts performance into experience, and the second proves it was not merely a useful improvisation. Athalia and Dylan can no longer treat physical closeness as a prop once their bodies respond beyond the needs of an audience. Yet the arrangement still offers them cover: they can call desire a tactic, or a reward for studying. The tutoring game links emotional and academic progress, making each correct answer both a small achievement for Athalia and a step toward intimacy she is not ready to name.

Wren Sees the Risk

A hidden kiss strains Athalia’s closest friendship

Athalia hides her kiss with Dylan from Wren, her blunt, fiercely loyal best friend, who learns about it through Henry’s circle. Wren confronts Athalia because she fears Dylan will hurt her as Jason, Athalia’s unfaithful ex, did. Athalia denies caring and accuses Wren of acting like a jealous girlfriend, then watches Wren withdraw.

As Thanksgiving approaches, Athalia becomes ill and struggles alone in their loft. Dylan arrives for tutoring, finds her feverish, carries her to the couch, brings medicine and toast, and stays until she sleeps. While caring for her, he tells her about his four sisters. Wren later returns and shares Athalia’s takeout with Dylan, a first small sign that their hostility may ease.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Wren’s warning is loving but also exposes how secrecy can make a friendship feel unsafe. Athalia refuses the conversation because naming her attraction would make it harder to control, while Wren’s own fear is sharpened by what she witnessed after Jason’s betrayal. Dylan’s care during Athalia’s fever complicates her belief that he is only participating for mischief. He attends to her practical needs without an audience, and his stories about his sisters reveal a domestic tenderness that his swagger usually conceals.

Thanksgiving on the Road

Dylan brings Athalia away from an empty holiday

With Thanksgiving nearing, Athalia expects to spend it alone because Wren has left for the holiday and Henry has not reached out. Dylan notices her distress and arrives at her apartment, then insists she come with him to his family’s home outside Washington. During the long drive, a rapid-fire question game gives way to Athalia’s account of her parents, their university histories, and the pressure she feels to resemble them.

She admits she is failing the subject her mother mastered and fears her parents would be disappointed. Dylan stops the car and reassures her that her life need not follow her parents’ path. At his family home, his mother Natalie and sisters welcome Athalia into their busy household.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The road trip shifts the story from manufactured attention to voluntary care. Athalia’s grief has narrowed her sense of family to Henry, whose distance makes the holiday especially painful. Dylan offers not a solution to that loss, but a place where she can speak without being corrected or hurried. His response to her academic shame matters because he separates her identity from her parents’ achievements. His family’s welcome then provides a lived alternative to isolation, one built from meals, teasing, and ordinary shared space.

A Holiday Without Pretending

Grief surfaces, and Dylan stays beside her

On the night before Thanksgiving, Athalia’s joking with Dylan gives way to a panic attack when he prepares to sleep in the guest room rather than cross a boundary while she is grieving. Dylan recognizes what is happening, helps her steady her breathing, and holds her until she can speak again. He tells her she is allowed to experience happiness without betraying her parents’ memory.

The next day, Athalia joins the McCarthys for Monopoly, helps Natalie prepare dinner, and goes with Dylan to buy holiday groceries. At the table, she discovers how much she wants the family’s approval. Their lively meal gives her room to remember her parents without letting grief consume the entire holiday.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The panic attack makes visible the cost of Athalia’s habit of treating grief as something she should either suppress or justify. Dylan’s restraint before the episode matters: he refuses to exploit her vulnerability, and then stays present when she cannot manage it alone. His reassurance does not erase loss; it loosens Athalia’s belief that joy and remembrance are mutually exclusive. The family’s noisy rituals give that insight a social form, allowing her to belong without pretending the past has stopped hurting.

The Messages She Missed

Athalia learns Henry spent Thanksgiving searching

On the drive back to campus, Dylan asks Athalia to use her phone for a statistics problem. Its notifications reveal that Henry spent Thanksgiving trying to reach her, even contacting Wren and fearing she had disappeared. Wren’s messages also show that she wanted Athalia safe, despite their fight, and had arranged for Dylan to take her home rather than leave her alone.

Once they return, Wren apologizes for withdrawing and explains that her feelings for Athalia had made the conflict harder, though she has since begun seeing someone else. Before they can settle everything, Henry arrives furious that Athalia left without telling him. His anger collapses into relief, and he embraces her after seven years of emotional distance.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The missed messages overturn Athalia’s simplest account of Henry: that he does not care. His concern does not excuse his earlier control, but it reveals that both twins have been grieving in isolation and mistaking distance for indifference. Wren’s explanation similarly reframes the silence between friends as fear and unspoken attachment rather than a lack of love. The discoveries do not instantly repair either relationship. They create the conditions for repair by making each person’s hidden motive visible.

The Twins Tell the Truth

Henry apologizes and shares what he has been protecting

After Wren gives the siblings privacy, Henry admits he has spoken with their therapist about his need to control Athalia when he feels powerless. Athalia explains that she staged the relationship with Dylan partly because Henry’s jealousy was the first sign in years that he cared. Henry apologizes for meddling and shutting her out, and she admits she never wanted to lose her twin.

He then reveals why he has been unusually tense: he has been working to reclaim their childhood summer home, which was at risk of being demolished. When he confirms the property is back in the family, Athalia recognizes that his secrecy came from trying to protect a place that holds their shared memories.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The siblings’ reconciliation succeeds because it moves beyond the immediate dispute and names the pattern underneath it. Henry’s control is tied to fear of helplessness, while Athalia’s provocation is tied to fear of being forgotten. Neither motive cancels the harm done, but both become understandable enough to address. The summer house gives Henry’s silence a concrete context: he has been carrying a threatened piece of their childhood alone. Reclaiming it cannot restore their parents, yet it offers the twins a shared object of care and a way to imagine family beyond loss.

The Deal Becomes Desire

Athalia visits Dylan even after the pretext disappears

Henry’s apology removes Athalia’s original reason for pretending to date Dylan. Rather than end the arrangement, she hurries through the rain to Dylan’s shared house and tries to tell him they can stop. The explanation stalls as he helps her out of her soaked boots, and she kisses him instead. They have sex for the first time, no longer under the pretense of convincing Henry, then fall asleep together.

Dylan leaves early for a match at Harvard, leaving Athalia a note about meeting later. When he does not answer her message, she assumes he is ignoring her and struggles to understand why the silence hurts. Her feelings have outgrown the deal, even as she still tries to call the encounter casual.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Athalia’s visit is the point at which the fake relationship loses its original function. She could leave with the problem solved, but she chooses Dylan without an audience or a tactical reward. The intimacy that follows is not proof that she has resolved her fear of attachment; her immediate return to the language of casualness shows the opposite. His note suggests continuity to her, so his silence becomes emotionally charged. Her confusion reveals that the relationship has become real in practice before either character has formally named it.

The Hospital Room Confession

A soccer injury explains Dylan’s sudden silence

When Dylan still has not answered, Blake calls Athalia from the hospital. Dylan has been tackled during the Harvard game and suffered bruising and broken ribs. Athalia rushes there with Wren, fearing the worst because the news recalls how she learned her parents had died. In his room, Dylan is medicated and unusually candid.

He explains that he has watched for Athalia since their first meeting, and that he once took a punch from a rival player who was insulting her. His injury had kept him from replying, not indifference. Athalia stays beside him, relieved he is alive and moved by what he reveals. His drugged honesty confirms that his attention began long before their fake-dating bargain.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The hospital scene turns a mundane silence into a crisis because Athalia’s past has trained her to expect sudden, irreversible loss. Her panic is not simply romantic worry; it is memory returning through a familiar pattern of unanswered contact and bad news. Dylan’s confession, blurted under medication, is persuasive precisely because it is not polished. His attention predates the contract, recasting their early antagonism as a defensive style that concealed interest rather than genuine dislike.

A Grade, Then a Future

Athalia passes, and the contract finally expires

A month later, Athalia and Dylan check their Statistics II results together. She hesitates to open hers, still afraid of failing the subject tied to her mother’s legacy, but finally learns she has passed.

Dylan tells her he believed in her throughout their tutoring, even when he pretended to doubt her to provoke effort. Athalia recognizes how their mismatched habits have become a kind of balance: he steadies her academic panic, while she pulls him away from work and toward rest.

Their relationship has continued beyond its planned end date, though they have not yet declared love. At the New Year’s gathering in the Pressley family’s Hamptons home, Athalia and Dylan kiss at midnight and finally acknowledge the love they have been showing each other.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Passing Statistics resolves the concrete problem that began the story, but the deeper victory is Athalia’s changed relationship to her mother’s legacy. She succeeds through practice and support, not by becoming a replica of Naomi. Dylan’s admission that he always believed in her also exposes the tutoring challenge as encouragement disguised as antagonism. The New Year’s setting closes the contract’s calendar while opening a relationship without rules. Their declaration follows months of care, making love less a sudden revelation than a truth their actions have already established.

Epilogue

At the Pressleys’ New Year’s party in the Hamptons, Athalia finds Dylan among his family and reconnects with Henry, who is trying, awkwardly, to welcome his sister’s relationship. As the countdown approaches, Dylan draws Athalia away from the crowd and kisses her at midnight.

The fake-dating contract has expired, leaving them free to choose what comes next. Athalia understands that she is in love with him, and Dylan tells her he feels the same. The party gathers the people whose attention she once tried to manipulate into a single room where affection no longer needs a performance.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The epilogue resolves the book’s central tension between performed affection and chosen intimacy. The contract’s expiration could have left Athalia and Dylan without a script, but the party shows that their attachment has survived the loss of its original excuse. Henry’s presence also matters: he is no longer the audience Athalia must provoke, but a brother learning to make room for her choices. The Hamptons setting brings family memory into the future, while the midnight confession turns the end date from a deadline into a beginning.

Analysis

Lessons in Faking uses a romantic comedy structure to examine a more difficult question: how do people ask to be loved when they have learned to treat need as weakness? Athalia does not begin by asking Henry to be closer. She creates a spectacle designed to make him jealous, because provocation feels safer than a vulnerable request. The scheme briefly succeeds, but it also exposes the limits of attention as a substitute for intimacy. Henry’s concern is real, yet his habit of controlling Athalia still harms her; the story does not confuse love with good judgment.

Dylan’s tutoring works as a counterpoint to both siblings’ defenses. He pushes Athalia to study, but his most consequential acts are often practical and private: caring for her when she is sick, accompanying her through Thanksgiving, and staying present during panic. These gestures move the romance beyond the public performance that launched it. Athalia’s academic struggle adds a parallel arc. Passing Statistics II does not make her a second version of her mother; it lets her succeed on her own terms, with help she has chosen to accept.

Grief shapes the book’s relationships without reducing them to a single wound. Athalia and Henry remember their parents differently and cope in opposite ways, while Wren’s fear for Athalia can become silence or anger. The Thanksgiving chapters make room for joy beside remembrance, resisting the idea that happiness is a betrayal of the dead. By the ending, Athalia has not exchanged one family for another or solved every loss. She has learned to recognize care in different forms, to speak more honestly, and to let affection be chosen rather than engineered.

Summary in 60 Seconds
Athalia Pressley is failing statistics when her tutor turns out to be Dylan McCarthy Williams, the soccer player her twin brother Henry hates. To provoke Henry into paying attention to her, Athalia persuades Dylan to pretend they are dating. Their public performance grows intimate, and kisses and private acts of care blur the bargain. Dylan takes Athalia home for Thanksgiving, where she finds comfort with his family and faces grief over her parents. When Henry finally explains his controlling behavior and reveals he has reclaimed their childhood home, Athalia no longer needs the pretense, but chooses Dylan anyway. After they sleep together, she mistakes his silence for rejection until she learns a soccer injury has left him in the hospital. Dylan admits his feelings began before their arrangement. Athalia passes statistics, and at New Year's, they confess their love and begin a genuine relationship.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.74 out of 5
Average of 10k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Lessons in Faking received mixed reviews, with many praising its charming romance, witty banter, and enjoyable tropes. Readers appreciated the chemistry between Athalia and Dylan, finding their fake dating storyline entertaining. Some criticized the plot as predictable and the characters as underdeveloped. The book's origins as a Wattpad fanfiction were noted, with some finding it added charm and others seeing it as a weakness. Overall, fans of college romance and classic tropes found it enjoyable, while others felt it lacked depth.

Your rating:
4.85
5 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Athalia Pressley

The restless twin

Athalia is a wealthy HBU student who prefers humor, spontaneity, and takeout to schedules or academic pressure. She lives in the shadow of her celebrated parents and feels especially exposed by failing Statistics II, the subject associated with her mother’s work. Her twin Henry is the person she most wants close, even when his attempts to help become controlling. Athalia often disguises hurt with sarcasm and treats attention as proof of affection, which makes her revenge plan emotionally riskier than she expects. Her loyalty to her best friend Wren and her capacity for warmth sit beneath her sharp comebacks. She wants independence, but also longs to be cared for without having to manufacture a crisis.

Dylan McCarthy Williams

The rival tutor

Dylan is Henry’s soccer rival, a capable student, and the teaching assistant assigned to tutor Athalia. He is dry, self-assured, and quick to provoke, especially when he can unsettle Henry. His confidence can look like indifference, but he is observant: he remembers Athalia’s preferences, notices when she is struggling, and brings practical care into moments when no audience is watching. Dylan’s family ties reveal a more domestic, dependable side than his teasing persona suggests. He enjoys competition and hides sincerity behind jokes, yet he takes Athalia’s boundaries seriously. His central tension is between his habit of treating attraction as a game and the growing care that makes the game difficult to sustain.

Henry Pressley

The protective twin

Henry is Athalia’s twin, a disciplined soccer star, and a person who has built his life around plans, achievement, and control. After a family loss, he copes by focusing on the future and often mistakes practical intervention for emotional support. His rivalry with Dylan is intense, but his concern for Athalia is real, even when he expresses it by deciding what she should do. Henry’s distance leaves his sister unsure whether she matters to him, while his occasional attempts to manage her life make closeness feel like a contest. He is stubborn and proud, yet capable of confronting his own patterns when he finally seeks help. His loyalty is easier to see in action than to hear in words.

Wren Inkwood

The loyal roommate

Wren is Athalia’s best friend and roommate, an introverted history student with split-dyed hair, a sharp tongue, and a deep reserve of practical loyalty. She does not drink, dislikes crowds, and nevertheless accompanies Athalia to parties and soccer games because showing up matters to her. Wren is protective after seeing Athalia hurt by an ex, and her concern can make her judgmental when Athalia takes a risk she cannot control. She is more comfortable acting than explaining herself, which contributes to a painful silence when she and Athalia fall out. Beneath the bluntness is a friend who notices when Athalia is isolated and tries to keep her from facing difficult days alone.

Jason Montgomery

The polished ex

Jason is Athalia’s former boyfriend, a charming, socially polished student whose betrayal has left her wary of renewed attention from him. At a party, he approaches her with suggestive familiarity and treats their past as if it entitles him to her company. His presence gives Athalia a reason to accept Dylan’s public support, while also exposing how easily old hurt can return.

Simon Shaw

The demanding professor

Professor Shaw teaches Statistics II and sets weekly tutoring with his teaching assistant as Athalia’s chance to pass. He is strict, openly unimpressed by her academic performance, and unwilling to let the Pressley name secure special treatment. His bluntness is intimidating, but it forces Athalia to confront the consequences of relying on shortcuts.

Blake Zachary

Dylan’s steady best friend

Blake is Dylan’s close friend and one of his housemates. He is sociable and initially approaches Athalia with mock suspicion, then drops the act and speaks with her easily. His friendship with Dylan places him near the couple’s circle, and he becomes an important link when Dylan is unable to contact Athalia.

Caden

The teasing teammate

Caden is one of Dylan’s teammates and housemates, a playful friend who enjoys embarrassing him in public. At a team celebration, he creates the awkward seating situation that pushes Athalia and Dylan into closer physical contact. His teasing helps expose how much effort their performance already requires.

Michael

The blunt teammate

Michael is a teammate and friend in the soccer circle who openly remarks on the oddity of Dylan dating Henry’s sister. His comment sharpens Henry’s visible discomfort and makes Athalia more conscious of the scrutiny around their supposed relationship.

Natalie Williams

The welcoming mother

Natalie is Dylan’s mother, a warm host who feeds her family and welcomes Athalia into their Thanksgiving gathering. Her affectionate exasperation with Dylan and his sisters helps establish the lively, teasing atmosphere of the household. Natalie’s easy inclusion gives Athalia a glimpse of family closeness without demanding that she explain her grief.

Lincoln Williams

The distant father

Lincoln is Dylan’s father, a reserved man whose relationship with his son is strained by different expectations for Dylan’s future. He is present at the family gathering but often keeps to himself, reflecting a distance Dylan is reluctant to discuss. His presence helps explain why Dylan’s bond with his mother and sisters is especially important to him.

Diana Williams

The eldest sister

Diana is Dylan’s eldest sister, recently finished with graduate school and comfortable calling out her brother’s behavior. She joins the family’s teasing and treats Athalia as welcome company. Her directness makes her one of the first to recognize how much Dylan cares.

Denise Williams

The returned traveler

Denise is one of Dylan’s older sisters, a traveler who has spent time in Europe. She joins in the family’s joking and adds to the crowded, affectionate atmosphere Athalia encounters at Thanksgiving.

Dakota Williams

The quick-witted sister

Dakota is one of Dylan’s younger sisters, lively and quick to tease him. She is comfortable enough to bicker with him, share family stories, and pull Athalia into the household’s jokes. Her easy warmth helps make Athalia feel less like a guest.

Delilah Williams

The youngest sister

Delilah is Dylan’s youngest sister, twelve years old and eager to meet Athalia. Her confidence and open friendliness make her one of the first family members to welcome the visitor.

Paula Castillo

Henry’s former girlfriend

Paula is Henry’s former girlfriend and a point of confusion in the rivalry between Henry and Dylan. Athalia has accepted Henry’s version of their history without questioning it, so Paula’s connection to both men helps reveal how easily assumptions harden into grievances.

Heather

The well-meaning messenger

Heather is one of Henry’s friends and a library acquaintance of Athalia. She inadvertently reveals that Henry contacted Professor Shaw about the tutoring arrangement, prompting Athalia to confront him.

Reuben

Henry’s thoughtful roommate

Reuben is one of Henry’s roommates and a calmer presence in his circle. He is nearby during the tense confrontation at the frat house and later appears among the people around Henry.

Laila

The friendly game guest

Laila is part of the wider soccer-team social circle and attends the postgame gathering. She talks with Wren and later helps with the ride home after an away match.

Stephanie

The siblings’ therapist

Stephanie is the therapist familiar to Athalia and Henry. Her work gives Henry a way to examine why fear and lost control lead him to interfere in Athalia’s choices.

Plot Devices

The dating contract

Rules for risky closeness

Athalia and Dylan formalize their fake relationship in writing, setting public dating expectations, a time limit, and boundaries. The contract gives them a reason to schedule dates, attend games, and show affection where Henry can see. Its clauses also let them pretend that attraction is merely part of an agreed performance. As their private behavior grows more intimate, the contract’s rules become an increasingly fragile defense against acknowledging what they want.

Statistics tutoring

A lesson becomes courtship

Athalia’s failing grade forces weekly sessions with Dylan, her brother’s rival. The tutoring gives the pair a recurring reason to meet outside their public dates and supplies a concrete measure of Athalia’s growth. Dylan turns correct answers into affectionate rewards, joining academic effort to physical attraction. Statistics also carries emotional weight because Athalia compares herself with her mother’s accomplishments. Progress in class therefore becomes a test of self-worth as well as a practical route toward passing.

The rose deliveries

A remembered dislike becomes a joke

Dylan repeatedly gives Athalia red roses after she identifies them as her least favorite flowers. The gesture is deliberately provocative, but it also demonstrates that he listened closely enough to remember a small preference. The roses accumulate in her room as visible evidence of their ongoing charade and of the growing familiarity beneath it. Dylan’s later doodle of a rose on a note links the joke to a quieter act of care.

The Thanksgiving drive

A road trip opens grief

Dylan’s invitation takes Athalia away from an empty apartment and into his family’s Thanksgiving gathering. The long drive gives her enough privacy and time to talk about her parents, her twin, and her fear of failing to live up to family expectations. His family’s ordinary warmth then makes the conversation concrete: Athalia experiences a crowded home in which care is expressed through food, teasing, and welcome. The trip contrasts isolation with belonging without pretending one can replace the other.

The phone messages

Silence reveals hidden care

Athalia’s powered-off phone conceals Henry’s repeated attempts to reach her over Thanksgiving. When Dylan prompts her to check it, she discovers that her brother was afraid for her and that Wren helped arrange for Dylan to be with her. The messages reverse Athalia’s assumption that Henry is indifferent, but they do not erase his earlier overreach. Instead, they make a direct conversation possible by revealing care that neither sibling had been able to express clearly.

About the Author

Selina Mae is a romance author who draws inspiration from her own experiences to create engaging love stories. Her writing style is characterized by witty dialogue, relatable characters, and classic romantic tropes. Mae's background as a romance reader herself informs her writing, allowing her to craft stories that resonate with fans of the genre. When not writing, she enjoys revisiting her favorite comfort reads and indulging in emotional responses to happy endings. Mae's work often explores themes of self-discovery and personal growth alongside the central romance, creating multi-layered narratives that appeal to a wide range of readers.

Download PDF

To save this Lessons In Faking summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.28 MB     Pages: 25

Download EPUB

To read this Lessons In Faking summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.27 MB     Pages: 29
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...