Plot Summary
Bigfoot on the Pass
At eighteen, Jolene Vero hides beside a mountain road in a gorilla suit, eager to frighten Elizabeth Smith, a classmate she resents for copying her style and possibly poisoning her. When Elizabeth's orange Karmann Ghia approaches, Jolene leaps into view. Elizabeth swerves and plunges down the embankment.
Jolene freezes at the sound of the crash, then flees in the costume rather than climb down to help. After reaching her car, she asks a woman walking a dog to call emergency services, but drives away before help arrives. Jolene later learns nothing that night. In fact, Elizabeth is trapped in a burning car, suffers severe injuries, and loses her leg.
The prank begins as a performance designed to control how others see Elizabeth, but the road turns that performance into irreversible physical harm. Jolene’s crucial failure is not simply misjudging the danger of a scare. Once the accident happens, she chooses self-protection over direct aid, then uses a stranger’s call for help to reassure herself that responsibility has been transferred. The scene establishes the story’s central moral pressure: Jolene can recognize that she has done wrong, yet recognition alone does not make her act accountably.
The Alibi Takes Shape
Shaking at home, Jolene calls her father, a criminal defense lawyer, and describes the crash as a hypothetical. He explains that the person who caused it could face serious charges if the driver is injured or killed. When Jolene admits the disguise, her father does not tell her to contact the police.
Instead, he leads her toward an account in which she stayed home all evening, packing for summer camp. Jolene accepts the offered escape, throws the gorilla suit away, and refreshes local news pages for word of the crash. Finding none, she imagines Elizabeth survived with minor injuries and sleeps. Elizabeth is still in a burn unit; surgeons amputate her leg the next morning.
Jolene’s father offers more than legal advice. He supplies a story that can replace the event, giving his daughter a way to move from panic to denial without facing the injured person. His intervention is loving and damaging at once: it protects Jolene from immediate consequences while making secrecy part of their bond. The absence of news becomes evidence only because Jolene wants it to be. Her imagination, which first made the prank feel harmless, now manufactures a survivable version of its aftermath.
Berkeley, Another Beginning
Ten years later, Jolene has left behind a string of cities, schools, jobs, and recovery attempts, while her father continues to help her restart. She moves to Berkeley, takes an assistant job arranged through him, and works for Suzanne Hill, a silver-haired poet who fills her house with possessions and guards a windowless writing shed.
Jolene likes the city’s unruly energy but feels unsettled by her empty apartment and uncertain work. Then she sees an orange Karmann Ghia parked nearby. Panic revives the memory she has spent years suppressing, and she confides in Alice, her longtime friend. When she joins an improv class, she hopes performance might finally become a life she can stay in.
Jolene’s repeated departures look like freedom from the outside, but the car reveals how much of her motion is organized around avoiding a fixed point. Berkeley attracts her as a place of possibility, yet the familiar orange car makes the past physically present before she has chosen to face it. Suzanne’s cluttered house and protected writing shed introduce another form of containment: a life with rooms Jolene can enter only by permission. Her new job and class offer structure, but she approaches each as a possible escape hatch.
Elizabeth at Improv
At improv, Jolene recognizes Elizabeth as soon as the woman turns toward the class. Elizabeth’s face is scarred, one eye is artificial, and she walks with a slight limp. She recognizes Jolene too, but greets her warmly rather than accusing her. They leave together and discover they live around the corner from each other.
Elizabeth describes her acting work and plans to study drama therapy, while Jolene hides how little she has settled on. She also learns that Elizabeth has endured years of trauma but cannot remember what caused the crash. Elizabeth invites Jolene to socialize, unaware of Jolene’s role. Jolene accepts, partly from guilt and partly because refusing would mean admitting how frightened she is.
The reunion denies Jolene the confrontation she has rehearsed in private. Elizabeth’s welcome does not absolve her; instead, it makes ordinary friendship feel morally unbearable, because every kind gesture arrives without knowledge of the harm beneath it. Elizabeth’s memory gap also deprives Jolene of an easy script for confession or blame. Their proximity turns the old secret from a distant event into a daily relationship, and Jolene responds by performing friendliness rather than deciding what honesty or repair would require.
A Rivalry Rewritten
As the reunion unsettles her, Jolene revisits senior year through memories that cast Elizabeth as her relentless imitator. She recalls Elizabeth praising her clothes at their first theater class, then adopting her red hair, makeup, and vintage look.
Jolene remembers winning Juliet while Elizabeth became understudy, and suspects Elizabeth tampered with the stage potion that made her violently ill before opening night. She also remembers Elizabeth taking Joey, the boy Jolene expected to attend prom with, and concludes that Elizabeth wanted whatever Jolene wanted.
The recollections leave Jolene feeling displaced and humiliated. They also supply the anger she later uses to justify the gorilla prank, though the memories themselves will prove less secure than she believes.
The remembered rivalry gives Jolene a coherent origin story for her resentment: Elizabeth takes, Jolene loses, and retaliation becomes a form of balance. Yet even here, the evidence is uneven. Some memories describe observable choices, while others depend on suspicion and interpretation, especially the alleged poisoning. By making the past feel like a case Jolene has already solved, the narrative shows how an emotionally satisfying account can harden into certainty. Her sense of being copied may be real, distorted, or reversed, but it has already become the framework through which she judges both women.
Blood on the Door
After Jolene finds a bloody-looking footprint on her apartment door, she notices the smear on her hand and fears Elizabeth knows the truth. Suzanne treats the mark as an omen. Soon after, a bird strikes Jolene’s window and lies dead below it, its head badly injured. Alice urges her to seek help, so Jolene visits therapist Maria Markland and, near the end of their first session, confesses that she caused Elizabeth’s crash and left the scene.
The admission brings brief relief followed by shame. Suzanne later asks Jolene to dispose of expired prescriptions; Jolene keeps the bottles instead. In a later session, Maria discusses psychedelic therapy, and Jolene begins to consider confronting the guilt she has spent years outrunning.
The footprints and bird turn guilt into apparent evidence of an outside pursuer, allowing Jolene to treat inner accusation as a threat arriving from the street. Her first therapy confession briefly breaks that division: she names what she did to another person, rather than describing only what she fears will happen to herself. But the private stash of medication points toward another kind of avoidance, a way to quiet distress without changing its cause. The section places genuine psychological insight beside supernatural interpretation, making Jolene’s growing suspicion difficult to separate from her real, concealed culpability.
Cookies and a Glass Eye
Elizabeth visits Jolene with cookies and concern after Jolene stops answering her messages. She removes her glass eye to show Jolene the socket, then urges her to eat. Jolene forces down a bite and later feels sick with guilt and suspicion. After cutting her hair short, Jolene goes to dinner at Elizabeth’s apartment and finds that Elizabeth has chosen the same pixie cut.
Elizabeth serves burnt pot pies and speaks about the accident, her disabilities, and the blank space in her memory. Jolene cannot bring herself to confess. She becomes violently ill after leaving and discovers a glass eye lodged in her sink drain. Convinced Elizabeth has begun targeting her, Jolene takes pills from the medicine stash to sleep.
Care becomes frightening because Jolene receives it from the person she harmed. Elizabeth’s cookies, touch, and invitation are ordinary offers of intimacy, but Jolene experiences each as a possible trap. Her suspicions are not wholly invented from nothing: a glass eye really is in the drain, and Elizabeth’s physical resemblance to Jolene’s new haircut feels uncanny. Yet Jolene repeatedly supplies the missing causal link herself. The result is a closed interpretive loop in which guilt makes coincidence look deliberate, while every unexplained object appears to confirm that someone is punishing her.
The Clown at Midnight
On Halloween, Jolene finds a broken clown on her doorstep and receives an ominous message from an unknown number. At improv, Elizabeth wears a Bigfoot shirt; Jolene accuses her of leaving the clown, but Elizabeth and Jerry provide an alibi for the night it appeared.
Another message deepens Jolene’s fear. After taking pills, Jolene sees a gorilla-suited figure at her window and runs to Elizabeth’s home, only to find Elizabeth asleep with Jerry. The next day, Jolene’s accusations and drinking drive Alice away; Alice reveals that she has been struggling with miscarriages.
Jolene’s father arrives and makes her flush the pills. On the day of her treatment, Jolene learns Suzanne was acquitted in her husband’s death, then Suzanne fires her for interrupting the writing shed.
The threat sequence weakens Jolene’s ability to test her beliefs against other people. Jerry’s alibi and Elizabeth’s confusion offer counterevidence, but Jolene has already begun treating disbelief as proof that others cannot see what she sees. At brunch, her attack on Alice exposes the cost of that pattern: she has mistaken a friend’s care for surveillance and failed to notice Alice’s private grief. Her father’s intervention removes the drugs but not the crisis. Meanwhile, Suzanne’s sudden dismissal and history of suspected violence leave Jolene with fewer supports just as she prepares to enter an altered state.
The Mushroom Trap
Jolene arrives at Maria’s home office for psilocybin therapy, expecting a guided session about guilt. Instead, while she is hallucinating, Elizabeth appears with Maria, who reveals she is Elizabeth’s stepmother.
They bind Jolene and describe the revenge they intend to inflict, using the injuries Elizabeth suffered as their model. Jolene struggles free as Elizabeth reaches for a saw. She escapes into the house, where Maria finds her in a closet. Following the voice in her head, Jolene strikes Maria with a weight.
Elizabeth then comes after her with a knife, and Jolene pushes her down the stairs. Elizabeth falls onto the blade and dies. Whether drug effects distort parts of what Jolene perceives, the injuries and deaths become the terrifying facts she must face.
The therapy room reverses its promised function: the person Jolene trusted to help her confront reality is part of a plan to punish her. The scene makes the voice in Jolene’s head newly ambiguous. It has long attacked her with accusations, but now its guidance helps her survive an actual assault. At the same time, the psychedelic state prevents her, and the reader, from treating every perception as transparent fact. The violence is presented as self-defense, yet it cannot undo the original harm or provide moral clarity. Jolene escapes immediate danger by entering a deeper uncertainty.
A Mirror Reverses
After the violence, Jolene hides Maria and Elizabeth’s bodies in Maria’s hot tub, cleans the house, and discovers the security system is switched off. She returns to her father, who collects her after she describes the killings as hypothetical; neither discusses what happened.
At Christmas, Alice reports that Elizabeth and the woman believed to be her mother were found in a hot tub, with the deaths attributed publicly to an unknown killer. Then Jolene examines old photographs and her yearbook.
They show Elizabeth with the red hair, Jolene as Juliet’s understudy, and a painting that may have been Jolene’s work. Her search history suggests she chose Berkeley to find Elizabeth. Jolene cannot settle which memories are true, and retreats once more into forgetting.
The ending refuses the comfort of a cleanly reliable narrator or a neatly resolved crime. Photographs, the yearbook, and search history undermine Jolene’s established account, suggesting she may have occupied the role of copycat and aggressor she assigned to Elizabeth. They do not settle every question, including what happened with the stage potion or how much Jolene knowingly sought Elizabeth out. Her father’s silence and the public story of a killer preserve her secrecy, while Alice’s suspicion threatens her remaining bond. Jolene answers uncertainty with her oldest strategy: choosing movement, or imagined movement, over a stable account of herself.
Analysis
Like It Never Was builds its suspense around a question that begins as a legal one: what happens when a person causes terrible harm and then hides from it? Jolene’s father offers an alibi instead of accountability, and his protection lets her treat time and distance as substitutes for repair. Her restless adult life appears at first to be a temperament, but the return of Elizabeth and the orange car exposes how much of that movement is organized around avoidance.
The book complicates guilt by placing it beside paranoia. Jolene has genuinely concealed a catastrophic act, so her fear is not baseless; yet she repeatedly turns uncertain details into proof of a revenge plot. The reader is asked to distinguish the reality of her original wrongdoing from the reliability of her later explanations. That distinction becomes more unsettling when her final keepsakes suggest she may have reversed the roles in her remembered high school rivalry. The evidence undermines her story without supplying a perfectly stable replacement.
The voice inside Jolene captures this conflict in intimate form. It resembles punishment, but during the assault it also helps her survive. Likewise, therapy begins as a hoped-for route toward self-knowledge and becomes the setting for betrayal. These reversals resist easy claims that confession, treatment, or remorse automatically produces healing. Jolene’s final escape preserves her life but not her innocence, and the cover-up repeats the secrecy that shaped the opening. Her choice to forget again is both a survival tactic and a refusal of the difficult work of knowing what she has done. The ending’s unease comes from leaving those two meanings intact.
Review Summary
Like It Never Was receives mixed reviews, averaging 3.42/5. Many readers praise its unhinged unreliable narrator, dark humor, and compulsive readability, often finishing it in one sitting. The twisty plot and morally complex characters are frequently highlighted as strengths. However, some critics find the storyline too over-the-top or implausible, and several note the characters speak with an immature, YA-like tone despite being thirty-year-olds. The ending divides readers — some find it mind-blowing, others feel it's rushed or unsatisfying.
Characters
Jolene Vero
Restless self-doubterJolene is an aspiring actor and serial beginner whose father’s support repeatedly gives her a fresh place to land. She is witty, imaginative, and quick to turn embarrassment into a joke, but she also uses reinvention to avoid sustained responsibility. Guilt over Elizabeth’s crash shapes her adult restlessness, while an internal voice gives her self-criticism the force of a separate presence. Jolene wants to be good, yet often confuses feeling remorse with making repair. Her account of herself is vivid and persuasive, which makes the gaps in her memory and the confidence of her interpretations especially important.
Elizabeth Smith
Scarred improv mentorElizabeth is Jolene’s former high school classmate, an acting coach who enters Jolene’s new life as an assistant in an improv class. She is energetic, sociable, and eager to make connection, with ambitions centered on using theater to help others. Her visible injuries and prosthetic devices are part of her daily reality, but they do not erase her humor, professional drive, or need to be seen as more than what happened to her. Jolene’s memories cast Elizabeth as a rival and imitator, while Elizabeth’s present-day warmth complicates that account.
Jolene's father
Protective defense lawyerA high-profile criminal defense attorney, Jolene’s father is devoted to his daughter and often acts as her practical safety net. He uses humor, forceful advice, and financial help to keep her moving through one crisis after another. His legal instincts and fierce protectiveness can blur into enabling, especially when Jolene needs accountability more than rescue. A widower who raised Jolene alone, he is also a person carrying grief he rarely discusses. His affection is unmistakable, even when frustration makes his attempts to guide her sound like reprimands.
Alice
Steady doctor friendAlice is Jolene’s closest friend since high school, a general practitioner whose stable adult life contrasts with Jolene’s appetite for abrupt change. She offers affection, practical advice, and a willingness to challenge Jolene when reassurance would only strengthen avoidance. Alice is patient, but not endlessly available, and her own private burdens are easy for Jolene to overlook. Their friendship gives Jolene a rare source of continuity, though that continuity depends on mutual attention rather than Alice simply absorbing every crisis.
Suzanne Hill
Eccentric poet employerSuzanne is a wealthy, silver-haired poet who hires Jolene to organize her crowded home and assist with creative work. She speaks in theatrical pronouncements, trusts auras and omens, and treats her writing shed as a protected space. Her eccentricity makes her difficult to predict, but she can also offer Jolene warmth and a sense of being noticed. Suzanne’s attachment to possessions, ritual, and the demands of artistic inspiration hints at a private life more complicated than her eccentric manner first suggests.
Maria Markland
Therapist with poiseMaria is a polished therapist who listens closely and encourages Jolene to examine guilt, fear, and the critical voice in her mind. Her calm manner makes her seem capable of containing Jolene’s most difficult disclosures. She is interested in treatments beyond medication and presents psychedelic therapy as a structured, supervised option. For Jolene, Maria represents the possibility of facing distress without being reduced to a diagnosis. Her controlled professionalism also makes it difficult for Jolene to know how much of Maria’s inner life remains hidden.
Jerry Pinkerton
Improvisation ringmasterJerry teaches Jolene’s improv class and gives it the bustling energy of a performance even when students are only warming up. A veteran actor and coach, he enjoys attention and takes pride in his theater credentials. He mentors Elizabeth and brings her into the class, where his loose, joking manner can make it unclear whether he is speaking as a teacher or as a friend. His role connects the women through the theater community that both associate with identity and reinvention.
Google Man
Unreadable upstairs landlordJolene’s landlord lives above her in the renovated Victorian she rents. He works from home, communicates tersely, and enters the apartment to deal with repairs, sometimes without the warning Jolene expects. His reserve and access to spare keys make him an easy focus for her suspicions, though his behavior also has ordinary explanations. He remains a practical presence in a home where Jolene feels increasingly unsafe.
Joey
Easygoing school friendJoey is a laid-back classmate Jolene remembers flirting with during senior year. He is kind and easygoing, but his friendliness makes him reluctant to take sides in Jolene’s conflict with Elizabeth. His position in their shared social circle becomes a source of jealousy and humiliation for Jolene, even as he does not see himself as part of a serious rivalry.
Daveed D'Angelo
Absent poet's husbandDaveed is Suzanne’s husband, present in the story through the belongings she keeps in boxes and the memories she may use in her writing. His absence shapes the crowded rooms Jolene helps organize and raises questions about Suzanne’s private history. He is not directly encountered by Jolene, but his possessions and prescription bottles connect the household’s past to events in her present.
Liam
Alice's grounded husbandLiam is Alice’s husband, an accountant who appears in the background of Jolene’s calls with her friend. His settled domestic life underscores how different the two women’s daily routines have become.
Sadie
Suspicious little dogSadie is Alice’s small chiweenie, usually dressed in carefully chosen outfits. She barks and growls at Jolene, adding comic friction to visits and making Alice’s home feel like a world with its own rules.
Jolene's mother
Memory's lost motherJolene’s mother died of breast cancer when Jolene was very young. Jolene has almost no dependable memories of her, while her father’s grief remains part of the family history neither discusses easily.
Plot Devices
Then and Now memories
Unstable personal historyThe narrative alternates between Jolene’s teenage account of the crash and her adult life in Berkeley. The past initially seems to explain why she resented Elizabeth and why the prank happened. Later, photographs, a yearbook, and search history contradict parts of that account. The structure makes memory an active force in the plot, not a neutral record: Jolene’s explanations shape the reader’s view until physical evidence unsettles them. The device leaves some facts unresolved, so the ending turns on the limits of certainty rather than a complete reconstruction.
The gorilla costume
Prank becomes hauntingJolene wears a gorilla suit to frighten Elizabeth after Elizabeth claims to have seen Bigfoot. The costume causes the crash that binds their lives together. Years later, a gorilla-suited figure appears outside Jolene’s window, turning her original disguise into a possible threat and intensifying her fear that Elizabeth has discovered the truth. Its return links the first act of reckless deception to Jolene’s later uncertainty about what she sees.
The inner voice
Guilt as an antagonistJolene experiences a harsh internal voice that insults her, warns her, and interprets events as evidence that she deserves punishment. She knows it comes from her own mind, but its apparent independence gives her self-condemnation dramatic force. During the psychedelic attack, the voice shifts from accusation toward practical guidance, helping her respond to immediate danger. This change complicates its role: it is both the language of guilt and, at a crucial moment, a survival instinct Jolene has learned to distrust.
Household omens
Evidence or projectionA bloody-looking footprint, a dead bird, an eye in a drain, a broken clown, and anonymous messages appear around Jolene as her paranoia grows. Some items have plausible explanations, while others remain disturbing or unresolved. Their accumulation encourages Jolene to connect them to Elizabeth, but her guilt and medication use make that interpretation unreliable. The objects work as a thriller’s trail of clues and as a psychological portrait of confirmation bias, keeping the reader between a genuine stalking plot and a mind struggling to separate coincidence from design.
Psychedelic therapy
A guided descentMaria presents psilocybin therapy as a supervised way for Jolene to confront guilt after other treatments have failed. Jolene enters the session expecting an inward journey, but the drug’s hallucinations overlap with a real attack by Maria and Elizabeth. The altered state heightens sensory confusion and obscures the line between perception and danger, while also forcing Jolene to act when the threat becomes physical. The device brings the novel’s psychological uncertainty into its climax without making the consequences of the violence imaginary.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.