Plot Summary
Prologue
Three months before the main story, Xavi1 sits blindfolded on his motorcycle at the cliff where his brother died, intoxicated and close to riding over the edge. A message changes his focus: someone has sent him compromising photographs of Nate2 and is threatening him.
Xavi1 calls Carter,4 his longtime friend and Nate’s best friend,4 for help, then deletes the messages and blocks the sender so Nate2 will not discover what he has done. He edges toward the drop, still torn between dying and protecting Nate2 from the secret that brought him there.
The opening makes self-destruction look less like a single impulse than the end point of Xavi’s practiced isolation. He has made the cliff, the blindfold, and intoxication part of a private ritual, but the threat to Nate breaks through that numbness. Even at his most hopeless, Xavi acts to protect someone else. That contradiction prepares the central tension: devotion keeps him alive, yet shame convinces him that love requires concealment. The glimpse forward also turns the later romance into a question of whether intimacy can survive the truth.
The Hospital Ring
Two years before the present, Xavi1 reaches the hospital high and desperate to learn whether Katy,3 his blind best friend3 and Nate’s younger sister,3 will survive. Nate2 sits with Xavi’s black number 13 ring, taken from Katy,3 and tells him she is dead. He accuses Xavi1 of causing her death, shoves him against a vending machine, then lets him collapse to the floor.
Nate’s parents10 grieve nearby, but Xavi1 cannot stay to say goodbye. He leaves carrying the blame Nate2 has placed on him and the knowledge that he had been with Katy3 the night before. In his car, he plays her voice messages repeatedly, turning a familiar sound into a punishment he cannot stop administering.
The ring gives grief a physical object to fight over. Nate reads it as evidence of Xavi’s claim on Katy, while Xavi experiences it as a remnant of their friendship. Neither can yet separate love from accusation. The hospital scene also establishes the novel’s moral pressure point: Xavi did not cause Katy’s death in a simple, intentional sense, but he believes his choices mattered, and Nate needs a person to hold responsible. Their shared guilt becomes a bond that initially permits only cruelty.
Two Years, One Driveway
In the present, Nate2 lives near campus with his best friend4 Carter,4 teammate6 Easton,6 and Frankie,5 a party-loving young woman he once gave a place to stay. When Nate2 brings a drunk Frankie5 home, he finds Xavi1 waiting beside his motorcycle. Nate2 punches him before learning that Xavi1 plans to attend Hawthorne University and live in the house.
Xavi1 says Nate2 has been absent from his family for two years, but Nate2 insists he has cut ties with everyone from home. He attacks Xavi1 again and orders him to leave. Xavi1 stays put, bruised and anxious, because college was a promise he made to Katy,3 and he is trying to build a life she had expected them to share.
The driveway turns the past into a domestic problem that neither man can avoid. Nate’s violence restores the old hierarchy at once: he can punish Xavi, while Xavi still chooses to remain within reach. But the decision to stay is not simple defiance. Xavi is carrying out a plan shaped by Katy’s hopes, which makes his arrival both an act of mourning and a bid for a future. The house will force proximity before either man has the language to negotiate it.
Carter’s House, Katy’s Plan
Carter4 reveals that he arranged Xavi’s1 move-in as a favor that Nate2 never requested. He gives Xavi1 a key and directs him to a room beside Nate’s,2 turning the former friends’ hostility into a daily fact of the house. Xavi1 remembers that Katy3 had imagined the three of them living there together at college.
He unpacks almost nothing, keeping her photographs close. At dinner, Easton6 offers Xavi1 food and invites him to a party, treating him more gently than he expects. Xavi1 goes, but the crowd, alcohol, and drugs overwhelm him, and he retreats outside. Nate2 watches him from across the yard, seeing both the boy he blames and the sober, fragile stranger he has become.
Carter’s scheme is more than a comic disruption. He puts Nate and Xavi in a setting where avoidance becomes impossible, but he does so without either man’s consent, repeating the story’s pattern of people deciding what another person can endure. Easton offers a different model of contact: practical kindness without interrogation. Xavi’s panic at the party shows recovery as an ongoing negotiation with ordinary environments, not a clean conversion. Nate’s watchfulness begins to shift from surveillance as punishment toward attention he cannot explain.
The Bathtub’s Dangerous Audience
Three years earlier, Nate2 finds his sixteen-year-old sister Katy3 and Xavi1 in her bathtub, fully clothed, soaked, and singing together after they have turned the bathroom into a game. Katy3 is blind, but Xavi1 guides her carefully out of the tub and checks that she is all right. Nate2 sees the ease between them and resents how much she trusts Xavi,1 especially after she admits she lied about where she was going.
He orders her to bed, then provokes Xavi1 by kissing Carter4 in front of him. Carter4 and Nate2 have a casual sexual arrangement, but Nate’s2 performance is aimed at Xavi.1 Xavi1 leaves with a defiant gesture, while Nate2 is left with the uncomfortable certainty that his anger includes jealousy.
This memory revises the rivalry’s origin. Nate’s protectiveness toward Katy is real, but so is his resentment when she accepts Xavi’s care more readily than his. Xavi’s attentiveness is not possessive: he checks Katy’s emotional state as well as her physical safety. Nate, unable to name his attraction, converts it into a contest for influence. His display with Carter is therefore both genuine sexual freedom and an instrument of control, a pattern that will later complicate his ability to distinguish desire from punishment.
Katy’s List Goes Missing
Xavi1 carries out items from a list he and Katy made, including swimming blindfolded in a stranger’s pool. He escapes Bryson West’s11 property scraped and bleeding, then returns to the house where Nate2 orders him to clean the blood from the floor. Nate2 begins entering Xavi’s1 unlocked room at night, watching him sleep and searching his phone and wallet.
He finds the photo strip of Xavi and Katy, then steals it. The next morning, Xavi1 panics because the pictures are gone and misses a therapy appointment after Nate2 disables his alarm. Nate2 finally gives the strip back, but only after Xavi1 begs. He tells Xavi1 to lock his door, disguising his own growing need to know everything about him as a threat.
The list lets Xavi turn grief into action, but its challenges also expose how little care he gives his own safety. Nate’s theft of the photographs is an attempt to control the evidence of a closeness he envies, while disabling the alarm crosses from antagonism into interference with Xavi’s recovery. The returned keepsake does not repair that violation. Instead, the exchange creates a charged private language in which tenderness and coercion arrive in the same gesture, making consent and power central questions rather than decorative complications.
The First Kiss Costs
At another party, Nate2 drags Xavi1 outside after Xavi1 invokes Katy3 during an argument. He pins him against the wall, touches him, then recoils when he realizes Xavi1 is sober. Nate2 reads sobriety as a claim to moral improvement, and Xavi1 explains that he stays clean because feeling the pain is a punishment he believes he deserves. Nate2 kisses him.
The kiss leads to sex in Nate’s2 room, but Nate2 makes the encounter rough and deliberately tells Xavi1 he means nothing to him. He orders him out afterward. Xavi1 leaves physically marked and emotionally exposed, replaying the night while Nate2 returns to silence. Their attraction is no longer deniable, but Nate2 has made intimacy another way to hurt him.
Nate’s response to sobriety reveals that he fears more than Xavi’s past behavior. If Xavi can change, Nate must confront the possibility that his own fixed story about blame is protecting him from grief rather than serving justice. Their first sexual encounter does not dissolve that story. Nate uses sex to reclaim control, while Xavi accepts pain because it seems more deserved than comfort. The scene’s emotional force lies in the mismatch between physical intimacy and emotional recognition.
The Cemetery’s Second Confession
Nate2 keeps watching Xavi,1 stealing into his room and becoming jealous when Easton6 feeds him or draws him close. At a game, Nate2 loses focus, fights his rival Jackson Banks,12 and is suspended after his team loses. Xavi1 finds him later at Katy’s3 grave. Their silence recalls a night two years earlier, on Katy’s3 birthday, when Nate2 found Xavi1 passed out beside her headstone, bruised and dangerously intoxicated.
Nate2 had beaten him in anger, then discovered he was still alive, wrapped him in his coat, and carried him to the hospital. In the present, Nate2 does not attack Xavi.1 He lets him stay beside the grave, where Xavi1 admits he tells Katy3 everything, including what has happened between them.
The cemetery memory complicates the clean division between victim and villain. Nate once met Xavi’s self-destruction with violence, but he also protected him when the immediate danger became undeniable. Neither gesture cancels the other. In the present, the grave becomes a place where Xavi can speak to Katy without competing with Nate, while Nate’s presence suggests he is beginning to tolerate a grief they share. The missed game and suspension show that mourning has entered Nate’s public life, where anger can no longer be contained as private discipline.
Birthday at the Pier
On Katy’s3 birthday, Nate2 finds Xavi1 trying to drink alone and takes him to the pier where he once brought Katy3 as a child. He tells Xavi1 how she escaped a family party to swim, giving him a memory of her that belongs to the siblings as well as to their friendship. They enter the cold water together, then share cupcakes at midnight for Katy3 and Xavi’s1 birthday.
Xavi’s1 wallet spills open, exposing Katy’s list. When Nate2 asks why Xavi1 was not with her on the night she died, Xavi1 admits he was with his dealer,7 having sex, while Katy’s3 call went unanswered. Nate2 feels the confession as a fresh betrayal and throws Xavi1 out of his room.
The pier briefly lets Nate and Xavi inhabit a memory without competing over its ownership. Their shared swim and birthday ritual create the tenderness that makes the confession devastating. Xavi’s guilt is not abstract: he remembers a call he chose not to answer, and Nate turns that absence into proof of moral failure. The scene shows how grief can make factual responsibility feel total. Nate’s anger is understandable, but his demand for an answer becomes another instance of using rejection to avoid the vulnerability the day had opened.
Blindfold Under Club Lights
After Nate2 doubts he can stay sober at a gay club, Xavi1 goes anyway to prove he can face temptation. He dances blindfolded on the bar to complete another item from Katy’s list, while Nate2 watches possessively and keeps him away from other men. The night ends with Xavi1 receiving a photograph of himself with Nate2 and a box of drugs left on his motorcycle.
The sender is Devin,7 Xavi’s former dealer,7 who warns that he wants Xavi1 back. Carter4 takes the drugs and goes to confront him. Nate2 does not yet know the full threat, but the message has reopened the dangerous history Xavi1 has been trying to keep outside the house.
The blindfold changes meaning across the book. For the club challenge, it is a chosen way to honor Katy and trust Nate; in the prologue, the same object belongs to Xavi’s suicidal isolation. Devin’s message punctures the safety of the night by turning intimate images into leverage. Nate’s possessiveness may look like protection, but it does not yet amount to knowledge or trust. Xavi remains caught between accepting care and concealing the history that could alter how Nate sees him.
Photographs Become Evidence
Nate2 tells Frankie5 about Katy3 and, later, brings Xavi1 through the list’s remaining experiences, including riding a motorcycle. He gives Xavi1 the box of Polaroids he had kept, returning a piece of Katy’s3 life that Xavi1 feared was lost. Together they watch videos of her singing and laughing. One recording catches Katy3 teasing Xavi1 about his crush on Nate2 and predicting that Nate’s2 feelings will change.
Nate2 hears the confession but cannot answer it honestly. He retreats into cruelty, telling Xavi1 that their relationship is only a game. Xavi1 takes Katy’s list and leaves the house, carrying the photographs with him. The same archive that brought them close now leaves him certain that Nate2 will never choose him.
The photographs function as more than memorial objects: they preserve the emotional truth that the living characters have distorted. Katy recognized Xavi’s longing and Nate’s jealousy before either man could admit what those feelings meant. Returning the images is a meaningful act of trust, but Nate cannot sustain the intimacy they create. His rejection repeats his oldest defense, turning fear into contempt. Xavi’s departure is not simply heartbreak. It is a refusal to keep making himself available for a relationship in which tenderness can be withdrawn without warning.
Devin’s House of Debt
After leaving, Xavi1 goes to Devin’s7 house, where he nearly takes a pill to escape his grief. Nate2 and Carter4 arrive before he does. Nate2 punches Devin,7 while Xavi1 explains that Devin7 once used private photographs of Katy3 to extort money and sex from him; Xavi1 was with Devin7 when Katy3 called on the night she died.
Devin7 falsely claims he assaulted Katy,3 trying to provoke Nate2 and deepen Xavi’s1 guilt. Carter4 confirms he helped Xavi1 confront Devin7 after Katy’s3 death, delete the photographs, and survive a later threat against Nate.2
That threat had driven Xavi1 to the cliff in the prologue, where Carter4 stopped his planned suicide and helped get him into rehab. Nate2 finally understands that Xavi’s1 silence came from coercion and shame, not indifference to Katy.3
The revelation reorganizes blame without erasing consequence. Xavi did miss Katy’s call, but Devin’s blackmail and exploitation shaped the circumstances he had hidden from Nate. Carter’s silence was meant to protect both men, yet it also left their most consequential wounds untreated. Devin’s lie about Katy shows how an abuser can weaponize uncertainty after the fact. Nate must now distinguish the painful truth of Xavi’s choices from the totalizing story he built around them.
Love in the Open
Nate2 takes Xavi1 home, apologizes, and admits that he loves him, then places his number 13 ring on Xavi’s1 finger. Xavi1 remains wary, but asks Nate2 to say the words plainly before he trusts the promise. Nate2 does. At the next game, he plays well and helps Hawthorne win.
He acknowledges their relationship in public, then faces both sets of parents when they object to his being with a man and warn that it could damage his basketball future. Nate2 refuses to hide Xavi,1 kisses him before the cameras, and chooses their relationship over his parents’10 approval. Their reconciliation becomes more than private desire: Nate2 accepts the public cost of standing beside Xavi.1
The ring completes a long exchange of meanings. Nate once took it from Katy’s body and wore it as a reminder of blame; now he gives it to Xavi as a chosen bond rather than a weapon. His public declaration matters because secrecy and family reputation have shaped his life as much as grief has. The novel does not make love a cure for addiction or loss. Instead, Nate’s decision makes commitment observable, while Xavi’s caution recognizes that a declaration must be followed by dependable behavior.
Epilogue
Six weeks later, Nate2 and Xavi1 visit a tattoo artist13 in Los Angeles after attending a Lakers game. Xavi1 is nervous that making a permanent mark might somehow mean leaving Katy3 behind, but Nate2 reassures him that the list and their shared memories are evidence of how much they loved her.
They each get a small matching heart tattoo on the inside of a wrist. Xavi1 crosses out the list’s final note, which names him and Nate2 together, and keeps the memories without treating them as a debt he must keep paying.
The matching tattoos do not replace Katy’s place in their lives; they give their grief a form that can be carried without being reenacted as punishment. The list began as a way for Xavi to keep promises to a dead friend, but its last line also names a future she imagined for him. Crossing it out marks completion rather than forgetting. The ending’s permanence is deliberately modest: a small heart, an ordinary mark on the wrist, and two men choosing to remember Katy without making suffering the only proof of love.
Analysis
The novel builds its romance around a difficult distinction between explanation and excuse. Nate’s2 grief makes his hostility legible, but it does not make his violence harmless; Xavi’s1 guilt has a factual basis in the unanswered call, but it does not make him responsible for every choice other people made. Their attraction repeatedly becomes a contest over who gets to define the past. Nate2 treats punishment as a way to keep Xavi1 close without admitting dependence, while Xavi1 accepts humiliation because he has confused suffering with accountability. The relationship becomes more viable only when secrecy begins to give way to specific truths, especially the history of Devin’s7 coercion and Carter’s4 attempts to contain its fallout. The book’s dark erotic dynamic depends on power, but its emotional resolution requires something different from domination: explicit honesty, chosen commitment, and the ability to refuse a harmful pattern. Katy’s list provides the narrative’s counterweight to stagnation. Each task asks Xavi1 to participate in life rather than merely remember it, yet the challenges are not automatically healing. The blindfolded swim and bar dance become meaningful because Xavi1 chooses them and accepts support, while the cliff makes clear how quickly solitude can turn a symbol into danger. Memory itself is similarly double-edged. Photographs and videos preserve Katy’s3 voice, but Nate’s ring and Xavi’s list can also become instruments of guilt. The story’s strongest insight is that love cannot repair grief by replacing the dead or declaring pain over. It can, however, change what the living do with that pain. Nate’s2 public choice of Xavi1 makes care answerable to the world, and the matching tattoos give remembrance a form that can be carried without requiring either man to keep punishing himself.
Review Summary
Like You Hate Me is a polarizing MM romance that many readers found addictive and emotionally intense. The enemies-to-lovers story follows Nate and Xavi, whose complicated past involves the death of Nate's sister. Readers praised the angst, steamy scenes, and character development, though some found Nate's treatment of Xavi too cruel. The book features themes of grief, addiction, and toxic relationships. While some loved the passionate dynamic, others felt the plot was repetitive or lacked depth. Overall, it's a divisive read that elicited strong reactions from its audience.
People Also Read
Characters
Xavi Hart
Grieving rule-breakerXavi is a sharp-tongued, impulsive young man whose bravado conceals a deep fear of being abandoned. His closeness to Katy3 gives him a sense of belonging he struggles to find elsewhere, while his history with drugs makes ordinary pain feel difficult to endure. He carries a list of experiences tied to Katy and tries to complete them as both an act of loyalty and a reason to keep moving. With Nate2, Xavi is drawn to the very person whose anger makes him feel most exposed. His tendency to accept punishment rather than ask for care reveals how thoroughly guilt has shaped his idea of what he deserves.
Nate Grayson
Wounded basketball captainNate is a gifted college basketball player, a protective older brother, and a young man trained to measure himself through discipline and achievement. He manages vulnerability poorly, converting fear and grief into control, anger, and physical confrontation. His loyalty to Carter4 and his care for Frankie5 show that tenderness is not absent from him, but he offers it unevenly and often disguises it as authority. Xavi1 unsettles the explanations Nate depends on, especially the belief that blame can make loss manageable. His conflict between family expectations10, public identity, and desire gives his harshness a context without excusing the harm it causes.
Katy Grayson
Blindhearted singerKaty is Nate’s younger sister2 and Xavi’s closest friend1. Blind since birth, she values being treated as capable and resists a family that can mistake protection for control. Music is central to her sense of possibility, and her powerful singing gives her a way to claim attention on her own terms. She is funny, stubborn, and unusually perceptive about the people around her. Katy brings Nate2 and Xavi1 into one another’s orbit, but she is not merely a bridge between them: her ambitions, dares, and friendships give the story its own emotional center.
Carter Westwood
Provocative loyal friendCarter is Nate’s lifelong best friend2 and one of the few people who can challenge him without disappearing from his life. He delights in schemes and provocation, often treating other people’s emotional crises as material for mischief. Beneath that recklessness, he is deeply loyal and more observant than he lets on. His friendships with Nate2 and Xavi1 place him in the uncomfortable position of protecting both while keeping secrets between them. Carter’s humor gives him influence, but it can also obscure how serious his interventions become.
Frankie
Defiant housemateFrankie is a bold, sharp-witted young woman who parties hard and refuses to present herself as fragile. Nate2 gives her a place to stay, and she becomes part of his chosen household alongside Carter4 and Easton6. Her humor helps her deflect questions, but she is perceptive about the pain other people try to bury. She challenges Nate2 when his protectiveness becomes controlling and offers Xavi1 a guarded form of acceptance. Frankie’s loyalty is real, even when her teasing makes it difficult to tell when she is being serious.
Easton Miller
Gentle teammateEaston is Nate’s basketball teammate2 and an easygoing presence in the shared house. He welcomes Xavi1 with food, includes him at social events, and notices when he is overwhelmed without forcing him to explain himself. His casual warmth contrasts with Nate’s2 more possessive attention, which can make their friendship a source of tension. Easton is generous but not especially subtle, and his willingness to step in when someone is in trouble gives the household a practical, protective balance.
Devin
Exploitative dealerDevin is Xavi’s former drug dealer1, a dangerous figure whose access to drugs is entangled with manipulation and coercive bargains. He uses other people’s vulnerabilities to keep them close and treats private information as leverage. His charm and apparent familiarity make him harder to dismiss than a straightforward threat, especially to someone already struggling with addiction. Devin embodies the way dependency can blur the line between seeking relief and surrendering control.
Bradley Hart
Controlling fatherBradley is Xavi’s father1, a wealthy, demanding parent who values discipline and reputation. He helps pay for Xavi’s1 education but often approaches their relationship through correction rather than emotional understanding. His criticism reinforces Xavi’s1 sense that he is a disappointment, even when he is trying to rebuild his life.
Xavi’s mother
Absent-minded parentXavi’s mother is a retired model who has built a life largely separate from her children. She is less openly demanding than Bradley8, but her inattention leaves Xavi1 without the steady reassurance he needs. Their distance helps explain why he often turns to friends instead of family.
Nate’s parents
Image-conscious parentsNate’s parents are wealthy and invested in the family’s public standing. Their expectations around athletic success and conventional respectability shape the pressure he feels to keep parts of himself private. Their grief and care for their children are complicated by a habit of prioritizing appearances.
Bryson West
Host with a poolBryson is the college student whose family owns a house with a pool where Xavi1 carries out one of Katy’s dares. He is a brief but memorable connection between the list’s mischievous challenges and the risks Xavi1 takes while performing them.
Jackson Banks
On-court rivalJackson is a rival basketball player who knows how to provoke Nate2 during a game. His taunts expose how easily Nate’s2 grief can disrupt the composure on which his athletic identity depends.
Xander Reid
Skilled tattoo artistXander is the tattoo artist Xavi1 and Nate2 visit in Los Angeles. His calm professionalism helps make their matching tattoos feel like a deliberate act rather than an impulsive gesture.
Jordyn
Tattoo artist’s wifeJordyn is Xander’s wife13 and the mother of their young daughter. Her comfortable family life gives Xavi1 and Nate2 a brief glimpse of a future that can include commitment without hiding it.
Plot Devices
Katy’s list
Grief turned into actionKaty’s list gives Xavi1 a sequence of experiences to attempt after she is gone, from swimming blindfolded to dancing on a bar and riding a motorcycle. Each task turns memory into a physical choice, sometimes playful and sometimes dangerous. The list also brings Nate2 into Xavi’s1 grieving rituals, giving them a reason to travel, remember, and argue together. Its final note points toward a future Xavi1 has difficulty believing he deserves. As a device, it converts mourning from passive remembrance into repeated encounters with risk, pleasure, and the possibility of continuing to live.
The number 13 ring
A keepsake changed by griefThe black ring marked with Nate’s2 basketball number passes through the central relationships. Xavi1 lends it to Katy3, Nate2 takes it after her death, and he later wears it as a reminder of his anger and loss. Its physical presence makes the past impossible for either man to treat as abstract. When Nate2 returns it to Xavi1, the object’s meaning changes from accusation to chosen intimacy. The ring does not erase what happened; it shows how the same token can carry love, guilt, possession, and commitment depending on who holds it.
Katy’s photographs and videos
Memory with a living voiceXavi1 keeps a photo strip and a large archive of pictures and videos that preserve Katy’s3 humor, singing, and closeness with him. Nate’s2 theft of the photo strip exposes his jealousy, while his later return of the larger collection becomes an act of trust. The videos let Nate2 encounter Katy3 as more than the person he lost: she appears teasing, ambitious, and alert to the feelings between him and Xavi1. The archive therefore does not merely trigger nostalgia. It challenges the stories the living tell themselves about who loved whom and what their future might have been.
The blindfold
Chosen risk, hidden dangerXavi1 uses a blindfold to complete a challenge from Katy’s list, entering a stranger’s pool without sight and later dancing on a bar at the club. In those scenes, the blindfold lets him honor Katy’s3 courage and depend on another person’s guidance. The prologue gives the same object a darker use, as Xavi1 approaches a cliff while contemplating suicide. Its changing role binds the story’s acts of remembrance to its moments of danger. What matters is not the object alone, but whether Xavi1 uses it to share risk or isolate himself from the world.
Basketball and public image
Success under family pressureNate’s2 position as Hawthorne’s star basketball player gives him a public identity built on control, discipline, and winning. When grief disrupts his performance, the court makes private pain visible through missed shots, a fight, and suspension. His athletic future also becomes a source of pressure from his parents10, who want him to protect the family’s reputation. By the final game, playing well and acknowledging Xavi1 publicly become linked choices: Nate2 no longer treats success and love as mutually exclusive, even when he must risk approval to stand by Xavi1.
Hawthorne University Series
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.