Plot Summary
Shakespeare at Stumble Inn
Twenty-two-year-old Bliss Edwards has never had sex, and her blunt, adventurous friend Kelsey takes her to a bar to change that. Bliss scans the room for a suitably uncomplicated stranger, then finds Garrick Taylor reading Shakespeare in a quiet corner.
His British accent and easy flirtation unsettle her careful plans. When Garrick takes her home on his motorcycle, Bliss burns her leg on the exhaust and discovers he lives in the neighboring building.
He tends the burn in her apartment, and their kisses turn heated enough to carry them toward her bed. Just as sex seems imminent, fear stops her. Unable to admit she is a virgin, Bliss invents an emergency involving a nonexistent cat and flees, leaving Garrick alone and naked in her apartment.
Bliss approaches sex as a task she can complete through preparation, alcohol, and Kelsey's confidence. Her body responds to Garrick before her habits of control can make sense of that response, and the discrepancy frightens her more than inexperience itself. The invented cat is comic, but it also shows how quickly she turns embarrassment into elaborate avoidance rather than risking honest vulnerability. Garrick's care for her burn complicates the idea of a disposable hookup: before either can decide what they want, he has already treated her as a person in need, not a conquest.
The Professor Behind the Door
The morning after her escape, Bliss tells Kelsey that the encounter went well, hiding both the truth and her mortification. At her first theatre class, the department introduces its temporary instructor: Garrick, a recent graduate and former student at the university.
He recognizes Bliss, but both keep their private history concealed while he explains the realities of an acting career. Their attempt to avoid each other falters at a campus coffeehouse, where Bliss's friend Cade invites Garrick to share a table.
Later, Cade's car will not start, so Garrick offers Bliss a ride home on his motorcycle. She accepts while carefully holding only his jacket, not his waist. Their attraction now sits inside a classroom hierarchy that could cost Garrick his job and damage Bliss's standing as a student.
The reveal converts a private mistake into a continuing institutional problem. Bliss can no longer escape Garrick by leaving the bar or avoiding his apartment; the classroom gives their attraction a schedule, witnesses, and consequences. Her insistence on keeping the encounter secret is partly self-protection, but it also reflects how little practice she has asserting desire without turning it into a crisis. Garrick's new role makes restraint ethically necessary, even as their repeated proximity tempts them to treat attraction as an exception to professional rules.
A Kiss Off Script
In a cold-reading exercise from A Streetcar Named Desire, Bliss's partner, Dom, ignores the scene's boundaries and kisses her without permission. Garrick pulls Dom away and sends him out, then checks Bliss's bruised arm.
His concern breaks through the professional distance they had agreed to keep, and he kisses her in the rehearsal room. Bliss kisses him back, then reminds him that they had promised to forget their first night. Garrick apologizes and resumes a careful distance in class.
Meanwhile, Bliss prepares for a major department audition, drawing on the shame and desire she has been trying to suppress. Her performance as Phaedra, a woman consumed by forbidden longing, turns private turmoil into the most emotionally open acting she has done.
Dom's violation makes the scene's distinction between performance and consent painfully concrete. Garrick protects Bliss, but his subsequent kiss also crosses a boundary of his own, making his desire inseparable from the authority he holds over her. Bliss's response is not simple acceptance or rejection: she wants him and fears the consequences, so she tries to restore control through a rule they have already failed to keep. Her audition offers a safer container for those conflicting feelings. Onstage, she can risk emotional exposure while pretending it belongs entirely to Phaedra.
Cade's Maybe
After the audition, Bliss celebrates with her theatre friends at Stumble Inn. Brandon, the bartender who had flirted with her on her first visit, asks her out, but she cannot imagine kissing him without picturing Garrick.
Later, a drunken game of spin the bottle pairs Bliss with Cade, her closest male friend. Their kiss is unexpectedly tender and intense, and the next morning Cade admits he has loved her for some time. Bliss cares for him deeply but cannot promise she feels the same; she asks for time, leaving them both suspended in uncertainty.
Kelsey warns Bliss against mistaking the first person she nearly slept with for a destined partner. That same morning, Bliss approaches the callback list, still carrying the fragile new knowledge of Cade's feelings.
Cade's confession forces Bliss to confront a different kind of intimacy from the charged, unfamiliar pull she feels toward Garrick. Their kiss matters because it threatens an existing friendship, not because it promises uncomplicated romance. Bliss's maybe is an attempt to avoid hurting Cade while preserving a possibility she cannot honestly assess. The hesitation is understandable, but it leaves him bearing the cost of her indecision. Kelsey's warning cuts through Bliss's tendency to turn sexual inexperience into a deadline: attraction cannot be chosen simply to make a personal milestone disappear.
Phaedra's Only Callback
Bliss finds that she has been cast outright as Phaedra, without a callback, while Cade is among the actors being considered for Hippolytus. Garrick praises the emotional risk in her audition, and Eric, the department head, tells her he wants her to bring that openness into the production.
During later callbacks, Bliss performs opposite Cade and watches him struggle to play disgust at Phaedra's love for Hippolytus. Garrick grows jealous, then follows Bliss outside and admits that he likes her despite the danger of their roles.
He kisses her; Bliss pulls away, frightened but unable to deny what she wants. The play's forbidden romance has become an uncomfortable mirror. Bliss must choose whether her carefulness is protecting her or simply keeping her from living.
The casting gives Bliss a professional affirmation that arrives just as her private life becomes less manageable. Eric's praise identifies a change in her craft: she is no longer merely executing an interpretation but allowing conflicting feelings to animate it. Cade's callback exposes how personal attachments can distort performance, while Garrick's jealousy shows that he, too, is failing to keep feeling separate from work. Phaedra is not a simple instruction to pursue forbidden desire. The play makes Bliss see its cost, even as the role helps her recognize that avoidance has costs of its own.
Hamlet at the Shelter
The next day, Bliss goes with Cade to adopt a cat, partly because she has told Garrick a cat was the reason she fled their first night. Holding the wary gray animal she names Hamlet, Bliss realizes that she cannot keep Cade waiting while she tests whether her feelings for Garrick will fade.
She tells Cade there may be someone else and withdraws her maybe. Hurt, Cade leaves before she can repair the friendship. Bliss brings Hamlet home, then goes to Garrick's apartment in tears.
He comforts her, brings dinner, and listens as she explains what happened. Garrick admits he has been lonely since returning to Texas and that Bliss has changed that. They agree to proceed carefully, and Bliss lets herself settle against him instead of inventing another escape.
The cat turns Bliss's first lie into a real responsibility, but adopting Hamlet is more than a comic consequence. Faced with an animal that is frightened and difficult to approach, Bliss recognizes that uncertainty cannot be solved by choosing the safest-looking option. Her decision to tell Cade no is painful precisely because she loves him as a friend and understands what the answer costs him. Garrick's comfort offers a contrast to her usual self-management: she accepts care without first making herself funny, composed, or deserving of it.
A Courtship Behind Curtains
Bliss and Garrick begin a secret relationship, trading cautious evenings at their apartments while he continues teaching and directing her production. Their closeness grows through small gestures, but Garrick slows their kisses whenever he senses Bliss becoming anxious.
When Kelsey arrives unexpectedly during dinner, Bliss hides Garrick in the bathroom and goes out with her instead. At the club, Garrick appears in disguise, unable to tolerate the thought of Bliss dancing with another man.
He leads her to a secluded corner, where they dance pressed together, then rides her home. Their kisses become urgent, but Bliss gets her earring caught in the bedroom curtain and they tumble against the dresser. The mishap breaks the moment. Garrick leaves rather than pushing her past her uncertainty.
The secrecy gives their romance an atmosphere of stolen time, but it also keeps Bliss from knowing what their relationship can look like in ordinary life. Garrick's restraint is not a lack of desire; the club makes that plain. It is his attempt to distinguish wanting Bliss from taking what she is not ready to give. The curtain catches her physically at the instant their passion threatens to outrun her consent, turning a slapstick accident into a pause the couple needs. Their intimacy develops through repeated permission, not a single dramatic surrender.
Rehearsal Breaks the Spell
As Phaedra rehearsals begin, Cade's unspoken hurt makes the cast stiff and the scenes lifeless. Garrick, serving as assistant director, tells Cade to stop letting his feelings for Bliss damage the production.
Bliss hears the rebuke and accuses Garrick of interfering in her friendship, pointing out the hypocrisy of his own relationship with her. She demands that he stay out of her personal life. Garrick withdraws, and Cade realizes that he is the man she has been seeing. When Bliss collapses in tears, Cade comforts her, even after learning she and Garrick had been together.
Their friendship begins to mend, but Garrick and Bliss stop speaking. Bliss later overhears Garrick on the phone and mistakes his comments about being over a past relationship for proof that he has dismissed her, so she tells him she is over it too.
This rupture is driven by overlapping roles that neither lover has managed to separate: teacher, director, student, friend, and secret partner all collide in one rehearsal room. Garrick's criticism of Cade may be professionally justified, but his personal jealousy gives it a cruelty Bliss cannot ignore. Her demand that he stay out of her life is both a defense of Cade and an attempt to regain control after exposing the affair. The phone misunderstanding then shows how their secrecy has damaged communication. Bliss has learned to read silence as rejection because neither of them has made their fears explicit.
The Fever Brings Him Back
Bliss tries to bury the breakup in rehearsals, but a report that Rusty has mono makes her fear she may have caught it at the spin-the-bottle party. She delays warning Garrick, then becomes dangerously feverish and collapses outside her apartment.
Garrick finds her, carries her inside, and stays to nurse her; soon he catches the illness too. As they recover, each cares for the other, and the forced quiet gives them room to speak honestly. Garrick explains that the phone call concerned Jenna, a former friend whose failed romance had driven him from Philadelphia, not Bliss.
He admits he was afraid of repeating that mistake with Cade. Bliss finally tells him she is a virgin and had invented the cat to hide her panic. They confess their love and understand the fears that kept them apart.
Illness suspends the social performances that have governed Bliss and Garrick's relationship. Too weak to manage appearances, they depend on each other in practical ways: carrying, cooling, feeding, and waiting. The physical vulnerability does not magically resolve their conflict, but it makes concealment harder to sustain. Garrick's history with Jenna explains why he treated Bliss and Cade's friendship as a warning, while Bliss's confession reveals that her first retreat was not a judgment of him. Their reconciliation begins when each stops asking the other to infer what fear has kept unsaid.
Opening Night, Open Future
After the cast's bout of mono delays the production, Bliss gives a powerful opening-night performance as Phaedra. Backstage, Eric praises her work, and Garrick congratulates her in a brief embrace.
Cade has regained enough ease with Bliss to drive her to the cast celebration, where he reveals he has been accepted to Temple University in Philadelphia and asks whether his plans would interfere with her relationship. Bliss promises they can remain friends. At home, she tells Garrick she wants to pursue acting and has begun researching Philadelphia theatres and apartments.
She is ready to have sex with him, and he checks that the choice is hers before they make love. Afterward, Garrick offers her a home in Philadelphia while she finds her feet. Bliss accepts the possibility without the panic that once governed her.
Bliss's opening-night success completes a professional arc alongside her romantic one. She has moved from treating acting as one option among safer alternatives to recognizing it as work she wants to pursue. Her conversation with Cade matters because it replaces the ambiguity that hurt them with a direct promise of friendship, while his Philadelphia plans make the future feel communal rather than competitive. Her first sexual experience is not framed as a prize for overcoming virginity; it follows emotional trust and her own clear decision. Choosing Philadelphia extends that agency beyond the bedroom.
Epilogue
Six months later, Bliss and Garrick are working together in Philadelphia on a production of Pride and Prejudice. After the show, Garrick watches Bliss slip into the dressing room and prepares to give her a ring he has hidden in the bedroom. He tries to guide her toward its hiding place by sending her to look for Hamlet's missing toy.
Bliss opens the drawer, finds the ring, and stands still for a moment. Then she begins to dance, just as she did when she won Phaedra and after opening night. Garrick understands that he may not need to wait months to ask her. The story closes with his proposal still ahead, but Bliss's delighted response already visible.
The epilogue revisits Bliss's dances as a bodily language for joy. Earlier, she tries to control her life by turning experience into plans; now the same spontaneous movement marks a future she can welcome rather than flee. Garrick's elaborate attempt to manage the ring's discovery mirrors Bliss's old habit of engineering a safe path through uncertainty. Her response gives him evidence without requiring her to speak first: she is not frightened away by the possibility of commitment. The ending preserves the proposal as an approaching choice rather than a completed transaction, keeping the couple's future open and mutual.
Analysis
Losing It treats inexperience less as a defect than as a conflict between social expectation and private readiness. Bliss wants to stop being defined by virginity, but she initially accepts Kelsey's timetable as though sex were a credential she has failed to acquire. Her body contradicts that plan: she is intensely attracted to Garrick, yet attraction cannot make her feel safe enough to proceed. The novel's comedy emerges from the gap between what Bliss feels and what she can say, especially in the invented-cat excuse. The joke does not erase the anxiety beneath it. It shows how a person can use cleverness to evade the vulnerability of a direct refusal or confession.
The theatre plot gives this conflict a second form. Bliss's early dependence on control makes her competent backstage but restrained as an actor. Eric's praise follows her willingness to bring desire, shame, and fear into Phaedra, suggesting that artistic risk and personal risk share a capacity for exposure, though they are not interchangeable. The distinction matters: performance provides a protected frame, while her relationship with Garrick carries real professional consequences. The story acknowledges the teacher-student imbalance rather than pretending that attraction alone makes it harmless. Their secrecy heightens the romance, but it also delays the honest conversations that might have prevented hurt.
Cade's subplot complicates the usual romantic choice between a safe friend and a thrilling stranger. Cade is not a consolation prize, and Bliss's refusal is not proof that dependable love lacks value. She recognizes that accepting him while longing for Garrick would make his hope serve her fear. Her decision costs them their easy friendship, and repair requires time rather than a single declaration. Garrick likewise brings old damage into the present, interpreting Bliss's bond with Cade through his own failed relationship with Jenna. Their reconciliation becomes possible when both replace inference with disclosure.
By the end, Bliss's change is measured in choices rather than a sudden cure for anxiety. She performs Phaedra, tells the truth about her virginity, chooses sex when she wants it, and considers a career and home beyond graduation. The novel's emotional claim is not that spontaneity is always wiser than caution, but that control cannot substitute for consent, honesty, or self-knowledge.
Review Summary
Losing It by Cora Carmack receives mixed reviews averaging 3.71 stars. Many readers praise the humorous, lighthearted romance between virgin college student Bliss and her British professor Garrick, enjoying the steamy scenes and witty banter. The awkward comedy and sexual tension are frequently highlighted as strengths. However, critics find the plot predictable, the heroine frustrating, and the British character stereotypical. Some reviewers dismiss it as fluffy and clichéd, while others consider it an entertaining, fun read perfect for the New Adult genre, particularly praising the authentic portrayal of first-time intimacy.
People Also Read
Characters
Bliss Edwards
The controlled heroineBliss is a twenty-two-year-old theatre student whose intelligence and organizational talent make her an excellent stage manager, but whose need to anticipate every outcome often interferes with acting and intimacy. She is funny under pressure, prone to elaborate explanations when a plain truth feels too exposing, and more observant than she initially believes. Her friendships with Kelsey and Cade give her different forms of support: one pushes her toward risk, the other offers steadiness. Bliss wants to feel adult and capable, yet resists the vulnerability that desire requires. Her attraction to Garrick confronts her with a choice between treating life as a list of problems to solve and trusting herself to act before certainty arrives.
Garrick Taylor
The careful teacherGarrick is a British-born actor and recent graduate who returns to Texas to teach a temporary theatre course. He is confident in flirtation and performance, but less practiced at navigating the consequences of attachment. His literary interests and theatrical training make him attentive to subtext, sometimes so attentive that he assumes he knows what Bliss or Cade feels without asking. Garrick is warm, physically expressive, and capable of genuine restraint, especially when he senses Bliss is unsure. His position as Bliss's instructor forces him to confront the difference between wanting someone and acting as though desire cancels professional responsibility. Beneath his charm is a man trying to rebuild a life and a creative career after a painful rupture in Philadelphia.
Cade Winston
The loyal best friendCade is Bliss's close friend and fellow theatre student, known for his warmth, steady presence, and instinct for caring for people without demanding attention in return. He has feelings for Bliss that complicate their easy friendship, but he is not simply a rival for her affection. His restraint comes from fear of losing the relationship they already have, and his hurt becomes difficult to hide once Bliss asks him to wait. Cade's voice and emotional openness suit the stage, even when private disappointment interferes with his work. He provides a counterpoint to Garrick: familiar, dependable, and deeply loved, though not necessarily the person Bliss wants romantically.
Kelsey Summers
The fearless instigatorKelsey is Bliss's outgoing, wealthy, sexually confident friend, quick to turn embarrassment into an adventure. She pushes Bliss toward bars, new clothes, dancing, and experiences Bliss would rarely choose alone. Her enthusiasm can become pressure when she assumes that what frees her will free Bliss too, but she is also loyal and perceptive enough to support her friend when the situation becomes serious. Kelsey values pleasure and self-discovery, and her boldness exposes the limits of Bliss's caution. Their friendship works best when Kelsey learns to offer a nudge without deciding what Bliss must want.
Eric Barnes
The demanding mentorEric heads the university theatre department and directs the student production of Phaedra. He expects discipline, preparation, and emotional commitment, while remaining capable of recognizing growth in a student he once considered too controlled. His praise helps Bliss understand that her strongest acting comes when she makes bold choices instead of hiding behind technical competence. Eric's authority also shapes the professional environment in which Garrick teaches and Bliss performs.
Rusty
The comic classmateRusty is a theatre student whose eccentric humor and accordion-playing make him a source of levity within the department's close-knit social circle. He joins the party where the students play spin the bottle, and his later illness carries consequences for the group. Beneath the jokes, he is an accepted part of the ensemble, comfortable enough with his friends to tease and be teased.
Hamlet
The wary gray catHamlet is the gray shelter cat Bliss adopts after using a nonexistent cat as an excuse to escape Garrick. Suspicious and difficult to handle, she does not provide instant comfort or easy affection. Her wary nature makes her an unlikely mirror for Bliss, who also wants closeness but often retreats when it becomes real. Hamlet's presence brings humor into Bliss's chaotic apartment life and gives her a small, concrete responsibility beyond her romantic anxieties.
Dom
The careless scene partnerDom is a fellow acting student whose confidence sometimes outruns his judgment. During a class exercise, he mistakes improvisation for permission and crosses a physical boundary with Bliss. His action forces Garrick to intervene and makes the class's discussion of performance and consent immediate.
Lindsay
The outspoken musicianLindsay is a theatre student and musician whose acoustic performances draw friends together at a campus coffeehouse. Her song about resisting desire lands with particular force for Bliss, even though Lindsay does not know the private situation it echoes. She is direct, politically minded, and part of the social world Bliss shares with Kelsey and Cade.
Jeremy
The hopeful young actorJeremy is a younger theatre student who is earnest, talented, and sometimes uncertain beside the older students. He develops a crush on Kelsey and competes for the role of Hippolytus. His warmth and inexperience make him an endearing presence in the production's shifting cast.
Brandon
The interested bartenderBrandon is the bartender at Stumble Inn who remembers Bliss from her first visit and offers her a drink and a date. He is friendly and direct, giving Bliss a straightforward romantic possibility outside the complications surrounding Garrick. Her inability to picture herself with him clarifies the depth of her attraction elsewhere.
Jenna
Garrick's former friendJenna is Garrick's friend from his graduate-school years in Philadelphia. Their attempt to become a couple damaged their friendship and disrupted their shared theatre work. Though she does not appear directly, her history helps explain why Garrick fears that romantic uncertainty can destroy a valuable friendship.
Plot Devices
The teacher-student boundary
Desire under rulesGarrick's temporary teaching job makes his attraction to Bliss more than a private complication. Their relationship unfolds in classes, auditions, and rehearsals where he has authority and she depends on fair evaluation. That imbalance creates practical risks, including exposure, professional consequences, and the need to behave differently in public than in private. The boundary also tests whether Garrick can distinguish his role as teacher from his desire as a partner, and whether Bliss can choose intimacy without confusing secrecy with safety.
The imaginary cat
A lie made realBliss invents a cat as an excuse to stop sex with Garrick, revealing that she is frightened to admit her inexperience. Because she later adopts a real gray cat named Hamlet, the excuse becomes an ongoing comic complication and a reminder of the truth she has not yet told him. Hamlet's presence turns a moment of panic into a continuing responsibility, while Bliss's eventual confession allows the original lie to be understood as fear rather than rejection.
Theatre as mirror
Private feeling onstageThe students' acting exercises and Phaedra production give Bliss a language for emotions she struggles to express directly. The forbidden desire in Phaedra echoes the pressure between Bliss and Garrick, while the scene from A Streetcar Named Desire brings consent and power into the classroom. Performing lets Bliss take emotional risks, and Garrick's direction connects her emerging confidence as an actor to the choices she is learning to make in her own life.
Spin the bottle
Friendship turns uncertainAt a drunken gathering, a party game pairs Bliss and Cade in a kiss that reveals a depth of feeling neither has discussed. The kiss leads Cade to confess his long-standing affection and forces Bliss to decide whether she can return it. The game also spreads risk through the group when Rusty's later mono diagnosis suggests the party may have exposed several friends. It therefore serves both the romantic subplot and the illness that later brings Garrick and Bliss back into close contact.
Mono and shared care
Illness suspends avoidanceRusty's diagnosis alerts the theatre group to possible exposure at their party. When Bliss becomes sick, Garrick carries her inside and cares for her; he then catches the illness himself. Their dependence on practical acts of care strips away the secrecy and careful distance that had kept them from speaking honestly. Their recovery gives them time to explain the misunderstandings involving Cade and Jenna, and to admit what each had concealed about desire, fear, and commitment.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.