Plot Summary
Prologue
Two years after his wife dies, retired repairman Remy Wilsson is still working late in the basement of his Brooklyn home when scratching sounds come from a small door beneath the stairs.
He opens it to find a battered teenage boy who has crawled to the entrance, leaving bloody handprints on the concrete. Remy recognizes that the boy needs help, pushes aside his own fear, and saves him. The boy is Sutton, though the reason for his injuries remains hidden for now.
Remy’s instinct to repair what others might discard gives the opening its moral shape. He approaches a frightened, injured boy not as a mystery to solve but as a life that can still be protected. The scene also plants the novel’s central contrast between damage and disposability: Sutton arrives physically wounded, while the history that brought him there is withheld. Remy’s quiet intervention links the book’s two families before Wren knows the connection, making care itself the first act of the romance’s eventual story.
A Ball in the Pool
Wren keeps his life narrow: engineering classes by day, cleaning a Brooklyn swim school at night, and home with Remy, Jordan, and Jordan’s son, Theo. After a food truck hits his bicycle, he tapes his swollen finger and works through the injury. In the empty pool room, he finds a stranger swimming and hurls a weighted ball at his forehead.
The man, Sutton Holland, surfaces grinning instead of angry, then openly flirts while admitting he entered without permission. Wren threatens to call police, but Sutton phones the pool’s owner, Quinn, himself. Quinn confirms Sutton is his friend and tells Wren to send him home. Sutton leaves, promising nothing and somehow making Wren expect to see him again.
The encounter begins with Wren’s practiced invisibility colliding with Sutton’s conspicuous ease. Wren chooses action over retreat, first by confronting a trespasser and then by refusing to be charmed out of his own judgment. Sutton’s shamelessness is funny, but it also works as camouflage: he controls how others read him by declaring himself shallow before they can ask for anything deeper. The pool establishes the novel’s recurring threshold, a workplace Wren uses to stay unseen that becomes the place Sutton repeatedly enters. Their first connection is not trust but a contest over who gets to set the terms.
The Unexpected Assistant
The next night, Sutton returns to the swim school as an assistant, supposedly working off his trespass at Quinn’s insistence. Wren expects a rich man to be useless, but Sutton scrubs showers and pressure-washes the pool with surprising skill. Between shifts, Wren runs into Ethan, the kind ex-boyfriend he left two years earlier after fear about his scars made intimacy impossible.
Seeing Ethan with another student brings back Jordan’s advice that life is too short to hide. Wren recognizes how thoroughly he has concealed himself, though he is not yet ready to explain why. Sutton keeps appearing, brings food, and asks questions that make their work feel less like punishment and more like the beginning of a habit.
Wren’s response to Ethan marks the first shift in his self-understanding: he can identify hiding as a choice with costs, even before he can change it. Sutton’s behavior complicates the easy category Wren assigned him. He boasts of avoiding work, yet he works competently; he claims not to care about Wren’s life, yet keeps asking about it. The story makes contradiction more revealing than confession. Wren’s home life with Remy, Jordan, and Theo offers dependable care, but the routine also lets him stay protected from the risk of being desired. Sutton unsettles that protection by making attention feel playful rather than pitying.
Birds and Liquid Courage
At a neighborhood bar, Wren and Sutton trade secrets. Sutton recounts a ridiculous arrest for swimming; Wren admits he sketches birds, a quiet practice that began during a long hospital stay when he was fifteen. Wren drinks too much, cannot direct the cab to his own home, and ends up at Sutton’s apartment.
Though he tries to initiate sex, Sutton stops him because he is drunk and puts him to bed, staying on the couch until Wren asks him to share the room. The next morning, Wren soberly explains that burn scars and earlier rejections have made sex frightening, and that he wants to know if someone can desire him without being repelled. Sutton agrees to try, leaving Wren exposed but no longer alone with the question.
The bird sketches give Wren a self he can offer without first explaining his scars. Sutton receives that interest with curiosity, allowing Wren to experience disclosure as something other than a prelude to judgment. The drunken advance tests Sutton’s character in a different way: he refuses an opportunity he had eagerly pursued because Wren cannot consent clearly. When Wren later names his fear and asks for a test, his request is not simply for sex but for evidence that his body can be met without recoil. Sutton’s agreement matters because it respects Wren’s agency without pretending the vulnerability is trivial.
Seen in the Darkroom
At Sutton’s apartment, Wren’s nervous attempt to begin sex leads them into Sutton’s darkroom and a box of photographs. The pictures show Quinn, Steph, and their friends in unguarded moments, revealing a patient, affectionate eye beneath Sutton’s polished persona. After they eat and trade childhood stories, Sutton kisses Wren gently.
When Wren freezes at the thought of removing his shirt, Sutton takes his own off first and waits. Wren exposes the burn scars covering much of his body, then undresses when Sutton remains visibly aroused. They agree on boundaries, and Sutton keeps checking Wren’s reactions as they touch. Wren’s anxiety returns, so Sutton has him pleasure Sutton first, easing the pressure until Wren also reaches orgasm.
The photographs make Sutton’s hidden depth visible before he explains it. His camera records people not as objects to impress but as lives worth attending to, a sensibility that mirrors the care he brings to Wren’s body. The scene’s emotional turning point is not exposure alone; it is Wren discovering that exposure does not automatically produce rejection. Sutton’s patience gives Wren room to set limits and change pace, while Wren’s pleasure becomes possible when he stops treating his body as an examination he must pass. Their intimacy begins with consent, but its deeper work is restoring Wren’s ability to inhabit sensation rather than monitor himself.
A Home Opened
Their arrangement quickly becomes a friendship threaded with sex, teasing, and long conversations. They sneak into the pool after hours, race through the water, and return to Sutton’s apartment for more intimacy.
While Sutton is away, he calls Wren and asks about his ordinary days; he returns early and finds him drawing birds in Central Park. Wren invites him to dinner with Remy, Jordan, and Theo. Sutton is guarded under Jordan’s questions, but later, alone in Wren’s room, he relaxes as Wren explains how the household became his family after the fire.
They kiss and fall asleep together. Awake beside Sutton, Wren realizes he wants more than their casual arrangement, but decides not to tell him because he fears losing what they already have.
The relationship crosses a boundary not through a grand declaration but through repeated domestic access: calls about lunch, a shared dinner, and sleep in Wren’s own room. These ordinary acts matter because Wren’s life has long been organized around keeping people at a safe distance. Sutton’s unease during Jordan’s questions hints that his self-description conceals unresolved history, while his ease with Wren’s household suggests he recognizes the security it offers. Wren’s decision to hide his love is both protective and costly. He wants to preserve closeness, but by withholding the truth he accepts an arrangement whose rules are designed to deny the future he desires.
The Gala’s Hidden Ledger
Sutton brings Wren to a black-tie fundraiser, stays beside him through a crowd of wealthy guests, and includes him in conversations instead of treating him as decoration. Outside on the balcony, Quinn tells Wren that Sutton did not really have to work off the pool trespass: he had helped fund the swim school, covered shifts, and raised money for its free lessons.
Quinn also reveals that Sutton runs the Holland Foundation and has made a major donation to a burn center. Wren realizes Sutton’s claim that he does nothing for a living is another lie, this time one that hides meaningful work. Quinn warns that Sutton is hard on himself and afraid, but leaves Wren to ask Sutton what lies beneath that fear.
The gala exposes the distance between Sutton’s performance of indifference and his actual investments in other people. His wealth gives him unusual freedom, but he uses that freedom to sustain a community pool and fund care rather than merely to escape obligation. Quinn’s disclosures do not erase Sutton’s evasiveness; they make it more legible as a defense. Wren has been learning to accept visible attention, while Sutton has learned to make generosity invisible so it cannot be mistaken for vulnerability. The contrast raises the romance’s central question: whether being known requires more than being helped, and whether Sutton can allow someone to see the motives he keeps disguising.
Love Breaks the Rule
Sutton photographs Wren on his bed, and when he later gives him the prints, Wren sees himself rendered as beautiful rather than damaged. The photographs break through his remaining defenses, and he tells Sutton he loves him. Sutton reacts with panic, insists Wren must take the words back, and ends their arrangement rather than risk a future he believes he cannot safely offer.
Wren argues that loving him is not wrongdoing and asks Sutton to admit whether he feels the same, but Sutton refuses to answer directly. He says he could hurt Wren and will not take that chance. Wren leaves, carrying the knowledge that their closeness was real but that Sutton has chosen fear over the possibility of building a life together.
The photographs turn the camera into an instrument of recognition: Wren can see what Sutton sees, and that new image makes silence impossible. Sutton’s response reveals that the rule against love was never an emotionally neutral preference. It is a barricade built from fear of becoming like his father, though Wren does not yet know the history behind it. Wren’s confession is an act of agency, not an attempt to compel reciprocation; he claims the right to name his own feeling. Sutton’s rejection therefore wounds precisely because he treats love as a danger to manage rather than a relationship they might negotiate together.
The Story Behind Sutton
After Remy tells Wren that he once rescued Sutton as a bleeding teenager, he gives Wren the address of Sutton’s mother, Amy. Amy explains that Sutton’s father, Everett, abused her for years, and that Sutton repeatedly tried to protect her. At fifteen, Sutton intervened when Everett was choking Amy, beat his father, and stumbled to Remy’s door.
Amy also explains Sutton’s foundation: it supports children affected by violence through therapy, helplines, grants, and outreach. Wren understands why Sutton fears repeating his father’s behavior, but also sees that Sutton has spent his life trying to prevent the same harm. Amy’s account does not excuse Sutton’s choices; it gives Wren the history he needs to understand their roots.
Amy’s account reframes Sutton’s apparent recklessness as a life shaped by the burden of being a child protector. His fear is not abstract: he witnessed violence, intervened physically, and came to associate his own capacity for force with the person who harmed his family. The foundation becomes an attempt to convert private history into practical protection for other children. Yet Wren’s understanding is not a cure or permission to overlook harm. The distinction matters: trauma explains the logic of Sutton’s terror without making that terror a reliable guide to what he will become. Amy’s disclosure gives Wren knowledge, but Sutton must still choose whether to live by it.
The Accident at Work
Wren begins an engineering internship and, while heartbroken, reconnects with Ethan over dinner. When Ethan kisses him outside the pool, Wren tells him to stop. Sutton arrives, pulls Ethan away, and accidentally strikes Wren’s nose when Ethan charges back.
Seeing blood, Sutton panics and treats the accident as proof that he will become violent like Everett. Wren insists that Ethan caused the collision, but Sutton describes how abuse can begin with small excuses and grow into control. He leaves rather than risk Wren.
Wren later visits Sutton’s office, where Remy challenges the idea that a violent parent determines a child’s future. Meanwhile, Jordan helps Wren understand that Sutton is panicking, not indifferent, and Wren decides he must speak plainly about the life he wants.
The physical accident makes Sutton’s fear immediate, but the deeper conflict lies in his interpretation of it. He sees a single unintended blow as the first step in a predetermined pattern, confusing vigilance with moral certainty. Wren refuses to accept that his own judgment should be replaced by Sutton’s fear, while Remy challenges the inherited-violence argument through Sutton’s work with children facing similar histories. Jordan’s account of his own panic about losing Theo offers a less absolute model: fear can distort action without defining character. Together, the older men help Wren understand Sutton’s reaction, but they do not ask Wren to abandon his need for an honest, mutual future.
The Last Step Home
Wren meets Sutton on the steps outside the pool and describes the life he wants: shared meals, errands, holidays, and an ordinary home. He makes clear that he is not demanding a promise, only telling the truth. Sutton says he never wanted to hurt him and remains silent, so Wren leaves, believing the relationship is over.
Sutton then runs after him and asks Wren not to let him walk away. They return to the apartment together. The next morning, Sutton stress-cooks an extravagant breakfast because he does not know what Wren will want; the absurd spread gives them a way to meet again without pretending the fear has vanished. They begin cautiously, restoring their closeness one choice at a time.
Wren’s list of domestic hopes makes love concrete rather than idealized. He does not ask Sutton to become fearless; he asks for the possibility of choosing each other in ordinary time. When Sutton lets him go, Wren refuses to chase him into silence, preserving the boundary that makes his eventual return meaningful. Sutton’s decision to run after him is not a cure for trauma, but it is a first action against its isolating logic. The overdone breakfast then functions as an awkward, human bridge: care can resume before either man has solved everything. Their reconciliation begins with mutual presence, not a sudden guarantee.
Birds on the Wall
Wren and Sutton rebuild their relationship without forcing labels, and Wren paints birds across a wall in Sutton’s apartment as a mark of belonging. Sutton accepts the mural as part of their shared home. Later, after unexpectedly seeing Everett, Sutton hides in an empty bathtub, afraid he may run. Wren climbs in behind him and holds his hands against his chest while Sutton explains the encounter and the temptation to flee.
This time Sutton stays. He tells Wren he loves him, and Wren answers without hesitation. The declaration differs from Wren’s earlier confession because Sutton offers it freely, after facing the history that made love feel dangerous. Their life together becomes a choice repeatedly renewed, not a fear-free state.
The painted birds transform Wren’s private practice into a shared mark on the space they inhabit. What began as a way to pass time alone becomes evidence that he can leave something visible and trust it will be welcomed. Sutton’s encounter with Everett revives the old impulse to flee, but Wren does not solve the crisis for him; he stays close while Sutton decides. The love declaration therefore carries a different weight from the earlier confession. Sutton’s words do not erase inherited fear, they place his present choice beside it. The novel defines healing less as forgetting the past than refusing to let it dictate every future action.
Epilogue
Fifteen years later, Sutton walks through a park with his young children, Annie and Finn, then brings them home to Wren. Their family life is made of bedtime reading, shared jokes, and plans for a Hawaii trip.
Sutton remembers that it took years of therapy and Wren’s steady presence before he felt ready to become a father, and that Wren never let fear make their decisions for them. Sutton runs the Holland Foundation, now focused on helping people rather than atoning for his past. Their life is not presented as effortless, but as a home they built together and continue to choose.
The time jump answers the novel’s central fear through lived evidence rather than a promise: Sutton becomes a husband and father without becoming Everett. His children are not proof that trauma has vanished, but that Sutton’s past does not dictate his identity. The epilogue also reframes the foundation. It begins as a response to violence and guilt, then becomes sustained service rather than self-punishment. Wren’s steadiness matters, yet Sutton’s growth remains his own work, including therapy and the decision to stay present. The ending’s domestic details complete the romance’s movement from secrecy to visibility: the intimacy once feared as a threat becomes the ordinary structure of home.
Analysis
Maybe You makes visibility its central romantic problem, but it gives that idea physical stakes. Wren has spent years concealing the scars left by a fire and the fear that other people will recoil. Sutton, by contrast, uses flamboyance and blunt sexual confidence to conceal a history that makes love feel dangerous. Their defenses differ, yet both reduce uncertainty by controlling what another person is allowed to see. The romance progresses as those controls loosen: Wren exposes his body, Sutton shows his photographs, and both begin sharing domestic space before they can agree on what their relationship means.
The book is careful to distinguish acceptance from cure. Sutton’s childhood explains why he fears his own capacity for harm, but neither Wren’s love nor the foundation’s work instantly resolves that fear. Remy and Jordan offer perspective, while Amy supplies the history Sutton has kept hidden. The decisive change comes only when Sutton chooses to stay and speak honestly after encountering Everett. In parallel, Wren’s development is not that he stops needing reassurance; it is that he asks for what he wants without surrendering his judgment. He accepts Sutton’s return but still insists that love must include a future he can name.
The novel also treats care as something built through specific, repetitive acts. Sutton refuses sex when Wren is drunk, checks his comfort when they are sober, cooks when he is anxious, and makes photographs that let Wren see himself differently. Wren draws birds on Sutton’s wall, listens when Sutton is afraid, and refuses to let inherited violence become destiny. These actions counter the book’s central threat, the idea that harm reproduces itself inevitably. The ending does not claim that history disappears. It shows two people creating a household in which history can be acknowledged without being allowed to author every choice.
Review Summary
Maybe You receives an overall rating of 4.31/5, with readers consistently praising Briar Prescott's sharp banter, natural dialogue, and compelling character development. Wren and Sutton's relationship—built on vulnerability, physical insecurity, and emotional walls—resonates deeply with many readers. Common criticisms include the predictable third-act breakup, insufficient resolution after the separation, a rushed ending, and a jarring 15-year epilogue jump. Some found the single POV limiting and Sutton's backstory reveal anticlimactic. Despite these complaints, most readers found the romance emotionally satisfying and consider it among the series' strongest entries.
People Also Read
Characters
Wren Mills
The guarded bird sketcherWren is an electrical engineering student who supports himself through night work at a swim school. After surviving a devastating fire as a teenager, he lives with extensive burn scars and has learned to keep his body and feelings out of view. His humor is dry, his curiosity vivid, and his care for others often more instinctive than his care for himself. Bird sketching gives him quiet pleasure and a way to attend closely to the world. Wren wants intimacy, but fears rejection enough to turn sex into a test. His courage lies not in becoming unafraid, but in choosing to be seen and asking clearly for the life he wants.
Sutton Holland
The charming guarded heirSutton is a wealthy New Yorker who presents himself as frivolous, blunt, and allergic to commitment. His flirtation and self-mockery let him control how closely others look, while his hidden skills, photographs, and acts of generosity reveal a more attentive man. A childhood shaped by domestic violence has left him afraid that desire and power might make him dangerous to someone he loves. He runs a foundation supporting children affected by violence, though he minimizes the work behind a pose of idleness. Sutton is funny and impulsive, but also capable of careful consent and genuine tenderness. His deepest conflict is whether he can distinguish his own choices from the harm he witnessed.
Remy Wilsson
The neighborhood repairmanRemy is a retired aerospace engineer who spends his days repairing neighbors’ broken possessions. He gave Wren a home after Wren’s hospitalization and treats him as family without demanding gratitude or disclosure. Quiet, practical, and perceptive, Remy offers help through useful actions, whether fixing a bicycle or making space for a difficult conversation. His long history with Sutton connects the two men before either understands the link. Remy believes people should be allowed to make their own choices, but he knows when a carefully chosen challenge can help someone see beyond fear.
Jordan
Wren’s protective anchorJordan is Remy’s close friend and Theo’s father, and he has made Wren part of his family. His protective instincts can turn into stern, affectionate interference, especially when Wren neglects his health or withdraws from life. Jordan understands the cost of loving someone while fearing loss, having built a life around raising Theo after becoming a father as a teenager. He offers Wren blunt advice, practical care, and humor rather than polished wisdom. His support helps Wren endure heartbreak without mistaking another person’s fear for a verdict on his own worth.
Theo
The quick-witted teenagerTheo is Jordan’s son and part of the household that gives Wren a stable sense of belonging. He is energetic, hungry, and fond of teasing Wren and his father, often puncturing tense moments with irreverent humor. Though young, he understands the household’s rhythms and participates in its affectionate give-and-take. Theo’s presence helps make Wren’s home life feel lived-in rather than solemn, and his relationship with Jordan shows the care and responsibility that hold their chosen family together.
Quinn
Sutton’s longtime friendQuinn owns the swim school where Wren works and has known Sutton for most of their lives. He is exasperated by Sutton’s stunts but trusts him, and his own relationship with Steph gives Wren a visible example of commitment built through patience. Quinn quietly supports the pool’s community mission and understands Sutton’s actions better than Sutton’s self-description suggests. He offers Wren important context about Sutton, but does not try to decide the relationship for him.
Steph
Quinn’s irreverent partnerSteph is Quinn’s partner, quick with a joke and comfortable moving through the world on his own terms. His easy affection with Quinn gives Wren another model of intimacy that includes teasing, loyalty, and shared space. Steph treats Wren warmly when they meet and helps make Sutton’s social world less intimidating. His humor often breaks tension without dismissing what is at stake.
Amy
Sutton’s guarded motherAmy is Sutton’s mother, a former waitress who came to New York dreaming of an acting career. She is warm in manner but carries painful knowledge about the family she raised. Her willingness to tell Wren about her life is shaped by regret and an understanding of how shame can keep abuse hidden. Amy is not defined only by what happened to her; she is also a mother trying to acknowledge the distance between loving a child and having protected him.
Ethan Russo
Wren’s kind former boyfriendEthan is Wren’s former boyfriend, a thoughtful economics student who later studies accounting. He once tried to make their relationship work despite Wren’s fear of being seen naked, and their reunion brings old tenderness and regret back to the surface. Ethan is friendly and socially at ease, but his assumptions about their renewed closeness lead him to misread Wren’s boundaries. His presence helps show how Wren has changed, rather than serving only as a rival.
Kira
Wren’s ambitious sisterKira is Wren’s older sister and Jordan’s former partner. Bright and ambitious from a young age, she leaves New York to pursue her education and career in California. She remains connected to Wren and to her son, Theo, even as distance and different life paths shape their family. Her choices help explain the unconventional household that gives Wren a home.
Everett
Sutton’s volatile fatherEverett is Sutton’s father, a powerful presence in the family’s past. His conduct shapes Sutton’s understanding of violence, responsibility, and the danger of repeating what one has witnessed. He represents the history Sutton fears, rather than a standard external antagonist.
Marlon
The neighborhood bartenderMarlon runs the neighborhood bar where Wren and Sutton share drinks and secrets. His familiar ease with Sutton hints that Sutton has connections beyond the wealthy social world Wren assumes he inhabits.
Plot Devices
The midnight swim school
An accidental meeting placeThe swim school brings Wren and Sutton together when Sutton breaks in for a late-night swim and Wren catches him. Quinn’s response turns the trespass into a reason for Sutton to return, first as a supposed punishment and then by choice. The building also gives the relationship a recurring space outside either man’s home, where Wren’s work routine meets Sutton’s impulsiveness. Later, their after-hours swim becomes a moment of play that deepens their physical attraction. The pool therefore functions as a threshold: it is where Wren first confronts Sutton, and where their private connection repeatedly spills into view.
Wren’s scars and bird sketches
Visibility without self-erasureWren’s burn scars shape his fear of nudity and his expectation that desire will turn into rejection. His bird sketches offer a contrasting form of visibility: they reveal patience, knowledge, and pleasure before he can explain his trauma. Sutton’s photographs later give Wren an image of himself that does not reduce him to injury. The camera and sketchpad thus operate as ways of seeing, not simply as hobbies. Wren learns to let another person look at him without controlling every response, while Sutton learns to make his own attention visible and meaningful.
The no-love rule
A shield against intimacySutton states early that he does not want love or commitment, framing their arrangement as purely physical. The rule gives both men a temporary structure: Wren can ask for sexual experience without fearing a conventional courtship, while Sutton can pursue closeness without naming it. As they share ordinary routines and become emotionally attached, the rule becomes impossible to maintain. Its collapse exposes Sutton’s fear that loving someone could make him dangerous. The device is therefore more than a romantic obstacle; it shows how a boundary can protect a person while also preventing them from testing whether the danger they fear is real.
Sutton’s photographs
Proof of a different gazeSutton’s photographs first reveal his quiet attention to friends and family, contradicting his claim to be shallow. Later, the portraits he makes of Wren show Wren as beautiful and fully present. Wren’s reaction to the prints prompts his declaration of love, making photography the direct catalyst for the central rupture. The camera externalizes Sutton’s capacity to see people tenderly, even when he cannot yet speak tenderly about himself. It also gives Wren evidence he can hold in his hands, though the images cannot resolve Sutton’s fear on their own.
The Holland Foundation
Trauma turned outwardSutton’s foundation supports children affected by domestic violence through therapy, helplines, grants, and outreach. Quinn’s disclosures reveal this work before Wren understands its personal history, and Amy later explains how Sutton’s childhood informs it. The foundation connects Sutton’s wealth to action, challenging his performance of doing nothing. At the same time, its charitable mission cannot simply cure his fear of becoming like his father. The device distinguishes public service from private healing: Sutton can work to protect others while still struggling to believe he himself is capable of building a safe relationship.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.