Key Takeaways
Judge remarkable people by resourcefulness, restraint, and justice toward others' weaknesses.
Character over status. Gurdjieff defines a remarkable person not by fame, clever tricks, or rank, but by a lively mind, self-restraint, and fair tolerance of other people's weaknesses. His father, a celebrated storyteller who lost his wealth after disease killed the cattle he had taken into his care, remained steady and generous. Dean Borsh, Gurdjieff's first tutor, lived simply despite his high position and gave his free time to study and teaching.
A demanding ideal. These men are memorable because their conduct matches their ideas. The book's portraits ask readers to judge influence by how a person behaves under pressure, especially when self-interest offers an easier route.
What's compelling is the shift from achievement to conduct. Resourcefulness matters, but restraint and fairness determine whether it serves others or merely makes someone more effective at getting their way. This standard resembles virtue ethics, which judges character through repeated choices rather than public reputation. It also avoids equating wealth or education with wisdom. The portraits are idealized, however, and a reader should distinguish an illuminating moral example from a complete assessment of a person's life.
Coordinate instinct, feeling, and thought instead of letting one rule.
A three-part model. In an ancient saying, Gurdjieff reads the wolf as bodily and instinctive functioning, the sheep as feeling, and the human caretaker as thought. A person worthy of the name, he argues, does not destroy one side to favor another, but makes conditions for these different parts to live together. The image is not a call to indulge every impulse or suppress emotion. It describes the work of governing competing needs.
Effort is required. Gurdjieff connects this idea to the river-crossing puzzle: a traveler must keep a wolf, a goat, and a cabbage safe by making an extra crossing. The lesson is that sound choices often require more than cleverness. They require attention, compromise, and repeated effort.
This model usefully resists the fantasy that reason can simply order the body and feelings into submission. Decisions are shaped by emotion and physical need, whether or not a person acknowledges them. Modern psychology also treats cognition, affect, and bodily processes as interacting rather than sealed compartments. The metaphor is a practical map, not a scientific account of three independent systems. Its strongest application is diagnostic: when one part dominates, the question becomes how to restore coordination rather than declare that part the enemy.
Investigate mysteries without mistaking an unexplained event for proof.
Curiosity begins in conflict. As a young man, Gurdjieff encounters table-turning, a reported Yezidi inability to leave a drawn circle, and stories of healings that doctors call chance. Each episode clashes with explanations he has read or been given. At a party, people offer competing accounts of the circle: a vow, a supernatural force, or hysteria. None satisfies him, so he keeps asking what is actually happening.
A search, not a verdict. The stories propel him from scientific books to religious communities and distant journeys. The important point is not that the book proves supernatural forces exist. It shows how unresolved experiences can expose the limits of easy certainty, including both credulous belief and dismissive explanations that merely rename the mystery.
The distinction between observation and explanation is essential here. An event can be real to a witness while the proposed cause remains uncertain; careful inquiry preserves both facts. That stance resembles scientific skepticism at its best, which neither accepts extraordinary claims on enthusiasm nor rejects them to protect a preferred theory. The narrative's limitation is that personal testimony is not controlled evidence. Its value lies less in settling the phenomena than in portraying the discomfort that can motivate better questions.
Educate for responsibility through disciplined effort, resilience, and practical competence.
Formation starts early. Gurdjieff's father taught him to love work for its own sake, show outward courtesy, and remain inwardly independent. He also exposed his son to things that commonly provoked fear or disgust, including harmless snakes, and insisted on cold-water washing and early rising. Gurdjieff later credits these practices with helping him withstand hardship, though some of the father's prescriptions, particularly about sexuality, reflect his own strict worldview rather than universal guidance.
Learn how to learn. Dean Borsh taught Gurdjieff mathematics and other subjects, arranged lessons with specialists, and encouraged practical crafts. When Gurdjieff became comfortable with one craft, Borsh moved him to another. The aim, as Gurdjieff understood it, was not a long list of skills but the ability to meet unfamiliar work without retreating.
The durable insight is that education forms habits of attention and response, not just stores of information. Exposure to manageable discomfort can build confidence, while switching tasks can teach flexibility. Yet resilience is not the same as hardship for its own sake, and a child's safety and temperament matter. The father's methods should be read as a portrait of a particular upbringing, not a ready-made parenting program. The broader question is whether a practice increases agency, judgment, and care.
Let conscience challenge customs that excuse harm.
Two kinds of morality. Bogachevsky distinguishes objective morality, grounded in conscience, from subjective morality, the local rules a group treats as proper. He tells Gurdjieff about an officer who struck a shoemaker and blinded him after the shoemaker demanded payment for boots. A military court acquitted the officer. In another case, an officer killed himself because he could not repay a debt to a card cheat, fearing damage to his reputation.
Whose honor counts? The contrast exposes a social code that protects an officer's standing while discounting a working man's livelihood and hungry children. Bogachevsky urges Gurdjieff to act from conscience rather than simply inherit the approval rules of his community. In his view, conscience should travel across cultures even when customs differ.
These cases show how institutions can make a moral code look neutral while distributing protection unequally. The shoemaker's story is especially sharp because the court's judgment treats status as more important than injury and debt. The distinction between conscience and convention can help people examine such arrangements. Still, conscience is not automatically infallible or culturally untouched. A useful test is whether a moral judgment can be explained to those who bear its costs, rather than merely defended by the group that benefits.
Choose work that develops capacity, not merely income.
Practice has a second payoff. Pogossian, Gurdjieff's young companion, keeps himself physically active even when no employer is paying him. He says the effort is meant to train his own nature, which prefers laziness, to cooperate with his intention. He later becomes a marine engineer. Abram Yelov applies a parallel idea to mental work: instead of letting his thoughts drift into fantasies, he studies languages, which both disciplines attention and may prove useful.
Skill travels. Gurdjieff's own life moves among carpentry, repair work, trading, and other ventures. His accounts suggest that learning to handle unfamiliar tasks can create options when circumstances change. Work is valuable here not only as a route to money, but as repeated practice in attention, persistence, and adaptation.
This view connects work to deliberate practice: repetition can build a capacity beyond the immediate task. It also broadens the idea of preparation, since physical or intellectual habits may become useful in settings that cannot be predicted. The caution is that effort alone does not guarantee security, and unpaid work can be exploited or become an excuse for overwork. The more defensible principle is to seek activities that produce both a needed result and transferable skill, while accounting for their real costs.
Measure understanding by what experience changes within you.
Knowing words is not enough. In a monastery described by Gurdjieff, Father Giovanni distinguishes knowledge, the ability to retain and repeat information, from understanding, which joins intentionally learned material with personally lived experience. Giovanni says that one person cannot simply hand another the understanding formed through a lifetime.
Two sermons, two effects. Giovanni contrasts Brother Sez, whose beautiful, fluent sermons move listeners intensely but leave little lasting change, with Brother Ahl, whose faltering speech seems unimpressive at first but gradually takes root in the listeners. The contrast suggests that eloquence can create an immediate feeling of insight without altering conduct. In the book's vocabulary, understanding is not merely a strong reaction. It is knowledge made consequential through experience.
The distinction captures a familiar gap between intellectual assent and practical competence. A person can explain patience perfectly and still lose patience under pressure; the test is what remains when the lesson must guide action. Research on skill acquisition likewise distinguishes declarative knowledge, knowing that, from procedural knowledge, knowing how, though the book gives this difference a spiritual interpretation. The contrast should not make eloquence suspect by default. Clear teaching can matter, but its effect is better judged by durable use than by the mood it produces.
Use effort to notice and interrupt automatic living.
Attention under pressure. As a boy, Gurdjieff and Karpenko become rivals over a girl and accept a bizarre duel: they hide near an artillery range during live firing, trusting chance to decide which one survives. During the ordeal, Gurdjieff describes an unusually intense awareness of himself and of the danger he has created. At day's end, he finds Karpenko wounded and, instead of feeling triumphant, becomes concerned for him. Their rivalry turns into close friendship.
Remembering oneself. Gurdjieff uses this phrase for deliberately maintaining awareness of oneself rather than being carried along by automatic thoughts and reactions. The episode presents a shock as an occasion for such awareness, not as a method to imitate. The book's safer lesson is to notice ordinary automatic behavior before it takes control.
The scene dramatizes how threat can narrow attention to the present, while also revealing how quickly self-interest can give way to concern for another. But danger is a poor training program: the duel nearly kills both boys and offers no reliable path to insight. Contemporary accounts of stress also recognize that threat can sharpen some forms of attention while impairing judgment. The practical extension is modest and safer: deliberate pauses, demanding practice, or honest self-observation can interrupt routine without requiring catastrophe.
Treat inherited traditions as clues, not unquestionable evidence.
A fragment becomes a trail. While studying ancient Armenian books with Pogossian near the ruins of Ani, Gurdjieff says they find a damaged parchment mentioning the Sarmoung Brotherhood, an esoteric school known through tradition but difficult to locate. The two men use the letter as a reason to search for traces of the group. Their journeys eventually lead to a secluded monastery, where they encounter teachings and practices unavailable in the institutions they had first consulted.
Knowledge in movement. One striking object there is a device used to teach priestess-dancers precise postures. The monastery's members believe their dances preserve knowledge across generations. The book presents this as a living alternative to relying only on written records, while leaving the historical claims inside the narrator's account rather than independently establishing them.
The story values embodied and communal transmission, forms of learning that a written archive can miss. Dance, ritual, and craft can preserve sequences of practice even when their meanings shift. At the same time, an old document or a secretive institution does not authenticate every claim associated with it. The strongest approach is neither to dismiss tradition nor to treat age as proof: ask what practices transmit, how communities interpret them, and what evidence supports claims about their origins.
Demand substance from language, not just persuasive polish.
Style can conceal thin thought. In the introduction, Gurdjieff recounts a Persian intellectual's complaint that contemporary books often prize polished wording over clear, useful ideas. The critic also distrusts journalism shaped by commercial interests, arguing that repeated publicity can manufacture authority. One example concerns a newspaper campaign praising sausages that were later linked, in the story, to a family's fatal poisoning. Another concerns lavish press praise for an actress whose performance the narrator considers inept.
Read for what is being said. The warning is not simply that some writing is bad. It is that readers can mistake fluency, repetition, and reputation for evidence. Gurdjieff presents literature as a possible instrument of human development, and judges it by whether its ideas reach the reader accurately and matterfully.
The critique anticipates a persistent problem in media systems: attention and commercial incentives can reward repetition and spectacle over verification. Its best advice is to separate a claim's evidence from the confidence of its presentation. Yet the narrator's broad dismissal of modern literature and journalism is itself sweeping, and the book uses elaborate digressions to carry its ideas. That tension is useful. It invites readers to judge not only style, but whether the form earns the attention it asks for.
Build practical independence around ideals, while counting the mission's costs.
Money as a means. In the final account, Gurdjieff describes earning money through varied enterprises to support his Institute and the people who depended on it. In Ashkhabad, he says, a repair workshop brought in 50,000 roubles in three and a half months. Among its services, he altered old corsets to match a new fashion and eventually sold thousands. He later accumulated substantial capital, but war, relocation, and the upkeep of his community repeatedly drained it.
A complicated independence. The business stories show improvisation and practical intelligence, but Gurdjieff also admits to charging people for repairs that required little or no work, taking advantage of their ignorance. His chosen ideal is to achieve a goal with a clear conscience. The narrative therefore raises a hard question: when does funding a worthy project justify tactics that would otherwise be considered unfair?
The account gives spiritual work a material infrastructure: people need food, buildings, tools, and time, none of which appear through conviction alone. That realism strengthens the portrait of a teacher who also has to manage resources. The ethical tension matters just as much. A mission can make questionable conduct feel necessary, especially when its leader controls the definition of the greater good. Financial independence is useful, but transparent limits and accountability help prevent the means from quietly replacing the mission.
Analysis
Meetings with Remarkable Men is an autobiographical sequence shaped less like a continuous life story than a chain of encounters. Gurdjieff meets a father, teachers, fellow seekers, a monk, and fellow travelers; each encounter becomes a test of what counts as knowledge, morality, work, or human development. The journey is both geographical and interpretive. He moves across the Caucasus, Central Asia, and the Middle East while revising his assumptions about science, religion, education, and himself.
The book's most durable ideas emerge from contrasts. Social honor can protect a powerful officer while abandoning a poor shoemaker. Fluent speech can move an audience without changing it. A person can know the language of virtue yet fail to embody it. Against these failures, Gurdjieff presents conscious effort, lived experience, self-observation, and disciplined work as ways to resist habitual living. The wolf and sheep image condenses this project: bodily impulse and feeling need not be enemies, but they require responsible coordination.
The stories make abstractions memorable, but they also complicate trust. The text presents extraordinary events, ancient brotherhoods, and historical claims through a self-assured narrator whose evidence is usually personal testimony or inherited tradition. The book's strongest contribution is not proof of every mystery. It is its insistence that easy explanations, whether mystical or scientific, deserve examination. Its weakest passages generalize sharply about Europe, Asia, women, and modern culture, often turning one anecdote into a verdict about whole populations. Those claims should be read as part of the author's polemic, not as established social analysis.
The result is a lively and deliberately difficult book about formation: people become themselves through what they attend to, practice, endure, and choose. Its portraits are most useful when treated as moral experiments rather than literal templates. They ask whether knowledge changes conduct, whether conscience can withstand group approval, and whether practical skill can serve an aim larger than private comfort.
Review Summary
Meetings with Remarkable Men receives mixed reviews, with ratings ranging from 1 to 5 stars. Many readers appreciate Gurdjieff's storytelling and philosophical insights, finding the book thought-provoking and enlightening. Others criticize his self-aggrandizing tone and question the authenticity of his tales. The book is seen as an introduction to Gurdjieff's teachings, blending autobiography with spiritual and philosophical concepts. Some readers enjoy the vivid descriptions of his travels, while others find the narrative structure disjointed and hard to follow.
People Also Read
Glossary
remarkable man
character beyond statusGurdjieff's term for a person distinguished by a resourceful mind, restraint in self-expression, and fair tolerance toward other people's weaknesses. The label is not meant to describe fame, social rank, or impressive tricks. His father and early teachers serve as examples because their conduct, as he presents it, embodies their values.
common presence
the whole functioning personGurdjieff's specialized phrase for the human being considered as an integrated whole, rather than as thought alone. In the excerpt, the whole includes bodily and instinctive functioning, feeling, and thinking. His central concern is how these different aspects can be coordinated through conscious effort rather than left to operate in conflict.
kastonsilia
a questioning practiceThe name Gurdjieff gives to a procedure practiced by his father and Dean Borsh. One man would unexpectedly pose an apparently misplaced question, and the other would answer calmly and plausibly. Gurdjieff says the exchanges seemed nonsensical to a child, but later helped him recognize ideas hidden beneath the surface and stimulated his thinking.
objective morality
morality grounded in conscienceBogachevsky's term for moral judgment rooted in conscience rather than a group's local customs. He considers it broadly applicable across places and societies. In his account, objective morality develops through human life and is maintained by conscience, while conventional rules can excuse unequal treatment or harm.
subjective morality
morality shaped by conventionBogachevsky's term for standards of good behavior invented and maintained by particular individuals, communities, or social groups. These standards vary across cultures and periods. His examples include different expectations for women's public behavior and bathing practices, and conflicting judgments about the debts of an officer and a shoemaker.
understanding
knowledge joined to experienceIn Father Giovanni's account, understanding is formed by information intentionally learned together with experiences personally lived through. It differs from knowledge understood merely as remembered words or facts. Understanding cannot simply be transferred from one person to another, because each person's experience and learning shape what they can grasp.
remembering oneself
maintained self-awarenessGurdjieff's phrase for sustaining awareness of oneself instead of becoming wholly absorbed in automatic thoughts, emotions, or reactions. The book presents this as a necessary element of self-development. The artillery-range episode is one instance in which Gurdjieff recalls an unusually intense awareness of himself and his situation.
Sarmoung Brotherhood
a traditional esoteric schoolAn ancient school described in the book through a damaged Armenian letter and traditions encountered during Gurdjieff's travels. The narrator and his companions search for it and eventually reach a secluded monastery associated with its teachings. Its antiquity and claimed knowledge are presented as part of the narrative, not independently verified in the excerpt.
Seekers of Truth
Gurdjieff's traveling circleThe name used for Gurdjieff's circle of companions who share interests in psychological, religious, and archaeological questions. Members include several of the men profiled in the book. They travel together, study traditions, conduct investigations, and pursue what they understand as personal preparation and the search for deeper knowledge.
FAQ
What's Meetings With Remarkable Men about?
- Semi-autobiographical narrative: The book is a semi-autobiographical account by G.I. Gurdjieff, focusing on his early life and the remarkable individuals he encountered.
- Spiritual journey: It details Gurdjieff's quest for knowledge and understanding of human nature, emphasizing self-awareness and personal development.
- Cultural insights: The narrative includes rich descriptions of various cultures and spiritual practices, particularly from the East and Central Asia, which influenced Gurdjieff's teachings.
Why should I read Meetings With Remarkable Men?
- Unique spiritual perspective: Gurdjieff offers a distinctive viewpoint on personal growth and the quest for meaning, making it relevant for those interested in self-improvement.
- Inspiring characters: The book features intriguing characters whose stories highlight the importance of mentorship and learning from others.
- Foundation for teachings: It lays the groundwork for understanding Gurdjieff's later works and teachings, including the "Fourth Way."
What are the key takeaways of Meetings With Remarkable Men?
- Self-knowledge is crucial: Gurdjieff stresses that understanding oneself is essential for personal growth and achieving one's full potential.
- Mentorship's value: The book highlights the significance of learning from others, particularly those with remarkable insights.
- Diverse philosophies integration: Gurdjieff advocates for a holistic approach to understanding life, drawing from various cultural and spiritual traditions.
What are the best quotes from Meetings With Remarkable Men and what do they mean?
- "Only he will deserve the name of man...": This quote emphasizes the need for balance between primal instincts and nurturing aspects within oneself.
- "The fundamental striving of every man...": Gurdjieff advocates for personal liberation from societal constraints as essential for authentic living.
- "Without salt, no sugar.": This saying reflects the idea that opposites are necessary for a complete understanding of life.
Who are the remarkable men mentioned in Meetings With Remarkable Men?
- Diverse characters: Gurdjieff encounters various individuals, including his father, Dean Borsh, and others, each contributing unique insights.
- Mentors and guides: Many serve as mentors, providing wisdom and guidance that shape Gurdjieff's spiritual journey.
- Cultural representatives: These men represent a range of cultures, illustrating the universal nature of Gurdjieff's quest for knowledge.
What is Gurdjieff's view on education in Meetings With Remarkable Men?
- Holistic education: Gurdjieff believes true education encompasses emotional and spiritual development beyond academic knowledge.
- Mentorship's role: He emphasizes the importance of guidance from experienced individuals in the educational process.
- Self-education: Gurdjieff advocates for self-directed learning, encouraging active knowledge-seeking.
How does Gurdjieff define a "remarkable man" in Meetings With Remarkable Men?
- Resourcefulness of mind: A remarkable man is characterized by critical and creative thinking.
- Restraint and justice: Self-control and fairness in interactions are emphasized as key traits.
- Continuous growth: A remarkable man is always striving for self-improvement and deeper understanding.
What methods does Gurdjieff suggest for personal development in Meetings With Remarkable Men?
- Self-observation: Gurdjieff encourages self-reflection and awareness of thoughts and actions.
- Conscious effort: Deliberate efforts in daily life are advocated for cultivating personal growth.
- Integration of experiences: He emphasizes integrating lessons from diverse experiences for holistic development.
What is the significance of Gurdjieff's travels in Meetings With Remarkable Men?
- Self-discovery journey: His travels symbolize the quest for knowledge and personal growth.
- Cultural exploration: They allow Gurdjieff to explore various cultures, enriching his worldview.
- Metaphor for life: The journey serves as a metaphor for the human experience, emphasizing exploration and learning.
How does Gurdjieff define the concept of "self-remembering" in Meetings With Remarkable Men?
- Awareness of oneself: "Self-remembering" involves being aware of one's thoughts, feelings, and actions in the present moment.
- Overcoming mechanical living: It emphasizes breaking free from automatic behaviors to live more consciously.
- Path to inner development: This practice is key for achieving personal transformation and understanding one's true nature.
What role does mentorship play in Meetings With Remarkable Men?
- Guidance and support: Mentorship is a recurring theme, with Gurdjieff learning from various figures who guide him.
- Personal growth: Mentors significantly contribute to his personal and spiritual development.
- Reciprocal learning: Interactions with mentors illustrate the reciprocal nature of learning, benefiting both parties.
How does Gurdjieff's philosophy evolve throughout Meetings With Remarkable Men?
- Foundation of ideas: The book illustrates the evolution of his philosophy through personal experiences.
- Integration of influences: Gurdjieff's philosophy evolves as he integrates various cultural and spiritual influences.
- Emphasis on inner work: He increasingly emphasizes inner work and self-awareness as essential components of personal transformation.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.