Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Otherwise Engaged

Otherwise Engaged

Old friends fake an engagement to secure a real-estate deal, but can old hurt survive desire?
by Avery Keelan 2021 480 pages
3.97
6k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

A Boyfriend From Thin Air

A gala boast traps Thayer in a lie

At a charity gala hosted by her mother’s oil-magnate husband, Thayer Montgomery endures her twin sister Quinn’s engagement to Adam, Thayer’s former college boyfriend. When Quinn and gossip-hungry Millie Pruitt pity Thayer for arriving alone, she claims she has a serious boyfriend and plans to bring him to the wedding.

The boast is meant to stop the matchmaking, but her mother immediately wants to meet the man before any engagement. Thayer has invented no details because there is no boyfriend to describe. Soon, family and friends are pressing her for a name, a photograph, and the story of how they met. A small defense of her pride has become a public promise with a three-month deadline.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Thayer’s lie is less a bid for romance than an attempt to reclaim control in a room where other people keep defining her as a problem to solve. Her family’s concern arrives disguised as kindness, but it leaves little space for her own choices. The invented boyfriend gives her a momentary escape from scrutiny, then converts private embarrassment into a performance she must maintain. That contradiction establishes the novel’s central pressure: Thayer can manage appearances far more easily than the vulnerability that genuine intimacy demands.

The Investor Wants a Fiancée

Bennett needs respectable love to rescue Flux's bid

Bennett Bradford, Thayer’s former friend and now a real-estate developer, cannot persuade investor Jared Callaghan to fund Flux Development. Callaghan distrusts Bennett’s bachelor image, sharpened by scandalous nightclub photographs, and wants to see a settled, family-minded man.

Flux needs Callaghan’s five million dollars to secure a valuable development parcel, while Bennett’s cousin Adam is building a rival company and competing for the same opportunity. When Bennett learns Thayer has claimed a boyfriend, he recognizes a mutual solution.

At a coffee-shop meeting, he exposes her lie and proposes that they pretend to date: she can present him as her mystery man, and he can bring a respectable partner to Callaghan. Each can protect a reputation, but both risk far more than they admit.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The arrangement begins as a transaction between two people who think they understand the price of intimacy. Bennett treats romance as a tool for managing investors; Thayer sees it as a dangerous exposure of her private life. Their needs are not identical, but each is legible to the other: he needs credibility, while she needs relief from social judgment. The scheme also makes reputation a form of economic currency. Callaghan’s prejudice is unfair, yet Bennett cannot afford to challenge it without jeopardizing the company he built.

Homecoming's Unfinished Kiss

A high-school secret turns friendship into years of silence

Years earlier, Thayer and Bennett were close classmates whose friendship was tipping toward romance. During a party game, they were sent alone into a bathroom, but Bennett held back from kissing her; later, he asked her to homecoming instead.

Soon after, Bennett learned that his father had been arrested for insider trading and confided in Thayer, who tried to comfort him. Their school soon buzzed with the news. Bennett concluded that Thayer had betrayed his confidence, stopped speaking to her, and later saw her at homecoming with another boy.

Thayer never understood why he turned against her. The abrupt break left both teenagers grieving a relationship neither had been brave enough to name, and the old hurt shadows their present-day bargain.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

This memory gives the present romance an asymmetrical history: each character carries a different explanation for the same rupture. Bennett reads exposure as betrayal, while Thayer experiences his silence as inexplicable rejection. Their youth does not make the harm trivial; it makes the harm more formative, because neither had the language or emotional security to test an assumption. The almost-kiss becomes less important than the conversation that never happens. Their adult conflict will repeat that structure until they risk asking what the other actually meant.

Terms for Pretending

Flowers and rules make their arrangement public

Thayer hesitates until Bennett sends deep-purple calla lilies to her lingerie store, giving Quinn and the gossip network fresh evidence that the supposed boyfriend exists. Faced with more family questions, Thayer agrees to the scheme and drafts a written contract.

They will appear exclusive for three months, attend events together, avoid sex with each other or anyone else, and keep the arrangement from friends and family. Bennett must provide health records, and he owes Thayer a future favor for pressuring her into the deal.

Thayer confides the truth to her best friend Lola, who helps her rehearse the story. Their plan now has rules, a witness, and an audience, but its most consequential terms cannot prevent either of them from developing real feelings.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The contract is Thayer’s attempt to turn uncertainty into administrable risk. She specifies duration, boundaries, and compensation because written terms feel safer than trusting Bennett’s intentions. Yet the document cannot govern the meanings their actions acquire in public or in private. Its prohibition on sex is especially revealing: both treat desire as the one variable that must be controlled, even as their arrangement depends on convincing others that they are genuinely close. Formal rules can limit conduct, but they cannot guarantee emotional distance.

A Kiss at the Dinner

A surprise investor forces them toward an engagement

Bennett and Thayer arrive at a family dinner expecting a manageable first performance, only to discover that Callaghan is among the guests. Thayer’s anxiety rises, and Bennett quietly recognizes the signs of a panic attack, giving her time to steady herself before they join the room.

Their story holds through dinner, but Millie tests how serious they are. To satisfy Callaghan and the watching family, Bennett claims they have discussed marriage. The claim pleases Callaghan and spreads instantly through the gathering.

When Thayer is cornered by Louis Sullivan, Bennett steps in, places an arm around her, and kisses her in the garden to make the relationship convincing. The kiss works too well: afterward, both struggle to dismiss the desire that their public performance has awakened.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The dinner shifts the couple’s problem from maintaining a simple lie to improvising a future that other people now expect them to inhabit. Bennett’s care for Thayer’s anxiety offers a glimpse of attention that his business strategy cannot explain, while the kiss turns performance into bodily experience. The scene exposes a familiar paradox of social acting: a gesture can be staged for an audience and still produce authentic feeling. Their danger is not merely that someone will uncover the arrangement. It is that the act may begin to change the actors.

The Ring and the Runway

A fake proposal collides with debt and Mexico

Once the engagement rumor spreads, Bennett buys Thayer a lab-grown diamond ring and slips it onto her finger before dinner with his business partner Ian and Ian’s wife, Laura. Their hoped-for meeting with Callaghan is canceled when his wife suffers a mini-stroke, delaying Flux’s financing again.

Bennett’s own troubles deepen: the IRS demands unpaid corporate taxes, his mother Lydia’s cancer has returned, and his younger brother Holden is struggling emotionally. Meanwhile, Quinn announces an all-expenses-paid bachelor and bachelorette trip to Mexico and has already included Bennett.

He and Thayer must pretend to be an engaged couple through the trip, now sharing a room and an uncertain amount of time alone. The ring gives their fiction a glittering center, while the business and family pressures make escape increasingly difficult.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ring makes the false relationship materially visible, a prop that carries social authority precisely because everyone assumes its meaning is sincere. At the same time, Bennett’s private burdens reveal how much of his confidence is defensive performance. He keeps handling crises alone, even when help is available, while Thayer’s presence draws him toward a less solitary way of coping. The accumulating obligations also complicate the romance: the couple is not choosing each other in a vacuum, but under financial pressure, family illness, and expectations neither controls.

One Bed, Two Secrets

Quinn confesses her shrinking chance of motherhood

In Mexico, the bridal party’s shared resort floor leaves Bennett and Thayer with a single bed and little privacy. Thayer is nervous about flying and leans on Bennett during takeoff; he comforts her rather than turning her fear into a joke.

The tenderness unsettles their usual sparring, but the deeper change comes when Quinn tells Thayer she has primary ovarian insufficiency. Quinn had imagined a large family and now fears that years of disordered eating may have damaged her fertility, though her doctors have not blamed it.

She also believes she and Adam should hurry toward marriage and children. Thayer senses that Quinn’s urgency may be making her ignore warning signs in the relationship. She keeps the confidence, but the knowledge sharpens her concern about Adam.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The room’s single bed externalizes the closeness the pair has been carefully avoiding, while the flight gives Bennett an opportunity to respond to fear with steadiness rather than flirtation. Quinn’s confession adds a second, more intimate pressure to the story: the imagined future of motherhood is becoming time-sensitive, and that fear can make a questionable present feel like the only available path. Thayer’s protectiveness is sincere, but her insight is limited by Quinn’s defensiveness. The scene asks how care can remain supportive without becoming another attempt to control someone.

The Line Breaks in Mexico

A zipline, an old lover, and jealousy undo restraint

Bennett persuades Thayer to try zip-lining, and she discovers she enjoys it despite her fear. Later, they run into Nina, a woman from Bennett’s past whose name he cannot remember. Thayer covers his awkwardness as his fiancée, then retreats emotionally, convinced she has seen how little commitment means to him.

Bennett leaves Adam’s rowdy nightclub outing early and finds Thayer with the women. He draws her back to their room, where he explains that he never hated her and that his presence in Mexico is not only about Adam.

Thayer lets him close, and they finally have sex. The contract’s boundary collapses, but the greater shift is emotional: both recognize that their attraction has become difficult to separate from trust, jealousy, and the old affection neither fully understood.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The zipline lets Thayer discover that fear can coexist with pleasure, a small rehearsal for the larger emotional risk she is taking. Nina’s appearance then makes Bennett’s past feel immediate, and Thayer’s jealousy exposes how thoroughly the pretend engagement has crossed into personal attachment. Bennett’s decision to leave the nightclub matters because he chooses her over the bachelor role he has been performing. Their first sex is therefore not simply the breaking of a rule. It is the moment when physical intimacy makes denial harder, though it does not yet resolve the mistrust that will return.

Ledgers Beneath the Romance

Thayer finds Adam's transactions hiding in Flux's books

The morning after they sleep together, Bennett admits Flux’s finances are in worse shape than he has let on. Thayer studies his accounts and spots suspicious payments to a numbered company; the transactions stop after Adam left the business.

Her discovery gives Bennett a reason to suspect his former partner has been quietly draining Flux. Back in Mexico, he still has to sit through brunch with Adam and the wedding party. When Bennett’s card is declined, Thayer invents an expiration-date explanation and pays the large bill herself, shielding him from Adam’s scrutiny.

Once home, Ian investigates the related vendors and finds inflated charges, but the scheme is difficult to prosecute. The evidence points toward Adam, yet Bennett needs stronger proof before he can act.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Thayer’s competence becomes a form of intimacy: she offers Bennett not just comfort but a clear-eyed reading of the records he has been too overwhelmed to interpret. His willingness to expose the company’s weakness marks a departure from his habit of treating dependence as failure. Still, the ledger’s clues do not instantly produce justice. The business plot resists the clean moral logic of romance, because suspicious transactions and inflated invoices are not enough by themselves to prove a case. Trust between the couple grows faster than certainty about Adam.

The Old Wound Opens

A lease fight revives Bennett's false accusation

After Mexico, Thayer learns that Quinn signed a long-term lease for a fourth Lace & Grace location in Adam’s development without consulting her. When Thayer brings the document to Bennett, he doubts her claim that she knew nothing about it. His suspicion triggers the old grievance: he tells her he believed she leaked the news of his father’s arrest in high school.

Thayer realizes Millie had been beside her when Bennett confided in her, and Bennett recognizes that Millie could have overheard them. He apologizes for assuming the worst, but the explanation cannot erase years of silence or his fresh accusation. Thayer uses the favor in their contract to ask him to leave her alone until the engagement party, then walks away heartbroken.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The lease dispute is both a practical crisis and a reenactment of the original wound. Bennett once again interprets incomplete evidence as proof that Thayer has betrayed him; she once again bears the cost of an accusation she did not earn. The old misunderstanding becomes intelligible, but understanding is not the same as repair. Thayer’s use of the contractual favor is especially pointed: the document she created to limit Bennett’s power now gives her a way to establish distance. Her request protects her from further injury, even as it prolongs their separation.

The iPad Confession

Quinn uncovers Millie, Adam, and a bribed mayor

Quinn eventually checks Adam’s messages on an iPad he left behind and discovers that he has been having an affair with Millie, who helped arrange his relationship with Quinn. She also finds evidence that Adam bribed the mayor to secure the development bid. Before Quinn apologizes, Thayer confronts her over the lease, reveals her own past with Adam, and quits the lingerie business rather than keep surrendering her plans.

Later, Quinn admits she was wrong and tells Thayer what she found. Thayer also explains that her engagement to Bennett began as a sham. Together, the sisters bring the evidence to Bennett. Quinn’s discoveries turn Thayer’s suspicions into something actionable and give the fractured sisters a reason to work together again.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Quinn’s discovery dismantles the future she had been using to justify her choices, but the revelation does not make her merely foolish. Her desire for family and security has made her especially vulnerable to someone who knows how to mirror those hopes. Thayer’s resignation is a separate act of self-definition: she stops treating loyalty to the business as an obligation to disappear inside her sister’s decisions. Their alliance begins only after they risk telling each other uncomfortable truths. The sisters’ renewed cooperation is grounded not in perfect agreement, but in a shared refusal to let Adam’s schemes define their lives.

AM Changes Hands

Bennett and Thayer turn evidence into control

Bennett uses Quinn’s records to confront his uncle Richard, who owns a major stake in Adam’s company. He offers Richard evidence of Adam’s bribery and the earlier diversion of Flux money, then negotiates to buy Richard’s shares.

Quinn’s father, Thomas, transfers his own shares to Thayer after learning what Adam did to Quinn. With Bennett’s stake and Thayer’s, they control enough of the company to merge it with Flux. Adam storms into Bennett’s office when he sees the ownership change, but the new majority fires him for cause and offers only a reduced buyout.

He insults Thayer; Bennett punches him and has security remove him. Adam loses both his company and his engagement, while Flux gains the assets and funding pathway it desperately needed.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The takeover converts private knowledge into institutional leverage. Rather than exposing Adam publicly and freezing the project, Bennett and Thayer use the ownership structure to remove him while preserving the development’s value. The resolution is satisfying because it answers Adam’s economic aggression on its own terrain, but it also carries ethical ambiguity: Bennett’s pressure on Richard relies on threats of reputational and regulatory consequences. The story does not pretend that justice arrives untouched by power. Thayer’s stake matters because she is no longer merely the woman beside Bennett; she participates directly in the decision that changes the balance.

The Engagement Becomes Real

Callaghan signs as the pair finally confess love

At Bennett’s parents’ engagement party, Callaghan signs the investment papers that can rescue Flux. With the business aim secured, Bennett finds Thayer in his childhood bedroom and apologizes for both the recent accusation and the years he spent believing she betrayed him.

He admits he loved her long before their bargain; Thayer admits she loves him too, but only after insisting she needs to know he will not shut her out again. They leave the room together, agreeing to make their relationship real and to live together. The ring stays on Thayer’s finger by choice rather than cover. Their mothers still imagine a grand wedding, but the couple privately prefers the idea of eloping.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The engagement party reverses the arrangement’s original logic. At first, Thayer and Bennett used a public relationship to secure money and social approval; now the external objective has been met, and they choose one another without needing the performance. Bennett’s apology matters because he names the damage rather than treating his love as a substitute for accountability. Thayer’s condition, that he not repeat the old withdrawal, makes reconciliation a negotiation between equals. The ring’s changed meaning is understated but decisive: the same object that once concealed a lie now represents a freely chosen commitment.

Epilogue

About a year later, Thayer is living with Bennett and has returned to school for her MBA. He recreates their high-school homecoming with music and a slow dance, then slides a wedding band onto her finger beside the engagement ring.

This time, Bennett asks her to marry him plainly, and Thayer accepts. They decide against a large wedding and choose to elope in Turks and Caicos the following month, leaving room for a small celebration when they return.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The epilogue gives the couple a second version of the moment that first went unfinished: a dance tied to their youth, now followed by a direct proposal rather than an assumption or a performance. Thayer’s MBA matters as much as the ring. She has resumed the ambition she postponed while carrying the business and managing other people’s expectations. Their choice to elope also marks a boundary with the family spectacle that shaped the opening. Commitment is no longer something they stage for investors or relatives; it is a private decision made alongside their independent futures.

Analysis

Otherwise Engaged treats romance as a problem of interpretation before it treats it as a problem of attraction. Thayer and Bennett are already fluent in each other’s habits, but both mistake familiarity for knowledge. Bennett assumes that a confidence was betrayed; Thayer assumes his silence means she was never important to him. Their fake engagement repeats this pattern in miniature. They perform intimacy convincingly because they know one another’s tells, yet the performance only becomes honest when they stop relying on inference and name what hurt.

The business plot gives that emotional conflict a material counterpart. Bennett wants to be trusted by Callaghan, but the investor’s preference for conventional respectability makes private behavior a financial qualification. Meanwhile, Adam turns family affection, corporate resources, and political influence into instruments of self-interest. The novel’s answer is not that love makes business harmless. Bennett and Thayer must examine ledgers, secure shares, and make difficult decisions before their affection can survive. Their partnership becomes credible through practical cooperation as well as desire.

Thayer’s arc is equally tied to work and self-determination. She has spent years doing the invisible labor that keeps Lace & Grace functioning while postponing her MBA and accommodating Quinn. Her decision to leave is not a rejection of her sister; it is recognition that love cannot require permanent self-erasure. Quinn’s eventual honesty allows them to preserve their bond without preserving the old arrangement.

The ending makes commitment less conventional than the social world demands. The ring changes from evidence in a strategic performance to a promise Thayer accepts freely, while the couple’s plan to elope rejects the enormous wedding their families imagine. The resolution is not simply that two people overcome their fear of marriage. They learn to distinguish chosen intimacy from public approval, and to build a shared future without surrendering their separate ambitions.

Summary in 60 Seconds
After her twin sister becomes engaged to her ex, Thayer claims she has a boyfriend to escape family pressure. Real-estate developer Bennett, her estranged childhood friend, proposes they pretend to date: she gets a convincing partner, while he hopes to impress an investor and save his company. Their staged engagement rekindles attraction, and in Mexico they finally sleep together. Thayer then discovers suspicious payments in Bennett’s accounts, while a renewed argument over their past drives them apart. Quinn finds evidence that her fiancé Adam has been having an affair with Millie and bribed a mayor, as well as proof of his financial misconduct. Thayer and Bennett use the evidence to take control of Adam’s company, remove him, and secure funding for Bennett’s business. They apologize, confess their love, and choose a real relationship. A year later, Bennett proposes, and they plan to elope.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.97 out of 5
Average of 6k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Otherwise Engaged receives generally positive reviews, averaging 3.97/5. Readers love the childhood-friends-to-enemies-to-lovers and fake engagement tropes, praising the chemistry and banter between Thayer and Bennett. Many highlight Bennett as an ideal book boyfriend and appreciate the dual POV and flashback sequences. Common criticisms include excessive info dumps, inconsistencies, typos, pacing issues with overly detailed monologues, and a third-act breakup driven by miscommunication. Despite flaws, most found it entertaining, emotionally engaging, and difficult to put down.

Your rating:
4.7
24 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Thayer Montgomery

The guarded co-owner

Thayer is a meticulous financial mind, co-owner of the Lace & Grace lingerie stores, and Quinn’s identical twin. She prizes competence and privacy, partly because her family’s social world rewards polished appearances while leaving little room for uncertainty. Her exacting habits help her manage money and risk, but they can also become a way to avoid asking for what she wants. She is wary of marriage, skeptical of romantic idealism, and more tender than her cool manner suggests. Her closest friendship is with Lola, who can see through her evasions. Thayer’s central tension is between being dependable to everyone around her and making a life that belongs to her.

Bennett Bradford

The image-conscious developer

Bennett is a co-founder of Flux Development, a charismatic risk-taker whose confidence masks financial pressure and a deep fear of being judged by his family history. He is competitive, sharp-tongued, and accustomed to keeping emotion separate from sex and business. That self-protection can become damaging when he treats suspicion as certainty or tries to solve problems alone. His long friendship with Thayer gives their arguments an intimacy neither can easily explain. Bennett is devoted to his mother and younger brother, even when he struggles to offer them the words they need. Beneath his polished social ease is someone still shaped by a painful adolescent mistake.

Quinn Montgomery

The radiant twin

Quinn is Thayer’s identical twin, her business partner, and a warm, socially fluent presence who thrives on celebration and connection. Her instinct is to smooth over conflict and preserve the future she has imagined, especially when love and family are involved. That optimism can leave her vulnerable to people who present self-interest as shared ambition. Quinn and Thayer care deeply for each other, but their partnership is uneven: Quinn often takes the public-facing role while Thayer carries much of the financial and administrative work. Her longing for a settled family life shapes how she evaluates relationships, sometimes more strongly than the evidence in front of her.

Adam Matthews

The polished rival

Adam is Bennett’s cousin, a former Flux partner, and Quinn’s fiancé. His polished manners and business connections help him move easily through the wealthy social circles around both families. He is ambitious and attentive to opportunity, but his charm often serves his own advancement rather than mutual trust. Adam’s past with Thayer complicates the sisters’ relationship and makes his sudden courtship of Quinn uncomfortable for Bennett. He treats business as a contest in which loyalty is negotiable, and he expects family ties to protect him from consequences. His confidence is most persuasive when others want to believe that his plans also serve their interests.

Lola Van Sant

Thayer’s candid confidante

Lola has been Thayer’s best friend for years. She is an art curator, socially adventurous, and far more relaxed about romance than Thayer. Her generous trust in people can make her vulnerable to disappointment, but it also lets her offer acceptance without demanding that Thayer become warmer or more conventional. Lola notices when Thayer is hiding something and helps her practice the public story, while making clear that her loyalty is personal rather than judgmental.

Millie Pruitt

The society gossip

Millie moves through the same elite social circle as Thayer, Quinn, and Bennett, collecting news and shaping how it travels. Her interest in other people’s private lives gives her social influence, while her rivalry with Thayer adds an edge to their encounters. She is skilled at presenting curiosity as friendliness, which makes her difficult to read and harder to trust. Millie’s hunger to be included in every story often matters as much as the facts she uncovers.

Ian Fenmore

Bennett’s level-headed partner

Ian co-founded Flux with Bennett and serves as its operational counterweight. Analytical, organized, and socially perceptive, he handles pressure with more restraint than his impulsive business partner. Ian understands that Bennett’s sales instincts cannot compensate for every risk, so he pushes him to consider how others perceive him. His marriage to Laura gives him a settled life that Callaghan views as a mark of reliability, though Ian’s loyalty to Bennett rests on years of shared work, not appearances.

Lydia Bradford

Bennett’s resilient mother

Lydia is Bennett and Holden’s mother, a warm and gracious woman whose illness has made her sons more protective. She values family connection and finds joy in hosting, even as health concerns limit her energy. Her kindness toward Thayer reflects a history of affection that survives the years of distance between the young couple. Lydia is emotionally perceptive without being intrusive, and the possibility of making her happy weighs heavily on Bennett.

Holden Bradford

Bennett’s vulnerable brother

Holden is Bennett’s younger brother, a law student who has struggled with depression and anxiety since adolescence. More inward and sensitive than Bennett, he can be overwhelmed by family conflict and relationship strain. Bennett feels responsible for protecting him, but their bond also shows the limits of trying to manage another person’s pain alone. Holden’s difficulties deepen the pressure Bennett carries beyond the company.

Richard Matthews

The calculating uncle

Richard is Adam’s father and Bennett’s uncle, a powerful financier who treats family and business as overlapping systems of leverage. He is exacting, strategic, and difficult to impress, with a long memory for weakness. His relationship with Bennett is shaped by old financial entanglements involving Bennett’s father. Richard’s help is never simple generosity; he expects control, security, or a return that justifies his involvement.

Thomas Montgomery

The wealthy, distant father

Thomas is Thayer and Quinn’s father, a wealthy financier who lives far from the daily routines of his daughters. He provides financial security through family wealth but is not a constant presence in their business or personal decisions. His relationship with Thayer is maintained through regular contact and a shared history that still carries emotional weight. Thomas’s resources give him influence, even when he is not physically present.

Alexandra Horvath

The status-conscious mother

Alexandra is Thayer and Quinn’s mother, a polished social figure now married to oil magnate Charles Horvath. She cares intensely about appearances and expects her daughters to participate in the family’s public life. Her affection is real, but it often arrives through pressure to conform, especially around dating and marriage. Alexandra’s own history of relationships informs her daughters’ contrasting beliefs about commitment.

Charles Horvath

The powerful stepfather

Charles is Alexandra’s wealthy husband and Thayer and Quinn’s stepfather. He hosts the charity gala that begins Thayer’s predicament and belongs to the social world of donors, politicians, and investors. His oil fortune gives the family substantial status, even as Thayer doubts the sincerity behind its charitable display.

Laura Fenmore

Ian’s perceptive wife

Laura is Ian’s wife and a familiar face to Thayer from their early-morning spin classes. Quiet and observant, she is less impressed by Bennett’s social charm than by the person beneath it. Her comfortable marriage gives the fake couple an intimate audience whose reactions are difficult to manipulate.

Jared Callaghan

The family-values investor

Callaghan is a wealthy investor whose money could secure Flux’s development project. He values personal respectability and conventional family life as signs of business reliability, a bias that puts Bennett at a disadvantage. Callaghan is not persuaded by numbers alone; he wants confidence in the people behind a proposal. His standards force Bennett to confront the commercial cost of his public reputation.

Plot Devices

The fake engagement

A lie with two audiences

Thayer invents a boyfriend to stop relatives from treating her single status as a problem, while Bennett needs a respectable partner to reassure investor Jared Callaghan. Their arrangement begins as a practical trade and acquires increasingly public signs of commitment, including a ring, family dinners, and a resort trip. The same performance serves two distinct purposes: it protects Thayer from gossip and presents Bennett as stable. Its central function is to create situations in which staged affection can become emotionally real. The device also makes the couple’s private decisions answerable to an audience that assumes the relationship is genuine.

The written contract

Boundaries under pressure

Thayer formalizes the arrangement with a contract setting a three-month term, public relationship duties, discretion, health disclosures, and a ban on sex. She also ensures Bennett owes her a future favor because she feels pressured into the deal. The document gives her a sense of control and provides an explicit record of what each person expects. As the relationship develops, the terms become an ironic measure of how little the pair can govern through rules alone. The favor later gives Thayer a way to request distance when trust breaks down, so the contract has practical consequences beyond its original purpose.

The overheard confidence

A mistaken source of blame

As teenagers, Bennett tells Thayer that his father has been arrested, and news of the arrest spreads through their school soon afterward. Bennett believes Thayer must have disclosed what he told her, while Thayer has no idea why he withdraws from her. The missing fact is that Millie was nearby when Bennett confided in Thayer and could have heard them. The misunderstanding shapes years of hostility and resurfaces when a new business conflict makes Bennett suspect Thayer again. This device links the romance’s present trust problem to an old injury caused by overhearing, assumption, and the refusal to ask a direct question.

The financial paper trail

Evidence becomes leverage

Suspicious payments in Flux’s records point toward Adam’s former role in the company, while later evidence connects him to inflated vendor charges and a mayoral payoff. Quinn’s access to Adam’s messages supplies proof that the business suspicions alone cannot provide. Bennett and Thayer then use ownership shares, rather than public exposure alone, to change who controls Adam’s company. The device makes the romantic partners collaborators in a concrete problem-solving plot. It also distinguishes suspicion from actionable evidence: a pattern can raise the alarm, but records and control of the company determine what can be done.

About the Author

Avery Keelan is a Canadian romance author specializing in sports and adult contemporary romance, particularly known for her hockey heroes. Her writing is characterized by snarky banter, lovable characters, steamy scenes, and dramatic storylines, all building toward satisfying happily-ever-afters. Originally gaining popularity on Wattpad, she has successfully transitioned to published works on platforms like Amazon. Readers frequently praise her distinctive voice and engaging writing style. Outside of writing, Keelan enjoys time with her family, watching hockey, and exploring the Canadian outdoors. She maintains an active social media presence across Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, BookBub, Pinterest, and her Amazon author page.

Download PDF

To save this Otherwise Engaged summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.39 MB     Pages: 23

Download EPUB

To read this Otherwise Engaged summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.49 MB     Pages: 31
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...