Plot Summary
Prologue
At a Norse wedding, a red ribbon binds a young bride and groom while they exchange knives instead of rings. The groom believes their vows will begin an ordinary life together.
Then the officiant changes into a terrible, white-haired figure. The bride cuts her new husband’s throat, and both collapse beside the sea. Their joined wrists remain bound by the ribbon as the world goes dark.
The wedding begins with love presented as a public promise, witnessed by family and sealed with a ribbon made from the groom’s dead mother’s tunic. Its abrupt reversal makes intimacy inseparable from danger before the reader knows why. The exchanged knives turn commitment into a double-edged act: the bride’s wedding gift becomes the instrument of the groom’s death. Yet the ribbon remains intact, suggesting that whatever binds the couple survives the violence. The scene plants a question that governs the novel: how can a love endure when its most familiar ending is murder?
The Feast Before the Knife
In El Salvador, Evelyn lives as Adella Sola, daughter of a coffee-growing family feuding with the Quiñónez family. Their parents have called a truce because Adella’s sister, Silvia, plans to marry into the rival family. Adella jokes her way through the strained dinner, then follows Rafael Quiñónez into the courtyard.
The familiar pull she associates with her recurring killer is absent, so she does not expect him. Rafael reveals himself as Arden and attacks. Adella fights back, cuts his throat, and falls into the pool with him. Their lives end together, as they have many times before. In the next life, she will remember the pattern and expect to die again before she turns eighteen.
The opening makes Evelyn’s danger less a matter of discovering whether Arden will find her than of surviving the interval before he does. Her teasing at the dinner table is not simple recklessness: she uses humor to loosen a family conflict she cannot otherwise control, even while privately rehearsing the loss that will follow her death. The courtyard attack unsettles her confidence because the familiar recognition fails. This life’s central problem is therefore not only the killer’s pursuit, but Evelyn’s uncertainty about her own instincts. The mutual death also establishes that violence binds them rather than separating them.
A Sister Needs Her Marrow
Evelyn awakens as Branwen Blythe in rural Wales, carrying memories of many lives but never having reached adulthood. Her father died in a road accident when she was eight, and now her fourteen-year-old sister, Gracie, has leukaemia.
Branwen is the only relative whose tissue matches; a stem-cell transplant may save Gracie, but the procedure is scheduled close to Branwen’s eighteenth birthday, when Arden is expected to find her.
She gives herself booster injections and tries to keep her mother hopeful, even as the doctors report that Gracie has an infection and the original transplant plan may need to be delayed. Branwen’s usual habit of imagining the worst now has a specific cost: she might die before her sister receives the help only she can provide.
The Welsh household gives the novel an intimate counterweight to its immense timeline. Branwen’s immortality does not make her detached from ordinary grief; it makes her acutely conscious that each family exists for only one brief incarnation. Gracie’s illness turns that fear into a practical deadline, and Branwen’s body becomes both the target Arden seeks and the resource her sister needs. Her jokes help protect the family from despair, but they also let her postpone asking for help. The transplant plot makes survival ethically concrete: living longer is not simply a personal wish when another person’s future depends on it.
The Siberian Bookshop Clue
At the hospital, Gracie reads from a new poetry collection about love recurring across centuries. Branwen recognizes its title from a copy Nia, her reserved bookshop coworker, later sets aside for her. Nia explains that the poems were found in the Siberian wilderness and published under an unknown author’s name.
Branwen suspects Nia might be Arden, but Nia’s manner gives her no certainty. Meanwhile, a blonde newcomer, Ceri Hughes, watches Branwen from outside the florist. She confronts him, shoves him into a display of flowers, and demands identification.
His licence shows a birthday months removed from hers, which should rule him out, but he acts so strangely afterward that she cannot fully trust the evidence. The poem and the stranger leave Branwen watching both faces for signs of her hunter.
The manuscript transforms a private history into an object that can circulate without its author’s consent. For Branwen, its publication offers intimacy and danger at once: Arden’s guarded inner life has reached her, but it may also identify the person who wrote it. Her suspicion of Nia and attack on Ceri show how long pursuit has trained her to treat ambiguity as a threat. The false lead is psychologically credible because she has already learned that familiar signals can fail. Even the book’s public availability cannot restore what she lacks most: certainty about who is in front of her.
Poison Beneath the Aurora
Reading the Siberian poems brings Branwen back to a life as Nadezhda, when she and Arden, then Mikha, were lovers in a remote village. The night before their eighteenth birthday, Mikha digs a grave in the frozen ground and admits it is meant for them. He has mixed poison into the cherry liqueur they shared, believing their deaths must come before adulthood.
As Nadezhda grows drowsy, Mikha panics and tries to save her, but the poison has already taken hold. They lie together in the grave and die. His poems reveal the tenderness he usually hides, while his final admission that a bargain made long ago governs them deepens Branwen’s questions. The memory also recalls earlier lives in which she and Arden loved, fought, and killed each other.
The Siberian memory complicates Branwen’s image of Arden as a cold executioner. His decision to poison them is still an act of control, but his reversal exposes the grief beneath it. He wants to protect her from something he refuses to explain, then discovers that protection has become irreversible harm. Branwen’s willingness to lie beside him does not erase her anger; affection and accusation occupy the same moment. The scene also clarifies why the poems matter: they preserve a version of Arden’s feelings that his present behavior tries to suppress. Writing becomes both confession and evidence.
The Farmhand's Hidden Identity
With her birthday near, Branwen agrees to meet Ceri and dresses for what may be her last date. During a tour of the farm, he recites a line from the Siberian poem but changes a word. Branwen realizes he is not the author after all, yet still fears he may be Arden. She strikes him with a shovel and drags his unconscious body into an unused stable.
Dylan, the cheerful farmhand who has worked on the Blythe farm for two years, finds her there and admits he is Arden. He explains that he kept close to the family and grew attached to Gracie, but still believes he must kill Branwen before they turn eighteen. When she begs for time to save her sister, he agrees to stay with her for six days.
The reveal overturns Branwen’s assumption that danger will announce itself through an unfamiliar face. Arden has entered the domestic life she most wants to preserve, sharing meals, caring for Gracie, and making himself useful on the farm. His disguise is not merely tactical: he has become attached to the people whose loss his usual plan would cause. Branwen’s mistake with Ceri is consequential and humiliating, but it also exposes how fear has narrowed her choices. The six-day agreement is a fragile compromise, not reconciliation. It gives her a little time while leaving the central threat, and the power imbalance between them, intact.
Ceri Gets His Choice
Ceri wakes in the stable with a head injury and overhears enough to understand that Branwen has mistaken him for someone else. Arden insists he must stay restrained, but Branwen unties him, risking the deadline she negotiated.
Arden does not kill her, and together they take Ceri to hospital. Later, Ceri confronts Branwen at the bookshop and asks what is happening. She records Arden confirming that he intends to kill her and warning that police involvement could hasten her death. Ceri leaves without promising to help.
Back at the farm, Branwen tells her mother that she and Dylan are together, a lie that allows her to stay near Arden. Her mother’s delighted response makes the deception hurt more, while Ceri now has evidence that could bring the police into their lives.
Branwen’s choice to release Ceri marks a limit she refuses to cross, even when her sister’s future is at stake. The decision does not make her harmless: she has already abducted and injured an innocent stranger. But she refuses to turn his vulnerability into a tool once she understands who he is. Arden’s restraint matters too, though it does not cancel his threat. Meanwhile, the false romance with Dylan lets Branwen remain close to her family and her captor at once. Her mother’s happiness sharpens the cost of pretending that the danger is an ordinary teenage relationship.
Six Days, No More
The NHS cannot schedule Branwen’s marrow extraction before her birthday, and Gracie’s infection has already delayed the transplant. Branwen asks her therapist, Dr Chiang, to help find a private surgeon. Dr Chiang initially refuses, worried that arranging an emergency procedure will reinforce Branwen’s fear.
At the cottage, Arden cuffs Branwen to his bed at night, and she hears him wake from a recurring nightmare with his back scratched raw. When she calls him back to bed, he admits that distance is a way to protect them both from the pain of their bond.
Later, Dr Chiang reconsiders and arranges a pro bono appointment with her wife, Dr Schneider, for the day before Branwen turns eighteen. The chance to save Gracie is real, but Arden still has not promised to spare Branwen.
This reprieve depends on two forms of care that the novel keeps in tension. Dr Chiang must decide whether helping Branwen is compassionate or whether it will strengthen a fear she cannot verify; her eventual change of mind shows that care sometimes requires acting under uncertainty. Arden’s nightmares reveal that emotional distance has not made him less vulnerable, only more isolated. Branwen’s response does not cure his fear, but it makes him acknowledge it. The scene’s tenderness remains compromised by the handcuffs. The couple can comfort each other while one still controls the other’s movement.
The Harvest and Escape
At Verdant Park, Dr Schneider extracts Branwen’s marrow without general anaesthetic. Arden stays beside her and distracts her through the pain by asking about the small pleasures she wants to keep living for. After the procedure, police arrive because Ceri has given them the recording.
Branwen tells Detective Inspector Dehghani about Arden’s threats and her own assault on Ceri, but officers cannot find him. Her mother brings her home, where Branwen slips out through a window and heads for the bus station.
Before leaving town, she turns back to visit Gracie, who wants to see a play together after recovery. Outside the hospital, Branwen finds Arden waiting. The marrow has been harvested in time, but she has one last night before her birthday and no longer believes escape will keep him away.
The operation is a victory with no guarantee of personal safety. Branwen endures pain to give Gracie a chance, and Arden’s presence at her bedside briefly makes their intimacy feel possible again. The police arrival then changes the terms of the chase without resolving it: legal protection may come, but not quickly enough to settle what will happen before dawn. Branwen’s visit to Gracie is the emotional hinge. She chooses a final encounter with the person she is trying to save over a cleaner escape. Her decision is not foolishness alone; it expresses the relational loyalty that has always shaped her choices.
The Devil's First Bargain
Arden meets Branwen outside the hospital, and she agrees to go with him only if he finally explains why he kills her. On a cliff above the Welsh valley, he reveals that in their first life, in Lundenburg, he was a grieving young man desperate to save his dying sister, Beorma.
Evelyn, then a devil raised by a being called the Mother, offered to cure her in exchange for Arden’s soul and service. The bargain was badly phrased: Beorma died the next day, and Arden endured seven days on burning coals before becoming a reaper.
He later discovered that killing Evelyn killed him too, resetting their lives before the age when the Mother could summon them to reap. Branwen understands that the apparent cycle of murder has been their escape from a worse fate.
The revelation reverses the moral arrangement at the centre of the romance. Branwen is not simply the hunted innocent, and Arden’s violence is not an unexplained private cruelty; both are caught in consequences that began with her desperate attempt to help him. Yet the explanation does not absolve her or him. A bargain made under pressure still creates real suffering, and the original failure to specify what saving Beorma meant becomes the seed of centuries of repetition. The memory imbalance between them also takes on new weight: Arden has carried the origin alone, while Branwen has been spared knowledge at the cost of agency.
A Mother Made of Suffering
Rather than repeat their deaths, Branwen and Arden let themselves be summoned to the Underrealm when they turn eighteen. Its black ground, falling ash, and trees made of bone match the landscape Branwen glimpsed in memories of an asylum escape. She tears a bone shard from a tree and follows the tether to the Mother, whose devils gather around a throne.
The Mother explains that suffering sustains her and that she sent them back to the trenches to recruit desperate souls. Arden recognizes that the reapers are fading under the pain they collect. Branwen stabs the Mother, but the servants bind her and force Arden onto the burning coals. The Mother heals herself by draining his suffering, then offers them freedom if they surrender their love.
The Underrealm turns the couple’s private trauma into a visible system: the Mother converts pain into power, then uses that power to produce more pain. Arden’s recognition that the other reapers are crumbling exposes the system’s weakness, but not before the Mother turns his own endurance against him. Branwen’s attack is courageous and strategically insufficient, a familiar pattern in a life where action has rarely meant control. Her choice to enter the Underrealm also changes the nature of the conflict. The question is no longer how to survive the next incarnation, but whether survival is worth sustaining a structure that feeds on other people.
Love Against the Underrealm
The Mother’s offer is stark: she will drain the love Branwen and Arden share, then release them from the duty to reap or return to the Underrealm. They refuse to condemn more souls to the same bargain and accept the cost. As the Mother draws their bond into herself, the force overwhelms her; she dies, and the devils disappear as the Underrealm breaks apart.
Branwen and Arden die too, their memories and attachment stripped away before the end. The choice ends their centuries of killing and frees future victims, but it also removes the bond that has been their one constant. Their story closes not with a shared afterlife or a promised reunion, but with the possibility of beginning without the burden they created.
The final choice refuses the familiar fantasy that love must defeat every cost in order to matter. Branwen and Arden save others by surrendering the very bond that has sustained them, not by turning it into a private exemption from the rules they imposed on everyone else. Their love proves powerful enough to destroy the Mother, but it cannot preserve their shared memory. This distinction makes the resolution morally sharper: emotion is not a magic reward for suffering, and a good choice may still entail profound loss. Freedom arrives as an ending to the cycle, not as a guarantee that the lovers will recognize one another again.
Epilogue
Years later, León Cazares, a celebrated fashion designer who has taken a temporary job in an Edinburgh bookshop café, sees a red-haired stranger settle beside the window. The stranger carries a notebook and a copy of Ten Hundred Years of You.
León feels an immediate, overwhelming recognition he cannot explain, as though his long search has reached its destination. He approaches and asks whether they have met before. The novel ends before the stranger answers, leaving the two souls at the beginning of an encounter without the memories that once defined them.
The epilogue offers recurrence without restoring the old curse. León’s instinctive pull toward the stranger suggests that the history between them has left a trace, but neither has conscious access to the lives that produced it. The book of poems acts as a bridge from the former cycle into an uncertain present: it carries evidence of their past, yet cannot tell them what to do with it. The ending therefore resists both a neat reunion and total erasure. Their next meeting may begin freely, without the Mother’s machinery, while still bearing an emotional residue neither can name.
Analysis
Our Infinite Fates makes reincarnation less a promise of romantic destiny than a test of what people do with repeated chances. Evelyn and Arden do not simply find each other again; they bring accumulated fear, uneven memory, and old decisions into each new life. Their bond can feel like home, but it also acts as a tether that narrows their freedom. The central revelation sharpens that tension: Evelyn once made the bargain that trapped them, while Arden has spent centuries carrying knowledge she cannot recall. Responsibility is therefore distributed unevenly, even between people who love each other deeply.
The Welsh present life gives these metaphysical questions a human scale. Gracie’s illness makes Branwen’s wish to survive more than self-preservation, while the transplant forces love into practical labor and physical pain. Her care for her family contrasts with the Mother’s possessive attachment, which treats suffering as a resource and closeness as something to consume. The book refuses to say that love alone repairs harm. Evelyn’s original compassion helped create the catastrophe, and the final act of compassion requires surrendering the relationship she most wants to keep.
Memory is another form of power. Arden’s detailed recall lets him protect, conceal, and control; Branwen’s fractured memories leave her repeatedly vulnerable to a history she helped create. The poems partially rebalance that difference by making his private emotional life available to her, but they cannot give her the whole truth. The ending answers this imbalance not by restoring their past but by freeing them from its machinery. In León and the stranger, recognition remains possible without certainty or obligation. Their bond may return, but it must begin as a choice rather than as a sentence.
Review Summary
Our Infinite Fates has received mixed reviews, with many praising its unique premise of star-crossed lovers reincarnating and killing each other across lifetimes. Readers appreciated the poetic writing, emotional depth, and exploration of love and fate. However, some found the character development lacking and the pacing slow. The book's comparison to "The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue" resonated with many fans. While some readers were deeply moved by the story, others felt it didn't fully deliver on its potential. Overall, the book has garnered passionate responses from readers.
Characters
Evelyn / Branwen Blythe
The stubborn remembererBranwen is the current life of Evelyn, a young woman who remembers a long succession of lives and the deaths that ended them. Her memory is uneven: recent lives return in detail, while earlier ones surface as disconnected images. She responds to grief with humor, practical care, and a persistent belief that people can still choose kindness. Her deepest fear is not pain itself but losing the particular people who make a life feel like home. Her loyalty can become self-sacrifice, and her optimism sometimes pushes her into danger, yet it also lets her keep forming attachments after repeated loss. Branwen’s central struggle is to preserve her compassion without surrendering her own right to choose.
Arden
The guarded belovedArden is Evelyn’s recurring counterpart, reborn in different bodies and drawn to writing, nature, and close observation. He carries memories that Evelyn cannot fully access, making him both her most intimate witness and the keeper of secrets that leave her at a disadvantage. His capacity for tenderness exists beside a disciplined willingness to do frightening things for what he believes is protection. Rather than risk repeated attachment and loss, he often tries to contain his feelings behind withdrawal and routine. His poetry offers a less guarded account of him than his actions do. Arden’s challenge is not learning to love Evelyn, but letting love remain visible when fear tells him to hide it.
Gracie Blythe
The sharp-witted sisterGracie is Branwen’s younger sister, a violinist with leukaemia and a talent for turning fear into outrageous jokes. Her sarcasm is not simply a defence against illness; it is part of how she keeps her own personality intact when adults treat her as fragile. She notices her mother’s sadness and tries, sometimes clumsily, to protect her from it. Branwen’s devotion to Gracie is rooted in their particular bond, not in an abstract wish to save everyone. Gracie’s wit gives the household warmth without pretending that illness is funny or fair. Her hopes for life beyond the hospital make Branwen’s urgency tangible.
The Mother
The ash-realm rulerThe Mother is an otherworldly figure associated with ash, bone, and the supernatural history surrounding Evelyn and Arden. Her presence brings both an uncanny pull and a dread Branwen cannot explain. She presents herself as a source of order, yet her power is bound to what people suffer and what they are willing to sacrifice. Her relationship to love is possessive rather than reciprocal: attachment becomes something she can use to keep herself from being alone. The Mother embodies the danger of treating another being’s pain as fuel for one’s own survival. Her influence gives the lovers’ private history consequences beyond themselves.
Mum
The grieving anchorBranwen and Gracie’s mother is still grieving her husband while trying to keep both daughters safe. She leans on practical routines, food, and steady care, but fear often overwhelms her at Gracie’s bedside. Branwen sees her vulnerability and tries to coax back the humor that once helped the family survive their father’s death. Mum’s open-hearted trust contrasts with Branwen’s lifelong suspicion of danger. Their relationship is loving but asymmetrical: Branwen knows much more about loss than her mother can imagine, while still needing her warmth.
Ceri Hughes
The wronged strangerCeri is a newcomer to Abergavenny whose attention catches Branwen’s notice at a precarious moment. He is confused by her sudden hostility and has no reason to understand the history she believes she sees in him. Even after she harms and frightens him, he responds with a concern for her safety that does not depend on liking or trusting her. Ceri’s ordinary moral instinct becomes significant beside Branwen and Arden’s extraordinary predicament: he treats a person in danger as someone worth helping, even when her story seems impossible.
Dylan Green
The farm's gentle handDylan is a young farmhand who has become woven into the Blythe household. He cares for Gracie, helps Branwen’s mother, and brings a warm, cheerful presence to the farm. His gifts are personal rather than grand: he notices what might comfort someone and makes time for the people around him. Branwen sees him as part of the patchwork of chosen family that helps her mother endure grief. He is also deeply connected to the land, finding meaning in practical work and the rhythms of the farm.
Nia
The bookish observerNia works with Branwen at Beacon Books and is thoughtful, shy, and guarded in conversation. Her interests range from chess and birds to nuclear warfare, and she is more comfortable with books than with direct attention. She gives Branwen a copy of the mysterious poetry collection, unintentionally intensifying Branwen’s suspicions about who might be nearby. Nia’s reserve makes her difficult for Branwen to read, but it does not mean she is secretly hostile. She offers a quieter contrast to Branwen’s impulsive humor and constant alertness.
Dr Chiang
The careful therapistDr Chiang is Branwen’s former therapist, a warm and attentive clinician who gives her room to speak without rushing to fill silences. She tries to distinguish compassion from reinforcing a patient’s fear, which makes her cautious when Branwen asks for help arranging an urgent procedure. Her care is not mechanical: she continues thinking about Branwen after their session and is willing to reconsider. Dr Chiang represents the difficult judgment involved in helping someone whose distress is real but whose explanation cannot easily be shared.
Dr Schneider
The willing surgeonDr Schneider is Dr Chiang’s wife and a surgeon who agrees to help Branwen when a last-minute procedure becomes possible. Her manner is direct and professional, but she takes time to explain the pain and risks involved. She treats Branwen as someone capable of making an informed decision rather than simply as a frightened teenager. Her practical kindness gives Branwen a chance to act for Gracie before the family’s usual medical plan can proceed.
Dr Onwuemezi
Gracie's oncologistDr Onwuemezi oversees Gracie’s cancer treatment and gives the family difficult news without pretending to have easy answers. When Branwen’s stem-cell count is too low and Gracie develops an infection, she explains why the transplant must be delayed and what alternatives remain. Her clinical realism makes the medical stakes legible, even when it frustrates Branwen’s urgent need to act.
DI Dehghani
The investigating detectiveDetective Inspector Dehghani leads the police response after Ceri provides evidence of a threat. She listens to Branwen’s account while trying to separate what can be investigated from what sounds impossible. Her presence brings ordinary legal scrutiny into a story governed by supernatural rules.
Silvia Sola
The hopeful sisterSilvia is Adella Sola’s sister in the El Salvador life, whose planned marriage prompts the rival families to attempt a truce. Her love offers the feuding households a reason to imagine peace, even as old resentments make that peace fragile.
Plot Devices
The soul tether
A bond that outlives deathEvelyn and Arden are drawn toward each other across successive human lives, and the death of one is inseparable from the death of the other. The tether explains how they repeatedly find one another and why neither can simply escape by hiding or dying alone. It is both intimacy and constraint: their connection offers recognition in unfamiliar worlds, but it also traps them in a pattern neither fully understands. The novel gradually reveals that the tether is not only a romantic mystery. It is part of a larger supernatural arrangement that carries their suffering and makes their choices consequential beyond any single life.
The eighteenth birthday
A deadline with a hidden costEvelyn and Arden’s repeated deaths before adulthood have become their way of avoiding an obligation that would begin when they turn eighteen. The birthday gives each life a visible countdown, turning ordinary milestones into moments of danger. Branwen’s transplant plans complicate that countdown because surviving a few extra days could give Gracie a chance to live. The age threshold initially seems like an arbitrary feature of the curse, but its meaning emerges through the original bargain and the Mother’s system. It makes the lovers’ repeated violence feel at once horrifying and, to them, necessary.
Ten Hundred Years of You
A manuscript crossing centuriesThe anonymously published collection of poems was written by Arden in a past life and discovered in Siberia. Its appearance in a modern bookshop gives Branwen access to feelings Arden has long kept private. The poems help her recognize the continuity of his character, but they do not resolve the mystery of why he hunts her. They also test what happens when private testimony becomes a public object: Arden is troubled that strangers have edited and profited from writing he never meant to publish. The book functions as a record of love, a clue to identity, and a reminder that memory can survive in forms the people who made it cannot control.
The soul bargain
Desperation turned into machineryA bargain made in Lundenburg links Evelyn and Arden to the Mother, setting rules that follow them through later lives. The deal begins with a desperate attempt to save a dying sister, but its terms are not precise enough to produce the promised outcome. It demands suffering and turns those who accept into reapers, creating a system that recruits further souls through pain. The bargains expose how a choice made under grief can become coercive once its consequences are hidden or misunderstood. In the final conflict, the Mother proposes a different exchange, making the lovers decide whether freedom is worth losing the bond that has shaped their entire existence.
The marrow transplant
A life saved in the presentBranwen is the only matching donor for her sister Gracie, so her body becomes the means by which the novel’s supernatural countdown intersects with ordinary medicine. Booster injections, an infection, a postponed operation, and the need for a private surgeon make the schedule uncertain. The transplant gives Branwen a reason to resist Arden’s deadline that is immediate and relational rather than abstract. It also requires her to endure a painful procedure without general anaesthetic because of an allergy. The medical plot grounds the epic reincarnation story in a concrete act of care: Branwen’s survival matters, but so does what she can give someone she loves.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.