Plot Summary
Two Campuses, One Goodbye
Rowan Roth, an aspiring romance writer, packs for Emerson in Boston while her boyfriend, Neil McNair, prepares to start at NYU. Their summer together has turned years of high-school rivalry into a new, tender relationship, but neither can postpone the flights waiting the next day.
At a Seattle farewell picnic, their friends and parents celebrate the adventure while Rowan privately feels the city she has always called home slipping away. Neil reassures her that their history will outlast the distance, and they promise to keep choosing each other. The prospect is frightening precisely because their relationship feels so natural. Rowan leaves determined that they can succeed where other young couples might give up.
New Cities, Old Insecurities
Neil lands in New York alone, hauling his luggage through the subway before meeting his easygoing roommate, Skyler Benedetti. Skyler's affectionate family highlights Neil's own complicated home life: his father was imprisoned after a violent assault, and Neil has spent years trying not to be defined by it.
Across the country, Rowan arrives at Emerson with her mother and finds a dorm room already cluttered by absent roommate Paulina. Her mother worries that a serious boyfriend could limit Rowan's college experience, but Rowan refuses to treat love and independence as opposites.
Both settle into unfamiliar routines, carrying private pressure beneath their excitement. Neil still wonders whether he belongs in the city he dreamed of, while Rowan wants to prove she belongs in the writing program she chose.
Freshmen Without Their Rival
Neil arrives late to his first linguistics class after subway service changes, then spends the day convinced he has failed an invisible test. He accepts Skyler's invitation to play ultimate Frisbee, makes new acquaintances, and takes a Frisbee to the eye.
Rowan, meanwhile, meets Kait Donnelly in creative writing and feels encouraged by their shared love of storytelling, but her first personal essay comes out thin and guarded. Professor Miranda Everett's thoughtful criticism unsettles Rowan more than a bad grade would, because she cannot tell what standard she is supposed to meet.
Paulina remains mostly absent, and Rowan worries she has done something to alienate her. Each young woman and man is discovering that being talented in high school does not automatically grant confidence in a new place.
Penn Station, Then A Fire Alarm
When Rowan visits New York, Neil meets her at Penn Station and their familiar closeness returns at once. He shows her the city, admits he has been too focused on classes to explore, and takes her advice to make room for fun.
Rowan shares Everett's critique, then suggests they save for a backpacking trip through Europe. Their first night alone in Neil's dorm is less effortless than either expected: Rowan's attention drifts during a new sexual experience, and a fire alarm empties the building before they can recover their privacy.
They reassure each other rather than blame one another, but Rowan leaves wondering why she misses him more after the visit. The trip plan gives them a future to anticipate, while the awkward night reveals that love cannot remove every pressure.
New Friends, Distant Intimacy
Neil tries parties and the Linguistics League, but neither immediately gives him the belonging he expected. A Shabbat dinner at NYU's Hillel brings him into conversation with Zoe, who becomes a friend after clearing up her earlier interest in him.
In Boston, Kait draws Rowan into a nighttime gathering where students read their embarrassing childhood writing; Rowan takes a turn and rediscovers the pleasure of sharing work. Their assignments remain difficult, but Neil and Rowan grow bolder with private, intimate messages, finding a way to feel close across screens.
Their Thanksgiving reunion is canceled when Rowan becomes ill, leaving Neil to spend the holiday in New York and confront memories of his father's volatility. He keeps those memories to himself, even as loneliness makes the distance harder to bear.
Letters Beneath Hanukkah
Winter break reunites Rowan with her best friends and Neil with his family. At Hanukkah, Rowan's parents welcome Neil, and the couple imagines a shared future while discussing their hoped-for Europe trip.
Neil's mother, Joelle, gives him a letter from his imprisoned father, who asks to see him; Neil reads it as an attempt to pull him back into a relationship he has never known how to repair. He hides the letter rather than tell Rowan. Soon afterward, Joelle becomes engaged to Christopher, the warm presence who has helped raise Neil and his younger sister, Natalie.
Their joy gives Neil a glimpse of the family life he wants, but his father's letter remains unresolved. Rowan also notices her mother's lingering concern about the relationship, although her parents' steady affection offers a more hopeful model of commitment.
Boston Cream at One A.M.
January brings Rowan a painful IUD displacement, worsening homesickness, and another stretch of writing that feels lifeless. She even researches transferring to NYU before Paulina, suddenly present and craving Boston cream pie, pulls her into a freezing late-night search.
Their unlikely Dunkin' stop reveals that Paulina has been avoiding heartbreak, not Rowan, and the outing loosens Rowan's sense of isolation. Neil's own college life is fraying: he misses an exam after sleeping through his alarm, grows exhausted, and becomes increasingly absorbed in psychology and research on inherited mental illness.
An East Coast scavenger hunt with Skyler, Zoe, and Adhira briefly helps him feel part of New York, but he also lies about his mother's job to conceal his family's financial difference. Both are struggling more than they admit.
One Hotel, Two Confessions
During Rowan's New York visit for her parents' book event, Neil finally explains that his father has sent two letters, including one to NYU. His worsening fatigue and loss of interest have begun to resemble depression, but he has hidden both the letters and his distress, afraid Rowan will have to carry them.
He also admits he cannot face their planned Europe trip, not because he lacks the savings but because he fears his unhappiness will spoil it. Rowan tries to accept the cancellation, yet Neil insists the problem is larger: he wants time to learn how to be happy without depending on her.
He suggests they separate, and Rowan reluctantly agrees. They spend the night together in grief, then Neil leaves the hotel before she wakes, turning a difficult conversation into a lonely morning.
Separate Roads Toward Help
After the breakup, Neil returns to Seattle during spring break and visits his father at the state penitentiary. He asks about the moods that shaped his childhood, but his father answers defensively and minimizes the harm.
Neil forgives him for what happened to him while making clear that he wants no further contact, including with Natalie. In Boston, Rowan's writing mentor, Miranda Everett, helps her see that perfectionism, not an absence of talent or happiness, has strangled her work.
At dinner with Miranda and her partner Jon, Rowan learns that their own long-distance college relationship survived by allowing both people to grow. She finds a note Neil once tucked into her coat, a small reminder of their affection. Neil begins therapy and starts considering a future in psychology; Rowan reaches out without demanding an answer.
The Common's New Clues
Neil tells Skyler the truth about his father, his depression, and why he pushed Rowan away; Skyler listens without treating him as a burden. Therapy gives Neil language for his history, and he decides to change his major from linguistics to psychology.
Near the end of the semester, he surprises Rowan in Boston with a scavenger hunt modeled on the game that first brought them together. Each location lets him explain a piece he had withheld: the prison visit, his changing ambitions, and his regret over leaving her alone.
Rowan admits that falling in love had made her fear she could no longer write romance, until Everett taught her to let imperfect drafts exist. They agree to share difficult truths sooner, support each other's separate college lives, and keep building the relationship without demanding that either stay unchanged.
First Year, Not Final Page
With their relationship repaired, Rowan and Neil finish freshman year without pretending the difficult months never happened. Rowan's writing begins to feel playful again, and Everett considers bringing her on as a research assistant.
Neil officially changes his major to psychology and continues therapy, while learning to let trusted friends see more of his family history. Rowan finally talks with her mother, who accepts that Neil is a meaningful part of her life. The couple cannot take the European trip that summer, so they imagine a smaller West Coast adventure instead.
Their plans are no longer proof that everything will work perfectly; they are an invitation to keep adjusting. When the school year ends, they return to Seattle with love intact and a clearer understanding that choosing each other does not require abandoning themselves.
Epilogue
Three years later, Neil graduates from NYU and Rowan joins his family to celebrate. They have just moved into a cramped Brooklyn apartment, their first home together, where boxes still crowd the floor and books already threaten to fill the shelves. Neil frames the yearbook confession that began their relationship alongside the letter Rowan wrote during their freshman-year separation.
Rowan is starting a publishing job while continuing to write, and Neil is preparing for graduate study in psychology. They have already traveled through Europe together, but what matters most now is the ordinary closeness of waking and sleeping in the same place. Their future remains open, and they meet it as partners who keep choosing one another.
The epilogue answers the novel's central fear through ordinary evidence rather than a grand declaration. The couple's shared apartment, unfinished boxes, and crowded bookshelf show that commitment is not a polished final scene but a life made through daily proximity and practical compromise. Framing the yearbook confession beside Rowan's freshman-year letter gives their history a physical place in the home, preserving both the impulsive beginning and the more deliberate love that followed their separation. Their careers continue to diverge, yet neither must surrender a vocation to make the relationship work. The future is not guaranteed by romance; it is sustained by the habits of honesty, mutual attention, and change that they have learned to practice.
Analysis
Past Present Future treats the first year of college as a test of identity, not simply a test of romance. Rowan and Neil arrive with reputations that once made sense in high school: the overachiever and the overachiever, the rivals who know how to spur each other forward. Distance removes that familiar structure. Their new classmates cannot confirm who they have been, and neither can effortlessly become the person they imagined they would be.
Their central mistake is not loving each other too much. It is assuming that love requires them to protect one another from painful knowledge. Neil hides his father's letters and depression because he believes disclosure would make Rowan responsible for him. Rowan hides her fear that love has damaged her writing because she worries the truth might implicate their relationship. In both cases, silence presents itself as care, but produces isolation. Their reunion works because they replace mind-reading with explicit boundaries and invitations to share.
The parallel artistic and psychological arcs sharpen that point. Rowan learns that skill cannot flourish under constant self-surveillance; her return to writing begins when she accepts a rough draft as a real beginning. Neil learns that understanding his father's behavior is not the same as excusing it, and that studying the mind does not require him to diagnose himself alone. Their growth is not symmetrical, and the book does not ask them to mature at identical speeds. It asks them to remain curious about the person the other is becoming.
The romance therefore revises the familiar idea of a happy ending. The couple's future is not secured by one declaration or a perfect summer trip. It is made through inconvenient honesty, therapy, friendships, family boundaries, creative work, and the willingness to let plans change. Their lasting promise is not that nothing will go wrong. It is that neither has to become smaller, or pretend to be well, in order to be loved.
Review Summary
Reviews for Past Present Future are generally positive, averaging 3.79/5. Fans of the first book, Today Tonight Tomorrow, appreciate the dual POV, Neil and Rowan's enduring chemistry, and the realistic portrayal of long-distance relationships and college life. Many praise the authentic mental health representation, particularly Neil's depression arc. Critics note the tonal shift from the lighthearted first book, with some finding it unnecessarily heavy or feeling the characters spend too much time apart. The epilogue was widely beloved, leaving readers hopeful for the couple's future.
Characters
Rowan Roth
Romance writer in progressRowan is a Seattle-raised college freshman, a lifelong romance reader, and an aspiring writer who has long relied on achievement to steady herself. Her high-school rivalry with Neil concealed a deep familiarity and attraction, so their relationship begins with a history few new couples possess. At Emerson, she wants to develop an artistic voice while building friendships and embracing a life beyond her hometown. Her confidence can become perfectionism: she expects her work to match the vivid stories in her head before she has allowed herself to draft freely. She is affectionate and perceptive, but she must learn that loving Neil does not require solving his pain or shrinking her own ambitions.
Neil McNair
Language lover seeking answersNeil is a thoughtful, disciplined student who has dreamed of studying linguistics at NYU. His carefulness with words, rules, and school has helped him build an identity beyond the violence and instability of his childhood. He is deeply sentimental, especially with Rowan, yet habitually hides distress because he fears becoming someone else's responsibility. New York exposes both his longing for connection and his discomfort with money, family history, and uncertainty about his academic future. Neil's gentleness is not passivity: he has a strong moral center and a serious capacity for loyalty. His challenge is to accept that honesty and seeking help are forms of strength, not evidence that he has failed to manage himself.
Skyler Benedetti
Roommate with hidden depthSkyler is Neil's outgoing NYU roommate, a Staten Island loyalist who seems to make friends wherever he goes. His easy flirtation and appetite for parties initially make him appear unlike Neil, but he also wants relationships in which he can drop the performance of being entertaining. He helps Neil enter college social life and offers unusually practical advice about communication and intimacy. His unresolved affection for Adhira gives him a vulnerability beneath his confident manner. Skyler's friendship with Neil grows through mutual honesty, showing that the people who look socially effortless may also be searching for a place to be genuine.
Kait Donnelly
Rowan's first writing friendKait is a fellow Emerson creative-writing student who meets Rowan in Professor Everett's class. She writes fan fiction, speaks candidly about the insecurities of making art, and offers Rowan an early friendship rooted in shared creative interests. Her own romantic life changes during the year, and she begins exploring storytelling through film as well as writing. Kait's humor makes vulnerability easier, though she cannot always provide the kind of reassurance Rowan hopes for. She represents the important, sometimes temporary friendships formed during a first year away from home.
Paulina Radowski
Absent-minded roommatePaulina is Rowan's roommate, a busy student from Sacramento whose near-constant absence makes her seem indifferent at first. She studies the business side of creative enterprises and wants a career in music, despite having little musical ability herself. Her distance is a way of keeping busy after a breakup, not a judgment of Rowan. A shared late-night search for Boston cream pie gives them a small opening into friendship. Paulina's story parallels Rowan's: staying occupied can postpone heartbreak, but it cannot replace the risk of letting another person see you.
Miranda Everett
Writer who teaches freedomMiranda is Rowan's celebrated creative-writing professor, a warm and attentive teacher who asks students to freewrite and share work before they have perfected it. She treats criticism as an invitation to become more emotionally present on the page, rather than as a verdict on a student's potential. Rowan's anxiety about her class pushes Miranda to explain how perfectionism can disguise itself as high standards. Her own long relationship with Jon gives her a grounded perspective on change and distance. Miranda offers mentorship without pretending to have a simple formula for creativity or love.
Ilana Roth
Rowan's protective motherIlana is Rowan's mother, a Mexican-born writer who co-creates children's books with her husband. She wants Rowan to make the most of college and initially worries that a serious long-distance relationship could narrow her choices. Her concern comes from protection, though Rowan experiences it as doubt in her judgment. Ilana's own enduring partnership with Jared complicates that advice and gives Rowan a model of lasting affection. She is close to her daughter and learns to support Rowan's relationship without mistaking care for control.
Jared Roth
Rowan's affectionate fatherJared is Rowan's father and Ilana's creative partner, an illustrator who works with her on children's books. He is affectionate, steady, and less cautious than Ilana about Rowan's relationship and college experiences. His playful warmth helps create the secure family atmosphere Rowan carries with her to Boston. Jared's own history with Ilana also reminds Rowan that adulthood does not require having every choice settled before love begins.
Joelle McNair
Neil's steadfast motherJoelle raised Neil and Natalie while rebuilding her life after the family was damaged by her husband's behavior and criminal case. She works hard, protects her children from unnecessary strain, and understands that each of them must decide what relationship, if any, they want with their father. Her quiet support allows Neil to make that decision for himself. Joelle's relationship with Christopher gives the family a gentler adult presence and a glimpse of stability that does not erase the past.
Natalie McNair
Neil's spirited younger sisterNatalie is Neil's younger sister, an energetic skateboarder who loves bright colors, physical challenges, and teasing her older brother. She was very young when their father left the household, which gives her a different, but no less complicated, relationship to the family history. Neil feels protective of her and worries that distance may keep him from being the sibling she needs. Natalie is affectionate and direct, able to acknowledge hurt while still making room for jokes and ordinary childhood interests.
Christopher
A kinder family presenceChristopher is Joelle's upbeat partner, an accountant who has become part of Neil and Natalie's family life. He bonds with Neil over word puzzles and shares Natalie's interest in skateboarding. His kindness is consistent rather than showy, making him an important contrast to the family's painful history. Christopher does not try to replace anyone; he earns trust through practical care and by welcoming both siblings into his relationship with their mother.
Lyle McNair
Neil's estranged fatherLyle is Neil and Natalie's father, a man whose volatility and rigid expectations shaped their childhood. Financial strain and emotional difficulty marked his time with the family, but neither circumstance erases the harm his behavior caused. His absence continues to influence Neil's self-image, especially Neil's fear that inherited traits might make him repeat his father's actions. Lyle's role in the story is less that of a present antagonist than of a history Neil must decide how to carry.
Adhira
Skyler's first loveAdhira is a psychology student and Skyler's former high-school girlfriend. Confident and funny, she is quick to challenge his posturing and perceptive about the person beneath it. Their brief teenage relationship ended when her family traveled, but their renewed friendship leaves room for unresolved feelings. She also becomes one of Neil's friends and shares her enthusiasm for psychology, giving him an easy way to talk about his emerging academic interests.
Zoe
Neil's Jewish community friendZoe is Adhira's roommate, a biochemistry student and a regular presence in Neil's growing New York circle. After realizing Neil is committed to Rowan, she approaches him as a friend and shares her own experience of being betrayed in a past relationship. Her interest in Jewish community events helps Neil feel less alone at NYU. Zoe's directness and warmth make her part of the network that begins to replace his assumption that he must manage everything privately.
Jon
Miranda's long-distance partnerJon is Miranda's partner, a carpenter who makes beautiful wooden objects and welcomes Rowan into their home. He attended a different college from Miranda, so their shared history offers Rowan an example of young love surviving years of separation and change.
Kirby Taing
Rowan's chaotic best friendKirby is one of Rowan's closest friends from Seattle and a university student who approaches life with comic disorder and fierce loyalty. She is in a relationship with Mara and remains a reliable source of teasing, affection, and home-town continuity for Rowan. Kirby's presence reminds Rowan that new friendships need not replace the bonds she already has.
Mara Pompetti
Rowan's gentle best friendMara is Rowan's longtime Seattle friend, a dancer whose gentleness balances Kirby's chaos. Her relationship with Kirby is affectionate and mutually respectful. She and Kirby stay connected to Rowan across the first year, giving her a familiar place to turn when Boston feels lonely.
Gabriel
Kait's college boyfriendGabriel is Kait's boyfriend at UConn. Their relationship has lasted since high school, and a summer trip through Europe gives Kait new perspective on their closeness and compatibility.
Plot Devices
The long-distance relationship
Love across two citiesRowan's college in Boston and Neil's in New York make absence an active condition of their relationship. Visits, calls, texts, travel costs, and missed holidays shape what they can share and when. The distance also exposes how differently each responds to change: Rowan tries to preserve closeness while building a new life, and Neil initially withdraws to avoid burdening her. It is not merely an obstacle to reunion. It forces them to distinguish support from dependence and to create a relationship that can contain two separate lives.
Howl and its scavenger hunt
A game becomes their languageHowl, the high-school game that helped Rowan and Neil move from rivalry to romance, gives their relationship a shared origin in playful competition. Neil later adapts its scavenger-hunt form for a New York challenge and, most importantly, for a Boston reunion. The clues turn difficult disclosures into a sequence of places and conversations, allowing him to speak about his father, his academic uncertainty, and his regret. The device makes their history useful without suggesting that repeating the past can solve the present.
Letters from Neil's father
The past breaks its silenceLetters from Lyle reach Neil during college, first at home and later at NYU. Their casual, affectionate presentation conflicts with the painful family history Neil has tried to contain. Rather than immediately answering, Neil hides the letters and grows more isolated, fearing that disclosure will make Rowan responsible for his distress. Their arrival gives his depression a concrete pressure point and eventually prompts him to visit his father, state his boundaries, and seek a fuller understanding of his own history.
Everett's writing exercises
Permission to write imperfectlyProfessor Everett's freewrites, personal narratives, and genre exercises expose Rowan's belief that every piece must arrive already polished. Her critical notes initially feel like evidence that Rowan does not belong, but classroom conversations and a potluck reveal that the assignments are designed to encourage exploration, not reward instant perfection. Advice to draft badly gives Rowan a practical way back into writing. The exercises also link her artistic development to the novel's larger interest in honesty: she must risk putting unfinished feelings on the page before she can understand them.
Psychology and family history
Questions without simple answersNeil's psychology courses begin as a science requirement but become personally urgent when he studies moral development and later encounters research on genetics and mental illness. The material encourages him to wonder whether his father's moods could be inherited, a fear that makes his own fatigue and withdrawal more alarming. Psychology does not supply a diagnosis or excuse past harm. Instead, the coursework gives Neil a vocabulary for questions he has spent years avoiding and helps lead him toward therapy and a possible change of academic direction.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.