Key Takeaways
Stop remodeling people; understand the temperament beneath their habits.
Start with the raw material. Littauer argues that people bring different inborn tendencies to life, so advice that transforms one person may fail another. Her four-part model names the types Popular Sanguine, the sociable enthusiast; Perfect Melancholy, the analytical planner; Powerful Choleric, the decisive achiever; and Peaceful Phlegmatic, the calm accommodator. Most people, she says, combine traits rather than fitting one type completely.
Difference is not defect. In her marriage, Littauer wanted her orderly husband to loosen up, while he tried to make her more organized. Even a disagreement about how to eat grapes became a miniature campaign to correct each other. Learning their temperaments helped them see that different preferences did not automatically mean one partner was wrong.
The book’s strongest move is shifting attention from moral judgment to patterns: a missed detail might reflect a habit of spontaneity, not disrespect. That reframing can reduce needless conflict and make requests more precise. Contemporary personality science also treats traits as dimensions that vary by degree, rather than sealed categories. The four types are therefore most useful as conversation starters, not as diagnoses or explanations for every action. A label should prompt curiosity about the individual, not replace it.
Build on the strength your temperament supplies naturally.
Four useful contributions. Littauer gives each type a role. Popular Sanguines enliven groups, make connections, and generate ideas. Perfect Melancholies notice details, think deeply, and value craft. Powerful Cholerics make decisions, organize work, and act under pressure. Peaceful Phlegmatics stay steady, listen, and mediate disputes. The point is not that every person in a type excels at every listed skill, but that these tendencies can help people recognize what comes more readily to them.
Strengths need a place. Littauer describes a decisive woman who organized stranded airline passengers into car groups when their flight was delayed. Her initiative turned a confused crowd toward a practical option. A team can use the same principle: place the idea-maker, detail-checker, decision-maker, and steady mediator where their contributions are useful.
This is a useful antidote to the assumption that leadership means one recognizable style. Groups need both momentum and error-checking, as well as people who keep cooperation intact. Organizational research often distinguishes task-focused contributions from relationship-focused ones, and effective teams need both. Still, assigning jobs by type alone risks stereotyping: a quiet person may be an excellent presenter, while an energetic one may be meticulous. Treat the profile as a hypothesis to test against demonstrated skill and preference.
Treat an overused strength as a weakness asking for adjustment.
Good traits have tipping points. Littauer’s central self-improvement principle is that a useful quality can become costly when pushed too far. Sociability can become monopolizing conversation; careful analysis can slide into brooding and criticism; decisiveness can turn into control; and accommodation can become passivity. The trait itself is not the whole problem. Its impact depends on degree and on how it affects other people.
Choose a small correction. Littauer advises the talkative person to cut back, the perfectionist to accept work that is good enough, the controller to relax and hear other views, and the avoider to make decisions and follow through. These are not personality makeovers. They are targeted adjustments that preserve a strength while limiting its collateral damage.
This principle resembles the idea of a behavioral strength used to excess: the same assertiveness that helps someone act in a crisis can silence colleagues in a routine meeting. That makes the book more constructive than a simple list of good and bad traits. The key question is not whether a characteristic is positive in the abstract, but whether it fits the setting and serves the relationship. Context matters, and other people’s honest feedback can reveal when a strength has crossed its tipping point.
Match the remedy to the habit, not to a generic ideal.
Use type-specific tools. Littauer’s advice starts with the problem rather than a demand to become someone else. A Popular Sanguine who forgets names can concentrate when introduced and write down useful details. A Perfect Melancholy who stalls over a project can begin before every condition is ideal. A Powerful Choleric can practice listening, apologizing, and leaving room for rest. A Peaceful Phlegmatic can make a choice, say no when needed, and communicate before resentment hardens.
Make change observable. Littauer’s own examples show how a small behavior can expose a larger pattern: she learned that a story could be shortened, while her husband learned that not every household preference needed correction. A practical plan names one behavior to change and a visible action to try, rather than relying on a vague promise to improve.
The method anticipates a sound principle from behavior change: a broad intention is difficult to act on, while a specific response can be practiced and noticed. It also respects differences in what makes change hard. Someone who avoids decisions needs a different intervention from someone who over-controls them. The caution is that type-based prescriptions can become rigid. The most effective adjustment is the one that addresses the person’s actual pattern, whether or not the label predicts it.
Interpret a partner’s difference before treating it as an insult.
Opposites can misread each other. Littauer recounts a couple whose differences turned ordinary routines into evidence of bad intent. She liked spontaneity; her husband preferred plans. He quietly fixed small household details, expecting her to notice, while she did not realize he saw them as problems. Their silence let irritation accumulate until minor disagreements carried the weight of larger grievances.
Explain before resentment grows. Littauer recommends making preferences explicit, deciding which issues matter, and accepting that a partner may not share the same standards. Her example of a husband buying a separate toothpaste tube rather than policing how his wife squeezed hers illustrates a practical compromise: protect the relationship by letting harmless differences remain different.
This is a useful account of attribution error, the tendency to interpret another person’s behavior as a statement about character or intent. A late arrival may mean carelessness, but it may also reflect a different sense of time; the explanation does not erase the inconvenience, but it changes the conversation from accusation to problem-solving. The model is especially helpful when paired with direct communication. Assuming benign intent is generous; checking what actually happened is more reliable.
Pair contrasting talents without turning colleagues into caricatures.
Let strengths complement. Littauer distinguishes natural blends, complementary blends, and opposite blends. For instance, she sees the analytical Perfect Melancholy as able to add structure to a Popular Sanguine’s ideas, while the Sanguine can bring warmth and animation to a more reserved partner. In work, a planner and an improviser may help each other produce something both sound and engaging.
Coordinate, do not correct. A committee that contains only enthusiastic starters may overlook cost and timing; one dominated by meticulous planners may never begin. Littauer’s model encourages people to value contributions they do not naturally provide themselves. The useful question is not which temperament is best, but what the task needs and who can supply it.
The complementary-strength idea has a close parallel in cognitive diversity: people who notice different risks and opportunities can improve a group’s range of options. But difference only helps when people can exchange information and share authority. Otherwise, the detail-checker becomes the brake, the idea-generator becomes the distraction, and each person’s contribution is caricatured. Role clarity and mutual respect matter more than a tidy match between labels.
Ask for candid feedback, then turn it into one concrete practice.
Make self-knowledge accountable. Littauer proposes a practical sequence: identify three strengths, name three weaknesses, ask trusted people what needs work, and choose specific steps for improvement. She stresses that asking for feedback means listening without immediately defending or counterattacking. A person who talks over others might deliberately leave pauses; a person who avoids decisions might take responsibility for one choice each day.
Use a tool, not a verdict. Her forty-question Personality Profile asks readers to select the words that most often describe them, then score the four types. Littauer presents it as a quick self-examination, not a claim that anyone is entirely one type. The results are most useful when they open an honest conversation about habits and relationships.
The feedback process is valuable because self-perception is often incomplete, especially when a behavior feels normal to the person displaying it. Asking several trusted people can reveal a pattern that one strained relationship might distort. The profile itself should be treated cautiously: the text offers no validation data, and its forced-choice format cannot capture every context or change over time. Pairing the score with examples and other people’s observations makes it more informative than treating a number as a fact about identity.
Consider whether a personality pattern is nature, coping, or both.
A label may hide a history. Littauer suggests that some apparently mixed temperaments can reflect what she calls Masks of Survival: behaviors learned in response to painful or unstable childhood circumstances. A child may become unusually compliant, controlling, perfectionistic, or entertaining to cope with family pressures. The book presents these patterns as possible explanations, not as a claim that every mixed profile comes from trauma.
Look for the story behind the score. If a trait feels extreme or confusing, Littauer encourages readers to reflect on childhood experience and consider whether an old response still shapes adult behavior. Her broader point is that temperament descriptions should help people understand themselves, not trap them in a fixed identity or excuse harmful conduct.
The distinction between a disposition and an adaptation is important: behavior can be shaped by both individual tendencies and the demands of an environment. Modern developmental thinking likewise treats personality as influenced by experience, not simply fixed at birth. The book’s survival-mask idea should be approached as a prompt for reflection, not a clinical explanation. Distress, trauma, and mood disorders cannot be reliably inferred from a temperament score, and may call for qualified professional support.
Use your personality as a starting point, not an excuse or ceiling.
Growth needs more than labels. Littauer closes by connecting self-improvement to Christian faith. She argues that people should recognize their gifts, admit their weaknesses, and seek spiritual strength to change rather than trying to copy someone else. Her own account describes her and her husband searching for answers after the loss of two sons, then finding direction in Christian belief and in the idea that different people can serve distinct roles.
Keep responsibility personal. The practical message is to work on one’s own conduct instead of treating a partner as a renovation project. In Littauer’s Christian framework, personality is part of a person’s potential, while spiritual commitment supplies purpose and power for growth. Readers outside that faith tradition can still take the self-examination and responsibility while understanding the book’s religious foundation.
The conclusion gives the book a moral center: self-acceptance is not resignation, and self-improvement is not imitation. Its Christian account of change is meaningful within the author’s worldview, while readers from other traditions may ground the same work in different commitments or communities. The distinction between accepting a temperament and excusing behavior remains crucial. A person may have a natural tendency to interrupt or withdraw, but the effect on others still matters, and responsibility includes choosing what to do next.
Analysis
Personality Plus is a practical, anecdotal guide organized around four temperaments and the relationships among them. Its great strength is not the precision of its classification system, but the change in posture it encourages: instead of assuming that a different preference is evidence of bad character, readers are asked to notice patterns, name their own weaknesses, and adjust how they work with others. Littauer makes that invitation memorable through domestic comedy. The recurring disputes over schedules, grapes, household order, and conversation show how intimacy can turn small preferences into tests of respect when people silently expect one another to operate by the same rules.
The book also resists a purely celebratory view of personality. Each temperament’s assets have costs when overused, and the author repeatedly asks readers to take responsibility rather than blame their partners. Her advice is most practical when it becomes a specific behavior: shorten a story, write down a name, listen before directing, or make a decision instead of postponing it. This makes the book more actionable than a simple personality quiz.
Its limitations matter. The text presents a four-type framework rooted in an old temperament tradition, but it does not provide evidence that its test is a validated psychological measure. Its broad descriptions can feel insightful while also encouraging confirmation bias: readers may remember the examples that fit and overlook the ones that do not. The language can also overgeneralize, particularly when describing types as naturally lazy, gloomy, or self-centered. Those claims work better as comic prompts for self-examination than as reliable judgments about individuals.
The soundest use of the book is therefore modest and relational. Treat its categories as shorthand for questions, not answers. Ask what a person tends to notice, avoid, contribute, or need. Check the impression against actual behavior, context, and the person’s own account. Used that way, the framework offers a lively vocabulary for difference and a reminder that understanding another person is more useful than trying to recast them in one’s own image.
Review Summary
Personality Plus receives mixed reviews. Many readers find it insightful for understanding themselves and others, praising its humor and practical applications. Some consider it life-changing, while others criticize it as pseudoscience or overly simplistic. The four personality types are seen as helpful by some but limiting by others. Readers appreciate the self-assessment test and real-life examples, though some find them exaggerated. Overall, the book is valued for its potential to improve relationships and self-awareness, despite its limitations.
People Also Read
Glossary
Popular Sanguine
sociable, expressive typeOne of Littauer’s four temperament categories. The Popular Sanguine is described as outgoing, enthusiastic, talkative, and drawn to people, novelty, and performance. Its strengths include friendliness, humor, and idea generation. Its common difficulties include disorganization, forgetfulness, interrupting, exaggeration, and poor follow-through.
Perfect Melancholy
analytical, detail-focused typeOne of Littauer’s four temperament categories. The Perfect Melancholy is described as thoughtful, serious, sensitive, orderly, and attentive to detail. Its strengths include analysis, creativity, compassion, and high standards. Its common difficulties include pessimism, low self-confidence, perfectionism, procrastination, and taking offense easily.
Powerful Choleric
decisive, goal-driven typeOne of Littauer’s four temperament categories. The Powerful Choleric is described as assertive, decisive, practical, and oriented toward leadership and results. Its strengths include initiative, organization, and action under pressure. Its common difficulties include impatience, bossiness, controlling behavior, poor listening, and reluctance to admit fault.
Peaceful Phlegmatic
calm, accommodating typeOne of Littauer’s four temperament categories. The Peaceful Phlegmatic is described as patient, low-key, adaptable, and easy to get along with. Its strengths include listening, mediation, steadiness, and administrative ability. Its common difficulties include indecision, procrastination, low enthusiasm, avoidance of conflict, and resistance to change.
Personality Profile
forty-question temperament inventoryLittauer’s self-assessment tool asks readers to choose one descriptive word from each of forty rows, then tally the answers across the four temperament categories. It is intended to identify a dominant pattern and secondary traits, not to declare a person entirely one type. The book provides no validation statistics for the inventory.
Natural Blends
similar temperaments combinedLittauer’s term for combinations she sees as sharing basic tendencies: Popular Sanguine with Powerful Choleric, and Perfect Melancholy with Peaceful Phlegmatic. She suggests that shared qualities can make these combinations feel internally consistent, while their component temperaments can still balance one another’s excesses.
Complementary Blends
temperaments that fill gapsLittauer’s term for combinations whose traits can offset one another. She identifies Powerful Choleric with Perfect Melancholy, and Popular Sanguine with Peaceful Phlegmatic. In her account, one partner’s drive or organization may complement the other’s analytical, social, or stabilizing tendencies, though each combination also carries potential conflicts.
Opposites
contrasting temperament combinationsLittauer uses this term for Popular Sanguine with Perfect Melancholy, and Powerful Choleric with Peaceful Phlegmatic. These pairings bring together contrasting tendencies, such as spontaneity and planning or control and ease. The framework highlights both attraction between unlike traits and the misunderstandings that can arise when differences are interpreted as personal rejection.
Masks of Survival
learned coping patternsLittauer’s term for behavior patterns she believes some people adopt in response to painful childhood circumstances. A person may appear to show traits unlike their underlying temperament because those behaviors helped them cope with rejection, abuse, family conflict, or pressure. The book presents this as a possible explanation for some mixed profiles, not a clinical diagnosis.
FAQ
What's "Personality Plus" by Florence Littauer about?
- Understanding Personalities: "Personality Plus" is a guide to understanding the four basic personality types: Popular Sanguine, Perfect Melancholy, Powerful Choleric, and Peaceful Phlegmatic.
- Self-Examination: The book provides a method for self-examination to help readers identify their own personality type and understand their strengths and weaknesses.
- Improving Relationships: It offers insights into how different personality types interact and how to improve relationships by understanding these dynamics.
- Personal Growth: The book encourages personal growth by helping readers recognize and overcome their weaknesses while amplifying their strengths.
Why should I read "Personality Plus"?
- Self-Discovery: It helps you discover your own personality type and understand why you behave the way you do.
- Relationship Enhancement: By understanding different personality types, you can improve your relationships with family, friends, and colleagues.
- Personal Development: The book provides practical advice on how to overcome personal weaknesses and enhance your strengths.
- Spiritual Insight: It integrates spiritual principles, offering a holistic approach to personal growth and self-improvement.
What are the key takeaways of "Personality Plus"?
- Four Personality Types: The book identifies four main personality types, each with unique strengths and weaknesses.
- Self-Improvement: It emphasizes the importance of recognizing and working on personal weaknesses to achieve personal growth.
- Interpersonal Skills: Understanding different personalities can improve communication and relationships with others.
- Spiritual Connection: The book suggests that spiritual growth can enhance personal development and interpersonal relationships.
How does the Personality Profile method work in "Personality Plus"?
- Self-Assessment: The Personality Profile is a self-assessment tool that helps you identify your dominant personality type.
- Scoring System: It involves answering a series of questions and scoring your responses to determine your personality blend.
- Understanding Traits: The profile helps you understand your strengths and weaknesses based on your personality type.
- Guidance for Improvement: It provides a foundation for personal growth by highlighting areas for improvement.
What are the characteristics of a Popular Sanguine personality according to "Personality Plus"?
- Extroverted and Talkative: Popular Sanguines are lively, talkative, and enjoy being the center of attention.
- Optimistic and Enthusiastic: They have a positive outlook on life and are often seen as cheerful and fun-loving.
- Creative and Spontaneous: They are imaginative and enjoy new experiences, often acting on impulse.
- Challenges: They may struggle with follow-through and can be disorganized or forgetful.
What defines a Perfect Melancholy personality in "Personality Plus"?
- Introverted and Thoughtful: Perfect Melancholies are deep thinkers who prefer solitude and reflection.
- Detail-Oriented and Organized: They are meticulous and value order, often excelling in tasks that require precision.
- Sensitive and Compassionate: They are empathetic and care deeply about others' feelings.
- Challenges: They can be prone to depression and may have high standards that are difficult to meet.
How is a Powerful Choleric personality described in "Personality Plus"?
- Natural Leader: Powerful Cholerics are decisive and thrive in leadership roles, often taking charge in situations.
- Goal-Oriented and Determined: They are driven to achieve their objectives and are not easily deterred by obstacles.
- Confident and Assertive: They have strong opinions and are not afraid to express them.
- Challenges: They may come across as bossy or impatient and can struggle with being overly controlling.
What are the traits of a Peaceful Phlegmatic personality in "Personality Plus"?
- Calm and Easygoing: Peaceful Phlegmatics are relaxed and avoid conflict, often acting as mediators.
- Patient and Well-Balanced: They are steady and reliable, providing stability in relationships and situations.
- Good Listeners: They are attentive and empathetic, making them great friends and confidants.
- Challenges: They may lack motivation and can be indecisive or resistant to change.
How can understanding personality types improve relationships according to "Personality Plus"?
- Enhanced Communication: Knowing personality types helps tailor communication styles to better connect with others.
- Conflict Resolution: Understanding differences can prevent misunderstandings and reduce conflicts.
- Appreciation of Strengths: Recognizing each type's strengths fosters appreciation and respect in relationships.
- Personalized Interaction: It allows for more personalized and effective interactions, improving overall relationship dynamics.
What are some practical tips for overcoming weaknesses in "Personality Plus"?
- Self-Awareness: Acknowledge and accept your weaknesses as the first step toward improvement.
- Set Realistic Goals: Create achievable goals to work on specific weaknesses gradually.
- Seek Feedback: Encourage honest feedback from others to gain different perspectives on your behavior.
- Spiritual Growth: Incorporate spiritual practices to support personal development and overcome challenges.
What are the best quotes from "Personality Plus" and what do they mean?
- "When we know who we are and why we act the way we do, we can begin to understand our inner selves, improve our personalities, and learn to get along with others." This quote emphasizes the importance of self-awareness in personal growth and relationship building.
- "Positives carried to extremes become negatives." It highlights the idea that strengths can become weaknesses if not balanced properly.
- "Each one of us is unique." This quote underscores the book's message that everyone has a distinct personality blend, which should be embraced and understood.
- "We are not going to try to imitate someone else." It encourages readers to focus on their own strengths and weaknesses rather than comparing themselves to others.
How does "Personality Plus" integrate spiritual principles into personal development?
- Spiritual Energy: The book suggests that spiritual growth can provide the energy needed for personal transformation.
- Biblical References: It uses biblical teachings to support the idea of self-improvement and understanding others.
- Holistic Approach: By combining personality insights with spiritual growth, the book offers a comprehensive approach to personal development.
- Encouragement of Faith: It encourages readers to rely on their faith as a source of strength and guidance in overcoming weaknesses.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.