Key Takeaways
Build lasting characters from shared human passions, not period fashion.
Common passions endure. Johnson’s central claim is that Shakespeare lasts because his characters respond to motives people recognize across eras: desire, fear, jealousy, ambition, affection, and self-deception. Shakespeare’s people are not merely specimens of a particular job or country. They reveal recurring patterns of human conduct, while remaining distinct enough that their speeches and actions belong to them rather than to interchangeable figures.
Life supplies the test. Johnson points to Othello’s trusting nature, Iago’s calculated malice, and Desdemona’s confidence in her innocence. Their circumstances are specific, but their emotional logic remains legible. The plays’ wisdom, he argues, emerges through unfolding action and conversation, not just through memorable lines lifted out of context.
What's compelling is the distinction between a character’s social costume and the motives underneath it. That idea resembles a useful principle in psychology: people recognize emotional patterns more readily than unfamiliar customs. Yet claims of universal human nature need care. What looks timeless may reflect the values of the culture doing the judging. Shakespeare’s durability can therefore support Johnson’s argument without proving that his characters represent every society equally.
Use centuries of rereading as evidence of merit, not proof.
Time tests reputation. Johnson rejects the idea that old books deserve automatic reverence. Age may preserve a work through chance, prejudice, or habit. But for art, where no scientific formula can measure excellence, continued admiration matters: generations have encountered the work, compared it with alternatives, and kept finding pleasure in it.
Shakespeare survives changing tastes. By Johnson’s account, the plays had outlasted the personal rivalries, local references, and temporary controversies that might once have boosted their reception. They were still read for the pleasure they gave. Johnson treats this endurance as persuasive evidence, not an infallible verdict. The distinction matters: a long life invites serious attention, but age alone cannot certify greatness.
Johnson offers an early account of collective evaluation: durable reputation is the result of many readers testing a work under changing conditions. That is stronger than simply trusting an authority’s praise. Still, cultural survival is not a neutral contest. Schools, theatres, publishers, and inherited prestige influence which works keep being read and which are forgotten. Johnson’s method is most convincing when duration is treated as a reason to investigate, rather than a substitute for judgment.
Let comedy and grief share a stage, as they share life.
Life refuses clean genres. Johnson defends Shakespeare’s habit of mixing comic and serious scenes. Actual life contains mourning beside celebration, private foolishness alongside political crisis, and consequences no one intended. A drama that separates laughter from sorrow may obey a tidy rule while presenting a less familiar world.
Variety can sharpen feeling. Johnson concedes that a joke may interrupt sorrow, but argues that one audience’s relief may be another’s welcome change of mood. Alternating tones can also make the serious moments feel more like parts of a lived world than exercises in uninterrupted anguish. Shakespeare’s plays are not simply tragedies or comedies by strict definition; their endings and scenes do not always fit those categories neatly.
This defense anticipates a modern understanding of emotional life as mixed rather than neatly sequenced. Humor can coexist with grief without making grief unreal, and tonal contrast can keep an audience attentive. Johnson’s case is strongest when variety serves the action or reveals character. It is weaker as a blanket defense: a poorly placed comic scene can still dissolve tension. The useful question is not whether genres may mix, but whether each shift changes what the audience understands or feels.
Break stage rules when they shrink the audience's imaginative freedom.
A play is not mistaken reality. Critics defended rules limiting a drama to one place and roughly one day because audiences supposedly could not believe rapid changes of location or long stretches of time. Johnson counters that spectators know they are watching actors on a stage. They accept the setting as an imaginative convention, so a scene can move from one city to another, or years can pass between acts, without requiring literal belief.
Keep the action coherent. Johnson sees unity of action as more important: events should connect, develop, and bring the play to a meaningful conclusion. He does not claim that time and place rules never help. They may create pleasure, but should not outrank variety, instruction, or a clear progression of events.
Johnson’s argument rests on a subtle distinction between believing a story is fact and understanding what it asks the imagination to represent. That distinction remains central to fiction: audiences can know a scene is invented and still respond emotionally to its human implications. The argument does not make every convention useless. Constraints can focus attention, but they are tools rather than laws. A rule earns its place when it improves the dramatic experience, not merely because critics inherited it.
Admire Shakespeare without laundering his moral and dramatic failures.
Praise need not excuse. Johnson admires Shakespeare’s range while identifying serious weaknesses. He faults him for letting convenience outweigh moral instruction, for plots that sometimes feel loosely assembled, and for endings that seem hurried or improbable. He also objects to historical confusion, coarse comic exchanges, inflated narration, and wordplay that can puncture a moment meant to move the audience.
The weaknesses vary by mode. Johnson finds Shakespeare’s comedy more effortless than his tragedy. Comic scenes often seem instinctive, while tragic passages can feel labored, with powerful moments of spontaneous feeling followed by speeches that sound forced. A pun can also derail an emotionally serious scene. These judgments do not erase the plays’ strengths. They establish that excellence can coexist with conspicuous defects.
Johnson models a kind of criticism that resists both demolition and worship. That balance is valuable because admiration can make readers reinterpret every flaw as intentional brilliance. His more specific judgments also invite disagreement: what one audience finds coarse, another may find socially revealing, and what seems a weak ending may express a deliberately harsh view of life. The key is to keep evaluation answerable to evidence in the play rather than to reverence for its author.
Treat genius as trained observation, not magic untouched by circumstance.
Talent needs material. Johnson resists the legend that Shakespeare’s gifts appeared without learning or effort. He thinks Shakespeare had limited access to classical languages, but stresses that English translations, histories, stories, and other reading supplied substantial material. The plays often adapt familiar plots rather than inventing every story from nothing.
Observation made the difference. Johnson credits Shakespeare’s close attention to people and the physical world. At a time when English drama offered few models for convincing characters and dialogue, Shakespeare developed both by watching life and reshaping what he saw. He also wrote for an audience drawn to striking events and stage spectacle. His originality lay not in isolation from his age, but in transforming its available stories and observations into unusually vivid drama.
This account replaces the myth of effortless genius with a more useful model: talent notices, selects, and recombines material that experience and study make available. It also takes the audience seriously. Artistic form develops in response to what spectators can follow and enjoy, not in a vacuum. Johnson may overstate the limits of Shakespeare’s education because the evidence available to him was incomplete. His larger point still holds: originality does not require creating from nothing.
Judge a character by its contradictions, not a single trait.
People exceed labels. Johnson’s Prince Hal is both a pleasure-seeking young man and a capable leader whose better qualities emerge under pressure. Falstaff is dishonest, cowardly, and exploitative, yet his comic energy makes him difficult to dismiss. Johnson sees a warning in this combination: charm can make corrupt influence easier to tolerate.
Small inconsistencies matter. In Hamlet, Polonius can offer sensible general observations but lose the thread when he must apply them. Johnson reads this as a believable portrait of an aging courtier whose confidence outlasts his sharper judgment. In Othello, he contrasts Iago’s careful manipulation with Othello’s openness and credulity. These characters feel convincing because their qualities interact, sometimes producing behavior that surprises even them.
Johnson’s character criticism treats personality as a pattern of competing tendencies, not a checklist of virtues and vices. That is close to how people are understood in everyday life: a person may be generous in one relationship and self-serving in another. Falstaff also illustrates a social risk, since entertainment can lower suspicion. The caution is not to assume that charm signals corruption. Johnson’s sharper point is that pleasure can distract from evaluating what a companion encourages.
Do not demand that every tragedy reward virtue with survival.
Justice and probability differ. Johnson accepts that tragedy may show good people suffering because that resembles ordinary events. Yet he is deeply troubled by Cordelia’s death in King Lear. He reports that audiences preferred an adapted ending in which Cordelia survives and triumphs, suggesting that emotional resistance to injustice can shape what spectators accept as satisfying.
Shakespeare’s endings can strain his morals. In Measure for Measure, Isabella argues for mercy toward Angelo despite his serious abuses, a plea Johnson finds difficult to justify. These cases expose a tension in the plays: they can portray the world’s unfairness while leaving readers dissatisfied with the particular distribution of punishment and mercy. Johnson does not treat realism as an automatic defense of every ending.
Johnson distinguishes two standards that are often confused: whether an ending resembles life, and whether it satisfies a moral expectation. A tragedy can be plausible yet feel intolerable, as his reaction to Cordelia’s fate makes clear. The audience’s preference for a repaired ending is informative, though it does not settle the artistic question. Comfort can weaken a tragedy’s force, while relentless injustice can feel manipulative. Good criticism asks what each ending makes visible, not merely whether it feels fair.
Edit damaged texts by preserving uncertainty, not polishing away difficulty.
The text has a history. Johnson explains that Shakespeare’s plays passed through imperfect copying, theatrical alteration, and printing without reliable authorial correction. Editors inherited passages that could be genuinely corrupted or simply unfamiliar. Changing a puzzling line may improve its apparent clarity while replacing Shakespeare’s wording with an editor’s guess.
Conjecture needs restraint. Johnson compares old editions, considers context, and favors the least disruptive explanation. He becomes more cautious about inserting his own proposed readings into the text as he sees how easily confident editors can be wrong. A suggested correction belongs in a note when it remains uncertain. His editorial ideal is not to avoid every intervention, but to distinguish evidence from speculation and preserve what readers may still interpret.
Johnson’s method resembles a sound practice in historical research: preserve the record, show where inference begins, and avoid confusing a plausible reconstruction with a verified fact. The restraint is especially apt when the original author cannot confirm a reading. Yet leaving a corrupted passage untouched also carries a cost, since readers may mistake damage for deliberate obscurity. His approach works best as transparent uncertainty: explain the problem, present evidence, and make the degree of confidence visible.
Read the play whole before letting footnotes interrupt its force.
Experience the design first. Johnson warns that annotations can clarify a phrase while weakening a play’s overall effect. Looking up each allusion or stopping at every textual puzzle breaks the reader’s attention and makes it harder to perceive how scenes build toward an ending. He recommends reading straight through first, accepting that some lines may remain obscure.
Return with sharper questions. After the plot and characters are familiar, notes can explain old words, customs, and textual problems. Johnson’s own comments demonstrate why this second pass is useful: he praises the concentrated action of King Lear, admires the characterization in Othello and Henry IV, and also identifies improbabilities, strained lines, and unresolved moral choices. Understanding the whole helps readers judge whether a disputed detail matters.
The advice reflects a distinction between immersion and analysis. Close attention is valuable, but attention has a cost: constant interruption can prevent a reader from holding a long structure in mind. The same principle applies to music, film, and other arts that unfold over time. A first encounter should preserve momentum; a second can examine technique. The caveat is practical: readers with language or access barriers may need notes immediately. The sequence is a helpful default, not a rule for everyone.
Analysis
Johnson’s Preface is both an argument about Shakespeare and a demonstration of how criticism should work. Its core claim is that lasting art represents recognizable human motives rather than relying on topical fashions or theatrical formulas. From there, Johnson judges the plays by their effects on readers and audiences: their characters feel credible, their action holds attention, and their mixed tones resemble the unevenness of life. His defense of Shakespeare is not an attempt to make the poet flawless. The catalogue of weak plots, moral carelessness, anachronisms, bombast, and intrusive wordplay gives the praise credibility, while revealing that Johnson’s own standards include both natural representation and moral responsibility.
The most productive tension is between realism and theatrical convention. Johnson argues that audiences never literally believe a stage is Rome or that actors are historical figures. They respond instead to the human possibility represented. This allows him to defend changes of time and place while insisting that dramatic action remain intelligible. His reasoning anticipates a distinction between factual belief and emotional engagement, but it does not settle when convention helps or harms. A formal restriction can limit scope, yet also intensify attention. Johnson’s standard is functional: rules matter when they improve the experience, not because authority has declared them sacred.
The editorial discussion extends the same skepticism to the text itself. Shakespeare’s words arrive through fallible transmission, and editors can mistake their own preference for restoration. Johnson’s caution is therefore more than a technical policy. It is an ethical stance toward evidence: preserve what is uncertain, identify conjecture, and admit when explanation fails. His advice to read the entire play before consulting notes follows naturally. Interpretation should begin with the work’s movement, then examine its parts without losing sight of the whole. The Preface remains useful because it combines conviction with provisional judgment: Shakespeare deserves close study, but neither fame nor scholarship removes the need to question what seems obvious.
Review Summary
Preface to Shakespeare receives mixed reviews, with ratings ranging from 1 to 5 stars. Many readers appreciate Johnson's insightful critique of Shakespeare's works, praising his balanced approach and eloquent writing style. Some find the preface challenging to read due to its 18th-century language and academic nature. Critics commend Johnson's analysis of Shakespeare's characters, themes, and literary techniques. However, a few readers express disappointment, finding the content dry or difficult to engage with. Overall, the preface is considered a significant work of literary criticism, offering valuable perspectives on Shakespeare's genius and flaws.
People Also Read
Glossary
general nature
shared human motivesJohnson’s term for recurring passions and principles that shape people across different places, occupations, and historical periods. Shakespeare’s characters endure, in Johnson’s account, because their motives remain recognizable beyond the customs that surround them. The term does not mean that every character is alike; it describes the common human patterns that make distinct characters broadly intelligible.
mixed drama
comedy and tragedy togetherJohnson’s description of Shakespeare’s plays as works that combine comic and serious characters, scenes, and effects. Rather than following the strict separation of comedy and tragedy, these plays reflect a world where joy and suffering coexist. Their shifts in tone can interrupt one audience’s emotion while relieving or engaging another.
unity of action
connected dramatic eventsThe principle that a play’s events should form a coherent progression, with a beginning, development, and conclusion. Johnson treats this as more important than keeping the entire drama in one place or within a short period. Episodes may vary, but the main design should guide expectation toward an intelligible ending.
unities of time and place
limits on dramatic settingCritical rules that restrict a play’s action to a short span of time and a single location. Their defenders believed these limits helped audiences find a drama credible. Johnson argues that spectators know the stage is an imitation, so they can imagine different places and longer periods without mistaking the performance for literal reality.
conjectural criticism
editorial repair by inferenceThe practice of proposing a reading for a damaged or confusing passage when surviving copies do not provide a reliable answer. Johnson sees it as sometimes necessary but especially vulnerable to overconfidence: an editor may replace an unfamiliar original with a smoother invention. He favors comparing available copies and making the least disruptive change.
poetical justice
virtue rewarded, vice punishedThe expectation that a literary ending should distribute outcomes according to moral deserts, rewarding virtuous characters and punishing the wicked. Johnson recognizes that real life does not always follow this pattern, so tragedy may plausibly deny it. He also observes that audiences can find such endings emotionally painful or unsatisfying, as in Cordelia’s death in King Lear.
FAQ
1. What is "Preface to Shakespeare" by Samuel Johnson about?
- Critical Introduction to Shakespeare: The "Preface to Shakespeare" is Samuel Johnson’s influential essay introducing his annotated edition of Shakespeare’s plays, first published in 1765.
- Evaluation of Shakespeare’s Merits and Faults: Johnson analyzes Shakespeare’s strengths and weaknesses as a dramatist, discussing his characters, plots, language, and adherence to dramatic rules.
- Historical and Editorial Context: The preface also surveys the state of Shakespearean scholarship and editing up to Johnson’s time, critiquing previous editors and explaining Johnson’s own editorial approach.
- Reflection on Literary Criticism: Johnson uses Shakespeare as a case study to reflect on broader issues in literary criticism, such as the value of tradition, the role of nature in art, and the limits of critical rules.
2. Why should I read "Preface to Shakespeare" by Samuel Johnson?
- Foundational Literary Criticism: Johnson’s preface is a cornerstone of English literary criticism, shaping how generations have read and understood Shakespeare.
- Insight into Shakespeare’s Genius: The essay offers a balanced, nuanced appreciation of Shakespeare’s artistry, making it valuable for students, scholars, and general readers.
- Historical Perspective: It provides a window into 18th-century attitudes toward literature, drama, and the process of editing classic texts.
- Model of Critical Thinking: Johnson’s method—fair, candid, and reasoned—serves as a model for how to approach literary analysis and criticism.
3. What are the key takeaways from "Preface to Shakespeare" by Samuel Johnson?
- Shakespeare as Poet of Nature: Johnson argues that Shakespeare’s enduring appeal lies in his faithful representation of universal human nature, not just the customs of his own time.
- Strengths and Weaknesses: While praising Shakespeare’s characters, dialogue, and dramatic variety, Johnson also points out his faults, such as loose plotting, lack of moral purpose, and occasional obscurity.
- Rules vs. Genius: Johnson contends that strict adherence to classical unities (time, place, action) is less important than capturing the variety and complexity of real life.
- Editorial Challenges: The preface discusses the difficulties of editing Shakespeare’s texts, given their transmission history and the errors of previous editors.
4. How does Samuel Johnson define Shakespeare’s greatness in "Preface to Shakespeare"?
- Mirror of Life: Johnson calls Shakespeare “the poet of nature,” emphasizing his ability to depict characters and situations that resonate across ages and cultures.
- Universal Characters: He notes that Shakespeare’s characters are not mere individuals but types representing general human passions and principles.
- Dialogue and Realism: Johnson praises Shakespeare’s dialogue for its naturalness and adaptability to real-life situations, contrasting it with the artificiality of other dramatists.
- Variety and Instruction: Shakespeare’s plays, according to Johnson, offer both entertainment and practical wisdom, blending comedy and tragedy to reflect the mixed nature of human experience.
5. What criticisms does Samuel Johnson make of Shakespeare in "Preface to Shakespeare"?
- Loose Plot Construction: Johnson observes that Shakespeare’s plots are often carelessly formed and sometimes neglected toward the end.
- Moral Ambiguity: He criticizes Shakespeare for not always promoting virtue or punishing vice, and for lacking a clear moral purpose.
- Violations of Time and Place: Johnson notes Shakespeare’s disregard for the classical unities, giving modern customs to ancient characters and mixing different eras.
- Obscurity and Quibbles: He points out Shakespeare’s tendency toward obscure language, forced metaphors, and excessive wordplay (quibbles), sometimes at the expense of clarity and dignity.
6. How does Samuel Johnson address the issue of the classical unities in "Preface to Shakespeare"?
- Unity of Action Upheld: Johnson argues that Shakespeare generally maintains unity of action, with a clear beginning, middle, and end.
- Time and Place Unities Rejected: He dismisses the necessity of unity of time and place, claiming that audiences willingly suspend disbelief and do not mistake the stage for reality.
- Variety Over Rules: Johnson believes that the richness and variety of Shakespeare’s drama outweigh the benefits of strict adherence to classical rules.
- Imagination and Drama: He asserts that the imagination can easily accommodate shifts in time and place, making rigid unities unnecessary for dramatic credibility.
7. What is Samuel Johnson’s view on Shakespeare’s use of language and style in "Preface to Shakespeare"?
- Natural and Durable Language: Johnson praises Shakespeare’s use of a style rooted in common speech, making his works more accessible and enduring.
- Occasional Ruggedness: He acknowledges that Shakespeare’s language can sometimes be rough, obscure, or inflated, especially in narration and set speeches.
- Quibbles and Conceits: Johnson criticizes Shakespeare’s fondness for puns and wordplay, which he feels often detract from the seriousness of the drama.
- Balance of Praise and Critique: While recognizing linguistic faults, Johnson maintains that Shakespeare’s overall mastery of dialogue and expression is unmatched.
8. How does Samuel Johnson evaluate the editorial history of Shakespeare’s works in "Preface to Shakespeare"?
- Survey of Previous Editors: Johnson reviews the contributions and shortcomings of earlier editors like Rowe, Pope, Theobald, Hanmer, and Warburton.
- Textual Corruption: He details the many errors introduced by careless transcription, printing, and editing, which have obscured Shakespeare’s original text.
- Johnson’s Editorial Principles: Johnson emphasizes fidelity to the earliest texts, cautious emendation, and the importance of explanatory notes for difficult passages.
- Limits of Criticism: He warns against excessive conjecture and the temptation to “improve” Shakespeare, advocating for a balanced, respectful approach.
9. What advice does Samuel Johnson give to readers and critics of Shakespeare in "Preface to Shakespeare"?
- Read for Pleasure First: Johnson suggests that new readers should enjoy Shakespeare’s plays without being distracted by notes or commentary.
- Use Notes Judiciously: He acknowledges the value of explanatory notes but cautions that they can interrupt the flow and enjoyment of the plays.
- Critical Humility: Johnson advises critics to approach Shakespeare with candor and without dogmatic reverence, recognizing both his merits and faults.
- Context Matters: He reminds readers to consider the historical and cultural context of Shakespeare’s time when evaluating his works.
10. What are some of the most notable quotes from "Preface to Shakespeare" by Samuel Johnson, and what do they mean?
- “Shakespeare is, above all writers, at least above all modern writers, the poet of nature.”
Johnson means that Shakespeare’s genius lies in his ability to depict universal human nature, not just the peculiarities of his own era. - “His characters are not modified by the customs of particular places... they are the genuine progeny of common humanity.”
This highlights Shakespeare’s creation of characters that transcend time and place, making them relatable to all audiences. - “Nothing can please many, and please long, but just representations of general nature.”
Johnson argues that lasting literary greatness depends on truth to universal experience, not on novelty or fashion. - “He sacrifices virtue to convenience, and is so much more careful to please than to instruct, that he seems to write without any moral purpose.”
Here, Johnson criticizes Shakespeare for sometimes prioritizing entertainment over moral instruction.
11. How does Samuel Johnson’s "Preface to Shakespeare" influence later Shakespeare criticism and literary studies?
- Foundation for Modern Criticism: Johnson’s balanced approach—praising Shakespeare’s strengths while acknowledging his faults—set a precedent for later critics.
- Emphasis on Human Nature: His focus on Shakespeare’s universality and psychological insight became central themes in subsequent literary analysis.
- Editorial Standards: Johnson’s discussion of textual corruption and editorial responsibility influenced the development of scholarly editing practices.
- Debate on Dramatic Rules: His arguments against the strict classical unities encouraged greater flexibility and appreciation for dramatic variety in English literature.
12. What are some specific examples of Johnson’s critical method in his notes on Shakespeare’s plays?
- Close Reading of Passages: Johnson provides detailed commentary on difficult or ambiguous lines, offering interpretations and sometimes suggesting emendations.
- Historical and Linguistic Context: He explains archaic words, references, and customs, making the plays more accessible to modern readers.
- Balanced Judgment: In his notes, Johnson often weighs the merits of previous editors’ suggestions, accepting or rejecting them with reasoned argument.
- Moral and Psychological Insight: His comments frequently explore the motivations and moral implications of characters’ actions, as seen in his discussions of Isabella in "Measure for Measure" or Falstaff in "Henry IV."
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.