Plot Summary
The Favor at Rink B
Lucy Sinclair is a single mother, an interior designer, and the reluctant referee in a bitter co-parenting arrangement with her ex-husband, Rick. Seven-year-old Angie wants to play hockey, but Lucy is already stretched thin by work, childcare, and the fear that Rick’s anger could reach their daughter.
Her youngest brother, Jayden, promises to help get Angie ready for her first practice, then discovers his wife’s medical appointment will keep him away. He asks teammate Benji Paxton, a Nashville Assassins defenseman, to take his place. Benji has spent years sober and alone, unsure he can build a life beyond hockey and the family he lost. He agrees without hesitation, setting two guarded lives on a collision course.
The story begins with practical pressure, not romantic longing: Lucy needs to get her child to the rink, keep her business alive, and shield Angie from Rick. Jayden’s favor turns care into the plot’s first action, while Benji’s willingness to help reveals a capacity for connection that his isolation has buried. The opening also establishes the novel’s central tension around caregiving. Lucy experiences responsibility as something she must carry alone; Benji sees a chance to give care again. Hockey becomes the place where these assumptions can be tested through deeds.
A Replacement Wins Trust
At the rink, Lucy is furious that Jayden failed to warn her, and she distrusts the towering stranger he sent in his place. Benji introduces himself as an Assassins teammate and offers to gear Angie up, but Lucy first insists that a phone search can teach her how. Angie chooses Benji anyway, and his patience begins to ease her nerves.
When the first skating drills leave her frozen with fear of making mistakes, he joins the course beside her, lets her believe she has beaten him, and sends her back into the line smiling. Angie scores during the scrimmage, then begs for Benji to return. Seeing him comfort her daughter unsettles Lucy’s defenses more than his looks do.
Benji earns trust by reading Angie’s fear accurately and changing the task rather than scolding her for freezing. His playful fake loss gives her a safe way to succeed, turning reassurance into a concrete experience of competence. For Lucy, the scene complicates a protective reflex built around distrust: she cannot dismiss Benji when Angie responds to him so openly. Yet her caution is not irrational. She has learned that adults can fail children, so trust must be earned through repeated attention, not charm.
The Hug Becomes a Night
Benji asks Lucy to dinner, but she refuses, telling herself she has neither time for a relationship nor room for another man in Angie’s life. The next day, she arrives at his house for a design consultation and learns that a burst pipe has made her apartment and office unusable. As the landlord explains the damage by phone, Lucy tries to hold back tears; Benji asks no questions first, simply embracing her.
Comfort turns into a passionate night together. Lucy wakes before Benji, panics at the intimacy, and slips out with one shoe missing and her design bag behind. Her flight leaves him with her belongings and a new fear: that the happiness he felt with her may vanish before he can understand it.
The first sexual encounter grows out of Lucy’s need for shelter in an emotional sense, not merely desire. Benji offers comfort without demanding an explanation, and her body answers before her defenses can organize another refusal. Her morning escape shows the cost of that surrender: pleasure has reopened the possibility of attachment, which she associates with danger. Benji’s longing is also shaped by loss; the intimacy matters because it makes him feel whole, but that intensity risks confusing a promising beginning with certainty. Both characters must learn to stay present rather than retreat into old protections.
An Office Behind His House
Benji returns Lucy’s forgotten bag to Jayden’s house and finds her temporarily displaced after the flood has worsened; her childhood home is being renovated too. He offers the empty guesthouse behind his property as office space, and Lucy visits with her assistant, Rayne. The building is large enough for her design business, so she negotiates rent and a written contract rather than accepting an open-ended favor.
Benji agrees to a low price and lets her make the space her own. Their growing closeness becomes harder to deny: they text, FaceTime, and share time with Angie. When Benji leaves on a road trip, Lucy misses him, then follows his suggestion to attend an Assassins game and cheer for him.
The guesthouse solves an immediate material crisis while preserving Lucy’s sense of agency. She insists on paying and formalizing the arrangement, converting dependence into a negotiated business relationship. Benji’s help is meaningful precisely because he does not use it to demand intimacy; Lucy can accept it without surrendering control. The office also gives the romance a lived-in setting. Their connection now involves schedules, work, and a child, not only desire. Lucy’s willingness to miss Benji and seek him out marks a shift from guarding her life to making room within it.
The Past Between Them
During a quiet bath together, Benji tells Lucy that he became an alcoholic as a young hockey player. After drinking heavily at a family gathering, he let his seventeen-year-old brother drive; a crash killed his brother, his wife Ava, and their toddler, Leary. Benji survived, entered rehabilitation, and has stayed sober for twelve years, but still blames himself.
Lucy answers with her own history. She married Rick young, endured his mother’s hostility, and stayed after discovering his affair with Heidi, who was pregnant at the same time as Lucy. When Rick beat Lucy in front of Angie, she finally escaped to her family. Benji listens without judging, and Lucy begins to trust him with the parts of herself she hides.
These disclosures create intimacy through accountability rather than confession as spectacle. Benji names his drinking and its consequences without pretending that sobriety erases grief; Lucy describes both her mistaken loyalty and the violence that made leaving necessary. Their stories are not equivalent, but each recognizes the other’s tendency to convert pain into self-blame. Benji does not rescue Lucy from her past, and she cannot absolve him of his. Instead, they offer a more useful form of care: witnessing the truth without reducing the person to the worst thing that happened.
Rick Makes Hockey a Battleground
Rick repeatedly dismisses Angie’s love of hockey, fails to support her games, and blames Lucy for their daughter’s ADHD and growing independence. At a game, he insults Lucy and Benji, then threatens to seek more custody; Benji steps between them, while Lucy resents needing protection even as Rick’s words shake her.
Angie later tells Benji that she fears the arguments and worries her mother is always angry. When Rick refuses to let Angie speak to Lucy during a weekend visit, Lucy finally follows her father’s advice and prepares to challenge the parenting plan.
Benji offers support, but Lucy’s fear is now about more than Rick’s cruelty. She worries that bringing Benji into the conflict will cost her the first happiness she has found in years.
Rick’s threat turns private harm into a public contest over who gets to define Angie’s needs. He recasts Lucy’s care as manipulation and Angie’s diagnosis as an excuse, forcing Lucy to defend ordinary parenting as though it were evidence in a trial. Benji’s intervention is loving, but it also exposes Lucy’s discomfort with being protected: she fears that help will become another vulnerability Rick can exploit. Angie’s quiet account shows how children absorb conflict even when adults believe they are shielding them. The choice to seek legal change follows from Lucy’s recognition that endurance alone is no longer protecting her daughter.
A Sinclair Christmas
At Christmas, Lucy’s family gathers for her mother Autumn’s wedding to River, the coach who has become a steady presence in the Sinclairs’ lives. Benji attends as Lucy’s boyfriend and is welcomed into the family’s noisy affection, despite the brothers’ relentless teasing.
During the Assassins’ holiday gathering, Baylor tells Lucy privately that she is pregnant, a surprise that gives her a reason to reconsider leaving hockey after repeated injuries.
The family’s happiness sharpens Lucy’s awareness of what she wants: a life in which Angie is loved by more than one dependable adult. Benji, meanwhile, sees in the Sinclairs the warmth he thought he had lost. Their holiday closeness makes the coming fight over Angie feel even more consequential.
The holiday scenes make family a practice rather than a bloodline. River’s marriage to Autumn gives Lucy a new model of love after her parents’ divorce, while Benji is included through shared meals, teasing, and attention to Angie. Baylor’s pregnancy reframes her possible retirement as a chosen transition rather than defeat, echoing the novel’s broader insistence that changing course can preserve a life rather than diminish it. Against this warmth, Rick’s looming custody challenge threatens more than a schedule. It threatens the ordinary community that has begun to make Lucy and Benji feel less alone.
The First Courtroom Blow
At the first custody hearing, Rick seeks full physical custody and attacks Benji’s sobriety, while Lucy’s father, Mark, presents medical records documenting Angie’s ADHD and her treatment. The judge asks Angie what she wants. She says she does not want to live with Rick and describes him as mean; she also explains that Benji plays hockey with her, helps with school, and makes her feel loved.
Rick’s lawyer points to the savings account Benji opened for Angie’s college, hoping to portray it as an attempt to buy her affection. Angie explains why it exists, and the judge rejects that accusation. He refuses Rick’s immediate bid but schedules another hearing, leaving Lucy fearful as Benji must return to the road with the Assassins.
The hearing makes Angie more than the prize adults are fighting over: the judge gives her a voice, and her account exposes the difference between biological entitlement and daily care. Benji’s college savings can be read as generosity or as leverage, so the scene tests intention against the child’s own understanding. Lucy’s fear does not disappear when the judge rejects Rick’s first move, because a temporary reprieve is not security. The procedural delay mirrors her lived uncertainty, while Benji’s departure reintroduces distance just when the family needs solidarity.
A Lie Sends Her South
While Benji is away with the team, Lucy learns that a hockey gossip blogger was paid to post his name beside a promised exposé, then discovers Rick has recorded Angie answering leading questions about Benji’s affection and money. Rick presents the clip as proof of abuse and threatens to take the allegation to court.
Lucy’s father warns that even a false claim could trigger an investigation and damage Benji’s reputation. Rather than tell Benji, Lucy leaves for Florida with Angie and says she needs time apart. Benji returns to an empty house, calls Mark, and learns that Lucy is trying to protect him from a lie that could still hurt his career. Mark reveals his investigator has found evidence against Rick.
The false video weaponizes the very intimacy that has made Benji a safe adult for Angie. Ordinary affection is edited into suspicion, while Lucy’s history of being threatened makes the accusation feel dangerous even before it is tested. Her attempt to protect Benji reproduces the isolation that once kept her trapped with Rick: she assumes she must absorb the damage alone. Benji’s empty house gives the emotional cost of her decision physical form. Mark’s investigation offers a counterweight, but the more important turn is that Benji now understands why she ran and can choose to meet her fear with action.
Florida Brings Them Back
Benji flies to Florida, where Lucy and Angie are staying with Jace and Avery, and confronts Lucy gently about leaving without explaining the threat. He tells her that losing her and Angie would hurt more than any damage to his name, and that they can face Rick together. Lucy admits she wanted to call him but feared making him suffer.
They reconcile and spend the rest of the trip together, letting Angie resume the plans she had made with Benji. Before they leave, Benji asks Lucy to marry him on the beach, with Angie helping reveal the question. Lucy accepts. The engagement gives their family a chosen future, but Rick’s custody challenge still needs to be settled when they return.
The reconciliation matters because Benji refuses the role Lucy has assigned him, that of a vulnerable person she must protect by abandoning him. He does not minimize the risk; he argues that mutual commitment is stronger than unilateral sacrifice. Lucy’s acceptance is therefore more than romantic surrender. It is a decision to practice trust under pressure, letting another adult share the burden she has carried alone. Angie’s involvement keeps the proposal grounded in the family they already are, while the unresolved legal fight prevents the engagement from functioning as a magical escape.
Rick Gives Up His Claim
Back in Nashville, Lucy and Benji meet Rick with the file Mark’s investigator assembled. It documents Rick’s relationship with Amy Masters, the twin boys he fathered with her, and money diverted from accounts connected to his household to support them.
Lucy and Benji explain that they will expose the evidence if Rick uses the staged video in court. Confronted with the risk of his secret family and finances becoming public, Rick abandons his custody campaign.
He says he no longer wants the expense or conflict and signs a statement agreeing to relinquish his parental rights so Benji can adopt Angie. Lucy is stunned by how casually Rick gives up, but Benji sees the promise he has been waiting for: he can become Angie’s father in law as well as in love.
Rick’s capitulation is not a sudden moral awakening. It comes when the private arrangement he has concealed becomes a liability, confirming that his custody campaign was driven by resentment and financial self-interest rather than sustained care. The evidence works because it reverses the surveillance he used against Benji: the person who tried to define others through selective proof is confronted with a fuller record of his own conduct. The result is liberating but emotionally stark. Angie gains a route to stability, yet the ease with which Rick relinquishes her forces Lucy to face how little of his campaign was truly about fatherhood.
Epilogue
Four months later, Benji, Lucy, and Angie stand before a judge to finalize the adoption. Angie wears Benji’s hockey jersey and proudly identifies him as her father. The judge approves the petition, giving her the Paxton name.
Benji holds his daughter and wife as the Assassins and the Sinclair family celebrate around them. He remembers the family he lost, but no longer treats happiness as betrayal of their memory. The long fight over who may love and protect Angie ends with a family the three of them have chosen together.
The adoption formalizes what the novel has already shown through school pickups, hockey practice, meals, and comfort after fear: parenthood is sustained by presence. Angie’s new name does not erase her history or her biological father; it recognizes the relationship she has chosen and the care Benji has consistently given. For Benji, legal fatherhood also revises his identity. He can love a child without replacing the one he lost, and he can build a future without claiming the past never happened. The ending resolves the opening’s central question of who will show up for Angie.
Analysis
Rushing the Goal treats love as a practice of showing up, and it makes that claim concrete through the recurring logistics of care: Benji tying Angie’s skates, helping Lucy preserve her business, collecting a child from school, and remaining present when a custody threat makes departure seem safer. The romance succeeds not because either protagonist is untouched by damage, but because both are willing to disclose it and revise their habits. Lucy’s self-reliance protects her from Rick, yet it also tempts her to decide for Benji that he should be spared the risk. Benji’s recovery gives him the discipline to reject that substitution of sacrifice for intimacy.
The book also distinguishes biological parenthood from responsible parenting without pretending biology is irrelevant. Rick uses his status as Angie’s father to claim authority, while Benji earns her trust through attention to her needs and interests. Angie’s voice matters because the adult conflict often threatens to turn her into evidence. Her stated preferences, her fear, and her joy in hockey show what the custody arguments obscure: a child’s welfare is measured in lived experience, not in an adult’s possessive claim.
Hockey functions as more than romance scenery. The rink offers Angie competence and belonging, gives Benji a route back into family life, and exposes Rick’s refusal to value what matters to his daughter. Lucy’s design work and the guesthouse arrangement add an economic dimension: accepting help need not mean losing autonomy when the terms are transparent. The eventual adoption does not erase grief, divorce, or the history that preceded it. Instead, it makes visible a family already formed through repeated acts of loyalty. The novel’s deepest reassurance is not that hardship disappears, but that care can become durable when people stop facing it alone.
Review Summary
Rushing the Goal is widely praised as an emotionally engaging and well-written addition to the Assassins series. Readers appreciate the complex characters of Lucy and Benji, their personal struggles, and the development of their relationship. The book is lauded for its humor, heartwarming moments, and the inclusion of characters from previous books. While some readers found the length excessive and the religious references off-putting, most enjoyed the hockey setting, family dynamics, and the adorable character of Angie. Overall, it's considered a strong entry in the series.
People Also Read
Characters
Lucy Sinclair
Guarded single motherLucy is a talented interior designer and a fiercely attentive mother to Angie. After a painful marriage and divorce, she has organized her life around keeping her daughter safe and her business afloat, often treating her own needs as expendable. Her sharp humor and quick temper can keep people at a distance, but they also mask fear and exhaustion. Lucy trusts actions more readily than assurances, which makes her independence both a strength and a barrier to intimacy. Her bond with her close-knit family gives her support, even as she struggles to accept help without feeling that she has lost control.
Benji Paxton
Sober hockey veteranBenji is a veteran Assassins defenseman who has rebuilt his life through sobriety, hockey, and the support of friends in recovery. Beneath his imposing frame is an awkward, warm-hearted man who remembers details, cares for children, and uses humor to ease tension. Grief and guilt have made him cautious about happiness, yet he longs for a family and a life not defined solely by the rink. His instinct is to help, sometimes before asking what help the other person wants. His challenge is to offer steady love without turning care into control or treating the past as a debt he can never repay.
Angie Hart
Hockey-loving daughterAngie is Lucy’s seven-year-old daughter, a lively, strong-willed child who loves hockey and thrives when adults give her patience and clear support. Her ADHD shapes how she moves through the world, but it does not define her intelligence or personality. She is funny, observant, and more emotionally perceptive than the adults sometimes expect. Angie wants to belong to the people she loves, and she responds strongly to whether they show up for her interests. Her candor can expose tensions the adults would rather avoid, while her delight in hockey gives her a source of confidence and joy.
Rick Hart
Controlling ex-husbandRick is Lucy’s former husband and Angie’s father. He is antagonistic toward Lucy and often treats co-parenting as a contest for leverage rather than a shared responsibility. His hostility is especially damaging because he can turn ordinary disagreements about school, sports, and discipline into threats about custody. Rick’s need to control the terms of family life contrasts with Lucy’s attempt to keep Angie’s routine stable. He is not simply a difficult ex; his behavior forces Lucy to weigh every decision against its potential effect on her daughter.
Jayden Sinclair
Protective hockey brotherJayden is Lucy’s younger brother, an Assassins captain and a devoted husband to Baylor. He is dependable and protective, though his quick decisions can create trouble for Lucy, as when he asks Benji to coach Angie without warning her. Jayden’s closeness with his siblings gives Lucy a strong safety net, and his concern for her happiness is genuine even when he expresses it through teasing or interference.
Autumn Sinclair
Lucy’s devoted motherAutumn is Lucy’s mother and the warm center of the Sinclair family. After the collapse of her marriage, she allows herself to seek love again, giving Lucy an example of life continuing after betrayal. Autumn is affectionate, openly hopeful, and sometimes overinvolved, especially when she senses Lucy shutting herself away. Her support comes with a blunt insistence that Lucy’s happiness matters as much as Angie’s.
River Moore
Steady family anchorRiver is a former NHL player, a coach, and Autumn’s partner. His calm warmth helps him become a trusted adult in Angie’s life and a stabilizing presence for the Sinclair family. He does not compete with Lucy’s father or try to claim authority over her children. Instead, River shows care through practical support and affection, offering a quieter model of masculinity than the men who have hurt Lucy.
Mark Sinclair
Lawyer and wounded fatherMark is Lucy’s father, a lawyer whose past choices fractured his relationship with his children. He remains devoted to Angie and is willing to use his legal knowledge to protect her, but his helpfulness does not undo the hurt he caused Lucy. Mark’s presence is complicated: he is both a resource Lucy needs and a reminder of a betrayal she has not fully forgiven. He must earn trust through action rather than rely on his role as her father.
Baylor Sinclair
Trailblazing hockey playerBaylor is Jayden’s wife and a professional hockey player whose determination has carried her into a male-dominated league. Repeated injuries test the identity she has built around competing, while her marriage gives her a place to be vulnerable. She is strong-willed and ambitious, but she also understands the cost of treating every limit as something to defeat. Her connection with Lucy grows through honest conversations rather than simple family proximity.
Shea Adler
Hockey coach and mentorShea is a former Assassins captain who retires from professional play to coach his children’s girls’ hockey team. His decision places family above continued prestige without diminishing his love of the game. He welcomes Angie into the team and treats Lucy with respect, offering practical help without making her feel incapable. Shea’s coaching creates the setting where Benji and Angie first form their bond.
Avery Sinclair
Young mother and confidanteAvery is Lucy’s sister-in-law, married to Jace and raising their young daughter, Ashlyn. She is kind but perceptive, willing to tell Lucy what she does not want to hear about loneliness and self-neglect. Avery’s youth does not make her naïve; she has a direct understanding of love, parenting, and the courage it takes to choose a life beyond fear.
Jace Sinclair
Youngest hockey brotherJace is Lucy’s youngest brother, a professional hockey player married to Avery. He is playful and sometimes immature, but his loyalty to his family is unquestioned. His move away with Avery and Ashlyn leaves Lucy missing the everyday closeness they once shared. Jace’s affectionate marriage and growing family form part of the loving, noisy world Lucy both cherishes and sometimes envies.
Jude Sinclair
Blunt older brotherJude is one of Lucy’s hockey-playing brothers, married to Claire. His teasing can be merciless, but his protectiveness is clear when Lucy is threatened. Jude represents the Sinclair family’s habit of turning anxiety into jokes and loud argument. Beneath his irreverence, he wants Lucy to be safe and loved, and he is unafraid to challenge the people who mistreat her.
Heidi
Rick’s wifeHeidi is Rick’s wife and the mother of his older daughter, Nina. Her history with Rick overlaps with Lucy’s marriage, leaving her relationship with Lucy strained and uneasy. Heidi often follows Rick’s lead rather than challenge his behavior, though she can show flashes of consideration. Her presence complicates Angie’s experience of her father’s household and underscores how adult choices shape children’s sense of belonging.
Jordie Thomas
Benji’s recovery friendJordie is Benji’s teammate and friend, a fellow recovering alcoholic who understands the work of staying sober. His marriage and family life give Benji a close example of the companionship he wants but doubts he deserves. Jordie offers direct advice, sometimes bluntly, and encourages Benji to stop using grief as a shield against new relationships.
Plot Devices
Angie’s Hockey Team
A rink for trustAngie’s girls’ hockey team brings Lucy, Benji, and Angie into repeated contact. Benji first meets them when he covers for Jayden, then earns Angie’s confidence by helping her through anxious drills. The team gives Angie a place where her effort is recognized, while practices and games create opportunities for Benji to support her and for Lucy to observe him. Hockey also becomes a pressure point in the custody conflict because Rick dismisses an activity Angie loves. The rink therefore serves as both a setting for connection and a practical test of who listens to the child.
The Guesthouse Office
Help without surrenderAfter a burst pipe leaves Lucy without a usable apartment and workspace, Benji offers her the guesthouse behind his home as an office. Lucy insists on paying rent and signing a contract, preserving her independence while accepting the practical help she needs. The arrangement keeps her design business operating and places her near Benji, allowing their relationship to develop through daily routines rather than only romantic encounters. The rent money also becomes a college savings account for Angie, a gesture Rick later tries to misrepresent. The space embodies the tension between Lucy’s fear of dependence and the possibility of accepting care on fair terms.
The Custody Record
Evidence against controlThe parenting plan, medical records, Angie’s account of her visits, and Mark’s legal work give Lucy a way to challenge Rick’s demands. Rick tries to use custody proceedings and a staged video to discredit Benji, while Lucy’s family preserves documentation and eventually hires an investigator to uncover Rick’s own concealed conduct. These records shift the conflict from competing accusations to evidence about who is caring for Angie and why. The device also raises the emotional stakes: Lucy must learn that protecting her daughter does not require hiding the truth from Benji or carrying every legal burden alone.
Benji’s Recovery
A life rebuilt soberBenji’s sobriety and participation in recovery meetings shape how he understands responsibility, guilt, and intimacy. His past includes a devastating family loss tied to his alcoholism, and he has long treated happiness as something he may not deserve. His friends in recovery challenge him to keep moving forward without forgetting those he lost. Lucy’s willingness to hear his history without condemning him becomes part of their growing trust, while Angie’s presence gives him a chance to care for a child in everyday, concrete ways. Recovery is not a cure for grief but the condition that lets him build a different future.
The Adoption Petition
Chosen family made legalAfter Rick relinquishes his parental rights, Benji petitions to adopt Angie. The court process transforms the father-daughter bond already established through hockey, school pickups, meals, and comfort into a legal relationship. Angie participates in the decision and identifies Benji as her father, making her wishes central rather than treating her as an object transferred between adults. The adoption resolves the instability that has shadowed Lucy’s parenting and gives Benji a chance to embrace fatherhood without pretending his past family never existed. It is the story’s final expression of family as sustained care and mutual choice.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.