Plot Summary
Second Place at Christmas
Four weeks before Christmas, Kelly Kaplan is raising her baby, Mia, while managing the office at her best friend Ava's bakery. Mia's father, Austin Graham, still sees them regularly, but Kelly keeps their relationship at a distance.
A year and a half earlier, their fling led to Mia, and Austin's past betrayal of people Kelly considers family destroyed her trust. When Austin cancels his usual Tuesday with Mia for a football-related charity event, Kelly unexpectedly agrees to a blind date arranged by an elderly bakery customer.
Meanwhile, Austin dreads another Christmas alone. His mother has chosen to visit his half-brother instead, and his career as a backup tight end reinforces his lifelong fear of coming second. Mia and Kelly remain the people he most wants to choose him.
The opening gives the romance two opposing forms of insecurity. Kelly protects herself by treating trust as a duty owed to her friends and daughter, not merely a feeling she can follow. Austin interprets exclusion as proof of a fixed ranking, a belief rooted in childhood abandonment and sharpened by his football career. Their co-parenting keeps them close enough for attraction to persist but not close enough to repair the injury. The blind date is less a genuine new beginning than Kelly's attempt to make forward motion visible, even to herself.
An Honest Starting Chance
At the charity party, Austin finds an unexpected point of connection with Asher Nash, the Aces tight end he has treated as a rival. Their talk about fatherhood softens the hostility between them. Soon afterward, the coaches announce a chance to compete for a starting place in a new two-tight-end formation. Austin recognizes his old impulse to undermine Chase Morgan, but chooses to earn the role through practice instead.
His effort wins him the starting spot alongside Asher. Excited to share the news with Kelly, he arrives at her house and learns she has a date that evening. Her decision lands like another rejection, but he does not pressure her. He takes Mia, watches over her while Kelly is out, and tries to accept that Kelly may move on.
Austin's competition finally becomes ethically meaningful. Before, he has treated the starting role as a cure for every private humiliation, which licenses shortcuts against teammates. This time the opportunity matters because he declines to secure it through harm. His success is concrete, but the scene does not pretend that professional recognition can repair his family life or restore Kelly's trust. Asher's small act of openness also challenges Austin's habit of reading distance as conspiracy. The date news then tests whether his better conduct can survive disappointment without reverting to control.
One Date Too Many
Kelly's evening with Max Cockshot begins with awkward conversation, a misplaced restaurant reservation, and a wine spill that ruins her favorite dress. The date confirms that she is not ready to build a life with a stranger, especially when Austin keeps crowding her thoughts.
Back home, she finds Austin asleep on the couch with Mia nestled against him. He has cared for their daughter until she fell asleep, and the sight stirs the tenderness Kelly has been trying to suppress.
After she puts Mia to bed, Austin shares the news that he earned a starting position honestly. Kelly celebrates by hugging him, and they share a brief kiss. He leaves without asking her to decide their future, but the evening makes her question whether distance is protecting her or simply prolonging her fear.
The comedy of the ruined date has a structural purpose: it makes Kelly's attempted escape look less persuasive than the ordinary intimacy she already shares with Austin. The contrast is not that Max is a bad person, but that a date assembled by someone else cannot compete with the accumulated knowledge between co-parents. Austin's restraint matters as much as his ambition. He shares his achievement without demanding that Kelly reward it with affection. Their kiss is small, yet it carries more consequence than the date because it emerges from a history neither can replace.
Greens, Apologies, and Touchdowns
Kelly wears Austin's jersey to his first game as a starter, and he scores a touchdown while she cheers from the stands. On the next Tuesday, he finds Kelly struggling to make Christmas wreaths while caring for Mia, so he stays to help build the wreath bases and entertain their daughter.
His practical support turns Kelly's hobby into a possible source of income: he urges her to price the handmade wreaths fairly, and Ava begins taking orders.
At the bakery, Austin then apologizes to Ava and her husband, Grayson, for the harm he caused their family, and he promises to speak with Asher and their brother, head coach Lincoln Nash, too. Ava tells Kelly that she and Grayson have already forgiven him, leaving Kelly to consider whether she can do the same.
This section shifts proof of change from Austin's intentions to observable labor. A touchdown may validate his athletic ability, but building wreaths and taking care of Mia demonstrate a less glamorous competence: noticing what Kelly needs and sharing the burden. The apology is significant because he addresses the injured people directly rather than treating Kelly's forgiveness as a prize he can win privately. Ava's response does not absolve Kelly of her fear; it removes the social obligation that had partly sustained it. Kelly must now distinguish loyalty from keeping an old injury alive.
Six Months of Waiting
After another Aces victory, Austin arrives at Kelly's house simply because he wants to see her. He admits he loves her and explains the changes he has made, including leaving the private club that had troubled her and stopping his attempts to sabotage teammates.
Kelly, moved by both his confession and his sustained effort, kisses him and chooses to restart their relationship. The next morning, Austin changes Mia, reads to her, and cooks breakfast, then asks Kelly and their daughter to move in with him so he can share the daily work of parenting.
Kelly does not accept immediately. After discussing the decision with Ava, she agrees to move after the holiday rush. When she worries about juggling Mia, the bakery, and new wreath orders, Austin reassures her that she can choose work and childcare on her own terms.
The reconciliation is built from two kinds of evidence: Austin names what he has changed, then demonstrates care in the unremarkable morning hours. Kelly's consent is not presented as a reward for his confession or a concession to their shared child. She pauses, consults her closest friend, and decides she wants Austin as a partner, not merely as Mia's father. His offer to share domestic work also corrects an imbalance that romance alone would leave intact. The move is a practical commitment, but Kelly's timing preserves her agency.
Tree Lights Come Crashing
Five days before Christmas, Kelly watches Austin score again and recognizes how deeply she loves him. Later, when he comes over, she lets him take responsibility for Mia's bath and asks him to repeat the question he has been asking for months.
This time, she agrees to try again. Before they can enjoy the quiet, Mia pulls herself up using the Christmas tree's lowest branch. Austin yanks their daughter clear, but the tree crashes down and shatters ornaments across the floor.
Kelly comforts Mia while Austin restores the tree, sweeps up the glass, and vacuums the room. Once their daughter is asleep, he promises they will replace the tree. In the calm afterward, Kelly tells him she loves him too, turning a near-disaster into their first shared test as a family.
The toppled tree makes domestic life literal: the beautiful scene Kelly has imagined cannot remain untouched by a baby's curiosity, broken glass, or fatigue. Austin does not interpret the accident as a sign that their renewed relationship is doomed. He takes responsibility for the mess while Kelly tends to Mia, and each responds to the immediate need rather than seeking blame. Their complementary actions give Kelly evidence of partnership more persuasive than another declaration. Christmas becomes less a flawless picture than a practice of repairing what falls.
Two Trees, One New Family
The following day, Austin replaces Kelly's tree and buys another for his own home, where he has never bothered to decorate. In matching gingerbread sweaters, he, Kelly, and Mia choose both trees, enjoy artificial snow at the lot, and shop for ornaments and wreath supplies.
They also leave Mia with a nanny at publicist Ellie Dalton's busy family home, giving Kelly a careful first experience of childcare beyond her own supervision. After they decorate Kelly's new tree and spend time together, Austin receives an urgent call ordering a random drug test.
He goes to the lab confident that the result will be clean. Soon afterward, Kelly and Mia prepare to fly to Chicago for Christmas with Kelly's parents and grandparents, while Austin faces the test outcome alone.
The paired trees mark a shift in Austin's relationship to Christmas: he is no longer only avoiding painful memories, but making a place for new rituals. The outing also expands Kelly's definition of care. Trusting a vetted nanny for a short visit does not mean she loves Mia less; it means she can let other adults help. That emerging confidence makes the sudden drug test especially destabilizing. Just as Austin begins to imagine belonging in Kelly's family, an institutional judgment threatens his career and the fragile trust he has rebuilt.
The Test at the Airport
The lab reports that Austin's sample contains a banned steroid, and the team owner summons him. He insists there has been a mistake, but Kelly is racing to board her flight with Mia and cannot resolve the accusation with him.
The crowded airport and a four-hour flight with a screaming, restless baby consume her attention. In Chicago, she sees photographs of Austin out drinking with teammates after he fails to return her call, and she begins to doubt whether his renewed commitment is real.
Austin, meanwhile, feels abandoned and fears Kelly believes the worst of him. Exhausted, Kelly tells her family that they are trying again, then privately recognizes that she has not yet told Austin she believes him. The distance leaves both of them interpreting silence as rejection.
The test exposes how reputation can outlast reform. Austin's earlier misconduct makes his denial less credible to the people around him, while Kelly's old distrust gives an ambiguous missed call the shape of a familiar betrayal. Neither misreads the facts maliciously; each lacks the information and emotional bandwidth to interpret them generously. The flight amplifies Kelly's isolation through the physical demands of solo parenting, while Austin's loneliness revives his expectation of being left. Their conflict is therefore not only about truth, but about whether trust can operate before certainty arrives.
Chase's Hidden Shortcut
After a difficult meeting with the Aces, Austin goes out with Asher, who believes his account. The next morning, news reports that the testing lab mixed up samples. A retest clears Austin, and team owner Jack Dalton identifies the other player as Chase Morgan, who had been competing with Austin for the starting role.
Austin is furious but follows Dalton's warning not to let anger undo the reputation he is rebuilding; he directs Chase to face the owner rather than attacking him himself. In Chicago, Kelly listens to her family and realizes she does believe Austin.
She sends him that reassurance, and he receives it as he prepares a surprise trip to see her. When his flight to O'Hare is grounded by the blizzard, an airline employee helps him find a route that can still get him to Chicago.
The mix-up is a plot reversal, but the deeper test is what Austin does after learning who benefited from it. His earlier self might have treated Chase's action as permission to retaliate. Instead, Austin accepts institutional consequences and keeps his anger from becoming another act that would confirm the worst assumptions about him. Kelly's message arrives at a crucial moment, not because it solves the procedural problem, but because it supplies the intimate recognition he most needs. Their separate choices begin to repair the trust that distance had distorted.
Christmas Eve Collision
Kelly, worried that she has left Austin alone at Christmas, books a flight back to Vegas with Mia. A blizzard cancels it before she can leave the airport. Austin has managed to reach Chicago by another route, and the two spot each other in the terminal.
He confirms that the drug test was a lab error and that he came because he wants to spend Christmas with them. Kelly tells him she believes him and regrets not making their family plans together. They collect their luggage and join her father for the drive to her grandparents' home, where Kelly's mother welcomes Austin warmly.
The surprise visit turns the canceled journey into a reunion. For Austin, the holiday he expected to spend alone becomes his first chance to share Kelly's familiar Christmas traditions with Mia and her extended family.
The airport encounter resolves a conflict that neither a test result nor a text could fully settle. Kelly and Austin arrive there by separate routes, each having decided that the other matters enough to cross distance for. The storm frustrates their plans but also makes their reunion possible, giving chance a role without replacing their choices. Austin's acceptance into Kelly's family is not automatic; it grows from his willingness to show up and her family's readiness to make room. The holiday setting becomes a measure of belonging rather than a backdrop for romance.
A Ring Beneath the Tree
On Christmas morning, Kelly's parents announce they are moving to Vegas, bringing Mia's grandparents closer. Austin gives Kelly's family a photograph of their first family portrait, then proposes in front of them. Kelly accepts.
Later, he reveals that he has established Kaplan's Crafts and funded it so she can turn wreath-making into a business without being forced to leave the bakery before she is ready. Kelly agrees to return to Vegas with him and begins planning a future that includes both her creative work and Ava's bakery.
When the couple visits the bakery after the holiday, Kelly tells Ava she needs to reduce her hours; Ava supports her new venture and offers display space. Austin's career, fatherhood, and relationship now belong to a life built with other people, not won through solitary competition.
The resolution gives each character a form of security that is not reducible to the engagement. Kelly gains a business that treats her craft as skilled work, while her parents' move answers a long-held wish for family nearby. Austin's proposal is public, but its emotional force comes from the family he has already begun to join. His gift also carries a risk: financial help could become another form of control. Kelly's plans with Ava preserve her independence and friendship, making the future a negotiated partnership rather than a life designed by Austin alone.
Epilogue
Two weeks later, Kelly is making Valentine wreaths while Austin helps sort decorations and prepare for Mia's first birthday. They have booked a spring wedding date, and Kelly is balancing her new business with a reduced schedule at Ava's bakery. When her wreath-making work threatens to crowd out their time together, Austin offers practical help instead of asking her to abandon it.
Their easy joking and shared intimacy show that their second chance has become a daily partnership. Austin, once convinced that every gain could only be followed by another loss, now understands his place through the family routines he helps create.
The epilogue tests the happy ending against ordinary life rather than adding another crisis. Kelly's business is already demanding time, and Austin's football career still shapes his schedule, so the couple must keep negotiating labor and attention. His response matters: he offers help without treating Kelly's ambition as a threat to their relationship. The wedding date formalizes their commitment, but the more persuasive evidence is their shared work around Mia and the household. Austin's sense of being chosen is no longer dependent on winning a starting position; it is sustained by reciprocal care.
Analysis
Second Down Scrooge treats self-worth as something Austin has mistaken for rank. As a football player, he measures progress by whether he starts; in his family, he measures love by whether his mother chooses him over his half-brother. Those measures make his harmful shortcuts feel, to him, like rational attempts to correct an unfair world. Yet the novel refuses to equate achievement with moral repair. Austin earns a starting role, but Kelly's trust begins to shift only when he stops treating people as obstacles and takes responsibility for specific harm.
Kelly faces a different problem. Her caution is not simple fearfulness: she has obligations to Mia and loyalty to friends Austin has hurt. The story makes her reconsider whether protecting others requires preserving anger on their behalf. Her eventual choice is not to ignore the past, but to evaluate Austin through repeated acts of accountability. Forgiveness becomes a judgment made with evidence, not a seasonal obligation.
Christmas provides the novel's organizing contrast. Kelly's traditions offer warmth, while Austin's memories make the holiday a yearly reminder of abandonment. Their shared rituals do not magically erase his childhood; they give him a different experience to add to it. The fallen tree is especially apt because it breaks the polished domestic picture just as Kelly chooses him. What follows is not a sign or a punishment, but practical cooperation: one parent comforts Mia while the other cleans the glass.
The romance also links love to material conditions. Kelly's wreath business, access to childcare, Austin's willingness to share parenting, and the prospect of nearby grandparents all matter alongside desire. The ending's promise is therefore larger than marriage. It is a household in which care is distributed, Kelly's work can grow, and Austin no longer has to earn belonging by defeating someone else.
Review Summary
Second Down Scrooge is a heartwarming holiday romance novella featuring Austin, a pro football player seeking redemption, and Kelly, a single mom. Readers praise the character development, sweet family moments, and festive atmosphere. The story explores themes of forgiveness, second chances, and personal growth. While some found it predictable or rushed, many enjoyed the emotional journey and steamy scenes. The book is part of a larger series but can be read as a standalone. Overall, it's a light, feel-good Christmas read with a satisfying happily-ever-after.
People Also Read
Characters
Kelly Kaplan
The wary wreath-makerKelly works at her best friend Ava's bakery and raises Mia with a protectiveness shaped by earlier heartbreak. She is cheerful, imaginative, and generous with people she trusts, but her optimism does not make her careless: when Austin's past choices hurt people she loves, she treats that history as evidence she must consider. Motherhood adds a new pressure to her decisions because the risks she takes now affect her daughter too. Her wreath-making offers a glimpse of an identity beyond being a mother and employee. Kelly's central tension is between the safety of keeping Austin at a distance and the desire to build a life with someone she still loves.
Austin Graham
The striving tight endAustin is a professional tight end whose career has taught him to measure himself against whoever stands ahead of him. His childhood was unsettled by his parents' divorce, an absent father, and a mother whose attention seemed to favor his half-brother. Football gives him a team and a route toward recognition, but his hunger to advance has sometimes pushed him toward destructive choices. As Mia's father and Kelly's former partner, he wants more than professional success, though he initially struggles to understand how to earn trust without demanding it. His charm and competitiveness sit alongside a deeper fear of being replaceable.
Mia Graham
Their little football fanMia is Kelly and Austin's young daughter, an affectionate, energetic child who adores her father and depends on her mother for daily care. Her presence connects the former couple even while their romantic relationship remains unresolved. Mia also changes what each parent considers a risk: Kelly is cautious because she must protect her daughter, while Austin wants to become someone Mia can respect. Her ordinary needs, from meals to bedtime, make the work of parenting visible and give the adults a reason to practice cooperation.
Ava
Kelly's steadfast best friendAva owns the bakery where Kelly works and gives her friend both professional opportunity and emotional candor. Married to Grayson, she understands what it takes to build trust in a relationship and is willing to tell Kelly when fear may be keeping her stuck. Ava does not dismiss the harm Austin has caused; she separates her own forgiveness from Kelly's decision about whether to let him close again. She also encourages Kelly's wreath-making, helping a private creative habit find customers. Her friendship offers Kelly a reliable place to test difficult choices without surrendering her independence.
Grayson
Ava's loyal husbandGrayson is Ava's husband and one of the people Austin previously wronged. He is part of Kelly's close circle, so Austin's actions toward him matter to her personally. Grayson approaches the old conflict with more readiness to move on than Kelly does, but he does not pressure her to feel the same. His willingness to hear an apology gives Austin a chance to address the consequences of his behavior directly. Grayson represents the possibility that friendship can survive serious mistakes when accountability is followed by changed conduct.
Asher Nash
The rival tight endAsher is a talented tight end on the Vegas Aces and a member of the Nash family, whose history with Austin contributes to their rivalry. He is engaged to Coach Dixon's daughter and is preparing for fatherhood, giving him and Austin unexpected common ground. Asher works to fit into the team without making a spectacle of himself, and his steadiness contrasts with Austin's suspicion that everyone is competing against him. He becomes an important measure of whether Austin can treat a colleague as a person rather than an obstacle.
Chase Morgan
Austin's roster competitorChase is another Vegas Aces tight end competing with Austin for playing time. Their professional rivalry becomes more consequential when the coaches consider using two tight ends, creating a genuine opening for either player. Chase is a functional but important presence in Austin's struggle to distinguish fair competition from the urge to undermine someone else. His ambition gives the football plot a human stake beyond the depth chart.
Mrs. Howard
The matchmaking customerMrs. Howard is a regular bakery customer who admires Kelly's handmade decorations and believes Kelly deserves a social life beyond work and motherhood. She arranges a blind date with her grandson, Max, with more confidence than tact. Her matchmaking gives Kelly a concrete chance to test whether she is ready to move on from Austin.
Max Cockshot
Kelly's awkward blind dateMax is Mrs. Howard's grandson, a computer programmer who meets Kelly on a date neither seems fully prepared to navigate. He is not presented as a serious rival to Austin; the evening instead reveals Kelly's distraction and inexperience with dating after becoming a mother. His unfortunate surname and the restaurant mishap give the encounter a comic edge.
Kelly's mother
A loving family anchorKelly's mother is warm, closely involved in her daughter's life, and delighted to spend time with Mia. She shares Kelly's traditions around Christmas and offers perspective when Kelly worries about Austin. Her retirement makes her a possible source of support, though her husband's work and their existing life complicate the prospect of moving nearer to Kelly. She represents the family steadiness Kelly hopes to give Mia.
Kelly's father
The practical encouragerKelly's father is affectionate and perceptive, offering advice without pretending he can choose for her. He understands that Austin's career creates real pressures, but he encourages Kelly to distinguish a difficult week from a settled pattern. His willingness to listen helps Kelly name what she wants rather than simply react to disappointment.
Kelly's grandmother
Keeper of Christmas ritualsKelly's grandmother hosts the family's Christmas traditions and offers her granddaughter an older, more patient perspective on relationships. Her cooking and hospitality make the family home a place where Kelly can remember her own childhood while introducing Mia to its rituals. She treats Austin with warmth, helping him experience the welcome he missed growing up.
Kelly's grandfather
A quiet family presenceKelly's grandfather is part of the close-knit family gathering in Chicago. His presence helps define the intergenerational warmth that surrounds Mia's first Christmas and gives Austin a glimpse of the stable family life Kelly grew up with.
Jack Dalton
The Aces team ownerJack Dalton owns the Vegas Aces and oversees the response to Austin's drug-test result. He requires the team to follow procedure but also recognizes that a player should be judged by the evidence and by how he responds to pressure. His authority makes the testing error consequential for Austin's career, while his judgment helps keep the dispute from becoming a personal feud.
Lincoln Nash
The Aces head coachLincoln Nash is the Aces' head coach and Asher's brother. His position makes him part of the family history that Austin resents, especially when Austin feels overlooked for the starting role. Lincoln must manage the team fairly while working with a player whose past conduct has strained trust. He is a reminder that professional decisions can feel personal even when they are based on football.
Coach Bruce
The tight ends coachCoach Bruce evaluates Austin and Chase during the competition for a starting place. He is a direct link between their work on the practice field and the coaches' decisions about playing time.
Ellie Dalton
Austin's publicistEllie is Austin's publicist and part of the wider Aces family network. Her home is full of children, and she helps Kelly and Austin explore a safe childcare option for Mia.
Elizabeth
The trusted nannyElizabeth is the nanny at Ellie's home, where Mia gets a first trial visit with other children. Her gentle manner helps Kelly consider accepting practical support while keeping her daughter's safety at the center.
Austin's mother
A source of old hurtAustin's mother lives far from him and has a strained relationship with her son. Her attention to his half-brother leaves Austin feeling like an afterthought, especially around Christmas. Her choices help explain his fear of being second, though they do not excuse the harm he causes when he tries to get ahead.
Carson
Austin's younger half-brotherCarson is Austin's half-brother and the favored focus of their mother's holiday plans. He is mostly absent from the action, but his place in the family helps illuminate Austin's long-standing sense of being overlooked.
Plot Devices
Christmas traditions
A measure of belongingChristmas carries opposite meanings for the couple. Kelly associates it with family rituals, childhood memories, and the traditions she wants to pass to Mia. Austin associates the holiday with his parents' divorce and the feeling that his mother chooses someone else. Matching sweaters, wreaths, trees, and the Chicago family gathering let the story turn familiar seasonal objects into visible signs of whether Austin can join Kelly's world and whether he can make new memories without erasing the old ones.
The starting tight end role
A test of fair ambitionAustin's competition with Chase for a place beside Asher gives his personal development a public arena. He has previously tried to advance through dishonest tactics, so earning a starting role through practice becomes evidence that he can compete without damaging other people. The position does not solve his loneliness or secure Kelly's trust, which prevents career success from serving as a simple cure for his deeper fear of being second.
Co-parenting and daily care
Love made practicalThe custody routine keeps Kelly and Austin connected while making the unequal labor of parenting visible. Austin initially sees Mia on a limited schedule, while Kelly handles most everyday care. Shared mornings, wreath-making days, baths, meals, and childcare decisions gradually give them evidence of what partnership would require. Mia is not a shortcut to romance; her needs force both adults to consider reliability, responsibility, and how their choices affect someone besides themselves.
Kelly's wreath business
A craft becomes independenceKelly's handmade wreaths begin as decorations for Ava's bakery and become a source of paid orders after customers admire them. Austin encourages her to charge fairly and helps with the work, while Ava provides a place to sell them. The growing business expresses Kelly's creative identity outside motherhood and gives her a practical future she can shape herself. Its importance is not merely financial: it lets her imagine choosing a relationship without giving up her own ambitions.
The mixed drug test
A trust under pressureA random test returns a positive result for a prohibited steroid, threatening Austin's career and exposing the damage his past conduct has done to his credibility. The investigation reveals that the lab mixed his sample with another player's. The mistake forces Austin to rely on evidence and restraint rather than retaliation, while Kelly must decide whether to trust him before she has proof. The device brings professional consequences into the romance and tests whether changed behavior can be believed before a crisis is resolved.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.