Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Some Choose Darkness

Some Choose Darkness

A forensic artist reopens a murder as her dead father's convicted client approaches parole.
by Charlie Donlea 2019 304 pages
4.2
52k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

In 1979, a killer uses a pulley rig to make a woman rise while he risks strangling himself for the sensation he calls the Rush. Later, a woman gathers roses while a young girl ties them into a bundle and wonders where they go.

The woman sends the child inside, then carries the flowers beyond the house and leaves them in the field. The two images seem unrelated: one built from terror, the other from a quiet daily ritual. The story will eventually bind them through a hidden family history.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The opening pairs a private ritual of violence with an ordinary act of care, establishing how easily concealed practices can live beside domestic routine. The pulley apparatus turns the killer’s body into part of his own mechanism, linking his craving to the danger he imposes on others. The roses offer a counter-image: gathered, bound, and carried somewhere unseen. Their destination is withheld, so the reader encounters concealment first as a tender mystery, before learning how secrecy can protect both the vulnerable and the guilty.

The Doll and the Dead

A grieving father draws Rory back into homicide work

Rory Moore has spent months away from forensic reconstruction, relying on thick glasses, strict routines, and distance from people to keep her anxiety manageable. At a library meeting, insurance businessman Walter Byrd brings her a shattered Kestner doll that belonged to his murdered daughter, Camille. He first hires Rory to repair the porcelain, then asks her to reconstruct Camille’s unsolved strangling.

Rory accepts, unable to ignore the case. The next day, while she meets Detective Ron Davidson at Grant Park, where Camille’s body was found, a call brings news that Rory’s father, Frank, has died. Grief joins the new investigation, while the sudden work gives Rory somewhere to direct the feelings she cannot easily name.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The doll gives Rory a way into the case that is both practical and emotional. Its fracture is repairable, unlike Camille’s death, but the task lets Rory approach the victim through an object that belonged to her life. Her acceptance also shows how her unusual attention works: once a pattern or unanswered question catches her, withdrawal no longer protects her. Frank’s death intensifies this dependence on work. Rory does not simply replace grief with investigation; she converts an unmanageable loss into a sequence of observable details, a form of control that can help her function while keeping intimacy at a distance.

A Client Called The Thief

Her father's final case carries a killer toward release

While closing Frank’s law practice, Rory finds one case no other firm can readily take: Thomas Mitchell, imprisoned since 1979 and about to receive parole. Judge Russell Boyle requires her to handle the final hearing and oversee Mitchell’s release arrangements.

Rory asks her longtime partner, forensic psychologist Lane Phillips, to explain the old case. Mitchell was convicted of murdering his wife, Angela, after an autistic woman’s investigation helped police build a case, though no body was produced.

The authorities suspected him in other disappearances but could not prove them. Lane’s account catches Rory’s attention, especially when she learns that her father represented Mitchell for decades. She begins pulling old police records, trying to understand why Frank kept the case close.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The parole order turns a family duty into a moral and investigative trap. Rory is not drawn to Mitchell as a client; she is drawn to the unexplained choices surrounding him, especially Frank’s unusually long commitment. Lane provides context without resolving the central uncertainty, preserving the difference between suspicion and proof that shaped the original prosecution. Rory’s professional roles now collide: she has to facilitate the release of a convicted killer while her instincts are trained on victims and overlooked evidence. The case becomes personal before she knows how personal it truly is.

Angela Maps the Missing

A 1979 pattern leads her from newspaper clippings to a hidden room

In the summer of 1979, Angela Mitchell, a socially isolated woman with autism and severe obsessive-compulsive symptoms, studies reports of women vanishing from Chicago. She builds biographies, searches old newspapers, and charts a decade-long rise in killings of women with similar traits.

Angela believes one predator has changed his methods after John Wayne Gacy’s crimes drew intense police attention. When a stranger offers to help move a couch from her garage, fear overwhelms her; she later recognizes him as Leonard Williams, a foreman hired by her husband’s construction company.

At Leonard’s Kenosha warehouse, she finds a concealed room containing a pulley device with two nooses. She leaves with no proof of what it means, but the room confirms that her research has led somewhere real.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Angela’s method is an early form of pattern analysis built from paper records, patience, and an unusually persistent memory. Her habits can intensify into distress, yet they also let her hold details that others treat as unrelated. The episode with Leonard complicates her judgment: her fear is justified by the danger around her, but the wrong man initially absorbs her suspicion. Her discovery is therefore not a sudden flash of genius so much as a costly process of testing associations. She must interpret evidence while living with a mind that makes uncertainty physically difficult to bear.

The Trophies in the Garage

A necklace exposes Angela's husband, not the foreman

Angela finds that Leonard lives near where Samantha Rodgers’s body was discovered, then sees red marks on her friend Bill Blackwell’s neck that resemble the injuries left by a noose. Her attention shifts to her own husband, Thomas, when she reads that Samantha wore a distinctive peridot-and-diamond necklace.

Angela recognizes it from a box in her garage, then uncovers Clarissa Manning’s purse and identification among Thomas’s stored possessions. Thomas returns unexpectedly, realizes she has searched, empties the garage and basement, and burns the Kenosha warehouse.

Before he can contain everything, Angela sends police a package of her research, the necklace, and Clarissa’s ID. She escapes to Greta Schreiber, the nurse who once helped her, and hides while Thomas’s wife is presumed dead.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The decisive evidence is intimate rather than forensic: a necklace misplaced in a familiar garage and a victim’s purse hidden among household clutter. Angela’s danger comes from having mistaken the crime’s distance. The killer is not merely near her home or connected to her social circle; he has been sharing her domestic space. Thomas’s cleanup shows how control over a home can conceal violence as effectively as a remote hideout. Angela’s package changes private observation into public evidence, but escape demands a second act of concealment, one meant to protect her from the person closest to her.

Frank Follows the Ghost

Catherine links Rory's father to Angela's disappearance

At Stateville, Rory meets Thomas Mitchell and learns that Frank had managed more than his appeals and parole paperwork. Thomas describes him as his only regular connection to the outside. Rory then contacts Catherine Blackwell, Angela’s closest friend, hoping to learn what happened in 1979.

Catherine says she never believed Angela was murdered and recalls that Frank visited her in 1981, asking about Angela after Thomas’s conviction. Catherine refused to help because she feared Thomas was searching for his wife.

The name unsettles Rory: Frank had not merely defended a notorious client, he had privately pursued Angela’s whereabouts. In a parallel 1981 thread, Frank visits the psychiatric facility where Angela once lived, then follows a lead to Greta Schreiber’s farmhouse.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Catherine’s certainty is emotionally compelling but not automatically reliable. Her belief that Angela survived rests on a memory of Frank’s search, and Rory must distinguish what that history proves from what Catherine hopes it means. Frank’s involvement makes the old case a family mystery rather than a historical curiosity. His legal work and private investigation seem to point in opposite directions: he helps Mitchell remain represented while looking for the woman whose testimony helped convict him. The tension invites suspicion without yet revealing whether Frank’s divided loyalties serve the client, Angela, or someone else.

A Child Hidden in the House

Greta shelters Angela, then Frank builds a life around secrecy

Frank discovers that Greta, a nurse and former friend of Angela, sheltered her after her escape. Angela had been pregnant and feared Thomas would find her. When complications struck during childbirth, Greta could not save her; the infant survived. Frank and his wife, Marla, agree to raise the child, while Frank leaves his law firm and keeps Thomas as a client so he can control what the imprisoned man learns.

He claims to search for Angela, keeping Thomas from hiring someone else. The child becomes Rory. Frank and Marla raise her as their daughter, and Greta remains close, providing the quiet farmhouse and doll-restoration work that help Rory manage her anxiety. Angela’s body remains undiscovered, leaving the world to assume she vanished.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The protection offered here depends on a morally complicated bargain. Frank uses the attorney-client relationship not only to serve Mitchell but to manage his access to information, turning professional loyalty into a shield for Angela’s child. Marla’s care makes the concealment more than a strategy: it becomes a family built through deliberate love, though its origin is withheld from Rory. Greta’s dolls and flowers carry different forms of memory. Restoration gives Rory a structure for distress, while the hidden history beneath the farmhouse remains beyond her conscious understanding. Safety is achieved, but only by making truth difficult to inherit.

The Safe-Deposit Revelation

Rory finds adoption papers as Mitchell's release nears

Rory inspects Mitchell’s secluded cabin near Starved Rock with Lane, the parole officer, and a social worker. Back in Chicago, Frank’s assistant, Celia, reveals that she was Frank’s partner and gives Rory the key to his safe-deposit box. The box contains adoption documents and a birth certificate that overturn Rory’s understanding of her childhood: Frank and Marla adopted her, and Greta is listed as her birth mother.

Rory also discovers Frank’s notes tracing Angela’s life, but cannot yet make the connection whole. Mitchell is released under cover of darkness and driven to the cabin. He has spent decades recording every lead Frank gave him, and begins following those notes to find Angela and complete the search he never abandoned.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The paperwork destabilizes Rory because it converts a vague family history into an administrative fact. Documents are usually her instruments of clarity, yet here they disclose a truth that her emotional life was built to survive without knowing. Celia’s revelation about her relationship with Frank adds another layer: the father Rory mourns had a private life and a long strategy she could not see. Meanwhile, Mitchell’s release makes the past active again. Frank’s concealment protected Rory for years, but the structure depends on Mitchell never reaching the people who know where Angela went.

The Visitor's Handwriting

Mitchell finds Greta, and Rory spots his signature

After his release, Mitchell pursues the names Frank recorded. He goes to Greta’s nursing home, where dementia leaves her unable to give him the answer he wants; when she refuses to reveal Angela’s whereabouts, he kills her. He also lures Catherine to the Starved Rock cabin, where she becomes another target. Rory learns that Greta has died and, grief-stricken, returns to the home to examine its visitor log.

The neat block letters beside Greta’s name contain a distinctive un-crossed A, matching Mitchell’s handwriting in letters from prison. Rory understands that he reached Greta before her death. The clue turns her suspicion into urgency: the man she helped release is now hunting down everyone connected to Angela.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The handwriting clue transforms an ordinary sign-in sheet into a forensic trace. Rory’s memory stores visual details without always explaining their importance at once; recognition arrives only after grief and repetition make the pattern legible. This is the novel’s central contrast between evidence and understanding: the mark was visible all along, but its meaning required a mind capable of connecting it to an earlier document. Greta’s death also removes the person Rory most wants to question. The failure is not only investigative; it is intimate, because the chance to ask about her own origins disappears with Greta.

The Graves Behind the Cabin

Rory finds Catherine and hides as Mitchell returns

Rory drives alone to Starved Rock, following the route she knows from the release inspection. Behind the cabin, she falls into a freshly dug pit. Inside, Mitchell has left papers and a survey map marked with the names of the women who disappeared in 1979, laid out as a burial plan. On the screened porch, Rory finds Catherine dead beneath the same M-shaped pulley apparatus Angela once drew.

Before Rory can call for help, a flashlight approaches. She slips into the pantry as Mitchell enters, eats, and plays Mozart’s Requiem. Through a narrow gap, Rory watches him move around the kitchen, unaware she is inside. The map, the body, and the approaching killer make escape possible, but would leave the buried victims undiscovered.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The open grave gives Rory a literal encounter with the work of reconstruction: she has stumbled into the landscape that will explain the old disappearances. The map turns names into a planned geography of erasure, while Catherine’s body confirms that Mitchell’s violence has continued after prison. Rory’s choice to hide rather than flee is not simple bravery. She understands that leaving would preserve her safety while abandoning the evidence and the victims whose stories she has spent her career recovering. Her professional ethic becomes physical risk, stripped of the distance that normally lets her study a crime after the fact.

The Stool Falls

Rory interrupts Mitchell's ritual and exposes the graves

Mitchell recreates the pulley ritual, fastening one noose around his own neck and using his weight to lift Catherine’s body opposite him. As he nears unconsciousness, Rory leaves the pantry and approaches. She folds away the knife she brought, then kicks the stool from beneath him before he can regain his footing. Mitchell cannot free himself from the noose.

Rory lowers Catherine’s body, calls the parole number, and leaves the phone on the table before walking out. Investigators later find the map and uncover the missing women behind the cabin. The scene is treated as Mitchell’s suicide, and Rory’s role remains hidden. The victims finally receive names and graves, though Angela is not among the remains found there.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Rory ends Mitchell’s control by exploiting the mechanism he built for himself. The act is both deliberate and morally charged: she does not merely survive an attack but decides that his life should end, after seeing what his system has done to Catherine and the missing women. Her decision echoes the novel’s question about choice without reducing it to a clean verdict. She also makes a second choice afterward, preserving the appearance of suicide and withholding her own intervention. Public justice arrives through recovered bodies, but the private truth remains carefully managed.

Roses at the Field's Edge

Rory understands Angela's fate and keeps her lineage private

After Greta’s death, Rory dreams of Camille, whose restored doll and shadow help her connect the signs she has carried since childhood. She understands that Angela was her birth mother and died after giving birth, while Frank and Marla raised Rory under a protective silence. In December, Rory returns Camille’s repaired Kestner doll to Walter Byrd and promises to devote herself to solving his daughter’s murder.

Then she drives to Greta’s old farmhouse, walks to the field where she once found roses, and lays down a fresh bundle. All of Thomas’s 1979 victims have been identified, but Angela’s remains are still absent from the cabin graves. Rory chooses not to expose the family history that Frank, Marla, and Greta concealed to protect her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ending distinguishes closure from disclosure. The recovered victims allow families and investigators to name what Mitchell did, but Rory does not treat every truth as public property. Her decision to protect Angela’s story repeats the protective secrecy that shaped her childhood, yet now it is conscious rather than imposed. Returning Camille’s doll also restores Rory to the work she had postponed: she can honor the dead without confusing one case with another. The roses bind memory to place, turning a childhood mystery into a chosen act of mourning. Rory has not solved every sorrow, but she decides what she will carry forward.

Analysis

Some Choose Darkness builds its thriller around the difference between seeing a fact and knowing what it means. Angela notices patterns that others dismiss, but her autism and compulsions make it easy for authority figures to treat her observations as symptoms. Rory inherits a related perceptual gift: images remain vivid, yet significance often arrives later, when a mark in a visitor log connects to a prison letter or a remembered shadow. The book makes cognition both instrument and liability. Memory can preserve evidence, but it cannot protect anyone without trust, interpretation, and action.

Its family plot complicates the usual opposition between truth and deception. Frank, Marla, and Greta conceal Rory’s origins, not to exploit her, but to give her a childhood outside Thomas Mitchell’s reach. Their silence protects her and deprives her of knowledge at the same time. Rory eventually inherits the burden of that choice. She understands that public exposure would satisfy curiosity while potentially undoing the refuge her family constructed, so she keeps Angela’s story private even as she helps recover the other victims. The doll and the roses provide contrasting models of repair. A damaged object can be restored through patient labor, though the history of its fracture remains. The roses cannot undo Angela’s death or restore the years Rory spent without the truth; they can only mark a place of remembrance. Rory’s work for Camille’s father also prevents her private revelation from consuming her professional identity. She returns to the unsolved murder she accepted at the beginning, carrying grief and knowledge without mistaking either for closure. The novel’s final moral choice is therefore not whether truth matters, but who has the right to disclose it, and what protection may justifiably require.

Summary in 60 Seconds
Forensic artist Rory Moore takes on the unsolved murder of Camille Byrd just as her father dies. While settling his affairs, she discovers he represented Thomas Mitchell, a convicted wife-killer nearing parole, and investigates the case. In 1979, Angela Mitchell had tracked missing women to a hidden room and sent evidence to police before escaping her husband. Pregnant, she died in childbirth, and Rory's adoptive parents raised her as their own. After Mitchell's release, he kills Greta, the nurse who sheltered Angela, and Catherine, Angela's friend. Rory finds Catherine's body and Mitchell's map of the missing women's burial sites. She disrupts his strangulation ritual, leaving him to die by his own noose, and alerts authorities, who recover the victims' remains. Rory learns the full truth of her origins but keeps it private, then returns to Camille's case.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.2 out of 5
Average of 52k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Some Choose Darkness is widely praised as one of Charlie Donlea's best works, earning an impressive 4.23 average rating. Reviewers consistently highlight the compelling dual timeline structure, alternating between 1979 and the present. The book's two autistic female protagonists, Rory Moore and Angela Mitchell, are celebrated as original, intelligent, and deeply human characters. Many readers found the pacing gripping and addictive, finishing it in a single sitting. While some guessed certain plot twists early, most were genuinely surprised by the ending's impact.

Your rating:
4.81
2 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Rory Moore

Forensic pattern reader

Rory is a Chicago forensic reconstructionist whose exceptional visual memory and attention to detail let her find order in crime scenes other investigators consider cold. She manages obsessive-compulsive symptoms and social anxiety through routines, solitude, and the restoration of antique dolls. Her reserve is not indifference; she forms intense attachments to victims, though she often finds objects and evidence easier to approach than living people. Lane understands both her professional gifts and her need for distance, while her father and Greta have long offered forms of safety she cannot easily request. Rory is driven by unfinished patterns, a habit that makes her invaluable at work and vulnerable when a case reaches into her private life.

Thomas Mitchell

Parole-seeking prison client

Thomas is a long-incarcerated Chicago killer approaching release after decades in prison. He has adapted to confinement by cultivating patience, a careful public manner, and a command of the details surrounding his case. His attorney, Frank Moore, has managed his appeals and finances for years, making their relationship unusually close. Thomas is preoccupied with a past he believes remains unresolved, and he treats his coming freedom as an opportunity to pursue it. The contrast between his calm presentation and the violence attached to his name makes him difficult for others to read, especially when he frames self-interest as ordinary planning.

Angela Mitchell

Isolated pattern hunter

Angela is an autistic woman whose memory, precision, and focus allow her to notice connections that police and newspapers overlook. Social contact can overwhelm her, and obsessive-compulsive symptoms sometimes turn fear into exhausting cycles of checking and self-injury. Her marriage gives her a sense of belonging, but she remains guarded about the parts of herself that other people have misunderstood or pathologized. When women disappear across Chicago, Angela studies their lives with a seriousness that grows beyond a hobby. Her investigation reflects both her vulnerability and her intelligence: she can see a pattern others miss, yet must persuade people to take her evidence seriously.

Frank Moore

Criminal defense attorney

Frank is Rory’s father and a criminal defense lawyer who builds a small practice after beginning his career at a major firm. He is ambitious, capable, and deeply protective of his family, but his instinct to manage problems privately can place him under years of pressure. His representation of Thomas Mitchell becomes the longest and most consequential relationship of his professional life. At home, he is a loving parent whose careful choices shape Rory’s sense of safety. His story asks how far professional duty can stretch before it becomes a cover for a different obligation, and what a parent may conceal in the name of protection.

Greta Schreiber

Doll-restoring family anchor

Greta is a nurse and midwife who offers practical compassion to people whom institutions have failed to understand. Her friendship with Angela begins when Angela is isolated in a psychiatric facility, and Greta becomes one of the few adults willing to listen without reducing her to a diagnosis. She also gives young Rory a patient, tactile way to manage anxiety through repairing china dolls. In old age, dementia pulls Greta between present relationships and distressing memories from her work. Her identity as caretaker is both strength and burden: she repeatedly accepts responsibility for people whose safety depends on someone willing to act.

Lane Phillips

Profiler and research partner

Lane is Rory’s longtime intimate partner and collaborator in the Murder Accountability Project. A former FBI profiler and forensic psychology expert, he studies patterns across homicides and gives law enforcement tools to identify serial offenders. His easy manner contrasts with Rory’s guardedness, but he understands her routines and does not demand conventional displays of affection. Lane’s work leaves him sensitive to the psychological cost of entering a killer’s mind, a cost that once pushed him away from direct profiling. He supports Rory without pretending that her risks are harmless, and his loyalty gives her a rare source of steadiness.

Catherine Blackwell

Angela's loyal friend

Catherine is Angela’s closest friend in 1979 and Bill’s wife. She accepts Angela’s unusual habits more generously than most people do, but her support has limits when Angela’s theories begin to implicate people in their shared community. Decades later, Catherine continues seeking answers through a Facebook page and carefully preserved records. Her persistence is fueled by loyalty and regret, especially over the moment she doubted Angela. Catherine’s belief and Rory’s forensic skepticism do not always align, but both women are trying to give Angela’s story a shape that the original investigation failed to provide.

Camille Byrd

Unsolved homicide victim

Camille is Walter Byrd’s twenty-two-year-old daughter, a recent college graduate whose murder in Grant Park remains unsolved when Rory takes the case. Her childhood Kestner doll is a cherished object and the first connection Rory makes to her life. The case file reveals a young woman with plans beyond college, not simply a victim reduced to the circumstances of her death. Camille matters to Rory because her story is unfinished, and because the doll gives her father a tangible link to the daughter he lost. The investigation becomes a measure of Rory’s responsibility to return to the work she accepted.

Walter Byrd

Grieving father and client

Walter is a wealthy businessman whose daughter Camille was murdered. He first approaches Rory to repair Camille’s porcelain doll, then reveals that he hopes her forensic skill can also reopen the investigation. His grief emerges through his attachment to the damaged keepsake and his frustration with detectives who have moved on. Walter is not merely seeking a culprit; he wants someone to treat Camille as a person whose life still deserves attention. His trust in Rory gives her a responsibility she struggles to meet while her father’s death and the Mitchell case consume her.

Ron Davidson

Homicide division chief

Ron leads Chicago Homicide and has worked with Rory long enough to understand her unusual boundaries and rely on her rare reconstruction skills. He is practical, politically pressured, and willing to use unconventional methods to bring Rory back from a break when a case needs her. Their friendship allows him to speak plainly, though he sometimes pushes her past her comfort zone. Ron respects Rory’s ability but also expects accountability, particularly when victims’ families are waiting for news. He represents the police institution at its most human, still burdened by workload, unsolved cases, and limited resources.

Celia Banner

Keeper of a hidden key

Celia is the administrator at Frank Moore’s law office and the person who discovers him after his death. Her years of working beside Frank have made her both efficient and emotionally invested in the firm’s history. She shares a private relationship with him that Rory does not know about, and the secret weighs on her after Frank is gone. Celia’s decision to bring Rory the safe-deposit key turns a hidden archive into a family revelation. Her role is small in the investigation but crucial in the transfer of knowledge from Frank’s private life to his daughter.

Marla Moore

Patient family builder

Marla is Frank’s wife, a woman whose repeated miscarriages have made the hope of raising a child emotionally fraught. She listens as Frank and Greta explain the circumstances surrounding a possible child, then makes a deliberate commitment despite the danger and secrecy involved. Her care is grounded rather than idealized: she needs to understand what she is agreeing to, and she does not mistake love for an easy solution. Marla provides the warmth of a stable home, balancing Frank’s strategic mind with the daily work of making a child feel wanted.

Bill Blackwell

Construction partner and husband

Bill is Thomas Mitchell’s business partner and Catherine’s husband. He works in construction, manages crews, and hires Leonard Williams as a foreman. His blunt reactions to Angela’s behavior expose the casual cruelty she has often encountered, even within a circle she hopes might accept her. Bill is not an investigator; he is part of the ordinary social world Angela struggles to navigate.

Leonard Williams

New foreman, false suspect

Leonard is a newly hired foreman for Mitchell-Blackwell Construction. Angela recognizes him as the stranger who once approached her in an alley, and his address near a victim’s discovery makes him appear suspicious. His presence gives Angela a plausible but misleading lead before her attention shifts to the evidence closer to home.

Judge Russell Boyle

Parole terms enforcer

Judge Boyle oversees the final arrangements for Thomas Mitchell’s parole and insists Rory take responsibility for the case after Frank’s death. He treats release as an administrative process with public consequences, setting conditions for Mitchell’s residence, finances, and supervision. His decisions force Rory into a role she would otherwise avoid.

Ezra Parker

Assigned parole officer

Ezra is the parole officer assigned to supervise Thomas Mitchell after release. He joins the inspection of the Starved Rock cabin and confirms the practical requirements for Mitchell’s residence. His role embodies the state’s attempt to monitor a high-profile parolee while keeping the process discreet.

Naomi Brown

Release-planning social worker

Naomi is the social worker responsible for assessing Thomas Mitchell’s transition from prison. She accompanies Rory and Ezra to the cabin and checks whether it meets the court’s conditions. Her work brings routine oversight to an arrangement made unusually delicate by Mitchell’s notoriety.

Dr. Dale Jefferson

Psychiatric facility physician

Dr. Jefferson once worked at the juvenile psychiatric facility where Angela spent part of her adolescence. Frank consults him while tracing Angela’s history, and Jefferson points him toward the nurse who helped her leave. He provides a fragment of the past without knowing how consequential the lead will become.

Plot Devices

The pulley and nooses

Violence made into ritual

The M-shaped pulley rig allows the killer to use his own weight to raise a victim while placing a noose around his own neck. Angela discovers a version hidden in a warehouse, draws it as evidence, and later Rory finds the apparatus rebuilt at the cabin. It gives the killer’s violence a recognizable physical signature and links the 1979 investigation to the final confrontation. The device also makes his craving dangerous to himself, a risk Rory eventually turns against him.

Angela's paper archive

Patterns before computers

Angela assembles newspaper clippings, victim biographies, older homicide reports, and hand-drawn charts to argue that the current disappearances belong to a longer series. Her archive makes her observations legible to police and later gives Rory a way to understand the case. Its paper form matters: Angela must manually search and compare records, while her precise memory allows distant facts to converge. The archive establishes her intelligence before the legal system reduces her to a diagnosis.

The damaged Kestner doll

A bridge into memory

Camille Byrd’s cracked porcelain doll brings Rory into contact with Camille’s father and starts her renewed work on the murder. Repairing it also gives Rory a familiar, structured task when grief and panic threaten her concentration. The doll connects Rory to Greta, who taught her restoration, and ultimately helps trigger an insight during Rory’s dreams. Its repaired face offers a concrete contrast to the unresolved damage of the homicide, while the object remains a personal memorial rather than mere evidence.

The bundled roses

A private memorial marker

Greta’s daily rose gathering first appears as a domestic ritual observed by a child. The flowers are carried to a secluded corner of the property, where the child later finds them and feels inexplicable calm. Years afterward, Rory returns to the farmhouse with a fresh bundle and leaves it at that same place. The roses connect concealed family history, childhood memory, and mourning without requiring a public explanation. Their sweetness is a sensory clue that survives what people have forgotten or chosen not to say.

A shield built from trust

Frank handles Mitchell’s appeals, finances, property, and parole for decades, while privately maintaining a search that serves a different purpose. Trusts keep the cabin and money difficult to trace, and Frank’s control of information prevents Mitchell from easily pursuing every lead himself. The arrangement allows Frank to protect people connected to Angela while maintaining the appearance of ordinary representation. After Frank dies, his records and safe-deposit box become the trail Rory must follow to understand both his choices and her own history.

About the Author

Charlie Donlea is a USA TODAY, IndieBound, and #1 internationally bestselling thriller author whose works include The Girl Who Was Taken, Don't Believe It, Twenty Years Later, and Those Empty Eyes. His ninth thriller, Guess Again, is currently available. Published across 40 countries and translated into twenty-five languages, his books have sold nearly 3 million copies in the U.S. alone. A Chicago resident, Donlea annually ventures to remote Canadian wilderness with his father, accessible only by floatplane — experiences that have directly inspired several of his novel settings.

Download PDF

To save this Some Choose Darkness summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.31 MB     Pages: 22

Download EPUB

To read this Some Choose Darkness summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.31 MB     Pages: 30
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...