Key Takeaways
Choose a startup location by the resources your growth plan actually needs
Location shapes access. Startups rely on more than office space. They need customers, skilled employees, investors, and advice, and those relationships often develop through repeated face-to-face contact. A Startup Common is a region’s shared pool of these resources. It grows when entrepreneurs and investors put back some of the capital, talent, and knowledge they draw from it. If the pool is depleted, ambitious founders may leave for a better-supplied region.
Fit beats prestige. The book’s 2017 snapshot found that San Francisco and Silicon Valley together attracted $7.75 billion in venture funding in one quarter, or 42 percent of the total cited. Yet Wayfair built its business in Boston, drawing on strengths in retail, branding, logistics, technology, and universities. Founders should compare a region’s resources with their company’s needs, rather than treating Silicon Valley as the answer for every startup.
The framework makes location an operating decision, not a lifestyle afterthought. A founder can use it to ask which relationships must be nearby, which can be built remotely, and which are missing altogether. The emphasis on repeated encounters also explains why online access alone may not replace a local network of trust. Still, the framework describes concentrations of resources more clearly than it predicts which particular company will succeed. A strong regional network improves access; it cannot substitute for a sound product or a capable team.
Build companies that replenish the city, not just extract its talent
Success can compound locally. Pillar companies are publicly traded local firms that support startups as customers, investors, employers, acquirers, or sources of experienced talent. Their alumni may start companies or invest in younger founders, helping create another generation of successes. The Pillar Company Staircase describes five broad stages, from cities with no pillars or fast-growing startups to regions with many pillars in huge markets.
A headquarters is not enough. Silicon Valley’s Fairchild Semiconductor helped seed companies such as Intel, while Israel’s Check Point Software produced founders who started or financed more security companies. By contrast, the book describes EMC as an anti-pillar because it used non-compete litigation against a former executive who joined startup SANgate. The lesson is reciprocal behavior: a large company can strengthen a startup community, or make it harder for one to emerge.
This model explains why one famous company rarely transforms a region by itself. The important mechanism is circulation: people, capital, customers, and experience move from established firms into new ventures and back again. It also usefully separates a company’s size from its local contribution. A profitable corporation can be economically important without nourishing startups. The staircase should be treated as a diagnostic, not a ranking of civic worth. Regions with a narrow industrial base may grow quickly, but become vulnerable if their dominant companies stagnate or leave.
Make universities commercial partners, not just talent factories
Research needs a route to market. Universities can contribute professors, students, intellectual property, licensing offices, incubators, internships, and an attitude toward entrepreneurship. The strongest contribution comes when these pieces connect: researchers can commercialize useful discoveries, students can join startups, and faculty entrepreneurship is respected rather than penalized.
Culture and proximity matter. MIT reported that its alumni had created 30,200 active companies, while Stanford alumni had created nearly 40,000 companies, according to figures cited in the book. Yet Worcester’s medical school licensed valuable technology to companies that often located in Cambridge, where relevant talent was more concentrated. Stanford also illustrates a risk: Clinkle, a student-led payments startup, raised more than $30 million with extensive university connections, then collapsed amid weak oversight and a product that failed to match its promise. Support matters, but it must include scrutiny.
Universities can act as bridges between knowledge and markets, but a licensing office cannot manufacture demand or an experienced founding team. The book’s cases suggest that incentives matter: what a university rewards in hiring and promotion influences whether researchers invest effort in commercial work. Clinkle adds an important qualification. Close institutional ties can speed access to mentors and capital, while also making it easier for prestige to stand in for evidence. The useful question is not simply whether a university supports startups, but whether it helps founders test assumptions and fill capability gaps.
Hire for the company you intend to become, not its current size
Skills change with ambition. A small lifestyle business may need only a few complementary capabilities. A company aiming for international growth needs expertise across engineering, sales, marketing, operations, customer service, and leadership. The book distinguishes three founder types: amblers grow at a measured pace, sprinters seek a relatively quick sale or public offering, and marathoners build large companies capable of sustained growth.
Location can solve one gap and create another. Israeli startups often kept research and development at home while placing sales and executive functions in the United States. Hong Kong’s AfterShip used programmers in India and Poland when local product-development talent was scarce. At the other end of the spectrum, Stockholm’s housing shortage discouraged a German startup from relocating despite the city’s startup reputation. A founder should map missing skills, likely hiring costs, and the practical ability to attract people before choosing a headquarters.
The people-first view connects startup strategy to labor economics: a region’s specialized workforce can lower the risk and cost of assembling a team, while a scarce skill can make growth prohibitively expensive. The book also resists the assumption that every function must sit in one city. Distributed teams can address local shortages, but coordination then becomes a management capability of its own. The founder’s ambition matters too. A deliberate small company may be well served by a lower-cost location, while a global growth plan can make access to experienced executives essential.
Match each funding round to the milestone, and beware excess money
Capital has stages. A startup first needs money to test a business model, often through founder funds, friends and family, or crowdfunding. Once customers show the model can work, angel investors may help it grow locally. Expansion into new markets can require larger venture-capital investments, and a public offering or acquisition may provide investors with an exit. A founder should raise the kind of capital suited to the next challenge, while understanding the control and obligations that accompany it.
More money can worsen a weak bet. Zoom raised substantial venture funding after its product gained customers, then used investor networks and advice to support growth. Juicero raised nearly $120 million for an expensive juicing machine whose basic function could be performed by hand. Jawbone raised about $900 million over its life but ultimately shut down. Capital access can accelerate a strong business, but it can also amplify poor judgment and delay a necessary reckoning.
The staged approach treats fundraising as a tool for resolving specific uncertainties, rather than as a scorecard. That distinction helps founders avoid selling ownership before they know what the business needs. The caution about excess funding is equally important: abundant capital can finance experimentation, but it can also reward persuasive storytelling over product evidence. Investors face a related problem. A region rich in successful exits can attract competition and risk-taking, yet fear of missing out may weaken due diligence. Neither scarcity nor abundance guarantees good allocation.
Seek mentors for named problems, not networking theater
Advice works best when targeted. Startup mentors can help with strategy, fundraising, hiring, company culture, product design, sales, operations, and acquisitions. The founder’s job is to identify a specific problem, find someone with relevant experience, explain why solving it matters, and follow up on the advice. A mentor is not a substitute for the founder’s judgment.
A good network can change a founder’s range. Engineer Mohit Aron, after cofounding Nutanix, sought advice from experienced executives while building Cohesity. His mentors helped him improve sales hiring, describe product benefits in terms customers cared about, and reach potential customers. In contrast, Paris founders warned that too many generic mentoring programs could distract entrepreneurs. Formal support can help a young startup, as Worcester’s Petricore Games found through peer feedback, but founders still need to select mentors for the challenges they actually face.
Mentoring is a form of organizational learning: it transfers experience that a young company cannot efficiently acquire through trial and error alone. Specific questions make that transfer more useful and make it easier to judge whether advice fits the company’s situation. The relationship also has to be reciprocal enough to last, whether through updates, collaboration, or future support for other founders. There is a limit, however. A mentor’s previous success does not guarantee that the same prescription applies to a new market, product, or team. Advice should sharpen a decision, not replace testing it.
A startup city’s values decide whether risk compounds or gets punished
Norms shape practical choices. The book maps startup values along two dimensions: appetite for risk and the time investors and founders are willing to wait for returns. Silicon Valley was described as more accepting of failure and more willing to pursue large opportunities over longer periods. Boston’s founders and investors often favored technical business markets and earlier exits. In Hong Kong, expensive real estate and family pressure toward banking or consulting could make entrepreneurship seem like an unnecessarily risky career.
Role models can shift expectations. In Stockholm, the success of companies such as Skype and Minecraft helped make startups more attractive, and Skype cofounder Niklas Zennström reinvested in local ventures. The contrast is a founder who sells out and leaves, or a celebrated startup that fails after investors overlook warning signs. Risk tolerance can encourage experimentation, but it can also excuse reckless leadership or unsupported claims.
Values are not just slogans. They are reflected in what families recommend, what universities reward, how investors treat failure, and whether successful founders return to help. Visible local successes can alter these expectations because they make an unfamiliar career path concrete. Yet a culture that celebrates risk can become a culture that excuses weak evidence. The useful distinction is between thoughtful risk and unaccountable risk. A healthy startup community can tolerate a failed experiment while still demanding honesty, sound governance, and respect for employees.
Build around local strengths, then fix the housing that growth strains
Start with evidence, not imitation. The book proposes a city-building process: bring entrepreneurs, businesses, universities, investors, government, and community leaders together; study other regions’ successes and failures; identify skills the city can credibly excel in; agree on a realistic vision; attract capable founders; and prepare housing, infrastructure, and cultural amenities for growth. Government can help, but the process cannot guarantee a pioneering founder or a successful company.
Subsidies do not create a community on their own. Chattanooga invested in high-speed fiber and attracted startups, including one later acquired for about $12 million, but the new jobs did not offset all losses from the downturn. Chile’s Start-Up Chile program distributed grants to visiting startups, yet 68 percent of participants had left the country. Meanwhile, successful hubs can price out workers and deter new firms. Infrastructure and talent retention are part of startup policy, not afterthoughts.
The city methodology is strongest as a discipline for coordinating stakeholders and making local strengths explicit. Its restraint is equally valuable: public officials can improve connectivity, education, and livability, but they cannot schedule a breakout company. A city should therefore assess policies by durable outcomes, not publicity or the number of incubator desks created. Growth also distributes gains unevenly. Rising property values may enrich owners while pushing workers away. If a startup strategy ignores housing access and transport, it can undermine the talent pool that made the region attractive.
Analysis
Startup Cities turns a familiar question, why do firms cluster in certain places, into a more operational one: what resources move through a startup region, and do successful firms replenish them? Its strongest contribution is treating companies, universities, talent, capital, mentors, and values as interacting parts rather than isolated policy levers. The Worcester and Cambridge comparison makes the idea concrete. Geographic distance alone does not explain divergent outcomes; density of relationships, commercial norms, and experienced people can matter more than the presence of colleges on a map.
The framework also improves on simple Silicon Valley imitation. Its five-stage Pillar Company Staircase gives city leaders a way to distinguish a region with promising startups but no exits from one with experienced founders and established local companies. That distinction matters because a seed grant, university incubator, or fiber network addresses different constraints at different stages. The cases suggest that public investment is most useful when it complements real capabilities and private actors, rather than trying to manufacture a complete ecosystem from scratch.
There are limits. The book’s cases are rich but do not establish how much each factor independently causes success. Successful cities may attract talent and capital because they are already successful, making cause and effect difficult to separate. The staircase can also imply a single ladder, even though a region may thrive in a specialized field without becoming a broad, Silicon Valley-style hub. Local policy should therefore define success in terms of durable firms, good jobs, and reinvestment, not only unicorns or public listings.
The framework’s most useful practical implication is a change in scale. Founders should choose locations around their particular growth bottlenecks, while city leaders should ask what their region can credibly support and what success might strain. Startup geography is neither destiny nor irrelevant. It is an evolving set of advantages, constraints, and relationships that people can strengthen, neglect, or outgrow.
Review Summary
Startup cities receives high praise from readers, with an overall rating of 4.00 out of 5 stars based on 5 reviews. One reader, likely an entrepreneurship educator, gave it a perfect 5-star rating. They found the book particularly valuable for ecosystem builders, entrepreneurship educators, and innovators. The reader emphasized its practical applications, noting how it helped implement new ideas into designing an entrepreneurial micro-ecosystem at a university campus. The book appears to offer actionable insights for developing and nurturing startup environments.
Glossary
Startup Common
Local startup resource poolThe regional system of resources that startups draw on and help replenish. It consists of pillar companies, universities, human capital, investment capital, mentor networks, and shared values. The concept emphasizes that founders need more than funding or talent alone, and that a region’s startup capacity weakens when firms consume resources without returning experience, capital, or opportunity.
Pillar Company Staircase
Five stages of startup developmentA five-level framework for assessing a region’s startup development. It ranges from no pillar companies and no fast-growing startups, through stages with emerging or acquired gazelles and niche-market pillars, to regions with many pillars in huge markets. The levels help local stakeholders distinguish their current position and choose policies suited to their actual strengths and gaps.
Pillar companies
Local firms that seed startupsPublicly traded local companies that can support startups by serving as customers, investors, acquirers, or sources of experienced employees. Their founders and employees may also start ventures or invest in younger firms. A company’s local presence alone does not make it a pillar: it must contribute resources or opportunities to the surrounding startup community.
Gazelles
Fast-growing startup companiesThe book uses the Kauffman Foundation’s term for startups intended to grow quickly, rather than small businesses primarily designed to support a founder and staff. Gazelles seek new customers and markets and may aim for an acquisition or public offering. Because they need larger amounts of talent and capital as they scale, they tend to cluster in particular regions.
Entrepreneurial Ecosystem
Country-level capital conditionsA framework for understanding why countries attract differing amounts of private capital. It comprises corporate governance, financial markets, human capital, and intellectual property protection. The book argues that these factors are useful for national comparisons but do not explain differences between regions within one country as well as the Startup Common framework does.
Amblers
Founders seeking gradual growthOne of three founder types used to describe growth ambition. Amblers build companies at a measured pace, often aiming to support themselves and their employees rather than pursue rapid expansion. The book associates this type most often with regions that lack pillar companies, where access to large amounts of capital and scaling experience may be limited.
Sprinters
Founders pursuing a quick exitOne of three founder types used to describe growth ambition. Sprinters aim to grow a company quickly and sell it or take it public, often without wanting to operate a large public company for the long term. The book suggests that some sprinters can develop into marathoners as they gain the experience and ambition to sustain larger firms.
Marathoners
Founders building enduring giantsOne of three founder types used to describe growth ambition. Marathoners build companies from early ideas into large public firms and continue managing their growth. The book presents them as essential to regions that want to develop major pillar companies, and notes that successful sprinters may learn the management skills required to become marathoners.
Startup Common Building Methodology
Six-step city planning processA process for local leaders seeking to strengthen a city’s startup activity. It begins by assembling stakeholders, then studies other regions, assesses local strengths, sets a shared vision, attracts capable entrepreneurs, and develops the housing and infrastructure needed to support growth. The methodology encourages evidence-based planning while recognizing that government cannot guarantee entrepreneurial success.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.