Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Telling Ain't Training

Telling Ain't Training

Your best presentation may have taught nothing. How trainers can tell, and what to build instead.
by Harold D. Stolovitch 2002 559 pages
4.09
467 ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Key Takeaways

Turn presentations into measurable learner capability, not polished information delivery

Learning means change. A memorable opening challenge asks readers to recall an 18-digit sequence. Most struggle until they recognize the numbers as familiar calendar and time relationships. In another challenge, written directions confuse readers, while a map makes the same route easier to remember. The lesson is that content alone does not ensure learning. Learners must actively make sense of it and become able to do something new.

Choose the outcome first. The book distinguishes training, which builds consistent execution; instruction, which helps people adapt knowledge to new situations; and education, which develops broader mental models and values. A product session succeeds not because the presenter was entertaining or the manuals were thorough, but because learners can position and sell the products.

Analysis

The opening challenges work because they make the reader experience the difference between receiving information and organizing it. This echoes a central principle in cognitive science: people learn by connecting new material to what they already understand, not by exposure alone. The performance emphasis also gives training a useful test: what can a learner reliably do afterward? That measure needs care, though. Some important outcomes, such as judgment or ethical awareness, develop gradually and cannot be captured by a single immediate task.

Teach novices in the form of knowledge they must use

Knowing differs from doing. Declarative knowledge is the ability to name, describe, or explain something. Procedural knowledge is the ability to carry it out. A skilled cyclist may balance instinctively yet struggle to explain the movements involved. Likewise, a grandmother may bake an excellent pie but have difficulty listing precise instructions. Expertise often lives in practiced action, not in words.

Experts see patterns. In a chess study described in the book, experienced players remembered scattered pieces better than novices because they recognized meaningful arrangements. But those expert patterns can make explanations hard for beginners, who see many separate details. Teaching therefore needs to match the goal: explain concepts when learners must reason or adapt, and provide guided practice when they must perform. Often, people need both.

Analysis

This distinction helps explain why asking a high performer to teach can fail even when that person is generous and knowledgeable. Expertise compresses experience into patterns that are difficult for a novice to perceive. The same issue appears in medicine, craft, and software debugging: a specialist may recognize a situation without being able to narrate each cue. Effective instruction makes those cues visible, then gives learners practice applying them. Yet explanation should not be discarded. It supports adaptation when conditions change, while practice builds fluency in familiar conditions.

Make learning relevant, respectful, participatory, and immediately usable

Adults arrive with stakes. The book’s four adult learning principles are readiness, experience, autonomy, and action. Readiness rises when people see a personal reason to learn. Experience means starting from what learners know, including frustrating past experiences. Autonomy means giving them meaningful chances to contribute and make decisions. Action means showing how they can use the learning soon after the session.

Context changes the message. In a bank training example, a dry overdraft-protection form becomes relevant when framed as protection against a costly lending mistake. A customer-service course for bus drivers works better when it acknowledges that drivers have been disciplined for helping passengers. Learners can then analyze real constraints instead of being handed simplistic rules. Respect does not mean leaving novices unsupported: choice and independence should grow as competence and confidence grow.

Analysis

These principles treat adult learners as people with histories, incentives, and workplace constraints, rather than as empty seats in a classroom. That aligns with adult motivation research, where perceived value and confidence shape effort. The bus-driver example makes an especially important point: resistance can be evidence of a mismatch between training advice and job conditions. Autonomy also has limits. A novice facing a safety-critical procedure may need clear direction before open-ended choice. Good design calibrates freedom to readiness.

Build each session around value, a visible goal, practice, proof, and feedback

Plan backward from performance. The book’s five-step model begins by giving learners a credible reason to engage. It then states an observable outcome, creates activities that build toward it, checks whether learners can meet it, and provides corrective or confirming feedback. The sequence replaces content coverage as the organizing principle.

Keep the test job-shaped. In an example for temporary fair ticket sellers, the target is to sell the requested tickets, collect payment, and give correct change quickly. Learners practice in simulated booths with noise and customers, then are assessed on accuracy and transaction time. The model can also repair an existing course: remove unnecessary material, align activities with outcomes, and check each outcome directly. A plan is useful only if its activities and assessment fit the actual learners and the available time.

Analysis

This is a practical version of constructive alignment: outcomes, learning activities, and assessment should reinforce one another. Its strength is diagnostic. If learners fail, the designer can ask whether the goal was unclear, practice insufficient, or feedback weak, rather than blaming attention or effort by default. A caution is that observable measures can distort work when chosen poorly. Speed may matter at a ticket booth, but in many jobs accuracy, safety, or customer judgment must carry greater weight. The performance standard should reflect the real task, not just what is easiest to count.

Teach learners to plan, select, connect, refine, and monitor their thinking

Learning has executive controls. Metacognition means managing one’s own learning and problem solving. The book identifies five skills: planning an approach, selecting the important information, connecting new ideas to prior knowledge, tuning understanding through practice, and monitoring results so strategies can change. A learner who treats every detail as equally important can quickly become overwhelmed; a learner who checks understanding can focus effort where it matters.

Give memory a structure. The book recommends cognitive strategies such as grouping related information, using diagrams and matrices, previewing what is coming, making comparisons, rehearsing, and creating memory aids. For example, organizing words under categories makes them easier to recall than presenting the same words in a jumble. These supports are especially valuable for novices, whose unfamiliar material creates more separate mental units.

Analysis

The emphasis on metacognition broadens the trainer’s role: learners need not only subject knowledge but strategies for managing unfamiliar tasks. This connects with self-regulated learning, in which people set goals, observe their own progress, and adjust their approach. The proposed supports can make those otherwise invisible processes teachable. Memory tricks, however, are not a substitute for understanding. A mnemonic may help retrieve a list, but learners still need to know when the information applies and how to use it. Designers should pair recall aids with meaningful application.

Replace passive telling with guidance calibrated to learner readiness

Choose the right learning approach. The book describes four approaches. Receptive training mainly presents information and is best used sparingly for awareness or orientation. Directive training gives novices a structured path with practice and feedback. Guided discovery lets learners solve cases with prompts and support. Exploratory learning gives capable, self-directed learners resources and room to investigate.

Support should fade, not vanish. The authors describe a teach-prompt-release progression: provide enough instruction to start, coach learners as they practice, then let them try independently while remaining available. A high-tech company once gave support engineers a manual of roughly 1,200 pages and five days of lectures, without troubleshooting practice. That approach delivered information but did not rehearse the job. For those engineers, realistic diagnosis exercises would have been a better fit.

Analysis

The four approaches offer a useful alternative to treating every lesson as a lecture or every learner as ready for open discovery. The progression resembles scaffolding: support is strongest when skills are new and fades as competence grows. It is not a rigid staircase, though. A veteran may need direct instruction when confronting a wholly unfamiliar tool, while a novice can still contribute useful questions. Designers should vary guidance by task, prior knowledge, risk, and confidence, rather than labeling a person as one fixed type of learner.

Assess the required skill, not a learner’s ability to endure exams

Make checks part of learning. The book distinguishes a learning check from an exam that feels like a judgment of the person. Criterion-referenced testing measures performance against a stated standard. A test should match the objective: ask learners to perform a visible task when the objective requires action, and use written or oral questions when it requires recall or explanation. Feedback should identify what is correct or what needs adjustment.

Practice can reduce fear. Railway workers once faced recertification exams that emphasized reading and content recall more than job tasks. After the exams were redesigned to match the work and practice, more than 90 percent scored at least 85 percent three and six months later, compared with weaker results under the earlier approach. The revised exams had 30 percent more questions, yet felt more familiar because training rehearsed the same kind of performance.

Analysis

Assessment can strengthen learning when it prompts retrieval, exposes gaps, and gives learners another chance to improve. The railway example illustrates how relevance can make a more demanding assessment feel fairer. It also highlights a validity principle: a test should measure the capability it claims to measure. Still, testing can produce anxiety, particularly when results carry employment consequences. Frequent low-stakes practice and clear feedback help, but high-stakes certification also requires reliable scoring and safety-conscious standards.

Fix workplace barriers before prescribing another training course

Performance has many causes. The book warns against assuming that every work problem reflects a skill gap. People may know what to do but lack clear expectations, tools, time, information, useful feedback, incentives, or supportive procedures. Training cannot compensate for a workplace that blocks the desired behavior.

Transfer needs conditions. The book cites an older review estimating that no more than 10 percent of training expenditures resulted in transfer to the job. That figure should not be treated as a universal current rate, but it underscores the gap between learning in a session and applying it at work. The authors also report estimates that roughly 70 to 80 percent of workplace learning happens informally, through work, colleagues, observation, and problem solving. Supervisors, job aids, practice opportunities, and aligned policies help turn formal instruction into sustained performance.

Analysis

This insight shifts attention from the learner to the system in which the learner must act. It is closely related to implementation science, which studies why interventions succeed or fail under real organizational conditions. A course may be effective in isolation and still have little impact if managers discourage its use or the necessary tools are missing. The older transfer estimate is best read as a warning, not a precise forecast. Organizations should measure local application and investigate barriers instead of relying on a single inherited percentage.

Buy learning technology for access and practice, never for magic

Technology changes delivery, not design. The book argues that digital tools can make learning easier to access, faster to distribute, simpler to update, and more consistent. They can also support immediate feedback, simulations, and flexible schedules. But an online course that merely turns slides into screens remains passive instruction. The quality depends on whether learners must think, practice, and receive useful feedback.

Decide on the medium last. Before choosing online learning, clarify who needs it, what they must do, the depth required, the time available, and how success will be measured. Blended learning can combine online preparation with face-to-face practice. A broader blend includes instruction, searchable information, and collaboration, such as colleagues sharing solutions or experts answering questions. A platform is an access route, not proof that learning has happened.

Analysis

The book’s technology argument remains useful because it separates distribution from pedagogy. Digital delivery can solve genuine logistical problems, especially when learners are geographically dispersed or need flexible access. Yet convenience is not neutral: workplace distractions, weak connectivity, inaccessible interfaces, and poor course maintenance can erase the promised benefits. The strongest design question is not whether a tool is modern, but what learner activity it enables that would otherwise be difficult, costly, or unsafe. Technology should be judged by that contribution.

Treat familiar teaching wisdom as a hypothesis, not evidence

Common sense can mislead. The book challenges claims that matching instruction to learning styles improves results, that enjoyable lessons necessarily teach more, that extra content means extra learning, or that technology itself produces superior outcomes. It also questions the idea that experts can always explain their own performance. In each case, an appealing story is not enough; evidence and the task itself matter.

Design for the learner’s limits. Human attention and working memory are limited, so flooding novices with detail can produce overload. The authors favor meaningful structure, practice, feedback, and worked examples when learners face unfamiliar problems. They also stress implementation: time, resources, supervisor support, and the opportunity to apply learning. Their practical test for any training proposal is whether it centers learners, targets performance, and can demonstrate results.

Analysis

This evidence-first stance is valuable in a field where fashionable labels can outrun validation. Learning-style categories, for example, often feel intuitively persuasive because people do have preferences, but preference alone does not establish that matching instruction improves achievement. The same skepticism should apply to the book’s own broad claims. Research varies by task, population, and outcome, and no single method dominates every context. Its best contribution is therefore not a list of eternal rules, but a habit of asking what evidence supports a design choice and what success would look like.

Analysis

Telling Ain’t Training is an applied guide to workplace instruction, but its deeper subject is a change in professional identity. The trainer is not primarily a speaker or custodian of content. The trainer is a designer of conditions under which people can acquire and use capabilities. The book makes that shift concrete through deliberately experiential challenges, cases, planning tools, activities, and assessment examples. Its form reinforces its argument: readers are repeatedly asked to retrieve, decide, compare, and practice rather than simply absorb exposition.

Its most durable contribution is the alignment of learner needs, observable outcomes, practice, assessment, and workplace conditions. These elements connect instructional design to both cognitive psychology and organizational performance. The distinction between declarative and procedural knowledge is especially useful because it exposes a common failure: instructors often explain actions that learners need to rehearse. Similarly, the insistence that performance problems may reflect missing resources or incentives prevents training from becoming the default response to every organizational difficulty.

Some claims deserve contextual reading. The book’s descriptions of memory capacity and sensory proportions simplify complicated research, and several technology conclusions reflect the evidence and terminology available around its 2011 edition. Its practical advice is stronger when treated as a design discipline than as a set of universal laws. Adult learners differ in confidence, prior knowledge, language, disability, and task risk. Active participation is not automatically meaningful, and learner choice is not always appropriate for a dangerous procedure.

The framework’s unifying test is nevertheless powerful: identify what people must be able to do, create the practice that develops it, and ensure the workplace permits its use. That test remains relevant across classrooms, digital platforms, and on-the-job coaching. It also changes evaluation from a satisfaction survey into a question about capability and application. The book’s message is not that explanation has no place. It is that explanation earns its place when it helps learners understand, practice, adapt, and perform.

Summary in 30 Seconds
Learning means a change in what people can do, so choose the observable outcome first and plan backward. Novices need guided practice with feedback, not explanation, because knowing about a task differs from doing it. Test the real skill, not recall or endurance. Many performance problems come from missing tools, incentives, or feedback, so fix the workplace before ordering training. Technology only provides access; learners still must think and practice.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.09 out of 5
Average of 467 ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Telling Ain't Training 2nd Edition receives positive reviews for its practical approach to adult learning and training design. Readers appreciate its focus on learner-centered, performance-based methods and debunking of training myths. The book offers valuable insights on adapting to learner differences, key learning principles, and effective training techniques. While some find it slightly outdated in technology-related content, most consider it an essential resource for both novice and experienced trainers. Reviewers praise its engaging style, interactive format, and useful activities, recommending it as a must-read for anyone involved in adult education.

Your rating:
4.49
283 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Glossary

Declarative knowledge

Knowledge that can be explained

Knowledge used to name, describe, or explain facts, concepts, and relationships. Someone may know the capital of a country or explain a rule declaratively. The book distinguishes this from procedural knowledge, which supports action. The two forms do not automatically convert into one another, so instruction should match the kind of knowledge learners need.

Procedural knowledge

Knowledge used to act

Knowledge that enables a person to carry out a task or skill. It may be acquired through repeated practice without the learner being able to explain every step verbally. Riding a bicycle is a familiar example. Training for procedural knowledge therefore requires learners to perform, not merely listen to descriptions of performance.

Metacognition

Managing one’s own learning

Higher-level processes for setting learning goals and guiding the effort to meet them. The book describes five related skills: planning, selecting important material, connecting new ideas to prior knowledge, tuning understanding through practice, and monitoring results. Instruction can support learners who have not yet developed these strategies.

Adult Learning Principles

Four conditions for adult learning

The book’s four principles are readiness, experience, autonomy, and action. Adults are more open to learning when they see its value, when instruction respects and uses their prior experience, when they can participate and contribute, and when they can apply the learning soon. The principles guide design without implying that every learner needs identical freedom or support.

Five-step model

A structure for learning sessions

A planning model that organizes instruction around learner value and a clear performance outcome. The designer creates relevant activities, checks whether learners meet the outcome, and provides corrective or confirming feedback. The model is intended to prevent content coverage from displacing practice and evidence of learning.

Criterion-referenced testing

Testing against a stated standard

Assessment that checks whether a learner meets a specified performance objective and standard. A procedural objective calls for a performance task or suitable simulation, while declarative objectives can be checked through oral or written questions. The test should directly match the capability it is intended to verify.

Teach-prompt-release

A progression toward independence

A learning sequence in which an instructor first provides enough information to orient learners, then supports their practice with prompts and feedback, and finally gives them room to perform independently. Release does not mean abandonment. Learners still need access to resources, feedback, or support when circumstances require it.

Blended learning

A combination of learning resources

The book first uses blended learning for combinations of online and classroom instruction. It also describes a broader blend that brings instruction together with information access and collaboration. The aim is to use each resource where it is most useful, rather than assuming that one delivery format can meet every learning need.

FAQ

What's Telling Ain't Training about?

  • Focus on Effective Training: The book critiques traditional training methods, particularly the ineffectiveness of "telling" as a learning strategy. It promotes a learner-centered, performance-based approach.
  • Research-Based Insights: It combines academic research with practical applications, aiming to bridge the gap between theory and practice in training.
  • Transformative Learning: The goal is to transform learners, not just transmit information, by engaging them actively and ensuring real-world application of knowledge.

Why should I read Telling Ain't Training?

  • Practical Guidance: Offers practical advice and tools for trainers to improve their effectiveness, suitable for both novice and experienced trainers.
  • Updated Content: Includes new sections on technology and over 300 references, addressing contemporary challenges in workplace learning.
  • Engaging Style: The conversational tone and interactive exercises make it an enjoyable and relatable read.

What are the key takeaways of Telling Ain't Training?

  • Learner-Centered Approach: Emphasizes focusing on the needs and experiences of learners, promoting a "learner centered… performance based" mantra.
  • Importance of Engagement: Active participation is crucial for effective learning, with strategies provided to involve learners in the process.
  • Metacognitive Skills: Highlights the importance of developing metacognitive skills to enhance learning outcomes.

What are the best quotes from Telling Ain't Training and what do they mean?

  • “Telling ain’t training.”: Highlights the need for interactive and engaging methods rather than just delivering information.
  • “Your mission is not to transmit information but to transform your learners.”: Encourages trainers to focus on facilitating change and real-world application.
  • “Learners generally want to learn; trainers want learners to learn.”: Reflects the mutual goal of creating a conducive learning environment.

What are the four key adult learning principles discussed in Telling Ain't Training?

  • Readiness: Adult learners are more open to learning when they see relevance and benefits, requiring trainers to communicate "what's in it for me."
  • Experience: Training should connect new information to learners' existing knowledge, acknowledging their wealth of experience.
  • Autonomy: Adult learners prefer taking charge of their learning, enhancing engagement through participation and decision-making.
  • Action: Focus on immediate, practical use of skills to ensure retention and application.

How does Telling Ain't Training suggest structuring a training session?

  • Five-Step Model: Introduces a model with Rationale, Objectives, Activities, Evaluation, and Feedback to ensure focused and effective training.
  • Rationale: Start by explaining the importance of training to engage learners and open their minds to the content.
  • Activities: Design activities that align with performance objectives, increasing retention and application.

What cognitive strategies are recommended in Telling Ain't Training?

  • Clustering: Organizing information into logical groupings to facilitate comprehension and retention.
  • Repetition: Emphasizes regular practice and rehearsal for long-term retention, reinforcing learning through revisiting content.
  • Memory Aids: Encourages using mnemonics and other aids to enhance recall, supporting learners in creating their own aids.

How can I apply the principles from Telling Ain't Training in my organization?

  • Assess Learner Needs: Conduct a needs assessment to tailor training to specific learner requirements and backgrounds.
  • Engage Learners Actively: Incorporate interactive activities like group discussions and role-plays to promote participation and collaboration.
  • Provide Continuous Feedback: Implement a system for timely and constructive feedback to help learners adjust and improve retention.

What are some common pitfalls in training that Telling Ain't Training addresses?

  • Over-Reliance on Lectures: Warns against relying heavily on lectures, which often lead to passive learning and poor retention.
  • Ignoring Learner Experience: Failing to acknowledge prior knowledge can lead to disengagement; training should build on existing knowledge.
  • Lack of Application Opportunities: Emphasizes the need for practical application to transfer learning to real-world situations.

How does technology fit into the training methods discussed in Telling Ain't Training?

  • Blended Learning: Discusses integrating technology with face-to-face methods to enhance accessibility and engagement.
  • Interactive Tools: Encourages using technology for interactive experiences like simulations, emphasizing thoughtful integration.
  • Continuous Learning: Technology facilitates ongoing learning opportunities, providing access to resources and additional materials.

What are some effective training activities mentioned in Telling Ain't Training?

  • Better Me Activity: Encourages reflection on personal growth and goal setting, fostering self-awareness and motivation.
  • Listening Teams: Promotes active listening and collaboration, enhancing communication skills and group dynamics.
  • Great Debate: Engages learners in critical thinking and argumentation, exploring different perspectives to enhance analytical skills.

What are the myths about learning styles discussed in Telling Ain't Training?

  • Learning Styles Myth: Challenges the belief that matching instruction to learning styles improves outcomes, citing lack of substantial evidence.
  • Focus on Engagement: Suggests engaging multiple senses rather than focusing on learning styles to enhance attention and retention.
  • Research Findings: Cites research indicating that learning styles do not significantly impact educational outcomes.

About the Author

Harold D. Stolovitch is a renowned expert in workplace learning and performance. As principal of HSA Learning & Performance Solutions LLC, he has consulted for major corporations worldwide. Stolovitch is professor emeritus at the University of Montreal and has received numerous accolades for his contributions to instructional and performance technology. These include the ISPI Distinguished Professional Achievement award, ISPI Member for Life, and the Canadian Society for Training and Development's President's Award for Lifetime Achievements. In 2004, Stolovitch and his team won the ASTD Outstanding Research Award for their work on workplace performance. His expertise and accomplishments have established him as a leading figure in the field of training and development.

Download PDF

To save this Telling Ain't Training summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.40 MB     Pages: 20

Download EPUB

To read this Telling Ain't Training summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.41 MB     Pages: 26
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...