Plot Summary
Prologue
At seventeen, Jane Flanagan finds the abandoned purple house on the cliffs and turns it into a refuge from her mother’s drinking and their crowded home. She had already given up a prestigious college seminar after learning she was selected as an at-risk student, a label that made escape feel less certain.
Years later, Jane becomes a Harvard archivist, marries David, and brings him to the house, imagining their future there. The old place holds her teenage loneliness and her hope of making a different kind of family, though she and David leave without knowing it will matter again.
The house first offers Jane a place to look closely at lives that have vanished, while her own family gives her little dependable attention. Her abandoned seminar matters because it shows how easily shame can turn an opportunity into a retreat. As an adult archivist, she makes preservation her vocation, yet she still struggles to let other people witness her need. The purple house becomes a private counter-history: not a home she owns, but a place where she can imagine belonging without having to ask anyone to make room for her.
A Pool Over Graves
In 2015, wealthy Boston couple Genevieve and Paul Richards buy the historic purple house Jane once loved. Genevieve pours money into modernizing it, clearing the grounds and emptying its rooms; she even purchases an expensive Abenaki basket to help present the renovation as respectful of local history.
When workers uncover a small family cemetery, Genevieve pays one of them to remove the graves so she can build an infinity pool. The worker leaves a red star tattoo as her only clue to his identity. Soon her four-year-old son, Benjamin, describes a girl in his room who keeps him awake. Genevieve believes him, but Paul dismisses the haunting as imagination, leaving her alone with the knowledge that she has disturbed the dead.
Genevieve treats the house as a project whose problems can be solved with money, design choices, and contractors. The cemetery exposes the limit of that approach: she can remove the stones, but not the consequences of erasing the people beneath them. Her purchase of an Indigenous basket further complicates her wish to honor history, since she treats the object as décor without asking what it means or how it came to the dealer. Benjamin’s account unsettles her precisely because it cannot be folded into the finished house. The room she has renovated remains inhabited by a past she cannot control.
The Girl Called D
Jane returns to Awadapquit after her mother Shirley’s death, staying in the cluttered family house while separated from David and on leave from the Harvard archive she loves. At a Rotary fundraiser, her friend Allison arranges a reading with Clementine, a medium.
Jane expects nonsense, but Clementine describes Jane’s grandmother and mother, then says a young spirit identified only by D needs her mother told she is at peace and no longer at Lake Grove. Jane’s curiosity catches on the unexplained place-name.
Clementine also suggests Jane may be pregnant; an old test proves negative, intensifying Jane’s private grief about the family she and David had hoped to start. With no proof that the reading means anything, Jane nevertheless writes down Lake Grove.
Jane’s skepticism does not protect her from wanting the medium’s claims to be true. She has built a career around recovering women’s histories, so Clementine’s unknown girl arrives in the shape of an unfinished archival obligation. The negative pregnancy test sharpens that obligation: Jane longs for a future child while being pulled toward a dead one. Her response is not sudden belief, but attention. She records the place-name and keeps thinking about it, the same disciplined curiosity that serves her at work now directing her toward a problem she cannot yet define.
The House Becomes Evidence
Genevieve hires Jane to research the house’s original owners, giving the archivist a paid reason to investigate the property she once explored as a teenager. Jane learns that Captain Samuel Littleton died when his ship, the Providence, wrecked near home, leaving his wife Hannah and their children behind.
At the local historical society, Lydia Beazley shows her an old book identifying the house as the Lake Grove Inn, once run by the Troy sisters. The name echoes Clementine’s message.
Jane also finds a local account of explorer Archibald Pembroke, then discovers evidence that his voyage kidnapped four Indigenous men. At a Portland exhibit, she meets Penobscot consultant Naomi Miller and learns that the town’s celebrated Abenaki name may be a colonial distortion. Jane’s notes begin linking private loss to public erasure.
Jane’s research makes the house more than a backdrop for a haunting. Each document corrects or complicates the polished version of local history, from the shipwreck to the boardinghouse to the explorer’s supposed discovery. Naomi’s explanation of the town name gives Jane a crucial method: place-names can preserve knowledge, but they can also be mistranslated until the original meaning disappears. This is the work Jane understands best, yet it now implicates the institutions and stories that shaped her own hometown. Genevieve wants a family portrait for her walls; Jane finds a much larger history that the walls cannot contain.
Daisy's Last Summer
The narrative shifts to Marilyn Martinson, the former Lake Grove owner, who once hoped to revive her painting career and her marriage to Herbert. Their daughter Daisy loved the house, its hidden bedroom, its marbles, and the Littleton family graves.
During Marilyn’s artist residency, Herbert began an affair with Mary Flanagan, the housekeeper, and Daisy died after slipping on scattered marbles in the dark and falling through a broken banister. Marilyn blamed Herbert, Mary, and herself, then left Lake Grove and stopped painting.
On the first anniversary of Daisy’s death, she returned intending to die beside her daughter, but survived her attempt and drove away. Decades later she still cannot bear to revisit the house, though she keeps it rather than let the past disappear entirely.
Marilyn’s history gives the house a grief that cannot be reduced to supernatural atmosphere. Daisy’s death follows adult secrecy and a neglected railing, ordinary failures with irreversible consequences. Marilyn’s artistic silence and refusal to sell Lake Grove become ways of remaining bound to her daughter, even as they prevent her from returning to the place. Her failed suicide attempt marks a painful distinction between wanting reunion and continuing to live. The novel also complicates blame: Herbert’s betrayal matters, but so does the house’s physical danger and Marilyn’s own distance from her child. No single explanation can contain the loss.
Sister Eliza's House
A second historical voice belongs to Eliza Green, who leaves the Shaker village at Sabbathday Lake and takes work in Hannah Littleton’s isolated home. Hannah has lost several children and is expecting another; Eliza tends her through a stillbirth and the following winter, then helps her recover.
Their attachment deepens into a loving household that also includes Hannah’s surviving children, Fannie and James. Samuel’s ship later wrecks within sight of the shore, and Eliza stays to support Hannah.
She dies young, and Hannah buries her in the family plot with only a plain stone marked Sister Eliza. After the family leaves, Eliza’s spirit returns to the house occasionally. She describes another silent presence on the cliff and Daisy, still trying to reach her mother.
Eliza’s story overturns the assumption that the house’s history belongs only to the people named on its plaque. She arrives as paid help, but the care she gives Hannah becomes reciprocal and intimate, forming a family that social convention cannot easily name. Her Shaker upbringing has taught her discipline and communal responsibility, yet her life with Hannah lets affection develop outside the rules she grew up with. The small grave marker both recognizes Eliza and limits how publicly she can be remembered. Her account also widens the haunting: Daisy seeks her mother, while the figure on the cliff remains unknown.
Two Ghosts, One Address
When Jane visits the renovated house to present her research, she is shaken by how much Genevieve has erased, including the foyer mural and the original rooms. Benjamin shows her the hidden door to his bedroom, then says he no longer sleeps there. Over dinner, Genevieve admits that a girl has visited him and that she suspects the ghost is Sister Eliza.
Jane recognizes a second link: Clementine’s spirit, D, also asked to reach her mother from Lake Grove. Neither woman can identify the girl, but the overlap persuades them to seek more answers. Genevieve reveals that she has avoided the house because she fears what she did there; Jane agrees to contact Clementine and accompany Genevieve to Camp Mira.
Jane’s return to Lake Grove changes the house from a cherished private refuge into contested territory. She sees the renovation as an erasure, while Genevieve sees the house as a home she has rescued and improved. Yet Genevieve’s confession creates an unexpected point of contact between them: both women are now listening for a child seeking her mother. Their agreement to investigate does not require either to profess belief. It requires them to treat Benjamin’s experience and Clementine’s message as questions worth following. The house draws them together before either understands how much their own family histories will enter the search.
The Island of Spirits
Jane, Genevieve, and Allison travel to Camp Mira, a Spiritualist retreat off Bar Harbor, hoping Clementine can clarify the haunting. They attend a talk on Spiritualism’s history, then hear a researcher describe children who report memories of past lives.
At a crowded public reading, medium Camille speaks to mourners, tells Genevieve that Eliza remains at her house, and says D has not crossed over. Jane distrusts Camille’s broad claims but sees Allison moved by a message about the burden she carries.
At Clementine’s cottage, the medium says the first woman of Lake Grove may be trapped by grief, though Jane corrects her mistaken account of Samuel’s shipwreck. On the ferry home, Jane resolves to try to repair things with David. Allison admits she arranged the original reading because she wants contact with her own mother.
Camp Mira exposes the difference between evidence, consolation, and the desire to believe. Jane watches Camille make claims that seem manipulative, yet she cannot dismiss the comfort other visitors receive. Allison’s admission reframes the reading as an act of friendship rather than a prank: she offered Jane the chance she wishes she had with her own mother. Jane’s decision to contact David follows the day’s encounters with grief, but the impulse does not erase the history between them. The trip lets the women share vulnerability without making them agree about what the dead can do.
The Ring in the Dirt
Back in Awadapquit, Jane stops at her sister Holly’s house and hears Holly’s son Jason describe Keith, a young worker who bragged about digging up an old cemetery for a rich client. Jason shows Jane a ring recovered from the grave, engraved with the words marking it as a mourning keepsake. Jane recognizes the story as Genevieve’s pool project.
Before she can act, Melissa leaves a message that Harvard’s board has fired her permanently. Jane then sees photographs of David having dinner with his former wife, Angela, and assumes he is moving on. Ashamed, furious, and suddenly without the job she thought would always hold, Jane goes drinking with local regulars. She remembers little of the night, setting up the disastrous morning that follows.
Three forms of evidence arrive almost at once: Jason’s account of the excavation, Melissa’s decision, and the photographs of David. Jane has no time to separate justified anger from wounded pride, so she turns to the response she knows best, alcohol. The ring is particularly charged because it was recovered from a grave after Genevieve had presented herself as a custodian of the house’s history. Yet Jane’s own judgment is compromised by her growing dependence on secrecy and drink. The scene places moral outrage beside self-destruction, not as equivalent harms, but as crises she can no longer manage separately.
The Night at Harvard
Jane’s memories reach back to college, when she first drank after feeling intellectually humiliated, and to years of blackouts she treated as isolated mistakes. Drinking became her way to feel sociable and less guarded, even as she lied about its consequences.
After her mother died, her drinking intensified and David urged her to seek help. At a Harvard event celebrating a major archival collection, Jane drank until she made out with Tim, a junior colleague, in front of donors, her boss Melissa, and David’s close friend Pearl.
The next morning Melissa sent her home and later placed her on unpaid leave as a harassment inquiry began. David stayed at first, but the couple’s trust collapsed. Jane proposed a separation, hoping to spare him from her, and left for Maine.
The flashback recasts Jane’s present collapse as the culmination of a pattern rather than one unlucky evening. She has used intelligence, punctuality, and professional success as evidence that she is not like her mother, while repeatedly treating blackouts as exceptions. At the Harvard event, that distinction fails in public and harms both her career and her marriage. Her choice to leave David sounds protective, but it also lets her avoid the sustained work of recovery while controlling the timing of rejection. The novel asks the reader to understand the roots of her behavior without confusing understanding with absolution.
David at the Door
Before dawn, David reaches Jane’s mother’s house after she called him repeatedly while drunk, then failed to answer him. He is angry that she frightened him, and Jane is too ashamed to explain herself. She discovers that Walter, her mother’s small Pomeranian, is missing.
They search for hours, speaking almost entirely about where to look next. Later, Jane returns to Genevieve’s property and accuses her in front of her guests of paying to erase the cemetery. Paul overhears the accusation and demands an explanation.
Jane has exposed the deed, but her own credibility is damaged by her drinking and disheveled state. David leaves without reconciliation, and Walter remains lost, turning the day into a public reckoning with consequences Jane cannot undo.
The missing dog and the graveyard confrontation make Jane’s private unraveling visible to other people. David’s arrival shows that concern survives the separation, but his anger also reflects the exhaustion of repeatedly managing Jane’s crises. At Genevieve’s, Jane names a real wrongdoing, yet she does so while intoxicated and in front of guests, making it easy for the accusation to be dismissed as an outburst. Her moral insight does not protect her from the damage her own behavior causes. The scene denies her a clean role as either truth-teller or victim.
Walter Comes Home
Walter disappears for three weeks, and Jane’s search gives way to an increasingly solitary routine of wine and liquor. When the dog finally scratches at the door, filthy but alive, Jane tells everyone he is back; David does not reply. Allison soon visits with cookies and asks directly whether Jane has started drinking again.
Jane denies the problem and resents the reports that friends have seen her buying alcohol. Allison reads a loving letter describing how much she fears for Jane, but Jane rejects the intervention and accuses her friend of acting superior. After Allison leaves, Jane retrieves wine she has hidden under the sink, drinks it, and drives to buy more. The household is nearly empty, and Jane is more isolated than before.
Walter’s return appears to restore a small piece of order, but Jane uses the relief to avoid confronting what happened during his absence. Her hidden bottle and quick lie reveal that drinking has become organized around concealment, not merely appetite. Allison’s intervention threatens Jane because it names a pattern she already recognizes from her mother and sister. Jane converts that fear into resentment, attacking the friend who has stayed closest. The emptying of the house sharpens the image of her withdrawal: possessions are being removed for a sale while alcohol quietly fills the space left behind.
The Letter's Hidden Kin
A mortgage paper reveals that Marilyn and Herbert once helped Jane’s grandmother buy her house. Online records lead Jane to Marilyn’s daughter Daisy, who died at eight, and Jane realizes that D is Daisy. When David calls, he explains that dinner with Angela was part of his own attempt to understand his past, then tells Jane he cannot continue their marriage.
Soon a package from Marilyn’s friend Caitlin brings Civil War letters, a photograph, and a letter Jane’s grandmother Mary wrote after Daisy’s death. Mary admits that, while widowed and drinking, she had an affair with Herbert; after Daisy’s accident, shame made her a cruel, unreliable mother to Shirley, who was taken away for a time.
Jane understands the pain beneath her mother’s failures, visits Allison’s ailing mother Betty, leaves Marilyn a message about Daisy, and finally enters an AA meeting.
The letter does not excuse Shirley’s treatment of Jane; it reveals a history of harm that began before Jane was born. Mary’s account shows how grief, alcohol, and shame can pass through a family without being openly named, leaving later generations to mistake secrecy for character. David’s decision arrives before Jane can use this new knowledge to repair their marriage. That loss forces her to act for a reason other than winning him back. Her visit to Betty and her first AA meeting turn attention outward and inward at once: she offers presence to someone else while finally seeking help for herself.
Names Beneath the Map
Two years later, Penobscot consultant Naomi Miller receives a map and an inherited story from her cousin Barbara. The map marks Sawadapskw’i, a coastal place Naomi recognizes from Jane’s research. The story follows Kanti, an Abenaki woman whose husband Manedo is taken aboard an English ship after a false invitation.
Kanti waits for his return on a marriage cliff, raises their daughter, and watches colonization dispossess her people. The tale says that some captives returned, but Manedo’s fate remained unknown; Kanti’s descendants eventually moved north, while she was buried on the cliff she had guarded.
Naomi sees the possible connection to Jane’s town and the four kidnapped men whose names Jane recorded. The account remains family testimony, not confirmed history, but Naomi knows Jane will want to hear it.
Naomi’s discovery extends the novel’s archival question beyond written records. The family story preserves a woman’s waiting, grief, and relationship to land where official histories often preserved only explorers and town founders. Its details echo Jane’s research, but the narrative does not flatten oral memory into proof. Naomi must consider what can be verified, what must be approached through community knowledge, and who has the right to interpret it. The map’s importance lies not only in locating a place, but in restoring an Indigenous name and the human meaning that colonial naming obscured.
Lake Grove Reopened
Jane chooses not to sell her mother’s house and begins rebuilding her life in Awadapquit. After her first AA meeting, she stays sober, later raises her daughter Mary, and accepts a modest job helping Lydia organize the local historical society.
Jane persuades Historic Homes of New England to support a museum at Lake Grove, which Genevieve and Paul eventually offer at a reduced price. She restores objects once scattered or discarded, including the Lake Grove Inn sign, Marilyn’s glassware, Littleton china, and Hannah’s mourning ring.
With Naomi’s consultation, Jane also develops exhibits on Wabanaki women and local Indigenous history. She remains divorced from David, but he is involved in Mary’s life, and their connection continues in uncertain, changing forms. The old house becomes a place where neglected stories can be encountered.
Jane’s recovery does not return her to the life she lost. Instead, she builds work and family in a different shape, keeping her daughter and her sobriety at the center of daily decisions. The museum answers the novel’s opening concern about lives disappearing, but it does so with an awareness that collecting objects is not the same as owning their meanings. Naomi’s consultation changes the project from a local celebration of prominent families into a more accountable account of Indigenous presence. Jane’s relationship with David remains unresolved, making the new life credible rather than magically repaired.
A Life Reassembled
On the museum’s opening morning, Jane prepares an exhibit about Maine Shaker women, including Eliza’s life at Lake Grove. She now directs the museum, works with assistant Jessie, and balances its public opening with caring for Mary, who is almost one. Jane and David are divorced, but he visits, helps with their daughter, and sometimes shares a tenderness neither can yet define as a future together.
As Jane welcomes the first visitors, Naomi calls with a story connected to Sawadapskw’i and the four men Jane once researched. The book ends before Naomi tells her what Barbara sent. Jane’s work has given the house new purpose, but the final call opens another history still waiting to be heard.
The ending offers continuity rather than closure. Jane’s daughter is not a cure for alcoholism or a guarantee of reconciliation; she is a person whose care depends on Jane’s ongoing choices. David’s presence remains loving but unsettled, resisting the simple restoration Jane once imagined. The museum brings the novel’s strands into a shared space: women’s lives, Shaker history, Indigenous knowledge, and the objects that survive them. Naomi’s call prevents that work from feeling complete. Jane has made a place for stories to be heard, and the final moment asks whether she can keep listening when the next account challenges what she thinks she knows.
Analysis
The Cliffs links two kinds of haunting. One is intimate: children and adults carry losses they cannot settle, from Daisy’s death to Jane’s grief for her mother and the marriage she damages. The other is historical: the land itself bears the consequences of colonization, renamed places, disturbed graves, and Indigenous objects separated from their makers and descendants. The novel does not make these harms interchangeable. Instead, Jane’s work as an archivist gradually teaches her that remembering must include questions of ownership, authority, and omission.
Lake Grove makes those questions physical. Genevieve renovates its rooms and removes its cemetery because she assumes care means control. Jane initially treats the house as a refuge that belongs to her emotionally, though she never owned it. Both women must confront the limits of those claims. The museum Jane eventually builds is a more responsible answer, not because it repairs every loss, but because it makes room for histories that a plaque or a decorative object cannot hold by itself.
The novel’s treatment of addiction is equally unsentimental. Jane’s intelligence and professional success do not protect her from alcohol; in some ways, they help her disguise its effects. Her blackouts create a personal archive full of gaps, and she can no longer rely on her own account of what happened. Mary’s letter reveals that addiction and shame have already shaped Jane’s family, but inherited harm is not destiny. Jane enters recovery only after David’s decision, Allison’s intervention, and a growing recognition that her behavior has consequences for others.
The ending offers a life, not a cure: Jane is sober, raising Mary, doing meaningful work, and still uncertain about David. Naomi’s final call keeps the history open. Preservation, the novel suggests, is not a final act of rescue. It is the continuing practice of listening, correcting the record, and returning meaning to the people and places from which it was taken.
Review Summary
Reviews for The Cliffs are mixed, averaging 3.56 stars. Praise highlights Sullivan's rich historical research, compelling female characters, and immersive blend of gothic mystery, family drama, and Indigenous history. Critics frequently cite the novel's length, disjointed pacing, and tendency to feel like a "lecture" on topics including Native American culture, the Shakers, and spiritualism. Many readers struggled to connect with protagonist Jane, though others found her journey redemptive. The haunted house premise captivated some while leaving others wanting more mystery and fewer historical tangents.
People Also Read
Characters
Jane Flanagan
The guarded archivistJane is an intelligent archivist who has learned to rely on competence, routine, and solitude. Her childhood in a financially unstable home with an alcoholic mother taught her to watch other people closely while concealing her own needs. She is drawn to lost histories because she understands the loneliness of being misunderstood, yet her professional command of other people’s stories does not make her equally honest about her drinking. Jane loves David and wants a child, but intimacy and the possibility of repeating her family’s patterns frighten her. Her curiosity, sharp humor, and capacity for careful work are real strengths; so are her habits of evasion. The novel asks whether she can extend to herself the attention she gives the dead.
Genevieve Richards
The ambitious restorerGenevieve is a wealthy, exacting homeowner who sees an old cliffside property as the answer to a life crowded by work, appearances, and a distant marriage. She wants beauty and permanence, and trusts that enough money can make a damaged house feel secure. Her polished manner hides loneliness and a sharp dependence on other people’s approval. Genevieve is a devoted mother to Benjamin, though she struggles to make her husband share the work of parenting. Her wish to honor the house’s history is sincere in feeling but compromised by her impulse to remake the property around her own desires. She is neither simply a villain nor a victim; she is someone forced to confront the difference between preserving a place and possessing it.
Marilyn Martinson
The painter who remembersMarilyn is a former painter whose eye for light and glass shapes the way she sees the rooms at Lake Grove. She is reflective, fiercely private, and capable of building her life around attachments she cannot easily release. Her first marriage to Herbert contains both artistic kinship and deep disappointment, while motherhood gives her a love more steadying than the recognition she seeks for her work. As she grows older, Marilyn measures her life in distinct chapters, each shaped by love, loss, and reinvention. She trusts a small circle of people rather than institutions, and even when she tells her story, she chooses carefully what to reveal. Her presence gives the house an intimate history that official property records cannot supply.
Eliza Green
The Shaker housekeeperEliza is a disciplined, observant woman raised in a Shaker community, where labor and faith organize daily life. She leaves the village wanting a life that belongs to her, though she has little idea what freedom will look like outside its rules. Work brings her to Lake Grove, where she is attentive to the moods and needs of the household. Her reserve comes from habit, not indifference; she is capable of deep tenderness once trust grows. Eliza understands care as practical labor, from preparing meals to staying beside someone in grief. Her story complicates the distinction between employee and family, and shows how a person with little legal or social power can become essential to a home.
Allison
Jane's steadfast witnessAllison has been Jane’s closest friend since they met as teenagers. Warm, socially capable, and deeply involved in Awadapquit, she appears to have the stable family life Jane once envied. Running an inn with her husband and raising two children leaves her little spare time, while her mother’s illness places a private weight behind her cheerfulness. Allison’s loyalty is active: she arranges Jane’s reading, checks on her drinking, and speaks up when affection alone is no longer enough. She can be overprotective and sometimes assumes she knows what Jane needs, but her care is not effortless or self-congratulatory. The friendship survives because Allison keeps showing up and because Jane gradually learns that listening must go both ways.
David
The patient, wounded partnerDavid is an economics professor, a thoughtful partner, and a man whose gentleness can shade into avoidance. Having experienced betrayal in his first marriage, he values stability and tries hard not to repeat the pain of divorce. He supports Jane’s independence and respects her attachment to work, while his patience sometimes allows problems to remain unspoken for too long. He is attentive to children and generous with Jane’s family, qualities that make her imagine him as a father. David’s emotional life is not reducible to being the good husband who waits; he has his own fears, boundaries, and work to do. His relationship with Jane is shaped by love, injury, and the difficult recognition that love alone cannot manage addiction.
Naomi Miller
The Wabanaki cultural stewardNaomi is a Penobscot consultant who works to reconnect Indigenous people with photographs, recordings, objects, and histories removed from their communities. Her approach is practical and relational: an artifact matters not only for its age or market value, but for its makers, descendants, and cultural responsibilities. Naomi is intellectually curious and direct, with a habit of pursuing a question well beyond the moment it first appears. She is also attentive to boundaries, aware that outsiders’ desire to know everything can repeat the possessive habits that caused historical harm. Her work gives Jane a more responsible way to approach local history. Naomi’s own family connections and newly shared stories remain central to how she understands preservation.
Shirley Flanagan
Jane's troubled motherShirley is Jane and Holly’s mother, a charismatic but unreliable woman whose drinking and unstable romances shaped her daughters’ childhood. She makes a living buying and reselling secondhand goods, filling the family home with objects others have discarded. Shirley can be funny, affectionate, and unexpectedly generous, but she often avoids responsibility and reacts defensively when her daughters question her choices. Her relationship with Jane is especially strained by their different temperaments and by the things neither woman knows how to discuss. Shirley’s cluttered house reflects both her resourcefulness and her difficulty letting go. Jane remembers the damage, but also the flashes of warmth that make their bond impossible to summarize as either love or resentment alone.
Mary Flanagan
The steady grandmotherMary is Jane’s grandmother, the dependable caretaker who first gives Jane a sense of routine and a lasting love of books and history. Widowed young, she builds a modest life in Awadapquit and keeps her household steady through faith, work, and practical attention to her granddaughters. Jane remembers her as a moral anchor, though the distance between memory and a full human life is one of the novel’s recurring questions. Mary’s belongings, letters, and influence remain present after her death, prompting Jane to reconsider what she thought she knew about her family. Her care for Jane is genuine, but the story also asks how much a child can understand about the adult who protects her.
Holly
Jane's older sisterHolly is Jane’s older sister, more openly social and impulsive than Jane, and closely aligned with their mother. She shares the family resale business and has built a home where Jason’s friends can find temporary shelter. Holly is generous in a loose, unstructured way, but her own drinking and erratic choices echo the patterns she grew up with. She and Jane rarely discuss their deepest feelings, so their conversations can turn quickly toward old grievances. Beneath the rivalry and differences in how they remember their mother is real attachment. Holly’s willingness to comfort Jane, even awkwardly, shows that their bond can make room for tenderness without erasing years of hurt.
Benjamin Richards
The child at the windowBenjamin is Genevieve and Paul’s young son, a sensitive child who prefers a small, hidden bedroom to the larger rooms in the renovated house. He is close to his mother and depends on her presence at bedtime, while his father has difficulty connecting with him. Benjamin speaks matter-of-factly about the girl he sees, unaware at first that his mother cannot see her. His experiences unsettle the adults because they do not fit neatly into their beliefs or plans. The novel does not treat him as merely a device for frightening his parents; his fear, curiosity, and changing sense of safety shape how the house’s past enters the present.
Hannah Littleton
The bereaved householderHannah is the wife of ship captain Samuel Littleton and the mistress of the house where Eliza comes to work. She is affectionate and capable, but repeated bereavement leaves her vulnerable to long periods of grief. Hannah’s relationship with Eliza grows through shared labor and mutual care, giving her companionship beyond the marriage and family structure expected of her. She is not defined only by sorrow: she enjoys books, domestic rituals, and the life she builds with those around her. The house and family plot keep her close to the people she has lost, while also binding her to the practical demands of survival.
Daisy Martinson
The curious little girlDaisy is Marilyn and Herbert’s daughter, a bright, imaginative child who loves Lake Grove and its secret spaces. She becomes attached to the house’s marbles and old family graves, and her curiosity reflects the freedom her parents try to encourage in her. Daisy’s presence is important to Marilyn’s sense of what family and artistic life might become. She is remembered through the objects and stories left behind, but the novel resists reducing a child to the tragedy that surrounds her. Her personality continues to matter to the adults who knew her.
Paul Richards
The absent summer husbandPaul is Genevieve’s husband, a successful businessman whose work keeps him away from the summer house and from much of Benjamin’s daily life. He is practical and skeptical, especially when confronted with Genevieve’s fears about the house. His distance frustrates Genevieve, who imagined the property as a place where they could recover intimacy. Paul is not presented as a monster; his failure is quieter, in what he neglects to notice and how readily he expects Genevieve to manage the family’s emotional life. His arrival at moments of crisis forces private choices into the open.
Clementine
The visiting mediumClementine is a professional medium who lives part of the year at Camp Mira. She is warm, unconventional, and accustomed to clients who doubt her while still hoping she can provide something they need. Her readings offer Jane a message about a child called D, creating a mystery that draws the contemporary and historical strands together. Clementine does not always understand what the spirits’ details mean, and she acknowledges that mediumship can be imprecise. Her role is therefore less to solve the story than to give Jane a reason to pay attention to it.
Lydia Beazley
The local historianLydia runs a toy store and maintains Awadapquit’s historical society in its cramped back room. She is blunt, energetic, and frustrated by the town’s failure to fund a proper historical space. Lydia knows local families and documents, and she gives Jane the materials that identify Lake Grove as a former inn. Her practical approach to preserving old buildings complements Jane’s archival expertise. She understands that maintaining a house or a record requires active care, not just admiration. Lydia’s humor and impatience make her a lively ally in Jane’s work.
Abe Adams
The lobster-boat mentorAbe owns the lobster boat where Jane worked as a teenager and remains a familiar, kindly presence in Awadapquit. He remembers Jane as a conscientious young tour guide and continues to treat her with uncomplicated warmth. His local knowledge connects the town’s maritime past to the lives of its present residents. Abe offers Jane companionship without pressing her to explain herself, which makes him one of the few people around whom she can briefly feel like her earlier self.
Melissa
Jane's formidable mentorMelissa directs the Schlesinger Library and hires Jane, becoming both her professional mentor and a friend. Brilliant, confident, and committed to widening whose lives archives preserve, she gives Jane work that feels like a calling. She also introduces Jane to David. The scandal at the library places Melissa in the difficult position of caring about Jane while protecting her staff and institution. Her kindness does not prevent her from setting limits, and her response makes clear how deeply Jane’s actions have damaged a relationship built on trust.
Agnes Crosby
Eliza's outspoken employerAgnes is Hannah’s sister and an outspoken journalist involved in women’s rights and temperance work. She hires Eliza to help care for Hannah, recognizing that her sister needs practical support. Agnes enjoys argument and expects people to defend their beliefs, but she can also recognize when she has misjudged someone. Her relationship with Eliza brings the young woman into Hannah’s household. Through Agnes, the historical strand connects domestic life to the political debates of the nineteenth century.
Caitlin Rogers
Marilyn's younger friendCaitlin is Marilyn’s younger neighbor and friend, a warm presence who invites her into a life of meals, art, conversation, and friendship. She encourages Marilyn to reconsider her abandoned painting career and listens carefully when Marilyn shares painful history. After Marilyn becomes seriously ill, Caitlin handles the objects and letters Marilyn hoped would reach the local historical society. Her care allows the past to travel beyond Marilyn’s private grief.
Jason
Holly's adult sonJason is Holly’s son and Jane’s nephew. As a child, he bonds with David over basketball and receives the kind of attention Jane wishes her family had known more often. As an adult, he remains close to Holly and helps with the resale business and household. He inadvertently gives Jane a crucial lead when one of his friends boasts about the cemetery excavation. Jason’s straightforward manner contrasts with the secrecy that surrounds the adults.
Tim
Jane's junior colleagueTim is a young assistant librarian at the Schlesinger. He attends the same celebratory event as Jane and becomes part of the incident that jeopardizes her position. He is not portrayed as the source of Jane’s drinking or as a simple villain; his presence exposes the imbalance and consequences of Jane’s behavior at work.
Thomas Crosby
The contested antiques dealerThomas Crosby is an Awadapquit antiques dealer who sells Genevieve an old Abenaki basket. Articles connect his former gallery to disputes over Indigenous objects. His role brings the novel’s questions about possession and cultural stewardship into Genevieve’s newly decorated home.
Evan
The museum colleagueEvan is Jane’s former graduate-school acquaintance, now a curator in Portland. He introduces Jane to a Wabanaki history exhibit and to Naomi Miller’s work. His enthusiasm reminds Jane of the intellectual community she has lost while on leave and helps redirect her research toward Indigenous history.
Plot Devices
Lake Grove
A house full of historiesThe cliffside property moves from family home to boardinghouse, from Marilyn’s retreat to Genevieve’s renovation, and finally toward becoming a museum. Its rooms and grounds hold multiple generations of women, children, workers, and Indigenous histories, often obscured by later owners. The hidden bedroom, cemetery, cliff, and former inn sign each reveal a different layer. The house works as more than a setting: its repeated alterations expose the tension between caring for a place and treating it as personal property.
Mediumship
A message across griefClementine’s reading gives Jane the clue of a girl called D who wants her mother to know she is at peace and no longer at Lake Grove. Benjamin’s account of a girl in his room supplies a second, uncertain connection. Mediums at Camp Mira offer competing claims, and the novel never makes every supernatural detail verifiable. The device moves Jane toward histories she would otherwise have left alone, while also testing her skepticism and showing why people seek contact with the dead.
The archival objects
Evidence carried in objectsLetters, a mourning ring, an old photograph, china, glassware, and a boardinghouse sign carry stories that official summaries omit. Jane’s professional skill helps her connect documents to people, but the objects are not neutral: the basket Genevieve buys raises questions about acquisition, while the ring recovered from a disturbed grave exposes the cost of treating history as something available for sale. Objects preserve memory, but their meanings depend on who made them, who kept them, and who has the right to interpret them.
The lost place-name
A map against erasureThe town’s familiar Indigenous name and the Wabanaki name Sawadapskw’i become evidence of how colonial histories distort or erase knowledge of place. Naomi explains that names once carried practical and cultural meaning, not merely scenic description. Barbara’s map and inherited account later connect the same landscape to a Wabanaki family story. This device shifts the novel’s historical scope from the private lives of house owners to the larger question of who was present before the town claimed to begin.
Blackouts and drinking
Memory that goes missingJane’s blackouts let consequences accumulate in the spaces she cannot remember. She repeatedly searches texts, photographs, and other people’s accounts to reconstruct what she did, turning her own life into a case file. The pattern echoes her work as an archivist, but with a cruel difference: the missing evidence concerns harm she has caused and the relationships she may lose. Alcohol offers temporary ease while making her less able to trust her memory, a cycle that the novel treats as both psychological and familial rather than as a single lapse of will.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.