Key Takeaways
Make every piece of content useful to people and sustainable for its publisher
Fit is the foundation. Good content suits its audience, its publisher, and the situation in which someone encounters it. It helps users accomplish real goals, while helping the organization meet business goals without exhausting its people or budget. The two interests are linked: content that wastes readers’ time can also drive them away from the organization it is meant to serve.
Plan for real conditions. Context includes what users are doing, what they know, how they feel, and what constraints they face. Someone contacting a medical service after hours may need immediate, practical guidance, not the same material they would seek during a routine appointment. Research improves these judgments, but no profile captures every circumstance. Useful content makes the likely answer easy to find without trapping readers in assumptions.
This principle treats usefulness as a relationship, not a property of the text alone. The same explanation can be excellent in a training manual and useless on a small phone screen during an urgent task. It also gives teams a way to reconcile user needs with organizational limits: a plan that cannot be maintained is not truly user-centered, because its quality will erode. The tension is that organizations may define sustainability too narrowly as low cost. A credible plan must count staff time and the harm caused by stale or inadequate information.
Give each page a job precise enough to judge
Specificity makes evaluation possible. A goal such as “sell products” is too broad to guide a page. Even “sell this product” leaves unclear what the content should do. A stronger purpose identifies the audience and the information that can help them decide, such as explaining how a product addresses a particular professional group’s needs. Once the job is clear, writers can choose evidence and structure that serve it, and reviewers can assess whether it works.
Make purpose visible. Define a job for each page, section, or content component before drafting or revising it. That purpose becomes a practical test: does the content deliver what this audience needs here? Without one, teams can spend time polishing language that is attractive but irrelevant, or debate quality using personal preference instead of agreed goals.
A page-level purpose functions like a testable hypothesis: this information, presented to this audience, should help them do something. That shift can make editorial review less subjective and expose gaps in organizational knowledge. It also disciplines measurement, since a team can ask whether the page performed its intended task rather than whether it merely attracted visits. One caution is that a page may serve several audiences or goals. In those cases, the purpose should clarify priorities, not pretend that competing needs have disappeared.
Use the audience’s language, needs, and moment, not the org chart
Start with people’s mental models. User-centered content describes the world in terms readers recognize, rather than reproducing internal department names, product divisions, or specialist jargon. A person looking for a common household tool should not have to understand a retailer’s internal taxonomy before finding it. The same principle applies online: navigation and labels should help people predict where information lives and what will happen when they select it.
Context changes the answer. Users’ goals, emotions, actions, and abilities shape what information is useful. A late-night search for public transit needs current service information more than a general overview. Research can uncover patterns, but it cannot anticipate every user’s situation. Offer a clear route to the likely answer, alongside a way to explore more detail when someone needs it.
The distinction between an organization’s map and a user’s map is a powerful diagnostic. Internal categories are often logical to staff because they reflect history, ownership, and budgets; those same categories can feel arbitrary to a newcomer. Translating them is not just a writing task. It may require changing navigation, search terms, or the underlying information structure. Context-aware design should also avoid over-personalization: inferred needs can be wrong, so users benefit from understandable choices and access to fuller information.
Delete content that consumes attention without helping anyone
More is not automatically better. Publishing everything an organization can produce makes useful material harder to find and spreads limited editorial effort across more pages. Common candidates for removal or revision include repetitive mission statements, unedited announcements, bloated feature lists, duplicate help pages, and videos padded with material readers must wait through. The deciding question is not whether content exists, but whether it serves a real audience need.
Use several kinds of evidence. Traffic data can reveal what people use, user research can show what they are trying to accomplish, and editorial judgment can identify material that is inaccurate, confusing, or needlessly long. Then trim at every level, from whole sections to paragraphs. Concision is not a demand to make every page short. It is a demand that each element earn the attention it takes.
Content removal is a form of information design: it reduces the number of choices and signals that the organization respects readers’ limited attention. The strongest case for pruning combines behavioral evidence with human interpretation, since low traffic may indicate either irrelevance or poor discoverability. There is also a governance dimension. Organizations often preserve pages because a department owns them or because deleting them feels politically risky. A clear purpose and accountable review process make those decisions easier to discuss.
Treat publishing as care work, not a CMS button
Content has a lifecycle. Facts need updating, expired event information needs removing, and community contributions need moderation. New material also needs planning, production, review, and distribution. These responsibilities continue after launch, which is why the book describes a recurring “Day Two Problem”: organizations prepare for publication but fail to plan for the work that follows.
Assign the human work. A content management system can store, display, and route material, but it cannot decide what should change, verify facts, or protect quality on its own. Maintenance must be recognized in staffing, job responsibilities, schedules, and budgets. A support plan should specify who reviews content, when that review happens, and what happens when information becomes obsolete. Otherwise, even a well-designed site can quietly become unreliable.
This view connects publishing to stewardship: information is not finished when it goes live because readers continue to rely on it under changing conditions. The comparison also corrects a common technology error, treating automation as a substitute for responsibility. Tools can reduce repetitive work, but accountability still needs an owner. Review schedules should be proportionate, though. Applying the same maintenance burden to every page wastes resources; high-risk and fast-changing information deserves closer attention than stable background material.
Build content strategy from editing, curation, persuasion, and information science
The discipline has several parents. Editors bring audience awareness, storytelling, and the coordination of creators. Curators contribute careful stewardship, attention to context, and systematic records. Marketing and rhetoric help teams shape persuasive messages, choose distribution channels, and assess results. Information science contributes methods for organizing, retrieving, and preserving information, including information architecture and content management practices.
The strategist runs point. Content strategy is not simply editing, marketing, or software administration. It joins these forms of expertise to plan content work, spot risks, and coordinate with designers, developers, researchers, and business teams. The strategist may flag a shortage of writers or an unrealistic launch plan before the problem lands on the people producing the content. Cross-training helps this role work across disciplinary boundaries without pretending to replace every specialist.
The field’s hybrid identity is useful because content problems rarely respect job titles. A page may fail because its claim is weak, its label is unfindable, its design obstructs reading, or nobody owns revisions. A team that understands these connections can diagnose the system rather than blaming the writer. The challenge is scope: an interdisciplinary practitioner can become a catch-all for work nobody else has planned. Clear authority, collaboration, and boundaries keep “running point” from becoming an excuse for chronic overload.
Define the project’s goals, constraints, and evidence of success first
Separate ends from requests. Stakeholders may ask for improved search or clearer navigation, but those are tactics, not necessarily the outcome the organization needs. Project definition distinguishes broad business goals, specific requests, immovable constraints such as budget or deadlines, and the objectives content work can actually achieve. Interviews and kickoff conversations help reveal where these elements align or conflict.
Set a measurable finish line. The book borrows the term “victory conditions” from games to describe explicit criteria for success. If a project aims to increase sign-ups, specify the target and the period in which it must be reached. Softer goals also need observable indicators. A brief that records objectives, constraints, and success measures gives the team a shared reference when new requests threaten to pull the work off course.
This practice protects projects from a familiar failure: mistaking activity for progress. A team can deliver a new navigation system and still miss the reason the redesign began. Separating outcomes from tactics makes it easier to consider alternative solutions and negotiate scope. Measurement needs care, however. Easily counted actions can crowd out harder goals such as comprehension or trust. A useful scorecard therefore combines behavioral measures with evidence about whether people can actually use the information.
Research users, existing content, and available capacity before prescribing change
Understand the starting point. Interviews help reveal what users need beyond the assumptions an organization has accumulated about them. Teams can summarize those findings with user proxies, such as personas or scenarios, which represent likely goals and behaviors for design discussions. A content inventory then records what already exists, including its location, format, type, and responsible owner. For a large site, that work can involve thousands of pieces.
Evaluate against evidence. A qualitative content audit judges whether material is appropriate, useful, clear, consistent, concise, and maintained. It is most meaningful after user needs are understood, since quality cannot be judged without knowing whom the content serves. Competitive reviews, workflow analysis, traffic data, and resource assessments add context. Together, these findings show what to keep, improve, create, or remove, and how much work those choices require.
The sequence matters: inventory tells a team what it has, while user research helps explain whether those assets matter. Together they prevent redesign from becoming a cosmetic exercise built around internal preference. Capacity analysis adds a less glamorous but essential check: recommendations are only useful if an organization can execute and maintain them. Research also has limits. Interviews and proxies simplify varied lives into patterns, so they should guide inquiry rather than become rigid descriptions of every user.
Turn messages into structures, channels, and measurable audience actions
Shape the communication before drafting pages. Messages are internal statements of the ideas an organization needs to convey, not finished copy. A message can be developed through evidence and reasoning, an emotional appeal, or the credibility of the organization speaking. These approaches help content teams decide how to communicate without turning every page into a slogan. Major shifts in audience, features, or tone should be explained with research and introduced early enough for stakeholders to respond.
Choose the route to the reader. A website is only one possible channel. A useful distribution plan may assign different parts of a message to a site, email, social channels, publications, or multimedia. Channel choice should reflect audience needs and business goals. Define how performance will be assessed, too. Visits and clicks can help, but the right indicators depend on what the content is intended to accomplish.
The distinction between a message and its expression is strategically valuable: a consistent idea can be adapted to the expectations of different channels without copying identical language everywhere. The rhetorical lens also makes persuasion more transparent by asking whether a claim rests on evidence, emotion, or credibility. That transparency matters because persuasive skill can serve readers or manipulate them. Measurement should therefore ask not only whether people acted, but whether the content helped them make an informed decision.
Give creators templates, authority, time, and an editor
Make strategy usable. A content template turns a page’s purpose into practical instructions. It identifies required and optional elements, explains what each should accomplish, sets useful specifications, and gives examples. That structure helps subject experts provide the right information and gives writers a clearer starting point than a blank document. Wireframes show how pages fit together; templates explain what belongs in their content.
Resource the whole process. Content may come from dedicated creators, internal experts, or curated material, but none is effortless. Experts need time and editorial support; writers need access to accurate subject knowledge; curation requires judgment and ongoing attention. An editorial lead coordinates reviews and approvals, while calendars and workflows support regular publishing and maintenance. The work is iterative: assess what exists, design a response, carry it out, then examine what happened.
Templates are valuable because they translate abstract strategy into a shared production interface between experts, writers, and publishing systems. They can improve consistency without requiring every contributor to become a professional editor. Yet a template cannot repair a missing decision-maker or create time in an overloaded team. Its effectiveness depends on authority and collaboration around it. The larger lesson is that content quality is organizationally produced: good prose matters, but so do access to expertise, review capacity, and clear ownership.
Analysis
Kissane’s central contribution is to reposition content from a late-stage writing task to an operating system for communication. The book’s examples repeatedly expose the cost of treating content as decoration: users confront internal labels, teams discover missing material near launch, and organizations mistake a content management system for a publishing process. The alternative is a connected practice that begins with purpose and user context, examines existing assets and capacity, shapes information and distribution, then assigns responsibility for production and upkeep.
The book’s strongest organizing idea is appropriateness. It ties user usefulness to business sustainability, avoiding the false choice between serving readers and serving an organization. Its professional lineage reinforces that claim: editing supplies audience judgment, curation supplies stewardship, marketing supplies persuasion and evaluation, and information science supplies structure and retrieval. Content strategy becomes the work of coordinating these capabilities, not claiming ownership of them all.
The book appeared in 2011, and some of its channel examples and technology references belong to that moment. The underlying problem has not aged in the same way. Organizations still publish across multiple formats, depend on people to maintain information, and risk confusing output volume with usefulness. The framework is therefore more durable than its period-specific examples.
A productive tension remains between consistency and context. Shared language and standards lower the burden on readers, but strict uniformity can erase differences between audiences, regions, or situations. Likewise, analytics can expose patterns without explaining their causes. The book’s insistence on research, judgment, and human ownership is a necessary counterweight to those limits. Its practical test is not whether a team has produced a strategy document, but whether that plan changes what readers can find, understand, and use, while remaining possible for the organization to sustain.
Review Summary
The Elements of Content Strategy receives mixed reviews. Many praise it as a concise, informative primer on content strategy, highlighting its usefulness for beginners and its practical advice. Readers appreciate the book's dense information and its ability to make them better at their work. However, some criticize it for being dry, lacking depth, and not offering enough new information for experienced professionals. The book's brevity is seen as both a strength and a weakness, with some finding it too basic and others valuing its concise nature.
People Also Read
Glossary
Content strategy
Plans and governs useful contentThe planning and leadership of content projects and ongoing publishing. It determines what content should communicate, whom it serves, how it should be created and distributed, and how it will be maintained. The practice combines editorial, business, user, organizational, and technical considerations rather than focusing only on writing or marketing.
The Day Two Problem
Neglecting content after launchThe failure to plan for the work that begins once a website or content project goes live. Organizations may budget for launch while overlooking ongoing production, review, distribution, moderation, and maintenance. The result can be outdated or unmanaged content, even when the initial project was carefully designed.
User proxies
Research-based user stand-insRepresentations that synthesize user research into likely needs, goals, and behaviors for a project team to use when evaluating ideas. Personas, scenarios, use cases, and activity flows are examples. They need not be elaborate documents, but should be grounded in research rather than stereotypes or unsupported assumptions.
Content inventory
Record of existing contentA detailed accounting of pages and other content assets relevant to a project. An inventory commonly records each item’s title, format, location, content type, and responsible owner. It helps teams understand the size and shape of existing material before deciding what to retain, revise, remove, or create.
Qualitative content audit
Assessment of content qualityA review of content that evaluates its quality and usefulness against defined criteria and audience needs. It can examine whether material is appropriate, clear, consistent, concise, current, and fit for purpose. User research helps establish the context for these judgments, while the audit helps estimate the work needed to improve content.
Victory conditions
Specific criteria for successExplicit, measurable conditions that establish when a project has succeeded. The term is borrowed from game design, where a player can identify what constitutes winning. In content projects, these criteria translate broad aims into observable results, such as a defined increase in sign-ups within a specified period.
Information architecture
Structures that make information findableThe design of information structures, including navigation and content taxonomies, to help people find what they need and complete tasks. Its work can include site maps, wireframes, page diagrams, and user flows. It overlaps with content strategy when teams organize, label, and connect information.
Content template
Instructions for a content typeA structured guide for creating a specific kind of page or content component. It identifies required and optional information, explains the purpose of each element, sets specifications such as format or length, and supplies examples. Templates help subject experts and writers produce content that fits user needs and site structure.
Channel strategy
Plan for content distributionA plan for selecting how content reaches its intended audience. Possible channels include websites, email, social communication, publications, applications, and multimedia. The choice should reflect audience needs and organizational goals, rather than treating publication on a website as a complete distribution plan.
FAQ
1. What is "The Elements of Content Strategy" by Erin Kissane about?
- Foundational guide to content strategy: The book distills the core principles, competencies, and practices of content strategy, focusing on planning, creation, publication, and governance of useful, usable content.
- Not a how-to manual: It is not a step-by-step tutorial or exhaustive compendium, but rather a concise reference for understanding the discipline’s essentials.
- Three-part structure: The book is organized into “Basic Principles,” “The Craft of Content Strategy,” and “Tools and Techniques,” providing a holistic overview.
- For all web professionals: It’s written for anyone involved in web projects—designers, writers, editors, marketers, and developers—who want to improve their approach to content.
2. Why should I read "The Elements of Content Strategy" by Erin Kissane?
- Clarifies a complex field: The book demystifies content strategy, making it accessible and actionable for professionals at any level.
- Practical, real-world advice: It offers concrete principles and methods that can be applied immediately to web projects of any size.
- Bridges multiple disciplines: Kissane draws on editorial, curatorial, marketing, and information science traditions, making the book relevant across roles.
- Advocates for better content: It helps readers understand why good content matters and how to advocate for it within organizations.
3. What are the key takeaways from "The Elements of Content Strategy"?
- Content must be appropriate: Good content is right for both the user and the business, considering context, goals, and sustainability.
- User-centered and purposeful: Content should be clear, useful, user-centered, consistent, concise, and always supported by a maintenance plan.
- Content strategy is multidisciplinary: The field draws from editing, curation, marketing, and information science, requiring cross-training and collaboration.
- No one-size-fits-all: There is no generic playbook; content strategy is about applying core principles to unique situations and evolving needs.
4. How does Erin Kissane define content strategy in "The Elements of Content Strategy"?
- Strategic planning for content: Content strategy is the planning and leadership of content projects and online publishing endeavors.
- Beyond copywriting: It is to copywriting what information architecture is to design—focused on structure, purpose, and governance, not just creation.
- Holistic approach: It encompasses creation, publication, and ongoing management, ensuring content is useful, usable, and sustainable.
- Alignment with business and user needs: The discipline ensures that content serves both organizational goals and user requirements.
5. What are the core principles of content strategy according to "The Elements of Content Strategy"?
- Appropriateness: Content must be right for the user, the business, and the context in which it appears.
- Usefulness and purpose: Every piece of content should have a clear, specific purpose and be evaluated against that purpose.
- User-centeredness: Content should adopt the cognitive frameworks and language of its users, not just internal jargon.
- Clarity, consistency, and conciseness: Content must be clear, consistent in style and presentation, and free of unnecessary information.
- Support and maintenance: No content should be published without a plan for its ongoing support and management.
6. What is the role of a content strategist as described by Erin Kissane?
- Project leadership: The content strategist leads content projects, acting as a point person who anticipates and manages risks.
- Cross-functional collaboration: They work with designers, developers, marketers, and stakeholders to align content with broader project goals.
- User and content advocacy: Content strategists advocate for both user needs and the requirements of content throughout the project lifecycle.
- Resource management: They assess available resources, plan for sustainable content creation, and ensure ongoing maintenance is feasible.
7. How does "The Elements of Content Strategy" explain the origins and influences of content strategy?
- Editorial roots: The discipline borrows heavily from editorial work, emphasizing serving the reader, storytelling, and publishing processes.
- Curatorial influence: Content strategists act as curators, caring for collections of content, ensuring quality, and respecting context.
- Marketing and rhetoric: The field incorporates principles of persuasion, messaging, and channel strategy from marketing and rhetoric.
- Information science: It draws on information architecture and content management, focusing on structure, taxonomy, and findability.
8. What methodologies and deliverables does Erin Kissane recommend in "The Elements of Content Strategy"?
- Three-phase methodology: Kissane’s approach involves Evaluate (research and assessment), Design (strategy and planning), and Execute (implementation).
- Key deliverables: These include content audits (quantitative and qualitative), user research, personas, communication briefs, editorial calendars, style guides, content templates, and workflow recommendations.
- Audience-focused documentation: Deliverables should be tailored to their intended audience—internal teams, clients, or stakeholders.
- Iterative and flexible: Methodologies and deliverables should be adapted to the project’s needs, not rigidly applied.
9. How does "The Elements of Content Strategy" advise on user research and content audits?
- User research first: Begin with interviews and develop user proxies (personas, scenarios) to ground content decisions in real needs.
- Content inventory: Conduct a quantitative audit to catalog all existing content, noting titles, formats, URLs, types, and owners.
- Qualitative audit: Assess content quality based on user needs and core principles—appropriateness, usefulness, clarity, etc.
- Synthesis and reporting: Summarize findings to inform strategy, identify quick fixes, and guide future content planning.
10. What guidance does Erin Kissane provide for content creation and management in "The Elements of Content Strategy"?
- Content creation options: Content can be produced by dedicated creators, internal experts, or through curation/aggregation.
- Editorial leadership: Assign an editorial lead to manage the process, facilitate information transfer, and maintain quality.
- Templates and guidelines: Use content templates and style guides to standardize and streamline content development.
- Ongoing management: Plan for regular reviews, updates, and maintenance, ensuring content remains accurate and effective.
11. What are some of the most important quotes from "The Elements of Content Strategy" and what do they mean?
- “Content strategy plans for the creation, publication, and governance of useful, usable content.” — Kristina Halvorson; underscores the comprehensive scope of content strategy.
- “Good content is appropriate for your business, for your users, and for its context.” — Erin Kissane; highlights the central principle of appropriateness.
- “An editor’s only permanent alliance is with the audience, the readership.” — Arthur Plotnik (quoted); emphasizes the user-centered nature of content work.
- “Content is expensive.” — Erin Kissane; reminds readers that quality content requires investment in people, time, and resources.
12. How can someone get started in content strategy, according to Erin Kissane?
- No single path: Most content strategists arrive from related fields—editing, design, marketing, or information management.
- Start doing the work: The best way to enter the field is to begin applying content strategy principles in your current role.
- Cross-disciplinary skills: Develop knowledge in information architecture, design, user experience, and communication.
- Engage with the community: Read content strategy blogs, attend events, and connect with practitioners to learn and find opportunities.
A Book Apart Series Series
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.