Key Takeaways
Study cyber operations as daily statecraft, not a digital nuclear exchange
The quiet contest matters. The book challenges the familiar image of cyber conflict as a rare, civilization-threatening strike. Most state hacking is less cinematic: governments spy, steal, sabotage, and disrupt in pursuit of a steady advantage. The Shadow Brokers showed how this routine competition can suddenly become public. Their 2016 release of NSA tools helped enable attacks that caused more than $14 billion in damage, even though the original operation was espionage, not a declaration of war.
Shape the conditions. The book distinguishes signaling, which communicates resolve or intent, from shaping, which secretly changes the environment to benefit one side. Cyber operations can do the second remarkably well. They are much less reliable at the first because their effects are hard to calibrate, their purpose can be obscure, and revealing a capability often weakens it.
The distinction redirects attention from spectacular scenarios to cumulative effects. In political science, this resembles the difference between public commitment and the less visible management of institutions, information, and access. A secret intrusion may alter what leaders know or what options they consider without producing a dramatic event. That makes cyber power easy to underestimate. The distinction also has limits: public attacks and leaks can be deliberate messages, even if they communicate poorly. The stronger claim is not that cyber operations never signal, but that secrecy, uncertain effects, and disputed attribution make them unreliable instruments of calibrated coercion.
Turn infrastructure access into intelligence before rivals know what matters
Geography still counts. Digital messages travel through physical cables, switches, and data centers. The Five Eyes alliance, comprising the United States, United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, occupies many important points in that infrastructure. The United States also benefits from the global reach of companies such as AT&T, Google, and Facebook, whose networks and data can provide intelligence access.
A vote shaped by secrets. Before a 2010 United Nations Security Council vote on sanctions against Iran, the NSA rapidly expanded surveillance of four newly seated member countries. Intelligence drawn partly from AT&T's access to United Nations communications helped US negotiators identify other governments' positions and negotiating limits. The resolution passed 12 to 2. The advantage depended on hidden collection, not on publicly threatening the other countries.
This is a useful corrective to the idea that the internet has erased geography. Physical routing and corporate jurisdiction create chokepoints, much as ports and trade routes have shaped earlier empires. The example also shows that intelligence is valuable only when it reaches decision-makers in time to change their choices. Yet access is not the same as understanding: a large haul of communications can overwhelm analysts or mislead them. The strategic advantage therefore rests on a chain of infrastructure, legal authority, corporate cooperation, analysis, and political judgment. A weakness at any link can blunt the benefit.
Encryption backdoors trade one country's access for everyone's exposure
One weakness travels far. Modern encryption is widely shared: the same systems protect ordinary users, businesses, governments, and intelligence targets. That convergence makes a deliberate weakness especially dangerous. NOBUS, short for “Nobody But Us,” describes the aspiration to exploit a vulnerability that only one highly capable agency can use. It depends on correctly judging what competitors can do, a difficult bet.
The Juniper warning. The Dual EC random-number system adopted by standards bodies had weaknesses that researchers warned could permit a hidden backdoor. Juniper Networks later incorporated it into security products used by governments and companies. Subsequent unexplained code changes created further possible backdoors, including a hidden password that could grant remote access. Investigators could not establish every actor's role, but the episode showed how a secret advantage can escape its supposed owner and expose customers worldwide.
The dilemma resembles a security externality: one organization may gain from a weakness while imposing risk on every user who relies on the same system. It also exposes a governance problem. Technical standards derive legitimacy from review and reproducibility, so secret influence can corrode trust well beyond one product. The strongest argument for retaining an exploitable flaw is that a uniquely capable agency may use it while rivals cannot. The weakness in that argument is epistemic: agencies cannot reliably know who else can exploit a vulnerability, or whether the flaw will remain secret. “Only us” is an aspiration, not a durable guarantee.
Bulk data theft can quietly redraw economic and military competition
Digital theft scales. Traditional spies stole documents one at a time; hackers can copy entire repositories in hours. China's long-running campaign used spear-phishing, deceptive emails designed to trick particular people into opening malicious files or surrendering credentials, to reach a broad range of Western targets. A private-sector investigation linked one Chinese group, APT1, to at least 141 organizations over seven years, including companies in industries aligned with Chinese strategic priorities.
The advantage compounds. APT1 stole product designs, business plans, and negotiating material. During a major Westinghouse nuclear-power deal in China, hackers reportedly took about 700,000 pages of company emails and documents. In a separate operation, a Chinese businessman helped military hackers select files on US aircraft, including the C-17. The resulting Y-20 cargo plane appeared in about a third of the time it had taken the United States to develop the original.
Espionage here functions as a shortcut through the expensive stages of research, negotiation, and military development. It is not merely information gathering; it can redistribute the returns on innovation toward the party that steals and applies the knowledge. The effect is difficult to measure because copied information does not automatically become a working product, and technical resemblance alone cannot prove the source of a design. Still, the cases show why economic security and national security overlap. The strategic harm may be less a single stolen secret than a persistent shift in the target's cost, bargaining power, and time to market.
Defend by penetrating adversaries' operations, not only hardening your own
Counterintelligence turns outward. Rather than waiting inside their own networks, defenders can seek access to the systems adversaries use to attack. In one operation, NSA hackers followed Chinese military hackers through compromised computers, or “hop points,” used to disguise their origin. By observing those machines and then targeting the internet provider used by the Chinese operators, they linked activity to specific accounts and learned more about the adversary's methods and targets.
Steal the stolen view. Fourth-party collection means acquiring information that another intelligence service has already stolen from its own target. The NSA, for example, reportedly obtained United Nations documents by accessing infrastructure used by Chinese hackers who had stolen them. This can reveal both an adversary's capabilities and the intelligence it has collected. It is an offensive form of defense, but the compromised relay computers often belong to uninvolved third parties.
The logic resembles active defense in public health: identifying the source and pathway of an outbreak can protect more than one immediate victim. It also resembles competitive intelligence, except the stakes include state secrets and operational access. This approach can help defenders anticipate attacks rather than simply repair damage. Its costs are substantial, however. Hacking intermediaries can place innocent owners in the crossfire, and intelligence obtained through an adversary may be incomplete or deliberately misleading. The method is most defensible when the information meaningfully reduces risk, not when the ability to intrude is treated as a goal in itself.
Use sabotage to create doubt, not merely destroy equipment
Uncertainty can be the weapon. Stuxnet, a US-Israeli operation against Iran's Natanz nuclear facility, manipulated the operation of uranium-enrichment centrifuges while showing Iranian engineers misleading signs of normal functioning. The design aimed not only to damage equipment, but to make failures look like engineering problems and slow the program while Iran investigated. Analysts estimate that Stuxnet destroyed more than a thousand centrifuges and delayed enrichment by roughly one to three years.
Precision has a price. The operation required detailed reconnaissance, testing on similar centrifuges, and safeguards to limit the worm's effects. Even so, Stuxnet escaped its intended environment and infected more than 100,000 computers around the world. A separate operation known as Wiper later damaged computers in Iran's oil sector. The episodes illustrate a central tradeoff: covert sabotage can buy time, but a self-spreading tool is difficult to control perfectly.
The deeper target of sabotage can be an organization's confidence in its own explanations. In engineering, unexplained failure consumes time and attention because teams must test competing hypotheses before they can safely resume normal operations. That makes concealment strategically valuable. But the same uncertainty can backfire: a target may interpret the event as an attack, harden its systems, or accelerate its program. Stuxnet's technical success and its broader political meaning are not identical. A delay can create room for diplomacy, but it cannot by itself determine whether leaders use that room well.
Don't mistake a destructive hack for a credible threat
Damage is not leverage. Iran's attacks on Saudi Aramco and American banks demonstrated that state-linked hackers could disrupt major businesses. Shamoon rendered more than 35,000 Aramco computers unusable, while Operation Ababil flooded bank websites with traffic. But these attacks did not clearly compel the targets to change policy. They expressed anger more readily than a credible, calibrated bargain.
Sony was a harder test. North Korean hackers stole files, damaged Sony Pictures' network, and threatened further leaks to stop the release of the film The Interview. Sony initially canceled its theatrical release, but the film soon appeared online and in independent theaters, becoming a symbol of resistance to censorship. The attackers' cyber coercion did not secure the lasting outcome they wanted. The episode shows that a threat can inflict real costs and still fail to control the target's decision.
Coercion requires more than pain. The target must understand the demand, believe the threatener can sustain or escalate pressure, and see compliance as preferable to resistance. Cyber attacks often struggle on all three counts: attribution can be disputed, capabilities can be spent in a single strike, and the damage may be too erratic to calibrate. Sony's first response also shows that coercion is interactive. A threat can stiffen resolve when leaders or audiences interpret compliance as a dangerous precedent. The film's eventual release was not simply a measure of technical resilience; it reflected public and political choices.
Influence campaigns widen social cracks that already exist
The hack was only one part. In 2016, Russian operators breached Democratic organizations, stole emails, and released selected files through websites and WikiLeaks. The releases were paired with fake social-media identities, targeted advertising, misleading stories, and political events organized under false pretenses. The campaign sought both to damage Hillary Clinton and to intensify divisions in American society. Russian-administered Facebook content reached more than 126 million people.
The wedge needs a crack. The book compares influence to a wedge: it works best when driven into a division that already exists. Leaks about Democratic primary politics gained attention partly because they fit existing suspicions about the party. Journalists, politicians, and ordinary users amplified material beyond the operators' own accounts. The evidence supports a Russian effort to sow division and help Trump, but it does not establish precisely how much that effort changed the election result.
This account treats influence as a system effect rather than a message-delivery problem. The operator supplies material, but platforms reward engagement, journalists select stories, and audiences interpret information through prior beliefs. That distribution chain can magnify a small foreign effort without any single intermediary intending to assist it. The wedge metaphor is powerful because it emphasizes local vulnerability, not just foreign skill. It also points to a harder response than deleting fake accounts: societies need institutions and habits that preserve shared standards for checking evidence. Yet no single measure can eliminate political disagreement, nor should it try.
A leaked exploit can turn state advantage into worldwide collateral damage
Secrets can become weapons for others. The Shadow Brokers released powerful NSA hacking tools, including ETERNALBLUE, a Windows exploit. The leak helped North Korean hackers build WannaCry, a self-spreading ransomware attack that infected hundreds of thousands of computers in more than 150 countries. Britain's National Health Service was disrupted, and total damage was estimated at more than $4 billion. A researcher slowed the outbreak after noticing and registering a domain that acted as a kill switch.
NotPetya scaled further. Russian hackers inserted malicious code into updates for MeDoc, software widely used by Ukrainian businesses. The resulting worm spread globally, destroying data rather than providing a workable path to ransom payment. Shipping firm Maersk had to rebuild thousands of servers and tens of thousands of computers. The attack caused more than $10 billion in damage, illustrating how automated propagation can erase the boundary between intended targets and unintended victims.
These incidents reveal a security externality built into offensive capability. An exploit kept secret may aid intelligence collection, but if it leaks, the cost is borne by users who never consented to the gamble. Automation magnifies that cost because it allows malicious code to reproduce faster than organizations can coordinate a response. The analogy to conventional weapons is imperfect, since software can be copied and repurposed, but that makes control harder, not easier. The policy question is therefore not simply whether an agency should retain a tool. It is whether the expected intelligence value justifies the public risk of keeping it vulnerable to theft.
Expect financial hackers to steal trust along with money
Banks are connected targets. North Korean hackers targeted the SWIFT system, which financial institutions use to communicate international transactions. In 2016, attackers who had compromised Bangladesh's central bank tried to transfer nearly $1 billion from its account at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Most transfers were stopped, but $101 million went through. Much of the $81 million sent to the Philippines disappeared through casino-linked accounts. A disabled transaction printer helped conceal the fraud while it unfolded.
The campaign evolved. North Korean operations also targeted cryptocurrency exchanges and used ransomware to distract or disrupt victims while attempting financial theft. In India, attackers reportedly used cloned bank cards to withdraw about $11 million across 28 countries in just over two hours. The profits helped fund a heavily sanctioned state, while manipulation of records and payment systems threatened confidence in the financial networks used by businesses and governments.
Financial infrastructure relies on shared confidence that instructions, records, and identities are authentic. An attack that falsifies transaction messages therefore threatens more than a bank's balance sheet: it raises doubts about whether the system can distinguish authorized activity from fraud. This resembles a problem in institutional economics, where trust lowers the cost of coordination but becomes a high-value target when it is concentrated in common systems. The Bangladesh case also shows that technical security and operational practice are inseparable. A weak local network, a hidden intrusion, and a delayed human response combined to create a global financial vulnerability.
Analysis
The book's most useful move is to relocate cyber power from the imagined battlefield to the ongoing contest over access, knowledge, and institutional confidence. Its distinction between shaping and signaling explains why some operations matter greatly without producing a visible political decision: intelligence can alter a negotiation, theft can shorten a competitor's research timeline, and sabotage can consume an adversary's attention. Cyber operations are not simply miniature versions of conventional weapons. Their effects depend on secrecy, software design, networks, and the choices of people who may not know they are participants.
The cases also demonstrate that capability is not the same as control. Stuxnet achieved a highly specific technical effect but spread beyond its intended setting. WannaCry turned a leaked exploit into a worldwide outbreak, while NotPetya's destructive reach exceeded the Ukrainian setting in which it began. These episodes expose a fundamental tension: the qualities that make cyber tools useful, replication, remote access, and speed, also make them difficult to contain. A state may seek a narrow advantage and impose broad costs on firms, workers, patients, and citizens.
The argument is strongest when it distinguishes operational effects from political outcomes. Aramco suffered severe disruption without a clear policy concession; Sony's temporary retreat did not produce permanent censorship; and the election operation's social reach does not allow a confident measurement of votes changed. These are not failures of storytelling, but features of the evidence. Cyber operations often create ambiguity, and the public record is necessarily incomplete. Still, that uncertainty means claims of strategic success should be made carefully. Access, damage, and attention are observable; durable political advantage is harder to prove.
The book's overall warning is therefore neither that cyber catastrophe is inevitable nor that hacking is inconsequential. It is that states have normalized persistent interference, while defenses, norms, and public understanding lag behind. The most consequential question is not whether a single attack qualifies as war. It is how repeated intrusions change the ordinary conditions under which governments, companies, and citizens make decisions.
Review Summary
The Hacker and the State explores the role of cyber operations in geopolitics, covering major attacks like Stuxnet and NotPetya. Buchanan argues that cyber capabilities are better for shaping events than signaling intentions, unlike conventional weapons. The book provides a comprehensive overview of state-sponsored hacking, detailing operations by various countries. Readers appreciate its analytical approach and historical context, though some found certain sections overly detailed. Overall, it's considered an informative and well-researched examination of cybersecurity's impact on international relations.
People Also Read
Glossary
Shaping
Changing the strategic environmentA form of statecraft that quietly alters conditions to advantage one side or constrain another. Cyber operations can shape by collecting secrets, stealing intellectual property, sabotaging equipment, or disrupting organizations. Unlike a public threat, shaping often works best when the target does not know who acted or how.
Signaling
Communicating intent or resolveA state communicates information about its priorities, capabilities, or willingness to act in order to influence another state's choices. Traditional examples include visible military deployments. The book argues that cyber operations often signal poorly because their effects are hard to calibrate, their purposes can be unclear, and useful capabilities may depend on secrecy.
Home-field advantage
Geographic and corporate accessThe intelligence advantage enjoyed by the United States and its close partners because important communications routes, telecommunications hubs, internet companies, and data centers fall within their reach or jurisdiction. The advantage combines physical access to network infrastructure with legal or cooperative access to information held by firms.
Passive collection
Intercepting passing communicationsIntelligence gathering that captures communications as they move through cables, telecommunications hubs, or other network chokepoints, rather than first installing malicious code on a target device. It can provide access to large volumes of foreign data, but routing is unpredictable, encryption can block access, and collection may sweep in information belonging to unintended users.
NOBUS
An exploit only one side can useShort for “Nobody But Us,” this is the aspiration to exploit a vulnerability that an intelligence agency believes only it has the resources or knowledge to use. The approach seeks to preserve access against adversaries while leaving systems secure against less capable actors. Its weakness is that the agency may misjudge who else can exploit the flaw.
Fourth-party collection
Taking another spy's intelligenceIntelligence gathered by accessing information that a different intelligence service has stolen from its own targets. The collection may be passive, by intercepting the other service's traffic, or active, by hacking its infrastructure. It can reveal the rival's methods and provide access to secrets that would otherwise be difficult to obtain.
Spear-phishing
Targeted deceptive messagingA social-engineering technique in which an attacker sends a tailored message to a specific person or group, hoping the recipient will open an attachment, follow a link, or provide login credentials. Because the message can imitate a colleague or familiar service, it can provide an initial foothold in an organization's network.
Worm
Self-spreading malicious softwareMalicious software that can copy itself from one computer or network to another without requiring a new manual installation at each step. Worms can spread rapidly and reach systems beyond an attacker's original target. Their ability to propagate makes them powerful, but also difficult to contain once released.
FAQ
What's The Hacker and the State about?
- Cyber Operations Focus: The book examines how cyber attacks have become essential tools in modern geopolitics, evolving from espionage to sabotage and destabilization.
- Historical Context: Ben Buchanan provides a historical overview of significant cyber incidents involving nations like the U.S., China, and Russia, linking them to broader international relations themes.
- Geopolitical Impact: It argues that cyber operations have reshaped traditional warfare and diplomacy, making them crucial in statecraft.
Why should I read The Hacker and the State?
- Modern Threats Insight: The book offers a deep dive into the complexities of cyber warfare, crucial for understanding its impact on national security and international relations.
- Accessible Analysis: Buchanan combines technical details with historical narratives, making the subject approachable for both technical and non-technical readers.
- Strategic Implications: It provides a framework for policymakers to understand and leverage cyber capabilities for strategic purposes.
What are the key takeaways of The Hacker and the State?
- Cyber as Statecraft: Cyber operations are integral to shaping geopolitical landscapes, used for manipulation, disruption, and destabilization.
- Home-Field Advantage: The U.S. and allies have an advantage in cyber operations due to control over key internet infrastructure.
- Operational Limits: Not all cyber operations succeed, as illustrated by various case studies in the book.
What are the best quotes from The Hacker and the State and what do they mean?
- “Hacking was a fundamental...tool of American statecraft.”: Highlights the integral role of cyber operations in modern geopolitical strategies.
- “The chaotic arena of cyber operations...”: Reflects the unpredictable and frequent nature of cyber warfare.
- “The struggle for advantage remains broad...”: Suggests the ongoing nature of cyber competition among states.
How does The Hacker and the State define cyber operations?
- Broad Definition: Cyber operations are actions by states to achieve strategic objectives through digital means, including espionage, sabotage, and destabilization.
- Types of Operations: Categorized into espionage, sabotage, and destabilization, each serving different strategic purposes.
- Operational Complexity: Success depends on careful planning and understanding of targets and environments.
What role does counterintelligence play in The Hacker and the State?
- Proactive Measures: Counterintelligence involves penetrating adversaries' operations to gather intelligence on foreign hackers.
- Secrecy Importance: Effectiveness often relies on maintaining secrecy to prevent adversaries from adapting.
- Case Studies: Examples like the NSA's tracking of Chinese hackers illustrate the dynamic nature of cyber espionage.
What are some notable examples discussed in The Hacker and the State?
- Stuxnet: A joint U.S.-Israel operation targeting Iran's nuclear centrifuges, marking a significant evolution in cyber warfare.
- Operation Aurora: A Chinese campaign targeting U.S. companies like Google, highlighting state-sponsored hacking's aggressive nature.
- Ukrainian Blackouts: Cyber attacks on Ukraine's power grid demonstrate the impact of cyber warfare on civilian infrastructure.
How does The Hacker and the State address the concept of signaling in cyber operations?
- Signaling vs. Shaping: Distinguishes between communicating intentions and manipulating environments, with cyber capabilities better suited for shaping.
- Signaling Challenges: Cyber operations often lack clarity and credibility, leading to misunderstandings.
- Case Examples: Illustrates how signaling attempts through cyber operations often fall short.
What is the significance of the Shadow Brokers in The Hacker and the State?
- Leaked NSA Tools: The group leaked powerful NSA hacking tools, exposing vulnerabilities and impacting global cybersecurity.
- Impact on Operations: Their actions led to widespread attacks like WannaCry, reshaping cyber warfare.
- Operational Security Challenges: Raised questions about the NSA's security and the utility of exposed tools.
How does The Hacker and the State explain the evolution of North Korean cyber capabilities?
- From Counterfeiting to Cybercrime: Traces North Korea's shift to sophisticated cybercrime, driven by the need for hard currency.
- Targeting Financial Institutions: Details systematic attacks on global financial institutions, showcasing growing ambition.
- Ransomware Use: Discusses ransomware like WannaCry as a revenue-generating and disruptive tool.
What are the implications of the NotPetya attack as discussed in The Hacker and the State?
- Widespread Disruption: NotPetya caused billions in damages, highlighting cyber operations' potential to disrupt infrastructure.
- Geopolitical Messaging: Served as a message to businesses in Ukraine about the risks of Russian aggression.
- Cybersecurity Lessons: Emphasizes the need for robust defenses against future attacks.
How does The Hacker and the State address the challenges of attribution in cyber operations?
- Attribution Complexity: Discusses difficulties in identifying attackers, complicating responses and deterrence.
- Case Studies: Examples like the DNC hack illustrate how attribution challenges hinder effective responses.
- National Security Implications: Calls for improved attribution methods to enhance accountability in cyberspace.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.