Plot Summary
Wedding Without a Groom
Goldy Bear1 has prepared her own reception and is trying to keep the wedding on schedule despite a missing groom, a locked reception hall, and a late priest. Her son, Arch,3 reassures her that the food is being moved, and her friend Marla5 helps manage the church.
Then Goldy1 learns why Tom Schulz,2 her fiancé2 and the county's lead homicide investigator, has not arrived: he went to collect Father Theodore Olson6 and found him shot dead. The wedding is postponed. When officers reach Olson's6 remote home, they discover signs of a struggle and find Tom2 gone. Goldy's1 second chance at marriage gives way, in a single morning, to fear that the man she loves has been taken by a killer.
The wedding's practical disorder matters because it makes Goldy's private hopes visible before violence interrupts them. She has organized food, family, and church ritual as if careful labor could protect a new household from the failures of her first marriage. Instead, the ceremony is derailed by a death that turns her fiancé's professional instincts into personal danger. The opening therefore links care with vulnerability: Goldy can feed a crowd and solve logistical crises, but she cannot manage what happens to Tom once he enters Olson's isolated home.
Clues in the Creek
Police bring Goldy1 to Olson's6 creekside property because Tom2 may have left evidence while being taken. In the churned mud, she identifies Tom's2 wallet, keys, and the velvet box holding the wedding ring he had meant to give her. Investigators find only one other set of footprints, so the abductor may have acted alone.
A damp page from Tom's spiral notebook contains compressed notes about a vehicle, Olson's6 gunshot wounds, prayer, and Judas, but Goldy1 cannot interpret them. The officers believe Tom2 was injured in the struggle and may have been forced into a vehicle. Goldy1 returns home with no answer about where he is, but with the conviction that Tom2 left the page deliberately and that its clues are meant to lead someone to him.
The objects at the creek make absence physical. The ring is meant to join two people, but the police recover it from the site where their future was interrupted. Tom's notebook offers a different kind of intimacy: his trained habit of recording facts becomes a message to Goldy, even though she cannot yet read it. Her usefulness is also tested. She is not an investigator by profession, but her knowledge of Tom's handwriting and habits gives the police access to details their evidence alone cannot supply.
A Parish Full of Rumors
At home, Goldy1 tells Arch3 that Tom2 has been abducted, while both try to hold on to the belief that he is alive. When she returns to the church office to retrieve Tom's2 ring, she finds the rooms ransacked and the phones smashed; she reports the break-in to police. Marla5 brings food and reveals that forty thousand dollars in pearl chokers intended for a church fundraiser cannot be found at Olson's6 house.
She also describes rumors of miraculous recoveries among parishioners, which have drawn money and divided the congregation. Agatha Preston,12 the unhappy daughter-in-law of organist Zelda,10 calls Goldy1 in a panic and asks whether she has seen someone. The scattered clues point toward church business, but none explains why Tom2 is missing.
The parish is not a single community but a crowded field of competing needs. The pearls promise money for charity or church projects; the healing stories promise hope; Olson's office holds private information. Each becomes a possible motive because people have attached practical or emotional value to it. Goldy, meanwhile, tries to keep the police line open while friends and parishioners turn her into an information source. Her grief is repeatedly interrupted by other people's agendas, which makes her search depend on learning which seemingly ordinary church details deserve attention.
The Church Car Trail
On Sunday, Goldy1 takes Tom's notes to church and tries to question the people who knew Olson.6 Sheriff investigator Boyd7 joins her, asking about the rector's6 conflicts and the missing vehicle keys.
The service exposes a parish split between Lucille Boatwright's9 traditionalists and Olson's6 charismatic followers; after the service, Bob Preston11 publicly turns Tom's2 disappearance into a prayer request. Police then report that a diocese-owned Nissan has been found abandoned near Deer Creek Canyon.
Tom's2 bloodied socks and college ring were hidden inside, evidence that he was restrained but alert enough to leave a trail. The vehicle's connection to church property narrows the search toward insiders. Goldy1 searches Olson's6 damaged office files, hoping to understand the note, but finds no clear answer.
The vehicle clue shifts the investigation from a remote crime scene into the parish's institutional network. Tom has used whatever freedom remained to him to communicate through ordinary belongings, while Goldy must translate his habits into evidence. The church service intensifies the contrast between communal prayer and public exposure: Bob's announcement asks the congregation to care, yet it also makes Goldy's crisis everyone's subject. The competing factions provide investigators with motives, but they also reveal why a tidy suspect list is impossible. Nearly everyone has some grievance against Olson, and nearly everyone can claim to be acting for the church.
Letters and Allegiances
Mitchell Hartley,15 a struggling candidate for the priesthood, tells Goldy1 that he saw Olson6 with a woman and heard that the bishop was investigating an affair. At brunch, Agatha12 admits she was Olson's6 counseling client, loved him, and wrote him private letters while secretly saving money in case she left Bob.11
She fears Bob11 may use the letters against her. Reporter Frances Markasian adds that Bob's11 oil business has failed and that a dispute over a Habitat house has set him against Olson.6
Goldy1 also learns that Canon George Montgomery13 and Olson6 argued over the reported healings. The parish's money, its reputation, and its theology now overlap. Goldy1 has gathered possible motives, but each revelation complicates the next rather than identifying the person who took Tom.2
Agatha's confession makes the supposed affair less a simple scandal than a response to loneliness and dependence. She wants a life beyond Bob's control, yet has entrusted her private plans to a priest whose role requires discretion. The same pattern appears elsewhere: Bob seeks standing through church projects, while the clergy argue over who can define credible faith. Goldy listens without reducing these people to suspects alone, but their disclosures sharpen her understanding that emotional injury and public authority are entangled. What looks like a mystery about stolen goods is increasingly a struggle over who gets to control the church's story.
Files Beneath Brio Barn
Goldy1 takes Arch3 to the neglected conference center, hoping to search for Tom2 before police arrive. A noise leads them into Brio Barn, where Arch3 falls through a rotten stage and lands on Lucille,9 who has been examining stored church files.
Lucille9 explains that she resents Olson's6 changes and had gone looking for the bishop's response to a traditionalist petition against the new music. She suspects Zelda Preston,10 the former organist whom Olson6 dismissed, may have had reason to hurt him.
Goldy1 alerts Boyd,7 but police learn that Zelda10 was interviewing for a position at the Catholic church when Olson6 was killed. The lead collapses. Lucille's9 anger reveals how deeply the parish's old disputes run, while the files she sought remain unexplained.
The fall through the stage turns the church's neglected infrastructure into a literal descent beneath its public surface. Lucille's search is both practical and symbolic: she wants a document that might restore the authority she believes Olson took from the traditionalists. Yet her suspicion of Zelda shows how readily institutional conflict becomes personal accusation. Goldy is tempted to treat every grievance as evidence, but the police check Zelda's whereabouts and rule out the most immediate theory. The episode also places Arch inside the investigation, reflecting how Tom's disappearance has drawn Goldy's chosen family into a danger she cannot fully control.
The Page Under Olson's House
Before dawn on Monday, Goldy1 returns alone to Olson's6 house, hoping the missing pearls may explain the murder. The rooms have been searched again; sacramental vessels are gone, and a crude cross marks the disturbed earth where Olson6 died. In a case holding church silver, Goldy1 finds Agatha's12 letters. Under the house, a box of broken glasses recreates the faint clatter she heard during Tom's2 phone call.
Nearby lies a photocopied page from an ordination exam, numbered 92-492. Before Goldy1 can take it to police, someone strikes her from behind and steals the page. She survives with a badly bruised back, but remembers the number. The evidence ties the crime to both Olson's6 private life and the priesthood exams.
Goldy's return to the crime scene is a breach of police procedure, but it follows a deeper refusal to let passivity become her only role. The house has been searched for valuables and for information, while its destruction makes the distinction difficult to read. The exam page is especially unsettling because it connects a private murder to the formal machinery that decides who may become clergy. Goldy's injury marks the cost of acting on partial knowledge. Still, she retains the one detail her attacker tried to erase, showing that attention, not physical strength, is her most reliable investigative resource.
Hartley's Last Exam
At the doctor's office, Goldy1 learns that Roger Bampton's16 leukemia diagnosis and sudden recovery remain medically unexplained, adding weight to the dispute over Olson's6 reported healings. Back home, she matches exam number 92-492 to Mitchell Hartley15 and reads his written answers, which show little pastoral judgment.
She and Marla5 find the missing keys to the diocese's Nissan and conference buildings on the floor of the Habitat house, apparently implicating Bob.11 That evening Hartley15 sits for an oral examination with Goldy1 and Father Doug Ramsey,14 but offers little clarity about the page or Tom.2 As Marla5 drives Goldy1 home, they find Hartley's15 body on the road. A missing pearl choker lies nearby, making him look like a thief even in death.
The evidence has begun to behave like a series of staged explanations. Keys at Bob's construction site and a pearl beside Hartley's body seem to offer the police neat answers, but both can be planted. Hartley's weak exam makes him an easy target for judgment, yet his failure as a candidate does not prove he is violent. The healing controversy also resists a clean verdict: the doctor cannot explain Bampton's recovery, and the church cannot agree on what it means. Goldy's task is therefore not simply to collect clues, but to distinguish what a clue establishes from what it merely encourages people to believe.
The Messages Beneath Church
After Hartley's15 death, Goldy1 realizes P.R.A.Y. may be Olson's6 voice-mail access code. Agatha12 helps her reach the church office, where stored messages reveal Bob11 threatening Olson6 and Montgomery13 arranging to bring the exam papers to him.
Montgomery13 arrives, demands the blood tests behind the healing claims, and attacks Agatha.12 Goldy1 escapes his grip by breaking a window; he flees and falls into Lucille's9 unfinished columbarium, where he suffers a fatal heart attack.
Doug Ramsey's14 description of early church vigils being held underground gives Goldy1 the idea to search the church renovation tunnel. With Roger Bampton's16 help, she finds the missing vessels, the pearl chokers, and Tom,2 bound in the passage. Montgomery13 had kept him alive because he believed Tom2 knew where the tests were.
The voice-mail system turns Olson's habit of preserving information into the case's decisive archive. Its messages do not provide a single perfect confession; instead, they reveal the pressure surrounding Olson, from Bob's threats to Montgomery's efforts to control the evidence. The culprit's violence grows from a desire to govern what counts as truth, not merely from greed. Goldy's escape depends on improvisation, while the tunnel discovery depends on connecting liturgical history to the building's physical renovation. The final rescue brings together the novel's material clues, but it also leaves the healing itself unresolved. Evidence can expose a murderer without settling a question of faith.
The Wedding Finally Comes
The day after Olson's6 funeral, Goldy1 and Tom2 marry at St. Luke's. Tom2 is weak and has a broken ankle after nearly three days captive, but he refuses a wheelchair. He explains that he pretended to know about the blood tests to keep Montgomery13 from killing him.
At Agatha's12 request, Boyd7 destroys her letters, and she and Bob11 choose counseling rather than an immediate divorce. Goldy1 invites Zelda's10 estranged daughter-in-law, Sarah,17 and grandson, Ian,18 to the ceremony; Zelda10 agrees to play the organ and reunites with them after five years apart.
Julian4 receives his acceptance to Cornell, and Arch3 and Julian4 help restore the reception Goldy1 had prepared. The wedding does not undo the deaths, but it gives the family and parish a day shaped by chosen care rather than crisis.
The resolution answers the opening's interrupted ritual without pretending that marriage can guarantee safety. Goldy and Tom make their commitment after surviving circumstances neither could control, and the vow carries the weight of experience rather than ceremony alone. Other relationships are repaired in smaller, less certain ways: Zelda meets her family again, while Agatha and Bob begin counseling instead of claiming instant resolution. Julian's college acceptance and Arch's presence return ordinary futures to the household. The reception's recovered food turns Goldy's labor from a failed preparation into a shared celebration, making domestic work an expression of renewed connection rather than an attempt to control events.
Analysis
The novel makes a small Episcopal parish function like a town within a town: it has budgets, factions, informal intelligence networks, rituals, and rules about who is entitled to speak. The murder grows out of conflicts that appear minor when isolated, including hymn selection, committee authority, ordination exams, and the handling of money. Together, these disputes become a struggle over institutional legitimacy. Olson's6 pastoral charisma attracts loyalty and donations, but his influence unsettles people who believe the church should remain governed by established practice.
Goldy's1 method offers a counterweight to formal authority. She has no police badge or clerical title, yet catering has trained her to notice timing, access, preparation, and what is out of place. Her attention to Tom's notes, Olson's6 stored messages, and the objects moved through church buildings lets her investigate without pretending that intuition is certainty. The novel also distinguishes care from control. Goldy1 cooks to care for people, while Montgomery's13 attempt to control the meaning of the healings turns fear of disorder into violence. The contrast does not prove the miracle claims true or false. It shows the danger of treating uncertainty as an affront that must be suppressed.
Food and ritual give the plot its emotional scale. Goldy's1 wedding meal is prepared before she knows whether the ceremony can happen; later, the same labor feeds people at church and gives her household a way to remain connected during the search. The ending restores the wedding, but not the world as it stood before the murder. Zelda's10 family remains marked by years of estrangement, Agatha12 and Bob11 need counseling, and the church must live with its divisions. The book's resolution is therefore not a claim that love erases harm. It is a concrete gathering in which people choose to resume care despite grief, uncertainty, and unfinished repair.
Review Summary
Reviews for The Last Suppers are mixed, averaging 3.87/5. Fans appreciate the series' character development, particularly Goldy and Tom's long-awaited wedding storyline, and enjoy the included recipes. Critics frequently cite the heavy religious/church politics content as tedious, Goldy's habit of referring to her fiancé by his full name as annoying, and her emotional reactions as unrealistic. Some readers found the mystery engaging with good plot twists, while others felt disconnected from the Episcopal Church setting and unlikable suspects.
Characters
Goldy Bear
Caterer turned investigatorGoldy is a resourceful caterer in Aspen Meadow, Colorado, and the mother of twelve-year-old Arch3. After leaving an abusive marriage, she has built a business and a cautious independence; marrying homicide investigator Tom Schulz2 means risking trust again. Her psychology is practical and observant. She notices what has been moved, remembers details others overlook, and uses cooking to impose useful order when fear makes ordinary life feel unmanageable. Goldy is not trained to investigate crimes, and her determination sometimes carries her into danger, but it also allows her to read the habits and relationships behind a clue. Her care for Arch3, Tom2, and her friends makes her both emotionally exposed and persistently active.
Tom Schulz
Homicide investigator and fiancéTom is Goldy's1 fiancé and Furman County's leading homicide investigator. His experience has taught him to observe carefully, record what matters, and stay composed under pressure. With Goldy1, he is affectionate and dependable, and he has become a source of security for both her and Arch3. Tom's confidence is not the same as emotional distance: he takes their family seriously and is willing to discuss the difficult questions that marriage brings up. His investigative habits also shape the way Goldy1 approaches uncertainty. He represents the trust she is learning to accept, while his work places that trust in constant contact with danger.
Arch Bear
Goldy's watchful sonArch is Goldy's1 twelve-year-old son, thoughtful, curious, and prone to worrying about whether adults will stay. His earlier experiences of family upheaval and school harassment make Tom's2 place in their household especially important to him. He uses drawing, routines, and practical chores to steady himself when events become frightening. Arch is bright and observant, with a fascination for odd mysteries, though his confidence can outrun his physical caution. He cares deeply for Goldy1 and wants to protect her, even when she must remind him that he is still a child.
Julian Teller
Young cook and household allyJulian is a nineteen-year-old boarder who has become a trusted member of Goldy1 and Arch's3 household. A gifted cook and pastry chef, he is also a serious student and competitive swimmer with ambitions to study food science. Previous instability has made him fiercely loyal to the family he has found, though anxiety can make him irritable and quick to act. Julian shows affection through work: he prepares meals, manages practical chores, and looks after Arch3. His presence gives Goldy1 another capable pair of hands, but his own hopes and vulnerabilities matter beyond his usefulness to her.
Marla Korman
Goldy's irrepressible best friendMarla is Goldy's1 closest friend, her matron of honor, and the other former wife of Goldy's1 first husband. Generous, socially connected, and devoted to fundraising, she often knows the parish gossip before anyone else. Her humor can be sharp, but it is also a way of staying present when Goldy1 is overwhelmed. Marla provides food, companionship, and occasional practical help even though cooking is not her strength. She understands that Goldy's1 independence is real but not limitless, and she repeatedly tries to keep her friend from facing danger or grief alone.
Theodore Olson
Reform-minded parish priestThe Reverend Theodore Olson is the rector of St. Luke's and a central figure in Aspen Meadow's divided Episcopal parish. Charismatic and attentive, he favors contemporary worship and personal pastoral involvement, reaching parishioners whom his predecessor neglected. His wish to reconcile people is sincere, but he also takes on more responsibility and secrecy than the community can comfortably absorb. Olson serves on church committees, counsels Goldy1 and Tom2, and becomes entangled in debates about money and reported healings. His private habits and public influence make him difficult for others to interpret, even when they believe they know his motives.
Horace Boyd
Sheriff's lead investigatorBoyd is a Furman County investigator and colleague of Tom's2. Blunt, tired, and persistent, he has to manage a complicated case while trying to keep Goldy1 safe and informed. He follows procedure and resists her attempts to direct the investigation, but he recognizes that her personal knowledge can be valuable. Boyd's irritation does not erase his compassion; he takes Tom's2 disappearance seriously and understands its effect on Goldy1. His match-chewing and dry manner lend him a grounded presence amid the parish's disputes.
Helen Keene
Victim support advocateHelen works as a victim advocate for the Sheriff's Department and has training in psychology. She offers Goldy1 practical emotional support, including a quilt, and warns her that a grieving person can become a public source of information for others. Her calm manner contrasts with the confusion around the investigation. Helen does not solve the case, but she helps Goldy1 notice her own needs and the strain the crisis places on her family.
Lucille Boatwright
Guardian of parish traditionLucille leads St. Luke's Altar Guild and helps oversee church weddings and the proposed columbarium. Exacting, forceful, and deeply attached to established customs, she tends to express anxiety by taking command. She resents the changes Olson6 brought to worship and believes her years of service deserve recognition. Lucille's concern for the parish is sincere, but her certainty can leave little room for disagreement. Her long friendship with Zelda10 and her involvement in church administration give her access to information and influence.
Zelda Preston
Traditional parish organistZelda is a trained organist, a longtime member of St. Luke's, and the mother of Bob Preston11. She values musical standards and familiar worship, and she clashes with Olson6 over the parish's move toward contemporary songs. Beneath her disciplined manner is grief over the loss of her son Mark and estrangement from her daughter-in-law17 and grandson18. Zelda has built much of her identity around church service and family loyalty. She is guarded about her pain, which makes her relationships difficult to read from the outside.
Bob Preston
Church organizer under strainBob is Zelda's10 son and Agatha's12 husband. Once an oilman, he devotes much of his time to church projects, Habitat for Humanity, and Sportsmen Against Hunger. He likes to lead and values the public respect those activities bring, especially after financial setbacks. His manner can be boastful or impatient, and he has difficulty separating his plans for the parish from his own standing within it. Bob is connected to several church resources and fundraising efforts, placing him near the investigation's competing suspicions.
Agatha Preston
Restless church volunteerAgatha is Bob's11 wife and Zelda's10 daughter-in-law. She performs much of the unglamorous volunteer work expected of her by the parish's older women, yet feels treated as a helper rather than an adult with a life of her own. Her scattered, dreamy manner can obscure how strongly she feels about love, freedom, and spiritual healing. Agatha is drawn to stories that promise certainty and to people who listen without judging her. Her private emotional life complicates the apparently orderly roles she occupies in church and marriage.
George Montgomery
Senior diocesan theologianCanon George Montgomery is an older theologian with authority in the diocese and a history of working closely with Olson6. Formal, self-conscious, and attached to orthodox church practice, he is also prone to turning sermons into verse. Grief and responsibility make him seem less composed than his title suggests. Montgomery worries about the direction of St. Luke's and the meaning of its reported healings. His relationship with Olson6 combines admiration, intellectual disagreement, and the uneasy burden of institutional oversight.
Doug Ramsey
Talkative assistant priestFather Doug Ramsey is Olson's6 young assistant and a fellow member of the theological examination board. He talks at length when nervous, often burying useful information beneath qualifications and worries. His concerns include church doctrine, the reported healings, and his place within the diocese. Doug is not naturally commanding, and the crisis exposes how much he relies on procedure and hierarchy to steady himself. Despite his awkwardness, he can supply details that help Goldy1 connect events.
Mitchell Hartley
Frustrated ordination candidateMitchell Hartley is a charismatic parishioner seeking ordination who works part time at the diocesan center. He has struggled in the examination process and is resentful of the people who assess him. His intense certainty about theology contrasts with weak interpersonal judgment, making him an unsettling presence in conversations. Hartley believes the church's hierarchy has treated him unfairly and interprets disagreement as evidence that others are against him. His connection to the exams and the parish's theological disputes makes him a figure others watch closely.
Roger Bampton
Parishioner at the center of healing claimsRoger is a St. Luke's parishioner whose serious illness and unexpected recovery become central to the congregation's debates about miracles. His experience draws attention from both believers and skeptics, while medical evidence remains difficult for the parish to interpret. Roger is an ordinary member of the community rather than a theological authority, which makes his health a personal matter caught in a public argument.
Sarah Preston Black
Zelda's estranged daughter-in-lawSarah is Mark Preston's widow and the mother of Ian18. Her decision-making during Mark's final illness remains painful for Zelda10, leaving their family divided for years. She has since remarried and built a life outside the Episcopal parish. Sarah is defined less by the town's version of the old dispute than by the difficult choices she faced as a spouse and parent.
Ian Preston
Zelda's distant grandsonIan is the son of Sarah17 and Mark Preston, and Zelda's10 grandson. He grew up apart from his paternal grandmother10 after a painful family rupture. A swimmer like his father, Ian carries the possibility of connection between generations who have lived with grief in different ways.
Plot Devices
Tom's coded notebook
A trail left under pressureTom's2 hurried notes record fragments from the moment Olson6 is shot and Tom2 is taken. The abbreviations, references to prayer and Judas, and vehicle details initially resist interpretation. Because Goldy1 recognizes Tom's2 handwriting and knows his habit of recording observations, she can help police treat the page as intentional evidence rather than meaningless scribble. Its mystery keeps the investigation moving while showing how a trained investigator communicates when he cannot speak openly.
The church voice mail
A hidden archive of motivesOlson's6 messages remain stored after his phone equipment is damaged. Goldy1 eventually understands P.R.A.Y. as the access code and listens to messages left by Agatha12, Bob11, and Montgomery13. The archive reveals private threats and plans that contradict the more public stories circulating through the parish. It turns an ordinary piece of office technology into evidence that cannot be destroyed simply by smashing a handset or answering machine.
The ordination exam page
A paper trail to HartleyA photocopied page from the ordination exams is found beneath Olson's6 house and bears candidate number 92-492. Goldy1 remembers the number after the page is stolen, then matches it to Mitchell Hartley15 using the exam list. The paper links the crime to the church's formal examination process and gives Goldy1 a reason to question Hartley15. Its meaning is more complicated than its first appearance suggests, since the person carrying it is not necessarily the person who left it.
Pearls and sacramental vessels
A convincing false trailThe missing pearl chokers and Olson's6 silver church vessels suggest robbery, while the keys found at the Habitat house appear to point toward Bob Preston11. Their disappearance creates a financial motive and draws suspicion toward several parishioners. The objects ultimately matter because they are hidden together in the tunnel beneath the church, but their planted or misleading appearances make the investigation vulnerable to easy conclusions. Their religious and monetary value also reflects the competing priorities within St. Luke's.
The reported healings
Faith becomes contested evidenceClaims that parishioners have recovered from serious illness draw donations, attract attention, and sharpen divisions between Olson's6 followers and his critics. Roger Bampton's16 leukemia diagnosis and recovery are examined by a local doctor, who cannot offer an ordinary explanation. The stories give Montgomery13 a reason to demand the blood tests and make the church's public reputation part of the murder investigation. The narrative does not settle whether the recovery is miraculous; instead, the uncertain evidence reveals how institutions react when experience outruns their ability to verify it.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.