Plot Summary
Peace in the Vale
Sienna and her legion of demons have found a rare peace in the magical Vale of Tyrnigg, a sanctuary where time stands still and the wounds of the past can begin to heal. The house becomes a home, with each member of the First Legion—Nick, Sam, Bel, Luke, and Ron—finding their place and purpose. Sienna, now the Demons' Muse, is both the heart and the catalyst for change, inspiring her companions to embrace new forms and new ways of living. The gentle rhythm of daily life, from gardening to building, is punctuated by laughter, flirtation, and the slow, sometimes awkward, growth of trust and affection. Yet beneath the surface, old insecurities and the threat of angelic enemies linger, reminding them that peace is always fragile.
Lessons in Aether
Sienna and Ronwe dedicate themselves to mastering the mysteries of aether, the magical force that binds the five planes of existence. Ron, once crippled and powerless, now flourishes as Sienna's student and friend, his mind as sharp as ever. Together, they experiment with skins, protections, and the limits of their abilities, always aware that their discoveries could tip the balance in the coming war. The process is both exhilarating and daunting, as Sienna realizes her power is both a gift and a responsibility. The lessons are not just magical but emotional, as the pair confide in each other about their fears, desires, and the complexities of loving more than one person.
Bonds of Legion
The First Legion is more than a fighting force—it is a chosen family, bound by loyalty and affection. Sienna navigates the tangled web of relationships, learning that love among demons is not limited by gender or number. The legion's motto—"Legion shares all"—is both liberating and terrifying for Sienna, who must unlearn the shame and guilt instilled by her human upbringing. Through candid conversations and gentle teasing, the group explores the boundaries of affection, trust, and jealousy. Each member, from the stoic Nick to the playful Sam, brings their own baggage and hopes, and together they begin to redefine what it means to belong.
Dinner and Confessions
Shared meals become a ritual of connection, where the legion can drop their defenses and speak openly. Over dinner, secrets are revealed: Nick's struggle with his sexuality, Sienna's fear of not being enough, Ron's insecurities about his body, and Bel's longing for acceptance. The conversation is raw and sometimes painful, but it is also healing. Sienna learns that her demons are not the heartless monsters she once believed, but complex, wounded souls who crave love and understanding as much as she does. The act of eating together becomes a metaphor for the nourishment they find in each other's company.
Facing Fears Together
Night brings anxiety and restless dreams, but also moments of clarity. Sienna wakes to find her lovers gone, and instead of jealousy, she feels trust—a sign of her growing confidence in their bond. The morning is spent in honest conversation, as Sienna, Nick, and Sam finally address the unspoken rules and fears that have held them back. They agree to try a new way of loving, one that allows for openness, vulnerability, and the possibility of loving more than one person. The decision is both terrifying and exhilarating, marking a turning point in their journey as a legion.
Permission and Love
With new rules in place, Sienna gives Nick and Sam permission to explore their feelings for each other, and in doing so, frees herself from the chains of jealousy and shame. The trio's intimacy deepens, culminating in a night of passion that is as much about trust as it is about desire. For the first time, Sienna feels truly seen and accepted, not just as a lover but as an equal partner in the legion. The experience is transformative, teaching her that love is not a finite resource, but something that grows the more it is shared.
Flying Lessons Begin
The next challenge is physical: learning to fly in their true forms. Sienna and Ronwe, both new to their wings, struggle with the mechanics and the fear of failure. The lessons are grueling, filled with crashes, laughter, and the unwavering support of their legion. Bel, ever the protector, is there to catch Sienna when she falls, while Luke and Nick guide Ron with patience and pride. The act of flying becomes a metaphor for the risks of love and the courage it takes to trust others to catch you. Each small victory is celebrated, and each failure is met with encouragement, reinforcing the bonds that hold them together.
Emotional Breakthroughs
As Sienna and Ronwe push past their physical limits, they also confront the emotional barriers that have kept them from fully embracing the legion's way of loving. Sienna learns to accept her own desires, to stop apologizing for wanting more, and to trust that her demons will not abandon her. Ronwe, long used to being overlooked, finds the courage to ask for what he wants and to believe that he is worthy of love. The breakthroughs are hard-won, but they mark the beginning of a new chapter, one where vulnerability is met with compassion, and love is no longer something to be feared.
Angelic Threats
The fragile peace is shattered when angels attack, drawn by the legion's growing power and the threat Sienna represents. The battle is fierce, with each member of the legion fighting not just for survival, but for each other. Sienna's power is both a weapon and a beacon, drawing the attention of Michael and the other archangels. The fight is a test of everything they have learned—about aether, about trust, and about the strength of their bonds. In the aftermath, wounds are tended, and the legion is reminded that their greatest strength lies in their unity.
Veil of Protection
With the threat of the angels ever-present, the legion turns their attention to the creation of a new veil—a magical barrier that will protect Vesdar and the midworlds from angelic incursion. Sienna's unique abilities are key, but the process requires the cooperation of the Unaffiliated Angels of Vesdar, a group with their own fears and agendas. Negotiations are tense, and trust is hard-won, but the shared goal of survival brings unlikely allies together. The act of building the veil is both a technical and emotional challenge, forcing Sienna to confront her own limits and the responsibilities of her power.
The Dragon's Gift
In the midst of battle, the legion is aided by a dragon—a being of immense power and ancient wisdom. The dragon recognizes Sienna as a kindred spirit, a Muse of Muses, and offers her a gift: access to the limitless aether of dragonkind. The experience is overwhelming, nearly breaking Sienna, but it also transforms her, giving her the strength to finish the veil and repel the angelic threat. The dragon's gift is both a blessing and a burden, a reminder that power always comes with a price.
The Price of Trust
With the veil in place, the angels of Vesdar must decide whether to trust Sienna and her legion, or to cling to old fears. Phanuel, their leader, is forced to confront the reality that the world has changed, and that survival depends on cooperation. Sienna, in turn, must decide how much to give, and how much to demand in return. The negotiations are fraught, but ultimately lead to a new understanding—a fragile alliance built on mutual respect and the recognition that they are all, in the end, fighting for the same thing: freedom.
Sins and Desires
As the immediate threat recedes, the legion is left to grapple with the consequences of their choices. Old wounds are reopened, and new desires come to the surface. Sienna must face the truth of her parentage, her place in the multiverse, and the legacy she is creating. The legion, too, must reckon with their own sins—the betrayals, the losses, and the ways they have hurt each other. Through honest conversation and shared vulnerability, they begin to forgive themselves and each other, making space for healing and hope.
The Power of Choice
With the veil secure and the angels held at bay, the legion turns inward, focusing on the bonds that hold them together. Sienna, now fully embraced as the Demons' Muse, learns that love is not about possession or sacrifice, but about choice. Each member of the legion chooses to stay, to fight, and to love—not because they must, but because they want to. The power of choice becomes their greatest weapon, allowing them to create a family that is stronger than any blood tie or magical bond.
Legion's Heart
The battle won, the legion returns to the Vale to rest and recover. The house is finished, the rooms are filled with laughter and love, and for the first time, Sienna feels truly at home. The group celebrates their victories, mourns their losses, and looks to the future with hope. Each member finds their place, their purpose, and their peace, knowing that whatever comes next, they will face it together. The heart of the legion beats strong, and Sienna knows that she is exactly where she is meant to be.
The Muse's Legacy
Sienna's journey comes full circle as she learns the truth of her origins and the meaning of her power. She is the product of all five planes, a being of impossible potential, and her legacy is one of change. The lessons she has learned—about love, trust, and the courage to be herself—become the foundation for a new way of living. The legion, too, is transformed, no longer defined by their past sins but by the choices they make each day. Together, they begin to imagine a future where peace is possible, and where the sins of desire are not something to be ashamed of, but something to be celebrated.
The Third Side
The war between angels and demons is no longer a simple binary. With the creation of the veil and the alliance with the angels of Vesdar, a third side emerges—one that values freedom, choice, and the right to live without fear. Sienna and her legion become the heart of this new movement, inspiring others to question the old ways and to imagine something better. The world is still dangerous, and the future uncertain, but for the first time, there is hope that the cycle of violence can be broken.
Becoming Whole
In the quiet after the storm, Sienna and her legion find a new kind of wholeness. The wounds of the past are not forgotten, but they are no longer the only story. Each member of the legion is changed—stronger, wiser, and more open to love. Sienna, once a lost and lonely girl, is now the center of a family that spans worlds. Together, they face the unknown, not with fear, but with the certainty that whatever comes, they will face it as one. The sins of desire have become their greatest strength, and the promise of forever is no longer a dream, but a choice they make every day.
Characters
Sienna (The Demons' Muse)
Sienna is a young woman thrust into a world of magic, demons, and angels, discovering she is the rarest of Muses—one whose power inspires not humanity, but demons themselves. Her journey is one of self-acceptance, as she learns to embrace her desires, her power, and her right to love more than one person. Sienna's relationships with her legion are complex, marked by vulnerability, courage, and a fierce determination to protect those she loves. Her greatest struggle is overcoming the shame and fear instilled by her human upbringing, but through honesty and trust, she becomes the emotional and magical center of the group. Her legacy is one of change, hope, and the belief that love is not a sin, but a strength.
Nick (Satanael/Satan)
Nick is the legendary Satanael, the Grim Reaper, and the de facto leader of the First Legion. His power is matched only by his capacity for love and guilt. Haunted by the loss of his wife and the weight of his past, Nick struggles to reconcile his demonic nature with his desire for connection and peace. His relationship with Sienna is both passionate and tender, marked by mutual respect and a willingness to confront hard truths. Nick's journey is one of learning to let go of control, to trust his legion, and to accept that he is worthy of love—not just as a leader, but as a man.
Sam (Samyaza)
Sam is the heart of the legion, the one who keeps the peace and ensures that everyone feels seen and valued. His easy charm and sensuality mask a deep well of wisdom and empathy. Sam is comfortable with his desires and unashamed of his love for both men and women, making him a model for the kind of open, honest relationships the legion aspires to. He is Sienna's confidant and partner in crime, always ready with a joke or a gentle nudge in the right direction. Sam's greatest gift is his ability to make others feel safe, loved, and accepted, no matter their fears or flaws.
Beelzebub (Bel)
Bel is the physical powerhouse of the legion, but beneath his intimidating exterior lies a sensitive, loyal soul who craves acceptance and love. His journey is one of learning to express his feelings, to trust that he can be both strong and gentle, and to believe that he is worthy of being loved for who he is. Bel's relationship with Sienna is marked by tenderness, patience, and a deep desire to care for her. He is also a bridge between the old ways of demonkind and the new, more open-hearted legion that Sienna inspires.
Lucifer (Luke)
Luke is the fallen angel, the outsider who becomes an integral part of the legion. His intelligence and cunning are matched by a deep sense of guilt and a fear of causing harm to those he loves. Luke's journey is one of learning to let go of the past, to accept that he can be both powerful and vulnerable, and to trust that he is not alone. His relationships with Ronwe and Sienna are complex, marked by mutual respect, longing, and the slow, painful process of healing old wounds. Luke is both the devil and the angel, and his greatest struggle is learning to be at peace with both sides of himself.
Ronwe
Ronwe is the demon of knowledge, once crippled and overlooked, now a vital member of the legion. His brilliance is matched by his humility and his deep capacity for love. Ron's journey is one of learning to believe in his own worth, to ask for what he wants, and to accept that he is not a burden, but a gift to those around him. His relationships with Luke and Sienna are marked by gentleness, honesty, and a shared understanding of what it means to be different. Ron is the quiet heart of the legion, the one who reminds them all that strength comes in many forms.
Phanuel
Phanuel is a pragmatic and wary leader, responsible for the safety of his people in a world that no longer fits the old angelic order. He is slow to trust, shaped by centuries of war and betrayal, but ultimately chooses cooperation over conflict. Phanuel's arc is one of learning to let go of old prejudices, to see the value in new alliances, and to accept that survival sometimes means embracing change. His relationship with Sienna and the legion is uneasy but hopeful, a symbol of the possibility for peace between former enemies.
Uriel
Uriel is a complex figure, torn between his loyalty to the angelic order and his love for his family. His decision to hide Sienna on Earth sets the entire story in motion, and his later willingness to help her marks a turning point in the war. Uriel's journey is one of redemption, as he learns to put love above duty and to accept the consequences of his choices. His relationship with Sienna is fraught but ultimately healing, a testament to the power of forgiveness and the possibility of change.
Kacira
Kacira is a former angelic slave who finds love and freedom with Uriel. Her decision to give up Sienna is an act of both desperation and hope, and her later reunion with her daughter is bittersweet. Kacira's arc is one of survival, resilience, and the quiet courage to hope for something better. She is a grounding presence for Sienna, a reminder that love is sometimes about letting go, and that family is defined by more than blood.
Michael
Michael is the primary antagonist, a being of immense power and ambition who will stop at nothing to maintain the old order. His obsession with control, his willingness to sacrifice anything for victory, and his inability to see the value in change make him both a formidable enemy and a tragic figure. Michael's actions force the legion to confront their own fears and to fight for a new way of living. He is the shadow against which Sienna and her family define themselves, a reminder that true power lies not in domination, but in the courage to choose love over fear.
Plot Devices
The Five Planes and Skins
The story is built on the existence of five interconnected planes—Earth, Daemin, Vesdar, Tyrnigg, and Angelis—each with its own rules, dangers, and forms of life. Characters must adapt to each world by creating new "skins," magical bodies that allow them to survive and blend in. This device is both literal and metaphorical, representing the ways in which we change ourselves to fit new circumstances, and the struggle to remain true to our core selves. The process of skin-making is also a source of power and vulnerability, as the right protections can mean the difference between life and death.
Aether and Magic Systems
Aether is the magical force that powers everything in the multiverse, from the creation of skins to the forging of veils and the healing of wounds. The ability to manipulate aether is both a gift and a curse, requiring knowledge, discipline, and emotional honesty. The story uses aether as a metaphor for the energy we invest in relationships, the risks of giving too much, and the dangers of holding back. The evolution of Sienna's power—from accidental drain to conscious creation—mirrors her journey toward self-acceptance and agency.
The Veil and Exclusion Runes
The creation of magical veils to protect worlds from angelic incursion is a central plot device, requiring cooperation, sacrifice, and trust. The process is fraught with technical and emotional challenges, as the characters must decide who to let in, who to keep out, and what price they are willing to pay for safety. The use of exclusion runes and the negotiation of control over the veils serve as metaphors for the boundaries we set in relationships, the difficulty of trust, and the ways in which fear can both protect and imprison us.
Legion as Found Family
The concept of the legion—a group bound by choice, not blood—is the emotional heart of the story. The legion's motto, "Legion shares all," is both a challenge and a comfort, forcing characters to confront their fears of jealousy, inadequacy, and abandonment. The polyamorous relationships that develop are not without conflict, but they are ultimately a source of healing and strength. The legion becomes a model for a new kind of family, one built on honesty, vulnerability, and the courage to love without limits.
Foreshadowing and Emotional Cycles
The story uses cycles of conflict and reconciliation, fear and trust, to foreshadow the characters' growth. Each time Sienna or another character faces a familiar fear—of abandonment, of not being enough, of losing control—they are given the chance to respond differently, to break the cycle and choose a new path. This repetition is both realistic and hopeful, showing that change is possible, but never easy. The emotional arc is as important as the external plot, with each breakthrough paving the way for the next challenge.
Analysis
Auryn Hadley's The Sins of Desire is a bold, emotionally intelligent reimagining of the paranormal romance genre, blending high fantasy, polyamorous romance, and deep psychological insight. At its core, the novel is about the power of choice—who we love, how we define family, and what we are willing to fight for. By centering the story on Sienna, a Muse whose power is rooted in desire and emotional honesty, Hadley challenges traditional notions of love, gender, and morality. The legion's journey from fractured survivors to a chosen family is both a metaphor for healing from trauma and a blueprint for building healthier, more inclusive relationships. The book's use of magical systems and world-hopping is not just for spectacle, but serves as a rich metaphor for the ways we adapt, change, and grow. In a modern context, The Sins of Desire is a celebration of found family, the courage to be vulnerable, and the radical idea that love—messy, complicated, and shared—is not a sin, but our greatest strength.
Last updated:
