Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
The Soulmate Theory

The Soulmate Theory

Reunited childhood friends share a school and an unfinished kiss, but can old trust survive?
by Sarah A. Bailey 2023 384 pages
4.02
1k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

Five years before the main story, Carter watches childhood friend Penelope prepare to leave for Oxford while he plans to move to Hawaii. His best friend, Dom, urges him to admit he has loved her for years. Carter follows Penelope into his family’s pantry, intending to confess, but their first kiss overwhelms the words he meant to say.

When someone calls for her, Penelope breaks away, convinced they cannot continue with her departure hours away. Carter stays behind, unable to tell her that the kiss confirmed what he had long suspected: she feels the same.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The kiss gives the romance its governing wound: mutual feeling arrives at the exact moment their lives divide. Carter’s silence and Penelope’s flight are not evidence of indifference, but the consequences of fear and timing. The pantry becomes a compressed version of their later pattern, intimacy followed by interruption, then years of imagining what might have happened. Because the two have grown up as neighbors and family friends, leaving also means risking a bond that has never been easy to name. Their separation begins not with rejection, but with an unfinished confession.

The Art Room Collision

A forced teaching assignment brings Carter home

At twenty-three, Penelope is back in Brighton Bay after leaving Oxford and returning to live with her adoptive parents. She works as a history teacher’s aide and is trying to rebuild an academic future, but her supervisor assigns her to cover art classes because the school cannot find a substitute.

The arrangement is already unwelcome when the photography substitute walks in: Carter, her childhood neighbor, whom she has not seen in five years. As he helps her clean red paint from a white shoe, its resemblance to blood triggers her fear of blood and exposes how little either of them knows about the other’s adult life. They are now colleagues, sharing a cramped studio and office, with no practical way to avoid each other.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The reunion makes proximity an institutional fact before either character can choose what it means. Penelope’s resistance to teaching art reflects more than modesty: she has withdrawn from a once-private part of herself and treats talent as irrelevant unless it serves a credential. Carter’s return unsettles that carefully narrowed identity. The red paint links present-day embarrassment to an older trauma that remains active in her body, while his immediate, practical help recalls their childhood pattern of care. Yet the scene does not let care solve anything. It establishes the central tension: Carter remembers a person Penelope no longer believes she can be.

Five Years at Dinner

Carter asks why Penelope has shut him out

Their parents and siblings reveal over dinner that they deliberately concealed both the job arrangement and each other’s return, hoping the reunion would be amusing. The discovery leaves Penelope feeling managed by the family, while Carter realizes they have not met since graduation. Afterward, he confronts her about the coldness she has shown him at work and at home.

Penelope apologizes and admits the old kiss still feels unfinished. Carter explains that he meant to confess his love before she left, then kissed her when he could not say it aloud. She learns that his feelings were real, not a momentary impulse. They agree to treat each other with care rather than erase the past by avoiding it.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The family’s matchmaking-by-surprise is affectionate, but it repeats a pattern that troubles Penelope: other people making decisions about her life before asking what she wants. Carter’s direct confrontation interrupts that pattern by giving her a chance to respond honestly. Their conversation also revises the meaning of the pantry kiss. What she had treated as an isolated, bewildering moment becomes a shared history of unspoken love. Still, knowledge does not instantly create intimacy. They choose friendship because it is the manageable option, showing how emotional truth can arrive before either person has the confidence to act on it.

The Second Dance

A school rejection shadows their first new closeness

Carter’s first weeks teaching photography bring him into Penelope’s classroom, where he sees that her artistic ability remains strong even as she denies it. At the school’s Spring Fling, she tells him she is afraid to open an admissions decision from Stanford, having already received rejections elsewhere. Carter recalls their eighth-grade dance, when he left his own date to ask Penelope to dance and she ran away.

This time, after he assures her the invitation is not pity, she accepts. Their shared dance loosens the stiffness between them, and he keeps her attention on the music rather than the unopened letter. At home, she reads the rejection alone. Carter responds with coffee and quiet support as further decisions arrive.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The dance gives the pair a small, concrete chance to revise an old mistake. Penelope stays instead of fleeing, while Carter makes clear that his choice is desire, not rescue. Yet the scene’s warmth sits beside her fear of academic failure, showing how tightly she has tied self-worth to achievement. Her choice to open the Stanford letter alone preserves control, but also isolates her from comfort she might accept. Carter’s coffees do not erase the rejections; their value lies in offering companionship without demanding that she perform optimism. The story makes emotional progress through repeated, modest acts rather than a single transformative declaration.

The Ride Home

Carter removes Penelope from Marshall’s reach

At trivia night, Penelope accepts Marshall’s bet and drinks far beyond her limits, unaware how eagerly he has encouraged her. When Carter sees Marshall trying to take her home, he steps between them and brings her instead to the converted pool house behind his parents’ home. Penelope has lost her coat, keys, and phone, so she cannot get into her own house.

While drunk, she tells Carter that she used to imagine him when she kissed James, then falls asleep. In the morning, Carter drives her to the beach before work. He warns her that Marshall’s behavior felt predatory, and she trusts his judgment. Penelope gets onto a paddleboard with Carter and watches the sunrise, sharing a rare, unguarded morning with him.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The night’s danger arises from an ordinary social bargain that Penelope cannot assess clearly once intoxicated. Carter’s intervention matters because he reads Marshall’s insistence as a threat and acts before Penelope can be left alone with him. The rescue is not framed as proof that she is helpless; the next morning she makes a choice to trust Carter and join him on the water. Her drunken remark about James also reveals that Carter has remained her private measure of intimacy, though she cannot yet discuss it sober. The sunrise provides a counterweight to the night’s vulnerability: safety becomes something she can experience, not merely be promised.

A Theory on the Roof

An annotated novel leads to a California invitation

As Penelope and Carter grow more comfortable, she tells Macie about their childhood and the kiss that sent her to England without explanation. Carter later joins their Thursday trivia group, where Marshall’s attraction to Penelope remains obvious and unsettling.

On Penelope’s roof, Carter lends her his heavily annotated copy of The Alchemist after learning she rarely reads. She explains a theory she found written on a pub bathroom door: separated atoms might find one another again as human soulmates.

Carter takes her idea seriously, even as they tease each other about the rarity of romantic destiny. When Penelope receives an invitation to a Pepperdine academic conference, Macie proposes a spring-break trip. Carter offers his mother’s flight discount, giving Penelope a reason to accept his company.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The book and the soulmate theory let the characters discuss intimacy indirectly, through ideas they can examine without immediately exposing their own stakes. Penelope’s skepticism is not simple cynicism; she believes connection is possible while fearing that a rare, ideal love may not be meant for her. Carter responds with curiosity rather than trying to defeat her theory, making intellectual attention part of their courtship. The planned trip joins the professional future she is trying to recover with the personal history she has kept sealed away. It also places their growing closeness in a new setting, where neither can rely on familiar routines to manage it.

The Story She Carries

Penelope tells Carter how she lost her mother

In Malibu, Macie discovers that the rental villa has only one bedroom, forcing the four friends to share close quarters. While Penelope rests outside, Carter brings her a blanket and asks about the mother she rarely mentions. Penelope describes the night her birth mother overdosed in their apartment.

At seven, she found her mother collapsed in the bathroom, saw the blood, and ran to a neighbor for help. Her adoptive father, Dan, was the doctor who later told her that her mother had died, then took her home with his wife, Jenna. Penelope still fears that her adoptive family’s love must be earned. Carter listens and holds her without turning her grief into a problem he can fix.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Penelope’s account connects her fear of blood, her guardedness, and her belief that love can be withdrawn to one childhood catastrophe. Her memory is fragmented, and she questions whether some gentler recollections are real, underscoring how trauma can leave a person unsure of their own history. Carter’s restraint is crucial. Rather than supplying comfort that would shut the story down, he stays present and allows her to set its pace. The revelation also complicates her gratitude toward her adoptive parents: she loves them, but interprets being chosen as a debt. The scene shows how care can coexist with grief, guilt, and uncertainty.

Malibu Won’t Let Go

Carter refuses a kiss while Penelope is drunk

The next night, Macie leads the group to a Los Angeles club, where Penelope drinks and dances while Carter watches from above. When a stranger approaches her, Carter steps in, then joins her on the dance floor after she makes clear she wants him there. Penelope asks him to kiss her, but Carter refuses because she is intoxicated and he wants her choice to be clear.

He takes her back to the villa, where she asks him to share the pull-out bed; they fall asleep holding each other without having sex. The next morning, Penelope leaves for her Pepperdine conference while Carter visits his friend Dom. Their growing attachment has become impossible to mistake, but Penelope still fears what it will cost to trust it.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Carter’s refusal interrupts the romance at its most physically charged point, but it is not a rejection of Penelope. He distinguishes desire from consent and refuses to let a vulnerable moment stand in for a sober decision. Penelope experiences the distinction as painful because she is accustomed to reading hesitation as proof she is unwanted. Their shared bed, with no further escalation, becomes evidence that closeness can exist without being taken as permission. The chapter also places Penelope’s academic ambitions beside romantic possibility. She can attend the conference and pursue a future while remaining emotionally connected to Carter, though she has not yet learned to trust that both can coexist.

The Kiss Interrupted

A kitchen embrace makes the flight home unbearable

After her conference, Penelope meets Carter at the beach, where they discuss marriage, careers, and whether soulmates can find one another across lifetimes. Back at the villa, their teasing turns into a kiss in the kitchen, but Macie and Jeremy return before it can go further. Carter then pulls away, and Penelope reads his restraint as another rejection.

On the flight home, he explains that he wants their intimacy to mean something to both of them, not to happen because alcohol or a charged moment has swept her along. He tells her he has loved her since childhood. Penelope admits she fears loving him because his retreat feels like falling. They share their first sober kiss and agree to keep the new relationship private for now.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The sequence makes misinterpretation the immediate obstacle between them. Carter’s restraint is an attempt to protect the meaning of their intimacy, but without explanation Penelope experiences it through her old fear of being unwanted. The flight removes her usual escape route and forces them to put their assumptions into words. Carter’s confession does not simply reassure her; it answers the question left open by the original kiss five years earlier. Their first sober kiss marks a change in the kind of relationship they can build, from a remembered possibility to a mutual choice. Keeping it private gives them room to develop before family expectations take hold.

Opal Creek Date

Carter turns Penelope into his first portrait

Back in Oregon, Carter takes Penelope to Opal Creek for what he admits is their first date. He photographs the waterfall and the green pool, then asks her to enter the freezing water so he can photograph her in the landscape. He joins her in the creek, guiding her into position and capturing the moment she looks up at him.

The outing restores a shared language of art: Carter sees her as more compelling than the scenery, while Penelope watches him work with renewed admiration. On the drive home, she returns The Alchemist, having finished it, and Carter gives her the rest of the adventure series he chose for her. Their connection deepens into a physical relationship, and they begin spending nights together in his pool house.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The creek scene converts looking into an act of mutual recognition. Carter has made a career of framing landscapes, but Penelope changes what he considers worth photographing; she, in turn, begins to see her own presence as worthy of attention. The cold water is not merely a romantic test. She accepts it because she understands the vulnerability of making art and wants to meet him there. The books extend that exchange into another medium: Carter shares a source of meaning, and Penelope chooses to enter it on her own. Their intimacy grows from participation and curiosity, rather than from the fantasy that love will automatically repair her life.

A Line at Work

Marshall’s harassment brings Carter’s anger into public

At school, Marshall continues making sexualized remarks about Penelope and treats her discomfort as a joke. Carter finally confronts him in the teachers’ lounge after Marshall insults Penelope and implies he should take Carter’s place. When Marshall threatens to involve his lawyer on the school board, Carter reveals that the lawyer is his father and warns him that the school will hear about his conduct.

Penelope later tells Carter she did not need him to defend her; what frightens her is the possibility of facing Marshall alone if she returns to school next year. She also worries that graduate study will leave no room for their relationship. Carter promises to support her education without asking her to shrink her ambitions for him.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The workplace confrontation turns Carter’s protective instinct into a question of agency. His intervention may stop Marshall in the moment, but Penelope is right that his presence cannot guarantee her future safety. The scene makes a distinction between defending someone and helping them believe they can act without you. Their argument moves beyond Marshall to the larger fear that love will compete with Penelope’s education. Carter’s promise is meaningful because it refuses the false choice between ambition and intimacy. The story treats support not as possession, but as a willingness to remain present while another person pursues a life that is her own.

UCLA Opens a Door

An acceptance revives Penelope’s academic future

Carter checks Penelope’s email and finds the decision she has been too anxious to open herself: UCLA has accepted her to its graduate archaeology program. The news releases months of fear, and Penelope tells her parents before sharing it with Macie.

Over coffee, Macie explains that she has ended her relationship with Jeremy, tired of being criticized for the very qualities that make her feel alive. Penelope then tells Macie the full story of James, the Oxford professor who became her mentor and sexual partner.

He had threatened her academic prospects, then blamed her when the relationship was exposed. Penelope still thinks of herself as the guilty party. Macie urges her to seek therapy and recognize how power and manipulation shaped what happened.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The UCLA acceptance restores a future, but it does not by itself restore Penelope’s sense of self. Her achievement arrives alongside the first full telling of the Oxford experience, separating academic failure from the shame she has carried as if they were the same thing. Macie’s breakup offers a parallel lesson: a relationship can diminish someone by making their personality feel like a defect. She refuses that diminishment, then helps Penelope question the story she has told herself about James. The scene reframes recovery as more than getting back into school. Penelope must also understand what happened before she can stop treating herself as its sole cause.

The Secret at Dinner

Easton exposes Penelope’s affair before Carter

At a family dinner celebrating Penelope’s acceptance and the coming move to California, Easton jokes that she once slept with her college professor. Carter hears the remark and realizes Penelope had described their Oxford relationship to him as a different kind of academic misconduct.

He asks whether James was married; Penelope’s expression answers yes. Carter leaves for his pool house, stunned that she withheld so much after they had built their relationship on trust.

Penelope follows and tries to explain that she was ashamed and had not understood her experience clearly enough to tell it. Carter, still overwhelmed by the lie, says he cannot continue the conversation and needs time. His withdrawal confirms Penelope’s fear that the truth makes her unlovable.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The disclosure is damaging not simply because of the affair, but because it occurs in public, at a family table, without Penelope choosing the moment or audience. Carter’s hurt is understandable, yet his response lands on the precise wound she has been trying to name: the fear that honesty will cost her love. Their conflict is therefore asymmetrical. He experiences a breach of trust; she experiences exposure of a past she still cannot interpret without self-condemnation. The novel does not erase either injury. Instead, it shows how unresolved shame can make concealment feel like self-protection, even when concealment damages the very relationship that might offer safety.

The Drive South

Penelope leaves as Carter learns what happened

After the argument, Penelope panics at home and tells her parents the complete story of James’s manipulation, including how he used his influence over her academic future. Her family comforts her, but she insists on leaving for Los Angeles that night with Easton and Maddie rather than wait for Carter to decide whether he can forgive her.

The next morning, Carter arrives to find her gone. Dan explains that Penelope has spent years believing she must earn love, then reveals that the family once removed her birth mother’s belongings from her life instead of helping her face the loss.

Carter finally understands that Penelope’s account of Oxford was distorted by shame and coercion. He packs his belongings, takes the box of her mother’s books from Dan, and drives south.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Penelope’s departure is both an act of agency and another repetition of flight. She chooses the timing and destination, but fear makes leaving feel safer than waiting to hear Carter’s response. Her family’s account of the Oxford abuse and the childhood losses surrounding her adoption gives context to the pattern without excusing the lie. Carter’s insight comes only after he has left her alone with the consequences of his anger. His decision to travel after her shifts love from a promise into an action. The box of her mother’s books matters because it carries a past the family had tried to set aside, now offered back to Penelope on her own terms.

Carter brings her mother’s books and his portrait

Carter reaches Penelope’s Los Angeles apartment after driving south from Oregon. He apologizes for treating her disclosure as a betrayal before understanding the coercion behind it, and Penelope apologizes for hiding the truth.

He takes her to the Venice property his father bought, where he plans to build a gallery devoted to art and nature. Inside, he shows her a large digital portrait based on the photograph he took of her at Opal Creek.

Penelope then brings out the painting she made of Carter’s eye, with the waterfall from one of his first published photographs reflected inside it. Each has made art from the other’s way of seeing. They reconcile, agree to face future conflicts without running, and begin planning their shared life in California.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The reunion resolves the central conflict through reciprocal acts rather than a simple declaration. Carter brings Penelope’s mother’s books, acknowledging that her history belongs in the life she is building; Penelope offers him a painting that translates his photographic vision into her own medium. Neither image turns the beloved into an ideal. Each records attention, time, and interpretation. The gallery gives their creative exchange a public home, while their apology acknowledges that love cannot function as an automatic guarantee against harm. Their renewed commitment depends on a practical promise: truth may be difficult, but neither will use distance as the first response to fear.

A Promise at Sunrise

Five years later, Carter asks for forever

Five years later, Penelope is an archaeologist with a PhD and a position at National Geographic; Carter works as a photographer and runs the Venice gallery with support from friends. During a visit to Hawaii, he takes her to a sunrise viewpoint and proposes with an emerald ring chosen to match her eyes.

Their families are waiting nearby, turning a private promise into a shared celebration. The proposal echoes the question Carter once asked Penelope’s father when they were children, though the answer now comes from Penelope herself. A little over a year later, they marry in a small ceremony on the beach in their Oregon hometown. Their vows promise to find one another in every lifetime.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ending returns the story to the images that have carried it: sunrise as a new beginning, the ocean as connection across distance, and the emerald color of Penelope’s eyes as a sign of being fully seen. Her career has not been traded for romance, and Carter’s creative life has not been reduced to following her; they have built work and home alongside one another. The proposal also transforms an old childhood wish into an adult choice. Their vow reaches beyond the certainty a person can prove, but its emotional force rests on what they have learned in this life: commitment requires both devotion and the repeated decision to return.

Epilogue

Five years after their reunion, Carter proposes to Penelope at sunrise in Hawaii, giving her an emerald ring that recalls the color of her eyes. Their families gather nearby to celebrate.

A little over a year later, Penelope and Carter marry in an intimate ceremony on the beach in their Oregon hometown. They do not frame their commitment as ending with death. Instead, they promise to seek and love one another in every lifetime.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The epilogue tests the couple’s soulmate theories against the ordinary labor of a shared life. Penelope has completed her doctorate, Carter has built a gallery, and both have pursued demanding creative work without surrendering the relationship to it. The sunrise proposal gives their private symbolism a public form, while the hometown wedding reconnects their adult commitment to the childhood world they once left. Their promise beyond death is not proof that fate controls them. It is a chosen expression of hope, made credible by the more difficult promise they have already practiced: to stay present, tell the truth, and return after conflict.

Analysis

The romance is built around a repeated confusion between protection and trust. Carter’s first instinct is to shield Penelope, while Penelope’s first instinct is to disappear before anyone can reject her. Their childhood bond makes these habits feel natural, but it also lets them mistake familiarity for understanding. They must learn to speak plainly: Carter has to explain when restraint is care rather than refusal, and Penelope has to risk telling the truth before shame decides the story for her.

Penelope’s academic ambition functions as both a source of identity and a defense against grief. After losing her birth mother and entering a new family, she tries to become indispensable through achievement. The Oxford scandal devastates her partly because it threatens the career she has built her selfhood around, but also because James’s manipulation reinforces her conviction that she is responsible for being used. Her recovery begins when she can separate a mistake from an entire identity and recognize that power shaped the choices she made.

The novel’s recurring images of oceans, tides, sunrise, and paired stars turn emotional ideas into physical settings. The ocean connects Carter to Hawaii and Oregon, while the sunrise repeatedly gives Penelope a way to experience hope without denying past darkness. Art works similarly: photography and painting make attention concrete, showing that being seen is not the same as being possessed. The lovers’ soulmate theories evolve from a search for cosmic certainty into an ethic of chosen care. Fate may explain their reunion, but it cannot do the work of honesty, consent, or forgiveness for them.

The resolution therefore does not ask Penelope to choose between love and education. Carter’s support matters because it leaves her future intact, and her own therapy and artistic return remain acts she undertakes for herself. Their lasting bond is not presented as a cure for trauma or a substitute for self-knowledge. It is a relationship in which two people practice staying present while the other becomes more fully themselves.

Summary in 60 Seconds
After five years apart, childhood friends Penelope and Carter reunite as coworkers at a school in Brighton Bay. Their first kiss before Penelope left for Oxford had gone unexplained, but Carter admits he meant to confess his love. As they grow close, Penelope shares the grief of finding her birth mother after an overdose and the shame surrounding a coercive relationship with a married Oxford professor. Carter and Penelope begin dating, and she is accepted into UCLA’s archaeology program. When Carter learns she concealed the professor’s marriage, he withdraws before understanding how shame and the professor’s influence shaped her account. Penelope drives to Los Angeles, and her adoptive father helps Carter understand her fears. Carter follows with her mother’s books, apologizes, and the two reconcile. Penelope earns her PhD and becomes an archaeologist; Carter builds a photography career and gallery. They get engaged in Hawaii and marry on an Oregon beach.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.02 out of 5
Average of 1k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.
Your rating:
4.66
25 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Penelope Mason

The guarded archaeologist

Penelope is an intellectually driven young woman whose ambition has long offered structure in a life marked by early loss and adoption. She is observant, private, and often more comfortable mastering a problem than asking another person to help her carry it. Her artistic ability and dry wit surface most readily when she feels safe, though she has learned to conceal both rather than risk judgment. Penelope’s central psychological struggle is the belief that love must be earned through achievement and good behavior. Her connection with Carter challenges that belief, but does not instantly erase it. She is defined by curiosity and persistence, even when fear makes her retreat from the very people who want to support her.

Carter Edwards

The patient photographer

Carter is Penelope’s childhood neighbor and lifelong admirer, a photographer whose work is rooted in landscape, ocean, and light. Easygoing in manner, he can seem untouched by worry, but his calm carries a strong instinct to protect the people he loves. He is attentive to small changes in Penelope’s behavior and remembers details others overlook, from her fear of blood to the difference in her smiles. His weakness is assuming that care means shielding someone from pain; his growth requires listening when protection is not what Penelope needs. Carter’s affection is steady, but the story asks him to make that devotion explicit and to respect Penelope’s ambitions as fully as he loves her.

Macie

The irrepressible best friend

Macie is Penelope’s colleague and closest new friend, a fast-talking organizer who throws herself into school events and draws people into her orbit. Her boldness helps Penelope take social and emotional risks, though Macie is not simply a comic foil. She recognizes when a relationship asks her to dim herself and expects mutual respect rather than endless accommodation. Her friendship with Penelope is direct, affectionate, and sometimes blunt, giving Penelope a place to speak before she is ready to face her family or Carter.

James Martin

The Oxford professor

James is an accomplished archaeology professor whose professional authority makes him an important figure in Penelope’s life at Oxford. He offers academic guidance and appears to understand her intellectual ambitions at a moment when she is isolated and homesick. The power imbalance between professor and student shapes how Penelope interprets his attention and how much influence he gains over her choices. He represents the danger of confusing mentorship with safety when one person controls access to opportunities the other desperately wants.

Marshall Ross

The boundary-testing colleague

Marshall teaches health and physical education at Seaside Middle and moves within the same staff circle as Penelope and Macie. He is brash, competitive, and inclined to disguise disrespect as humor. His attention to Penelope creates tension among their colleagues, while his assumption that persistence will win her over reveals how little he attends to her boundaries. Marshall’s role exposes the difference between playful banter and conduct that makes another person feel unsafe.

Dom

Carter’s oldest confidant

Dom is Carter’s best friend, the person who knows how deeply Carter’s feelings for Penelope run. He encourages Carter to be honest rather than wait for circumstances to decide for him. As an adult, Dom works in real estate in California and helps Carter imagine a future beyond freelance photography. He is practical and perceptive, often recognizing the emotional truth beneath Carter’s breezy explanations.

Dan Mason

Penelope’s adoptive father

Dan is a doctor who became Penelope’s adoptive father after meeting her in the hospital where her birth mother died. He is warm and conscientious, but his desire to offer stability sometimes leads him to make choices on Penelope’s behalf. He expects a great deal from his children while wanting them to be happy, and he struggles to see how Penelope interprets love as a debt she must repay. His history with Carter and Carter’s father also makes him part of the families’ long-standing closeness.

Jenna Mason

Penelope’s adoptive mother

Jenna is Penelope’s adoptive mother and a longtime artist. She welcomes Penelope into the family, shares creative interests with her, and wants her children to feel supported. Jenna’s care is genuine, though she cannot always see the private guilt Penelope carries about being adopted or the pressure Penelope places on herself. Her artistic life also provides an early model for the creative interests Penelope later suppresses and gradually rediscovers.

Easton Mason

Penelope’s older brother

Easton is Penelope’s older brother, a law student with a confident, teasing manner. He can be self-involved and impulsive, especially when he turns a family gathering into an occasion for a joke. Beneath that bravado, he cares about Penelope and becomes more attentive when he recognizes how deeply she is hurting. His mix of humor and loyalty reflects a sibling relationship in which affection is real, even when tact is not his strongest quality.

Maddie Mason

Penelope’s younger sister

Maddie is Penelope’s younger sister and Charlie’s close friend. She is observant, mischievous, and more emotionally perceptive than she sometimes lets on. As a child, she offered Penelope quiet comfort after her return from England; as an adult, she remains a source of loyalty who can support her without demanding a full explanation. Maddie’s ease with Penelope helps restore the ordinary sibling routines that make home feel less like a place of judgment.

Tom Edwards

Carter’s father

Tom is Carter’s father, a lawyer and member of the school board. His work makes him a figure of authority in both Carter’s professional return and Penelope’s job at Seaside Middle. He is practical and sometimes absorbed in responsibility, yet he cares deeply for his family and for Penelope, whom he has known since childhood. His relationship with Carter contains affection that is not always spoken plainly, and he has to recognize how easily Carter can feel like a visitor in his own family.

Marlena

Carter’s devoted stepmother

Marlena is Carter’s stepmother and Charlie’s mother. She has been part of Carter’s life since he was young and treats him as her son, with uncomplicated affection. Her warmth helps make the Edwards home an extension of Penelope’s childhood world.

Charlie Edwards

Carter’s younger sister

Charlie is Carter’s younger sister and Maddie’s best friend. She shares the family’s playful streak and helps create the surprise that brings Penelope and Carter back into the same workplace. Carter is protective of her, while she is comfortable enough with him to tease and confide in him. Her place in both families makes her a bridge between the Edwards and Masons.

Jeremy Bridges

Macie’s fellow teacher

Jeremy teaches mathematics at Seaside Middle and is part of the social group that includes Macie, Penelope, and Marshall. He is quieter and more reserved than Macie, sometimes shrinking from her energy rather than meeting it with curiosity. His discomfort with her exuberance shapes their relationship and gives Macie a reason to reconsider what she wants from a partner.

Christine

Penelope’s teacher colleague

Christine is a teacher at Seaside Middle who works with Penelope and shares classroom duties with her. She offers practical friendship and a comfortable professional space during Penelope’s difficult return to work.

Plot Devices

Forced proximity at school

Keeps the past present

A teacher shortage leads the school to assign Penelope to temporary art classes and Carter to photography classes. Because they share a studio and small office, their reunion cannot remain a single awkward encounter. Daily routines compel them to communicate about lessons, students, supplies, and schedules, while their childhood history gives every small exchange a second meaning. The workplace also gives them a common task beyond romance: both must learn how to teach. This structure brings attraction, professional insecurity, and old familiarity into the same room, allowing the relationship to develop through repeated choices rather than a sudden return to intimacy.

The soulmate theories

Gives longing a language

Penelope’s idea about separated atoms finding one another again lets her speak about destiny while protecting herself from the vulnerability of direct confession. Carter takes her theory seriously and offers competing possibilities, turning their flirtation into an exchange about chance, choice, and what makes two people belong together. The ideas recur through their discussions of the ocean, marriage, and lifetimes. By the end, Carter’s view shifts emphasis from predestination to mutual influence: a soulmate is someone who helps another become more fully themselves. The theories do not prove that fate is real. They give the characters a way to imagine connection while they learn to build it through trust.

The annotated book

Carries private encouragement

Carter lends Penelope his worn, annotated copy of The Alchemist, a book he returns to whenever he feels lost. Its notes reveal the way he has made meaning from uncertainty, while his recommendation gently invites Penelope back into reading after she has avoided it because of her mother. He later gives her the rest of an archaeology adventure series, chosen because it connects to her childhood fascination with Atlantis. The books become more than gifts: they offer a form of companionship that does not demand immediate disclosure. They also mark Penelope’s gradual willingness to reclaim curiosity and pleasure beyond grades, admissions, and professional goals.

The Oxford scandal

Turns shame into conflict

Penelope initially describes her departure from Oxford as the result of a fraudulent recommendation letter and an academic violation. That partial account reflects the story she has come to believe about herself. The fuller truth is that James, an older professor who controlled access to academic opportunities, used her isolation and ambition, then blamed her when the relationship was exposed. Penelope’s decision to conceal the truth strains her renewed relationship with Carter and drives her flight to Los Angeles. The plot device is a revelation about power as much as a secret: it forces the characters to distinguish culpability, manipulation, shame, and the damage done when fear makes honesty feel unsafe.

Art made of each other

Makes attention visible

Carter’s photography and Penelope’s drawing and painting give the couple ways to see and represent one another. At Opal Creek, Carter photographs Penelope in the water, shifting his focus from landscape to person. Later he transforms that photograph into a large digital artwork for the gallery he plans to open. Penelope answers by painting Carter’s eye with a waterfall from one of his early photographs reflected inside it. Their works do not merely celebrate beauty; each shows how one person has learned to look through the other’s perspective. The images become a tangible record of their mutual inspiration and help turn reconciliation into a shared creative future.

About the Author

Sarah A. Bailey discovered her love of reading through the Magic Treehouse Series as a child, finding that books could transport her anywhere and allow her to experience countless lives. She specializes in warm, heartfelt romance novels designed to brighten even the darkest days and make skeptics believe in soulmates. Born in California and raised in Southern Oregon, Sarah considers herself a Pacific Northwest girl at heart, with a love of coffee, rain-soaked forests, and a firm belief in Sasquatch. She now lives in North Carolina with her husband, Mike, and their dog, Rue, spending her time writing, reading, and seeking great coffee.

Download PDF

To save this The Soulmate Theory summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.45 MB     Pages: 26

Download EPUB

To read this The Soulmate Theory summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.59 MB     Pages: 36
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...