Plot Summary
The Ferry Brings Jeff Back
At twenty-eight, Eddie Grant has a glamorous Manhattan job as assistant to romance novelist Dinah Lavender, but agrees to spend the summer on Nantucket helping her younger sister, Barrett, open a shop and checking on their withdrawn father.
Years earlier, after their mother left and their brother Stearns died, the family moved to the island to begin again. Eddie met local carpenter Jeff Jefferson at a bookstore, fell deeply in love, then left when he proposed: she believed she could never be a mother and refused the family life he wanted.
Now Jeff is waiting at the ferry terminal. He tells her he still loves her; she admits she feels the same, but insists that nothing has changed. His abrupt departure leaves her homecoming charged with the future she once rejected.
A House Buried in Books
At the farmhouse, Eddie finds her father, William, still surrounded by books and losing himself in research, while Barrett is preparing Nantucket Blues, her carefully planned blue-themed gift shop. Their mother, Sabrina, has long since left, and the sisters are still carrying the loss of Stearns and the old friend who vanished from their lives.
Eddie takes over cooking and housework so Barrett can focus on opening. Seeing books crowd every room, she proposes moving some into the empty barn and selling them there. William is intrigued, and suggests Jeff build the book bins. Eddie agrees, knowing the project is practical, though seeing Jeff again has already unsettled her resolve to leave the island.
Dinah Leaves Manhattan
Dinah calls Eddie from New York, convinced that a man who has appeared near her several times is stalking her. Eddie cannot return to the city, so she invites Dinah to stay at the farmhouse, where family and a dog can make her feel safer. Dinah arrives in designer clothes and immediately charms the carpenters working on the barn.
She also throws herself into Barrett’s shop opening, arranging champagne and turning curious passersby into customers. Although she initially plans only a short visit, Dinah enjoys the household and the island enough to rent a car and stay through the summer. Her arrival changes the home’s rhythm: Eddie must care for her employer as well as her family, and Dinah begins drawing William out of his isolation.
The Book Barn Opens
Jeff and his coworker Paul Folger build simple book bins, while Eddie and Barrett sort the Grant family’s crowded rooms. Dinah helps furnish the barn, donates her novels, and promotes its opening with a signing. At first no one comes, but a line of readers soon appears, delighted to meet her. William watches Dinah’s ease with her audience and feels exposed beside his unfinished scholarly book.
When she invites him to read her work and offers to read his, he retreats rather than share it. Still, the barn gives the family a reason to work together, and customers begin carrying books away. Dinah’s warmth and public success unsettle William, but her practical help also makes the project feel like more than a way to clear shelves.
Barrett's Shop Finds Its Audience
Barrett’s first customer is Drew Fischer, a wealthy Boston executive buying his sister a hand-knit sweater. He asks Barrett out, and their date brings easy conversation and a first kiss, but his polished attention leaves her uncertain.
Paul, meanwhile, makes her a shop sign and brings her carved bluebirds and jewelry boxes to sell. Barrett admires the patience and imagination behind his work, though she continues seeing Drew. At home, Eddie and Jeff begin spending time together as he builds the barn.
Their old attraction returns, but Eddie keeps reminding herself that she once left because she did not want children and Jeff wanted a family. Barrett’s shop succeeds through her own labor, while both sisters find their romantic pasts and futures harder to keep at arm’s length.
Dove Returns with Bobby
After years without contact, Dove Fletcher arrives at the farm with her three-year-old son, Bobby, who bears a striking resemblance to Stearns. Dove explains that after her father’s embezzlement destroyed the Fletcher family’s standing, she felt too ashamed to turn to the Grants.
Stearns found her during her drinking crisis, helped her become sober, and later became Bobby’s father. After Stearns died, Dove moved to Colorado and relapsed. Now she has end-stage liver disease and has come to ask Eddie and Barrett to raise Bobby.
She refuses the fantasy of a cure and wants her son settled with family while she still has strength. The sisters are overjoyed to see Dove, then shocked by the scale of her illness and the responsibility she is placing in their hands.
A Family Learns to Care
Dove moves into the farmhouse with Bobby, and the household forms a routine around her rest and his need for ordinary days. William takes Bobby to beaches and museums; Eddie cooks, reads to him, and keeps him company in the Book Barn. Jeff brings a workbench and Legos, then tells Eddie he wants to help raise the boy.
His care makes Eddie imagine motherhood differently, though grief and fear still make her hesitate. Dove says she wants to remain at home as long as possible, and begins preparing Bobby for the separation she believes is coming. Eddie also starts writing privately, discovering that turning experience into fiction gives her a way to imagine choices beyond the ones she has been afraid to make.
Dinah's Stalker Has a Name
Barrett meets John Henderson, a Kansas visitor who asks to see Dinah and leaves his card. Worried that he may be the stalker, the family follows Dinah when she meets him at the White Elephant hotel. They find her safe, with John’s boxes of her novels. His wife, Bea, is ill and facing surgery; he has traveled with 112 books so Dinah can sign them and give Bea something meaningful to hold onto.
William stays to help open and sort the books, a small act that turns his anxious pursuit into a chance to be useful. Dinah’s fear eases, and William’s protectiveness becomes harder to disguise. The encounter shows the novelist that her books matter intimately to readers, while giving William a way to meet her on ground beyond literary status.
Promises Made on the Island
Jeff shows Eddie the house he is building, including a cupola designed as a child’s hideaway. Eddie recognizes that she wants a life with him and Bobby, and Jeff proposes with a diamond ring. She accepts.
Barrett, meanwhile, learns that Drew took another woman to a gala, then sought her out afterward expecting intimacy. She ends their relationship, rejecting his assumption that his wealth and attention entitle him to her. Paul tells Barrett he wants a future with her, and she admits she wants one too.
The sisters’ choices are not simple escapes into romance: Eddie must leave her job with Dinah and face raising a child, while Barrett keeps the business she built. Each chooses a different form of commitment without surrendering the work that gives her life shape.
Dove's Last Days
Dove’s liver and kidneys continue to fail, and she agrees to enter Nantucket Cottage Hospital when pain requires stronger care. Before then, she arranges legal and financial matters for Bobby, including money earned from a video game Stearns created, and asks Eddie to adopt him.
She has told Bobby that she must take a long trip, preparing him for her absence without making him watch her final decline. At the hospital, Eddie and Barrett hold Dove’s hands, remembering their childhood games and promising to care for her son.
Dove dies with her sisters beside her. The loss is both intimate and practical: Eddie and Barrett must grieve their friend while becoming the secure adults Bobby needs, and the family must learn how to keep its promise to him.
Ashes in the Ocean
After Dove’s death, Eddie and Barrett tell Bobby that his mother has gone on the trip she prepared him for. He asks when she will return, and sometimes cries or erupts in anger; the family answers with routines, outings, and company rather than demanding that he understand what he cannot yet grasp. Jeff takes Bobby to see seals, and Paul shows him how to sand a small wooden angel.
When Dove’s ashes are ready, Eddie and Barrett wade into the ocean at Cisco and release them together. They speak of meeting again far in the future, honoring Dove’s beliefs without asking Bobby to attend. The sisters’ farewell does not close their grief, but it converts their promise into action: they will keep Dove present through the care they give her child.
A New Map of Home
In September, Dinah buys a house on the cliff and William becomes her partner in love and in a book about romance. She offers Eddie part-time work, leaving Eddie free to build a life with Jeff and Bobby. Jeff’s house is nearing completion, and the couple plan their wedding and the legal adoption.
Barrett keeps Nantucket Blues, which is profitable and earns a feature in Cape Cod Life; she and Paul plan a future that leaves room for his sculpture. William offers to help run her shop and gives Bobby another dependable adult. The farmhouse remains part of Bobby’s home, with Barrett living there and the barn proposed as Paul’s studio. Eddie ends not with a finished novel, but with the courage to imagine writing one.
Analysis
The novel makes starting over less a dramatic reinvention than a set of repeated acts: opening a shop each morning, carrying books to a barn, cooking for a household, and learning how to let other people help. Eddie’s central conflict grows from a painful inheritance. Her mother experienced motherhood as confinement, so Eddie interprets her own reluctance as evidence that she would become the same kind of parent. The story challenges that conclusion through action rather than argument. Eddie’s patience with Bobby, her growing trust in Jeff, and her private writing show that care and creative ambition need not cancel each other.
Barrett’s plot offers a parallel model of self-definition. She does not have to choose between romance and work by surrendering her shop; she becomes more capable of intimacy by protecting the life she has made. Paul’s respect for her business contrasts with Drew’s assumption that she should rearrange it around him. Their differing relationships to money also expose Nantucket’s social divide without making wealth alone a moral verdict.
The Book Barn and Nantucket Blues are complementary forms of authorship. William’s books have accumulated into a barricade, while Barrett’s objects create a carefully ordered public identity. Eddie’s work of sorting them asks what can be released and what deserves to remain. Dinah complicates the novel’s hierarchy of artistic value: her popular romances are financially successful, emotionally useful to readers, and ultimately a bridge between her and William. The novel’s resolution does not erase loss or promise a painless family. Dove dies, and Bobby’s grief remains real. Instead, the Grants answer absence with a network of chosen care, allowing home to become something shared, revised, and deliberately maintained.
Review Summary
Reviews for The Summer We Started Over are mixed, averaging 3.92/5. Praised aspects include the vivid Nantucket setting, charming characters, and cozy, summery atmosphere, with many comparing it favorably to Elin Hilderbrand's work. Critics, however, found the plot slow and lacking tension, the dialogue unrealistic, and the young characters unconvincingly written for their age. Several readers noted repetitive prose and underdeveloped romances. While fans of light beach reads embraced it warmly, others felt it fell below the author's usual standards.
Characters
Eddie Grant
The returning eldest sisterEddie is the oldest Grant sibling, a voracious reader who works as personal assistant to successful romance novelist Dinah Lavender. She is capable, observant, and accustomed to taking responsibility when others falter, habits formed in a family where her mother was emotionally distant and her father withdrew into grief. Eddie wants a life connected to books, but has often mistaken glamour and movement for freedom. Her fear of becoming a resentful mother shapes her choices, as does her instinct to protect Barrett and William. She can be brisk when overwhelmed, yet her care is practical and generous: she cooks, organizes, and makes space for people. Writing privately becomes a way to examine desires she has not yet allowed herself to name.
Barrett Grant
The blue-shop dreamerBarrett is Eddie’s younger sister, a resourceful Nantucket newcomer who has spent years saving money and learning the business skills needed to open Nantucket Blues. Her imagination is vivid, but unlike Eddie, she is drawn to making one place her own rather than pursuing a glamorous career elsewhere. Family loss has left her both resilient and hungry for reassurance; she works hard, jokes readily, and sometimes hides uncertainty beneath cheerfulness. Her shop is more than a livelihood. It gives form to her private vision and connects local makers with visitors. Barrett values Eddie’s judgment but also wants to be seen as an adult with authority over her own life, especially when romance threatens to distract her from the future she has built.
Jeff Jefferson
The island carpenterJeff is a year-round Nantucket carpenter with a successful small construction business and a deep attachment to the island. He is warm, physically confident, funny, and more traditional than Eddie, whose appetite for books and city life once seemed incompatible with his hopes for a settled family. His loyalty to his parents and admiration for his older brother shape his steady, unshowy way of caring. Jeff rarely presses Eddie to make a choice before she is ready, but he is honest about what he wants. His work is an extension of his character: he builds patiently, thinks in practical steps, and believes a home is something made through repeated acts of attention.
Dinah Lavender
The restless novelistDinah is a famous romance novelist whose lavish clothes and theatrical manner make her impossible to overlook. She is emotionally expressive, often dramatic, and more vulnerable than her public image suggests. As Eddie’s employer, she relies on the younger woman for practical support, but their relationship grows into a genuine friendship. Dinah is generous with money and attention, quick to turn an event into a celebration, and skilled at making strangers feel welcome. She understands that romance novels offer readers emotional pleasure and recognition, even when more prestigious literary circles dismiss the genre. Beneath her glamour is a strong desire for safety, companionship, and a place where she can belong without performing for an audience.
William Grant
The grieving scholarWilliam is a former English professor and father to Eddie and Barrett. He moved the family to Nantucket after a succession of losses, then buried himself in books and a long, difficult scholarly project. His learning is real, but so is his insecurity about whether his work will ever be finished or valued. William is affectionate and intellectually lively when his daughters draw him into family life, though he can retreat behind research rather than risk failure or intimacy. The Book Barn gives him a reason to share books instead of merely accumulating them, while Dinah challenges his assumptions about literary worth. He is not simply an absent father: beneath his withdrawal remains a man capable of humor, tenderness, and renewed curiosity.
Dove Fletcher
The vanished childhood friendDove grew up next door to the Grant children and became the imaginative center of their shared childhood. She was radiant, inventive, and skilled at turning ordinary rooms and objects into settings for elaborate games. Her family’s wealth once made her home a refuge for the Grant siblings, but her identity was also tied to the security and status that home provided. When that world is threatened, Dove struggles with shame and isolation rather than asking her friends for help. Her attachment to Stearns is deep, and she carries both the joy of being loved and the difficulty of surviving sudden change. She can be warm and funny, but she is also fiercely protective of her privacy and her child.
Bobby
The watchful little boyBobby is Dove’s three-year-old son, curious about animals, books, toys, and the adults who fill his world. He is energetic but capable of becoming absorbed in solitary play, whether studying a story or building with blocks. Because he is too young to understand adult grief in full, he responds to changes through questions, routines, and the security of familiar people. Bobby’s affection for Duke, Duchess, and Jeff gives the household small, concrete ways to welcome him. He does not function only as a symbol of the past: his needs are immediate and particular, requiring patience, food, play, reassurance, and adults willing to make room for him.
Stearns Grant
The gifted younger brotherStearns is Eddie and Barrett’s younger brother, a brilliant student and self-taught computer specialist with a playful streak. As a boy, he makes graphic novels about his close-knit circle of friends and gives each person a place in their imagined adventures. He is especially devoted to Dove, and his choices reflect both a strong independent streak and deep loyalty. The family’s memories of Stearns remain vivid because his creativity and affection are woven into their shared childhood. His work in computer games also has a practical legacy, connecting his private talent to the future of the people he loved.
Paul Folger
The island artisanPaul is Jeff’s coworker, a Nantucket-born carpenter whose quiet skill extends into intricate wood carving. He works hard, keeps his artistic practice private, and initially brings his creations to Barrett’s shop as a way to support her business. His physical confidence is softened by patience and modesty about his craft. Paul listens more than he performs, and he values the island’s local character even as construction and wealth reshape it. He sees Barrett’s work as serious rather than quaint, and his regard for her combines attraction with respect for her independence.
Drew Fischer
The polished summer suitorDrew is a Boston pharmaceutical executive from a wealthy family that summers on Nantucket. He is handsome, socially fluent, and accustomed to measuring time and effort in terms of work and opportunity. His charm initially draws Barrett in, and he can be attentive to his younger sister, Janny. Yet he often assumes that his schedule and desires should take priority, and his polished manners conceal a transactional view of relationships. Drew’s background is not itself the problem; the tension lies in his expectation that Barrett will fit into his life without equal regard for the business and community she is building.
Sabrina Grant
The restless motherSabrina is the mother of Eddie, Stearns, and Barrett, a woman who never felt fulfilled by domestic life and resented the limits she associated with motherhood and her husband’s academic income. She pursues new interests with enthusiasm, then turns away when they no longer satisfy her. Her emotional distance forces Eddie into a caretaker role while the children are young. Sabrina is not presented as a simple villain: she has her own longing for independence and significance, but she rarely considers how her departures affect her children.
Janny Fischer
The lively shop assistantJanny is Drew’s younger sister, a college student who takes a part-time job at Nantucket Blues. She is charming with customers, energetic, and devoted to Drew, whom she has long experienced as a protector. Janny’s confidence can become intrusive when she assumes she knows what is best for her brother and Barrett. Her social ease helps Barrett manage a busy shop, while her family loyalty complicates the women’s relationships.
John Henderson
The devoted book seekerJohn is a Kansas businessman who travels to Nantucket with boxes of Dinah Lavender’s novels. He is earnest and awkward in his efforts to reach the author, driven by a desire to give his ill wife a meaningful gift. His persistence looks alarming from the outside, but it comes from devotion rather than menace.
Jessie Jefferson
The welcoming carpenter's motherJessie is Jeff’s warm, talkative mother, a gardener and community volunteer who makes Eddie feel welcome at dinner. She enjoys matchmaking and is quick to notice William’s loneliness. Her conversational energy contrasts with her quieter husband and offers Eddie a glimpse of the maternal warmth she fears she cannot provide.
Plot Devices
The Book Barn
Turns clutter into communityThe barn begins as a practical answer to William’s uncontrolled book collecting and the family’s crowded farmhouse. Eddie, Barrett, William, Jeff, and Paul turn it into a low-cost used bookstore, while Dinah helps make it welcoming and contributes her own novels. The project gives the family shared labor, brings readers to the farm, and lets William encounter people outside his study. Its modest sales matter less than its ability to make private possessions circulate again. It also creates a work space where Eddie can read, reconnect with Jeff, and begin writing on her own.
Nantucket Blues
Makes Barrett's dream visibleBarrett’s shop gathers locally made sweaters, jewelry, photographs, and gifts into a carefully curated world of blue. It turns years of saving and planning into a public business, giving Barrett an independent purpose on an island where housing and work are shaped by seasonal wealth. Its success brings her into contact with customers, makers, and potential partners, while its daily demands force her to decide what kind of relationship can fit the life she is building. The shop also gives the family a practical measure of Barrett’s commitment: she is not merely imagining a future, she has made one and continues to tend it.
Books and writing
Expose hidden ambitionsBooks shape nearly every household relationship. William uses them to pursue scholarship and, at times, to avoid the world; Dinah turns them into a profession and a bond with readers; Eddie reads for pleasure and begins to write in private. Moving books from the farmhouse to the barn makes the family confront the difference between preserving memory and being trapped by it. The contrast between Dinah’s prolific popular career and William’s unfinished study initially sharpens his insecurity, then opens a conversation about whose writing deserves respect. Reading and writing are not abstract decorations here: they change how the characters see work, identity, and possibility.
The absent family
Makes care a choiceThe family is shaped by two departures: Sabrina’s withdrawal from motherhood and Dove’s disappearance after her life collapses. Their absence leaves Eddie and Barrett carrying responsibilities that should have been shared, and it makes Eddie wary of repeating a pattern she associates with motherhood. When a child needs a stable home, the sisters must distinguish their own history from the future they can offer him. This device is a spoiler because it culminates in the family taking on a lasting parental role, but its emotional groundwork begins much earlier, in the girls’ childhood and the care they provide their father.
Duke and Duchess
Measure trust through touchThe family dog and standoffish horse give the household recurring, physical tests of safety and affection. Duke welcomes people easily, while Duchess keeps her distance and accepts closeness only on her terms. Their contrasting responses echo the different ways the human characters approach grief, trust, and belonging. Bobby’s connection with the animals helps him feel at home without requiring adult explanations, and the horse’s gradual tolerance gives the family a quiet marker of change. Their scenes keep the story grounded in daily care: feeding, watching, approaching gently, and respecting another creature’s limits.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.