Key Takeaways
Build for the moment the Internet becomes part of every industry
Three eras, one direction. Case divides Internet history into three waves. The First built the networks, devices, and software that made getting online possible. The Second used that foundation for search, online shopping, social networks, and mobile apps. The Third, in his 2016 account, begins when connectivity is woven into industries that do not define themselves as technology businesses.
From apps to essential systems. Healthcare, education, food, transportation, and finance become candidates for reinvention. A connected medical device, for example, could give doctors a stream of health measurements rather than relying only on a patient's memory during an appointment. The important shift is from making Internet products to using the Internet to improve everyday services.
What's striking is the change in the unit of innovation. In the Second Wave, the product could be an app. In the Third, technology becomes part of a larger service system, where outcomes depend on workers, institutions, and physical infrastructure as well as software. This is a useful model for assessing a startup: ask what must change around the technology for it to matter. The forecast also needs restraint. Connectivity alone does not make a service better, and industries such as healthcare have human and organizational constraints that code cannot simply erase.
Treat failure as evidence about the model, not the mission
A failed modem taught the lesson. Case joined Control Video Corporation, which tried to deliver video games through a specialized modem. The game market collapsed, orders disappeared, and the modem could send information only one way just as two-way devices were becoming standard. A supposed competitive advantage had become a liability.
Change the means, preserve the aim. The team stopped making hardware and focused on easy-to-use online services. When potential partners still distrusted the struggling company, it created Quantum Computer Services, licensing the software and giving the team a fresh balance sheet. Partnerships with Commodore, RadioShack, and IBM helped the new company survive. The product changed repeatedly; the underlying ambition to bring ordinary consumers online remained.
This story separates persistence from stubbornness. The team did not defend the modem merely because it had invested in it. It treated market response and technical standards as information, then changed the business model while keeping the broader goal. That resembles experimental reasoning: a failed test should revise a hypothesis, not automatically end inquiry. Still, a clean corporate restart is not available to every founder, and persistence can become a way to postpone recognizing that demand is absent. The useful discipline is to specify what evidence would trigger a change before loyalty to the original plan takes over.
Make the Internet welcoming enough for ordinary people to belong
Connection was the product. Case argues that AOL's central insight was not simply that people wanted information or commerce. They wanted to communicate and form communities. At a time when the Internet seemed technical and impersonal to many newcomers, AOL made its service easier to navigate and gave it a human voice. The familiar mail notification helped make an unfamiliar medium feel approachable.
Reduce the cost of trying. AOL borrowed a consumer-marketing lesson from Case's earlier work at Procter & Gamble: free samples can persuade people to try something they do not yet understand. The company mailed enormous numbers of trial discs and simplified access. For users, the service became a first place to email, shop, read news, and meet others online. Inclusion was not a decorative value. It was a growth strategy.
The insight connects product design to social adoption. A technology can be technically accessible yet culturally forbidding; clear cues, low-risk trials, and familiar social uses help close that gap. This is especially relevant when a service depends on network effects, because each new participant can make it more valuable to others. Yet community is not created by friendliness alone. It also requires norms, moderation, and trust, all of which become harder as participation scales. The lesson is to design the social conditions of adoption, not merely the interface.
Borrow credibility through partnerships before trying to scale
Access can matter more than code. Case's three-part playbook for the Third Wave is partnership, policy, and perseverance. Partnerships matter because health systems, schools, food networks, and other industries have gatekeepers. A strong prototype may not reach users without approval from organizations that control access, distribution, or trust.
Build a ladder of confidence. Early deals with Commodore and RadioShack helped Quantum win a partnership with Apple, then IBM. Each relationship made the young company seem less speculative to the next partner and to investors. Case also points to Apple's iTunes launch: despite a polished product, Apple needed music companies to license songs. A small startup can borrow legitimacy from respected advisers, customers, or institutions, then use early results to earn broader support.
Partnerships function here as more than sales channels. They provide legitimacy, complementary assets, and access to people a startup cannot reach alone. This resembles institutional entrepreneurship: new ventures often change established systems by working through existing organizations, not by bypassing every one of them. The danger is dependence. A dominant partner can dictate terms, delay launch, or absorb the value being created. The strategic question is not simply whom to partner with, but how to build several sources of credibility so one gatekeeper cannot become the company's single point of failure.
Map regulators into the product plan before launching
Rules shape the route to market. Case says the main uncertainty changes across Internet waves: early founders worried whether technology could be built; the next generation worried whether people would adopt it; Third Wave companies must also ask whether rules allow it to operate. A health product may need Food and Drug Administration review. Drones, lending, and transportation face different regulators and requirements.
Treat policy as operating work. Founders do not need to become lawyers, but they do need a credible plan for approvals, safety, privacy, and government engagement. Case notes that some startups cannot attract funding without showing how they will manage these risks. Government is not only a rule-maker, either. It can be a customer, as when public agencies buy sensors or digital services, and a source of early research or market access.
This is a reminder that regulation is part of a product's environment, much like supply chains or customer behavior. Early engagement can reveal design requirements before a company has committed to an expensive path. It can also help regulators understand a new technology before a crisis defines the debate. But fluency should not collapse into treating public rules as hurdles to clear. In health, transportation, and finance, regulation often represents real risks to other people. A sound strategy asks both how to comply and whether the product's benefits justify the risks it introduces.
Keep adapting when partners, markets, or regulators reject the first version
Progress rarely follows a straight line. AOL's path included a failed gaming product, a broken hardware strategy, and the collapse of its Apple partnership. After Apple withdrew, Quantum negotiated a settlement, abandoned its private-label approach, combined its services under a company-owned brand, and launched America Online. Each setback forced a new operating choice rather than a simple return to the original plan.
Persist with revisions. Case's third P, perseverance, means staying committed through long development cycles while changing tactics. He cites 23andMe, which faced a Food and Drug Administration restriction on its consumer genetic-testing product, then obtained a limited exemption and resumed sales. Third Wave ventures may encounter obstacles in software, manufacturing, distribution, regulation, or trust. A founder needs endurance, but also enough flexibility to redesign the route.
The distinction between persistence and inflexibility is central. In complex ventures, setbacks often reveal a mismatch between the product and the surrounding system, rather than a verdict on the problem's importance. A useful response is to identify which assumption failed: technical feasibility, demand, permission, or partner willingness. That diagnosis supports targeted changes instead of indiscriminate pivoting. The harder question is when to stop. Perseverance is most valuable when there are credible signs of learning and progress, not when continued effort is justified only by money already spent.
Choose a startup's home by its industry, not its hype
Innovation has a geography. Case calls the spread of entrepreneurial activity beyond established centers the rise of the rest. In 2014, he notes, three-quarters of U.S. venture capital went to California, New York, and Massachusetts. But Third Wave companies may benefit more from proximity to the industries they aim to change than from proximity to software firms.
Local knowledge creates openings. Agriculture ventures may fit the Midwest, healthcare companies may find useful expertise in Nashville or Baltimore, and robotics founders may benefit from Pittsburgh's manufacturing base and Carnegie Mellon's research strengths. A New Orleans teacher, Jen Medbery, built Kickboard after seeing how schools struggled to use student data. Local costs can also stretch early funding further. The claim is not that every city is equally ready, but that talent and problems are widely distributed.
The geographic argument broadens the usual picture of entrepreneurship. A founder embedded in a field may notice operational problems that a distant software team misses, while local institutions can supply early customers and expertise. This is a strong case for matching ventures to ecosystems rather than treating one technology hub as the universal starting point. Still, capital and specialized talent remain unevenly distributed. Lower costs do not automatically compensate for limited access to later-stage investors or experienced hires. Regional growth therefore depends on durable networks, not simply an inspiring local success story.
Make social impact part of the business case
Profit and purpose can reinforce each other. Case describes impact investing as placing capital in businesses intended to generate both financial returns and measurable social benefit. He argues that Third Wave companies often work on essential services, so their social consequences are built into the business rather than added as a charitable afterthought.
Revolution Foods shows the model. Founders Kristin Groos Richmond and Kirsten Saenz Tobey saw that school meals often offered poor nutrition, especially in underserved communities. They built a company to provide healthier food at affordable prices, addressing a public problem through a commercial operation. The Case Foundation and Case's investment firm supported different parts of the impact-investing ecosystem. A Wharton review of 53 private equity funds, cited in the book, found that impact funds could meet targeted returns and achieve mission-aligned exits.
The strongest version of impact investing makes the social outcome inseparable from how the company earns revenue. That can align incentives more durably than philanthropy alone, especially when customers and investors reward the same outcome. The approach also raises a measurement challenge: financial returns are comparatively legible, while social benefit can be diffuse, delayed, or unevenly shared. A credible impact thesis therefore needs explicit measures and accountability, not just a compelling mission statement. Purpose may attract people and capital, but it does not exempt a business from proving that its model works.
Force incumbents to fund the future that threatens them
Scale can be an innovation asset. Established companies hold research talent, capital, customers, and expertise that startups often lack. Case argues that these firms can respond to disruption by supporting internal innovators, taking more experimental bets, creating startup investment funds, or partnering with young companies. John Deere, for example, had developed GPS-guided tractor technology long before self-driving cars became a major technology-sector focus.
Self-disruption is difficult but necessary. Apple accepted that the iPhone would reduce demand for the iPod; Amazon developed ebooks despite its success selling printed books. Kodak presents the counterexample: its engineers built an early digital camera, but leaders prioritized the existing film business over a distant threat. Companies need room to test ideas that may compete with current revenue, and leaders must protect those experiments from short-term pressures.
The organizational challenge is not a shortage of ideas so much as a shortage of permission. A mature company can possess the relevant technology and still fail to commercialize it if success threatens established budgets, status, or customer relationships. Separate teams and external partnerships can protect experiments, but separation can also isolate them from the resources needed to scale. The practical test is whether promising work receives real authority, talent, and capital, not merely an innovation lab and a press release. Self-disruption requires changing incentives, not just declaring urgency.
A merger can unite assets while leaving the people divided
Strategic logic could not repair mistrust. AOL's 2000 merger with Time Warner joined a fast-growing Internet company to a media and cable giant. Case believed their assets could combine online distribution, broadband, and trusted content brands. But senior Time Warner leaders were often excluded from negotiations, and the merger began with resentment. Then the dot-com crash damaged the combined company's value and intensified suspicion.
The operating system is culture. Time Warner's divisions largely acted as separate fiefdoms, while AOL and the legacy media businesses disagreed about the Internet's importance. The cable unit did not deliver the broadband access AOL expected, and internal conflict blocked initiatives. Case says he also stayed too far from executives, partly to avoid confusion about who was in charge. The failure illustrates that strategic fit on paper cannot substitute for trust, clear authority, and shared incentives.
The merger is a caution against evaluating combinations only through assets, market value, and projected synergies. Integration depends on people interpreting the deal as legitimate and worthwhile, especially when identities and status are threatened. Organizational theory often treats culture as informal infrastructure: it determines which information travels, who can make decisions, and whether cooperation feels safe. Yet culture is not an excuse for every poor outcome. Leadership choices, governance, and incentives shape it. The useful due diligence question is not whether two companies have complementary strengths, but whether they can actually coordinate them.
Treat startup policy as economic infrastructure, not campaign rhetoric
New firms need a functioning ecosystem. Case distinguishes high-growth startups from small businesses with steadier growth ambitions, arguing that young, fast-growing firms account for a substantial share of new job creation. He urges policymakers to improve access to capital, attract skilled immigrants, sustain public research, and update rules for emerging industries and forms of work.
The JOBS Act offers a case study. Case helped build bipartisan support for legislation that included crowdfunding and other changes intended to make it easier for young companies to raise money. The act passed in 2012, though implementation took years and left founders with burdensome requirements. The broader point is that entrepreneurship depends on many connected conditions: research creates ideas, financing helps companies test them, and talent and workable rules make growth possible. A weakness in any link can send opportunity elsewhere.
This ecosystem view is more useful than debating whether government is simply friend or foe. Public research, capital rules, immigration, and labor protections influence who can start companies and who benefits from their growth. The argument also resists a common policy error: treating every small firm as if it had the same needs as a venture-backed company seeking rapid scale. Still, pro-startup reforms should be judged by outcomes, including job quality, access beyond wealthy networks, and public value. Faster company formation is a means, not a complete measure of economic success.
Analysis
The book's central contribution is to recast the Internet's next phase as an institutional challenge rather than a purely technical one. Case's history of AOL supports that argument through concrete reversals: a proprietary modem fails, a major Apple partnership collapses, and the company survives by changing its business model and its name. The narrative makes a useful distinction between preserving a mission and preserving a particular product. It also shows how access, credibility, and consumer trust can matter as much as technical originality.
The Third Wave framework extends this lesson from online services into healthcare, education, food, finance, and transportation. These are not empty markets waiting for a clever app. They are complex systems with professional norms, public safeguards, entrenched organizations, and physical infrastructure. The emphasis on partnership, policy, and perseverance follows logically from that complexity. It is also a corrective to a startup mythology in which speed and disruption alone guarantee progress.
The AOL-Time Warner story is the book's strongest counterweight to its optimism. The merger paired valuable assets but failed to create trust or operational coordination. Case's account usefully includes his own misjudgments, especially his assumption that strategic logic would persuade people without sustained relationship-building. That humility strengthens the organizational lesson, although the memoir remains one participant's account, shaped by hindsight and personal responsibility.
The book is less conclusive as a forecast than as a strategic lens. Its 2016 predictions about connected industries and regional entrepreneurship should be read as hypotheses, not settled outcomes. Technology can widen access, but it can also concentrate power; impact claims can become branding; partnerships can entrench incumbents as readily as enable change. The most durable takeaway is therefore a method of attention: identify who controls access, what public rules protect, where domain expertise resides, and which incentives prevent organizations from changing. Innovation succeeds when those forces are designed into the venture, not wished away.
Review Summary
The Third Wave receives mixed reviews, with some praising its insights into entrepreneurship and the future of technology, while others criticize it as self-indulgent and lacking depth. Readers appreciate Case's experience with AOL and his vision for the "Third Wave" of internet development, focusing on partnerships, policy, and perseverance. Critics argue the book is more memoir than guidebook and offers little new information. Many find the AOL history interesting but feel the future predictions are vague. Overall, the book is seen as a quick read with some valuable perspectives on the evolving tech landscape.
People Also Read
Glossary
First Wave
Internet infrastructure buildingCase's name for the early Internet era focused on creating the hardware, software, and networks that let people connect. Companies built access systems and consumer services while trying to make online use affordable and understandable. AOL belongs to this wave because it helped bring ordinary households onto the network.
Second Wave
Internet services and appsCase's term for the phase that built services on top of established Internet access. Search, online shopping, social networks, smartphones, and mobile applications expanded what people could do online. Many successful businesses in this period could scale software quickly without the extensive industry partnerships required in more regulated sectors.
Third Wave
Internet integrated into industriesCase's term for the phase in which Internet connectivity becomes embedded in major parts of daily life and conventional industries. Healthcare, education, food, transportation, and finance become candidates for technology-enabled change. Compared with app-centered ventures, Third Wave companies face more gatekeepers, regulation, operational complexity, and need for cross-sector partnerships.
Internet of Everything
Connectivity across daily lifeCase's expansive description of Internet integration across products, services, and ordinary activities. He uses it to distinguish the broad transformation of whole industries from the narrower idea of connecting objects through sensors. In this vision, Internet access becomes so routine that it is no longer a special feature of a product.
The Three P's
Partnership, policy, perseveranceCase's framework for building Third Wave companies. Partnership helps ventures reach gatekeepers, gain credibility, and access customers. Policy means understanding government rules and engaging with regulators, especially in industries where safety and public interests matter. Perseverance means continuing through long development cycles while adapting the product and strategy when conditions change.
Rise of the Rest
Entrepreneurship beyond major hubsCase's term for the growth of startup communities outside the traditional centers of venture capital and technology, especially California, New York, and Massachusetts. He argues that regions with deep expertise in healthcare, agriculture, manufacturing, or education can be strong homes for companies addressing those industries, while spreading jobs and investment more widely.
Impact investing
Investment seeking social benefitAn investment approach intended to generate financial returns alongside measurable social or environmental benefit. In Case's account, it bridges commercial business and philanthropy by directing capital to companies that address public needs through viable operations. The approach depends on showing that the claimed impact is real, not merely part of a company's branding.
3 C's
Content, context, communityCase's shorthand for elements he believes support successful online learning and information services. Content is the material being delivered. Context helps users understand and navigate it, often through curation or trusted institutions. Community enables people to connect with one another around the material. The framework argues that technology and content alone may not create lasting engagement.
FAQ
What's "The Third Wave: An Entrepreneur's Vision of the Future" about?
- Overview of the book: "The Third Wave" by Steve Case explores the future of the Internet and its integration into every aspect of our lives, marking a new era of technological evolution.
- Three Waves Concept: The book is structured around the concept of three waves of the Internet: the First Wave (building the Internet), the Second Wave (building on top of the Internet), and the Third Wave (integrating the Internet into everything).
- Focus on Entrepreneurship: Case emphasizes the role of entrepreneurs in driving innovation and transforming industries such as healthcare, education, and food through the Internet of Everything.
- Personal Insights: The book also includes Case's personal experiences and lessons learned from his time at AOL, providing a unique perspective on the evolution of the digital world.
Why should I read "The Third Wave"?
- Future Insights: The book offers valuable insights into the future of technology and how it will impact various industries, making it essential reading for anyone interested in innovation and entrepreneurship.
- Entrepreneurial Guidance: Case provides practical advice for entrepreneurs navigating the challenges of the Third Wave, including the importance of partnerships, policy understanding, and perseverance.
- Historical Context: By reflecting on the history of the Internet's development, the book provides context for understanding current and future technological trends.
- Inspiration and Motivation: Through personal anecdotes and success stories, Case inspires readers to embrace change and seize opportunities in the rapidly evolving digital landscape.
What are the key takeaways of "The Third Wave"?
- Integration of the Internet: The Third Wave will see the Internet fully integrated into every aspect of life, transforming industries and creating new opportunities.
- Importance of Partnerships: Success in the Third Wave will require building strong partnerships across sectors, including with government and established industries.
- Role of Government: Government will play a crucial role as both a regulator and a customer in the Third Wave, making it essential for entrepreneurs to engage with policymakers.
- Rise of Impact Investing: The convergence of profit and purpose will drive the growth of impact investing, aligning financial returns with social good.
How does Steve Case define the "Three Waves" of the Internet?
- First Wave: This phase involved building the Internet's infrastructure, with companies like AOL, Cisco, and Microsoft laying the groundwork for connectivity.
- Second Wave: Characterized by the development of applications and services on top of the Internet, this wave saw the rise of social media, e-commerce, and mobile technology.
- Third Wave: The current phase focuses on integrating the Internet into every aspect of life, transforming industries such as healthcare, education, and transportation.
- Evolutionary Process: Each wave builds on the previous one, with the Third Wave representing a more profound and integrated use of the Internet.
What are the "Three P's" that Steve Case emphasizes for Third Wave startups?
- Partnerships: Building strong partnerships is crucial for navigating the complex landscape of the Third Wave, especially in regulated industries.
- Policy: Understanding and engaging with government policy is essential, as many Third Wave industries are heavily regulated.
- Perseverance: Entrepreneurs must be prepared for a long journey, requiring adaptability and resilience in the face of challenges and setbacks.
How does "The Third Wave" address the role of government in innovation?
- Regulatory Role: Government will play a significant role in regulating industries affected by the Third Wave, such as healthcare and transportation.
- Government as a Customer: The public sector will also be a major customer for Third Wave innovations, creating opportunities for startups to provide solutions.
- Policy Engagement: Entrepreneurs must engage with policymakers to navigate regulations and advocate for supportive policies.
- Historical Examples: Case highlights past government initiatives, like DARPA, that have driven technological advancements and set the stage for future innovation.
What is "impact investing" according to Steve Case, and why is it important?
- Definition: Impact investing involves making investments that generate financial returns while also creating positive social or environmental impact.
- Third Wave Alignment: Many Third Wave companies will naturally align with impact investing, as they address core societal needs and challenges.
- Millennial Influence: The growing influence of millennials, who prioritize social impact in their investments and careers, is driving the rise of impact investing.
- Convergence of Trends: Impact investing, the Third Wave, and the rise of the rest are converging to create new opportunities for entrepreneurs and investors.
What does Steve Case mean by "the rise of the rest"?
- Geographic Shift: The rise of the rest refers to the emergence of new innovation hubs outside traditional tech centers like Silicon Valley, New York, and Boston.
- Regional Opportunities: As the Third Wave unfolds, industries will cluster in regions with relevant expertise, such as healthcare in Nashville or agriculture in the Midwest.
- Economic Impact: This geographic diversity will spread the economic benefits of innovation more broadly, creating jobs and revitalizing communities across the country.
- Investment Strategy: Case sees the rise of the rest as an investment opportunity, with untapped potential in regions often overlooked by venture capital.
How does Steve Case view the relationship between Silicon Valley and Washington, DC?
- Cultural Divide: There is often a disconnect between the tech industry and government, with Silicon Valley viewing government as an impediment to innovation.
- Need for Collaboration: Case argues that collaboration between tech and government is essential for addressing the challenges and opportunities of the Third Wave.
- Mutual Benefits: Both sides can benefit from working together, with government providing a regulatory framework and tech offering innovative solutions to societal problems.
- Bridging the Gap: Case advocates for building bridges between the two worlds to foster understanding and cooperation.
What are some of the best quotes from "The Third Wave" and what do they mean?
- "If you want to go quickly, go alone. If you want to go far, go together." This African proverb emphasizes the importance of partnerships in achieving long-term success.
- "Vision without execution is hallucination." Attributed to Thomas Edison, this quote underscores the need for practical action to turn visionary ideas into reality.
- "The Stone Age didn’t end because we ran out of stone. It ended because we invented something better." This quote highlights the power of innovation to drive progress and change.
- "Alone we can do so little. Together we can do so much." A quote from Helen Keller, reinforcing the value of collaboration and teamwork in achieving great things.
How does Steve Case's personal journey influence "The Third Wave"?
- AOL Experience: Case draws on his experience co-founding and leading AOL to provide insights into the evolution of the Internet and the challenges of entrepreneurship.
- Lessons Learned: He shares lessons learned from both successes and failures, offering practical advice for navigating the Third Wave.
- Vision for the Future: Case's vision for the future is shaped by his belief in the transformative power of technology and the potential for positive impact.
- Inspiration for Others: By sharing his journey, Case aims to inspire and motivate the next generation of entrepreneurs to embrace change and seize opportunities.
What industries does Steve Case predict will be transformed by the Third Wave?
- Healthcare: The integration of technology will revolutionize healthcare, improving outcomes, reducing costs, and enhancing convenience.
- Education: Edtech innovations will democratize learning, personalize education, and expand access to knowledge.
- Food: The food industry will be transformed by technology, from production and distribution to consumption and safety.
- Transportation: Advances in transportation, such as self-driving cars, will reshape how we move and interact with the world around us.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.