Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
They Call Her Regret

They Call Her Regret

A teen's friend drowns at her party; can a lake spirit's bargain undo the horror?
by Channelle Desamours 2026 320 pages
4.00
500+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Masks at Ozzy's

Simone keeps grief from her friends and Cory

Sixteen-year-old Simone Washington hides from classmates in Ozzy’s Pizza restroom, where her estranged mother’s teenage graffiti still marks the wall. Outside, best friend Kira celebrates with her boyfriend, Rich, while Simone watches Rich flirt with other girls and worries Kira is giving up an art-school future for him.

Their former friend Cory Gooding now works at the restaurant; they have barely spoken since Trenton Jones, a boy they both loved, died in a hit-and-run two years earlier.

Cory mentions a missing college student, Natalie Dawson, and invites himself to Simone’s Halloween party. Simone agrees, though his presence brings back the friendship and losses she has tried to bury. Her father, Tony, offers a steadier home life, but Simone keeps her mother’s absence and her own pain hidden.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Simone’s concealment is not simple reserve. She builds a social self as deliberately as she plans a haunted party, using competence and coolness to keep people from asking what she cannot answer. Her old restroom refuge makes that defense material: her mother’s writing remains where her mother no longer does. Cory is unsettling because he knew Simone before she perfected this public version of herself. The missing student introduces another local absence, but Trenton’s death is the private wound shaping Simone’s attention to every disappearance. Her protective impulse toward Kira is sincere, yet her inability to speak plainly foreshadows how care can become control.

The Doll's Head Trail

Cory's legend turns Simone's birthday into a gamble

At home, Simone finds Cory’s blog post about broken toys leading through Champlain Park to Doll’s Head Lake. A handwritten warning in a local history book names a specter called Regret and cautions visitors to bring an offering.

Simone secretly builds her senior birthday gathering around the site, then accepts Kira’s sister Layla’s offer of a secluded family cabin instead of the booked recreation hall. Layla and her husband John prepare the property while Simone decorates and slips into the woods to inspect the toys.

A strange light unnerves her. Later, a man named Nate Hightower appears at the cabin, claiming to be its new groundskeeper, though his late visit and evasive manner trouble her. Simone reports him to John, then locks the doors and waits for her guests.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The legend gives Simone a form of fear she believes she can manage: she chooses the location, props, and audience, turning danger into a designed experience. Yet the preparation steadily erodes that distinction. Her light sightings echo Trenton’s fatal hit-and-run, and Nate’s unexplained appearance puts an actual stranger inside her controlled set. The warning about offerings also carries a moral charge that Simone does not yet understand. She treats the toys as atmospheric material, not as evidence of a history that might still be active. The cabin is therefore both party venue and threshold, a place where her theatrical command of horror begins to fail.

A Party Turns Personal

Simone finds Rich arranging a secret meeting

Simone’s guests arrive to a jack-in-the-box scare, a bonfire, and a ghost story she invents from the woods’ abandoned dolls. When Kingston retrieves a toy, the group hears a recorded baby cry and races back laughing. Cory also arrives with pizza, slips easily into the gathering, and revives memories Simone is trying to suppress.

Later, while everyone plays games, Simone notices Rich texting Shaina, another guest. She checks Shaina’s phone and finds plans for them to meet privately at the dock after the others fall asleep. Simone wants Kira to know, but fears Kira will dismiss another warning about Rich. When the guests begin dozing, Simone wakes Kira and leads her outside, choosing confrontation over the quiet night Kira wanted.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Simone’s party succeeds as spectacle, but its most consequential discovery is not supernatural. She sees the betrayal she has long suspected and again assumes that acting quickly is the same as helping. Her decision to access Shaina’s messages violates privacy, even as it confirms Rich’s deception. That double edge matters: Simone’s protective instincts are real, but she tends to trust her own reading of a situation more than the people involved. Cory’s easy return to the group makes the night emotionally unstable, while the invented ghost story unknowingly borrows from the site’s actual history. The staged baby cry becomes a rehearsal for a much less controllable encounter.

The Lake's First Bargain

A shove makes Kira's life the price

At the dock, Rich denies that Shaina is with him, and Kira asks Simone to stop pressing him. Simone grabs for Rich’s phone; during the struggle, she shoves Kira too hard. Kira falls into the lake, where she cannot swim. Rich dives in, pulls her to shore, and tries CPR, but she is dead.

As Simone continues compressions, a young-looking, waterlogged apparition appears and identifies herself as Regret. She offers to restore Kira in exchange for another life, provided the chosen person is on the grounds, and gives Simone until the next new moon to free her.

Regret’s vision shows Rich blaming Simone in court for Kira’s death. Convinced he would falsely accuse her, Simone chooses Rich. The world abruptly changes, leaving Kira alive and the bargain unresolved.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The supernatural bargain arrives after a human mistake, not in place of one. Simone’s shove is accidental, but it follows her refusal to accept Kira’s request to stop; the scene makes intention and impact impossible to separate. Regret exploits that confusion by framing the choice as a clean exchange, even though Simone is panicked, grieving, and shown only one possible future. Choosing Rich is partly self-protection and partly an attempt to protect Kira from a man Simone distrusts. The bargain turns a private ethical failure into a deadline, while its promise to erase regret tempts Simone with relief rather than repair.

Fourteen Days to Decide

Rich dies as Simone doubts her own memory

Kira reappears dry and unharmed, and Rich stands alive by the firepit; neither remembers the drowning or bargain. Simone questions whether the encounter was a hallucination, but a mechanical doll later counts down the days remaining.

In the morning, Rich is found dead outside, his hand burned while holding a generator cord after a storm. Police call it an accident. Simone recognizes that the cord and power failure offer a plausible explanation, yet she cannot forget Regret.

At home, a video on her phone forces her to remember kissing Rich under the school bleachers that summer. Kira later admits she confronted Rich over a suspicious text, broke up with him, and dreamed Simone pushed her into the lake. Simone cannot tell her the dream was real.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The reset does not restore innocence. Kira’s survival and Rich’s death create a version of events that looks ordinary enough to doubt, while the doll’s countdown keeps Simone’s private knowledge alive. Her uncertainty is psychological as much as paranormal: she has hidden a real kiss with Rich, suppressed her grief over Trenton, and now has reason to distrust her own memory. Kira’s dream nearly bridges the gap between them, but Simone withholds the truth again. The apparent electrocution offers the comfort of a natural explanation, yet the timing makes that comfort precarious. The story makes denial feel useful for a moment, then turns it into another burden Simone must carry.

Old Guilt, New Evidence

Cory helps trace Regret to Evelyn Young

Simone reconnects with Cory at a neighborhood playground and asks for his help investigating the lake, admitting only that she fears something supernatural happened.

Together they question Mr. Otis, who recalls a reclusive young woman named Evelyn Young and rumors of heartbreak, then visit Tandy’s thrift shop, where its owner repeats a tale about Evelyn losing a child. Simone and Cory locate Violet Savoie’s daughter, Elmira, and secretly search Elmira’s attic after a cleaner reveals where a spare key is hidden.

They find Violet’s diary and books on magic. The diary portrays Evelyn as responsible for the death of Violet’s cousin Dorothy, so Simone and Cory take a forgiveness letter from Elmira to the lake. Regret rejects it and demands that Violet herself confess.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Research becomes the form Simone can tolerate for intimacy: she works beside Cory, but still withholds the bargain and the most painful parts of her past. The investigation also shows how a town’s memory can preserve names while deforming causes. Otis’s recollection and Tandy’s inherited story contradict one another, while Violet’s diary seems authoritative because it is private and detailed. Simone and Cory nevertheless trespass and take family records, repeating the very pattern they are trying to expose: they act on incomplete information because the deadline makes patience feel dangerous. Regret’s rejection of the letter punctures the comforting fairy-tale logic of forgiveness and forces them to seek evidence rather than symbolism alone.

What the Sand Remembered

Mama Dee uncovers Violet's bargain and betrayal

Church records reveal that Evelyn placed a two-year-old boy for adoption, with Deidra Hightower, known locally as psychic Mama Dee, listed as coordinator. Mama Dee remembers the case and explains that the child was Dorothy’s son, Nathaniel, not Evelyn’s.

She says Violet brought him to the church after helping a stranger murder Dorothy and conceal her body in the lake; Violet then cursed Evelyn to keep her from exposing the crime. The stranger had offered Violet money while her family was in debt.

Mama Dee gives Simone a photograph and records showing Nathaniel grew up safely, plus tiger’s-eye necklaces and instructions for drawing memories out of lake sand. She warns that the power transferred through Simone’s bargain may let her perform the ritual herself.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The revelation dismantles two versions of the past at once. Violet’s diary protects her by recasting Evelyn as the culprit, while the town’s toy offerings preserve a distorted story about a bereaved mother. Mama Dee’s account restores the child’s actual relationship to Dorothy and exposes money, not romance, as the motive behind the cover-up. The material-memory ritual offers a different model of knowledge: history is not recovered by choosing the most compelling story, but by testing what objects retain. Mama Dee also reframes Simone’s supernatural connection as a transfer of power, not merely a debt. Simone is becoming capable of action, but capability does not guarantee control.

Natalie's Missing Thread

A necklace links the missing student to Rich

While investigating Rich’s unexplained drug levels, Simone notices a sticker of an astronaut vomiting a rainbow on a memorial card and later spots the same image in a photograph of missing student Natalie Dawson.

Natalie wears a gold K pendant like Kira’s, but the lettering and a small chip show Simone has found a different necklace. At a Sittersville high school, a student links the sticker to secret raves; Simone and Cory visit an abandoned warehouse and find a number advertising drugs.

Rich could have obtained GHB there. Separately, Simone learns from Kira that Rich had been at a rave and had concealed much of his life from her. The clues suggest Rich and Natalie may have shared a dangerous connection, but do not yet prove what happened to her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The case widens from Simone’s guilt to a pattern of harm that may have preceded the party. The matching visual clues are small and ordinary, a sticker and a pendant, yet they connect a missing college student to Rich’s concealed life. Simone is tempted to turn coincidence into certainty because a larger crime might explain the supernatural bargain and give her a path to justice. Cory’s investigative discipline sometimes slows that leap, while Simone’s urgency pushes them toward the warehouse and its drug contact. The scene also complicates her memory of Rich: he is no longer only Kira’s unreliable boyfriend or her own secret, but a person whose hidden choices may have endangered someone beyond their circle.

The Washington Secret

Simone learns who killed Trenton

As the deadline closes in, Simone visits her estranged mother, Camille, hoping to clear the guilt she has carried since Trenton’s death. Camille reveals that she was drunk when she struck Trenton with her car, then hid the damage and let an elderly man become the public suspect.

Simone had seen the damaged car and heard her parents’ argument, but stayed silent. She had also sent Camille’s employer an anonymous email, hoping a forced intervention would make her stop drinking; instead, Camille’s life deteriorated and she left.

Camille explains that she once met Regret at the lake, rejected the apparition as a drunken hallucination, and later returned too late to change what had happened. Simone leaves with the truth, but not absolution, and decides she must face the lake without relying on escape.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The revelation changes the moral scale of Simone’s story. Her guilt about being late to the movie and kissing Cory was real, but it was not the deepest secret: she knowingly let an innocent person be blamed for her mother’s crime. Camille’s addiction explains the concealment without excusing it, and Simone’s anonymous attempt to force help shows how her care repeatedly becomes covert intervention. The mother and daughter mirror one another in choosing self-preservation over disclosure, though each tells herself a different story about why. Camille offers flight as protection; Simone refuses because evasion has already shaped too much of her life. This is the emotional preparation for a confession she cannot outsource.

The Yearwoods' Lake

Simone's ritual reveals John dumping Natalie

Simone discovers vials and astronaut labels among Kira’s returned belongings, then connects Nate Hightower to Mama Dee’s family history. At the cabin, she uses lake sand, a vial, and Natalie’s pendant in Mama Dee’s ritual.

The vision shows John Yearwood pushing Natalie’s body from the dock into the lake. Before Simone can learn more, John appears in person. He recognizes the objects and attacks her. Kira arrives and admits she had suspected John’s affair with Natalie but stayed silent, just as she had struggled to believe Simone about Rich.

Simone accuses John of killing Dorothy as well as Natalie, implicating a Yearwood family pattern. John confirms that more women will die, then lunges again. Regret offers to enter Simone, and Simone accepts.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ritual turns the investigation from conjecture into witnessed evidence, but it gives Simone no safety or complete account. John’s appearance makes the danger physical, and Kira’s arrival reverses the earlier pattern: she now acts on suspicion instead of waiting for certainty. Her admission also reveals how silence can be shared without being identical. Simone’s accusation about Dorothy connects a private murder to the family’s ownership of the land, but the full history remains uncertain until John’s threat confirms further victims. Accepting Regret’s presence is not a clean alliance. Simone knows the spirit is hungry and dangerous, yet chooses immediate power because the alternative is allowing another person to be harmed.

A Hunger Unbound

Regret uses Simone to stop the killer

Regret takes control of Simone and drives her knife into John. Kira sees the killing, while Cory arrives with gasoline and the toys collected from the trail. Simone throws Violet’s diary into the fire and offers proof that Nathaniel lived a full life.

Regret accepts the evidence, then reveals that John killed Rich after seeing him flee the lake in the earlier version of events; her manipulation of time could not erase their linked futures. To satisfy the spirits gathering over the water, the three friends confess what they have hidden.

Simone admits she pushed Kira and describes choosing Rich in the bargain; Cory confesses he lied to Trenton about the movie time. Simone withholds her mother’s crime and her kiss with Rich. They carry John’s body into the lake, where the ghostly women consume it and rise away.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The climax refuses a tidy distinction between justice and violence. John is exposed as a killer, but Simone kills him while possessed by the very force she has been trying to release. The spirits’ demand for confession makes truth an instrument with immediate supernatural consequences, yet Simone chooses what to disclose and what to keep. Her omission is not a lapse in the climax; it is an assertion of agency after weeks of being pushed by guilt, threats, and other people’s interpretations. Cory’s confession corrects the history of Trenton’s final night, while Kira’s presence turns the secret from Simone’s solitary burden into shared knowledge. They gain action, not absolution.

The Name She Keeps

Regret crumbles, but Simone inherits her hunger

After the spirits leave, Regret expects to follow, but her body begins to disintegrate instead. She tells Simone there is more she must learn, then dissolves without removing Simone’s memories or the strange presence inside her.

Simone later sends an anonymous tip connecting Natalie’s remains to Yearwood Lake; police recover Natalie and at least four other women, while John remains missing and under investigation. Two months later, Cory’s narration reveals he had long known Camille killed Trenton and had stayed silent too.

Simone appears at a New Year’s Eve party dressed like the young Evelyn in an old photograph. She notices a guest wearing the rave’s astronaut emblem, studies him, and introduces herself as Regret. Cory recognizes that Simone’s pale eyes and hunger are no ordinary costume, and wonders how to help her loosen the spirit’s hold.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ending grants practical justice but withholds spiritual resolution. Natalie and the other women are found, and Simone takes the risk of directing investigators toward the lake, yet John’s disappearance leaves the human consequences unsettled. Regret does not pass cleanly into an afterlife; instead, she vanishes while leaving a recognizable appetite and identity with Simone. Cory’s epilogue confession sharpens the book’s central symmetry: he too protected himself by withholding the truth about Trenton. The final costume is therefore not simply homage or Halloween play. Simone’s adoption of Regret’s name suggests a new identity formed through possession, choice, and unresolved guilt, with Cory’s loyalty unable to make that inheritance harmless.

Epilogue

Two months later, Cory narrates that he had known Camille killed Trenton since the night of the accident, when he saw the damage to her car and Simone watching from her window. He had kept quiet, leaving Simone to believe she alone carried the secret. She has since sent police an anonymous tip about Natalie and the lake, where investigators recover Natalie and several other women.

At a New Year’s Eve party, Simone wears clothes modeled on a photograph of Evelyn Young. When she spots a guest bearing the rave’s astronaut emblem, her eyes turn pale gray and she claims Regret as her name. Cory realizes the spirit has not simply disappeared. Simone and Regret may have become something like partners, though he hopes to help her break free.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The epilogue shifts the reader’s trust without undoing the emotional truth of Simone’s story. Cory’s silence makes him an accomplice to the same protective logic he has watched Simone struggle against: he saw evidence, feared the consequences of speaking, and let someone else carry the burden. His narration also suggests that intimacy does not automatically produce honesty; the two friends can care for each other while concealing the facts that most threaten them. Simone’s new name and gray eyes leave the resolution deliberately unstable. She has acted to expose the crimes around the lake, yet the supernatural hunger now seems to inhabit her. The future is not restored innocence, but an unsettled negotiation over what she will do with inherited power.

Analysis

The novel’s central question is not whether guilt is deserved, but what a person does with it once it becomes impossible to avoid. Simone’s first failures arise from an effort to protect: she warns Kira about Rich, hides her own part in Trenton’s story, and intervenes at the dock without respecting Kira’s request to stop. The book distinguishes caring intention from harmless impact without reducing Simone to a villain. Her fear of becoming her mother or Violet is sharpened by the repeated pattern of women concealing harm to preserve a life they can still control.

The town’s folklore offers a parallel form of concealment. Stories about Regret make the lake legible as a haunted place, but they flatten specific crimes into a tale of a grieving mother and her child. Diaries, church records, photographs, the necklace, and sand memories gradually challenge that inherited account. Knowledge comes not from a single authority but from comparing sources, especially when those sources have motives to lie or have been shaped by time. The dolls are poignant because they function as an archive that the town has kept without reading correctly.

The supernatural bargain makes ethical choices urgent but not clean. Simone cannot undo Kira’s drowning or Rich’s death by wishing hard enough; she can only act within a situation whose rules are partly hidden and manipulated. The final killing of John yields evidence and apparent justice for the women in the lake, yet it is also an act Simone performs while inhabited by Regret. Her withheld confessions and the epilogue’s revelation that Cory also stayed silent deny the comfort of a single guilty person. The ending offers connection and accountability as possibilities, not absolution. Simone’s new identity suggests that surviving a cycle of secrecy may mean learning to govern its power, rather than pretending it has vanished.

Summary in 60 Seconds
Sixteen-year-old Simone Washington accidentally causes her friend Kira to drown at a lakeside party. A spirit called Regret offers to revive Kira in exchange for another life, and Simone chooses Rich, Kira's boyfriend. The timeline resets, but Rich later dies, and Simone joins her former friend Cory in investigating the lake's history. Their research exposes an old murder and a curse, while Simone discovers her estranged mother killed Trenton, a boy Simone and Cory loved, and that she concealed the truth. A ritual reveals that John Yearwood murdered missing student Natalie and several other women. Regret possesses Simone, who kills John; the spirits take his body. They accept evidence that the child supposedly lost in the old legend survived and depart. Simone tips police to the victims, but Regret remains inside her. At a New Year's party, Simone takes the spirit's name, leaving Cory to hope he can help her resist it.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.00 out of 5
Average of 500+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

They Call Her Regret receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, with readers praising its airtight plot, atmospheric horror, and emotionally resonant characters. Fans particularly highlight the compelling protagonist Simone, the creepy supernatural elements surrounding Doll's Head Lake, and unexpected plot twists. The audiobook narration, especially the voice of Regret, receives frequent acclaim. Many reviewers note the book's thoughtful exploration of guilt, forgiveness, and personal regret alongside its spooky thrills. Minor criticisms include occasional pacing issues and a slightly underwhelming final chapter. Most readers enthusiastically recommend it as an ideal Halloween or spooky-season read.

Your rating:
4.66
27 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Simone Washington

The masked horror-maker

Simone is a gifted, high-achieving teenager who designs frightening experiences because staged fear gives her control over what real grief does not. She loves horror, researches local mysteries, and manages her friendships through sharp observation and carefully chosen masks. Her estrangement from her mother and the loss of Trenton have taught her to treat vulnerability as a liability. That self-protection sits uneasily beside her loyalty to Kira: Simone wants to save her friend, but often acts before listening. Her intelligence makes her a resourceful investigator; her urgency can also make uncertain evidence feel conclusive. Beneath the cool public persona is a young woman trying to decide whether remorse can guide her without becoming another form of self-punishment.

Cory Gooding

The patient investigator

Cory is Simone’s former close friend, a homeschooled student who works at Ozzy’s Pizza and runs a blog about Fairville’s mysteries. He approaches strange claims with curiosity rather than ridicule, and his methodical research complements Simone’s instinct for patterns. Their shared affection is shadowed by the history of Trenton’s death, which neither initially knows how to discuss. Cory is socially frank, patient with awkwardness, and attentive to small details that make Simone feel seen. He also has his own tendency toward silence when speaking could bring painful consequences. His role is not merely to validate Simone’s fear, but to help her test stories against records, objects, and the people who remember them.

Kira Davis

Simone's trusting best friend

Kira is Simone’s warm, expressive best friend, an artist whose plans for art school matter even when her relationship threatens to pull her elsewhere. She is generous with trust and often tries to ease tension rather than confront it, a habit Simone mistakes for naivety. Kira’s openness is not weakness: she notices hurt, stands up for people, and eventually has to decide which suspicions she can no longer ignore. Her friendship with Simone is intimate but imperfect, shaped by the things Simone withholds and by Kira’s own difficulty admitting when she has been hurt. She wants love to be dependable, and the gap between that hope and Rich’s behavior strains the friendship she values most.

Regret

The lake's hungry specter

Regret is a frightening presence associated with Doll’s Head Lake, where visitors leave toys among the trees. She can appear and vanish, alter what a person sees, and offer bargains built around life, death, and memory. Her shifting form suggests both vulnerability and predation: she can speak with a gentle, intimate manner before revealing an appetite that makes her dangerous. The town’s stories about her are contradictory, leaving her motives difficult to read. She is drawn to remorse and appears to understand how people use guilt to conceal other truths. Her presence forces Simone to distinguish between a legend’s convenient explanation and the complicated history that might actually have produced it.

Rich Pearson

Kira's charming boyfriend

Rich is a popular football player and Kira’s on-again, off-again boyfriend. His charm and easy confidence make him a center of attention, but Simone sees how readily he flirts with other girls and how often Kira excuses his behavior. He can be thoughtful as well as careless, which makes Simone’s warnings harder for Kira to accept and harder for Simone to deliver without seeming judgmental. Rich’s social ease masks parts of his life that even his closest friends do not know. He functions in the story as more than a romantic rival: his hidden choices reveal how little a public reputation can tell friends about the risks someone is taking.

Camille Washington

Simone's estranged mother

Camille is Simone’s mother, a once-present figure whose separation from her daughter followed the collapse of her marriage and a struggle with alcohol. She values polish and privacy, habits that leave the people around her uncertain about what she is carrying. Simone’s memories of Camille are tied to tenderness as well as abandonment, so their distance is never emotionally simple. Camille represents the danger of treating concealment as protection: she wants to spare her family pain, yet her silence leaves Simone to interpret events alone. Her daughter’s need for an honest reckoning eventually draws both women back into the same room.

Tony Washington

Simone's steady father

Tony is Simone’s father, a retired NFL player who now runs a real-estate business. He provides a warm, stable home and watches over his daughter without always knowing what she refuses to tell him. His practical concern appears in small rituals, birthday food, household care, and attempts to keep Simone talking. He believes that forgiveness can help people move forward, though his advice sometimes arrives before he understands the full damage being discussed. Tony’s presence gives Simone a source of care outside her friendship with Kira, but his own involvement in the family’s secrets complicates the security he offers.

John Yearwood

Layla's practical husband

John is Layla’s husband and a member of the wealthy Yearwood family, whose property includes the cabin near Doll’s Head Lake. He presents himself as practical and protective, worrying about the cabin’s condition and volunteering to help supervise Simone’s party. His easy familiarity with the property and its arrangements makes him a trusted adult in the teens’ orbit. John is also connected to the social and financial structures that shape who owns land and who is believed in Fairville. For much of the story, that ordinary helpfulness makes him seem like a reassuring counterweight to the frightening woods.

Layla Yearwood

Kira's capable older sister

Layla is Kira’s older sister, a newly married woman who is good at persuading people and turning plans into workable arrangements. She secures the cabin for Simone’s birthday and takes responsibility for preparing it, while her husband John helps with the practical tasks. Kira admires Layla’s settled life, which adds pressure to Kira’s own decisions about love and the future. Layla is caring but not omniscient; she trusts the arrangements she has made and assumes the teenagers will be safe. Her presence links the young friends to the adults and property owners surrounding the lake.

Deidra Hightower

Fairville's psychic elder

Known locally as Mama Dee, Deidra Hightower is a centenarian psychic who also ran an adoption service decades earlier. Some residents distrust her spiritual work, while others seek her help when conventional explanations fail. She is direct, observant, and protective of children, and she remembers details that town gossip has blurred or distorted. Her accounts connect the lake’s past to living descendants and physical objects. Mama Dee does not promise Simone an easy answer; she shares what she knows, warns her about the danger, and makes her recognize that the ability to act may carry responsibilities as well as power.

Nate Hightower

The unexplained groundskeeper

Nate is a groundskeeper who appears at the cabin before Simone’s party, late at night and with a toolbox. He says he has recently been hired to prepare the property, but his evasive answers and unexpected arrival make Simone wary. His connection to the Hightower name gives him an indirect link to the lake’s older history.

Shaina Reyes

A friend with suspicions

Shaina is one of Simone and Kira’s classmates, invited to the cabin gathering and drawn into Rich’s orbit. She is blunt, socially alert, and less willing than Kira to excuse his flirtation. Her suspicions after the party make her a source of information, but grief and incomplete knowledge can turn her questions into damaging rumors. Shaina’s role shows how a partly accurate observation can become harmful when passed through a community eager for a culprit.

Evelyn Young

The woman behind the legend

Evelyn Young is a young woman from Fairville whose name survives in contradictory stories about the lake. Some describe her as independent and reclusive; others tie her to broken friendship, children’s toys, or witchcraft. These accounts come from people who knew her imperfectly or inherited rumors from earlier generations. The gulf between Evelyn and the figure called Regret is central to the mystery: the legend turns a particular person’s experiences into a reusable warning, obscuring the choices and violence that formed it.

Violet Savoie

Evelyn's former friend

Violet is a member of Fairville’s once-wealthy Savoie family and Evelyn’s close friend. Her private diary offers a confident account of their shared past, but the town’s conflicting memories make her version difficult to accept without corroboration. Violet’s family history places her near questions of money, respectability, and who can afford to have a scandal forgotten. She is an important presence even before the investigation uncovers the facts, because the conflict between her account and Evelyn’s legend drives Simone and Cory to seek stronger evidence.

Trenton Jones

The friend Simone lost

Trenton was a friend of Simone and Cory during a summer when Simone’s family was breaking apart. He shared their interests and plans, and his absence shapes the way both of them think about guilt, timing, and the consequences of keeping quiet. Simone remembers him through places, photographs, and the ordinary plans they once made together. His story is not simply a past tragedy: it remains an unresolved moral question that influences her choices in the present.

Mr. Otis

Fairville's living memory

Mr. Otis is an elderly Fairville resident Cory knows from his volunteer work. He remembers the recreation center’s segregated and exclusive past and offers the first concrete name connected to the lake legend. He is careful about repeating rumors, showing respect for people whose lives have been reduced to local gossip.

Ms. Tandy

The town's eager historian

Ms. Tandy runs a thrift shop and prides herself on preserving Fairville’s history, including photographs and stories that might otherwise be discarded. Her enthusiasm helps Simone and Cory find a visual trace of Evelyn, though her account also demonstrates how a vivid rumor can pass for fact.

Elmira Simpson

Violet's surviving daughter

Elmira is Violet Savoie’s daughter, raised by her father’s second wife and protective of the family life she actually knew. She is wary of strangers turning old family pain into a story. Her guardedness forces Simone and Cory to pursue public records and inherited belongings rather than rely on easy access to the past.

Dorothy Savoie

Violet's cousin and mother

Dorothy is Violet’s cousin and the mother of a young boy who appears in the lake’s buried history. She is remembered through accounts told by others, but those accounts disagree about the circumstances surrounding her disappearance. Her story gives the investigation its clearest example of how violence can be hidden beneath a convenient legend.

Plot Devices

The Countdown Doll

A clock with a voice

A battered Gabby Greta doll repeatedly counts down the days Simone has left to fulfill Regret’s demand. It first appears as a strange party souvenir, then resurfaces after being thrown away, making it difficult for Simone to dismiss the bargain as a dream. Its childish mechanism contrasts with the threat it carries. The countdown compresses research, grief, and friendship into a deadline, while its changing number turns time into an intrusive presence in Simone’s everyday life.

The Lake Bargain

A choice with a deadline

Regret offers to restore Simone’s drowning friend in exchange for another life, with Simone required to free the spirit before the new moon. The bargain gives the mystery its urgent structure and makes Simone’s private decisions consequential beyond her immediate relationships. It also exploits her fear of being blamed, presenting a future in which Rich accuses her. Because the apparent exchange and later events do not align cleanly, the bargain remains a source of uncertainty rather than a simple supernatural rule.

The Doll Trail

A distorted town archive

Broken dolls and toys mark a path through the woods toward Yearwood Lake. Visitors interpret them as offerings to a ghost, and Simone uses them as party decorations and props before learning that the objects belong to a much older story. The trail works as a physical archive whose meaning has been altered by retelling. It connects the present-day mystery to a child and a family history, while showing how a community can preserve traces of harm without understanding what they record.

Memory in Materials

Objects reveal hidden events

Mama Dee explains that materials can retain memories and gives Simone instructions for drawing a scene from the lake sand into herself. Simone combines sand, a vial, and Natalie’s pendant, then sees John disposing of Natalie’s body. The method shifts the investigation from competing testimony toward supernatural evidence, but it reveals only a fragment and places Simone directly inside the danger she is investigating. The ritual also suggests that objects carry histories even when people have hidden or forgotten them.

Masks and Confession

Concealment meets consequence

Simone’s habit of masking her feelings links her parties, friendships, and family history. At the lake, Regret’s spirits demand that the people present confess their deepest regrets before the dead can be fed. Confession becomes both a supernatural requirement and a test of personal agency: Simone tells some truths while withholding others. The device avoids a simple moral lesson in which honesty automatically heals. Instead, it shows disclosure as consequential, difficult, and entangled with the speaker’s right to choose what remains private.

About the Author

Channelle Desamours balances two creative lives as both a published author and a high school science teacher. Known for her disciplined work ethic, she rises as early as five a.m. to dedicate time to her writing before her teaching day begins. Outside of her professional pursuits, she enjoys the imaginative world of The Sims 4, where she indulges her passion for building tiny homes. She is also an enthusiastic soccer fan, regularly cheering on Atlanta United. Needy Little Things marked her debut novel, with They Call Her Regret following as her sophomore release.

Download PDF

To save this They Call Her Regret summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.39 MB     Pages: 25

Download EPUB

To read this They Call Her Regret summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.46 MB     Pages: 34
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen1 mins
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...