Plot Summary
The A303 Lottery
Matthew Oxenhay, a sixty-year-old former futures trader, drives north on the A303 with a decision waiting at the end of the road. If his wife, Judy, answers when he calls, he will go home; if she does not, he will return to Somerset and seek out Anna, a woman he has only recently encountered again.
He treats the call as a wager, trusting chance more than his own judgment. Five months out of work, drinking heavily and unsure whether his marriage has any life left in it, Matthew wants the phone to settle what he cannot. The road gives him time to rehearse both outcomes, but not the confidence to choose between them.
Matthew’s ritual turns a painful choice into a test of luck, a familiar maneuver for a man whose career taught him to disguise risk as calculation. His faith in an arbitrary signal is not simple superstition. It protects him from having to own the consequences of choosing Judy or Anna, and from admitting that neither woman can decide what he wants to do with himself. The first-person narration makes that evasion intimate: he notices how absurd his method is even as he relies on it. The road is less a route home than a stage on which he delays becoming responsible for his future.
Sixty Birthday Rupture
At Matthew’s May 2008 birthday party, Judy gathers their children, Sarah and Adam, their partners, friends and Matthew’s chief executive, Rupert Loxley. Matthew drinks alone upstairs, studies his ordinary-looking sixty-year-old body and decides the comfortable life below has little connection to the person he once hoped to become.
When Judy brings him back to the guests, he delivers an unprepared speech that dwells on their shortcomings, then collapses before he can turn the joke on himself.
The next morning he overhears Sarah defending him and Adam insisting his drinking has gone on too long. Sarah tells him Judy is upset and has worried about his drinking for months. Matthew recognizes that Judy’s illness and his lost promotion worsened the drinking, though he suspects his despair began much earlier.
The party makes a private crisis visible to the people who have been accommodating it. Matthew’s speech is meant to expose everyone’s absurdities, but its failure to reach his promised self-criticism leaves his family with injury rather than intimacy. His children disagree about how much sympathy he deserves, yet both see that his behavior has become a pattern. The scene also complicates his resentment of Judy: her care is real, but he experiences the orderly life she built as evidence that he disappeared inside it. His self-loathing does not correct his cruelty. Instead, it helps perpetuate it.
The Office Ghost
A few weeks after the party, Rupert offers Matthew a freelance title with no guaranteed hours and no access to his former clients. Matthew rejects the arrangement, and the firm makes him redundant with a substantial severance package.
Rather than tell Judy, he continues dressing for work and spends his days greeting former colleagues at the office entrance, then sitting in cafés until it is time to go home. Rupert eventually offers him the use of his empty office, provided Matthew stays sober, avoids clients and treats staff politely.
Matthew accepts because going home with nothing to do seems worse. Money is not the obstacle: he has savings and a pension. The loss of work leaves him without structure, purpose or a convincing answer to what the rest of his life might contain.
Matthew’s unemployment strips away the role that made his compromises feel purposeful. He has enough money to avoid the necessity of finding new work, but that security becomes a trap: it lets him postpone change while leaving each day unclaimed. His ritual of greeting colleagues makes his exclusion visible, yet he prefers that humiliation to the domestic closeness he fears. Rupert’s offer is both humane and potentially degrading, a small shelter that preserves Matthew’s connection to the institution that has discarded him. The scene exposes his central contradiction: he despises the City’s values while relying on its status to know who he is.
The Woman at Tate
Three months into his makeshift office routine, Matthew attends a Tate Modern meeting about corporate sponsorship. Afterward, he meets Anna, a visitor studying a painting called The Promise. Her appearance stirs a sense of recognition, but he does not tell her that he believes they met in 1967.
Anna introduces herself as a woman living in Somerset; Matthew presents himself as a futures trader and avoids mentioning that he has lost his job. They leave the gallery together, cross the river in the rain and continue their conversation in a bar.
Anna describes a quiet life of gardening, chickens and market stalls, while Matthew is drawn to her wit and independence. Before they part, she gives him her email address, leaving open the possibility of another meeting.
The encounter gives Matthew a sudden alternative to the life he has been enduring, but it arrives already filtered through memory. His decision not to disclose their supposed history creates an imbalance: Anna thinks she is meeting a stranger, while he treats her as a recovered possibility. The painting’s title encourages him to see coincidence as direction, though the force of that interpretation comes from his own need. Anna’s rural routine also unsettles his assumptions about success and freedom. He imagines her as the person who can reconnect him with his younger self, a burden no new acquaintance can knowingly accept.
The Pleasant Life Cracks
At home, Judy arranges a weekend visit to her wealthy aunt, Lucy. Matthew claims he must go to Dorset for work, though the wind-farm visit he cites has already happened. Before that, Judy hosts Brian Carson, a Conservative Rotary chairman, and his wife for lunch. Matthew drinks whisky, announces that he votes Labour and turns their meal into a political argument, which Brian enjoys more than the women do.
After the guests leave, Judy offers a holiday in France and gently asks whether Matthew ever blamed her illness for his failure to win the chief executive post. He denies it and says nothing about losing his job. The next day he emails Anna, arranging to visit her in Somerset. He chooses the trip over a chance to ask Judy for help.
The lunch is not merely a comic breach of manners. Matthew uses provocation to manufacture the conflict his home life avoids, while Judy’s careful hosting embodies the security he experiences as suffocation. Her question about his missed promotion offers a rare opening for honesty, but he evades it because disclosure would require him to face both his dependence on her and his own changed circumstances. The invented work trip lets him move toward Anna without confronting the marriage he is already leaving emotionally. His refusal to speak is therefore an action with consequences: it turns secrecy into the condition of his next decision.
Lost Across Blackdown
On Saturday, Matthew drives through Somerset’s narrow lanes, unable to match Anna’s directions to the roads around him. He reaches the Blackdown Hills, calls her without success and misses the lunch she had prepared.
In Wellington, he searches a farmers’ market that is not Anna’s usual one, then drinks at a pub and berates himself aloud. A retired psychologist named Ernest tries to help, but Matthew drives him away with suspicion and insults. Eventually, a local woman recognizes Anna’s description and directs him to her cottage.
A note on the door explains that an emergency took Anna elsewhere and says he may return the next day. Matthew leaves the note in place, uncertain whether to go inside or whether his pursuit has become an act of desperation.
Matthew’s failed arrival converts romantic anticipation into a test of his ability to function. He cannot navigate a rural landscape, interpret a stranger’s concern or manage disappointment without turning it against himself. His response to Ernest is especially revealing: help feels like an accusation, so he rejects it before it can make demands. Yet he does eventually ask a local woman for directions and reaches Anna’s home. The note then gives him a choice rather than a reunion. He treats its invitation as a puzzle about how much to reveal, continuing to seek control through tactics when what he needs is candor.
Summer on Blackdown
While waiting to decide whether to return, Matthew remembers meeting a young woman named Anna in 1967. A friend introduces them at a village cricket match, and Anna takes him to a secluded field on Blackdown Hill. They talk about university, France, love and the lives they expect to lead. Anna invites him to travel with her, but Matthew refuses because he has no money and assumes they will meet again.
After her trip, she avoids his calls, leaves for university and does not respond to a poem he sends her. Matthew has spent decades treating that silence as the loss of a possible life. The memory explains why the woman at Tate feels so consequential, though it remains his recollection, not something he has yet confirmed with her.
The remembered afternoon becomes the emotional template through which Matthew interprets the present. He turns a brief connection and a refusal into a lifelong unfinished story, preserving its promise while neglecting the evidence that the relationship never developed. His youthful decision not to travel is not only a lost opportunity; it is an early example of waiting for certainty before acting. The poem and unanswered calls keep the past alive in a form he can revisit without risking a new rejection. Because this account comes entirely through Matthew, its vividness should not be mistaken for verification. Memory here is both testimony and self-protective fiction.
A Cottage in Somerset
Matthew returns the next morning, and Anna welcomes him into her cottage. He sees a life unlike the one he had imagined: carefully tended vegetables, named hens, shelves of old novels and no photographs. They discuss the choices that brought them to Somerset and London.
Matthew admits that he no longer has a paid job and had driven there specifically to see her. Anna describes a painful period in her own past, including an abortion and later difficulties, and explains that she has learned to keep men at a distance.
After lunch, they lie together and make love. The intimacy does not settle what comes next. Anna wants to know what Matthew’s marriage and family mean to him, and asks him to understand what he is offering before they meet again.
The cottage visit briefly gives Matthew the frank conversation he feels has vanished from his life. Anna’s independence attracts him, but her boundaries resist the fantasy that desire alone can repair years of disappointment. Their intimacy is real in the moment, yet it does not make him free of his wife or his history. Anna’s account of her own losses also shifts her from an emblem of youthful possibility into a person with vulnerabilities and limits. Her question about what he offers forces the relationship toward ethical reality: Matthew cannot claim a future with her without first naming the obligations and evasions shaping his present.
The Call to Judy
Driving home after the weekend, Matthew decides to let a phone call choose between Barnet and Anna’s cottage. Judy answers. He tells her he is leaving, but Judy reveals she has known about his dismissal for months. Rupert had warned her the job was at risk, and she had asked him to let Matthew keep an office so he would not have to face unemployment all at once.
She also says the family is worried about his condition and urges him to come home for help. Matthew hears her care as a conspiracy and ends the call. He buys whisky and cigarettes, although he had stopped smoking, and realizes he has run out of his prescribed pills. As his thoughts grow confused, he turns the car back toward Anna.
Judy’s disclosure overturns Matthew’s belief that he alone has been managing the truth. Her collaboration with Rupert was intended as practical care, but because Matthew did not know about it, he experiences it as surveillance and betrayal. This reaction exposes how shame has narrowed his capacity to receive help: kindness becomes evidence that others are controlling him. His declaration that he is leaving Judy is therefore less a settled plan than an act made during mounting confusion. The missed medication, renewed drinking and abrupt reversal on the road give the scene concrete danger. What Matthew calls a choice is entangled with a deteriorating ability to assess it.
Chicken Feed at Midnight
Near three in the morning, Matthew reaches Anna’s cottage and finds the doors locked. Certain that she expects him, he throws handfuls of chicken feed at her bedroom window, imagining she left it nearby for this purpose. Anna arrives from a local charity shift and brings him inside.
Matthew tells her he has left Judy and assumes they now share a home; he also misjudges how much whisky he has drunk and cannot keep his thoughts in order. Anna pours away the alcohol, gives him a place to sleep and learns that he has run out of medication.
The next day she drives him to a psychiatric hospital in Bridgwater, where clinicians assess him and provide more medication. Anna does not treat his sudden decision as proof that he is ready to build a life with her.
The scene makes Matthew’s impaired judgment impossible to dismiss as mere eccentricity. He reads locked doors as a temporary obstacle, chicken feed as a message and Anna’s arrival as confirmation of a shared future. The sequence is both comic in its odd details and alarming in its consequences. Anna responds with practical containment rather than romantic reassurance: she removes the whisky, gets him somewhere safe and takes him for professional assessment. Her refusal to validate his assumptions matters. Care here means protecting Matthew from the certainty he feels, not rewarding it with the intimacy he expects.
The Poem in Her Drawer
After the hospital visit, Matthew sits with Anna on her lawn while he begins to feel calmer. She finds a poem in her papers that she copied from a university magazine, and Matthew recognizes it as one he wrote decades earlier.
He takes this as proof that they shared the 1967 afternoon he remembers. Anna instead explains that she has always been Anna Halfyard, studied at Southampton, travelled to Italy and never lived in the village he describes. She does not remember the Surrey Blackdown, the invitation to France or the young man in his story.
Matthew cannot reconcile her account with his own. He leaves the cottage and drives away, while Anna remains behind. The discovery does not explain his memories, but it breaks the future he had built around them.
The poem is a powerful but unstable piece of evidence. It confirms that the writing exists and has a history beyond Matthew’s present account, yet it does not confirm the identity or shared past he attaches to it. Anna’s details expose a direct conflict between their memories, forcing him to confront the possibility that recognition has become projection. His departure is not a resolution so much as a retreat from a reality he cannot integrate. The scene asks readers to hold two truths together: Matthew’s emotional experience is genuine, while his interpretation of its source may not be. That distinction is the novel’s sharpest account of unreliable memory.
The Chemist's Odds
Driving through the night, Matthew remembers his older brother Alan, who once told him he often thought about suicide and planned to make his death look accidental. Three years later, Alan died when his car hit a tree. The family accepted that he had fallen asleep, but Matthew never told his parents about the earlier conversation.
At the crash site, he drinks whisky and considers whether his own life should continue. He decides that if he passes a late-night chemist, he will buy as many paracetamol tablets as he can and take them with his remaining medication and alcohol. If no chemist appears, he will return to Barnet and Judy. The novel ends before he reaches either outcome, leaving his survival and destination uncertain.
Alan’s history changes the meaning of Matthew’s final indecision. The possibility of suicide is no longer an abstract provocation or a device for forcing a dramatic choice; it is tied to a family secret Matthew has carried without knowing what to do with it. His conditional plan gives chance one last role, but the stakes now exceed the earlier romantic wager. The chemist rule preserves ambiguity while making the danger explicit. Matthew’s silence about Alan also echoes his failures to tell Judy about his job and to tell Anna the truth about their supposed past. The ending refuses an easy recovery narrative and leaves responsibility suspended in uncertainty.
Analysis
Trading Futures follows a man who has mistaken the stories he tells about himself for a stable identity. Matthew calls his career a gamble, his marriage a compromise and his interest in Anna a return to a lost possibility. Each label lets him simplify a more difficult truth: he has benefited from security while resenting it, hurt his family while believing himself merely unhappy, and trusted memory because it offered a past in which his present failures could still become meaningful. His first-person wit makes these evasions entertaining, but it also makes them harder to detect. The jokes are not a reliable cure for self-deception; they are one of its instruments.
The novel’s treatment of chance is especially pointed. Matthew believes a phone call, a coin game or a change in the weather can deliver a decision without exposing his motives. Yet the events that matter most resist that tidy logic. Judy answers, but her response reveals care as well as conflict. Anna’s cottage offers intimacy, but not the future Matthew has imagined. The poem supplies evidence, but cannot verify the shared past he needs it to prove. Objects and coincidences acquire meaning through interpretation, and interpretation is precisely what Matthew’s deteriorating judgment can no longer safely manage.
The novel also refuses to equate a dramatic break with freedom. Matthew’s life with Judy may feel airless to him, but leaving her in a confused state does not automatically create a better life. Anna insists on boundaries, professional help and the separation of his problems, resisting his wish to make her the solution to them. The final road leaves the practical question of survival unanswered, while Alan’s concealed despair shows how silence can outlast the person who first carried it. The book’s bleakest insight is not that life lacks meaning, but that people can evade the work of making meaning by choosing a story that feels better than the evidence. Its modest counterweight is the possibility of honest care, offered without guarantees and accepted only when someone can bear to see it clearly.
Review Summary
Trading Futures received mixed reviews, with ratings ranging from 1 to 5 stars. Many readers found it witty and thought-provoking, praising Powell's writing style and the protagonist's midlife crisis portrayal. Some appreciated the dark humor and philosophical elements, while others felt the story became tedious as it progressed. Critics noted the book's strong start but weaker ending. Reviewers were divided on the main character, Matthew, with some finding him relatable and others disliking his pretentious nature. Overall, the novel sparked discussions about aging, career disappointments, and life choices.
People Also Read
Characters
Matthew Oxenhay
Restless City traderMatthew is a former futures trader who has spent decades turning instinct and risk into a lucrative career. At sixty, he is perceptive about other people’s evasions but often blind to his own, using irony to hide shame and provocation to break through the calm domestic routines he resents. Losing his position removes the structure that had helped him define himself, while his drinking and fixation on a woman from his past expose how little confidence he has in his own judgment. He wants freedom, yet often waits for luck, memory or another person to choose for him. His narration is witty and self-aware, but its confidence cannot guarantee that his account of events is reliable.
Judy
Keeper of the householdJudy is Matthew’s wife of thirty-five years, a practical and patient woman who values security, family loyalty and the ordinary work of keeping a household intact. She left paid employment when their children were young and understands her contribution as a meaningful life, not a sacrifice she needs to resent. Matthew experiences her steadiness as a kind of confinement, but he also depends on the care he dismisses. She has her own fears about his drinking and changing behavior, and she tries to help without turning their home into a battlefield. Her conflict with Matthew is not a simple contest between dullness and freedom; they have built different definitions of a good life.
Anna Halfyard
Independent rural smallholderAnna lives in rural Somerset, where she tends vegetables, keeps chickens and sells produce at local markets. She is intellectually curious, funny and attentive to words, but also protective of the independence she has built after painful experiences. Her life is neither the pastoral idyll Matthew imagines nor a retreat without costs: she misses the culture and conversation of cities while valuing the rhythms of the countryside. Anna is capable of intimacy, yet refuses to let affection erase the need for clear boundaries. Her combination of warmth and guardedness challenges Matthew’s tendency to turn another person into an answer to his own dissatisfaction.
Sarah
Practical adult daughterSarah is Matthew and Judy’s daughter. After the birthday party, she shows concern for Matthew while refusing to pretend that his drunken behavior has not hurt the family. She believes his misery helps explain his conduct, but she also urges him to accept support. Her position is more compassionate than Adam’s without becoming an excuse for Matthew, and her concern reflects the emotional labor Judy has been carrying largely out of his sight.
Adam
Angry, wary adult sonAdam is Matthew and Judy’s son. He sees his father’s drinking as a long-running problem and is frustrated by explanations that do not lead to change. His anger contrasts with Sarah’s willingness to interpret Matthew’s distress, but it also shows how repeated behavior has worn down the family’s patience. Adam’s bluntness makes him a useful measure of the consequences Matthew would rather treat as temporary.
Rupert Loxley
Chief executive and rivalRupert is Matthew’s chief executive and the colleague who won the promotion Matthew believed should have been his. Matthew’s jealousy colors nearly every judgment he makes about him. Rupert is neither the villain Matthew wants nor a flawless benefactor: he dismisses Matthew when the firm needs to change, then offers him access to an empty office as a way to soften the transition. His conduct reveals a personal concern that Matthew is reluctant to recognize.
Alan
Matthew's thoughtful older brotherAlan is Matthew’s older brother, three years ahead of him and someone Matthew admired. He speaks seriously about the unhappiness he sees in life, while remaining concerned about what his feelings might do to their parents. The conversation he has with Matthew becomes a private memory that shapes how Matthew understands family, responsibility and loss.
Ernest
Retired local psychologistErnest is a retired psychologist Matthew meets in a Wellington pub. He notices Matthew’s distress and tries to check whether he is safe. Matthew responds with hostility, turning a brief offer of help into another sign of how suspicious and isolated he has become.
Brian Carson
Rotary host at lunchBrian is a Conservative Rotary chairman whom Judy invites to lunch with his wife. He enjoys arguing with Matthew about politics, even when the exchange makes the women uncomfortable. His response shows that Matthew’s deliberate disruption can sometimes entertain the very people he expects to offend.
Aunt Lucy
Judy's wealthy auntAunt Lucy is Judy’s difficult, wealthy relative, whose invitation to a weekend visit gives Matthew an excuse to claim he has other plans. Although she never appears directly, the proposed visit helps expose how readily he uses invented obligations to avoid honest conversation.
Plot Devices
The deciding phone call
Chance as decision-makerMatthew repeatedly treats a phone call as a device that can settle what he cannot decide for himself. At the beginning, he plans to let Judy’s presence or absence determine whether he goes home or returns to Somerset. When Judy answers, the expected binary test collapses into a conversation that exposes his hidden unemployment and family’s concern. The call therefore does not remove responsibility. It reveals how Matthew uses chance to postpone owning his choices, even as his decisions increasingly have serious consequences.
Futures and coin games
Gambling masks controlMatthew understands his career as a form of gambling, but his trading methods rely on pattern, habit and judgment as much as luck. In Somerset, he studies a coin game and uses its results to decide whether to return to Anna. These episodes connect his professional identity to his personal evasions: he wants to believe that a calculated wager can make an uncertain future manageable. The book repeatedly tests that belief, showing that skill may exist without giving anyone control over what a choice means or what follows from it.
The 1967 memory
Memory becomes a mapMatthew’s recollection of a summer afternoon on Blackdown gives his renewed interest in Anna a history and emotional logic. The field, the proposed journey to France and the unanswered calls have remained vivid to him, shaping his belief that their connection was interrupted rather than concluded. Because the recollection is filtered through Matthew, it also makes the reader question the reliability of the story as he tells it. Its meaning changes as the present-day encounter challenges the past he has preserved.
The old university poem
A fragile reality checkA poem Matthew wrote in his youth becomes a physical link between his memories and Anna’s papers. Its presence initially feels like confirmation, but Anna’s different account of her past prevents it from proving the shared history Matthew believes in. The poem therefore works in two directions: it gives his memory a tangible object, then exposes the limits of what that object can establish. Its significance depends not only on who recognizes it, but on how differently Matthew and Anna interpret the evidence.
Medication and alcohol
Unstable judgment made visibleMatthew’s drinking and interrupted use of prescribed medication accompany increasing confusion, impaired judgment and erratic behavior. The signs accumulate through his inability to manage disappointment, his confrontation with Ernest, his misplaced certainty about Anna and his midnight return to her cottage. Anna’s response, removing the whisky and taking him for assessment, makes the danger concrete without reducing his entire experience to a diagnosis. These details complicate the reader’s trust in his narration and underline the difference between feeling certain and being able to judge clearly.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.