Key Takeaways
Trade with a proven uptrend instead of trying to call its bottom
Follow the prevailing direction. Guppy treats a price chart as a record of crowd decisions, not a description of a company’s quality. When prices have been rising, the next move is more likely to continue that pattern than reverse without a strong opposing force. His illustrative estimates assign a 75% chance to an established uptrend continuing, and an 80% chance to a downtrend continuing. These are observations offered by the author, not universal probabilities guaranteed by markets.
Choose odds over prophecy. The practical point is to seek situations where existing buying has already demonstrated itself. Trying to buy at the bottom means betting against the current pattern, where a reversal is possible but less likely. The approach sacrifices the fantasy of perfect timing for a repeatable attempt to participate in a sustained rise.
The useful shift is from forecasting a turning point to asking what current evidence makes more likely. That distinction can reduce the temptation to explain away a falling chart with an appealing company story. The percentages, however, should be treated as the author’s estimates, not as calibrated odds for every market, asset, or time period. Trends can reverse abruptly, and past direction alone cannot establish a reliable probability. The framework is strongest as a discipline for choosing which side of the market to investigate, not as a promise that continuation is certain.
Your edge is disciplined use of public information, not secret tips
The same facts, different trades. Guppy argues that an information advantage is usually fleeting. A tip tells a trader what to buy without teaching why, when to exit, or how to limit a loss. His alternative, called the Shares strategy, used stocks mentioned in a widely read investment magazine, but selected only those already in an uptrend. In the author’s historical sample, about 90% of those rising stocks were still rising one month later, and 80% remained in an uptrend after two months.
Execution separated the groups. Workshops gave participants the same candidates and method, yet returns ranged from 6.33% to 16.19%. The difference came from stock selection and trade management, especially whether participants cut losing positions. Shared information did not produce shared outcomes.
This is a persuasive argument against the mystique of exclusive information. The workshop comparison makes the important point that a method is not just an entry signal: choices among candidates and responses to failure are part of the method too. The magazine figures are historical relationships reported by the author, not a guarantee that publicity creates a durable edge. Their deeper lesson is methodological: test observable patterns, record the results, and do not confuse a memorable winning tip with evidence of a reliable process.
Treat shares as a ride, not a partnership with management
Separate ownership from control. A small shareholder generally cannot direct hiring, strategy, or daily operations. Guppy points to AMP’s 2003 capital raising as an example of how small holders could be left outside decisions made by the company and large institutions. Owning shares does not make a private trader a business partner in the practical sense.
Control the decisions available. A trend trader treats a stock as a vehicle moving in a useful direction. The trader chooses when to get on and when to get off, but cannot steer the company or compel the price to rise. If the trend changes direction, the plan calls for leaving and looking elsewhere. This way of thinking applies whether a position lasts weeks or years: holding duration does not turn a capital-gain trade into income investing.
The distinction deflates a common emotional trap: identifying with a company can make a falling share feel like a personal argument to win. The author’s rider model redirects attention to decisions that are genuinely under the trader’s control. It also clarifies that income-focused ownership and trading for capital appreciation are different activities, even when both involve the same stock. The model is deliberately narrow, though. Long-term shareholders may have voting rights or other legitimate reasons to hold; the point is not that ownership is meaningless, but that it rarely grants the influence many small holders imagine.
Screen opportunities until only clear, manageable trends survive
Reject more than you select. Guppy’s selection process begins with a pool of possible stocks, then narrows it by asking whether the chart is plainly rising, whether a trend line gives an intelligible management signal, whether the trend has sound character, whether an entry and stop can be defined, and whether the position fits the trader’s capital. Each filter is meant to remove a trade that is hard to manage, not merely one that looks unattractive.
Simplicity can outperform clutter. In Darwin, beginners who relied mainly on the visual direction of charts returned 16.19% over eight weeks in one workshop, outperforming groups applying more elaborate selection. This does not prove that visual screening is always superior. It illustrates Guppy’s warning that adding tools can create competing interpretations and obscure the obvious question: is price actually moving up?
The screening logic treats attention and decision clarity as scarce resources, alongside money. A stock with a strong story but ambiguous price behavior may demand more judgment precisely when discipline matters most. The Darwin result is memorable because the novices had fewer preconceptions, but it is one workshop outcome, not a controlled demonstration that less analysis always wins. The durable principle is to prefer a manageable opportunity over a theoretically perfect one whose signals invite endless negotiation.
Use moving-average groups to read crowd commitment, not just crossovers
Two groups, two horizons. The Guppy Multiple Moving Average, or GMMA, combines six short-term exponential moving averages, from 3 to 15 days, with six longer-term averages, from 30 to 60 days. Guppy uses the short group to infer trader activity and the long group to infer investor activity. These are interpretations of price behavior, not direct observations of what market participants think.
Read shape and spacing. When averages within a group spread apart, the group is moving with greater force; when they compress, prices and values are converging across those time horizons. A broadly rising, separated long-term group suggests a trend supported by longer-horizon buying. If short-term averages repeatedly sink into the long-term group and recover weakly, the trend may be under pressure. Unlike a simple two-average crossover, the GMMA is meant to describe trend character, not issue an automatic buy or sell command.
The GMMA’s distinctive contribution is to turn a familiar moving-average tool into a way of comparing behavior across time horizons. It can help distinguish a steady rise from a fragile rally, which a single crossover often cannot. Yet the trader and investor labels remain inferences drawn from the same price series. The display organizes evidence; it does not reveal private intentions or independently confirm the story attached to it. Its best use is therefore comparative: notice whether support and momentum are strengthening or deteriorating, then combine that reading with a predefined trade plan.
Let the count back line turn price action into explicit trade decisions
Wait for confirmation. The count back line, or CBL, is a price-based technique using three significant bars to set a trigger. In a downtrend, the calculation begins at the latest low and identifies successive higher highs. A close above the resulting line confirms an entry signal; an intraday poke above it is not enough. This is especially useful when another tool, such as a trend line break, has already suggested that a reversal may be developing.
Change the calculation after entry. Once a rising position is open, the CBL is recalculated from significant highs and intervening lower lows to create a trailing stop. A close below the line signals an exit. Guppy treats the line as a management rule, not as a device that predicts the market. If an established trend remains strong, the GMMA may help decide whether a CBL exit is a false break or a genuine weakening.
The CBL addresses a practical weakness of vague intentions: without a price trigger, every decline invites a fresh debate about what the trader meant by risk control. Requiring a close also filters out some brief intraday moves. But any trigger can produce false exits, while overnight gaps can push prices beyond a planned level before a trader can respond. The technique becomes meaningful only when its role is fixed in advance, including whether a signal is immediate or requires corroboration. Otherwise, a seemingly objective line can become another indicator interpreted to match a mood.
Cap portfolio risk by changing position size, not forcing arbitrary stops
Place the stop where the chart makes sense. Guppy favors a logical price level, such as established support or a CBL, where prices may pause and offer an orderly exit. A random 5% threshold can sit in the middle of ordinary price movement, while a chart-based stop reflects the stock’s own behavior.
Size the position to the loss limit. The 2% rule means risking no more than 2% of total trading capital on one position, not limiting the position itself to 2% of the account. If a $100,000 portfolio permits a $2,000 loss, the entry-to-stop distance determines how many shares fit that limit. A stop far from entry calls for fewer shares. The author presents 2% as a ceiling, and urges traders to reduce the dollar risk if that amount feels too large to act on.
This separates two questions that traders often muddle: where the trade thesis fails, and how much capital to expose before that point. Position sizing can reconcile a wide, technically sensible stop with a controlled portfolio loss. The arithmetic is straightforward, but actual exits may be worse than planned when liquidity is thin or prices gap. The book’s percentage is a proposed discipline, not a universal optimum for every person or account. Its more general insight is that risk limits must be both mathematically defined and psychologically executable.
Buy confirmed strength with Darvas boxes, then ratchet risk behind it
Define a moving price range. A Darvas Box is built after a stock reaches a new high: the high is confirmed when three following days fail to exceed it. The box bottom is set from the lowest price after that high, once three later days hold above the low. A move above the box signals bullish strength; a close below its bottom signals an exit. The strategy is designed to follow rising strength, not to bargain-hunt for a low.
Adapt the stop to volatility. In modern markets, prices may rise too quickly for a fresh box to form, leaving an old stop far below current prices. Guppy’s ghost box projects the height of the last valid box upward to create intermediate stop levels. He reports stronger reliability for 12-month highs than six-month highs, while shorter lookbacks weaken the method. These are his reported results, not a guarantee.
Darvas offers an appealing alternative to indicators that depend on smooth trends: a box marks the range buyers and sellers have recently defended. Its central discipline is structural. The trader does not widen the stop simply because a high price feels expensive or because a short-term indicator disagrees. The ghost-box modification tries to solve a genuine tension between protecting gains and allowing room for volatility. That added flexibility also introduces judgment about when a projected box is valid, so the method works best when those rules are specified before a position is open.
Design for your own fear before the trade starts
Planning and trading are different states. Guppy describes a split between the calm person who writes a trading plan and the emotional person who manages an open position. Fear can lead to avoiding the account screen or refusing to accept a loss. Greed can turn a reasonable target into an invitation to hold for more, then make a profitable trade difficult to exit.
Make the plan harder to evade. The book suggests recording every open position, making losses visible, discussing trades with a trusted person, or using an external service to execute a prewritten plan. It also warns that a trader’s tolerance changes with experience, market conditions, and personal events. If a planned dollar loss repeatedly feels impossible to take, reduce the risk until the rule can actually be followed.
This is a more realistic model of discipline than assuming that knowledge automatically produces self-control. The proposed solutions alter the decision environment: visibility, accountability, and smaller stakes can make a difficult action more manageable. The analogy between private trading and socially unconstrained behavior is suggestive, though it cannot explain every trader’s choices. It also raises a useful test: if a plan depends on heroic composure during a sharp decline, the plan may be poorly designed for the person expected to execute it.
Judge a trading method by repeatable losses, not one dramatic win
Separate luck from a failing process. Guppy recommends tracking losses across comparable periods and examining their average and variability. A single unusually large loss may reflect an exceptional event; repeated large losses suggest a problem with the system, its fit to current conditions, or the trader’s execution. He advises comparing periods with at least five trades, while recognizing that such small samples offer limited certainty.
Compare return with drawdown. The book also discusses the Sterling ratio, which relates average returns over several periods to the largest realized decline in account value, with an adjustment added to that decline. In Guppy’s example, one system with lower returns but smaller drawdowns scores better than a higher-return system with larger losses. A spectacular gain is not persuasive if the process can also produce a devastating decline.
This performance lens resists the common habit of treating a winning streak as proof of skill and a losing streak as mere bad luck. Looking at both consistency and drawdown asks whether returns are survivable, not simply impressive. Still, a handful of trades cannot reliably distinguish randomness from a genuine change in a system’s behavior. Performance records are most useful when they preserve every trade, include execution costs, and are reviewed over enough varied conditions to expose weaknesses rather than confirm a preferred story.
Analysis
Trend Trading is both a practical trading manual and an argument about how people behave when money is exposed to uncertainty. Its organizing claim is that durable advantage comes less from private information than from selecting established trends, managing exits, sizing positions, and following rules under emotional pressure. The sequence of filters turns that claim into a usable process: find candidates, reject unclear charts, assess trend strength, define entry and exit conditions, then limit the financial consequences of being wrong. The recurring reader tests dramatize the gap between knowing a rule and obeying it.
The book’s strongest intellectual move is to treat technical analysis as a language for describing market behavior rather than a machine for predicting the future. The GMMA becomes an interpretive map of short- and long-horizon activity; the count back line converts a chart reading into a trigger; the Darvas method offers another way to define acceptable price ranges. These tools matter less as isolated formulas than as ways to make decisions explicit before fear and greed distort them.
Its empirical claims require caution. The reported success rates and workshop comparisons arise from the author’s own samples, and the text does not provide enough methodological detail to establish that the results generalize. Trend continuation may be a useful hypothesis, but markets change, and a strategy that fits one period can fail in another. Technical indicators are also transformations of price history, not independent evidence of investor intentions. A dense dashboard can create an illusion of confirmation when several indicators simply restate similar information.
A modern evaluation would test the rules on data not used to devise them, account for transaction costs and slippage, and compare results against a simple benchmark. It would also distinguish a profitable system from skillful discretion, since readers may alter rules after seeing outcomes. Those cautions do not erase the book’s central contribution. They sharpen it: specify a trade, control the size of failure, record results honestly, and distrust any method that cannot survive testing beyond its best examples. This is a framework for decision-making, not a promise of returns or a substitute for independent financial advice.
Review Summary
The reviews for Trend Trading are mixed, with an overall rating of 4 out of 5 stars based on 55 reviews. Some readers found the concepts like GMMA and CBL interesting and useful for determining trend believability. Others appreciated the simple writing style but noted unnecessary repetition. One reviewer rated it excellent despite giving only 1 star, praising its presentation of interesting concepts. However, some readers didn't finish the book or found it only moderately engaging, resulting in 3-star ratings.
Glossary
Guppy Multiple Moving Average (GMMA)
Trend-character indicatorA chart indicator made from two groups of exponential moving averages. The shorter group uses 3, 5, 8, 10, 12, and 15 days; the longer group uses 30, 35, 40, 45, 50, and 60 days. Guppy uses their direction, spacing, and compression to infer short-term trader activity and longer-term investor support. It is an interpretive tool, not a standalone buy or sell signal.
count back line
Price trigger and trailing stopA price-based technique that identifies significant bars to create a trigger level. In a downtrend, a close above the line can confirm an entry after other analysis suggests a possible reversal. Once a rising trade is open, the calculation is reversed to create a trailing stop, with a close below the line signaling an exit. It can also help define risk and protect accumulated profits.
Darvas Box
Range-based trend boundaryA price range constructed after a new high is followed by three days that do not exceed that high. Its lower boundary is based on a subsequent low followed by three days with higher lows. A move above the top signals strength, while a close below the bottom signals weakness or an exit. The box is designed to track trends and define stops, rather than identify bargain prices.
ghost box
Projected volatility stopA modification to Darvas trading for fast-moving markets. When prices rise too quickly for a new valid Darvas Box to form, the height of the most recent valid box is projected upward in steps. A close above a projected box advances the stop level. The aim is to reduce the open profit left exposed while preserving the original method’s allowance for normal price movement.
2% rule
Portfolio loss ceilingA money-management guideline that limits the planned loss on one trade to 2% of total trading capital. The percentage refers to the account’s capital at risk, not the percentage decline in the individual stock or the amount invested. The entry-to-stop distance determines the position size. Guppy presents 2% as a maximum and emphasizes lowering risk when a trader cannot comfortably act on that loss.
Shares strategy
Publicity-based trend selectionA method described in the book that selects stocks mentioned in Shares magazine only when they are already in an uptrend. It does not attempt to judge the magazine’s analysis or find hidden information. The strategy relies on the author’s observed relationship between publication, reader attention, and trend continuation, then uses a defined holding period and stop-loss management.
No secrets test
Shared-data decision exerciseA recurring exercise in which readers receive the same stock chart, entry, and indicators, then decide whether to stay in or exit. The trade unfolds across successive sections, allowing readers to compare their decisions with those of other participants. Its purpose is to show how fear, greed, and inconsistent interpretation can produce different results even when traders share the same information.
Sterling ratio
Return relative to drawdownA performance measure discussed in the book that compares average returns over several periods with the largest realized percentage decline in account value during those periods. The calculation adds an adjustment to the drawdown before comparing it with return. A higher ratio indicates a more favorable relationship between reward and risk, though it depends on the selected time span and the quality of the underlying records.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.