Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Trying Not to Try

Trying Not to Try

The Art and Science of Spontaneity
Can deliberate effort create spontaneity, or does trying too hard get in its way?
by Edward Slingerland 2014 304 pages
3.74
1k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Key Takeaways

Practice wu-wei: prepare deeply, then stop micromanaging the moment

Effortless action, not passivity. Wu-wei is the early Chinese ideal of acting effectively without feeling that a conscious self is forcing every move. It can describe an artist improvising, a skilled person responding smoothly, or someone navigating a delicate conversation. The trouble is that deliberately trying to become spontaneous can make spontaneity disappear. The book opens with Mindball, a game in which players move a ball by relaxing their brains. As the ball nears a player, the pressure to relax often makes them tense up. Athletes and performers face the same trap: intense self-monitoring can interrupt abilities that normally run smoothly.

A practical distinction. Effort matters in preparation, but it can obstruct performance when attention turns inward at the wrong time. The aim is not to stop caring or practicing. It is to reach a point where preparation supports action instead of crowding it out.

Analysis

The Mindball image neatly captures a broader feature of self-regulation: goals can become counterproductive when monitoring them consumes attention. Similar problems appear when people try to fall asleep or suppress an intrusive thought. The useful lesson is not that conscious control is bad, but that it has a timing problem. It helps set direction and prepare; during fluent action, it may need to recede. This distinction also guards against a romantic misunderstanding of spontaneity. Effortless performance is usually built on prior work, not a magical refusal to try.

Practice the craft until attention can return to the living situation

Skill grows by stages. In the Zhuangzi, Butcher Ding begins by seeing only a daunting ox. Years of experience teach him to perceive its structure, and eventually he can work through it with little conscious calculation. His blade lasts because he follows the spaces between joints instead of forcing through resistance. The story is not advice to become a butcher. It presents skilled responsiveness as a model for moving through obstacles without needless collision.

Train, then release. Confucius and Xunzi make a related case: years of study and ritual can turn deliberate rules into spontaneous conduct. Learning to drive begins with conscious attention to each move; with practice, much of the task becomes automatic. A study of jazz pianists found reduced activity in a region associated with deliberate control during improvisation, alongside activity in systems relevant to performance. The scan suggests a pattern, not a recipe for turning off the mind.

Analysis

Expertise often depends on moving from explicit instructions to tacit judgment. A chess master, for example, does not calculate every possible move from scratch; experience shapes what stands out as relevant. This helps explain why self-monitoring can damage performance after a skill is learned. Yet the butcher story should not be mistaken for proof that intuition is always wise. Automatic responses can reproduce bad habits or fail in unfamiliar conditions. The strongest version of the lesson is conditional: automate stable skills, while keeping enough attention available to detect when the situation has changed.

Let culture educate instinct, not merely police behavior

Civilized ease is learned. Confucius treated etiquette, classical study, and ritual as training for a genuine, unforced character. The point was not simply to follow rules in public. Repeated forms could teach people what to notice, how to treat others, and which desires to restrain. Confucius’s careful assistance to a blind musician shows the intended result: tactful conduct that fits the person and moment, rather than stiff rule-following.

Shared habits scale cooperation. Human instincts are well suited to close relationships, but large societies require trust among strangers. Cultural knowledge, accumulated across generations, can help guide behavior beyond what any one person could reason out. A Fijian taboo on certain reef fish, for instance, helps protect pregnant and nursing women from toxins, even when the causal explanation is not widely understood. In the book’s account, wu-wei becomes socially valuable when trained conduct expresses shared values from within.

Analysis

This argument makes culture more than a set of constraints. Customs can store practical knowledge, coordinate expectations, and make considerate behavior easier to perform without constant calculation. That is a powerful corrective to the idea that good conduct always begins with a fresh personal decision. Still, cultural inheritance is not automatically wise: traditions can preserve hierarchy or prejudice as efficiently as useful knowledge. The relevant question is therefore not whether a practice is old or spontaneous, but whether it reliably helps people live together while remaining open to scrutiny and repair.

Grow compassion by extending feelings already alive in you

Mencius favors cultivation, not coercion. He compares moral development to tending a sprout: neglect it, and it withers; pull it upward, and it dies. His four moral beginnings are empathy, a sense of right and wrong, deference, and moral discernment. In one thought experiment, a person sees a small child about to fall into a well and feels alarm before calculating any benefit. Mencius treats that unbidden concern as a starting point for compassion.

Extend a real feeling. King Xuan of Qi once spared an ox because he could not bear its terror. Mencius helped him recognize the compassion behind the decision, then asked him to extend similar concern to people suffering under his rule. The method combines noticing an existing response, reflecting on it, and practicing its application to a wider circle. It differs from a purely calculating ethics that asks people to override their emotions with abstract rules.

Analysis

Mencius’s method resembles learning through concrete cases: a vivid situation makes a moral concern perceptible before a general principle is applied. That can be more motivating than instruction alone, especially when a learner needs to recognize what compassion feels like. But empathy is uneven. People often feel more for those who seem familiar or vivid than for distant strangers. The king’s ox story exposes both sides: an existing feeling can become a bridge to wider concern, but it does not automatically travel there. Deliberate practice is needed to broaden its reach.

Cut desire's treadmill without mistaking withdrawal for wisdom

The Laozi questions manufactured wants. It contrasts basic needs with appetites stirred by status, novelty, and comparison. A person can be satisfied with a useful possession until a newer, more prestigious one appears. The book connects this cycle to the hedonic treadmill: gains and losses often lose some of their emotional force as people adapt, while comparison keeps attention fixed on what remains out of reach.

Analysis can spoil experience. In experiments described in the book, people asked to explain why they preferred particular jams or posters made choices they later rated less favorably than people who simply judged them. Verbal analysis can distort a preference when the experience is difficult to explain. The Laozi’s proposed answer is to simplify desires and loosen the grip of labels and ambition. Its limit is equally important: rejecting all culture or striving can become another rigid ideal, not a universal route to contentment.

Analysis

The distinction between a need and a socially amplified want remains useful in an economy designed to refresh dissatisfaction. Comparison can change how a person evaluates what is already adequate, even when the object itself has not changed. However, a preference for simplicity is not neutral or effortless for everyone. Some cultural learning expands pleasure, skill, or opportunity rather than merely manufacturing envy. The more durable test is whether an aspiration enriches a valued life or mainly feeds a moving status contest. Renunciation is a tool, not a complete theory of the good life.

Empty the mind enough to notice what the moment actually requires

Zhuangzi warns against fixed categories. His friend Huizi receives huge gourds, rejects them because they cannot serve as ordinary containers or spoons, and smashes them. Zhuangzi points out that they could have made a raft. The joke targets mental habits that confuse a familiar use with an object’s only possible use. Zhuangzi’s broader counsel is to loosen rigid judgments and attend to what circumstances make possible.

Forget the self-monitoring, not the world. In the story of the fasting of the mind, a student gives up rehearsed plans and becomes receptive to the people and situation around him. This is not simply blankness. It means reducing self-protective calculation so that attention can respond flexibly. The book links this to creative insight and skilled performance, where a brief break from deliberate analysis can help. But turning off judgment indiscriminately is risky: reflection remains essential when consequences are serious or unfamiliar.

Analysis

The gourd story captures a real cost of expertise: knowing what things usually do can make unusual uses harder to imagine. Periods of incubation, when a problem is set aside, can also allow less obvious associations to surface. The point is not to distrust categories altogether. Categories are efficient tools, and a pause is most useful when habitual thinking has become stuck. Zhuangzi’s image of receptivity is strongest as a method of reopening attention, not as a command to abandon evidence, planning, or responsibility.

Treat sincerity as the currency of trust, not polished performance

De is visible social power. In early Chinese thought, de means virtue, potency, or charismatic influence: the quality that makes others feel drawn to, or at ease with, someone. The book offers a modern interpretation: relaxed, spontaneous behavior can signal that a person’s actions match their actual motives. That signal matters because cooperation depends on distinguishing reliable partners from people who only appear committed.

Virtue is not just skill. A pianist can perform beautifully while thinking about dinner; the music still works. A generous act, however, loses its moral meaning if it is only a performance for praise. The book illustrates this with a police officer who bought boots for a cold, barefoot man. The story moved people partly because it seemed spontaneous. If the act had been staged for attention, the material help would remain, but trust in the officer’s compassion would collapse.

Analysis

The distinction between output and motive explains why observers care about authenticity even when the practical result is unchanged. Trust depends not only on what someone does once, but on whether their intentions seem dependable across situations. Signals such as ease, emotional expression, and costly commitments can help, but none is foolproof. Charismatic confidence can be performed, and sincere people may appear awkward or guarded. De is best understood as a useful social impression, not a reliable lie detector. Institutions and evidence remain necessary safeguards against misplaced trust.

Choose cultivation or release according to the obstacle in front of you

No single route works everywhere. The book maps four broad approaches: Confucius and Xunzi emphasize long training; Laozi favors reducing artificial wants and effort; Mencius recommends nurturing moral tendencies already present; Zhuangzi urges people to loosen fixed judgments and respond to the moment. These are competing answers to one problem: how to change without turning change into a strained performance.

Match the method to the task. A beginner may need detailed instruction; an expert may need to stop monitoring each movement. Moral growth can benefit from stories, guided reflection, and repeated practice, while a high-pressure performance may call for attention outside the self, focused on the task or people nearby. Wu-wei is not a guaranteed technique. It is a way to notice when effort supports action and when it obstructs it, while keeping action connected to something genuinely valued.

Analysis

This pluralism makes the book more practical than a universal recipe would be. Learning, moral development, performance, and social ease pose different problems, so they need not share one technique. A helpful extension is to treat each approach as a temporary experiment: notice what kind of interference is present, then adjust the balance of structure, reflection, and release. The caution is that appeals to spontaneity can excuse impulsiveness, while appeals to cultivation can justify conformity. The test is not whether an action feels effortless, but whether it is responsive, skillful, and aligned with defensible values.

Analysis

The book’s central contribution is to treat spontaneity not as a personality quirk or performance trick, but as a problem at the junction of skill, morality, and social trust. Its Chinese thinkers disagree about whether reliable spontaneity must be carved into us through culture, drawn out from moral tendencies already present, or uncovered by relinquishing rigid thought. Their disagreement matters because each approach diagnoses a different failure: untrained impulse, overbearing self-control, weak motivation, or fixation on one’s own plans.

The most persuasive synthesis is temporal rather than doctrinal. Conscious effort can select aims, build habits, and create cultural scaffolding. Yet when an action depends on quick perception or sincere connection, continual self-observation can interfere. The question is not effort versus ease, but when effort should lead and when it should hand control back to embodied skill. That insight applies to the butcher’s knife, a performer under pressure, and a ruler learning to notice other people’s suffering.

The book also broadens the meaning of flourishing. A satisfying state is not merely absorbed attention or heightened performance. It is absorption in an activity or relationship that matters within a larger frame of value. This distinction explains why some absorbing pursuits feel nourishing while others leave people depleted, and why interpersonal ease can carry moral significance.

Some scientific explanations are necessarily provisional. Brain imaging can correlate patterns of activity with improvisation, but it cannot by itself establish a complete mechanism for effortless action. Nor does evidence that automatic responses can be useful show that they are invariably accurate or ethical. The book is strongest when science illuminates the limits of conscious control without turning the brain into a simple switchboard. Its final answer is appropriately modest: no paradox-free technique exists, but people can learn to vary training, reflection, and release according to the demands of the moment.

Summary in 30 Seconds
Skilled, flexible action depends on effort at the right time: practice builds ability, while constant self-monitoring can disrupt performance. Confucian training shapes conduct; Laozi counsels reducing manufactured wants; Mencius develops compassion from existing feelings; Zhuangzi loosens fixed judgments. Repeated ritual can turn rules into instinct, while reflection helps extend empathy. No single approach fits every obstacle, and spontaneity is not automatically wise or ethical.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.74 out of 5
Average of 1k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Trying Not to Try explores the Chinese concept of wu-wei (effortless action) and its relevance to modern life. Reviewers appreciate Slingerland's blend of ancient philosophy and contemporary science, finding the book insightful and accessible. Many praise the author's humor and engaging writing style. Some readers find certain sections repetitive or overly academic. Overall, the book is well-received for its unique perspective on spontaneity and flow, though a few readers struggle with its philosophical depth.

Your rating:
4.31
311 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Glossary

wu-wei

Effortless, responsive action

An early Chinese ideal often translated as effortless action or non-forcing. A person in wu-wei may be highly active, but action feels unselfconscious and fits the situation without constant deliberate control. It is not mere passivity: skilled performance, tactful social behavior, and moral conduct can all exemplify it.

de

Virtue with social force

A quality associated with a person who acts in wu-wei. It can mean virtue, power, or charismatic influence, and is understood as an outward radiance that attracts trust or eases interaction. The book interprets de partly as a social signal of sincerity and effective conduct, while retaining its early Chinese spiritual and political significance.

hot cognition

Fast, embodied thinking

The book’s term for fast, automatic, largely unconscious processes, including habits, emotional responses, tacit skills, and quick judgments. These processes handle much everyday activity efficiently, but they can be rigid or poorly adapted to unfamiliar conditions. They work best when shaped by experience and supported by deliberate reflection where needed.

cold cognition

Slow, deliberate thinking

The book’s term for conscious, effortful thought used in planning, reflection, language, and cognitive control. It can override habitual responses, model other minds, and use knowledge that has not yet become automatic. Its limits are slowness, finite attention, and the risk of disrupting fluent action through excessive monitoring.

four sprouts

Beginnings of moral virtue

Mencius’s name for four innate beginnings of moral development: empathy, a sense of right and wrong, deference, and moral discernment. They are tendencies rather than fully formed virtues. Education should help identify and nourish them, much as a farmer tends a plant, without neglecting them or trying to force their growth.

paradox of wu-wei

Trying to become unforced

The difficulty of deliberately pursuing a state that must feel sincere and unforced. Directly striving for spontaneity, virtue, or social ease can undermine the very state being sought. The book links this tension to trust: actions that signal genuine commitment matter socially, but strategic attempts to manufacture that signal can make it unconvincing.

fasting of the mind

Releasing fixed mental schemes

A Zhuangzian practice of becoming less governed by habitual analysis, self-interest, and preconceived plans. The practitioner shifts from merely taking in sensory information or categorizing it to a more receptive awareness of the situation. Its purpose is flexible response, not blankness or the abandonment of necessary judgment.

FAQ

What's Trying Not to Try about?

  • Exploration of Spontaneity: The book delves into the concept of spontaneity through ancient Chinese philosophy, focusing on Daoism and Confucianism. It emphasizes the state of effortless action, known as wu-wei, as a path to effectiveness and happiness.
  • Philosophy and Science Integration: Edward Slingerland bridges ancient wisdom with modern cognitive science, showing how classical Chinese thought can enhance our understanding of human flourishing.
  • Practical Applications: The book offers advice on cultivating spontaneity in daily life, suggesting that trying too hard can be counterproductive and advocating for a more relaxed approach to achieving goals.

Why should I read Trying Not to Try?

  • Unique Perspective: The book combines ancient philosophy with modern cognitive science, challenging the conventional wisdom that hard work is the key to success.
  • Improving Well-Being: It provides insights into achieving happiness and well-being through wu-wei, offering practical applications for personal and professional life.
  • Engaging and Accessible: Slingerland's clear writing and use of anecdotes make complex ideas accessible, enriching the reading experience with examples from both ancient and modern contexts.

What are the key takeaways of Trying Not to Try?

  • Wu-Wei Concept: Central to the book is wu-wei, or "effortless action," which is crucial for personal effectiveness and happiness. It's about harmony with one's environment, not inaction.
  • Cognitive Science Support: The book highlights how modern cognitive science validates ancient insights about spontaneity and unconscious processes in decision-making.
  • Cultivating Spontaneity: Slingerland offers strategies for cultivating spontaneity, suggesting a focus on being present and relaxed rather than striving excessively.

What is wu-wei, and how is it defined in Trying Not to Try?

  • Definition of Wu-Wei: Wu-wei translates to "no trying" or "no doing," referring to a state of effortless action where individuals are fully engaged without conscious effort.
  • Effortless Action: It is described as a state where actions feel spontaneous and unforced, akin to being "in the zone," allowing for graceful and skilled performance.
  • Cultural Context: Rooted in Daoism, wu-wei contrasts with Confucian emphasis on effort, enriching the reader's understanding of its significance.

How does Trying Not to Try connect ancient philosophy with modern cognitive science?

  • Bridging Two Worlds: Slingerland connects ancient Chinese concepts, particularly wu-wei, with contemporary cognitive science, offering insights into human behavior and flourishing.
  • Scientific Validation: The book discusses how modern psychology and neuroscience support the role of unconscious processes in decision-making and performance.
  • Practical Implications: By integrating these perspectives, Slingerland provides strategies for cultivating spontaneity and well-being, encouraging a holistic understanding of human nature.

What strategies does Slingerland suggest for cultivating spontaneity?

  • Relaxation Techniques: Emphasizing relaxation and presence, techniques like mindfulness and meditation help individuals let go of excessive striving.
  • Embracing Naturalness: Readers are encouraged to embrace natural tendencies and instincts, nurturing innate moral sprouts as discussed by Mencius.
  • Engaging in Flow Activities: Participating in activities that promote flow can lead to greater satisfaction and effectiveness in personal and professional pursuits.

How does Trying Not to Try address the paradox of trying not to try?

  • Understanding the Paradox: The book explores the contradiction in trying not to try, noting that effort can undermine the desired outcome, central to wu-wei.
  • Cultural Insights: Ancient Chinese thinkers developed strategies to navigate this paradox, recognizing the balance between effort and relaxation.
  • Practical Solutions: Slingerland advises focusing on openness and receptivity rather than rigidly pursuing goals, facilitating more effortless engagement with life.

What role does trust play in the concept of wu-wei as discussed in Trying Not to Try?

  • Foundation of Cooperation: Trust is crucial for wu-wei, fostering cooperation and social harmony, as spontaneous behavior is perceived as more trustworthy.
  • Spontaneity and Trust: Authenticity and sincerity in spontaneous actions enhance trust, essential for effective social interactions.
  • Implications for Relationships: Cultivating wu-wei enhances relationships, creating environments where trust flourishes, leading to meaningful connections.

How does Trying Not to Try critique modern society's emphasis on effort and productivity?

  • Critique of Striving Culture: Slingerland critiques the obsession with effort and productivity, arguing it leads to burnout and dissatisfaction.
  • Value of Relaxation: The book emphasizes relaxation and spontaneity as antidotes to modern pressures, tapping into natural abilities for fulfillment.
  • Reimagining Success: Readers are encouraged to redefine success in terms of well-being and authentic engagement, leading to a balanced and satisfying life.

What are the best quotes from Trying Not to Try and what do they mean?

  • "Sometimes trying hard is overrated.": This quote encapsulates the theme that excessive effort can hinder performance and well-being, advocating for a relaxed approach.
  • "The goal of this book is to explore the many facets of spontaneity.": It highlights the focus on understanding spontaneity's importance in achieving a fulfilling life.
  • "The importance of being in the zone is perhaps nowhere more appreciated than in professional sports.": This illustrates wu-wei's relevance across fields, emphasizing peak performance from relaxed focus.

What role does the concept of "choking" play in Trying Not to Try?

  • Definition of Choking: Choking is performing poorly under pressure due to overthinking, illustrating the negative effects of trying too hard.
  • Psychological Insights: External pressures and conscious focus disrupt automatic processes, with studies showing experienced performers struggle when overly aware.
  • Connection to Wu-wei: Choking contrasts with wu-wei, where performance is effortless and natural, teaching readers to cultivate a relaxed approach.

How can I cultivate wu-wei in my daily life according to Trying Not to Try?

  • Practice Mindfulness: Engaging in mindfulness practices like meditation helps quiet the conscious mind, fostering wu-wei.
  • Focus on the Environment: Shifting attention to the environment enhances performance and reduces anxiety, connecting with life's flow.
  • Embrace Simplicity: Letting go of excessive goals and expectations allows for a more effortless approach, focusing on what truly matters.

About the Author

Edward Slingerland is a Distinguished University Scholar and Professor of Philosophy at the University of British Columbia. His academic expertise spans early Chinese thought, comparative religion, cognitive science, and virtue ethics. Slingerland has authored multiple books, including "Trying Not to Try" and the forthcoming "Drunk: How We Sipped, Danced and Stumbled Our Way to Civilization." He has also published numerous academic works, translations, and articles. Slingerland's research focuses on integrating humanities and sciences, particularly in the areas of cognitive linguistics and the cognitive science of religion.

Download PDF

To save this Trying Not to Try summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.37 MB     Pages: 18

Download EPUB

To read this Trying Not to Try summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.40 MB     Pages: 23
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen10 mins
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...